Adr 6
Adr 6
Adr 6
Compiled by
JHARKHAND STATE LEGAL SERVICES AUTHORITY, RANCHI
Compiled by :
JHARKHAND STATE LEGAL SERVICES AUTHORITY, RANCHI
5
SCHEME FOR TRAINING UNDER MEDIATION AND CONCILIATION PROJECT COMMITTEE
6
SCHEME FOR TRAINING UNDER MEDIATION AND CONCILIATION PROJECT COMMITTEE
7
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
9
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
10
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
11
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
12
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
13
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
15
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
16
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
17
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
(6) Where the mediator is an advocate, he shall not appear for any
of the parties in respect of the dispute which he had mediated.
(7) Mediators have a duty to know the limits of their competence
and ability in order to avoid taking on assignments which they
are not equipped to handle.
(8) Mediators have a duty to remain neutral throughout the
mediation.
(9) Mediators must respect the voluntary nature of mediation and
must recognize the rights of the parties to withdraw from the
mediation at any stage.
(10) Mediation being confidential in nature, a mediator shall be
faithful to the confidentiality reposed in him.
(11) Mediator has a duty to encourage the parties to make their own
decisions both individually and collectively about the resolution
of the dispute, rather than imposing his own ideas on the parties.
Self determination is the essence of the mediation process.
(12) Settlement of dispute must be based on informed consent.
(13) Conduct all proceeding relating to the resolution of dispute in
accordance -with the law.
(14) Mediator must refrain from promises or guarantee of results.
Rule 28. Consequences of breach of Rule 27 :
It shall, be open to the Coordinator to take such action with
the approval of the High Court Mediation Committee as may be
appropriate if the mediator violates any code of conduct expressed
in Rule 27 or behaves in a manner not expected of him as a Mediator”.
qqq
18
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
19
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
20
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
21
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
Capsule Curriculum
“Concept & Techniques of Mediation”
Day - 1 (10.00 AM - 5.00 PM)
Time Sessions Study Topic
10.00 AM to Session-I Conflict Management and Resolution
11.30 AM 1. Perception
2. Conflict : Definition, Causes
3. Management & Resolution
Role Play - I
(Savitri V Lokesh Chander)
11.45 AM to Session-II Mediation : Definition Components
1.00 PM Difference between mediation and judicial process
Difference between mediation and Arbitration
Difference between mediation and Lok Adalat
Difference between mediation and Conciliation
Difference between mediation and Panchayat
Benefit of Mediation
Role of Mediators
1.30 PM to Session-III Mediation : Process
5.00 PM A. Introduction
B. Joint Session
C. Caucus
D. Closing
a. Settlement
b. Non-Settlement
Role Play-II
(Robbert V Arun)
Lunch Break : 1.00 PM to 1.30 PM
Tea Breaks : i) 11.30 AM to 11.45 AM
ii) 3.15 PM to 3.30 PM
22
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
23
MEDIATION RULES - 2015
24
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
25
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
28
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
c) Where all the parties to the suit decide to exercise their option
and to agree for judicial settlement, they shall apply to the Court
within thirty days of the direction under clause (b) of Rule 2 and
then the Court shall, within thirty days of the application, refer
the matter to a suitable institution or person and such institution
or person shall be deemed to be a Lok Adalat and thereafter
the provisions of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (39
of 1987) which are applicable after the stage of making of the
reference to the Lok Adalat under that Act, shall apply as if the
proceedings were referred for settlement under the provisions
of that Act.
d) Where non of the parties are willing to agree to opt or agree to
refer the dispute to arbitration or the Lok Adalat, or to Judicial
settlement within thirty days of the direction of the Court under
clause (b) of Rule 2, they shall consider if they could agree for
reference to conciliation or mediation, within the same period.
e) i) Where all the parties opt and agree for conciliation, they
shall apply to the Court, within thirty days of the direction
under clause (b) of Rule 2 and the Court shall, within thirty
days of the application refer the matter to conciliation and
thereafter the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) which are applicable after the stage of
making of the reference to conciliation under that Act, shall
apply, as if the proceedings were referred for settlement by
way of conciliation under the provisions of that Act.
ii) Where all the parties opt and agree for mediation, they shall
apply to the Court, within thirty days of the direction under
clause (b) of Rule 2 and the Court shall, within thirty days of
the application, refer the matter to mediation and then the
Mediation Rules, 2003 in Part II shall apply.
