Building Surveys and Technical Due Diligence of Commercial Property 2010 1
Building Surveys and Technical Due Diligence of Commercial Property 2010 1
Building Surveys and Technical Due Diligence of Commercial Property 2010 1
The fourth edition of this guidance note aims to provide surveyors with
Building surveys and technical due
information and guidance in respect of commercial property surveys.
It covers:
diligence of commercial property
• taking instructions; 4th edition, guidance note
• survey preparation;
• inspection; and
• reporting.
Also included are appendices comprising:
• a summary of insurance issues;
• a summary of legal issues; and
• useful sources of information and further reading.
rics.org/standards rics.org/standards
Building surveys and technical due diligence
of commercial property
Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) November 2010. Copyright in all or part of this publication rests with RICS, and save by prior
consent of RICS, no part or parts shall be reproduced by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, now known or to be
devised.
A Insurance 26
Working group
Ian Bragg, BSc MRICS, GVA Grimley Ltd
Laura Brazil, RICS
Alex Charlesworth, BSc (Hons) MRICS, Cushman & Wakefield LLP
Nevin Hutchinson, BSc (Hons) MRICS, King Sturge LLP
David Mann (Chair), BSc (Hons) MRICS, Tuffin Ferraby Taylor LLP
Trevor Rushton, FRICS ACIArb FBEng, Watts Group plc
The working group expresses its thanks in particular to the following contributors:
Pat Coleman, Faber Maunsell | AECOM
Michael Earp, FINEX Global, Willis Limited
Jason Juden, SJ Berwin LLP
Glyn Thomas, Land Securities Properties Ltd
+ precisely who the surveyor/surveying company + an agreement with the client on the level of
is; reliance (i.e. assignment); and
+ what is not being provided (e.g. a valuation); + depth of document review the surveyor is to
carry out.
+ the detailed limitations on the scope of the
survey and report; The surveyor may consider capping the time spent
reviewing the documentation and reserve the right
+ the date of the instruction;
to charge additional fees. For example, the
+ involvement of other consultants or contractors documents may be held at a different location, or
and the extent of their appointment (e.g. on the surveyor may be required to locate relevant
behalf of the client); documents among boxes of associated property
+ the timescales for completing the instruction information.
and any intermediate stages;
It is important to make the client aware of the
+ what the fee will be; practical limitations of any inspection or survey
+ how variations to the instruction will be exercise. In any building, but particularly large
assessed; buildings or complexes of buildings, there are
literally hundreds of items that may need to be
+ specialist access required, access restrictions
checked. Many of them will be hidden and/or
and health and safety;
inaccessible. Repetitive items (such as windows)
+ how the fee will be claimed/become payable will normally only be checked on a sample basis.
and the charges for late payment; However, a client will reasonably expect that all
+ how the fee will be calculated if the instructions major defects (or potential major defects) and
are aborted early; issues would be addressed.
+ whether disbursements are included or not, in In addition to what the surveyor considers to be a
particular where access hoists are required; priority for the specific exercise being undertaken,
The importance of precisely identifying the areas to The surveyor may benefit from knowing if the
be covered within the survey should not be premises, or parts thereof, are vacant. It is also
The surveyor ought to ensure that all PII conditions + Clients require a consistent level of service in
have been met in all circumstances. The surveyor both the UK and Europe. Surveyors should only
may insert a copy of the consultant’s report into his accept instructions if these can be adequately
or her own report within the appendices, but it resourced and standards maintained.
must not be altered. Salient issues may be + Surveyors should assess each instruction and
extracted and used in the surveyor’s report, though establish whether limited local knowledge will
the source should be quoted and whether it was a be a barrier.
