Bending Strength and Nondestructive Evaluation of Structural Bamboo
Bending Strength and Nondestructive Evaluation of Structural Bamboo
Bending Strength and Nondestructive Evaluation of Structural Bamboo
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Optimization on the use of bamboo requires comprehensive understandings of the physical, mechanical,
Received 10 April 2016 and chemical properties. When using bamboo as a building material, one needs to know its specific grav-
Received in revised form 1 April 2017 ity, stiffness and bending strength properties. This work investigated density, stiffness, bending strength
Accepted 10 April 2017
properties and nondestructive evaluation of four-year old Bambusa vulgaris ’Vittata’, very common in
Available online 17 April 2017
Manaus, used on the construction of an ecological and sustainable village for Amazonia. Flexural bending
strength samples were cut from eight culms in three 3-m segments (base, middle, and top). The 3-m long
Keywords:
culms were first tested nondestructively through axial sonic vibration of a Stress Wave Timer (SWT), then
Bamboo bending strength
Density
in thirdpoint loading static bending with a clear span of 2.71 m. The average moisture content and den-
Bambusa vulgaris ’Vittata’ sity of the bamboo culms tested were 12.95% and 646 kg m3, respectively. The average dynamic modu-
Amazonia lus of elasticity was 17.3 GPa. The average ultimate load, modulus of rupture and modulus of elasticity
Bamboo nondestructive evaluation were 7.9 kN, 88 MPa and 9.6 GPa, respectively. Analysis of the results showed that bamboo culm density
and dynamic modulus of elasticity can be used to determine its strength and stiffness. Also, SWT can be
used for nondestructive evaluation of bamboo culms strength and stiffness.
Ó 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2017.04.074
0950-0618/Ó 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
R.A. Sá Ribeiro et al. / Construction and Building Materials 146 (2017) 38–42 39
variations of the said factors around the nodes. Culm characteristic 2.2. Nondestructive testing of the culms
crookedness induces early load-displacement effects. The random
Determination of moisture content, density (mass by volume) and bending
nature of this load-displacement effect is mobilized by the lateral strength properties of the bamboo culms were done according to the standard
displacementss of the structure under lateral loads and governed ISO 22157-2 [26]. The 3-m long culms were first tested nondestructively through
by the culm initial deformations [18]. axial sonic vibration of a Metriguard 239A Stress Wave Timer, as illustrated in
Test results of clear specimens are not directly transferred as Fig. 1. The testing procedure was the following:
those of full culms, because the culm tends to fail in the weakest
1. Attach the bamboo culm ends to the stop and start clamps of the SWT. Measure
link (the nodal regions), and to develop high tensile parallel stres- the distance between the start and stop accelerometers.
ses. Both factors are very much random in nature. The culms initial 2. Impact the start-end of the specimen with the pendulum ball-hammer device.
deformations would also lead to low rigidity at the start of the Read the time (in microseconds) it takes for the stress wave to travel the prede-
termined distance and record it.
load-displacement path [18].
Bambusa vulgaris is the most common cultivated bamboo spe-
cies in Manaus (03°060 0700 S, 60°010 3000 W, 93-m). In spite of its 2.3. Flexural bending test
plentiful, the properties of B. vulgaris grown in this region are yet
to be researched in detail. Vetter et al. [8] investigated the season- Flexural bending test of full bamboo culms was done using a Universal Testing
ing, density and shrinkage characteristics of Bambusa vulgaris ‘Vit- Machine with a 500-kN load cell capacity at a speed of 30 mm min1 up to rupture.
Test specimens were loaded with a third point loading and simply supported over a
tata’ grown in Manaus. B. vulgaris was used for the construction of
2.71-m clear span, as illustrated in Fig. 2. Deflections were measured at mid-span
a sustainable ecological village in the Amazon in 2007 [2]. The pre- using a potentiometer. The potentiometer was Celesco position transducer with a
sent work aimed to attain data on density, stiffness, bending measuring range of 254 mm and a position sensitivity of 94 mV V1 inch1.
strength properties and nondestructive evaluation (NDE) of full
culm B. vulgaris ‘Vittata’ and how these properties are related.
Ed ¼ qv2 ð1Þ
Chen et al. [24] applied NDE techniques by means of a Stress
Wave Timer (SWT) to determine the moisture content (MC) at fiber
saturation point (FSP) for three bamboo species: Dendrocalamus
giganteus Munro, Dendrocalamus latiflorus Munro, and Bambusa
stenostachya Hackel. More recently, Lin et al. [25] used NDE tech-
niques to determine Ed of Phyllostachys edulis lamina.
