Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 20 views

    Evaluation Reports - Journal of Multidisciplinary Applied Natural Science

    Uploaded by

    Hanif Amrulloh ZA
    The manuscript investigates the impact of feedpoint position on the return loss and bandwidth of a rectangular patch antenna. The authors tested 15 different feedpoint locations on an FR4_epoxy substrate and identified the best performing configuration. However, the reviewer provides several comments to improve the quality of the work, such as adding more details to the introduction, results, and comparison to prior work. The manuscript would benefit from addressing these comments to better highlight the advantages and contributions of the proposed antenna design.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Evaluation Reports - Journal of Multidisciplinary Applied Natural Science

    Uploaded by

    Hanif Amrulloh ZA
    20 views2 pages
    The manuscript investigates the impact of feedpoint position on the return loss and bandwidth of a rectangular patch antenna. The authors tested 15 different feedpoint locations on an FR4_epoxy substrate and identified the best performing configuration. However, the reviewer provides several comments to improve the quality of the work, such as adding more details to the introduction, results, and comparison to prior work. The manuscript would benefit from addressing these comments to better highlight the advantages and contributions of the proposed antenna design.

    Original Title

    Evaluation Reports_Journal of Multidisciplinary Applied Natural Science_

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The manuscript investigates the impact of feedpoint position on the return loss and bandwidth of a rectangular patch antenna. The authors tested 15 different feedpoint locations on an FR4_epoxy substrate and identified the best performing configuration. However, the reviewer provides several comments to improve the quality of the work, such as adding more details to the introduction, results, and comparison to prior work. The manuscript would benefit from addressing these comments to better highlight the advantages and contributions of the proposed antenna design.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    20 views2 pages

    Evaluation Reports - Journal of Multidisciplinary Applied Natural Science

    Uploaded by

    Hanif Amrulloh ZA
    The manuscript investigates the impact of feedpoint position on the return loss and bandwidth of a rectangular patch antenna. The authors tested 15 different feedpoint locations on an FR4_epoxy substrate and identified the best performing configuration. However, the reviewer provides several comments to improve the quality of the work, such as adding more details to the introduction, results, and comparison to prior work. The manuscript would benefit from addressing these comments to better highlight the advantages and contributions of the proposed antenna design.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    Manuscript entitled: Impact of Feedpoint Position on Patch Antenna’s Return Loss and Bandwidth

    Authors in this research work have investigated the effectiveness of a rectangular patch antenna by altering the
    feed point locations. The best outcome of the 15 feeding locations of the proposed antenna on the FR4_epoxy
    substrate has been demonstrated. The idea and content of the manuscript are interesting and they can be
    supported with promising achievements. But, before final recommendation, authors are requested to improve the
    quality of their work by properly addressing the following comments.
    1) Please add the application of the proposed work in the title.
    2) Please highlight the advantages of the hybrid techniques in the abstract section.
    3) Please support the abstract section with some numerical achievements.
    4) Advantages of the proposed study on altering the feed point position should be highlighted in the abstract
    section.
    5) Please add more keywords to the manuscript.
    6) Introduction section can be improved by adding more elaborations on the proposed topic and microstrip
    antennas. There are various types of microstrip antennas with high performances which can be mentioned in the
    introduction section along with proper references. Below are helpful suggestions.
    "Impedance Bandwidth Improvement of a Planar Antenna Based on Metamaterial-Inspired T-Matching
    Network," IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 67916-67927, 2021.
    “New CRLH-Based Planar Slotted Antennas with Helical Inductors for Wireless Communication Systems, RF-
    Circuits and Microwave Devices at UHF-SHF Bands", Wireless Personal Communications- Springer
    Journal, Wireless Personal Communications, February 2017, Volume 92, Issue 3, pp 1029–1038.
    “Miniature CRLH-based ultra wideband antenna with gain enhancement for wireless communication
    applications”, ICT Express, Volume 2, Issue 2, June 2016, Pages 75–79.
    “Hexa-Band Planar Antenna with Asymmetric Fork-Shaped Radiators for Multiband and Broadband
    Communication Applications” IET Microwaves, Antennas & Propagation, Volume 10, Issue 5, 13 April
    2016, p. 471 – 478.
    “Broadband 3-D Shared Aperture High Isolation Nine-Element Antenna Array for On-Demand Millimeter-
    Wave 5G Applications”, Optik, Volume 267, 169708, October 2022.