4.3.1 Roofs
4.3.3 Walls and cladding
The surveyor should inspect external roof areas as
closely as is feasible using the available equipment The exposed elements of all walls should be
and from safe vantage points. The interior of visually inspected externally and internally where
accessible roof voids or the ceiling void of the top unobstructed by heavy plant growth, fixed linings or
floor should also be inspected as far as possible furniture. Flues and wall cavities cannot ordinarily
with the equipment and access available. be inspected except from pre-formed access
Inaccessible voids can be noted and an opinion points. Foundations are not normally exposed
given by inference, with recommendations for during a building survey, unless there is a specific
further investigations if appropriate. reason or instruction to do so. An assessment of
the foundation is then usually undertaken by a
Timbers or steelwork should be checked for structural engineer.
damage and/or deterioration, alignment, etc. The
type and quantity of insulation provided should be The effectiveness of damp-proof courses, cills,
determined wherever possible. The condition of the copings, cornices, brise soleil, flashings and similar
external surface, weathering details, poor components require attention to confirm their
workmanship and/or detailing, and an assessment protection against dampness and weather
of its age and life expectancy should be noted, conditions. External cladding should be inspected
along with the presence of fragile roof coverings for degradation, movement, cold bridging, defective
and asbestos cement sheeting. Subject to the sealants and coatings, fire stopping, cracking or
findings of the survey, further testing such as corrosion.
thermography or earth leakage testing may be The surveyor should comment on the condition,
deemed appropriate. Any recommendations for a extent and type of insulation where possible.
proposed renewal should ensure compliance with Composite panel construction should be
current Building Regulations. highlighted to the client, and advice from the
Rainwater goods may be considered as integral to client’s insurers may be required. Evidence of
the roof, or as a separate heading (see 4.3.2), as alterations or repairs can be noted and reviewed for
can elements such as roof windows, smoke vents, legal or structural implications.
services extracts, parapets, flashings, fascias, Subject to the findings of the investigation, it may
soffits and barge boards. Depending on their size be necessary to undertake invasive examination,
and form of construction, each roof requires e.g. opening up the structure or using an
individual inspection but may be reported upon endoscope. This is over and above the scope of a
separately, in groups or as a whole. Balconies, roof normal survey, with a further visit and additional
terraces and external plant areas may also be cost being incurred, subject to the client and
considered separately or as part of the roof. building owner’s approval.
The need for specialist cladding or fenestration
4.3.2 Rainwater goods consultants should be considered and suitable
Rainwater goods should be inspected as closely as recommendations made for their appointment
practicable using the available equipment and where appropriate.
Under normal circumstances, the surveyor would 4.6 Health and safety considerations
not be expected to carry out a detailed assessment
of the building services, as most of these would The surveyor should be aware of relevant legislation
require a specialist. However, the surveyor should that might affect general health and safety within
perform a visual appraisal of the services sufficient the building. Detailed compliance checking and
to form an overall opinion of the apparent visible auditing, or the preparation of risk assessments,
condition and age and the need for further are beyond the scope of a normal building
investigation. A disclaimer stating that only a inspection; however, it may help to give a qualified
building surveyor’s visual inspection has been opinion on the most obvious points, such as:
undertaken ought to be included in the surveyor’s + slips, trips and fall hazards;
report. Specialist engineers will provide a more + low head heights;
detailed report on the condition of the services, and + overloading, including crowd loading
recommendations for their appointment can be requirements (e.g. stadiums);
given when appropriate.
+ instability;
4.5 External areas, outbuildings and + demolition hazards, presence of potential
asbestos containing materials (ACMs);
boundaries
+ maintenance and other safe access issues;
The surveyor should aim to inspect any available 4.9 Environmental consideration
fire risk assessments and statutory approvals,
particularly when alterations have been made. Any
discrepancies with the fire certificate or non- 4.9.1 Orientation and exposure
compliance with fire safety regulations, building The surveyor should consider the orientation of the
regulations and the Fire Precautions Act 1971 building to identify the possible effects of exposure
should be noted. Consideration of fire precautions to the prevailing winds or sunlight, as these could
falls into three main categories: affect the performance and durability of the fabric
+ fire resistance, separation, smoke ventilation of a building. Exposure to other factors, such as
and compartmentation; salt spray in a coastal location or industrial
+ means of escape, escape routes, signage and pollution, may also have a profound influence on
emergency lighting; and the life or performance of the fabric and should be
identified where particular risks exist.