f) Where under clause (d), all the parties are not able to opt and
agree for conciliator or mediation, one or more parties pay apply
to the Court within thirty days of the direction under clause (b)
of Rule 2, seeking settlement through conciliation o mediation
29
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
as the case may be, and in that event, the Court shall, within a
further period of thirty days issue notice to the other parties to
respond to the application and
i) In case all the parties agree for conciliation, the Court shall
refer the matter conciliation and thereafter, the provisions
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 which are
applicable after the stage of making of the reference
conciliation under that Act, shall apply.
ii) In case all the parties agree for mediation, the Court shall
refer the matter mediation in accordance with the Civil
Procedure Mediation Rules, 2003 Part II shall apply.
iii) In case all the parties do not agree and where it appears to the
Court, that there exist elements of a settlement which may
be acceptable to the parties and that there is a relationship
between the parties which has to be preserved, the Court
shall refer the matter to conciliation or mediation, as the
case may be. In case the dispute is referred to conciliation,
the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 which are applicable after the stage of making of the
reference to conciliation under that Act shall and in case the
dispute is referred to mediation, the provisions of the Civil
Procedure-Mediation Rules, 2003, shall apply.
g) i) Where none of the parties apply for reference either to
arbitration, or the Lok Adalat, or judicial settlement, or
for conciliation or mediation, within thirty days of the
direction under clause (b) of Rule 2, the Court shall, within
a further period of thirty days, issue notices to the parties
or their representatives fixing the matter for hearing on
the question of making a reference either to conciliation or
mediation.
ii) After hearing the parties or their representatives on the
day so fixed the Court shall, if there exist elements of a
settlement which may be acceptable to the parties and
30
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
31
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
32
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
34
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
35
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
37
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
38
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
him and shall thereafter interact with the other mediators, with
a view to resolving the disputes.
12. Mediator not bound by the Evidence Act, 1872 or the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908. - The mediator shall not be bound by the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 or the Evidence Act, 1872, but shall be
guided by the principles of fairness and justice, have regard to the
rights and obligations of the parties, usages of trade, if any, and the
nature of the dispute.
13. Non-attendance of Parties at sessions or meetings on due dates.
-
(a) The parties shall be present personally or may be represented
by their counsel or power-of-attorney holders at the meetings
or sessions notified by the mediator.
(b) If a party fails to attend a session or a meeting notified by the
mediator, other parties or the mediator can apply to the court
in which the suit is filed, to issue appropriate directions to that
party to attend before the mediator without sufficient reason,
the court may take action against the said party by imposition
of costs.
(c) The parties not resident in India, may be represented by
the counsel or power-of- attorney holders at the sessions or
meetings.
14. Administrative assistance - In order to facilitate the conduct of
mediation proceedings, the parties, or the mediator with the consent
of the parties, may arrange for administrative assistance hy a suitable
institution or person.
15. Offer of settlement by parties -
(a) Any party to the suit may, ‘without prejudice’, offer a settlement
to the other party at any stage of the proceedings, with notice to
the mediator.
39
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
(b) Any party to the suit may make a, ‘with prejudice’ offer, to the
other party at any stage of the proceedings, with notice to the
mediator.
16. Role of mediator - The mediator shall attempt to facilitate voluntary
resolution of the dispute by the parties, and communicate the
view of each party to the other, assist them in identifying issues,
reducing misunderstandings, clarifying priorities, exploring areas
of compromise and generating options in an attempt to solve the
dispute emphasizing that it is the responsibility of the parties to
take decisions which affect them; he shall not impose any terms of
settlement on the parties.
17. Parties alone responsible for taking decision - The parties
must understand, that the mediator only facilitates in arriving at a
decision to resolve disputes and that he will not and cannot impose
any settlement nor does the mediator give any warranty that the
mediation will result in a settlement. The mediator shall not impose
any decision on the parties.
18. Time-limit for completion of mediation. - On the expiry of sixty
days from the date fixed for the first appearance of the parties before
the mediator, the mediation shall stand terminated, unless the court,
which referred the matter, either suo motu, or upon request by the
mediator or any of the parties, and upon hearing all the parties, is
of the view that extension of time is necessary or may be useful; but
such extension shall not be beyond a further period of thirty days.
