Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force Report 2023

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 16

Key Findings and Recommendations of the

Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force

Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force Members

Jenna M. Bedsole, Managing Shareholder, Baker Donelson (Birmingham)

Melanie R. Bridgeforth, MSW, President and CEO, Women’s Foundation of Alabama, Alabama
Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force Chair (Birmingham)

Representative Adline Clarke, Alabama House District 97 (Mobile)

Amanda Foster, CFP®, CRPS®, Practical Financial Solutions, American Association of


University Women Huntsville (Huntsville)

Kendra Key, Principal, Community Economic Development (Birmingham)

Representative Joe Lovvorn, Alabama House District 79 (Auburn)

Mike Polis, VP of Human Resources at Morris Group International, Director of AL Society for
Human Resource Management State Council (Montgomery)

Dr. Cynthia Warrick, President, Stillman College (Tuscaloosa)

Representative Andy Whitt, Alabama House District 6 (Harvest)

Dr. Kelly Collins Woodford, Associate Dean and Professor of Management, University of South
Alabama (Mobile)

Dr. Stephanie Yates, Endowed Professor and Director of Regions Institute for Financial
Education, University of Alabama at Birmingham (Birmingham)

1
Table of Contents
Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force Members ........................................................................1
Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................3
Introduction .................................................................................................................................4
Strengthen Equal Pay Protections to Close the Gender Wage Gap ............................................5
Key Findings............................................................................................................................5
Recommendations...................................................................................................................5
Recommendation: Prohibit employers and third-parties from requesting pay history from job
applicants.............................................................................................................................5
Recommendation: Incentivize equal pay audits by creating a good faith defense to litigation
for the CF-EPA.....................................................................................................................6
Invest in Childcare to Support and Grow Alabama’s Workforce...................................................7
Key Findings............................................................................................................................7
Recommendations...................................................................................................................7
Recommendation: Create tax incentives to increase the supply and affordability of quality
childcare in Alabama. ...........................................................................................................7
Recommendation: Utilize all available federal funding, including temporary COVID relief, to
support access to affordable, quality childcare. ....................................................................8
Recommendation: Explore innovative ways to close the childcare supply gap, such as a
revolving fund or start-up grants for childcare facilities and capital expenses. ......................8
Recommendation: Prioritize childcare in Alabama’s future workforce policy planning by
creating an intra-agency council on workforce and childcare................................................8
Strengthen the Workforce Development Pipeline for Women and Girls .......................................9
Key Findings............................................................................................................................9
Recommendations...................................................................................................................9
Recommendation: Add representative(s) to the Alabama Workforce Council(s) to focus on
gender dynamics in workforce development. .......................................................................9
Recommendation: Increase funding for early intervention programs that expose and prepare
girls for careers in STEM......................................................................................................9
Recommendation: Increase funding for apprenticeship programs and “earn and learn”
pathways............................................................................................................................10
Recommendation: Increase funding for workforce navigators and career coaches. ...........10
Conclusions ..............................................................................................................................11
Task Force Member Signatures ................................................................................................12
Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................13
Citations ....................................................................................................................................14
Appendix ...................................................................................................................................15
House Joint Resolution 115 ...................................................................................................15

2
Executive Summary

The Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force was commissioned by the State Legislature
via House Joint Resolution 115. The body was charged with identifying evidence-based policies
to assist lawmakers in implementing laws to close the gender wage gap and bolster female
workforce participation. Armed with data from leading experts on the status of pay inequality,
workforce participation dynamics, and equal pay protections, the Task Force prioritized the
following specific and actionable recommendations for consideration by the Alabama Legislature.

Key Findings:

• Alabama’s gender wage gap is one of the largest in the country, where women are paid only
67 cents for every dollar a man earns. Black women and Hispanic women are paid even less,
making only 52 cents and 41 cents, respectively, for every dollar a white man earns.1

• The gender wage gap in Alabama is a result of several structural and systemic factors
including occupational segregation, discriminatory practices, and low labor force participation
among women.

• The labor force participation rate of women in Alabama is the lowest in the Southeast (52%)
and must be addressed to meet the state's hiring needs.

