Dcac PDF

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 117

E6501 POWER ELECTRONIC CONVERTERS (39 h)

Semester 1, AY 2009/10

SECTION D: DC/AC INVERTERS (12 h)

By Associate Professor Luo Fang Lin (DR)

(S1-B1c-108, Tel: 5023, e-mail: [email protected])

I. Introduction

Since the students to take this course have studied the courses EE2001,

EE2005, E3015 and E4532, you have already known the conversion

technology that has four aspects:

• DC/DC converters

• DC/AC inverters

• AC/DC rectifiers

• AC/AC converters

DC/AC inversion technology is a big subject area in research

investigation and industrial applications. We study the DC/AC inverters

in advanced schemes: pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique,

multilevel inversion technique and z-source inversion technique (not

introduced in this course). PWM technique was carefully discussed in

under-graduate courses. We just review some switching signal

arrangement; do NOT pay more attention in the whole technique in

detail.

1
DC/AC inverters are quickly developed knowledge of the power

switching circuits applied in industrial applications in comparison with

other power switching circuits. In recent century, plenty of topologies of

DC/AC inverters have been created. Generally say, the DC/AC inverters

are mainly used in AC motor adjustable speed drive (ASD). Although

choppers were popular in DC/AC power supply long time ago, power

DC/AC inverters were widely used in industrial application since later

1980’s. Semiconductor manufacture development brought Power devices

such as GTO, Triac, BT, IGBT and MOSFET and so on in higher

switching frequency (say from thousands Hz up to few MHz) into the

DC/AC power supply since 1980’s. Because of the devices such as

thyristor (SCR) with low switching frequency, the above mentioned

devices have low power rate.

Square-waveform DC/AC inverters were used in early ages before 1980’s.

In those equipment thyristor, GTO and Triac could be used in low-

frequency switching operation. High frequency/high power devices such

as Power BT and IGBT were produced in 1980’s. The corresponding

equipment implementing the pulsewidth-modulation (PWM) technique

has large range of the output voltage and frequency, and low THD.

Nowadays, most DC/AC inverters are PWM DC/AC inverters in different

prototypes.

2
DC/AC inverters are used for inverting DC power source into AC power

applications. They are generally used in following applications:

1. Variable voltage/Variable frequency AC supplies in adjustable

speed drive (ASD), such as induction motor drives, synchronous

machine drives and so on.

2. Constant regulated voltage AC power supplies such as

uninterruptible power supplies (UPS’s).

3. Static var (reactive power) compensations

4. Passive/Active series/parallel filters.

5. Flexible AC transmission systems (FACTS’s)

6. Voltage compensations.

(a) Switch-mode inverter in AC motor drive

3
(b) Switch-mode converters for motoring/regenerative braking

Figure 1. A standard adjustable speed drive scheme

Adjustable speed induction motor drive systems are widely applied in

industrial applications. These system requested the DC/AC power supply

with variable frequency usually from 0 Hz to 400 Hz in fractional horse-

power (HP) to hundreds HP. A large number of DC/AC inverters are in

the world market. The typical block circuit of an ASD is shown in Figure

1. From this block diagram we can see that the power DC/AC inverter

produces variable frequency and voltage to implement ASD.

1.1. Pulse-Width Modulation (PWM)

The pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique is a popular method to

implement DC/AC inversion technology. The corresponding circuit is

called the pulsewidth modulator. We believe you have already known the

knowledge in your undergraduate courses. We will review this technique,

and mainly introduce other advanced methodologies in this course.

4
Typical input and output waveforms of a pulsewidth modulator are shown

in Figure 2. The output pulse train has the pulses with same amplitude

and different widths, which corresponding to the input signal at the

sampling instants.

f (t )

(a) Input signal

f w (t )

t
T

(b) Output signal

Figure 2. Typical input and output waveforms of a pulsewidth modulator

The modulation ratio m is arranged in certain area, which is usually

yielded by a uniformed-amplitude triangle (carrier) signal with the

amplitude V tri-m . The maximum amplitude of the input signal is assumed

5
V in-m . We define the amplitude modulation ratio ma for a single-phase as

follow expression.

Vin −m
ma = (1)
Vtri −m

Figure 3. Voltage control by varying ma

We also define the frequency modulation ratio m f as follow expression.

f tri −m
mf = (2)
f in −m

Since the value of the input signal is always smaller than and/or equal to

6
the maximum amplitude V in-m , the modulation ratio m is always smaller

than and/or equal to the modulation ratio m a . The voltage control by

varying ma for a single-phase PWM is spitted in three areas which are

shown in Figure 3.

1.1.1. Linear Range ( ma ≤ 1.0 )

The condition (Vˆ ) = m . V2


Ao 1 a
d
determines the linear region. It is a

sinusoidal PWM where the amplitude of the fundamental frequency

voltage varies linearly with the amplitude modulation ratio m a . The PWM

pushes the harmonics into a high frequency range around the switching

frequency and its multiples. However, the maximum available amplitude

of the fundamental frequency component may not be as high as desired.

1.1.2. Over modulation ( 1.27 > ma > 1.0 )

The condition
Vd
2
( )
< VˆAo 1 <
4 Vd
π 2
determines the over modulation region.

When the amplitude of the fundamental frequency component in the

output voltage is increase beyond 1.0, it reaches over modulation. In over

modulation range, the amplitude of the fundamental frequency voltage no

longer varies linearly with m a .

Over modulation causes the output voltage to contain many more

harmonics in the sidebands as compared with the linear range. The

7
harmonics with dominant amplitudes in the linear range may not be

dominant during over modulation.

1.1.3. Square Wave (Sufficiently Large m a > 1.27)

The inverter voltage waveform degenerates from a pulse-width

modulated waveform into a square wave.

Figure 4. Typical waveforms of PWM for single-phase operation

8
If the signal is a sinusoidal wave, we usually call this inversion is

sinusoidal pulse-width-modulation (SPWM). The typical waveforms of

SPWM are shown in Figure 4.

1.2. Total Harmonic Distortion (THD)

Refer to Figure 4 (c) some parameters are introduced in this sub-section.

1.2.1. Harmonic Factor (HF)

Harmonic Factor (HF) is a variable to describe the weighted percent of a

certain individual harmonic referring to the amplitude of the fundamental

harmonic V 1 . It is defined as

Vn
HFn = (3)
V1

where V n is the amplitude of the nth order harmonic. n = 1 corresponds

the fundamental harmonic.

1.2.2. Total Harmonic Distortion (THD)

Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) is an important variable to describe the

waveform distortion. It is defined as

9

∑V
n =2
n
2

THD = (4)
V1

A pure sinusoidal waveform has THD = 0.

1.2.3. Weighted Total Harmonic Distortion (WTHD)

Weighted Total Harmonic Distortion (WTHD) is a variable to describe

the waveform distortion. It is defined as


Vn2
∑ n
WTHD = n =2 (5)
V1

Note that THD gives an immediate measure of the inverter output voltage

waveform distortion. WTHD is often interpreted as the normalized

current ripple expected into an inductive load when fed from the inverter

output voltage.

1.3. Voltage Source Inverter and Current Source Inverter

DC/AC inverters have three typical supply methods:

• Voltage Source Inverter (VSI)

• Current Source Inverter (CSI)

• Impedance Source Inverter (z-source inverter)

10
Generally say, the circuits of VSI and CSI can be same. The difference

between VSI and CSI is the type of the power supply sources, which are

voltage source and current source correspondingly.

1.3.1. Voltage Source Inverter (VSI)

A Voltage Source Inverter is supplied by a voltage source. Since the

source is a DC voltage it is necessary to avoid short-circuit of the DC

voltage source during operation. The control circuit and interface have to

be designed to leave small gaps between switching signals to the up-

switches and lower-switches. For example, the output voltage frequency

is in the range 0 – 400 Hz, and the PWM carrying frequency is in 2 – 20

kHz, the gaps are usually set in 20 - 100 ns.

This requirement is not very convenient for the control circuit and

interface design as well, but most DC/AC inverters are VSIs. VSI usually

converts the voltage from high to low such as a Buck technical feature.

1.3.2. Current Source Inverter (CSI)

A Current Source Inverter is supplied by a current source. Since the

source is a DC current source it is necessary to avoid open-circuit of the

DC voltage source during operation. The control circuit and interface

have to be designed to have a small overlaps between switching signals

to the up-switches and lower-switches. For example, the output voltage

11
frequency is in the range 0 – 400 Hz, and the PWM carrying frequency is

in 2 – 20 kHz, the overlaps are usually set in 20 - 100 ns.

This requirement is easy for the control circuit and interface design, but

not many DC/AC inverters are CSIs. CSI usually converts the voltage

from low to high such as a Boost technical feature.

1.4. Circuits of DC/AC Inverters

The general used DC/AC inverters are introduced below.

1. Single-phase half-bridge voltage source inverter (VSI)

2. Single-phase full-bridge VSI

3. Three-phase full-bridge VSI

4. Three-phase full-bridge current source inverter (CSI)

5. Multistage PWM Inverters

6. Multilevel PWM Inverters

7. Soft-switching Inverters

8. z-source Inverters

1.4.1. Single-Phase Half-Bridge Voltage Source Inverter

12
A single-phase half-bridge voltage source inverter (VSI) is shown in

Figure 5. The carrier-based pulse-width modulation (PWM) technique is

applied in this single-phase half-bridge VSI. Two large capacitors are

required to provide a neutral point N, therefore, each capacitor keep the

half of the input DC voltage. Two switches S+ and S- are switched by the

PWM signal.

Figure 5. Single-phase half-bridge VSI

In general, linear modulation operation is considered, so that m a is

usually smaller than unity, e.g. m a = 0.8. Generally, in order to obtain

low THD, the m f is usually taken large number, e.g. mf = 9. In order to

well understand each inverter, we shown some typical circuit below:

13
(a) Carrier and modulating signals

(b) Switch S+ state

(c) Switch S- state

(d) AC output voltage

(e) AC output current

14
Figure 6. Single-phase half-bridge VSI (ma = 0.8, m f = 9)

How to determine the pulsewidth is the clue of the PWM. If the v C is a

sine-wave function as shown in Figure 6, we call the modulation is

sinusoidal pulsewidth modulation (SPWM). For example, the m a = 0.8

and m f = 9. Assume that the amplitude of the triangle wave is 1, the

amplitude of the sine-wave is 0.8. Refer to Figure 6 (a), the sine-wave

function is

f (t ) = ma sin ωt = 0.8sin100π t (6)

Where ω = 2πf, f = 50 Hz. The triangle functions are lines:

f Δ1 (t ) = −4 fm f t = −1800t f Δ2 (t ) = 4 fm f t − 2 = 1800t − 2
f Δ3 (t ) = 4 − 4 fm f t = 4 − 1800t f Δ4 (t ) = 4 fm f t − 6 = 1800t − 6

……
f Δ(2 n −1) (t ) = 4( n − 1) − 4 fm f t f Δ2 n (t ) = 4 fm f t − (4 n − 2) (7)

……
f Δ17 (t ) = 32 − 1800t f Δ18 (t ) = 1800t − 34
f Δ19 (t ) = 36 − 1800t

The leading edge of the first pulses are at t = 0. Refer to Figure 6 (a), the

first pulsewidth (time or degree) is determined by the equation:

0.8sin100π t = 1800t − 2 (8)


15
This is a transcendental equation with the unknown value of t. Using

iterative method to solve the equation, let x = 0.8sin100πt and y =

1800t-2, and initial t 0 = 1.38889 ms = 25 O ,

t (ms/degree) x y |x|:y remarks


1.38889/25 O 0.338 0.5 < decrease t
1.27778/23 O 0.3126 0.3 > increase t
1.2889/23.2 O 0.3152 0.32 < decrease t
1.2861/23.15 O 0.3145 0.315 ≈

The first pulsewidth to switch-on and off the switch S + is 1.2861 ms (or

23.15 O )

Other pulsewidths can be determined from other equations using iterative

method.

Figure 7. Sinusoidal PWM

16
Figure 6 shows the ideal waveforms associated with the half-bridge VSI.

We can find out the phase delay between the output current and voltage.

For a large m f we can see the cross points demonstrated in Figure 7 with

smaller phase delay between the output current and voltage.

1.4.2. Single-Phase Full-Bridge Voltage Source Inverter

A single-phase full-bridge voltage source inverter (VSI) is shown in

Figure 8. The carrier-based pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique is

applied in this single-phase full-bridge VSI. Two large capacitors may be

used to provide a neutral point N, therefore, each capacitor keep the half

of the input DC voltage. Four switches S 1 +/S 1 - and S 2 +/S 2 - are applied

and switched by the PWM signal.