19. Parties to act in good faith. - While no one can be compelled to
commit to settle his case in advance of mediation, all parties shall
commit to participate in the proceedings in good faith with the
intention to settle the dispute, if possible.
20. Confidentiality, disclosure and inadmissibility of information.
1) When a mediator receives confidential information concerning
the dispute from any party, he shall disclose the substance of
that information to the other party, if permitted in writing by
the first party.
40
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
41
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
22. Immunity - No mediator shall be held liable for anything bone fide
done or omitted to be done by him during the mediation proceedings
for civil or criminal action, nor shall he be summoned by any party to
the suit to appear in a court of law to testify in regard to information
received by him or action taken by him or in respect of drafts or
records prepared by him or shown to him during the mediation
proceedings.
23. Communication between mediator and the Court.
a) In order to preserve the confidence of parties in the Court and
the neutrality of the mediator, there should be no communication
between the mediator and the Court, except as stated in clauses
(b) and (c) of this Rule.
b) If any communication between the mediator and the Court is
necessary, it shall be in writing and copies of the same shall be
given to the parties or their counsel or power of attorney.
c) Communication between the mediator and the Court shall be
limited to communication by the mediator:
(i) with the Court about the failure of the party to attend;
(ii) with the Court with the consent of the parties;
(iii) regarding his assessment that the case is not suited for
settlement through mediation;
iv) that the parties have settled the dispute or disputes.
24. Settlement agreement -
1) Where an agreement is reached between the parties in regard
to all the issues in the suit or some of the issues, the same shall
be reduced to writing and signed by the parties or their power-
of-attorney holders. If any counsel have represented the parties,
they shall attest the signature of their respective clients.
2) The agreement of the parties so signed and attested shall be
submitted to the mediator who shall, with a covering letter
42
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
signed by him, forward the same to the court in which the suit is
pending.
3) Where no agreement is arrived at between the parties, before
the time-limit stated in Rule 18 or where, the mediator is of the
view that no settlement is possible, he shall report the same to
the said court in writing.
25. Court to fix a date for recording settlement and passing decree.-
(1) Within seven days of the receipt of any settlement, the Court
shall issue notice to the parties fixing a day for recording the
settlement, such date not being beyond a further period of
fourteen days from the date of receipt of settlement, and the
Court shall record the settlement, if it is not collusive.
(2) The Court shall then pass a decree in accordance with the
settlement so recorded, if the settlement disposes of all the
issues in the suit.
(3) If the settlement disposes of only certain issues arising in the
suit, the. Court shall record the settlement on the date fixed for
recording the settlement, and
i) if the issues arc severable from other issues and if a decree
could be passed to the extent of the settlement covered by
those issues, the Court may pass a decree straight away in
accordance with the settlement on those issues without
waiting for a decision of the Court on the other issues,
which are not settled,
ii) If the issues are not severable, the Court shall wait for
a decision of the Court on the other issues which arc not
settled.
26. Fee of mediator and costs. -
1) At the time of referring the disputes to, mediation, the Court
shall, after consulting the mediator and the parties, fix the fee of
the mediator.
43
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
45
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
the panel by the District & Sessions Judge, the same shall be
put on the Notice Board.
(ii) Copies of the said panel referred in clause (i) shall be
forwarded to all the Subordinate Courts by the District &
Sessions Judge and to the District Bar Associations.
(c) The consent of the persons whose names are included in the
panel shall be obtained before empanelling them.
(d) The panel shall contain Annexure giving details of the
qualifications of the mediators/conciliators and their
professional or technical experience in different fields.
(e) The panel of mediators/conciliators appointed under Clause (a)
and clause (b) (i) shall normally be for a period of three years
from the date of appointment and further extension of the panel
of mediators/conciliators or any mediator/conciliator shall be
at the discretion of the High Court or the District & Sessions
Judge with the prior approval of the High Court, as the case may
be.
Rule 4 : Qualifications of persons to be empanelled under Rule 3.
The following persons may be enlisted in the panel of mediators/
conciliators under Rule 3, namely :
(a) 1. Retired Judges of the Supreme Court of India;
2. Retired Judges of the High Courts;
3. Retired District & Sessions Judges or retired Officers of
Delhi Higher Judicial Service;
4. District & Sessions Judge or Officers of Delhi Higher Judicial
Service.
