Rehmanwaheed - 3271 - 18189 - 2 - 5a. The Negotiable Instruments Act 1881
Rehmanwaheed - 3271 - 18189 - 2 - 5a. The Negotiable Instruments Act 1881
Rehmanwaheed - 3271 - 18189 - 2 - 5a. The Negotiable Instruments Act 1881
The Negotiable
Instruments Act, 1881
Rehan Waheed
1
03/03/2022
Rehan Waheed
Rehan Waheed
2
03/03/2022
3
03/03/2022
Rehan Waheed
Rehan Waheed
4
03/03/2022
Drawee The person on whom bill of exchange or cheque is drawn and who is directed
to pay the amount
Acceptor A bill of exchange (other than a cheque) must be presented to the drawee for
acceptance first, and then presented for payment on due date. Drawee
becomes acceptor when he accepts the bill duly signing it
Rehan Waheed
Rehan Waheed
5
03/03/2022
Rehan Waheed
Rehan Waheed
6
03/03/2022
Rehan Waheed
7
03/03/2022
Meaning A holder is a person who legally obtains the A holder in due course is a person who acquires the
negotiable instrument, with his name entitled on negotiable instrument bona fide for some
it, to receive the payment from the parties liable consideration, whose payment is still due
Consideration Not necessary Necessary
Right to Sue A holder may not sue all prior parties A holder in due course can sue all prior parties
Good Faith The instrument may or may not be obtained in The instrument must be obtained in good faith
good faith
Maturity A person can become holder, before or A person can become holder in due course,
after the maturity of negotiable instrument only before maturity of negotiable
instrument
Rehan Waheed
Rehan Waheed
8
03/03/2022
Rehan Waheed
Rehan Waheed
9
03/03/2022
Rehan Waheed
10
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2. Promissory Note
2.1 Definition of promissory note [Section 4]
• A “promissory note” is an instrument in writing (not being a bank note or currency note)
containing an unconditional undertaking, signed by the maker, to pay on demand or at a fixed
or determinable future time a certain sum of money only to, or to the order of, a certain
person, or to the bearer of the instrument
• The analysis of the definition shows that, a promissory note is a written and signed promise
to pay a certain sum of money to a specified person or his order
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.2 Parties to a promissory note [Section 7]
• Following are the two main parties in a promissory note:
2.2.1 Maker
• It is a person who makes the promissory note and promises to pay the money stated in it
• The maker is liable to pay according to tenor of the note and compensate any party to the
note for loss sustained because of his default
2.2.2 Payee
• It is a person to whom the amount of promissory note is payable i.e. to whom the promise to
pay is made
Rehan Waheed
11
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.3 Specimen of a promissory note
Three months after date I promise to pay Ashraf or to his order the sum of Rupees Ten Thousand, for value received
To Sign: __________
Ashraf Zahid
Jail Road Saddar
Karachi Karachi
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
• The essential elements of a promissory note are discussed below:
2.4.1 In writing [Section 4]
2.4.2 Promise to pay [Section 4]
2.4.3 Definite and unconditional [Section 4 & 5]
2.4.4 Signed by maker [Section 4]
2.4.5 Certain parties [Section 4 & 5]
2.4.6 Sum payable must be certain [Section 4 & 5]
2.4.7 Sum payable must be legal tender
Rehan Waheed
12
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.1 In writing [Section 4]
• A promissory note has to be in writing. An oral promise to pay does not become a promissory
note. The writing may be on any paper, on any book
• The words used must impart a clear undertaking to pay, but it is not necessary that the word
promise should be used
Example
• Azam signs the instruments in the following terms: “I promise to pay Babar or order Rs. 500”.
This is valid promissory note.
• Asif signs the instruments in the following terms: “I acknowledge myself to be indebted to
Basit in Rs.1,000 to be paid on demand, for value received”. This is valid promissory note.
• Adeel promise to pay Behram a sum of Rs. 500 on telephone. This promise will not make a
promissory note because it is not in writing.
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.2 Promise to pay [Section 4]
• There must be a promise or a clear undertaking to pay
• A mere acknowledgement of indebtedness is not a promissory note, although it is valid as an
agreement and may be sued upon as such
Examples
• Azam signs the instruments in following terms: “Mr. Bilal I owe you Rs. 1,000”. The instrument
is not promissory note as there is no clear undertaking or promise to pay. There is only an
acknowledgement of indebtedness.