Figure 8. Single-phase full-bridge VSI

Figure 9 shows the ideal waveforms associated with the full-bridge VSI.

There are two sine-waves used in Figure 9 (a)corresponding the two legs

17
operation. We can find out the phase delay between the output current

and voltage.

(a) Carrier and modulating signals

(b) Switch S 1 + and S 1 - state

(c) Switch S 2 + and S 2 - state

(d) AC output voltage

18
(e) AC output current

Figure 9. The full-bridge VSI (ma = 0.8, m f = 8)

The method to determine the pulsewidths is same as that introduced in

the previous section. Refer to Figure 9 (a), we can find that there are two

sine-wave functions:

f + (t ) = ma sin ω t = 0.8sin100π t (9)

and f − (t ) = − ma sin ω t = −0.8 sin100π t (10)

The triangle functions are:

f Δ1 (t ) = −4 fm f t = −1600t f Δ2 (t ) = 4 fm f t − 2 = 1600t − 2
f Δ3 (t ) = 4 − 4 fm f t = 4 − 1600t f Δ4 (t ) = 4 fm f t − 6 = 1600t − 6

……
f Δ(2 n −1) (t ) = 4( n − 1) − 4 fm f t f Δ2 n (t ) = 4 fm f t − (4 n − 2) (11)

……
f Δ15 (t ) = 28 − 1600t f Δ16 (t ) = 1600t − 30
f Δ17 (t ) = 32 − 1600t

19
The first pulsewidth to switch-on and switch-off the switches S 1 + and S 1 -

is determined by the equation below:

0.8sin100π t = 1600t − 2 (12)

The first pulsewidth to switch-on and switch-off the switches S 2 + and S 2 -

is determined by the equation below:

−0.8sin100π t = 1600t − 2 (13)

This is the exercise for student’s homework.

1.4.3. Three-Phase Full-Bridge Voltage Source Inverter

Figure 10. Three-phase full-bridge VSI

A three-phase full-bridge VSI is shown in Figure 10. The carrier-based

pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique is applied in this three-phase

full-bridge VSI. Two large capacitors may be used to provide a neutral

20
point N, therefore, each capacitor keep the half of the input DC voltage.

Six switches S 1 - S 6 are applied and switched by the PWM signal. Figure

11 shows the ideal waveforms associated with the full-bridge VSI. We

can find out the phase delay between the output current and voltage.

(a) Carrier and modulating signals

(b) Switch S 1 /S 4 state

(c) Switch S 3 /S 6 state

vab1
vab vi

ωt
0 90 180 270 360

(d) AC output voltage

21
(e) AC output current

Figure 11. Three-phase full-bridge VSI (m a = 0.8, m f = 9)

Figure 12. The function of m a for a three-phase inverter

The modulation indication of a three-phase VSI is shown in Figure 12.

1.4.4. Unipolar Single-Phase Half-Bridge Voltage Source Inverter

22
Bipolar inverters are not used in industrial applications. An unipolar

single-phase half-bridge voltage source inverter (VSI) with ma = 0.8 and

m f = 12 is shown in Figure 13. The circuit is same to the bipolar VSI, but

the regulation is different, which is like the two stage regulation.

ii
vi/2 S+ D+

C+ io
a +
vi vO
N _

vi/2
C- S- D-

(a) The circuit

(b) The regulation waveform

(c) The output waveform

Figure 13. An unipolar 1-Φ half-bridge VSI with ma =0.8 & m f =12

23
The sine waveforms’ equation is:

f (t ) = ma sin ωt = 0.8sin100π t (14)

Where ω = 2πf, f = 50 Hz. The positive triangle waveforms’ equations

triangle functions are lines:

f Δ1 (t ) = 1 − 2 fm f t = 1 − 1200t f Δ2 (t ) = 2 fm f t − 1 = 1200t − 1
f Δ3 (t ) = 3 − 2 fm f t = 3 − 1200t f Δ4 (t ) = 2 fm f t − 3 = 1200t − 3

……
f Δ(2 n −1) (t ) = (2 n − 1) − 2 fm f t f Δ2 n (t ) = 2 fm f t − (2 n − 1) (15)

……
f Δ11 (t ) = 11 − 1200t f Δ12 (t ) = 2 fm f t − 11

The leading edge of the first pulses is at point A, the tailing edge is at

point B Referring to Figure 13 (a), the first pulsewidth (time or degree) is

determined by the equation:

[A] 0.8sin100π t = 1 − 1200t (16)

And [B] 0.8sin100π t = 1200t − 1 (17)

These are transcendental equation with the unknown value of t. Using

iterative method to solve the equation for point [A], let x = 0.8sin100πt

and y = 1-1200t, and initial t 0 = 1.38889 or ωt 0 = 12 O ,

24
t (ms)/ωt(degree) x y |x|:y remarks
0.66667/12 O 0.16633 0.2 < increase t
0.72222/13 O 0.17996 0.13333 > decrease t
0.69444/12.5 O 0.17315 0.1667 > decrease t
0.68333/12.3 O 0.17042 0.18 < increase t
0.68889/12.4 O 0.17179 0.17333 ≈ end

The leading edge of the first pulse of the switch S + is 0.68889 ms (or

12.4 O )

Using iterative method to solve the equation for point [B], let x =

0.8sin100πt and y = 1200t -1, and initial t 0 = 1.38889 or ωt 0 = 18 O ,

t (ms)/ωt(degree) x y |x|:y remarks


1.0/18 O 0.24721 0.2 > increase t
1.05556/19 O 0.26045 0.26667 < decrease t
1.04444/18.8 O 0.25781 0.25333 ≈ end

The tailing edge of the first pulse of the switch S + is 1.04444 ms (or

18.8 O ). Therefore the first pulse width is 1.0444-0.68889 = 0.3555 ms (or

18.8-12.4 = 6.4 O ).

Students can try to obtain the first pulse width for the switch S -, which

should be same to the one of the first pulse width of the switch S +.

1.4.5. Three-Phase Full-Bridge Current Source Inverter

A three-phase full-bridge current source inverter (CSI) is shown in

Figure 14.

25
ii S1 S3 S5

D1 D3 D5 ioa
a +v
_ ab
vi b
c
S4 S6 S2 C C C

D4 D6 D2

Figure 14. Three-phase CSI

The carrier-based pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique is applied in

this three-phase full-bridge CSI. The main objective of these static power

converters is to produce AC output current waveforms from a DC current

power supply. Six switches S 1 - S 6 are applied and switched by the PWM

signal. Figure 15 shows the ideal waveforms associated with the full-

bridge CSI.

(a) Carrier and modulating signals

(b) Switch S 1 + state

26
(c) Switch S 3 state

(d) AC output current

(e) AC output voltage

Figure 15. Three-phase CSI (ma = 0.8, m f = 9)

We can find out the phase ahead between the output voltage and current.

1.4.6. Multistage PWM Inverter

Multistage PWM inverter consists of many cells. Each cell can be a

single-phase or three-phase input plus single-phase output VSI, which is

27
shown in Figure 16. If the three-phase AC supply is a secondary winding

of a main transformer, it is floating and isolated from other cells and

common ground point. Therefore, all cells can be link in series or parallel

manner.

ii
L
S1+
D1 D3 D5
vi/2 D1+ S2+ D2+
C+
isa
io
N a +
b vo
_

D4 D6 D2 vi/2 C- S1-
D1- S2- D2-

Figure 16. Three-phase input Single-phase output cell.

A three-stage PWM inverter is shown in Figure 17. Each phase consist of

three cells with difference phase-angle shift by 20 O each other.

The carrier-based pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique is applied in

this three-phase multistage PWM Inverter. Figure 18 shows the ideal

waveforms associated with the full-bridge VSI. We can find out the

output the phase delayed between the output current and voltage.

28
Figure 17. Multistage converter based on a multicell arrangement.

vca vΔ1 vΔ2 vΔ3 -vca

ωt
0 90 180 270 360

(a) Carrier and modulating signals

vo211 v
vo21 i

ωt
0 90 180 270 360

(b) Cell c 11 AC output voltage

29
(c) Cell c 21 AC output voltage

(d) Cell c 31 AC output voltage

(e) Phase a load voltage

Figure 18. Multicell PWM inverter (3 stages, m a = 0.8, m f = 6)

1.4.7. Multilevel PWM Inverter

A three-level PWM inverter is shown in Figure 19. The carrier-based

pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technique is applied in this multilevel

PWM inverter. Figure 20 shows the ideal waveforms associated with the

30
multilevel PWM inverter. We can find out the output the phase delayed

between the output current and voltage.

ii
S1a D1a S3a D3a S5a D5a

vi/2 C+
S1b S5b
Da+ Db+ S3b Dc+ D5b
D1b D3b
ioa
a +v
_ ab
N b
c

S4a S6a
Da- Db- Dc- S2a D2a
D4a D6a
vi/2 C-
S4b D4b S6b S2b D2b
D6b

Figure 19. Three-phase Three-level VSI.

(a) Carrier and modulating signals

(b) Switch S 1a status

31
(c) Switch S 4b status

(d) inverter phase a-N voltage

vab1
vab Vi
Vi/2
0 90 180 360
ωt
270

(e) AC output line voltage

van 0.66·Vi

0 90 ωt
270 360
180
van1

(f) AC output phase voltage

Figure 20. Three-level VSI (3 levels, ma = 0.8, m f = 15)

32
1.5. FFT - Fast Fourier Transform

FFT - Fast Fourier Transform is very versatile method to analyze the

waveforms. A periodical function with the radian frequency ω, can be

represented by a series of sinusoidal functions:

a0 ∞
f (t ) = + ∑ (an cos nωt + bn sin nωt ) (18)
2 n =1
where the Fourier coefficients are:


1
an =
π ∫
0
f (t ) cos(nωt )d (ωt ) n = 0, 1, 2, … ∞ (19)


1
bn =
π ∫
0
f (t )sin( nωt )d (ωt ) n = 1, 2, … ∞ (20)

In this case we call the item(s) with the radian frequency ω the

fundamental harmonic, and the items with the radian frequency nω (n > 1)

higher-order harmonics. Draw the amplitudes of all harmonics in the

frequency domain. We can get the spectrum in an individual peaks. The

item a 0 /2 is the DC component.

1.5.1. Central Symmetrical Periodical Function

33
If the periodical function is a central symmetrical periodical function the

all items with cosine function disappear. The FFT is remaining as


f (t ) = ∑ bn sin nωt (21)
n =1

where:

1
bn =
π ∫
0
f (t )sin( nωt )d (ωt ) n = 1, 2, … ∞ (22)

We usually call this function Odd-Order Function, or Odd-Function. In

this case, we call the item with the radian frequency ω the fundamental

harmonic, and the items with the radian frequency nω (n > 1) higher-

order harmonics. Draw the amplitudes of all harmonics in the frequency

domain. We can get the spectrum in an individual peaks. Since it is an

Odd-Function, the DC component is zero.

1.5.2. Axial (mirror) Symmetrical Periodical Function

If the periodical function is an axial symmetrical periodical function the

all items with sine function disappear. The FFT is remaining as

a0 ∞
f (t ) = + ∑ an cos nωt (23)
2 n =1
where a 0 /2 is the DC component and

34

1
an =
π ∫
0
f (t ) cos(nωt )d (ωt ) n = 0, 1, 2, … ∞ (24)

We usually call this function Even-Order Function, or Even-Function. In

this case, we call the item with the radian frequency ω the fundamental

harmonic, and the items with the radian frequency nω (n > 1) higher-

order harmonics. Draw the amplitudes of all harmonics in the frequency

domain. We can get the spectrum in an individual peaks. Since it is an

Even-Function, the DC component is usually not zero.

1.5.3. Non-Periodical Function

If a function is non-periodical function, it is possible represented by

Fourier Integration. The spectrum in the frequency domain is not a

discrete spectrum. It is a continuous function spectrum.