(b) Legal practitioners with at least ten years standing at the Bar at
the level of the Supreme Court or the High Court or the District
Courts.
(c) Experts or other professionals with at least fifteen years
standing.
47
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
48
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
49
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
51
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
55
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
56
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
57
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
58
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
59
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
60
JHARKHAND HIGH COURT MEDIATION RULES
By order,
Sd/- P.R.Dash,
Registrar General
Memo no. 303 - 36 R&S Dated, Ranchi the 31st Jan., 2012.
Copy forwarded to the all the Principal District and Sessions Judges,
Jharkhand / the Principal Judicial Commissioner, Ranchi / Secretary, Law
(Judl.)Department, Govt, of Jharkhand, Ranchi / The Director, Judicial
Academy, Jharkhand, Ranchi / The Member Secretary, JHALSA, Ranchi/
The Office of the Registrar General/ The Registrar (Admn.)/The Registrar
(Estab.)/ The Registrar (Vigilance)/ The Joint Registrar, List & Computer/
The Joint Registrar-cum-P.P.S. to Hon'ble the Chief Justice/ The Assistant
Registrar (Judl.J/The Section Officer, Vigilance Cell/The Section Officer,
Administrative (Appointment) Section Jharkhand High Court, Ranchi for
kind information and needful.
Sd/-
Registrar General
qqq
61
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
62
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
(2) In Regulation 25 (b), for the words and figures “Rs. 400/-
(Rupees Four Hundred only)” the words and figures “ Rs. 3000
(Rupees Three thousand only)” shall be substituted.
(3) In Regulation 25 (c), for the words and figures “Rs. 250/- (Rupees
Two Fifty only)” the words and figures “ Rs. 2000 (Rupees Two
thousand only)” shall be substituted.
(4) In Regulation 25 (d), for the words and figures “Rs. 150/-
(Rupees One hundred and Fifty only)” the words and figures “
Rs. 1000 (Rupees One thousand only)” shall be substituted.
4. Omission of Regulation 29 -Regulation 29 shall be omitted.
5. Amendment of Regulation 35 (a) Regulation 35- Composition
of the Lok Adalat; Existing Sub Regulation 1, 2 and 3 shall be
substituted as follows:
(1) At State Authority Level.- The Member-Secretary organizing
the Lok Adalat shall constitute benches of the Lok Adalats, each
bench comprising of a sitting or retired Judge of the High Court
or a serving or retired judicial officer and anyone or both of the
following:
(i) a member from the legal profession; and
(ii) a social worker of repute who is engaged in the upliftment of
the weaker sections of the people, including the Scheduled
Castes, the Scheduled Tribes, women, children, rural and
urban labour and interested in the implementation of legal
services schemes or programmes.
(2) At High Court Level.- The Secretary of the High Court Legal
Services Committee organising the Lok Adalats shall constitute
benches of the Lok Adalats, each bench comprising of a sitting
or retired Judge of the High Court or a serving or retired judicial
officer and anyone or both of the following:
(i) a member from the legal profession;
63
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
65
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
Schedule B
Fee for Legal Aid Counsels in Subordinate Court
Civil Cases
(1) Before District Judges including MACT,
Family Court, Labour Court
(a) For civil appeal Up to admission After final
stage Rs. disposal Rs.
1000/- 2000/-
(b) For original Civil, Labour, Matrimonial, , Rs. 4000/- Rs. 1000/- on
Probate, Succession, Letter of Administration, framing of issues
Arbitration, Land Acquisition, Insolvency or or points, Rs.
any other original proceeding 1500 on closure
of evidence and
Rs. 1500 on final
disposal
Drafting fee Rs.
500/- for (a) &
(b)
(c) For Misc. appeal, restoration application, Rs. 500/- Rs. 1000
Transfer application, misc. application etc.
(2) Before Civil Judge (Senior or Junior Divisions)
(a) For original suit Rs. 4000/- (Rs. 1000/- at the stage
of framing of issues or point, Rs.
