Gandhi’s Critique of

UNIT 4 SWARAJ* Development

Structure
4.1 Introduction
Aims and Objectives
4.2 Swaraj
4.3 Political Swaraj
4.4 Economic Swaraj
4.4.1 Village Decentralization (Gram Swaraj)
4.4.2 Swadeshi and Khadi
4.4.3 Trusteeship
4.4.4 Bread and Labour
4.5 Social Swaraj
4.6 Swaraj as Self-Control
4.7 Summary
4.8 Terminal Questions
4.9 Suggested Readings

4.1 INTRODUCTION
The late 19th Century witnessed a growth of a national identity and cultural
nationalism in India. The Indian National Congress was established in

1885; Swami Dayananda and Swami Vivekananda awoke India’s pride in its
own identity. They espoused the ‘Vedas’ and the greatness of India’s past. The
educated Indian middle class still felt inferior to the ‘white sahibs’. The partition
of Bengal by the British shook up the Indians and writers such as Rabindranath
Tagore were working to forge an Indian identity through their works such as
‘Swadeshi Samaj’. Tilak’s call for ‘Swaraj as my birthright’ consolidated the
new mood of Indian nationalism particularly after the Ilbert Bill (1883).

Gandhi underlined the need to bridge the gulf between the cities and villages,
educated and uneducated not under the colonial influence, but through the
awakening and efforts of the Indian themselves. In ‘Hind Swaraj’ (1909) Gandhi
propagated the spirit of ‘Swaraj’ using this word instead of the English word
independence or freedom. According to Gandhi a collective effort was needed to
build a nation with continuity of tradition, incorporating essential reforms and
giving proper position to the concept of individualism. Gandhi said that Swaraj
is an inclusive concept-political, economic, social and moral-emphasising on
the utmost necessity of the human being to be as perfect as possible.

Aims and Objectives

After reading this Unit, you would be able to understand
Gandhi’s concept of Swaraj
The meaning of Swaraj as self-rule.

Suruchi Aggarwal, H-6A Panchsheel Vihar, Nr. D.D.A. Flats, Khirki Extn., New Delhi 55
Gandhi’s Poliitical Concerns Political, Economic and Social dimensions of Swaraj
Swaraj as self-control

4.2 SWARAJ
The concept of Swaraj has been given much importance in Gandhi’s spiritual,
political, social and economic ideas and has been frequently espoused in his
writings and speeches. He re-evaluated the meaning of Swaraj according to the
times he lived in, and used the word, Swaraj, to reawaken the spirit of Indian
people. According to him the word Swaraj was a sacred word, a Vedic word,
meaning self-rule and self-restraint. Gandhi believed that national Swaraj could
be achieved by the same means that were needed for attaining individual Swaraj.
Gandhi believed that the methods of attaining individual Swaraj with national
Swaraj were similar and complementary to each-other. Gandhi proclaimed that
self-government depended entirely upon one’s internal strength, upon one’s ability
to fight against all odds. He said that political self-government, that is, self-
government for a large number of men and women, is no better than individual
self-government, and, therefore, it is to be attained by precisely the same means
that are required for individual self-government or self-rule.

4.3 POLITICAL SWARAJ

Gandhi believed that each nation should have its own system of government
according to the conditions prevalent in which there would be the rule of the
people. The essence of his concept of Swaraj was that power must be in the
hands of the people. He aimed at a democratic state based on moral authority. He
insisted that democracy would be an impossible thing until the power was shared
by all. Gandhi was impressed by Abraham Lincoln’s concept of democracy as ‘a
Government of the people, by the people for the people’24. Gandhi opined that
under democracy individual liberty of opinion and action should be fiercely
protected. He emphasised that a democrat must be totally selfless and must not
think about himself/herself or party but only of democracy. He wanted a healthy
and honest difference of opinion in democracy.

Gandhi tried to give a democratic orientation to the concept of Swaraj. He believed

that the government of the country must be based on the will of the majority of
the people which should be ascertained through adult suffrage. The people who
elect such Swaraj government should have contributed manual labour to the
state. To quote him, “By Swaraj I mean the government of India by the consent
of the people as ascertained by the largest number of the adult population, male
or female, native-born or domiciled, who have contributed by manual labour to
the service of the State and who have taken the trouble of having registered their
names as voters.”25 Gandhi accepted parliamentary form of government as the
immediate goal of his conception of Swaraj. His Swaraj was the Parliamentary
government of India in the modern times. He supported parliamentary Swaraj as
the immediate political objective, but also as an ideal to strive for. Basically
Gandhi wanted the rule of majority only to the extent that it could be regarded as
an expression of the collective social will.