Eight culms from two clumps were collected from a plantation at the Brazilian
National Institute for Amazonian Research (INPA) in Manaus (latitude 3°060 0700 ,
longitude 60°010 3000 , altitude 93 m), Amazonas. The culms were approximately
four years old with 87-mm average diameter.
Each culm was cut into three segments (base, middle, and top) of 3-m long,
labeled, measured, and conditioned according to the standard ISO 22157-2 [26].
These culms were conditioned for nondestructive testing (NDT) and for the flexural
bending test. Some specimens were discarded due to cracks along the length of the
culm, and were not substituted due to time constrains. Samples for MC determina-
tion and density were taken from each culm immediately after the completion of
the bending test. Fig. 2. Third-point loading bending strength test for bamboo culm.
40 R.A. Sá Ribeiro et al. / Construction and Building Materials 146 (2017) 38–42
A small piece was cut from each specimen near the point of failure for MC and acquired by the researchers. Cumbersome adjustments (mainly
density determination. MC was determined by oven-dry method and volume by
for MC and geometries) would be necessary, and are beyond the
water-displacement method.
scope of this present work.
A plot for the load-displacement of the bamboo culm – bases,
3. Results middles, and tops tested on third-point loading flexural bending
is illustrated in Fig. 3. As expected, the base-culms carried more
Physical and mechanical characteristics of the bamboo culms
are given in Table 1.
The average Ed was 17.3 GPa. The average MC and density of the 18
bamboo culms of B. vulgaris tested were 12.95% and 646 kg m3, 16
respectively. The average ultimate load, modulus of rupture 14
(MOR) and MOE of full culms tested in third-point loading bending
12
were 7.9 kN, 88 MPa and 9.6 GPa, respectively. Other findings
10
attained from several researchers are summarized in Table 2.
Load (kN)
8
While the average density of B. vulgaris from different places in
the world shows similar values, bending strength properties 6
(MOR and MOE) vary widely. The researchers certainly used the 4
same well known standard procedure to determine the density 2
of the bamboo. If this is true, B. vulgaris average density may not 0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280
vary significantly with the location. On the other hand, the deter-
Displacement (mm)
mination of the bending strength properties was attained by the A1B A3B A4B A2M A3M A2T A3T
researchers using different standard procedures including dissimi-
lar test specimens and MC. Therefore, it is not possible to make a Fig. 3. Load-displacement diagrams for bamboo culms – base-middle-top from
straight comparison on the bending strength property values cluster A.
Table 1
Physical and mechanical properties of the bamboo culms tested.
Table 2
Physical and bending strength properties of B. vulgaris full size culms.
Table 3 140
Regression analysis for tested structural bamboo culms. 120 (a)
MOR (MPa)
100
Regression r2 Equation/Model 80
60
MOR = f(MOE) 0.8338 MOR ¼ 0:0098 MOE 7:1701 40 MOR = 0.0098 MOE - 7.1701
MOR = f(q) 0.6570 MOR ¼ 0:2481 q 72:716 20 R² = 0.8338
MOR = f(Ed) 0.6964 MOR ¼ 0:0075 Ed 41:919 0
MOE = f(Ed) 0.6569 MOE ¼ 0:6843 Ed 2250:7 5000 7000 9000 11000 13000 15000
MOE = f(q) 0.6174 MOE ¼ 22:344 q 4796:3 MOE (MPa)
Ed = f(q) 0.7724 Ed ¼ 22:253 q 3031:3 MOR x MOE Linear (MOR x MOE)
140
120 (b)
load than the middle-culms, and the latter carried more load than
100
MOR (MPa)
the top-culms. The tube-like bamboo is a structurally efficient 80
beam with a cross-section comparable to a steel beam I-profile. 60
The bending failure mode is by longitudinal splitting of the mate- 40
MOR = 0.2481 ρ - 72.716
rial due to the fracture of the weaker lignin bonding the fibers 20
R² = 0.657
0
together [31]. After load removal, the bamboo beam returns to 500 550 600 650 700 750 800
its original straight form, which is an advantage in case of an earth- Apparent density, ρ (kg/m3)
quake or a hurricane. MOR x ρ Linear (MOR x ρ)
140
120 (c)
4. Discussion
MOR (MPa)
100
80
This work emphasizes the use of statistical relationships 60
between variables, considering analysis of covariance and analysis 40
MOR = 0.0075 Ed - 41.919
R² = 0.6964
of residuals of the variables for the determination of bending 20
13000 15000 17000 19000 21000 23000
strength properties of bamboo culms by means of NDE. MOR,
Ed (MPa)
MOE, Ed, and apparent density were analyzed statistically. Correla-
MOR x Ed Linear (MOR x Ed)
tions between mechanical and physical properties were deter-
mined. Linear regressions were run to see which NDE factors 15000
would predict MOR and MOE efficiently. (d)
12500
MOE (MPa)
10000
5. Conclusions
7500 MOE = 22.344 ρ - 4796.3
In order to simplify the use of bamboo culm strength properties R² = 0.6174
5000
this work suggests applying the average values among base, mid- 500 550 600 650 700 750 800
Apparent density, ρ (kg/m3)
dle, and top parts. The MOR values of the tested bamboo culms var-
MOE x ρ Linear (MOE x ρ)
ied from 48 to 132 MPa, MOE varied from 6.1 to 14.2 GPa, and Ed
varied from 13.7 to 22.3 GPa (Table 1).