• Asif signs the instruments in following terms: “I am liable to pay to Baqir Rs. 500”. The
instrument is not promissory note as there is no clear undertaking or promise to pay. There is
only an acknowledgement of indebtedness.
Rehan Waheed
13
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.2 Promise to pay [Section 4] (contd…)
Examples
• Adeel signs the instruments in following terms: “I have taken from Behzad Rs.2,000 and I am
accountable to him for the same with interest”. The instrument is not promissory note as
there is no clear undertaking or promise to pay. There is only an acknowledgement of
indebtedness.
• Akmal signs instrument in following terms: “I acknowledge myself to be indebted to Bano in
Rs.1,000 to be paid on demand for value received.” This is a valid promissory note.
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.3 Definite and unconditional [Section 4 & 5]
• The promise must not depend upon the happening of some uncertain event. i.e. a
contingency or the fulfilment of a condition
• If an instrument contains a conditional promise to pay, it is not a valid promissory note and
will not become valid and negotiable even after happening of the condition
Example
• Azam signs the instrument in the following terms: “I promise to pay Basit Rs.500 seven days
after my marriage with Shahzadi”. The instruments is not valid as the payment is made
dependent upon the happening of an uncertain event which may never happen and as a
result the sum may never become payable.
Rehan Waheed
14
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.3 Definite and unconditional [Section 4 & 5]
Examples
• Asif signs the instrument in the following terms: “I promise to pay Babar Rs. 500 as soon as I
can”
• The instruments is not valid as the payment is made dependent upon the happening of an
uncertain event which may never happen and as a result the sum may never become payable
• But a promise to pay is not conditional if the amount is made payable
• at a particular place or
• after a specified time or
• on the happening of an event which must happen, although the time of its happening
may be uncertain
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.3 Definite and unconditional [Section 4 & 5] (contd…)
Examples
• Ajmal signs an instrument stating “I promise to Pay Babar Rs.500 seven days after Saleem’s
death”, the promissory note is valid because it is not considered to be conditional, for it is
certain that Saleem will die one day.
• Amir signs the instrument in the following terms: “I promise to pay Bilal Rs. 500 on Dawood’s
death, provided Dawood leaves me enough to pay the sum”. The instruments is not valid as
the payment is made dependent upon the happening of an uncertain event which may never
happen and as a result the sum may never become payable.
Rehan Waheed
15
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.4 Signed by maker [Section 4]
• It is imperative that the promissory note should be duly authenticated by the signature of the
maker
• If the maker is illiterate he may place his thumb mark.
Example
• Asif writes the instrument but does not sign thereon: “I promise to pay Bilal Rs. 5,000”. The
note is not valid promissory note.
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.5 Certain parties [Section 4 & 5]
• The instrument points out with certainty as to who is the maker and who is the payee. Where
the maker and the payee cannot be identified with certainty, the instrument even if it
contains an unconditional promise to pay is not a promissory note
• Where the person intended can reasonably be ascertained from the promissory note, he is a
certain person although he may be misnamed or designated by description only
Example
• A promissory note payable to the principal of a college is regarded as payable to a certain
person. The person can be identified specifically. Hence, it will be considered a valid
promissory note.
Rehan Waheed
16
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.6 Sum payable must be certain [Section 4 & 5]
• It is essential that sum of money promised to be payable must be certain and definite. The
amount payable must not be capable of contingent addition or subtraction
Example
• Azam signs instrument in following terms: “I promise to pay Bilal Rs.500,000 and all other
sums which shall be due to him”. The instrument is invalid as promissory notes because the
amount is not certain.
Rehan Waheed
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.6 Sum payable must be certain [Section 4 & 5] (contd…)
Examples
• Amir signs an instrument in following terms: “I promise to pay Babar Rs.300,000 and all fines
according to rules”. Instrument is invalid as promissory note because amount is not certain.
• The sum payable is certain:
• when it is payable with interest (or return in any other form).; or
• When it is payable at an indicated or current rate of exchange; or
• When it is payable in instalments, with a provision that on default being made in
payment, the balance unpaid shall become due.
• A promise to pay is not ‘conditional’ nor is the sum payable ‘uncertain’ by reason of the sum
payable being subject to adjustment for profit or loss, as the case may be, of the business of
the maker.