Parliamentary democracy should also be a participatory democracy. This involved

a democratic structure of the government in which an individual enjoyed
56 maximum freedom of thought, expression and participated in decision-making
and implementation processes. The people should also be fully competent to Swaraj
retain political power in their hands to reduce the interference of government to
a minimum to establish self-government to avoid coercive control. Gandhi sought
to build up a democratic structure from the grass-root levels, the self-government
(the real Swaraj) by making the masses aware of their power and dignity.

4.4 ECONOMIC SWARAJ

Gandhi believed that India had lost political control due to losing the control
over its economy. In his exhaustive treatise ‘Hind Swaraj’ he devotes a complete
chapter ‘Why was India lost?’. This chapter gives an economic argument for the
enslavement of India by the British. It further goes on to give Gandhi’s vision for
a good economic system. Gandhi’s concept of Swaraj included economic Swaraj
which was not separated from human condition in its totality. For Gandhi political
Swaraj would not work without bringing about an economic Swaraj. For Gandhi
economic development was related to the concept of Swaraj. Economic
dependence does not allow individuals or nations to formulate and take decisions
for themselves (Swaraj).

4.4.1 Village Decentralization (Gram Swaraj)

Gandhi saw each village as a self-reliant unit. He was more inclined towards
development of cottage industries and not large-scale industrialization. He felt a
decentralized economy would negate exploitation of labour and corruption. He
always espoused that there are abundant resources in nature for everyone’s need
but not for everyone’s greed. Gandhi believed that decentralisation was essential
for the survival of democracy. Gandhi preferred the decentralisation of small
units of production as compared to the setting up of large scale units in few
places. He wanted to carry the production units to the homes of the masses,
particularly in villages. Cottage and village industries help increasing
employment. Commodities can be produced cheaply as there is no need for a
separate establishment; very few resources are needed. There is no problem of
storage. Transport cost is negligible. Integration of cottage industries with
agriculture provides work to the farmers in the off season time. This helped in
utilizing all their energies which would have otherwise have been wasted. In
fact, these industries are best suited for a rural life. These industries increase the
income of the villages and satisfy their basic needs. According to Gandhi this
would help in the removal of poverty and unemployment from the villages and
also make them self-sufficient economic units.

4.4.2 Swadeshi and Khadi

The concept of Gandhi’s Swadeshi gave preference to local products even if
they are of inferior grade or expensive than things manufactured elsewhere and
tried to resolve the problems of local manufacturers.  Gandhi’s Swadeshi did not
imply rejection of all foreign goods just because they are foreign, and to go on
wasting national time and money in the promotion of manufactures of one’s
country for which it is not suited. This would be wrong and against the Swadshi
spirit. In the Swadeshi economic order there will be healthy exchange of products
and not cut-throat competition through the play of market forces. The guiding
principle that he laid down in respect of all foreign goods was that those things
should not be imported which were likely to prove harmful to the interests of the
indigenous industry. 57
Gandhi’s Poliitical Concerns Gandhi found khadi as the necessary and most important corollary of the principle
of Swadeshi in its practical application to society. Gandhi stressed the importance
of the development of Khadi industry. For Gandhi, khadi was the symbol of
unity of Indian humanity of its economic freedom and equality and Swaraj. He
believed that the development of Khadi industry would save millions of people
from hunger and poverty. Gandhi advocated the use of charkha and the ‘Charkha’
was considered to be the symbol of non­violence. His slogan was ‘Swaraj through
spinning’.

4.4.3 Trusteeship
Economic Swaraj for Gandhi also meant an egalitarian society which would
further the cause of democracy (political Swaraj). He was against the idea of
large fortunes in the hands of few. The rich and entitled should be trustees of the
society and use their resources for the welfare of the downtrodden. In this his
views had a Marxist orientation. Trusteeship provides a means of transforming
the present capitalist order of society into an egalitarian one. It gives no importance
to capitalism, but gives the present producer/owner class the chance of reforming
itself. It is based on the faith that human nature is never beyond redemption. It
does not recognise any right of private ownership of property except the amount
permitted by society for its welfare. It proposed to fix a decent minimum living
wage, the limit of this minimum wage should be fixed according to the maximum
income allowed to any person in society. The difference between such minimum
and maximum incomes should be reasonable and equitable and should vary from
time to time so that the tendency would be towards eradication of such difference.