23000
Preliminary analysis of the literature available on physical 21000
(f)
Ed (MPa)
References [16] J.J.A. Janssen, The mechanical properties of bamboo, In: Recent Research on
Bamboo, Proceedings of the International Bamboo Workshop, Hangzhou,
China, 6–14 October 1985. Chinese Academy of Forestry, Beijing, China; IDRC,
[1] M.G. Sá Ribeiro, R.E. Vetter, R.A. Sá Ribeiro, J.S. Rocha, T.M.F. Bessa, C.L.F.
Ottawa, Canada; 1987, pp. 250–256.
Pontes. Bamboo based wall panels for houses in Brazilian Amazonia. In: K.
[17] M.F. Kabir, D.K. Bhattacharjee, M.A. Sattar, Physical and mechanical properties
Ghavami, H. Savastano Jr., A.P. Joaquim, (Eds) Proceedings Conferência
of four bamboo species, Bangladesh J. For. Sci. 20 (1&2) (1991) 31–36.
Brasileira de Materiais e Tecnologias Não-Convencionais: Habitações e Infra-
[18] O. Arce, Bamboo housing in seismic prone areas, Bamboo, People, the
Estrutura de Interesse Social – Brasil NOCMAT, Pirassununga, SP. Editora
Environment, Vol. 3, INBAR Technical Report No. 8; 1995.
ABMTENC; 2004, pp. 418–427.
[19] R.A. Sá Ribeiro, M.G. Sá Ribeiro, Mechanical properties of Amazonian lumber
[2] M.G. Sá Ribeiro, R. Toledo Filho, R.P. De Vasconcelos, R.K. Vieira, A.K. Vieira, E.
for the development of design stresses, In: Sugiyama H, editor. Proceedings of
Bittencourt, R.A. Sá Ribeiro, Building of a sustainable ecological village in the
the 1990 International Timber Engineering Conference, Tokyo, Japan; 1990,
Amazon – related projects and activities, Chem. Eng. Trans. 17 (2009) 343–348,
Vol. 3, pp. 819–826.
http://dx.doi.org/10.3303/CET0917058.
[20] R. Gonçalves, O.A.L. Costa, Influence of moisture content on longitudinal, radial
[3] M.G. Sá Ribeiro, R.A. Sá Ribeiro, Sustainable school-village, Key Eng. Mater. 600
and tangential ultrasonic velocity for two Brazilian wood species, Wood Fiber
(2014) 768–772, http://dx.doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/KEM.600.768.
Sci. 40 (4) (2008) 580–586.
[4] K. Ghavami, A.B. Marinho, Propriedades físicas e mecânicas do colmo inteiro do
[21] C.H.S. Del Menezzi, R.R. Silveira, M.R. Souza, Estimativa das propriedades de
bambu da espécie Guadua angustifolia, Rev. Bras. Eng. Agríc Ambient 9 (1)
flexão estática de seis espécies de madeiras amazônicas por meio da técnica
(2005) 107–114.
não-destrutiva de ondas de tensão (Predicting flexural properties of six
[5] M.A. Sattar. Traditional housing in Asia: present status and future prospects,
Amazonian hardwoods using stress wave nondestructive method), Acta
Bamboo, People, The Environment, Vol. 3. INBAR Technical Report No. 8; 1995.
Amazonica 40 (2) (2010) 325–332.
[6] A.C. Sekhar, R.K. Bhartari, Studies of strength of bamboo: a note on its
[22] R.F. Teles, C.S. Del Menezzi, F. Souza, M.R. Souza, Nondestructive evaluation of
mechanical behavior, Indian Forester 86 (5) (1960) 296–301.
a tropical hardwood: interrelationship between methods and physical-
[7] SN Sharma, MI Mehra, Variation of specific gravity and tangential shrinkage in
acoustical variables, Ciência da Madeira 2 (1) (2011) 1–14.
the wall thickness of bamboo and its possible influence on trend of the
[23] R.F.S. Hearmon, Theory of the vibration testing of wood, For. Prod. J. 16 (8)
shrinkage moisture content characteristics, Indian Forester Bull. 259 (7)
(1966) 29–40.