• Quality, affordable, childcare is essential to a healthy and productive workforce, and is


particularly important for women who are more likely to step back from the workforce to
shoulder family responsibilities.

Recommendations:

• Strengthen equal pay protections by adding a salary history ban and incentivizing businesses
to conduct equal pay audits.

• Invest in childcare to support and grow Alabama’s workforce using targeted tax credits and
innovative financing to build and expand access to quality, affordable childcare.

• Streamline and scale the workforce development pipeline for women and girls, including
additional funding for programs that increase awareness of and access to high-demand, high-
paying jobs.

3
Introduction

Alabama’s economic prosperity depends on removing the barriers that hold women back from
fully participating in and benefitting from the state’s economy. Women in Alabama already
contribute $43 billion to the state’s economy despite experiencing one of the largest gender wage
gaps (67 cents for every dollar a man earns) and one of the lowest female labor force participation
rates (52% of working-age women).1 While Alabama continues to attract new businesses bringing
thousands of new jobs to the state, industries continue to struggle to find the talent they need.
Simply put, the state is on a trajectory where there will be more work than workforce. Alabama
must act now to create policies and practices that enable women to fully participate in the
economy.

In 2022, the State Legislature commissioned the Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force
to identify evidence-based policies to assist lawmakers in implementing laws to close the wage
gap (via House Joint Resolution 115). The 11-member Task Force, comprising lawmakers,
business and industry leaders, higher education experts, and community leaders, contributed a
diverse range of professional experience including economic development, public policy, human
resource management, financial planning, and employment and labor law. Throughout the
convenings, the Task Force heard from experts who shared cutting-edge research that quantified
the economic impact of women in Alabama, defined factors that drive labor force underutilization,
and compared the efficacy of equal pay laws across the United States. After the learning and
research phase, the Task Force set forth to craft specific policy recommendations to help close
the gender pay gap and bolster the workforce participation rate of women in Alabama.

The impact of closing the pay gap and workforce participation gap is significant. Achieving pay
parity in Alabama is estimated to create 59,000 new jobs, generate $15 billion in new income that
could be deployed in businesses throughout the state, and grow the state’s economy by up to
$22 billion.1 Furthermore, if women participated in the workforce at the same rate as men, the
state economy is estimated to grow by an additional $12 billion. Beyond the statewide economic
impact, ensuring equal pay and access to occupations would have a profound impact on the lives
of individuals, children, and families – 74% of which rely on a female breadwinner to pay for
necessities like food, housing, and childcare.2 When the path is cleared for women in Alabama to
reach their potential, families and communities prosper.

This report includes an overview of key findings and recommendations from the Task Force to
close the gender pay gap and increase workforce participation in Alabama. The following report
is divided into three sections highlighting and supporting recommendations to (1) strengthen the
state’s equal pay protections, (2) invest in childcare to support and expand the workforce, and (3)
streamline and strengthen the workforce development pipeline for women and girls.

4
Strengthen Equal Pay Protections to Close the Gender
Wage Gap
Key Findings
Women in Alabama are paid considerably less than men — across education levels, occupations,
and counties — and closing the wage gap would substantially boost Alabama’s economy.
According to research commissioned by the Women’s Foundation of Alabama, the gender pay
gap in Alabama is one of the largest in the country, with the average woman earning only 67 cents
for every dollar a man earns.1 This translates to a lifetime wage gap of over $510,000, where
women in Alabama would need to work to age 74 to catch up to what men make by age 60.3
These disparities are even worse for women of color in the state, where Black women and
Hispanic women earn only 52 cents and 41 cents, respectively, for every dollar a white man earns.

The gender wage gap in Alabama is a result of many factors including occupational segregation,
low labor force participation, the “motherhood penalty”, and the lasting impact of past
discriminatory practices.1 While the Clarke-Figures Equal Pay Act (CF-EPA) was a significant
step towards equal pay in Alabama, the law is currently underutilized and could be improved to
assist in closing the wage gap in Alabama.

Recommendations
Recommendation: Prohibit employers and third-parties from requesting pay history from
job applicants.