Rehan Waheed
17
03/03/2022
Promissory Note
2.4 Essential elements of a promissory note
2.4.7 Sum payable must be legal tender
• A promise to pay a certain amount of foreign currency or to deliver a certain quantity of
goods is not a promissory note
Example
• An instrument signed by Asif, “I promise to pay Kamal Rs. 50,000 and to deliver him my black
horse” is not a valid promissory note.
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3. Bill of Exchange
3.1 Definition of bill of exchange [Section 5]
• A “bill of exchange” is an instrument in writing containing an unconditional order, signed by
the maker, directing a certain person to pay on demand or at a fixed or determinable future
time a certain sum of money only to, or to the order of, a certain person or to the bearer of
the instrument
• The analysis of the definition shows that, a bill of exchange is a written and signed order
directing a person to pay a certain sum of money to the bearer of the instrument or to a
specified person or his order
• Generally, a bill of exchange is drawn by a creditor, who directs his debtor to pay the money
to the person specified in the instrument
Rehan Waheed
18
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.2 Parties to a bill of exchange [Section 7]
3.2.1 Drawer
• It is a person who draws a bill of exchange. The drawer is liable on a bill of exchange as
principal debtor until the drawee accepts the bill
3.2.2 Drawee / Acceptor
• It is a person who is ordered to pay the amount of the bill of exchange (on whom the bill is
drawn). When drawee accepts the bill of exchange (when he gives consent to make the
payment) he is called the acceptor. The drawee is not liable until acceptance. On acceptance
he becomes liable as acceptor to pay holder on demand after maturity
3.2.3 Payee
• It is a person to whom the amount of bill of exchange is payable
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3.3 Specimen of a bill of exchange
Date: September 15, 20XX
Rs. 10,000/- only
Three months after date pay to Yaseen or to his order the sum of Rupees Ten Thousand, for value
received.
Accepted
Aslam
Rehan Waheed
19
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
• The essential elements of a bill of exchange are shown below:
3.4.1 In writing [Section 5]
3.4.2 Order to pay [Section 5]
3.4.3 Definite and unconditional [Section 5]
3.4.4 Signed by drawer and drawee [Section 5]
3.4.5 Certain parties [Section 5]
3.4.6 Sum Payable must be certain [Section 5]
3.4.7 Sum payable must be legal tender
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.1 In writing [Section 5]
• A bill of exchange is required to be in writing. Like promissory note, a bill of exchange also
cannot be oral
Example
• Azam signs the instruments in the following terms: “Pay Rs. 5,000 to Azam or order”. It is a
valid bill.
• Asif orders to Behram to pay a sum of Rs. 500 on telephone. This order will not make a bill of
exchange because it is not in writing
Rehan Waheed
20
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.2 Order to pay [Section 5]
• A bill of exchange contains an order to pay instead of a promise to pay like in promissory note
• This feature distinguishes it from promissory note. Further, a request to pay money is not
considered to be a bill of exchange
Examples
• The following instrument signed by Azam is valid bill of exchange as it contains an order to
pay, though the language used is very polite:
• “Babar, please pay Rs. 50,000 to Ehsaan or order.”
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.2 Order to pay [Section 5] (contd…)
Examples
• The following instrument signed by Adeel is valid bill of exchange as it contains an order to
pay, though the language used is very polite:
• “Bilal will much oblige me by paying to Dawood Rs. 30,000.”
• The following instrument signed by Akbar is not valid bill of exchange as it contains only a
request to pay and no order to pay:
• “Babar, please let Jazib have Rs. 50,000, and place it to my account and oblige.”
• The following instrument signed by Asif is not valid bill of exchange as it contains only a
request to pay and no order to pay:
• “Bushra, I shall be highly obliged if you make it convenient to pay Rs.10,000 to Ghalib.”
Rehan Waheed
21
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.3 Definite and unconditional [Section 5]
• The order to pay should not depend upon a condition or upon the happening of an uncertain
event
Example
• Asif draws a bill on Behram as “Pay Rs. 5,000 to Saleem as early as possible”.
• It is not a valid bill of exchange on account of uncertainty.
• But an order to pay is not conditional if the amount is made payable
• at a particular place or
• after a specified time or
• on the happening of an event which must happen, although the time of its happening
may be uncertain
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.4 Signed by drawer and drawee [Section 5]
• The instrument must be signed by the maker i.e. drawer and subsequently by drawee (for
acceptance)
Example
• Asif draws a bill on Behram as “Pay Rs. 10,000 to Saleem or order” but does not sign it.