1.5.4. Useful Formulae and Data

Some trigonometric formulae are useful for FFT:

π
sin 2 x + cos2 x = 1 sin x = cos( − x)
2

sin x = − sin( − x ) sin x = sin(π − x )


cos x = cos( − x ) cos x = − cos(π − x )

35
d d
sin x = cos x cos x = − sin x
dx dx

∫ sin xdx = − cos x ∫ cos xdx = sin x

sin( x ± y ) = sin x cos y ± cos x sin y


cos( x ± y ) = cos x cos y ∓ sin x sin y

sin 2 x = 2sin x cos x


cos 2 x = cos2 x − sin 2 x

Some values corresponding the special angles are usually used:

π π
sin = sin15O = 0.2588 cos = cos15O = 0.9659
12 12
π π
sin = sin 22.5O = 0.3827 cos = cos 22.5O = 0.9239
8 8
π π 3
sin = sin 30O = 0.5 cos = cos30O = = 0.866
6 6 2
π 2 π 2
sin = sin 45O = = 0.7071 cos = cos 45O = = 0.7071
4 2 4 2
π π
tan = tan15O = 0.2679 tan = tan 22.5O = 0.4142
12 8
π 3 π
tan = tan 30O = = 0.5774 tan = tan 45O = 1
6 3 4
1 π
tan x = tan x = co− tan( − x)
co− tan x 2

36
1.5.5. Example of FFT Applications

In order to help readers understand FFT and its applications, some

examples are listed below.

1.5.5.1. An odd-square waveform

The waveform is shown in Figure 21.

Figure 21. An Odd-square waveform

The function f(t) is

⎧1 2nπ ≤ ωt < (2n + 1)π


f (t ) = ⎨ (25)
⎩ −1 (2n + 1)π ≤ ωt < 2(n + 1)π

The Fourier coefficients are

37
2π nπ
1 2 1 − ( −1)n
bn =
π ∫
0
f (t )sin( nωt )d (ωt ) =
nπ ∫0 sin θ dθ = 2 nπ
4
or bn = n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (26)

Finally, we have obtain

4 ∞
sin(nωt )
F (t ) =
π
∑ n =1 n n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (27)

The fundamental harmonic has the amplitude 4/π. If we consider the

higher order harmonics until 7 th -order, i.e. n = 3, 5, 7. The HFs are

HF 3 = 1/3; HF 5 = 1/5; HF 7 = 1/7

The THD is

∑V
n =2
n
2

1 1 1
THD = = ( )2 + ( )2 + ( )2 = 0.41415 (28)
V1 3 5 7

The WTHD is

38

Vn2
∑ n 1 1 1
WTHD = n =2 = ( )3 + ( )3 + ( )3 = 0.219 (29)
V1 3 5 7

1.5.5.2. An even-square waveform

The waveform is shown in Figure 22.

Figure 22. An Even-square waveform

The function f(t) is

⎧1 (2n − 0.5)π ≤ ωt < (2n + 0.5)π


f (t ) = ⎨ (30)
⎩ −1 (2n + 0.5)π ≤ ωt < (2n + 1.5)π

The Fourier coefficients are

a0 = 0

39
nπ nπ
1

4 2 4sin
2
an =
π ∫
0
f (t ) cos(nωt )d (ωt ) =
nπ ∫ cosθ dθ =
0

4 nπ
or an = sin n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (31)
nπ 2


The item sin is used to define the sign. Finally, we have obtain
2

4 ∞

F (t ) =
π
∑ sin
n =1 2
cos( nωt ) n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (32)

The fundamental harmonic has the amplitude 4/π. If we consider the

higher order harmonics until 7 th -order, i.e. n = 3, 5, 7. The HFs are

HF 3 = 1/3; HF 5 = 1/5; HF 7 = 1/7

The THD is

∑V
n =2
n
2

1 1 1
THD = = ( ) 2 + ( ) 2 + ( ) 2 = 0.41415 (33)
V1 3 5 7

The WTHD is

40

Vn2

n =2 n 1 1 1
WTHD = = ( )3 + ( )3 + ( )3 = 0.219 (34)
V1 3 5 7

1.5.5.3. An odd-waveform pulse

The waveform is shown in Figure 23.

Figure 23. An Odd-waveform pulse

The function f(t) is in the period –π - +π:

⎧ π −x π+x
⎪⎪ 1 ≤ ωt <
2 2
f (t ) = ⎨
⎪ −1 π+x π −x (35)
− ≤ ωt < −
⎪⎩ 2 2

The Fourier coefficients are

41
π +x π −x π+x
1

2
n
2 cos( n ) − cos( n )
2 2
bn =
π ∫
0
f (t ) sin( nωt )d (ωt ) =
nπ ∫
π −x
sin θ dθ = 2

n
2

π −x nπ nx
2 cos( n ) 4sin( )sin( )
=2 2 = 2 2
nπ nπ
4 nπ nx
or bn = sin sin n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (36)
nπ 2 2

Finally, we have obtain

4 sin(nωt )

nπ nx
F (t ) = ∑ n
π n =1
sin
2
sin
2 n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (37)

4 x
The fundamental harmonic has the amplitude sin . If we consider
π 2
the higher order harmonics until 7 th -order, i.e. n = 3, 5, 7. The HFs are

3x 5x 7x
sin sin sin
HF3 = 2 HF5 = 2 HF7 = 2
x; x; x
3sin 5sin 7sin
2 2 2

The values of the HFs should be absolute values.

If x = π, The HFs are

42
3x 5x 7x
sin sin sin
HF3 = 2 =1 HF5 = 2 =1 HF7 = 2 =1
x 3; x 5; x 7
3sin 5sin 7 sin
2 2 2

the THD is

∑V
n =2
n
2

1 1 1
THD = = ( )2 + ( )2 + ( ) 2 = 0.41415 (38)
V1 3 5 7

The WTHD is

Vn2
∑ n 1 1 1
WTHD = n =2 = ( )3 + ( )3 + ( )3 = 0.219 (39)
V1 3 5 7

1.5.5.4. A 5-level odd-waveform

The waveform is shown in Figure 24.

Figure 24. A 5-level Odd-waveform

43
The function f(t) is in the period –π - +π:

⎧ π 2π
⎪2 ≤ ωt <
3 3

⎪1 π π 2π 5π
≤ ωt < , ≤ ωt <
⎪ 6 3 3 6

f (t ) = ⎨ 0 other
⎪ 5π 2π π π (40)
⎪−1 − ≤ ωt < − , − ≤ ωt < −
⎪ 6 3 3 6
⎪ 2π π
⎪ −2 − ≤ ωt < −
⎩ 3 3

The Fourier coefficients are

5 nπ 2 nπ
2π 6 3
1 2
bn =
π ∫0
f (t )sin( nωt )d (ωt ) =
nπ n∫π
[ sin θ dθ + ∫π sin θ dθ ] =
n
6 3

2 nπ 5nπ nπ 2nπ 4 nπ nπ
= [(cos − cos ) + (cos − cos )] = (cos + cos )
nπ 6 6 3 3 nπ 6 3
4 nπ nπ
or bn = (cos + cos ) n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (41)
nπ 6 3

Finally, we have obtain

4 ∞
sin(nωt ) nπ nπ
F (t ) = ∑ n
π n =1
(cos
6
+ cos
3
) n = 1, 3, 5, … ∞ (42)

44
2
The fundamental harmonic has the amplitude (1 + 3) . If we consider
π
the higher order harmonics until 7 th -order, i.e. n = 3, 5, 7. The HFs are

2 3 −1 3 −1
HF3 = = 0.244 ; HF5 = = 0.0536 ; HF7 = = 0.0383
3(1 + 3) 5(1 + 3) 7(1 + 3)

The values of the HFs should be absolute values. Therefore, THD is

∑V n
2

THD = n =2

V1
= ∑ HF
n =2
n
2
= 0.2442 + 0.05362 + 0.03832 = 0.2527 (43)

The WTHD is


Vn2

n =2 n

HFn2 0.2442 0.05362 0.03832
WTHD =
V1
= ∑
n =2 n
=
3
+
5
+
7
= 0.1436 (44)

II. Multilevel DC/AC Inverters

DC/AC inverters can be constructed as PWM inverters, z-source inverters

and multilevel inverters. PWM inverters accumulate the output voltage in

vertical pulses. A typical inverter is shown in Figure 25. Multilevel

inverters are newly developed. They accumulate the output voltage in

horizontal pulses.

45
Figure 25. Block diagram of a PWM DC/AC inverter

2.1. Introduction to Multilevel Inverters

Multilevel inverters contain several power switches and capacitors.

Output voltages of multilevel inverters are the additions of the voltages

due to the commutation of the switches. Figure 25 shows a schematic

diagram of one phase leg of inverters with different level-numbers. A

two-level inverter, as shown in Figure 26 (a), generates an output voltage

with two levels with respect to the negative terminal of the capacitor,

while the three-level inverter of Figure 26 (b) generates three voltages,

and so on. Thus, the output voltages of multilevel inverters have several

levels. Moreover, they can reach high voltage, while the power

semiconductors must withstand only reduced voltages.

46
Figure 26. One phase leg of an inverter: (a) Two levels, (b) Three levels, and

(c) n levels

Multilevel inverters have been receiving increasing attention in recent

years, since multilevel inverters have many attractive features. Firstly,

the output voltage distortion is very low due to multiple levels of the

output voltages. Secondly, the dv/dt of switches is low since the switches

endure reduced voltage. Thirdly, the switches can operate at a lower

switching frequency. Finally, in the applications of motor drives, the

draw input currents have low distortions and the common-mode voltages

are reduced. Additionally, the common-mode voltages can be eliminated

using sophisticated modulation methods.

Various kinds of multilevel inverters have been proposed, tested and

installed. They are diode-clamped (neutral-clamped) multilevel inverters;

capacitors-clamped (flying capacitors) multilevel inverters, cascaded

multilevel inverters with separate dc sources, hybrid multilevel inverters,

generalized multilevel inverters, mixed-level multilevel inverters,

multilevel inverters by the connection of three-phase two-level inverters,

47
and soft-switched multilevel inverters. The family tree of multilevel level

inverters is shown in Figure 27.

Figure 27. Family tree of multilevel inverters

The family of multilevel inverters has emerged as the solution for high

power application, since it is hard to be implemented via single power

semiconductor switch directly in medium-voltage network. Multilevel

inverters have been applied to different high power applications, such as

large motor drives, railway traction applications, high voltage dc

transmissions (HVDC), unified power flow controllers (UPFC), static var

compensators (SVC) and static synchronous compensators (STATCOM).

The output voltage of the multilevel inverter has many levels synthesized

from several dc voltage sources. The quality of the output voltage is

improved as the number of voltage levels increases, so the effort of

output filters can be decreased. The transformers can be eliminated due

48
to reduced voltage that the switch endures. Moreover, as cost effective

solutions, the applications of multilevel inverters are also extended to

medium and low power applications, such as electrical vehicle propulsion

systems, active power filters (APF), voltage sag compensations,

photovoltaic systems and distributed power systems.

Multilevel inverter circuits have been around for about 30 years. The

cascaded multilevel inverter was first proposed in 1975 by Baker.

Separate DC-sourced full-bridge cells in series to synthesize a staircase

ac output voltage. The diode-clamped inverter, also called the neutral-

point clamped (NPC) inverter, was presented in 1980 by Baker. Because

the NPC inverter effectively doubles the device voltage level without

requiring precise voltage matching, the circuit topology prevailed in

1980s. The capacitor-clamped multilevel inverter came in the 1990s.

Although the cascaded multilevel inverter was invented earlier, its

application did not prevail until the mid 1990s. The advantages of

cascaded multilevel inverters were indicated for motor drives and utility

applications. The cascaded inverter has drawn great interest due to the

great demand of medium-voltage high-power inverters.

The cascaded inverter is also used in regenerative-type motor drive

application. Recently, some new topologies of multilevel inverters

emerges, such as generalized multilevel inverters, mixed multilevel

49
inverters, hybrid multilevel inverters and soft-switched multilevel

inverters. Today, multilevel inverters are extensively used in high-power

applications with medium voltage levels, such as laminators, mills,

conveyors, pumps, fans, blowers, compressors, and so on. Moreover, as a

cost-effective solution, the applications of multilevel inverters are also

extended to low power application, such as photovoltaic systems, hybrid

electrical vehicles and voltage sag compensation, in which the effort of

output filter components can be decreased much due to low harmonics

distortions of output voltages of the multilevel inverters.

2.2. Multilevel Inverter Using Diode/Capacitor Clamped


Topologies

In this category, the switching devices are connected in series to make up

the desired voltage rating and output levels. The inner voltage points are

clamped by either two extra diodes or one high frequency capacitor. The

switching devices of an m-levels inverter are required to block a voltage

level of V dc /(m-1). The clamping diode or clamping capacitor needs to

have different voltage rating for different inner voltage levels.