Rationale: While asking job applicants about their prior pay may seem innocuous on the surface,
it can have unintended and harmful consequences including perpetuating the gender wage gap.
Employers’ reliance on salary history to make hiring and compensation decisions is particularly
harmful for women, as the practice can unintentionally relegate women to lower pay based on
prior discrimination.4 Employers who have conducted pay equity audits say that differences in
salary history are a key driver of their gender pay gaps.5 Furthermore, salary history is often not
an objective measure of a worker’s value, as it fails to capture labor market conditions and the
applicant’s current qualifications, experience, abilities, and capacity to work.

While Alabama’s equal pay statute prohibits retaliation against individuals who refuse to provide
salary history, 17 other states actively prohibit employers from inquiring or seeking salary history.
Emerging research on existing salary history bans shows that these policies are effective and are
helping narrow the gender wage gap in participating regions.6 Across dozens of states, individuals
who changed jobs after the implementation of a salary history ban received pay increases that
were 5% higher than those received by comparable individuals who changed jobs in the absence
of a salary ban. 7 Similarly, this research showed that salary history bans have been most
beneficial for job changers who were female and/or people of color.

Each state’s salary history ban includes unique language to address the scope, definition, and
timing of pay history prohibitions. A subcommittee discussed the key differences and
recommended the following components to be included in the Clarke-Figures Equal Pay Act. First,
prohibit employers – including third-parties such as staffing agencies – from seeking wage history
information during the application, screening, and interview process. Second, exceptions should
be allowed for voluntary disclosures and disclosures required by law. Lastly, the definition of wage
history should remain consistent with current statute.

5
Recommendation: Incentivize equal pay audits by creating a good faith defense to
litigation for the CF-EPA.

Rationale: A pay audit is a critical tool that helps employers identify pay disparities and
opportunities to improve pay equity. According to a survey conducted by the Society of Human
Resource Management (SHRM), 83% of organizations that have conducted pay equity audits
have adjusted employees’ pay following the conclusion of the review.8

Acknowledging the direct and immediate impact that pay audits can have on an employer’s
compensation practices, several states have policies to incentivize pay equity audits. For
example, Rhode Island, Colorado, and Massachusetts allow recent equal pay audits to serve as
evidence of “good faith” when considering violations and penalties of their equal pay statutes.
Allowing recent pay audits to serve as a good faith defense provides a means to incentivize
employers to conduct these audits and reduce any identified pay disparities.

The subcommittee considered ways to structure a good faith defense to litigation for the CF-EPA
that would incentivize equal pay audits. An appropriate good faith defense would require a recent
bona fide equal pay audit conducted by an independent outside party and proof of corrective
action if applicable. The good faith defense could be used to lessen damages in wage disparity
cases, but not violations pertaining to the salary history ban. As an affirmative defense, equal pay
audits would not be mandatory.

6
Invest in Childcare to Support and Grow Alabama’s
Workforce
Key Findings
The labor force participation rate of women in Alabama is the lowest in the Southeast, and
Alabama must increase women’s participation in the labor force to meet the state's hiring needs.
According to the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, family responsibility and childcare are leading
factors that contribute to the underutilization of women in the labor force.9

Childcare is essential to a healthy and productive workforce. Yet, according to the Bipartisan
Policy Center, Alabama has a childcare supply gap of 85,550 children. This represents 40% of
children under age 6 who may need childcare but whose families cannot reasonably access
it.10 Furthermore, the workforce of childcare is predominately female; 90% of Alabama’s childcare
providers are women.11

Across the country, states are acknowledging the importance of childcare as a critical support for
working parents and early learning opportunity for its youngest citizens. For example, in April 2022
Kentucky enacted a public-private partnership to administer an Employee Child-Care Assistance
Program, where the state will match employer childcare benefits with state dollars and commit
$15 million over the next two years to support the program. In November 2022, New Mexico
became the first state to create a permanent fund for childcare and is planning to spend
approximately $150 million annually to support early learning. Childcare is a complex issue that
requires multi-faceted solutions from government, business, and local communities to address
affordability, accessibility, and quality in a sustainable way.

Recommendations
Recommendation: Create tax incentives to increase the supply and affordability of
quality childcare in Alabama.