• It is not a valid bill of exchange.
Rehan Waheed
22
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.5 Certain parties [Section 5]
• All the parties must be certain i.e. indicated in a bill of exchange with reasonable certainty
• Where the person intended can reasonably be ascertained from the bill of exchange, he is a
certain person although he may be misnamed or designated by description only
Example
• Asif draws a bill as “Pay Rs. 10,000 to Jameel or order” but does not specify the name of
drawee.
• It is not a valid bill of exchange.
• Where the payee is fictitious or non-existing person, the bill of exchange may be treated as
payable to bearer.
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.6 Sum Payable must be certain [Section 5]
• It is essential that sum of money ordered to be payable must be certain and definite. The
amount payable must not be capable of contingent addition or subtraction
Example
• Majeed draws a bill on Naveed as “Pay to Saeed Rs. 20,000 and all other sums due to him”. It is not a
valid bill.
• The sum payable is certain:
• when it is payable with interest (or return in any other form).; or
• When it is payable at an indicated or current rate of exchange; or
• When it is payable in instalments, with a provision that on default being made in payment, the balance unpaid
shall become due.
• An order to pay is not ‘conditional’ nor is the sum payable ‘uncertain’ by reason of the sum payable
being subject to adjustment for profit or loss, as the case may be, of the business of the maker.
Rehan Waheed
23
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.4 Essential elements of a bill of exchange
3.4.7 Sum payable must be legal tender
• If the instrument contains an order to pay something other than money or something in
addition to money, it will not be valid bill of exchange
Example
• Azam draws a bill on Babar as “Pay Rs. 50,000 and deliver 100 bags of wheat to Saleem”. It is
not a valid bill.
Rehan Waheed
Bill of Exchange
3.5 Difference between promissory note and bill of exchange
Rehan Waheed
24
03/03/2022
Bill of Exchange
3.5 Difference between promissory note and bill of exchange (contd…)
Difference Promissory Note Bill of Exchange
Nature of The liability of the maker of a The liability of a drawer of a bill of exchange
Liability promissory note is primary and is secondary and conditional. It is only when
absolute the acceptor does not honour the bill that
the liability of the drawer arises as a surety
Maker’s Position The maker of a promissory note stands The drawer of an accepted bill stands in
in immediate relation with the payee immediate relation with the acceptor and
not the payee
Payable to A promissory note cannot be drawn A bill of exchange can be so drawn provided
Bearer “payable to bearer” that it is not drawn “payable to bearer on
demand”
Notice of In case of dishonour of a promissory In case of dishonour of a bill of exchange,
Dishonor note, no notice of dishonour is required notice of dishonour must be given by the
to be given to the maker “holder” to all prior parties who are liable to
pay (including the drawer and endorser)
Rehan Waheed
Cheque
4. Cheque
4.1 Definition of Cheque [Section 6]
• Cheque is a bill of exchange drawn on a specified banker and not expressed to be payable
otherwise than on demand
• The analysis of the above definition reveals that a cheque is a bill of exchange but is different
in following two characteristics:
• Drawee will always be a banker
• Always payable on demand
Rehan Waheed
25
03/03/2022
Cheque
1.2 Parties to a cheque [Section 7 & 3(b)]
• Following are the three main parties in a cheque:
1.2.1 Drawer
• It is a person who draws a cheque i.e. the customer/ account-holder of a bank
1.2.2 Drawee
• It is a banker who is ordered to pay the amount of the cheque.