2.2.1. Diode-Clamped Inverters

A three-level diode-clamped inverter is shown in Figure 28 (a). In this

circuit, the dc-bus voltage is split into three levels by two series-

connected bulk capacitors, C1 and C 2 . The middle point of the two

50
capacitors, n, can be defined as the neutral point. The output voltage v an

has three states: E, 0 and -E. For voltage level E, switches S 1 and S 2 need

to be turned on; for -E, switches S 1’ and S 2’ need to be turned on; and for

the 0 level, S 2 and S 1’ need to be turned on.

Figure 28. Diode-clamped multilevel inverter circuit topologies

(a) Three-level (b) Five-level

The key components that distinguish this circuit from a conventional

two-level inverter are D1 and D 1’ . These two diodes clamp the switch

voltage to half the level of the dc-bus voltage. When both S 1 and S 2 turn

on, the voltage across a and 0 is 2E, i.e., v a0 = 2E. In this case, D 1’

balances out the voltage sharing between S 1’ and S 2’ with S 1’ blocking the

voltage across C1 and S 2’ blocking the voltage across C 2 . Notice that

output voltage v an is ac, and v a0 is dc. The difference between v an and v a0

51
is voltage across C 2 , which is E. If the output is removed out between a

and 0, then the circuit becomes a dc/dc converter, which has three output

voltage levels: E, 0 and -E.

Figure 28 (b) shows a five-level diode-clamped converter in which the dc

bus consists of four capacitors, C 1 , C 2 , C 3 and C4 . For dc bus voltage 4E,

the voltage across each capacitor is E, and each device voltage stress will

be limited to one capacitor voltage level E through clamping diodes. The

corresponding example multilevel waveforms are shown in Figure 29

with the voltage unit is E.

(a) Three-level

(b) Five-level

Figure 29. Multilevel waveforms


52
To explain how the staircase voltage is synthesized, the neutral point n is

considered as the output phase voltage reference point. There are five

switch combination to synthesize five level voltage across a and n.

• For voltage level v an = 2E, turn on all upper switches S 1 ~ S 4 .

• For voltage level v an = E, turn on three upper switches S 2 ~ S 4 and one

lower switch S 1’ .

• For voltage level v an = 0, turn on two upper switches S 3 and S 4 and

two lower switches S1’ and S 2’ .

• For voltage level v an = -E, turn on one upper switch S 4 and three lower

switches S 1’ ~ S 3’ .

• For voltage level v an = -2E, turn on all lower switches S 1’ ~ S 4’ .

Four complementary switch pairs exist in each phase. The

complementary switch pair is defined such that turning on one of the

switches will exclude the other from being turn on. In this example, the

four complementary pairs are (S1 , S 1’ ), (S 2 , S 2’ ), (S 3 , S 3’ ), and (S 4 , S 4’ ).

Although each active switching device is only required to block a voltage

level of E, the clamping diodes must have different voltage ratings for

reverse voltage blocking. Using D 1’ of Figure 28 (b) as an example, when

lower devices S 2’ ~ S 4’ are turned on, D 1’ needs to block three capacitor

53
voltages, or 3E. Similarly, D2 and D 2’ need to block 2E, and D1 needs to

block 3E.

2.2.2. Capacitor-Clamped Inverter

Figure 30 illustrates the fundamental building block of a phase-leg

capacitor-clamped inverter. The circuit has been called the flying

capacitor inverter with dependent capacitors clamping the device voltage

to one capacitor voltage level. The inverter in Figure 30 (a) provides a

three-level output across a and n, i.e. v an = E, 0, or -E. For the voltage

level E, switches S 1 and S 2 need to be turned on; for -E, switches S 1’ and

S 2’ need to be turned on; and for the 0 level, either pair (S 1 , S 1’ ) or (S 2 ,

S 2’ ) needs to be turned on. Clamping capacitor C1 is charged when S 1 and

S 1’ are turned on, and is discharged when S 2 and S 2’ are turned on. The

charge of C 1 can be balanced by proper selection of the 0-level switch

combination.

The voltage synthesis in a five-level capacitor-clamped converter has

more flexibility than a diode-clamped converter. Using Figure 30 (b) as

the example, the voltage of the five-level phase-leg a output with respect

to the neutral point n, van , can be synthesized by the following switching

combinations.

54
Figure 30. Capacitor-clamped multilevel inverter circuit topologies

(a) Three-level (b) Five-level

• For voltage level v an = 2E, turn on all upper switches S 1 ~ S 4 .

• For voltage level v an = E, there are three combinations:

o S 1 , S 2 , S 3 , S 1’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - E (C1 );

o S 1 , S 3 , S 4 , S 3’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - 3E (C 3 ) + 2E (C 2 ).

o S 2 , S 3 , S 4 , S 4’ : v an = 3E (C 3 ) - 2E (lower C 4 ); and

o S 1 , S 2 , S 4 , S 2’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - 2E (C 2 ) + E (C1 ).

• For voltage level v an =0, there are six combinations:

o S 1 , S 2 , S 1’ , S 2’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - 2E (C 2 );

o S 3 , S 4 , S 3’ , S 4’ : v an = 2E (C 2 ) - 2E (lower C 4 );

o S 1 , S 3 , S 1’ , S 3’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - 3E (C 3 ) + 2E (C 2 ) - E (C1 );

o S 1 , S 4 , S 2’ , S 3’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - 3E (C 3 ) + E (C1 );

o S 2 , S 4 , S 2’ , S 4’ : v an = 3E (C3 ) - 2E (C2 ) + E (C 1 ) - 2E (lower C4 );

and

55
o S 2 , S 3 , S 1’ , S 4’ : v an = 3E (C 3 ) - E (C1 ) - 2E (lower C 4 ).

• For voltage level V an = -E, there are three combinations:

o S 1 , S 1’ , S 2’ , S 3’ : v an = 2E (upper C 4 ) - 3E (C 3 );

o S 2 , S 1’ , S 2’ , S 4’ : v an = -2E (lower C 4 ) + 3E (C 3 ) - 2E (C 2 );

o S 4 , S 2’ , S 3’ , S 4’ : v an = E (C1 ) - 2E (lower C 4 ); and

o S 3 , S 1’ , S 3’ , S 4’ : v an = 2E (C 2 ) - E (C1 ) - 2E (lower C 4 ).

• For voltage level v an = -2E, turn on all lower switches, S 1’ ~ S 4’ .

In the preceding description, the capacitors with positive signs are in

discharging mode, while those with negative sign are in charging mode.

By proper selection of capacitor combinations, it is possible to balance

the capacitor charge.

The output waveforms of the three-level and five-level capacitor-clamped

multilevel inverters can be also shown in Figure 29.

2.3. Multilevel Inverters using H-Bridges (HBs) Connected

The basic structure is based on the connection of H-bridges (HBs).

Figure 30 shows the power circuit for one phase leg of a multilevel

inverter with three HBs (HB 1 , HB 2 and HB 3 ) in each phase. Each HB is

supplied by a separate dc source. The resulting phase voltage is

synthesized by the addition of the voltages generated by the different

HBs. If the dc link voltages of HBs are identical, the multilevel inverter

is called the cascaded multilevel inverter. However, it is possible to have

56
different values among the dc link voltages of HBs, and the circuit can be

called as the hybrid multilevel inverter.

Figure 31. Multilevel inverter based on the connection of HBs

2.3.1. Cascaded multilevel inverter (CMI)

In cascaded multilevel inverter, the dc link voltages of HBs are identical,

etc. in Figure 31,

Vdc1 = Vdc 2 = Vdc 3 = E (45)

where E is unit voltage. Each HB generates three voltages at the output:

+E, 0, and -E. This is made possible by connecting the capacitors

sequentially to the ac side via the three power switches. The resulting

57
output ac voltage swings from -3E to 3E with seven levels as shown in

Figure 32.

Figure 32. Waveforms of cascaded multilevel inverter

2.3.2. Binary Hybrid Multilevel Inverter (BHMI)

In binary hybrid multilevel inverter (BHMI), the dc link voltages of HB i

(the ith HB), V dci , is 2 i-1 E. In a 3-HB one phase leg,

Vdc1 = E Vdc 2 = 2 E Vdc 3 = 4 E (46)

As shown in Figure 33, the output waveform, v an , has 15 levels. One of

the advantages is the HB with higher dc link voltage has lower number of

commutation and thereby reducing the associated switching losses. The

BHMI illustrates a seven-level (in half-cycle) inverter using this hybrid

topology. The HB with higher dc link voltage consists of lower switching

frequency component, e.g. IGBT. The higher switching frequency

components, e.g. IGBT, are used to construct the HB with lower dc link

voltage.
58
Figure 33. Waveforms of binary hybrid multilevel inverter

2.3.3. Quasi-Linear Multilevel Inverter (QLMI)

Figure 34. Waveforms of quasi-linear multilevel inverter

In quasi-linear multilevel inverter, the dc link voltages of HBi , V dci can

be expressed as

59
⎧ E i =1
Vdci = ⎨ i−2 (47)
⎩2 × 3 E i≥2
In a 3-HB one-phase leg,

Vdc1 = E Vdc 2 = 2 E Vdc 3 = 6 E (48)

As shown in Figure 34, the output waveform, v an , has 19 levels.

2.3.4. Trinary Hybrid Multilevel Inverter (THMI)

In trinary hybrid multilevel inverter, the dc link voltages of HB i , V dci , is

3 i-1 E. In a three-HB one phase leg,

Vdc1 = E , Vdc 2 = 3E , Vdc 3 = 9 E (49)

Figure 35. Waveforms of trinary hybrid multilevel inverter

60
As shown in Figure 35, the output waveform, v an , has 27 levels. To the

best of author’s knowledge, this circuit has the greatest level number for

a given number of HBs among existing multilevel inverters.

2.4. Other Kinds of Multilevel Inverters

The are several other kinds of multilevel inverters introduced in this sub-

section.

2.4.1. Generalized Multilevel Inverters (GMI)

A generalized multilevel inverter topology has previously been presented.

The existing multilevel inverters, such as diode-clamped and capacitor-

clamped multilevel inverters, can be derived from this generalized

multilevel inverter topology. Moreover, the generalized multilevel

inverter topology can balance each voltage level by itself regardless of

load characteristics. Therefore, the generalized multilevel inverter

topology provides a true multilevel structure that can balance each dc

voltage level automatically at any number of levels, regardless of active

or reactive power conversion, and without any assistance from other

circuits. Thus, in principle, it provides a complete multilevel topology

that embraces the existing multilevel inverters.

61
Figure 36. Generalized multilevel inverter structure

Figure 36 shows the generalized multilevel inverter structure per phase

leg. Each switching device, diode, or capacitor’s voltage is E, i.e., 1/(m-1)

of the dc-link voltage. Any inverter with any number of levels, including

the conventional two-level inverter can be obtained using this

generalized topology.

As an application example, a four-level bidirectional DC/DC converter,

shown in Figure 37, is suitable for the dual-voltage system to be adopted

in future automobiles. The four-level dc/dc converter has a unique

feature, which is that no magnetic components are needed. From this

62
generalized multilevel inverter topology, several new multilevel inverter

structures can be derived.

Figure 37. Application example: a four-level inverter for the dual-voltage

system in automobiles

2.4.2. Mixed-Level Multilevel Inverter Topologies

For high-voltage high-power applications, it is possible to adopt

multilevel diode-clamped or capacitor-clamped inverters to replace the

full-bridge cell in a cascaded multilevel inverter. The reason for doing so

is to reduce the amount of separate dc sources. The nine-level cascaded

inverter requires four separate DC sources for one phase leg and twelve

for a three-phase inverter. If a three-level inverter replaces the full-bridge

cell, the voltage level is effectively doubled for each cell. Thus, to

achieve the same nine voltage levels for each phase, only two separate

DC sources are needed for one phase leg and six for a three-phase

63
inverter. The configuration can be considered as having mixed-level

multilevel cells because it embeds multilevel cells as the building block

of the cascaded multilevel inverter.

2.4.3. Multilevel Inverters by Connection of Three-Phase Two-Level

Inverters

Figure 38. Cascaded inverter with three-phase cells

Standard three-phase two-level inverters are connected by transformers

as shown in Figure 38. In order for the inverter output voltages to be

added up, the inverter outputs of the three modules need to be

synchronized with a separation of 120 O between each phase. For example,

obtaining a three-level voltage between outputs a and b, the voltage is

synthesized by Vab = V a1-b1 + V a1-b1 + V a1-b1 . The phase between b 1 and a 2

is provided by a 3 and b 3 through an isolated transformer. With three

64
inverters synchronized, the voltages V a1-b1 , V a1-b1 , V a1-b1 are all in phase;

thus, the output level is simply tripled.