Rationale: While the Alabama Legislature made a historic $17.8 million investment in quality
childcare in 2022, additional investment is needed to support childcare as a critical workforce
infrastructure. Tax credits aimed at families, employers, and childcare providers are powerful tools
that can increase access to quality and affordable childcare for families at all income levels.

In 2009, Louisiana pioneered comprehensive childcare tax credits to incentivize parents,


providers, and employers to participate in the state’s Quality Start program (Quality STARS/QRIS
equivalent).12 Briefly, their School Readiness Tax Credits include:

(1) Tax credits for families with young children (under 6) who are enrolled in a qualifying
licensed childcare program, with the value of the credit increasing with higher ratings of
the childcare program.

(2) Tax credits for childcare business owners who participate in the state’s quality program
based on the rating of their program and the number of high-need children served.

(3) Tax credits for childcare teachers and directors if they teach in a program that
participates in the quality program based on the level of education obtained by the
individual.

7
(4) Tax credits for businesses that provide financial support to childcare programs that
participate in the quality program or that donate to childcare resource and referral
agencies.

Since the implementation of these tax credits, Louisiana has seen a significant increase in the
number of children participating in quality childcare programs, and an increase in the number of
childcare instructors receiving training and credentials to improve their teaching practices.13 In
2014, $16.7 million in tax credits was utilized to positively impact 14,468 families, 3,770 educators,
405 childcare centers, and 190 businesses. A similar investment in Alabama’s childcare would go
a long way towards closing the childcare gap and boosting labor force participation for women in
the state.

Recommendation: Utilize all available federal funding, including temporary COVID relief,
to support access to affordable, quality childcare.

Rationale: Alabama has a limited time opportunity to direct federal funds from COVID-relief to
support childcare, whose workforce and customers (working parents and their children) were
deeply impacted by the pandemic. While some COVID-relief funds have been successfully
deployed to subsidize childcare worker salaries and address ongoing health and safety needs of
current providers, American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds could also be used to expand the
supply of care by providing start-up grants for new and expanded programs.

Recommendation: Explore innovative ways to close the childcare supply gap, such as a
revolving fund or start-up grants for childcare facilities and capital expenses.

Rationale: Start-up and expansion costs can be prohibitive for childcare business owners seeking
to launch or expand their operations. To address this problem, states like Maryland and California
have created revolving loan funds to provide zero-interest financing to cover capital expenses
and facilities costs for licensed childcare providers. Alternatively, the state could explore funding
start-up grants for aspiring childcare business owners and childcare providers who are currently
operating with a religious exemption to licensure. Providing a funding mechanism for currently
unlicensed or exempt childcare providers would create a much-needed incentive for childcare
providers to become licensed and expand.

Recommendation: Prioritize childcare in Alabama’s future workforce policy planning by


creating an intra-agency council on workforce and childcare.

Rationale: Childcare is essential to building and maintaining a healthy and productive workforce,
and all of society benefits when those closest to an issue weigh in on the solution. To facilitate
multi-sector collaboration to address Alabama’s complex childcare needs, an intra-agency council
on childcare and the workforce should be formed to bring together integral state agencies as well
as representatives from employers, childcare providers, and childcare resource and referral
agencies. With input from the Alabama Department of Human Resources, Department of Early
Childhood Education, Alabama Community College System, Department of Commerce, and
Department of Labor, the council will be able to coordinate and collaborate on approaches that
are currently fragmented.

8
Strengthen the Workforce Development Pipeline for
Women and Girls
Key Findings
Occupational segregation – or the over-representation of women in low wage jobs – is a key driver
of the gender wage gap in Alabama. Men and women tend to work in different occupations, and
the occupations that employ more women (e.g., retail, childcare, food preparation) usually pay
the least.1 Differences in occupations and employment within industries account for as much as
half of the gender wage gap. As such, disrupting occupational segregation will go a long way
towards closing the earnings gap and ensuring women’s broader participation in the economy.

To increase the number of women in the workforce and address occupational segregation,
Alabama must invest in thoughtful interventions across the lifespan that disrupt traditional gender
stereotypes and remove barriers to accessing quality, high-wage jobs. Fortunately, there is no
shortage of workforce development organizations, programs, and initiatives taking place
throughout the state. However, awareness of and access to these education and training
resources poses a challenge, reducing the reach and impact for those who could benefit most.
Coordination, cooperation, and communication within and across such initiatives could be
improved to ensure that all Alabamians have an equal opportunity to access the education and
training necessary to secure sustainable employment.