    "An Innovative Antenna Array with High Inter Element Isolation for Sub-6 GHz 5G MIMO Communication
    Systems", Scientific Reports, 12, 7907, 2022.

    "A Comprehensive Survey on Antennas On-Chip Based on Metamaterial, Metasurface, and Substrate Integrated
    Waveguide Principles for Millimeter-Waves and Terahertz Integrated Circuits and Systems," IEEE Access, vol.
    10, pp. 3668-3692, 2022.
    “Dual-Polarized Highly Folded Bowtie Antenna with Slotted Self-Grounded Structure for Sub-6 GHz 5G
    Applications”, IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 70, no. 4, pp. 3028-3033, April 2022.

    “A high gain multiband offset MIMO antenna based on a planar log-periodic array for Ku/K-band applications”,
    Scientific Reports, 12, 4044 (2022).

    "Novel Concentric Hexagonal-Shaped RFID Tag Antenna With T-Shaped Stub Matching", IEEE Journal of
    Radio Frequency Identification, vol. 6, pp. 112-120, 2022.

    "Compact and Low-Profile On-Chip Antenna Using Underside Electromagnetic Coupling Mechanism for
    Terahertz Front-End Transceivers", Electronics, 10(11), 1264, 2021.

    “Optimum Power Transfer in RF Front End Systems Using Adaptive Impedance Matching Technique”,
    Scientific Reports, 11, 11825, 2021.
    "High-Isolation Antenna Array Using SIW and Realized with a Graphene Layer for Sub-Terahertz Wireless
    Applications", Scientific Reports, 11, 10218, 2021.

    "Bandwidth and Gain Enhancement of Composite Right Left Handed Metamaterial Transmission Line Planar
    Antenna Employing a Non Foster Impedance Matching Circuit Board", Scientific Reports, 11, 7472, 2021.

    "Singular Integral Formulations for Electrodynamic Analysis of Metamaterial-Inspired Antenna Array," IEEE
    Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters, vol. 20, no. 2, pp. 179-183, Feb. 2021.

    "Study on on-Chip Antenna Design Based on Metamaterial-Inspired and Substrate-Integrated Waveguide


    Properties for Millimetre-Wave and THz Integrated-Circuit Applications", Journal of Infrared, Millimeter, and
    Terahertz Waves, volume 42, issue 1, 17–28, 2021.
    “Traveling-Wave Antenna Based on Metamaterial Transmission Line Structure for Use in Multiple Wireless
    Communication Applications", AEUE Elsevier- International Journal of Electronics and
    Communications, Volume 70, Issue 12, December 2016, Pages 1645–1650.
     “A New Planar Broadband Antenna Based on Meandered Line Loops for Portable Wireless Communication
    Devices” Radio Science,Volume 51, Issue 7, July 2016, Pages 1109–1117.
    “Periodic Array of Complementary Artificial Magnetic Conductor Metamaterials-Based Multiband Antennas
    for Broadband Wireless Transceivers” IET Microwaves, Antennas & Propagation, Volume 10, Issue 15, 10
    December 2016, p. 1682 – 1691.
    “Bandwidth Extension of Planar Antennas Using Embedded Slits for Reliable Multiband RF
    Communications”, AEUE Elsevier- International Journal of Electronics and Communications, Volume 70, Issue
    7, July 2016, Pages 910–919.
    "A Comprehensive Survey on "Various Decoupling Mechanisms with Focus on Metamaterial and Metasurface
    Principles Applicable to SAR and MIMO Antenna Systems"", IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 192965-193004, 2020.
    "A Comprehensive Survey of "Metamaterial Transmission-Line Based Antennas: Design, Challenges, and
    Applications"", IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 144778-144808, 2020.
    7) Fig.2 shows the proposed antenna layout, please explain two horizontal separated strips on the top side of the
    main radiator? Their impact can be elaborated in depth.
    8) Why have authors selected and implemented the proposed geometry of the antenna exhibited in Fig.2? What
    are its benefits and advantages?
    9) Please add the 2D curves of the radiation gain and efficiency plots over the operating frequencies.  
    10) To highlight the advantages of the proposed work, authors can compare it with some prior art before
    concluding the manuscript. The results can be listed in a table.
    11) Please support the conclusion with more numerical results.
    12) Reference part can be improved by a proper extension as per above mentioned suggestions. 

    You might also like