1500/- after the closure of evidence
and Rs. 1500/- on final disposal)
Drafting fee Rs. 500/-
(b) For Execution application Rs. 2500/- (one time payment)
(c) For any other application or proceeding Rs. 1500/- (one time payment)
Criminal Cases
(1) Before Sessions Court
(a) For cases involving sentence of death or life Rs. 6000/- (1/3 on framing of charge,
imprisonment or imprisonment exceeding 7 1/3 on conclusion of evidence and
yrs. 1/3 on final disposal)
66
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
(b) For all other Sessions Cases including cases Rs. 5000/- (1/3 on framing of charge,
under Spl. Acts 1/3 on conclusion of evidence and
1/3 on final disposal)
(c) Criminal Appeal or Criminal Revision Rs. 2500/- (one time)
Drafting fee Rs. 500/-
(d) Bail or ABP Rs. 1500/- (one time)
(e) Any other application, IA etc requiring hearing Rs. 500/- per case
in the case.
(2) Before CJM/ ACJM, JM 1st Class or any Rs. 3000/- (1/3 payment at the
Judicial Magistrates under Special Act (Be it stage of framing of charge, 1/3 at
GR, Public or Private Complaint or the like) conclusion of evidence, 1/3 on final
disposal)
Bail application or any other application Rs. 500/- (one time)
requiring hearing in the case
Schedule-C
For cases before District Level Revenue Court or Executive Court i.e. Deputy
Commissioner, Addl. Commissioner, DCLR, SDO/SDM, City Magistrates
1. Appeal or original proceeding Up to admission stage For final hearing Rs.
Rs. 1000/- 2000/-
2. Misc. appeal, restoration proceeding Rs. 800/- Rs. 1700/-
or other misc. proceeding
Expl.
1. In batch matter with substantially similar pleading or nature or
arising out of same FIR, order or common judgement one extra fee of
Rs. 500/- for a set of three persons/cases shall be admissible subject
to a maximum of 3 times of original fee
2. The court fee, clerkage (10% of the fee), Tying charges, photo copy
and other misc. expenses shall be admissible on actual on production
of genuine bill
3. Court fee through Legal Aid shall be payable by way of judicial stamp.
67
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
68
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
69
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
6 a. Honorarium /Fee payable to outstation lawyers, other legal Rs.1000/- per day+
experts as Resource Person approved by JHALSA/HCLSC/ expenses*
DLSA/ SDLSC for imparting training of legal services.
b. Honorarium /Fee payable to local lawyers and other legal Rs.500/- per day+
experts as Resource Person approved by JHALSA/HCLSC/ expenses*
DLSA/ SDLSC for imparting training of legal services.
Provided also that in appropriate cases with prior
approval of the Hon’ble Executive Chairman of JHALSA,
special honorarium/ remuneration/ fee and other expenses
may be sanctioned in favour of any person being invited as
Resource Person for any National, State or district Level
Conference, Seminar, Workshop, Symposium etc.
*Expenses:
1. On actuals on production of Tickets by rail or by bus or on production
of vouchers or Rs. 5/- per Km, whichever is less.
2. Rs.150/- would be paid for Local traveling within the jurisdiction of
DLSA
3. With the prior approval of Executive Chairman, JHALSA; Chairman,
HCLSC; Chairman, DLSA and SDLSC respectively; above expenses
including bills for any other expenses may be sanctioned and passed
by the Member Secretary or Secretary as the case may be.
4. For organizing Awareness camps, Seminars, literacy programmes
etc, or supervising any other activity, DLSA can arrange transport
by hiring vehicle on need base locally with ceiling of 60 ltrs. Fuel per
month. The Chairman of the DLSA/ SDLSC may approve extra fuel
not exceeding 20 ltrs. in special case for such purposes the expenses
to be met out of State Legal Aid fund of the DLSA/SDLSC as the case
may be. The DLSA or SDLSC shall maintain proper Log Book for the
same. Actual incidental expenditure including typing misc. charges
incurred by the legal aid advocate will be reimbursed provided it is
supported by the vouchers and a certificate is given to that effect by
70
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
Sd/-
(B.K Goswami)
Member Secretary
(Principal District Judge)
qqq
71
The Jharkhand State Legal Services Authority (Amendment) Regulation, 2013
72
Printed & Distributed by :
"NYAYA SADAN"
JHARKHAND STATE LEGAL SERVICES AUTHORITY (JHALSA)
Near A.G. Of ice, Doranda, Ranchi
Phone : 0651-2481520, Fax : 0651-2482397
Email : [email protected]
Website : www.jhalsa.org