Recommendations
Recommendation: Add representative(s) to the Alabama Workforce Council(s) to focus
on gender dynamics in workforce development.

Rationale: AlabamaWorks! and AlabamaWorks! Success Plus have outlined a structured path
for our state to add credentialed workers to the workforce and have created the organizational
infrastructure to support workforce development in all regions of the state. Expanding and
improving the coordination of state-wide and regional workforce development efforts could have
a meaningful impact on the labor force participation of women in our state.

To ensure that those closest to the problems facing women in the workforce are contributing to
their solutions, the Task Force recommends adding a representative to the Alabama Workforce
Council(s) to focus on gender dynamics in workforce development (e.g. pay gap, labor force
participation, occupational segregation, and childcare), as well as oversee programs that are
targeted to women in the workforce.

Recommendation: Increase funding for early intervention programs that expose and
prepare girls for careers in STEM.

Rationale: Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) fields account for some
of the fastest growing and highest paying jobs of the future. Yet, girls and women are less likely
than boys and men to prepare for and enter these fields. Girls experience implicit and explicit
gender bias in school and at home that tells them that boys and men are better at math and
science – even when there is no evidence to support that.

There are many steps that can be taken to create a lifelong pathway of opportunity for girls and
women in STEM. 1415 However, the National Science Foundation has shown that interventions

9
aimed at 12- to 13-year-old girls are particularly effective at interrupting mindsets about their
capabilities and career opportunities. Immersive camps focused on STEM careers, like the Tech
Trek Camp hosted by the University of Alabama at Huntsville, have been successful in reversing
stereotypes and convincing young women that competency in spatial learning, math and science
is learned through study and experience, not determined by innate abilities. Similarly, career
expos that target students and young people – like the Worlds of Work – provide a valuable venue
to showcase regional workforce opportunities and increase awareness of high-demand, high-
paying jobs.

Furthermore, increasing the number and availability of STEM camps for adolescent girls is a
relatively small investment with potential for great impact. For reference, the cost of such a camp
for 65 girls is around $50,000.

Recommendation: Increase funding for apprenticeship programs and “earn and learn”
pathways.

Most people in Alabama – women especially – do not have the financial security to take time
away from lower paying jobs to complete a training or certifications that would increase their
wages in the long term. For this reason, “earn and learn” pathways are beneficial for women
because they enable trainees to learn a valuable skill or trade while continuing to earn a living.
Apprenticeships are one such pathway successfully deployed in Alabama to train and employ
people in trade and manufacturing occupations. According to the Urban Institute, the most
successful models are apprenticeship programs that collaborate between multiple employers,
intermediaries, and community colleges.1617

Reimagining the types of jobs that are eligible to achieve certification through apprenticeship is
essential to filling worker shortages as well as opening doors to higher paying jobs for women.
Other states are pioneering – with success – earn and learn programs in professions historically
viewed as unsuitable for apprenticeships. For example, Tennessee is pioneering a teaching
apprenticeship program that allows educators in training to achieve certifications and even four-
year degrees while gaining paid experience in the classroom. Similarly, tech training programs
that provide data science and coding bootcamps and professional development opportunities are
preparing the next generation of analysts and software engineers for stable, high-paying jobs.

Recommendation: Increase funding for workforce navigators and career coaches.

Rationale: Women face considerable barriers to completing workforce training programs,


entering the workforce, and staying employed. Among the leading challenges are transportation,
health care, childcare, and wage disparities. Workforce navigators – such as those employed by
regional Alabama Works – help job seekers access the resources they need to access quality
jobs, including transportation, childcare, and housing. Similarly, career coaches provide
personalized support to community college students while they are completing their studies and
starting their careers. Increasing the number of workforce navigators and career coaches would
expand the number of students and job seekers that can be supported, trained, and employed.

10
Conclusions

Alabama must address its wage gap and barriers to workforce participation that keep its citizens
from fully contributing to the economy and benefiting from their hard work.