2.4.4. Soft-Switched Multilevel Inverters

There are numerous ways of implementing soft-switching methods, such

as zero voltage switching (ZVS) and zero current switching (ZCS), to

reduce the switching losses and to increase efficiency for different

multilevel inverters. For the cascaded multilevel inverter, because each

inverter cell is a two-level circuit, the implementation of soft switching is

not at all different from that of conventional two-level inverters. For

capacitor- or diode-clamped inverters, however, the choices of soft-

switching circuit can be found with different circuit combinations.

Although zero-current switching is possible, most literatures proposed

zero-voltage-switching types including auxiliary resonant commutated

pole (ARCP), coupled inductor with zero-voltage transition (ZVT), and

their combinations.

2.5. Multilevel Inverters in High Power Applications

In medium-voltage network, it is hard to connect a single power

semiconductor switch directly to medium-voltage grids (2.3, 3.3, 4.16, or

6.9 kV). Multilevel inverters are presented as the solutions for working

with higher voltage levels.

65
2.5.1. Large Motor Drives with Non-Regenerative Front Ends

Diode-clamped three-level multilevel inverters are now widely applied in

medium-voltage (2.3, 3.3, 4.16, and even 6 kV) application, using an

IGBT with forced-air cooling. There applications cover a wide range of

high-power loads including fans, pumps, blowers, compressors, and

conveyors. A three-level capacitor-clamped multilevel inverter is also

used as a motor drive. A seven -level cascaded multilevel inverter is used

in non-regenerative drives in 2.3 kV network. The input part of each HB

has a three-phase diode rectifier, which does not allow the regeneration

of power. It presents a transformerless multilevel inverter as an

application for high-power electric vehicle (HEV) motor drives.

Multilevel inverters have almost no electromagnetic interference or

common-mode voltage; and make an HEV more accessible/safer and

open wiring possible for most of an HEV’s power system. A hybrid

seven-level inverter is applied in 4.16 kV system, in which the top HB

uses IGBT and the low one uses GTO.

2.5.2. Large Motor Drives with Regenerative Front Ends

The use of a three-level active front end (AFE) at the input side of a

three-level diode-clamped inverter has become a very popular solution

for high-power regenerative loads. Especially, two three-level AFEs are

used in a so-called tandem configuration. It presents a multilevel

converter with regeneration capacity. Each cell in the converter contains


66
a single-phase inverter at the output side and a PWM rectifier at the input

side. The output side inverters of the cells are connected in series, while

the input side rectifiers are connected in parallel through the input

transformer. A single-phase AFE, instead of a three-phase one, has been

considered at the input side of each cell for the following reasons: less

power semiconductors and simpler control.

2.5.3. Applications in Power Systems

The first unified power flow controller (UPFC) in the world was based on

a diode-clamped three-level inverter. The UPFC is comprised of the

back-to-back connection of two identical GTO thyristor-based three-level

converters, each rated at 160 MVA. It was commissioned in mid 1998 at

the Inez Station of American Electric Power (AEP) in Kentucky for

voltage support and power-flow control. On the other hand, the cascaded

multilevel inverter is best suited for harmonic/reactive compensation and

other utility applications, since each HB inverter unit can balance its dc

voltage without requiring additional isolated power sources. GEC

Alsthom T&D has commercialized the cascaded multilevel inverter for

reactive power compensation/generation (STATCOM).

2.6. Multilevel Inverters in Medium and Low Power Application

67
The ac output terminal voltage that multilevel inverters synthesize have

low harmonic distortion, thus the filter requirement is reduced. Moreover,

with the topologies of multilevel inverters, the transformers can be

eliminated. In recent years, the volume and price of active components

(semiconductor switches) decreased much, while the passive components,

such as inductors, capacitors or transformers are kept the almost same.

Therefore, in the medium and low application, the systems with the

configuration of multilevel inverters can be compacter and cheaper.

2.6.1. Photovoltaic Systems

Various topologies of multilevel inverters are investigated for the

application of photovoltaic system. Amongst the topologies for

transformerless systems, the diode clamped multilevel inverters and the

cascaded multilevel inverters have been identified as the most promising

topologies. The design and control issues associated with the

development of a 1.8 kW prototype single-phase grid-connected

photovoltaic system incorporating a cascaded multilevel inverter are

discussed.

2.6.2. Voltage Sag Compensation

A cascaded multilevel inverter was studied as a cost-effective way of

series sag compensation, because it eliminates the bulky injection

68
transformers and other large filter components used in series active

filters. Batteries and high-current automotive MOSFETs proved to be

interesting options in terms of energy storage and switching components

for this design.

2.6.3. Distributed Energy Application

Distributed energy system, mostly those using alternative energies such

as fuel cells or photovoltaic panels, can be easily configured with a

separate source connected through the power conversion circuits used as

an energy module or building block to provide individual output. A

cascaded multilevel inverter can then be configured with multiple

modules. Such a system does not need a transformer to provide isolation,

and the system can be constructed in a cost effective manner.

2.7. Investigation of THMI

2.7.1. Topology and Operation

A single-phase THMI with h HBs connected in series is shown in Figure

39. The key feature of the THMI is that the ratio of dc link voltage is

1:3:…:3 h-1 , where h is the number of HBs. The maximum number of

synthesized voltage levels is 3 h .

69
Figure 39. Configuration of THMI

As shown in Figure 39, v Hi represents the output voltage of the i th HB.

V dci represents the dc link voltage of the ith HB. A switching function, F i ,

is used to relate V Hi and V dci as shown in

vHi = Fi ⋅ Vdci (50)

The value of F i can be either 1 or -1 or 0. For the value 1, switches S i1

and S i4 need to be turned on. For the value -1, switches S i2 and S i3 need

to be turned on. For the value 0, switches S i1 and S i3 need to be turned on

or S i2 and S i4 need to be turned on. Table 1 shows the relationship

between the switching function, the output voltage of a HB and states of

switches.

70
Table 1. Relationship between the switching function, output voltage of

a HB and states of switches


Fi v Hi Si1 Si2 Si3 Si4
1 V dci conduct block block conduct
-1 - V dci block conduct conduct block
0 0 conduct conduct block block
0 0 block block conduct conduct

The output voltage of the THMI, v an , is the summation of the output


h

voltages of HBs. van = ∑v


i =1
Hi (51)

From (50) and (51), we can get


h
van = ∑ Fi ⋅Vdci (52)
i =1

In a single-phase h-HB THMI, the ratio of dc link voltage is 1:3:…:3 h-1 .

Suppose E is unit voltage, the dc link voltage can be expressed as:

Vdci = 3i −1 E (53)

From (52) and (53), we can get


h
van = ∑ Fi ⋅ 3i −1 E (54)
i =1

Suppose l is ordinal of expected voltage level that the inverter outputs. If

l is not negative, the inverter output the positive lth voltage level. If l is

negative, the inverter outputs the negative (-l)th voltage level. In a single

phase THMI with h HBs, given the value of l, the value of F i can be

determined by

71
ABS(l ) 3h −1 − 1
Fh = Bb (ABS(l ) − )
l 2
ABS(l ) 3h − 2 − 1
Fh −1 = Bb (ABS(l ) − ABS(Fh ) ⋅ 3h −1 − )
l 2

ABS(l ) h
3i −1 − 1
Fi = Bb (ABS(l ) − ∑ (ABS(Fk ) ⋅ 3 ) −
k −1
) (55)
l k = i +1 2

h
ABS(l )
F2 = Bb (ABS(l ) − ∑ (ABS(Fk ) ⋅ 3k −1 ) − 1)
l k =3
h
ABS(l )
F1 = Bb (ABS(l ) − ∑ (ABS(Fk ) ⋅ 3k −1 ))
l k =2

where ABS is the function of absolute value and the bi-polar binary

function, Bb , is defined as
⎧1 τ >0

Bb (τ ) = ⎨ 0 τ =0 (56)
⎪ −1 τ <0

From (54), we can get the relationship between the output voltage of the

inverter, v an , and the values of switching functions in the THMI with

different number of HBs.

Table 2. Relationship between the output voltage of the inverter and the

values of switching functions in a single-phase two-HB THMI


v an -4E -3E -2E -E 0
F1 -1 0 1 -1 0
F2 -1 -1 -1 0 0
v an 4E 3E 2E E
F1 1 0 -1 1
F2 1 1 1 0

72
In the case of a two-HB THMI, Table 2 shows the relationship between

the output voltage of the inverter and the values of switching functions.

The waveforms of a single-phase two-HB THMI is shown in Figure 40.

4E

3E

Figure 40. Waveforms of a single-phase two-HB THMI

Table 3. Relationship between the output voltage of the inverter and the

values of switching functions in a single-phase three-HB THMI


v an 13E 12E 11E 10E 9E 8E 7E
F1 1 0 -1 1 0 -1 1
F2 1 1 1 0 0 0 -1
F3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
v an 6E 5E 4E 3E 2E E 0
F1 0 -1 1 0 -1 1 0
F2 -1 -1 1 1 1 0 0
F3 1 1 0 0 0 0 0

The output voltage of a single-phase three-HB has 27 levels. v H1 , v H2 and

v H3 can be negative when v an is positive. Table 3 shows relationship

73
between the output voltage of the inverter and the values of switching

functions in a single-phase three-HB THMI. From (54), we can get

van = −v 'an ⇔ Fi = F'i i = 1...h (57)

The cases about the negative value of v an can be deduced from Table 3.

2.7.2. Prove for the Greatest Number of Output Voltage Levels of the

THMI

Among existing multilevel levels THMI has the greatest levels of output

voltage using the same number of components. In the section, firstly, the

theoretical prove for this conclusion is specified, then the comparison

between various kinds of multilevel inverters is given.

2.7.2.1. Theoretical prove

This section proves that the THMI has greatest levels of output voltage

using the same number of HBs among the multilevel inverters using HBs

connected. A phase voltage waveform is obtained by summing the output

voltages of h HBs as shown in (50). If the dc link sources of all HB cells

are equal, the multilevel inverter is called the cascaded multilevel

inverter and the maximum number of levels of phase voltage is given by

m = 1 + 2h (58)

74
On the other hand, if at least one of the dc link sources is different from

the other ones, the multilevel inverter is called the hybrid multilevel

inverter. In section 2.3, the BHMI, the quasi-linear multilevel inverter

and the THMI are introduced. Thus, considering that the lowest dc link

source E is chosen as base value for the p.u. notation, the normalized

values of all dc link voltages must be natural numbers to obtain a

uniform step multilevel inverter, i.e.:

Vdci* ∈ E , i = 1, 2,…, h (59)

Moreover, to obtain a uniform step multilevel inverter, the dc link

voltage of the HB cells must also respect the following relation:


i −1
Vdci* ≤ 1 + 2∑Vdck * , i = 2,3, …, h (60)
k =1

where it is also considered that the dc link voltages are arranged in an

increasing way, that is:

Vdc1* ≤ Vdc 2* ≤ Vdc 3* ≤ ≤ Vdch* (61)

Therefore, the maximum number of levels of output phase voltage

waveform can be given:

m = 1 + 2σ max (62)

where σ max is the maximum number of positive/negative voltage levels

and can be expressed:


h
σ max = ∑ Vdci* (63)
i =1

75
From (61), (62) and (63) it is possible to verify that hybrid multilevel

inverters can generate a large number of levels with the same number of

cells. Moreover, in the THMI, the dc link voltages respect


i −1
Vdci* = 1 + 2∑ Vdck * , i = 2,3, …, h (64)
k =1

Therefore, the THMI has greatest levels of output voltages using the

same number of HBs among multilevel inverters with HBs connected.

2.7.2.2. Comparison between various kinds of multilevel inverters

Two kinds of comparisons are presented in this section. In the first

comparison, the components are considered to have same voltage rating,

E. This comparison is for high power and high voltage applications, in

which the devices connected in series, are used to satisfy the requirement

of high voltage ratings. Table 4 shows the comparison between

multilevel inverters: diode-clamped multilevel inverter (DCMI),

capacitor-clamped multilevel inverter (CCMI), cascaded multilevel

inverter (CMI), generalized multilevel inverter (GMI), BHMI and THMI.

The m is the number of steps of phase voltage. From Table 4, we can find

that CMI, BHMI and THMI use fewer components. The CMI, BHMI and

THMI use the same number of components. However, in practical

systems, the redundancy requirement must be satisfied. THMI uses fewer

components than BHMI and CMI in practical systems since THMI use

less redundant components. Moreover, the THMI uses fewer dc sources

than the CMI and the BHMI.