(1970).
[24] T.Y. Chen, C.H. Shih, H.C. Chen, Determination of the moisture content at fiber
[8] R.E. Vetter, R.A. Sá Ribeiro, M.G. Sá Ribeiro, I.P.A. Miranda, Studies on drying of
saturation point of bamboo by nondestructive testing method with stress
imperial bamboo, Eur. J. Wood Prod. 73 (2015) 411–414, http://dx.doi.org/
wave timer, In: Natterer J, Sandoz JL editors, Proceedings of the 5th World
10.1007/s00107-015-0900-6.
Conference on Timber Engineering, Montreux, Switzerland; 1998, Vol. 2, pp.
[9] W. Liese Characterization and utilization of bamboo, In: T. Higuchi (Ed.),
820–821.
Bamboo production and utilization. Proceedings of the Congress Group 5.04,
[25] C.J. Lin, M.J. Tsai, S.Y. Wang, Nondestructive evaluation techniques for
production and utilization of bamboo and related species, XVIII IUFRO World
assessing dynamic modulus of elasticity of moso bamboo (Phyllostachys
Congress Ljubljana, Yugoslavia, 7–21 September 1986. Kyoto University,
edulis) lamina, J. Wood Sci. 52 (4) (2006) 342–347, http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/
Kyoto, Japan.
s10086-005-0772-1.
[10] M.A. Sattar, M.F. Kabir, D.K. Bhattacharjee, Effect of age and height position of
[26] ISO. ISO 22157–2: Bamboo – Determination of physical and mechanical
muli (Melocanna baccifera) and borak (Bambusa balcooa) on the physical and
properties – Part II: Laboratory manual. International Standards Organization,
mechanical properties, Bangladesh J. For. Sci. 19 (1&2) (1990) 29–38.
Geneva, Switzerland; 2004.
[11] M.F. Kabir, D.K. Bhattacharjee, M.A. Sattar, Effect of age and height on strength
[27] M.A. Sattar, M.F. Kabir, D.K. Bhattacharjee, Physical and mechanical properties
properties of Dendrocalamus longispatbus, Bamboo Inf. Centre Indian Bull. 3 (1)
of six important bamboo species of Bangladesh, In: Bamboo and its uses.
(1993) 11–15.
Proceedings of the International Symposium on Industrial Use of Bamboo,
[12] Z.B. Espiloy, Effect of age on the physico-mechanical properties of some
Beijing, China, 7–11 December 1992, pp. 112–117.
Philipine bamboo, In: Bamboo in Asia and the Pacific, Proceedings of the 4th
[28] S. Prawirohatmodjo, Comparative strengths of green and air-dry bamboo, In:
International Bamboo Workshop, Chiangmai, Thailand, 27–30 November
Bamboos current research, Proceedings of the International Bamboo
1991. IDRC, Ottawa, Canada; FRSP for Asia and the Pacific, Bangkok,
Workshop, Cochin, India, 14–18 November 1988. KFRI, Kerala, India; IDRC,
Thailand; 1994, pp. 180–182.
Ottawa, Canada; 1990, pp. 218–222.
[13] A.C. Sekhar, A.S. Gulati, A note on the physical and mechanical properties of
[29] J.G. Palisoc, E.D. Bello, Bamboo furniture industry in the Philippines, In:
Dendrocalamus strictus from different localities, Van Vigyan 11 (314) (1973)
Bamboo People and the Environment, Vol. 3: Engineering and Utilization.
17–22.
INBAR Technical Report No. 8, Bali, Indonesia; 1996, pp. 258–269.
[14] K. Ghavami, Application of bamboo as a low-cost energy material in civil
[30] K. Ghavami, Application of bamboo as a low-cost construction material, In:
engineering, In: Symposium Materials for Low Income Housing, 3, CIB/RILEM,
Bamboos Current Research, Proceedings of the International Bamboo
Mexico City, Mexico; 1989, pp. 526–536.
Workshop, 14–18 Nov 1988, pp. 270–277.
[15] Z.B. Espiloy, Physico-mechanical properties and anatomical relationship of
[31] J.J.A. Janssen, Designing and Building with Bamboo: INBAR Technical Report
some Philippine bamboos, In: Recent Research on Bamboo, Proceedings of the
20, International Network for Bamboo and Rattan, Beijing, China, 2000, p. 211.
International Bamboo Workshop, Hangzhou, China, 6–14 October 1985.
Chinese Academy of Forestry, Beijing, China; IDRC, Ottawa, Canada; 1987,
pp. 257–264.