Alabama’s gender and racial wage gaps arise largely from occupational segregation, low labor
force participation, and the legacy of discriminatory practices. Women face unique barriers that
make it harder for them to work and earn a fair wage, including an increased burden of family
responsibilities and shortage of quality, affordable childcare.

Here, the Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force has identified specific and actionable
recommendations for the legislature to consider that would help strengthen the state’s equal pay
protection, expand access to childcare, and reinforce the workforce development pipeline. If
implemented, these recommendations will pave the way to an Alabama where all residents,
including women, are paid an equal wage for equal work.

11
Task Force Member Signatures

As appointed members of the Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force, I endorse the
recommendations as laid out in this document.

12
Acknowledgements

The Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force offers their sincere appreciation to the
following expert presenters, panelists, consultants, and administrators who lent their time and
expertise to these recommendations:

Allan M. Freyer, Ph.D., Principal and Founder of Peregrine Strategy Solutions


He is a public affairs professional with more than 20 years of experience driving policy change at
the intersection of politics, advocacy, and policy-making. He was also the lead researcher for the
2022 Clearing the Path report on the Economic Impact of Women in Alabama.

Linda Smith, Director of the Early Childhood Initiative, Bipartisan Policy Center
She most recently served as the deputy assistant secretary for early childhood development in
the Administration for Children and Families (ACF) at the U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services.

Andrea Johnson, J.D., Director of State Policy, Workplace Justice & Cross-Cutting Initiatives,
National Women’s Law Center
In this role, she coordinates efforts to advance state policies across NWLC’s priority issue areas
while working directly on legislation and litigation related to pay discrimination, sexual
harassment, pregnancy discrimination, and unfair scheduling practices.

Alex Ruder, Ph.D., Principal Advisor, Community and Economic Development Team, Federal
Reserve Bank of Atlanta
As an affiliate of the Atlanta Federal Reserve’s Center for Workforce and Economic Opportunity,
he specializes in community and workforce development as well as public policy.

Anoop Mishra, VP/Regional Executive, Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, Birmingham Branch
He oversees the Birmingham Branch's economic and financial education program and provides
regional input into the Atlanta Federal Reserve's monetary policy process.

Rhonda Kay Gaede, Ph.D., Interim Associate Provost, Associate Chair & Professor of
Engineering, University of Alabama Huntsville, Chair of Tech Trek (a week-long immersive STEM
camp for 12–13-year-old girls)

Bernard Houston, Childcare Services and Workforce Development, Alabama Department of


Human Resources

Donny Jones, Executive Director, Region 3 Workforce Development Council/West Alabama


Works

Ashley Smith, Legislative Attorney, Legislative Services Agency

Mary Ruth Davis, Committee Clerk for Alabama House of Representatives

13
Citations
1
Women’s Foundation of Alabama. (2022). Clearing the Path: Galvanizing the Economic Impact
of Women.
2
Women’s Foundation of Alabama. (2020). Status of Women in Alabama.
3
National Women’s Law Center. (March 16, 2021). The Lifetime Wage Gap, State by State.
4
Bleiweis, R. (March 24, 2021) Why Salary History Bans Matter to Securing Equal Pay. Center
for American Progress.
5
Harvard Business Review Analytic Services. (2019). Navigating the Growing Pay Equity
Movement: What Employers Need to Know About What to Do. Harvard Business School
Publishing.
6
Hansen, B & McNichols, D. (April 2020). Information and the Persistence of the Gender Wage
Gap: Early Evidence from California's Salary History Ban. National Bureau of Economic
Research.
7
Bessen, J.E., Meng, C., & Denk, E. (June 2020). Perpetuating Inequality: What Salary History
Bans Reveal About Wages. SSRN.
8
Society for Human Resources Management. (2021). Bridging the Pay Gap: Why Pay Equity
Pays Off
9
Ruder, A. (2022, September 22). Labor Force Underutilization in Alabama. Federal Reserve
Bank of Atlanta.
10
Bipartisan Policy Center. (2019). The Supply Of, Potential Need For, And Economic Impact
Of The Gaps In Child Care In Alabama In 2019.
11
Women’s Foundation of Alabama. (2021). Clearing the Path, Strengthening Childcare,
Strengthening Alabama
12
Stoney, L. (2009, June 10). Using Tax Credits to Promote Quality Early Child Care and
Education. New America.
13
Louisiana Policy Institute for Children. (2016, October). Giving Credit Where it is Due: School
Readiness Tax Credits Benefit Louisiana Families and Communities
14
American Association of University Women. (2013). Why So Few? Women in Science,
Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics
15
American Association of University Women. (Closing the STEM Gap).
16
Urban Institute. (2022). Best Practices for Being an Apprenticeship Friendly State.
17
Elliott, D., Marotta, J., Hernandez, F., and Rayfield, J. Urban Institute. (June 2022). What
Works in Tech Apprenticeship: Best Practices for Expanding Registered Apprenticeships in the
Tech Sector. Urban Institute.