4.4.4 Bread and Labour

Gandhi was influenced by law of bread and labour as put forward by T.M.
Bondaref and which was also propounded by Ruskin and Tolstoy. This law
emphasises that man must earn his bread (livelihood) by his own labour (work).
If all people laboured for their bread, there would be enough food and clothing
for all, they would be healthier and happier, and there would be no problem of
food shortage, no disease and no misery. He strongly believed that without
physical labour no one was entitled to get food. He advised the rich also to do
physical labour for earning a livelihood.
Gandhi’s perceptions of economic Swaraj were based on self-control and self-
restraint by the individual and society as a whole. He was against consumerism
and amassing of wealth by individuals, all these he put forward when people
practised self-control and restrained their wants and needs. Self-control by the
individual as a unit and society collectively was also a key concept of Swaraj or
self-control.26

4.5 SOCIAL SWARAJ

While elaborating upon social Swaraj Gandhi wanted a state of social existence
where each individual irrespective of his/her religion, race, caste, sex, place of
birth, residence or parentage will enjoy equal social status. Thus, the society
shall be an integrated community devoid of any artificial and manmade
distinctions. It shall be a society inspired by the spirit of social equality, equality
of status and equal dignity of all its members irrespective of a variety of natural
58 and manmade distinctions.
 Swaraj
4.6 SWARAJ AS SELF-CONTROL
Gandhi championed the cause of individual freedom. According to him Swaraj
really means self-control. Only that person is capable of self-control who observes
the rules of morality, does not cheat or give up truth, and does his duty to his
parents, wife and children, servants and neighbours. Such a man can truly enjoy
Swaraj and a nation enjoys Swaraj if it can boast of a large number of such good
citizens. An individual Swarajist has to observe eleven vows like truth, non-
violence, non-stealing, non-possession, celibacy, fearlessness, manual labour,
non-indulgence in food, use of Swadeshi, equal respect for all religions and
eradicating untouchability. Gandhi considered individual as an end and as such
opposed to servility.

Gandhi believed that Swaraj or true freedom is conformity to moral law, the
inner conscience, and the law of one’s true being. It induces a person to seek the
good and attain it, an end that is worthy. Freedom means self-control, a conquest
over self which can be attained only by being fearless. It involves rigorous
discipline and requires that one follows one’s vows of self-purification and self-
realisation. It is through active involvement and participation in the day to day
affairs of society that the individual attains salvation or ‘moksha’. Gandhi insisted
on the need to rationalise and synthesise desires in an integrated life in order to
attain the morals necessary to distinguish humans from brutes. Another implication
of Swaraj is moral and spiritual freedom or ‘anâsakti’ which comes as the
consequence of will and reason leading to concentration of energy. This was the
most important lesson that Gandhi learnt from the ‘Bhagavad Gita’.

Swaraj as self-rule or self-control means three things: first freedom is primarily

an individual, not a collective quality. Second, it includes the conventional civil
liberties of the press, speech, association and religion and third, it distinguishes
between inner and outer forms of freedom, inner freedom as anchoring and
sustaining outer freedom. For Gandhi, the individual is the pillar of Swaraj but
this does not mean unbridled individualism; rather it implies, as explained by T.
H. Green, a balance between individual freedom and social restraint. He insisted
on individuals cultivating qualities of discipline, voluntary loyalty and solidarity
and internal freedom as these would ensure an unimpeachable character and
conduct. He constantly emphasised that inactive and weak people would never
be able to attain freedom and individual consciousness alone would lift people
out of all forms of bondage. Gandhi considered weakness, cowardice and fear as
sins against human spirit. He taught the Indians the spirit of fearlessness. Self-
rule, self-restraint, self-discipline and voluntary self-sacrifice rooted in the notions
of individual autonomy and moral self-determinism formed the basis of his Swaraj.
“When Gandhi pursued the political goal of Swaraj (self-rule) he meant to teach
himself and Indians, that only those who could rule themselves in the sense of
self-restraint could rule themselves in the sense of controlling their political
universe”27

Gandhi saw an intimate link between Swaraj and Swadeshi or self-reliance. For
Gandhi, freedom is rooted in human nature and is to be claimed as part of self-
awareness earned through self-effort and conversely, any external threat to human
freedom arises not from circumstances outside one’s control but by recognising
our weaknesses in the first place, which is why he considered self-purification
as integral to the concept of Swaraj. This gives the individuals the strength and
59
Gandhi’s Poliitical Concerns capacity to translate the abstract notion of freedom into a practical reality in
society and politics. According to Gandhi, a person truly realises freedom if he
listens to his conscience or the inner voice, the only tyrant that one should accept.
Fearlessness, self-rule, self-restraint, self-discipline, non-attachment, renunciation
and voluntary self-sacrifice would make resistance to evil easy and that forms
the core of the philosophy of ‘Satyagraha’. Gandhi described Satyagraha as the
act of the brave and the fearless and through it, “Gandhi turned the moral tables
on the English definition of courage by suggesting that aggression was the path
to mastery of those without self-control, non-violent resistance the path of those
with control”28

