Assessing The Effectiveness of Comic-Style Illustrations For Promoting Environmental Sustainability
Assessing The Effectiveness of Comic-Style Illustrations For Promoting Environmental Sustainability
Assessing The Effectiveness of Comic-Style Illustrations For Promoting Environmental Sustainability
net/publication/344693332
CITATIONS READS
0 302
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Consumers' Perception of Product Naming and Package Design in Akure, Nigeria View project
The VIsual Typicality of Non-Alcoholic Beverage (NAB) Package Forms in Akure, Nigeria View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Blessing Chidubem Ario on 16 October 2020.
Abstract
Environment and lives are interconnected. The environment is currently faced with many challenges such as
climate change, which has been due to effects of harmful human activities on the environment. In order to stay
alive and healthy, the environment has to be properly cared for, as such, activities causing environmental
degradation are to be drastically reduced. This study adopted a pamphlet design as a visual communication tool
in order to address and increase awareness on environmental issues, using comic-style illustration to educate the
public. Additionally, assessments were made on the effectiveness of the visual design created. Primary data were
collected through structured questionnaire administered to a sample of 323 respondents which were randomly
selected within business district in Akure. Questionnaire were administered to elicit data on the effectiveness of
the design created which were analyzed using Chi-square. The result of the findings revealed that there were
positive changes in the disposal habit of the people.
Keywords:Graphic Design, Sustainability, Visual Communication, Environment, Wastes Disposal,
Indiscriminate waste disposal, Illustration.
Publication date:September 30th 2020
DOI: 10.7176/ADS/85-02
1.0 Introduction
Graphic design involves the juxtaposition of words, images, symbols that communicates the designers’ intent to
viewers through visuals and has helped the society to grow into a highly complex and multicultural one
(Oladumiye and Adelabu, 2011). The human environment is surrounded with graphic designs ranging from signs
to posters, printed materials to non-printed materials and product design to packaged products. These designs are
creatively rendered in order to please, beautify, communicate with and provoke some forms of reactions or
actions from people. Since inception, man has always looked for ways to beautify and sustain his environment
and the role of graphic design cannot be ignored and overlooked in achieving this vital task.
However, graphic design has gone beyond just creating designs and products. It has a role to play in
shaping the environment, hence contributing to its sustainability or otherwise. Michael (2015) specified that
sustainability is the dynamic equilibrium in the interaction between a population and its interacting environment
without compromising each other. Sustainability is multi-dimensional and one of its major aspect is
environmental sustainability (Giovannoni and Fabietti, 2014). Environmental sustainability is however multi-
faceted and a part is the disposal of waste. As the news on environmental sustainability are spreading around the
world, people are becoming aware of the effect of environmental degradation on the earth. Brundtland (1987)
stated that the earth is one but the world is different, thus our lives and the lives of other living things around us
is being sustained under one biosphere in earth. The factors in the environment work together in order to create a
healthy environment by promoting a sustainable environment without having adverse effect on population
consisting of humans, lands, plants and animals.
Sadly, graphic designers and design educators in developing countries like Nigeria have continued to ignore
environmental issues especially in practice (Stoknes, 2015; Deniz, 2016). This has partially led to the continuous
degrading of the environment through unhealthy human activities such as improper waste disposal. Often,
graphic designers create appealing products with compelling messages which eventually become acceptable to
the populace. In order to create a sustainable environment, graphic designers have a role to play as they serve as
the intermediary between clients and the consumers and their responsibility is becoming more important in
creating designs with less negative impact as well as proffering solutions to the earth’s problems (Deniz, 2016).