• “Banker” means a person transacting the business of accepting, for the purpose of lending or
investment, or deposits of money from the public, repayable on demand or otherwise and
withdrawable by cheque, draft, order or otherwise, and includes any Post Office Savings Bank
1.2.3 Payee
• It is a person to whom the amount of cheque is payable
Rehan Waheed
Cheque
1.3 Specimen of a cheque
Rehan Waheed
26
03/03/2022
Cheque
1.4 Essential elements of a cheque [Section 5 & 6]
• It must be in writing
• There must be an express order to pay and not a request to pay
• The order must be definite and unconditional
• It must be signed by the drawer
• The three parties (drawer, drawee and payee) must be certain
• The order must be to pay a certain sum
• The order must be to pay money only
• It must always be drawn upon a specified banker
• It must always be payable on demand
Example
• Adeel draws a bearer cheque on 1st July 2020. It is valid for six months. Holder of cheque may get cash
by demanding payment over the counter of the banker on whom the cheque is drawn during this time
Rehan Waheed
Cheque
1.5 Cheque not operating as assignment of funds [Section 131C]
• A cheque, of itself, does not operate as an assignment of any part of the funds to the credit of
the drawer with the banker
Example
• Adeel draws a cheque of Rs. 5 million in favour of Kashif on 1st July 2021. Kashif does not
become entitled to Rs. 5 million that are in the account of Adeel at bank on just receiving this
cheque. He must deposit the cheque in his account and when bank transfers the amount to
his credit, he will become entitled to those Rs. 5 million
Rehan Waheed
27
03/03/2022
Cheque
1.6 Difference between cheque and bill of exchange
Difference Cheque Bill of Exchange
Drawee Cheque is always drawn on a banker Bill may be drawn on any person, including a banker
Payable on A cheque can only be drawn payable A bill may be drawn payable on demand or on the
Demand on demand expiry of a certain period after date or sight
Payable to A cheque drawn “payable to bearer A bill drawn “payable to bearer on demand” is
bearer on on demand” is valid absolutely void (though can be made payable to the
Demand bearer later by endorsement in blank)
Acceptance A cheque does not require any A bill requires acceptance by the drawee before he
acceptance by the drawee can be made liable upon it
Stamp A cheque does not require any stamp A bill of exchange must be properly stamped
Crossing A cheque may be crossed for the A bill of exchange cannot be crossed
purpose of safety
Stop The payment of a cheque may be The payment of a bill cannot be countermanded by
Payment countermanded by the drawer the drawer
Rehan Waheed
Crossing of Cheque
2. Crossing of Cheque
2.1 Purpose of crossing
• A cheque is said to be crossed when it bears across its face two parallel transverse lines which
are usually drawn on the left hand top corner of the cheque
• It is an instance of an alteration which is authorised by the Act
• A crossing is a direction to the paying banker not to pay across the counter
• The purpose of crossing is to direct the drawee (banker) to pay the amount of the cheque
only to a banker so that the party who receives the payment can easily be traced
Rehan Waheed
28
03/03/2022
Crossing of Cheque
2.2 Types of crossing
2.2.1 General crossing [Section 123]
• A cheque is said to be crossed generally where it bears across its face an addition of the words
“and company” or any abbreviation of it between two parallel transverse lines, or of two
parallel transverse lines simply
Effect of general crossing [Section 126]
• When a cheque is crossed generally the banker on whom it is drawn shall not pay it otherwise
than to a banker
Rehan Waheed
Crossing of Cheque
2.2 Types of crossing
2.2.2 Special crossing [Section 124]
• A cheque is said to be crossed especially where it bears across its face an addition of:
• Name of the banker
• Parallel lines are not necessary
Effect of special crossing [Section 126]
• When a cheque is crossed specifically the banker on whom it is drawn shall not pay it
otherwise than to a banker to whom it is crossed or his agent for collection
Rehan Waheed
29
03/03/2022
Crossing of Cheque
2.2 Types of crossing
2.2.3 Restrictive crossing [Section 123A]
• Restrictive crossing may be added with general crossing by adding the words “A/c Payee” or
“A/c Payee only”
Effect of restrictive crossing
• Where a cheque is crossed as “account payee”, it shall cease to be negotiable
• Strictly speaking, the amount collected on the cheque must be credited only to the account
of payee named in the cheque
Example
• Kamran provided some services to Ikram. Ikram paid him by cheque drawn on ABC Bank with “Account
payee only” crossing. Kamran has only one bank account in XYZ Bank. Kamran will deposit the cheque
in his account with XYZ Bank. XYZ Bank (as collecting banker) shall get clearing of cheque from ABC
Bank (paying banker). XYZ Bank shall credit the amount in account of Kamran from where Kamran may
transfer or withdraw the amount
Rehan Waheed
Crossing of Cheque
2.2 Types of crossing
2.2.4 ‘Not negotiable’ crossing [Section 130]
• The addition of the words not negotiable does not restrict further transferability of cheque
• It only takes away the main feature of negotiability, which is transferability free from defects
• Effect of ‘not negotiable’ crossing
• The effect of the words ‘not negotiable’ on a crossed cheque is that the title of the transferee
of such a cheque cannot be better than that of its transferor
• Therefore, a holder with a defective title cannot give a good title to a subsequent holder
• The object of crossing a cheque not negotiable is to afford protection to the drawer or holder
of the cheque against miscarriage or dishonesty in the course of transit by making it difficult
for the cheque so crossed cashed, until it reaches its destination
Rehan Waheed
30
03/03/2022
Crossing of Cheque
2.3 Crossing of a cheque after issue [Section 125 & 125A]
• A crossing authorised by the Act is a material part of the cheque. It means that it is unlawful
for any person to obliterate, add or alter the crossing except as authorised under the Act.