76
Table 4. The first comparison between multilevel inverters
Converter
DCMI CCMI GMI CMI BHMI THMI
type
Main
switching 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2
devices
Diodes m ( m -1) m -1 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2
Capacitors m -1 0.5 m ( m -1) m -1 ( m -1)/2 ( m -1)/2 ( m -1)/2
Total ( m -1) ( m -1) 2 m +1 +
4.5( m -1) 4.5( m -1) 4.5( m -1)
components ( m +1) (0.5 m +3) m -5

Table 5. The second comparison between multilevel inverters


Converter
DCMI CCMI CMI GMI BHMI THMI
type
Main
switching 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 4×log 2 [( m +1)/2] 4×log 3 m
devices
Diodes 4 m -6 2 m -2 2 m -2 2 m -2 4×log 2 [( m +1)/2] 4×log 3 m
0.5 m
Capacitors m -1 2 m -3 m -1 log 2 [( m +1)/2] log 3 m
-0.5
Total 4.5 m 2 m +1 +
7 m -9 6m -7 9×log 2 [( m +1)/2] 9×log 3 m
components -4.5 m -5

The second comparison is for medium and low power application, in

which the voltage rating of main switching components, diodes and

capacitors can be researched easily. Therefore, the numbers of main

switching components, diodes and capacitors are minimal required values.

Table 5 shows the comparison results among DCMI, CCMI, CMI, GMI,

77
BHMI and THMI. From Table 5, we can find that the THMI uses the

fewest components among these multilevel inverters.

2.7.3. Modulation Strategies for THMI

Five modulation strategies for the THMI are investigated. They are the

step modulation strategy, the virtual stage modulation strategy, the

hybrid modulation strategy, the sub-harmonics pulse width modulation

(PWM) strategy and the simple modulation strategy. Since multilevel

inverters are used in three-phase systems typically generally, only

modulation strategies for the three-phase systems will be investigated

here. In the three-phase systems, triple-order harmonic components of

voltages need not be eliminated by the modulation strategies since they

can be eliminated by proper connection of three-phase voltage sources

and loads. In other words, only 5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, 17th, 19th …

harmonic components should be eliminated by the modulation strategies.

In addition, the amplitude of the fundamental component should be

controlled. The list can be expressed by

⎧ 3i -2 ∀i = odd
ηi = ⎨ i>0 (65)
⎩3i -1 ∀i = even

The step modulation strategy, the virtual stage modulation strategy and

the simple modulation strategy belong to low-frequency modulation

strategies. The high-frequency modulation strategies used in the hybrid

78
multilevel inverters include the hybrid modulation strategy and the sub-

harmonic PWM strategy.

2.7.3.1. Step modulation strategy

Figure 41. Step modulation strategy of THMI

Figure 41 shows a general quarter-wave symmetric stepped voltage

waveform synthesized by a THMI where E indicates unit voltage of dc

source. Consider that ς is the number of switching angles in quarter wave

of v an and σ is the number of positive/negative levels of v an . In step

modulation strategy,

ς =σ

By applying Fourier series analysis, the amplitude of any odd jth

harmonic of v an can be expressed as


ς
4
van j =

∑ [ E cos( jθ )]
i =1
i (66)

79
where j is an odd harmonic order and θ i is the ith switching angle. The

amplitudes of all even harmonics are zero. According to the values, θ 1 to

θ ς must satisfy

0 < θ1 < θ 2 < ... < θς < π / 2 (67)

The switching angles controlled by step modulation technique are derived

from (66). Up to (ς-1) harmonic contents can be removed from the

voltage waveform and the amplitude of fundamental component can be

controlled.

⎧ς
⎪∑ cos(η1θi ) = σ ⋅ MR
⎪ i =1
⎪ ς
⎪ ∑ cos(η2θi ) = 0
⎨ i =1 (68)


⎪ ς
⎪ ∑ cos(ης θi ) = 0
⎩ i =1

where MR is the relative modulation index and is expressed as

π van 1
MR = (69)
4σ E

where |v an | 1 is the amplitude of fundamental component of the output

voltage of the inverter.

The equation sets (68) from which the switching angles can be derived

are nonlinear and transcendental. For example, in a two-HB THMI, with

the step modulation technique, the equations set are expressed as (70)

when the relative modulation index is 0.83. The correct solution must

satisfy the inequational condition as shown in (67).

80
cos(θ1 ) + cos(θ 2 ) + cos(θ3 ) + cos(θ 4 ) = 0.83 × 4
cos(5θ1 ) + cos(5θ 2 ) + cos(5θ3 ) + cos(5θ 4 ) = 0
cos(7θ1 ) + cos(7θ 2 ) + cos(7θ3 ) + cos(7θ 4 ) = 0 (70)
cos(11θ1 ) + cos(11θ 2 ) + cos(11θ 3 ) + cos(11θ 4 ) = 0

The constrained optimization approach can be used to solve the nonlinear

and transcendental equations sets. Each equation is regarded as an

equational constraint. However, the computational problems of

constrained optimization do not converge easily. Since in the actual

electric system there are always mismatches and parameter tolerances,

lower order harmonics will be small but not exactly zero. This gives a

rise to an idea of transforming the constraint optimization model to a

non-constraint one. The non-constraint optimization is expected to have

better convergence property.

The target function of the new scheme of optimization without equational

constraints can be written as:


ς ς ς
FT = p1[∑ cos(η1θi ) − σ ⋅ M ]2 + p2 [∑ cos(η 2θi )]2 + + pς [∑ cos(ης θi )]2 (71)
i =1 i =1 i =1

The p 1 ~p ς are penalty factors. The penalty factors were selected as

4
pi = (72)
2i − 1

81
Thus, the penalty factors put more weight on elimination of lower order

harmonics.

Figure 42. Synthesized phase leg voltage waveform and frequency

spectrum of a two-HB THMI with step modulation technique

The two-HB THMI can synthesize nine-level output voltage. Figure 42

and Figure 43 show the typical synthesized waveform of the phase leg

voltage, line-to-line voltage waveform and their frequency spectrums, as

MR is equal to 0.83. The switching angles are 0.1478, 0.3232, 0.5738 and

0.9970. According to (38), the fifth, seventh and eleventh harmonics of

phase leg voltage can be eliminated in the two-HB THMI as shown in

Figure 42. The THD of phase leg voltage is 9.66%. The triple-order

82
harmonic components do not exist in the line-to-line voltage as shown in

Figure 43. The THD of line-to-line voltage is 5.91%.

Figure 43. Synthesized line-to-line voltage waveform and frequency

spectrum of a two-HB THMI with step modulation technique

According to (68), all switching angles must satisfy the constraint (67). If

switching angles do not satisfy the constraint, this scheme no longer

exists. The theoretical maximum amplitude of fundamental component is

4ςE/ π , which occurs as θ 1 ~ θ h equal to zero. Because of the internal

restriction of switching angles, the relative modulation index has upper

and lower limitation. The limitation of the relative modulation index can

be explained using Figures 44 and 45.


83
Figure 44. Limitation to the minimum MR in the step modulation

Figure 45. Limitation to the maximum MR in the step modulation

As shown in Figure 44, as the relative modulation index is less than a

certain value, denoted by MR (min), θ ς approaches to π /2 and the

limitation of minimum modulation index occurs. Similarly, when the

relative modulation index is greater than MR (max), θ 1 approaches to

zero and the limitation of maximum modulation index occurs as shown in

Figure 45.
84
For a THMI with h HBs, the maximum number of levels of the phase leg

voltage is m, which equals to 3 h . The maximum number of the

positive/negative phase leg voltage levels is σ max , which equals to (m-1)/2.

As mentioned above, the relative modulation index MR has limitations.

To extend to the smaller ranges of modulation index, the inverter will

output fewer voltage levels. Consequently, the number of

positive/negative voltage levels that the inverter outputs, σ, is smaller

than the maximum number of the positive/negative levels, σ max . In the

step modulation strategy, the number of switching angles in the quarter

wave of v an , ς, equals to σ. The definition of relative modulation index,

MR, is based on σ as shown in (69). This definition is easily included in

(68) to express the nonlinear transcendental equation sets that are used to

calculate the switching angles. In practice, the modulation index, M, is

used. M is based on the σ max and can be expressed as:


π van 1
M= (73)
4σ max E

The relationship between MR and M can be expressed as

M σ
= (74)
MR σ max

In the two-HB THMI, according to (69), the maximum MR is calculated

as 0.86 and the minimum MR is 0.55 as the levels of output voltage are

nine. The range of M is also from 0.55 to 0.86 with the nine-level output

voltage. To extend to lower modulation index, fewer output voltage

levels are synthesized. The range of MR is 0.46~0.83 when the output

85
voltage levels are seven. According to (74), the range of M is 0.34~0.62

when output voltage levels are seven. Thus, the modulation range is

extended to 0.34 by decreasing levels of output voltage.

Table 6. Range of modulation index under different output voltage

levels with the step modulation in a two-HB THMI


σ MR MR (max) M (min) M (max) Range of M
(min)
1 0 1 0 0.25 0-0.15
2 0.3 0.9 0.15 0.45 0.15-0.34
3 0.46 0.83 0.34 0.63 0.34-0.55
4 0.55 0.86 0.55 0.86 0.55-0.86
4* 0.3 0.94 0.3 0.94 0.86-0.94

Table 6 shows the relative modulation index and the modulation index

with different output voltage levels in the two-HB THMI. Firstly, the

minimum and maximum MR is calculated by the optimization method.

Secondly, the minimum and maximum M is calculated by (74). It is

preferable to use more output voltage levels. The last column of Table 6

shows the arrangement of M with different output voltage levels. In

addition, the maximum limitation of M can reach 0.94 without regard to

the elimination of the 11th harmonic as shown in last row of Table 6.

2.7.3.2. Virtual stage modulation strategy

In the step modulation strategy, the output voltage levels of the

multilevel inverter limit the amount of eliminated lower order harmonics.

86
Only three lower order harmonics can be eliminated by the step

modulation in a two-HB THMI. It is not very satisfied in the applications

that required a high-quality sinusoidal voltage output. The virtual stage

modulation strategy is a new modulation strategy that increases the

amount of eliminated lower order harmonics without increasing the

number of output voltage levels. The switching angles can be derived as:

β
⎧α
⎪ ∑ cos(η θ
1 pi ) − ∑ cos(η1θ ni ) = σ ⋅ MR
⎪ i =1 i =1

⎪ α β
⎪ ∑ cos(η2θ pi ) − ∑ cos(η2θ ni ) = 0
⎨ i =1 i =1 (75)


⎪ α β

⎪ ∑ cos(η θ
ς pi ) − ∑ cos(ης θ ni ) = 0
⎩ i =1 i =1

where σ is the number of positive/negative levels of v an and can be

expressed as

σ =α −β (76)

ς is the number of switching angles in quarter waveform of v an and can be


expressed as ς =α +β (77)

MR is shown in (69). The equation (75) is subject to

⎧ 0 < θ p1 < θ p 2 < ... < θ pα < π / 2



⎨ 0 < θ n1 < θ n 2 < ... < θ nβ < π / 2 (78)
⎪θ < θ j = 1, 2,..., β
⎩ nj p ( j +σ )

In the two-HB THMI, when the output voltage changes between E and 2E

or -E and -2E, the switching components of the higher voltage HB will

switch on/off as shown in Figure 46.

87
Figure 46. Scheme of switching angles with the step modulation as a function

of modulation index in a two-HB THMI

To keep high-voltage switching components switch at lower frequency in

the THMI, the limitation (79) is added into (75) to assure that higher

voltage switching components switch at the fundamental frequency.

θ p 2 < θ n1 (79)

Figure 47 illustrates the waveform using the virtual stage modulation for

the two-HB THMI whose output voltage levels are nine. The number of

virtual stages, β, is two.

88
Figure 47. Waveform using the virtual stage modulation Two-HB, nine-level,

α=6, β=2

Figures 47 and 48 show the typical synthesized waveform of phase leg

voltage, line-to-line voltage waveform and their frequency spectrum in

the virtual stage modulation strategy. The MR is 0.83 and the number of

virtual stages is two. θ p1 to θ p6 is 0.1321, 0.3320, 0.5307, 0.6226, 0.9133

and 1.0419. θ n1 is 0.5750 and θ n2 is 0.9652. Because of two additional

virtual stages, four more degrees of freedom of switching angles are

created such that 13th, 17th, 19th and 23rd harmonics can be eliminated

from the phase leg voltage as shown in Figure 48. The THD of phase leg

voltage is 10.67%. The triple-order harmonic components of line-to-line

voltage do not exist and the harmonics are pushed to 1250Hz as shown in

Figure 49. The THD of the line-to-line voltage is 7.3%.