However, there is a growing recognition of the contributions of art and design to finding creative solutions for
global challenges (Wilson, 2010). Visual communication can play major roles in shaping the sustainability of the
environment. On the other hand, to communicate efficiently to people about matters relating to the environment
using graphic design, visual communication is recognized to be more effective. It has been studied that humans
have different types of learning abilities and the human brain is competent in understanding more visually
inclined images rather than words (Lydia, 2001). Hence, communication technique need to adjust to the
changing condition of the environment by understanding how visuals can be used to tackle environmental
problems. Hence, there is the need for graphic designers, especially in developing countries, to adopt graphic
designs not just as a means for creating products and aesthetics, but also as a tool for solving issues ranging from
social, economic to environmental problems
10
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
11
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
3.0 Methodology
Akure is the largest city and capital of Ondo state which is made up of Akure South and Akure North local
government and has a population of 491,033 (Ondo State Bureau of Statistics, 2019). This research adopted the
practice-led design and survey research. The study adopted the practice-led design to create and explore the
effectiveness of graphical designs that could be used to curb the negative habit of improper municipal waste
disposal and the survey design method to evaluate the effectiveness of the design created to promote
environmental-friendly behavior. Data used were collected through administered questionnaires. The study relied
on primary data collected in some selected locations within Akure south and Akure North. Secondary source
were gotten from relevant information on related literature in order to supplement data gotten from the field. The
sources included thesis, journals, articles from the internet and libraries. Purposive sampling involving selecting
samples based on the researcher’s judgement was used to select business centers within the study area while
random sampling technique was adopted for the purpose of sampling the residents in the business areas. 323
respondents were sampled within the business districts of the study area.
Research Questions
1. What visual communication tool may be used in creating effective environmental awareness?
2. How may the design created to promote environmental-friendly behaviour influence the users?
Research Aim and Objectives
The aim of the study is to increase awareness on the management of waste disposal with view to promoting
environmental sustainability.
1. create visual communication design to promote environmental-friendly behaviour on municipal solid
waste disposal; and
2. evaluate the effectiveness of the design created to promote environmental-friendly behaviour.
12
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
The inner page of the pamphlet design described anthropogenic activities and the effect of such action on
health which could result to sicknesses. It also labelled the effect climate change, could have on the environment
such as global warming, drought, flood, desertification which could affect human daily activities and source of
livelihood.
13
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
mean score of 3.8 and colour choice was also excellent with a mean score of 3.5 while clarity of message was
good with a mean score of 3.3. The evaluators showed a positive judgement towards the environmental visual
design because their responses was majorly between excellent and good for promoting awareness on the
environment.
Therefore, this indicated that the visual design was credible enough to be administered to the communities
for awareness creation.
14
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
The current method used for disposing waste among the respondents is presented in Table 3 and the results
indicated that 11 respondents representing 4.3% dispose their waste by burning. The result revealed that 24
respondents representing 9.4% dispose their wastes using dumpsites. 179 respondents representing 69.9%
dispose their waste by using waste management agency, while 42 of the sampled population representing 16.4%
indulge in road sides dumping to dispose their wastes.
From the above results of Table 2 and 3 respectively, it is revealed that 28 respondents representing 10.9%
disposing their waste by burning dropped down to 11 respondents representing 4.3%, 129 respondents
representing 50.4% disposing their wastes using the waste management agency increased to 179 respondents
representing 69.9%. However, 21 respondents representing 8.2% disposing wastes in dumpsites increased to 24
respondents representing 9.4% while the 6 respondents representing 2.3% disposing wastes in drainages stopped
it totally.
The analysis implies that there is a little change in the disposal method after the introduction of the design
which has influenced the attitude of the users positively even though the difference might not be significance.
Figure 4. Bar chart representation of the effectiveness of design created
Effectiveness of visual design created
Drainages
Road side dumping
Waste management agency
Dumpsites
Burning
0.00% 1000.00%2000.00%3000.00%4000.00%5000.00%6000.00%7000.00%
Current Method of disposing waste2 Initial method of disposing waste
15
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
languages used by lack of how to break down the environmental matter clearer makes it difficult for residents
understanding on such matter.
The time effectiveness (Time) indicated that the respondents agreed that the design is effective with a mean
score of 3.66. However, majority indicated that they are indifferent about the time and it was observed that when
in their business places, they are mostly particular about their business and might not have the luxury of time to
constantly pick up the design to read.
On cost effectiveness (Cost), the design was also revealed to be highly effective with a mean score of 4.64.