• A cheque may be crossed after its issue in the following manner
Case Right to Cross
Where a cheque is uncrossed The holder may cross it generally or specially
Where a cheque is crossed generally The holder may cross it specially by adding the name
of the banker
Where a cheque is crossed generally or specially The holder may add the word “Not negotiable”
Where a cheque is crossed specially The banker to whom it is crossed may again cross it
especially to another banker (his agent) for collection
Rehan Waheed
Payment of Cheque
3. PAYMENT OF CHEQUE
3.1 Payment of cheque crossed specially more than once [Section 127]
• Where the cheque is crossed specially to more than one banker, except when crossed to an
agent for collection, the banker to whom it is drawn shall refuse payment thereof
Examples
• Azam drawn a cheque on ABC Bank in favour of Babar. Azam had crossed cheque specially
twice mentioning the name of XYZ Bank and KLM Bank. ABC Bank must refuse the payment
of such cheque.
• Jazib drawn a cheque on ABC Bank in favour of Ghalib. He crossed cheque specially
mentioning the name of XYZ Bank. XYZ Bank crossed it specially again in favour of KLM
Bank, who shall collect the amount from ABC Bank as agent of XYZ Bank. ABC Bank shall not
refuse payment of the cheque.
Rehan Waheed
31
03/03/2022
Payment of Cheque
3.2 Payment of crossed cheque in due course [Section 128]
• Where the banker, on whom a cross cheque is drawn, makes a payment in due course, the
paying banker and the drawer are entitled to be positioned as if the cheque had been paid to
and received by the true owner thereof
Example
• Kashif gave a cheque drawn on ABC Bank of Rs. 10,000 to Munawar with ‘account payee’
crossing. Another person named Munawar (having account in XYZ Bank) stole the cheque
and presented for credit to his account. ABC Bank paid the amount in due course to XYZ
Bank. XYZ Bank credited the amount to the credit of (fake) Munawar, who then withdrew the
amount from his account. ABC Bank (as paying banker) and Kashif shall be entitled to be
positioned as if the cheque had been paid to true owner (the real Munawar).
Rehan Waheed
Payment of Cheque
3.3 Payment of crossed cheque out of due course [Section 129]
• Where the banker, on whom a cross cheque is drawn, makes a payment out of due course,
the paying banker shall be liable to the true owner of the cheque for any loss he may sustain
owing to the cheque having been so paid
Examples
• Adeel gave a cheque drawn on KLM Bank of Rs. 10,000 to Kumail with general crossing. The cheque was stolen by
Kamil and he presented the cheque on counter of KLM Bank for payment. KLM Bank paid the amount over the
counter. This is payment out of due course as the cheque was not payable to bearer. KLM Bank is liable to Kumail for
the loss.
• However, a paying banker shall not be responsible if it pays the cheque in good faith and without negligence where a
cheque is presented for payment which does not appear to be crossed or have had crossing which has been
obliterated or altered.
• Adeel gave a cheque drawn on KLM Bank of Rs. 10,000 to Kumail with “account payee” crossing. The cheque was
stolen by Kamil who concealed the crossing in such a way that the cheque appeared to have never been crossed.
Kamil presented the cheque on counter of KLM Bank for payment. KLM Bank paid the amount over the counter.
KLM Bank is not liable in this case.
Rehan Waheed
32
03/03/2022
Payment of Cheque
3.4 Protection to the banker in case of defective title [Section 131]
• A collecting/receiving banker is one who receives the payment of a crossed cheque on behalf
of his customer
• If the collecting banker has collected a cheque on behalf of a person whose title to the cheque
was defective, the collecting banker would be protected and would not be held liable in
conversion to the true owner, provided it proves that it acted in good faith and without
negligence
Examples
• Kashif gave a cheque drawn on ABC Bank of Rs. 10,000 to Munawar with ‘account payee’ crossing. Another person
named Munawar (having account in XYZ Bank) stole the cheque and presented for credit to his account. Then, XYZ
Bank sent the cheque for collection to ABC Bank. ABC Bank paid the amount in due course to XYZ Bank. XYZ Bank
credited the amount to the credit of (fake) Munawar in good faith and without negligence, who then withdrew the
amount from his account. XYZ Bank shall be protected and would not be held liable to true owner (the real
Munawar).