4.7 SUMMARY
This elaborate explanation of the meaning of Swaraj and the three pillars of
Swaraj sums up the entire political philosophy and action of Gandhi. Emphasising
on the utmost necessity to have unity in a situation of larger plurality and also
with the larger awareness of two Indias, one of the city and another of the village
with abject poverty allowed him to portray a more realistic depiction of the Indian
reality, much better than attempted by the socialists and the Marxists. To give
life and meaning to the concept of Swaraj, Gandhi’s formulation of the
constructive programme is of supreme importance. It portrays the essential
reformative nature of his theories ensuring the minimum resources and
environment essential for self-development of every single Indian and as a means
of reaching the goal of Swaraj.
Gandhi prefers to use Swaraj instead of the English word, independence or
freedom. By Swaraj Gandhi did not mean only political Swaraj. Freedom or
Swaraj, for Gandhi, is an inclusive concept-political, economic, social and moral
emphasising on the utmost necessity of the human being to be as perfect as
possible. Gandhi borrows the term ‘Swaraj’ from the Vedas. One meaning of
Swaraj is self-rule and self-control and differs from the English usage, which
implies freedom without restraints. Swaraj for Gandhi also meant positive
freedom, to participate in the process of politics in every possible way. It implies
participatory democracy as there exists an intimate relationship between the
citizen and the state. Gandhi’s concern for majority alleviation led him to advance
the notion of village decentralization or ‘Gram Swaraj’ with its focus on the
village, at the centre of his social, political and economic philosophy.

4.8 TERMINAL QUESTIONS

1) Explain Gandhi’s concept of Swaraj.
2) What does Gandhi mean by Swaraj as self-rule?
3) Elaborate Gandhi’s political, economic and social Swaraj?
5) Explain Gandhi’s Swaraj as self-control.

4.9 SUGGESTED READINGS

Bandyopadhyaya, J. Social and Political Thought of Gandhi. Bombay. Allied
Publishers, 1969.
Bhattacharya, B. Evolution of the Political Philosophy of Gandhi. Calcutta.
60 Calcutta Book House, 1969.
Bondurant, J. V. Conquest of Violence: Gandhian Philosophy of Conflict. Swaraj
Berkeley. University of California Press, 1967.
Bose, N. K. Studies in Gandhism. Ahmedabad. Navajivan Publishing House,
1972.
Chatterjee, M.. Gandhi’s Religious Thought. London. Macmillan. 1983.
Chatterjee, P. Nationalist Thought and the Colonial World: A Derivative
Discourse. Delhi. Oxford University Press, 1986.
Dalton, D. India’s Idea of Freedom. Gurgaon. Academic Press. 1982.
Haksar, V. “Rawls and Gandhi on Civil Disobedience”. Inquiry. 1976.
Iyer, R. N. The Moral and Political Thought of Gandhi. Bombay. Oxford
University Press, 1973.
Kolge, Nishikant and N. Sreekumar. ‘Towards a Comprehensive Understanding
of Gandhi’s Concept of Swaraj: Some Critical Thoughts on Parel’s Reading of
Swaraj.’ Research Gate. May 2010. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/
280082549_Towards_a_Comprehensive_Understanding_of_Gandhi’s_Concept
_of_ Swaraj_Some_Critical_ Thoughts_on_Parel’s_Reading_ of_Swaraj.
Pantham, T and Deutsch, K., (ed). Political Thought in Modern India. New Delhi,
Sage Publications, 1986.
Parekh, B. Gandhi’s Political Philosophy. Notre Dame. Notre Dame University
Press, 1989.
Ray, Alok Kumar. ‘Swaraj: The Gandhian Vision’. Odisha Review. August, 2015.
http://magazines.odisha.gov.in/Orissareview/2015/August/engpdf/5-9.pdf.
Rudolph, L. and Rudolph, S., The Modernity of Tradition. Chicago. University
of Chicago Press, 1967.
Shaile, Kriti. ‘Economic Ideas of Mahatma Gandhi’. Economic Discussion. n.d.
http://www.economicsdiscussion.net/articles/economic-ideas-of-mahatma-
gandhi/21133.
Sharma, Naresh Kumar. ‘Reflections on Gandhi’s Economic Ideas’. Mahatma
Gandhi. December, 2010. https://www.mkgandhi.org/articles/gandhi’s-
economic-ideas.html.
Shiya. ‘Essay on Gandhi’s Views on Swaraj’. Preserve Articles. n.d. http://
www.preservearticles.com/201106238412/gandhi-and-swaraj.html.
Woodcock, G. Mohandas Gandhi. New York. Fontana, 1971.

61