This could be linked with the fact that the design was brought to them in their comfort zone and without having
to wait for electricity before reading the content of the message or having to fuel their respective power
generating machines in order to hear the environmental news. And so with this, the design is not cost effective.
Assimilation effectiveness (Assimilation) indicated that majority of the respondents agreed that the design
highly effective with a mean score of 4.61. This implies that the design was well understood and knowledge
gained can be shared among others. This can therefore be linked to their positive change in attitude towards their
disposal habit. Noha (2017) and Tobias (2016) buttressed the findings that visual aids help assimilation among
young and old when oral word seems to be difficult to understand.
The table also revealed on effective information (information) that the information passed was highly
effective with a mean score of 4.71. This indicates that the respondents were able to update their understanding
about environmental issues as well as realized the negative impact indiscriminate disposal could have on lives.
The respondents however revealed that design on clean environment (Clean Env.) effectiveness was
effective with a mean score of 3.75, although there was only 1% different from those who indicated that they are
indifferent about clean environment. This revealed that no matter the message passed across, some people
nevertheless are of the opinion that anybody can still choose to discriminate the environment which can be
associated to behaviour cankerworm. However with more awareness creation, this believe and mind set might be
altered.
Finally, on effective attitude towards indiscriminate dumping (ATID), respondents revealed it to be
effective with a mean score of 3.76. This indicates that the design was able to influence their disposal culture.
Based on observation, often times, passers-by engaged in discriminating the environment by littering the
environment but with continuous awareness creation, there should be more environmentally conscious behaviour.
Yet, the results indicated that the environmental design was able to pass the intended message across to the users
and can be linked to Tobias (2016) who confirmed there is a great potential of communication using comic
illustrations approach, hence increasing environmental consciousness. By this, both old and young people can
easily interpret the message with the aid of illustrated images.
5.0 Conclusion
Improper management of waste in the environment has increased environmental degradation amongst other
degrading activities humans in third world countries indulge in, with Nigeria as no exception. Environmental
issues faced today is no news to a lot of people as well as the different environmental awareness raised as
supported by Olabode, William and Kim (2019).
As it is, depletion of the ozone layer causing intense hot weather and other variations in climate, however,
this is not only due to the improper disposal of waste but other unsustainable environmental actions. The future
of the upcoming generations is compromised and with further degrading activities, then what will the future hold?
Hence, the society need to work hand in hand in order to sustain the environment by living sustainably such as
engaging in activities that protects the physical environment. This can be achieved by indulging in sustainable
practices and ensuring that our lifestyle does not harm other people or deprive the future generations of their
ability to a great life.
What can Designers do to Promote a Sustainable Environment?
Graphic designers are great asset to promoting a sustainable environment due to their communication skills
with the aid of design tools, thus take responsibility in pioneering different sustainable behavior and eco-friendly
products. Nicos (2017) attested that professional practice should avoid creating excessive and useless products,
thus developing a product with short life span should be discouraged and emphasis should be placed on
promoting products that could be sustainable in such that could be re-used and re-cycled. Although, lot of
designers are after aesthetics but this is where the social responsibility sets in for the purpose of sustaining the
environment. Other contributions can be towards one’s community by promoting sustainable practices through
creating designs for the purpose of educating the society and advocate for reduction of human-made impact on
the environment and the ecosystem.
This paper hence contributing to knowledge in design for social change, by discussing environmental issues
using comic-style illustrations and sustainable practices was proffered. From the findings of the study, the use of
graphic design as a means of visually communicating to people by increasing environmental awareness is
effective in which when such awareness are continuously raised, people will develop an environmental friendly
16
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
6.0 Recommendation
1. Designers should render services to humanity by using their power and tool as designers to increase
awareness on the environment.
2. The researcher recommends that more awareness be created using illustration comics on behavior
change and environmental programs be introduced to children at their early stage of education in order
to inculcate environmental friendly behavior and open their minds to sense of community responsibility
for environments.