89
Figure 48. Synthesized phase leg voltage waveform and frequency spectrum of

a two-HB THMI with the virtual stage modulation

Figure 49. Synthesized line-to-line voltage waveform and frequency spectrum

of a two-HB THMI with the virtual stage modulation

I n virtual stage modulation strategy, the relative modulation index also

has upper and lower limitation. Compared with the step modulation
90
strategy, the optimal computation of the virtual stage modulation strategy

endures more unequal restriction as shown in (78) and (79). When the

switching angles do not satisfy these restrictions, the themes of switching

angles no longer exist.

Table 7 Range of modulation index with the virtual stage modulation

in a two-HB THMI
σ β MR (min) MR (max) M M (max) Range of
(min) M
3 1 0.51 0.92 0.38 0.69 0.38-0.459
4 2 0.459 0.92 0.459 0.92 0.459-0.92

The concept of the relativ e mo dulatio n inde x c an b e use d in the ste p

m odulation strategy by the similar method. Table 7 shows two cases.

One is the nine-level output voltage with two virtual stages and the other

is the seven-level output voltage with one virtual stage. With the nine-

level output voltage and two virtual stages, the 5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, 17th,

19th and 23rd harmonics can be eliminated. With the seven-level output

voltage and one virtual stage, the 5th, 7th, 11th and 13th can be

eliminated. When output voltage levels are five or three, the virtual stage

modulation strategy is not applicable in the two-HB THMI since the

restriction (79) must be violated. Therefore, when M is less than 0.38 in

this case, the step modulation strategy will be used. With the virtual

stage modulation strategy, the scheme of switching angles is shown in

Figure 50.

91
Figure 50. Scheme of switching angles for the virtual stage modulation as a

function of modulation index in a two-HB THMI

p1 to p6 mean θp1 to θp6, n1 to n2 mean θn1 to θn2

2. 7.3.3. Hybrid modulation strategy

The hybrid modulation strategy for the hybrid multilevel inverters has

been presented, which incorporates stepped voltage waveform synthesis

in higher power HB cells in conjunction with hi gh frequency variable

PWM in the lowest power HB cell. Figure 51 presents a block diagram of

the command circuit utilized to determine the command signals of the

power devices of all HB. As shown in Figure 51, the reference signal of

the hybrid multilevel inverter, v ref is the command signal of the HB with

92
the highest dc voltage source (V dc,h ). This signal is compared with a

voltage level corresponding to the sum of all smaller dc voltage sources

of the hybrid multilevel inverter, σ max,h-1 . If the command signal is greater

than this level, the output of the inverter with the highest dc voltage

source must be equal to V dc,h . In addition, if the command signal is less

than the negative value of σ max,h-1 , the output of this cell must be equal to

-V dc,h , else the output of this cell must be zero.

Figure 51. Hybrid modulation for hybrid multilevel inverters

The command signal of ith HB cell is the difference b e tween the

command signal of the HB i+1 and the output voltage of the HBi+1 . In this

way, the command signal of the ith cell contains information ab out the

h armonic content of the output voltage of all higher voltage cells. This

command signal is compared with a voltage level corresponding to the

sum of all voltage sources until the HB i-1 (σ max,i-1 ). In the same way that

93
presented for the HB h , the output voltage of this cell is synthesized from

the comparison of these two signals.

Finally, the command signal of HB 1 ( lowest power inverter) is compared

with a high frequency triangle carrier signal, resulting in a high

frequency output voltage. Therefore, the output voltage harmonics will

be concentrated around the frequencies multiples of the switching

frequency of the inverter with the lowest dc voltage source. Consequently,

the spectral response of the output voltage depends on the switching

frequency of the lowest power inverter, while the power processing

depends on the inverter with the highest dc voltage source.

However, with the hybrid modulation strategy, a voltage waveform must

be synthesized to modulate at high frequency among all adjacent voltage

steps. Only the lower voltage HB can switch at high frequency, so the dc

voltages must satisfy the following equation:


i −1
Vdci* ≤ 2∑ Vdck * , j = 2,3,… , h (80)
k =1

where * mean the normalized value. Therefore , the hybrid modulation

strategy can be applied in binary hybrid multilevel inverters and quasi-

linear multilevel inverts. The relationship of DC voltages of the THMI is

shown in (64), so the THMI cannot use the hybrid modulation strategy.

94
2.7.3.4. Sub-harmonic PWM strategies

Sub-harmonic PWM strategies for multilevel inverters employ extensions

of carrier-based techniques used for conventional inverters. It has been

reported that the spectral performance of a five-l evel waveform can be

significantly improved by employing alternative dispositions and phase

shifts in the carrier signals. This concept can be extended to a nine-level

case with the available options for polarity and phase variation. A

representative sub-harmonic PWM waveform with the nine-level phase

leg voltage is shown in Figure 52.

Figure 52. Representative waveforms for sub-harmonic PWM waveform with

carrier polarity variation

If a two-HB THMI is used to synthe size the nine-level phase leg voltage

as shown in Figure 52 (b), the higher voltage HBs will switch at high

frequ encies, since the output voltage varies between E and 2E or -E and -
95
2E continually in certain interval. In THMI, it is not appropriate that the

higher voltage HBs switch at high frequency. Therefore, the sub-

harmonic PWM is not applicable in THMI.

Figure 53. Illustration of the simple modulation strategy

2.7.3.5. Simple modulation strategy

The simple modulation strategy is the simplest modulation strategy with

which the switching pattern is determined by comparing a reference

signal with stages and then choosing the stages most close to the

reference signal. Figure 53 shows the illustration of the simple

modulation strategy with the nine-level output voltage.

96
The advantage of this strategy is simple control algorithm, high

flexibility and dynamic response. The disadvantage is that the amplitudes

o f lower order harmonic components are relatively higher. The THMI can

generate the greatest voltage levels among all multilevel inverters using

the same number of components. If the number of voltage levels is high

enough, the lower-order harmonic components of output voltages will be

very small with the simple modulation strategy. For example, in the case

of a four-HB THMI that can generate 81-level voltage, with the simple

modulation strategy, the amplitude of each lower-order harmonic

components of the output voltage is less than 0.9% of the amplitude of

the fundamental component and THD of output voltage is less than 2%.

2.7.3.6. Summary of modulation strategies for THMI

Several modulation strategies have been investigated. With the hybrid

m odulation strategy and modulation strategies working with high

switching frequencies, such as sub-harmonic PWM s trategy, a voltage

waveform must be synthesized to modulate at high frequency among all

adjacent voltage steps. However, in THMI, it cannot be achieved when

only the lowest voltage HB switch at high frequency, which can be

derived from (64) and (80). In other words, if a voltage can be

synthesized to modulate at high frequency in THMI, the higher voltage

HBs must switch at high frequency. One of most important advantage of

THMI is that higher voltage HBs can switch at lower frequency.

Therefore, higher-frequency switching of higher voltage HBs not only is

97
unacceptable in high power application but also violate the main

advantage of THMI. Therefore, the hybrid modulation strategy and other

modulation strategies working with high switching frequencies are not

applicable in THMI. The low-frequency modulation strategies such as

step modulation strategy and virtual stage modulation strategy are

suitable in THMI. In the virtual stage modulation, additional constraint,

such as (79) for two-HB THMI, must be added to ensure the higher HB

switch at lower frequency. Additionally, the simple modulation strategy

can be used in the THMIs that can generate many voltage levels. At the

same time, for the THMIs that can generate many voltage levels, the

space vector modulation {Rodriguez, 2004 #54} can achieve a very good

linearity between the modulation index and the fundamental component

of load voltage and eliminate common-mode voltages.

2.7.4. Regenerative Power

The dc sources of the THMI can be batteries or bridge rectifies. Batteries

cannot endure large reverse current for a long ti me, which will damage

batteries. Diode bridge rectifies cannot permit reverse power. Controlled

bridge rectifies can transmit energy to supplies. However, compared to

simple diode bridge rectifies, the controlled bridge rectifies are much

more complex and costly because of complex control circuits and higher

price of controlled semiconductors.

98
2.7.4.1. Analysis of dc bus power injection

The switching function is involved in the analysis of dc bus power

in jection. The switching function, F, is shown in Table 1. The

relationship between output voltage of a HB , v H , and dc link voltage of

the HB, V dc , can be written as (82). The relationship between i dc (current

flowing through the dc bus) and i an (output current of the THMI) can be

also derived as (83).

vH = F⋅ Vdc (81)

idc = F⋅ ian (82)

Only fundamental component of output current of the THMI is

c onsidered since high frequ ency harmonic components do not gen erate

a verage power. So i an can be expressed as

ian = I an ⋅ sin(ωt + ϕ ) (83)

where I an is the amplitude of i an and ϕ is the angle of power factor.

General waveforms of v H and i an are shown in Figure 48. The average dc

p ower that supplies the HB over a p eriod can be calculated as (84)

1 T
T ∫0
Pdc = Vdc ⋅ idc dt (84)

where T is the period of i an . From (82) and (84), we can get

1 T 1 T
Pdc =
T ∫
0
Vdc ⋅ F⋅ ian dt =
T ∫0
vH ⋅ ian dt (85)

99
Figure 54. General waveform of dc bus voltage and THMI output current

Th e relationship between switching angles in Figure 54 can be express ed

a s (86).

⎧ π + θ i − 2ς i = (2ς + 1) 4ς
θi = ⎨ (86)
⎩π − θ 2ς +1−i i = (ς + 1) 2ς

Derived from (86), v H has following characteristic

vH (π − ωt ) = vH (ωt ) (87)
vH (ωt + π ) = −vH (ωt ) (88)

F rom (79), we can get

ian (ωt + π ) = −ian (ωt ) (89)

Derived from (88) and (89), the average dc power can be calculated over

h alf period as:

2 T2
Pdc = ∫ vH ⋅ ian dt (90)
T 0

Suppose P i mean the power is generated by the voltage pulse from θ i / ω to

θ i+1 / ω and corresponding voltage p ulse from θ 2 ς-i / ω to θ 2 ς+ 1 -i / ω. P i can be


expressed as:

100
(−1) n ω θi +1 / ω θ 2 ς +1−i / ω
Pi = (∫ Vdc ⋅ I an ⋅ sin(ωt + ϕ )dt + ∫ Vdc ⋅ I an ⋅ sin(ωt + ϕ )dt ) (91)
π θi / ω θ 2 ς −i / ω

where i = 2n – 1 a nd n is natural number. Derived from (86) and (91), P i

is expressed as

(−1) n
Pi = Vdc ⋅ I an ⋅ 2 ⋅ cos(ϕ ) ⋅ (cos(θi ) − cos(θi +1 )) (92)
π

Thus, the average dc power of the HB can be expressed as:

2
Pdc = Vdc ⋅ I an ⋅ cos(ϕ ) ⋅ ∑ (cos(θ 4 n −3 ) − cos(θ 4 n − 2 ) − cos(θ 4 n −1 ) + cos(θ 4 n )) (93)
π

In (89), if θ j is greater than π /2, θ j will be set as π /2.

In general, power factor angle ϕ is from - π /2 to π /2, so cos(φ) is greater

than zero. V dc and I an are positive. Thus, we can conc lude from (93) that

th e power of dc bus is negative if:

∑ (cos(θ 4 n +1 ) − cos(θ 4 n + 2 ) − cos(θ 4 n +3 ) + cos(θ 4 n + 4 )) < 0 (94)

Negative power of dc bus means regenerative power.

2.7.4.2. Regenerative power in THMI

Regenerative power may occur in lower-voltage HBs of THMI. Take the

e xample of a two-HB THMI. If the step modulation strategy is applied,

the restrictions that are added to (78) to ensure power of dc buses is

always positive are shown in Table 8. With these restrictions, ranges of

relative modulation index are calculated as shown in Table 9. The range

of relative modulation index decreases much when σ is two or three

compared with Table 6. The range of modulation index is not continuous


101
as shown in the last column of Table 9. The regenerative power will

occur in the lower voltage HB when M is from 0.51 to 0.55 or from 0.33

to 0.44.

Table 8. Additional restriction to avoid regenerative power of dc buses

in the step modulation


σ Restriction
1 cos(θ 1 ) > 0
2 cos(θ 1 ) - 2cos(θ 2 ) > 0
3 cos( θ 1 ) - 2cos( θ 2 ) + cos( θ 3 ) > 0
4 cos(θ 1 ) - 2cos(θ 2 ) + cos(θ 3 ) + cos(θ 4 ) > 0

Consider the v irt ual sta ge modulatio n strategy is used in a two-HB THMI.