• This protection to the receiving banker is available even if it credits customer’s account with the amount of the
cheque before receiving payment thereof.
Rehan Waheed
Payment of Cheque
3.4 Protection to the banker in case of defective title [Section 131] (contd…)
Examples
• Kashif gave a cheque drawn on ABC Bank of Rs. 10,000 to Munawar with ‘account payee’
crossing. Another person named Munawar (having account in XYZ Bank) stole the cheque
and presented for credit to his account. XYZ Bank credited the amount to the credit of (fake)
Munawar in good faith and without negligence, who then withdrew the amount from his
account. Then, XYZ Bank sent the cheque for collection to ABC Bank. ABC Bank paid the
amount in due course to XYZ Bank. XYZ Bank shall be protected and would not be held liable
to true owner (the real Munawar).
Rehan Waheed
33
03/03/2022
Payment of Cheque
3.5 Protection to the banker crediting cheque crossed ‘account payee’ [Section 131B]
• Similarly, if the collecting banker has collected a cheque which does not at the time of
delivery appear to be crossed “account payee” or to have had a crossing “account payee”
which has been obliterated or altered, the banker, in good faith and without negligence
collecting payment of the cheque and crediting proceeds thereof to a customer, shall not
incur any liability by reason of the cheque having been so crossed
Example
• Adeel gave a cheque drawn on KLM Bank of Rs. 10,000 to Kumail with “account payee”
crossing. The cheque was stolen by Kamil who concealed the “account payee” crossing in
such a way that the cheque appeared to have crossed generally only. Kamil presented the
cheque for credit to his account at XYZ Bank. XYZ Bank collected payment from KLM Bank
and (in good faith and without negligence) credited to Kamil’s account who then withdrew
the amount. XYZ Bank shall not incur any liability.
Rehan Waheed
Payment of Cheque
3.6 Revocation of banker’s authority [Section 122A]
• The duty and authority of a banker to pay a cheque drawn on him by his customer are
determined by:
• Countermand of payment;
• Notice of customer’s death;
• Notice of adjudication of the customer as an insolvent
Examples
• Anum drawn a bearer cheque on her banker but lost it before encashment. She informed the banker immediately
the cheque number and details. Someone found that bearer cheque and is demanding the payment. The banker
must refuse.
• A customer died on 16th March. His legal representative informed the banker of his death on 26th March day-end.
The banker must refuse to honour cheques from 27th March. However, the banker is not liable if any payment of
cheque was made from 16th March to 26th March.
• Abid had account in PQR Bank. Abid was adjudicated as insolvent on 9th February and it was communicated to PQR
Bank on 10th February. PQR bank must refuse the payment of cheques from account of Abid from 10th February.
Rehan Waheed
34
03/03/2022
Payment of Cheque
3.7 Rules applicable to bank draft [Section 131A]
• Rules relating to payment of cheque are also relevant to bank draft as if draft were a cheque
• A bank draft is an order issued by one bank on another bank or on its own branch instructing
it to pay a specified sum of money to a specified person or his order. A bank draft is an
instrument similar to cheque with following distinctions:
• It can be drawn only by a bank on another bank or on its own branch and not by an
individual as in the case of a cheque
• It cannot be made payable to bearer
• Its payment cannot be stopped as easily as that of a cheque
Rehan Waheed
Payment of Cheque
3.7 Rules applicable to bank draft [Section 131A] (contd…)
Example
• Adeel made a deal to buy a plot of land, the seller required payment by bank draft. Adeel
went to his banker and applied for a bank draft and provided details. The banker transferred
the relevant amount from Adeel’s account and transferred it to Bank’s name and issued the
bank draft to Adeel in the name of seller and particulars of Adeel were also mentioned on it.
Adeel gave this bank draft to seller in consideration of transfer of plot in his name. The seller
will deposit the bank draft in his account and his account will be credited with the amount.
The payment is more secure for seller because bank draft cannot be dishonoured like a
cheque due to insufficient fund in the account
Rehan Waheed
35
03/03/2022
Questions
&
Discussions
Best of luck!
36