References
Aakhus M. (2007). Communication as Design. Communication Monographs. ISSN 0363-7751. 74 (1).
https://doi.org/10.1080/03637750701196383
Ajayi, C., Etuki, E., and Usang, N. (2016). From Environmental Awareness to Environmental Responsibility:
Towards a Stewardship Curriculum. Journal of Educational Issues. ISSN 2377-2263. 2(2).
https://doi.org/xxx10.5296/jei.v2i2.9265
Aleksandar, D. (2015). Typography in Advertising. Tomas Bata University, Zlín.
Ario, B. C., Oladumiye, E. B., & Ibiwoye, T. I. (2020). Adopting Comic- Style Illustrations for Promoting
Environmental Sustainability. International Journal of Innovative Research and Development, 9(3), 5-13
http://52.172.159.94/index.php/ijird_ojs/article/view/151624.
Brundtland Report (1987). World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED), OurCommon Future.
Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Daniel, S. (2012). Designing for Social Change. Social responsibility and the graphic designer. K3, Malmö
högskola.
Deniz, D. (2016). Sustainability Thinking and Environmental Awareness through Design Education. Procedia
Environmental Sciences, Elsevier B.V, Turkey. 34(1) 70-79.
Giovannoni, E. and Fabietti, G. (2014). What Is Sustainability? A Review of the Concept and Its Applications.
Integrated Reporting, Springer International Publishing, Switzerland. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-
02168-3_2
Jorge, F. (2004). Communication Design: Principles, Methods, and Practice. Published by Allworth Press. An
imprint of Allworth Communications, Inc. 10 East 23rd Street, New York, NY 100101
Jubilee, P. (2008). Environmental Awareness and Environmental Attitude of secondary School Teachers of
Maldives: A Study. RIE, Mysore.
Lydia, K. (2001). Virtual Language in Architectural Design. UNITEC, Auckland, New Zealand.
Michael B. (2015). Sustainability: Definition and Five Core Principles. The Sustainability Laboratory
Publication. 229 East street, New York.
Nicos, S. (2017). Design for Social Change and Design Education: Social Challenges Versus Teacher-Centred
Pedagogies. Design for next. 12th EAD Conference, Saplenza university of Rome.
Noha, H. (2017). Visual Aids and Multimedia in Second Language Acquisition. Published by Canadian Center of
Science and Education. English Language Teaching; Vol. 10(6); http://doi.org/10.5539/elt.v10n6p53
Norman, D. A. (1988). The Design of Everyday Things. Published by Basic Books. 250 West 57th Street, 15th
Floor, New York, New York 10107. ISBN 978-0-465-05065-9 (pbk.)—ISBN 978-0-465-00394-5
Olabode, E. O., William, S. and Kim, M. (2019). An Assessment of Material Waste Disposal Methods in the
Nigerian Construction Industry. Recycling Journal. 4(13). https://doi:10.3390
Oladumiye, E. B. and Adelabu, O.S. (2011). Graphic Design: A Developmental Tool for Eliciting Ethical Values
and Human Rights. IRCAB Journal of Science and Technology 1(1)
Ondo State Bureau of Statistics (2019). Retrieved March 5, 2019 from
http//www.ondostatistics.org/ondo_profile.php
Otinga C. S. (2014). Media and Environmental Awareness in Kenya: The Case of Tv. A Research Project
Presented to University of Nairobi: School of Journalism, as Partial Fulfillment of Degree in Master of Arts
(Communication Studies)
Ruksana, S. (2017). Role of Mass Media in Creating Environmental Awareness. National Journal of
Multidisciplinary Research and Development. PCSW, SCERT, Assam, India. ISSN: 2455-9040. 2 (1); 01-
04
Stoknes, P.E. (2015). What we think about when we try not to think about Global Warming. Chelsea Green
Publishing, White river junction, Vermont.
Tobias Feldt (2016). Increasing Environmental Awareness Using Comic-Style Illustrations as a Visual
Communication Tool, Madagascar. University of Kassel, Germany. [email protected]
Wilson, C. (2010). Arts. Environment. Sustainability. How Can Culture Make a Difference? Heng Mui Keng
17
Arts and Design Studies www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-6061 (Paper) ISSN 2225-059X (Online)
Vol.85, 2020
18