In Table 7, tw o cases are analyzed. One is four-level positive/negative

output voltag e with two virtual stages and the other is fi ve-level

positive/negative output voltage with one virtual stage. Only dc bus of

the lower voltage HB is possible to have regenerative power. For the first

case, the restriction that ensures positive power can be written as:

cos(θ p1 ) − 2cos(θ p 2 ) + cos(θ p 3 ) + cos(θ p 4 ) + cos(θ p 5 ) + cos(θ p 6 ) − cos(θ n1 ) − cos(θ n 2 ) > 0 (95)

Table 9. Range of modulation index with the step modulation in a two-

HB THMI (avoid regenerative power of dc buses)


σ MR MR M M Range of
(min) (max) (min) (max) MA
1 0 1 0 0.25 0-0.15
2 0.3 0.66 0.15 0.33 0.15-0.33
3 0.59 0.68 0.44 0.51 0.44-0.51
4 0.55 0.86 0.55 0.86 0.55-0.8 6
4* 0.56 0.94 0.56 0.94 0.86-0.9 4

102
To the second case, the r est riction c an be exp ressed as :

cos(θ p1 ) − 2 cos(θ p 2 ) + cos(θ p 3 ) + cos(θ p 4 ) + cos(θ p 5 ) − cos(θ n1 ) > 0 (92)

With th ese res trictio ns, t he ran ge of relative modulation index de creases

a s shown in Table 10. The regenerative power will occur in the lower

voltage HB when M is from 0.53 to 0.62.

Table 10 . Range of modulation index range with the virtual stage

modulation strategy in a two-HB THMI (avoid regenerative power of dc bus)


σ β MR (min) MR (max) M (m in) M (max) Range of M
3 1 0.62 0.71 0.46 0.53 0.46-0.53
4 2 0.62 0.92 0.62 0.92 0.62-0.92

2.7.4.3. Method to avoid regenerative power

In last s ec tio n, the regenerative power that lower voltage HBs is possi ble

t o g ene rat e i s disc ussed . In t his se ction, the meth ods th at are use d to

s olve this problem will be introduced. A method is proposed that the dc

links of lower voltage HBs are supplied by the low power, isolated power

sources fed by a common power supply from the highest voltage HB.

These power sources is bidirectional and a bidirectional dc-dc power

supply is used for this purpose. It is also possible to use independent

output transformers with a common dc supply, as show in Figure 55. A

variation of this configuration was used by ABB in his 16 2/3 Hz

substation for railroads in Bremen (Germany). In the system described

here, the transforms are smaller for lower voltage HBs because the

103
voltages are scaled in power of three. Besides, the switching frequency of

transformers connected with lower voltage HBs are lower. Then the

transforms connected with lower voltage HBs become smaller for two

reasons: voltage and switching frequency.

Figure 55. THMI with output transformers

The above two methods to solve the problem of the regenerative power

use additional equipments, such as bi-directional dc-dc converter or

output transformers, which increase the cost of the inverter system and

power losses. A new method is presented to avoid regenerative power.

This method does not use additional devices. The regenerative power is

104
eliminated by avoiding outputting several null voltage levels, which will

be explained by an example of a four-HB THMI in the following.

The average power of the DC bus of a HB can be expressed as (93). In

general, power factor angle ϕ is from - π /2 to π /2, so cos(φ) is greater

th an zero. V dc and I an are positive. Therefore, from (93) and Figure 54, we

can conclude that the reason of the regenerative power is the negative

segments of v H when the fundamental components of v an is positive or the

positive segments of v H when the fundamental components of v an is

negative. The segments of v H resulting in the regenerative power of the

HB are called regenerative segments. The basic idea of eliminating

regenerative power is to avoid output several levels of v an which will

cause regenerative segments in HBs. Table 11 shows the voltage levels

of v an which cause regenerative segments of HBs in the case of a four-HB

THMI. The voltage levels of v an which are not selected to output are

called null voltage levels. Table 11 also shows the priory of null voltage

levels. For example, if the regenerative power occurs in the dc link of the

HB 1 , the voltage level (14) and (-14) are selected as null voltage levels

firstly. If the regenerative power still occurs, the voltage levels (17) and

(-17) are also selected as null voltage levels. With the priory shown in

the Table 11, the null voltage levels distribute as evenly as possible,

which results in better power quality.

105
Table 11. Voltage levels of van which cause regenerative segments of HBs
HB 1 ±14, ±17, ±32, ±23, ± 5, ± 20, ± 38, ± 29, ± 26, ± 11, ±2, ±8, ±35
HB 2 ±14, ±32, ±23, ±5, ±15, ± 34, ± 25, ± 7, ± 16, ± 6, ± 24, ±33
HB 3 ±14, ±17, ±15, ±20, ±19, ±16, ±21, ±18, ±22

Figure 56. Flow chart of the algorithm to stabilize dc link voltages

Figur e 56 shows the flow chart of the algorithm that stabilizes the dc link

v oltage of a HB. V dc is the dc link voltage of a HB. V dc,normal is the normal

dc link voltage. V dc,last is the dc link voltage in the previous sampling.

N null is the number of null voltage levels. In the switch table, the voltage

levels are set as null or not based on N null and Table 11.

106
Figure 57. Relationship between the modulation index and THD

With lower modulation index, the power quality that the THMI outputs is

a little bit poorer with the proposed control scheme because more null

v oltage levels do not devote themselves to the output voltage of the

THMI. In the case of the four-HB THMI, with up to 81-level output

voltage of the THMI, the simple modulation strategy as shown in section

3 is suitable for the THMI. If the simple modulation strategy is used and

the new method is applied to eliminate the effect of regenerative power,

the relationship between the modulation index and the THD is shown in

Figure 57.

2.7.4.4. Summary of regenerative power in THMI

The topolog y of THMI has distinct advantage of least components used

c ompared with other topologies of multilevel inverters, but the THMI


107
also has notable disadvantage that power of the lower voltage HBs is

possible to be regenerative with lower modulation index. If the THMI

feeds a RL or RC load and simple diode bridge rectifies are used as dc

sources, the regenerative power will cause the increase of the dc

capacitor voltages, which will damage devices.

Therefore, basically, the THMI is suitable for two applications. The first

one is the application of reactive power com pensation. The average

p ower of dc link of a HB is zero when power factor angle is zero as

shown in (89), so the problem of regenerative power is avoided. The

second one is the application in which the inverter always runs with

higher modulation index. From Table 9, we can find that the two-HB

THMI runs with step modulation without problem of regenerative power

when M is from 0.55 to 0.94. From Table 10, we can find that the two-

HB THMI runs with virtual stage modulation without problem of

regenerative power when M is from 0.62 to 0.92.

However, the inverter is required to work at any modulation index for

active load in most cases. Two methods have b een presented to solve

r egenerative power problem. The first one uses bidirectional dc/dc

converters and the second one use additional output transformers. A new

method to solve the regenerative power is presented as a cost-effective

solution because it does not use additional equipments. The dc capacitor

voltages of lower voltage HBs are kept stable by the new method. The

108
tradeoff is that power quality will decrease a little bit with lower

modulation index.

2.7.5. Experimental Results

2.7.5.1. Experiment to verify the step modulation and virtual stage

modulation

The performance of step modulation strategy and virtual stage

modulation strategy has been verified by the experimental of a single

two-HB THMI. In the control circuit, a TMS320F240 DSP is used as the

main processor, which provides the gate logic signals. In a HB, four

MOSFETs, IRF540, are used as the main switches, which are connected

in a full-bridge configuration. The load is a 23.2 Ω resistor. The total

ratio of voltage measure is 1:2. The frequency spectrums are analyzed by

the FFT (Fast Fourier Transform) function of oscilloscope. The scale of

Y-axis of frequency spectrum is 5dbV/div and reference level is 5dbV.

Figure 58. Output voltage of the THMI with the step modulation M = 0.83

(10V/div)

109
Figure 59. Frequency spectrum with the step modulation M = 0.83

The switching pattern of step modulation technique is programmed and is

loaded to the DSP. In step modulation strategy, when output voltage

levels are nine and M is 0.83, the switching angles are 0.14778, 0.32325,

0.57376 and 0.99696. The THMI output voltage is shown in Figure 58.

The frequency is 50Hz and the step voltage is about 5V. The frequency

spectrum is shown in Figure 59. The 5th, 7th and 11th harmonics are less

than 0.028V (–37db×2V), which means they are nearly eliminated. It

verifies the simulation result as shown in Figure 59.

When output voltage levels are seven and M is 0.49, the switching angles

are 0.44717, 0.9097 and 1.1215. The output voltage of the THMI is

shown in Figure 60 and the frequency spectrum is shown in Figure 61.

The 5th and 7th harmonics are less than 0.02V (–40db×2V), which means

they are nearly eliminated.

110
Figure 60. Output voltage of the THMI with the step modulation M = 0.49

(10V/div)

Figure 61. Frequency spectrum with the step modulation M = 0.49

111
Figure 62. Output voltage of the THMI with the step modulation M = 0.32

(10V/div)

Figure 63. Frequency spectrum with the step modulation M = 0.32

When output voltage levels are five and M is 0.32, the switching angles

are 0.51847 and 1.1468. The output voltage of the THMI is shown in

Figure 62 and the frequency spectrum is shown in Figure 63. The fifth

harmonics are less than 0.02V (–40db×2V), which means they are nearly

eliminated.

112
Figure 64. Output voltage of the THMI with the virtual stage modulation M =

0.83 (10V/div)

Figure 65. Frequency spectrum with the virtual stage modulation M = 0.83

The switching pattern of modified virtual stage modulation technique is

programmed and is loaded to the DSP. In virtual stage modulation, when

output voltage levels are nine and M is 0.83, the switch ing ang les are

0.13177, 0.33186, 0.52855, 0.6202, 0.91294, 1.0423, 0.57124 and

0.96573. The output voltage of the THMI is shown in Figure 64 and the

frequency spectrum is shown in Figure 65. T he 5th, 7th, 11th, 13th, 17th,

1 9th and 23rd harmonics are less than 0.035V (–35db×2V), which means
113
they are nearly eliminated. It verifies the simulation result as shown in

Figure 65.

Figure 66. Output voltage of the THMI with the virtual stage modulation M =

0.49 (10V/div)

Figure 67. Frequency spectrum with the virtual stage modulation M= 0.49

When output voltage levels are seven and M is 0.49, the switching angles

are 0.40549, 0.88038, 1.1497, 1.5318 and 1.5082. The output voltage of

the THMI is shown in Figure 66 and the frequency spectrum is shown in

114
Figure 67. The 5th, 7th, 11th and 13th harmonics are less than 0.02V (–

40db×2V), which means they are nearly eliminated

2.7.5.2. Experiment to verify the new method to eliminate the

regenerative power

Figure 68. General representation of experimental test system

The performance of the methods to eliminate the effect of regenerative

power by avoiding output the null voltage levels is verified by the

e xperiment of a 4-HB THMI, in which diode bridge rectifies are used as

the dc sources of HBs. The step voltage is 5.9V. The frequency of output

voltage is set at 50 Hz and the sampling frequency is set at 10 kHz. The

output voltage levels of the inverter has up to 81 levels, so the simple

modulation strategy as show in section 0. The control algorithm to

stabilize the dc link voltages is shown in Figure 68. A TMS320F240 DSP


115
controlled card is used to control the inverter. The configuration of

experimental system is shown in Figure 68.

Figure 69. Waveform of output voltage of the inverter with the simple

modulation strategy M = 0.79 (100V/div), Frequency = 50 Hz, THD = 1.94%

Figure 69 shows the waveform of output voltage of the 4-HB THMI with

simple modulation strategy when modulation index is 0.79. The power

quality is good due to a great deal of voltage levels.

Figure 70. Waveform of output voltage of the inverter M = 0.7 (100V/div)


116
Figure 70 shows the output voltage waveform with some null voltage

levels when modulation index is 0.7. From the enlarged figure, we can

observe that some voltage levels are not generated. Moreover, the step

voltages are kept nearly same, which means that the voltages of dc

cap acitors are kept stable. Figure 71 shows the worst case when the

m odulation index is 0.53. In this case, null voltage levels include ±5, ±14,

± 15, ±16, ±17, ±19, ±20, ±21, ±23, ±32 and ±34.

Figure 71. Waveform of output voltage of the inverter M = 0.42 (100V/div)

117

You might also like