14
Appendix
House Joint Resolution 115
CREATING THE ALABAMA WORKFORCE AND WAGE GAP TASKFORCE

WHEREAS, accelerating economic opportunity for women is central to solidifying the positive
economic trajectory that Alabama enjoys; and WHEREAS, the wage gap for women in Alabama
is larger than for women in the United States overall; women in Alabama earn only 73 cents for
every dollar a man earns, while women in the United States earn 82 cents for every dollar a man
earns; if the current trend continues, Alabama women will not reach pay equity until 2089; and

WHEREAS, women are more likely than men to have filed claims for unemployment during the
COVID-19 pandemic, accounting for 55.37 percent of total claims; and WHEREAS, women with
children who wish to enter the workforce face steep child-care costs as the annual child-care
costs for an infant under 12 months of age in Alabama is estimated at $5,858 per year, which is
nearly 17 percent of women's median annual earnings; and

WHEREAS, paying employed single women the same amount as comparable men would reduce
the state's poverty rate by nearly half; and

WHEREAS, raising the labor participation rate of women in Alabama to the national average could
add more than 380,000 women to the workforce; and

WHEREAS, women remain disproportionately represented in certain occupations, such as


teaching, nursing, social work, and office and administrative jobs, which are demanding and tend
to pay less; and

WHEREAS, more than 74 percent of women in Alabama are the breadwinners in their households
and more than 10 percent of employed mothers have young children; the wage gap is even larger
for Black women and Latina women in Alabama, indicating racialized structural barriers to well-
being; Black women made 58.5 cents and Latina women made 48.8 cents for every dollar that a
white man earned in Alabama in 2017; and

WHEREAS, identifying evidence-based policies that can close the wage gap would assist policy
makers in their efforts; and

WHEREAS, creating a task force that will gather those policies and report to policy makers is a
necessary step in the quest to close the wage gap between men and women; now therefore

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF ALABAMA, BOTH HOUSES THEREOF


CONCURRING, that there is hereby created the Alabama Workforce and Wage Gap Task Force
to identify evidence-based policies to assist lawmakers in implementing laws to close the wage
gap.

(a) The task force shall be composed of the 4 following members:

(1) Three members appointed by the Governor, who shall be representatives of university
colleges of business and management, including at least one from a Historically Black College or
University.

15
(2) Two members appointed by the Senate President Pro Tempore upon recommendation by the
Women's Foundation of Alabama and the American Association of University Women, one of
which shall serve as chair as selected by the Senate President Pro Tempore.

(3) One member appointed by the Senate Minority Leader.

(4) Two members appointed by the Speaker of the House of Representatives upon
recommendation by the Business Council of Alabama and the Alabama Department of Labor.

(5) One member appointed by the House of Representatives Minority Leader

(6) One member appointed by the Women's Section of the Alabama State Bar.

(7) One member appointed by the Society of Human Resource Management.

(b) The appointing authorities shall coordinate their appointments to assure that the task force is
inclusive and reflects the racial, gender, geographic, urban, rural, and economic diversity of the
state.

(c) The task force shall hold its first meeting within 60 days of this resolution's passage, at a time
and place designated by the chair. Each appointing authority named herein shall be provided a
copy of this resolution upon its passage.

(d) The task force shall report any findings or recommendations to the Legislature and stand
dissolved and discharged of any future duties and liabilities no later than December 31, 2022.

16

You might also like