+ protection including detection, alarms,
sprinklers and extinguishers.
4.9.2 Thermal insulation and energy
Where specialist and/or proprietary systems of fire
efficiency
protection are used, the surveyor should consider
whether to recommend specialist advice, especially The surveyor should describe the thermal shell of
if inadequacies are noted. In complex buildings the building including external walls, windows,
such as shopping centres or sports stadiums, it roofs, exposed floors and ground floors, and take
may be necessary to involve a fire engineer to into consideration the layout, location and
comment fully. The fire log or records of the regular orientation of the property. The nature of the
testing and servicing of fire alarms, emergency heating and cooling systems and controls should
lighting, fire extinguishers, sprinklers, smoke vents, be considered and recommendations made in
fire curtains or shutters, etc., can also be reviewed. conjunction with a services engineer (if appointed)
Testing does not usually form part of a standard for suitable improvements. The surveyor should
building survey unless requested by the client. provide advice on practical and relevant methods
of upgrading insulation, and on measures to reduce
4.8 Accessibility any associated risk of condensation.
The Disability Discrimination Act 1995 and 2005 4.9.3 Noise and disturbance
duties have been incorporated into the Equality Act
It is worth considering the effect of noise from
2010, which came into force on 1 October 2010.
external sources on activities within the subject
This aims to protect aims to protect disabled
property and its grounds. Noise (e.g. from aircraft,
people from discrimination in all aspects of
rail, traffic, adjoining properties and other sources)
everyday life, particularly in employment, access to
can be noted if it is significant at the time of
good and services, and buying, letting and
inspection or could, from inspection, reasonably be
managing premises. In addition, as part of any
anticipated. The sound insulation qualities of party
development work, Part M of the Building
structures may also need to be considered.
Regulations requires reasonable provision to be
made for people to gain access to, and use, the Provisions and facilities that could cause occupier
building and its facilities. annoyance, e.g. heat rejection fans, should be
In determining the limitation of the inspection, the + Low: management by routine procedures.
surveyor should bear in mind the final report, which Risk management can be qualitative and/or
aims to inform the client inter alia of the following: quantitative, enabling the client to better identify,
+ what, if anything, is wrong; analyse, monitor, report on and respond to risks.
For technical due diligence, this can assist in
+ why it is wrong;
determining what responses the surveyor should
+ what damage has occurred; recommend to the client and which risks to avoid,
+ how serious this is; transfer, mitigate or accept. Such decisions are
+ what is needed to put it right; linked to the future management of the building.
+ how much this is likely to cost;
5.2 Report layout
+ when the remedial work should be carried out;
+ who is responsible for rectification works; and An executive summary of principal considerations
+ what further action is to be taken by the client. is often provided at the start of the report. The
main body includes a description, with comments
on the condition of all building elements, plus any
5.1.1 Time frame
findings, a conclusion and recommendations.
It is generally accepted in the property industry that Photographs and/or plans may be required and
time periods are identified as follows: supporting specialist reports would normally be
+ Immediate: within one year appended to the report. Section 5.3 includes a
typical list of main headings included in the
+ Short term: one to two years
contents page, with commentary. Different types of
+ Medium term: three to five years survey and individual surveyors may give rise to
+ Long term: six to ten years. deviations from the suggested list.
The fourth edition of this guidance note aims to provide surveyors with
Building surveys and technical due
information and guidance in respect of commercial property surveys.
It covers:
diligence of commercial property
• taking instructions; 4th edition, guidance note
• survey preparation;
• inspection; and
• reporting.
Also included are appendices comprising:
• a summary of insurance issues;
• a summary of legal issues; and
• useful sources of information and further reading.
rics.org/standards rics.org/standards