Teaching Listening
Teaching Listening
makes for ease in comprehension, but the presence of more performance variables and
other hesitations can either help or hinder comprehension.
Dialogues involve two or more speakers and can be subdivided in those exchanges that
promote social interaction (interpersonal) and those for which the purpose is to convey
propositional or factual information (transactional). In each case, participants may have a
good deal of shared knowledge (background info); therefore the familiarity of the interlocu-
tors will produce conversations with more assumptions, implications, and other meaning
hidden between the lines. In conversations among participants who are unfamiliar to each
other, references and meanings have to be made more explicit to assure effective compre-
hension. When such references are not explicit, misunderstandings can easily follow.
These categories are not discrete or mutually exclusive, but rather a continuum of possibil -
ities.
What makes listening difficult?
Whenever designing lessons, a number of characteristics of spoken lge need to be taken
into consideration:
o Clustering: in spoken lge, we break down speech into smaller groups
of words.
o Redundancy: rephrasing, repetitions, elaborations, etc. Such
redundancy helps the hearer to process meaning by offering more time and extra informa-
tion. Learners need to be aware that not every new sentence or phrase will necessarily
contain new information.
o Reduced forms: Reduction can be phonological, morphological, syntactic or pragmatic.
These reductions usually pose significant difficulties for language learners.
o Performance variables: in spoken language, except for planned discourse, hesitations,
false starts, pauses and corrections are common.
o Colloquial language: idioms, slang, reduced forms and shared cultural knowledge are all
manifested at some point in conversation.
o Rate of delivery: it is common for language learners to think that native speakers speak
too fast.
o Stress, rhythm and intonation: the prosodic features of English lge are very important for
comprehension. Intonations patterns are very significant, not just for interpreting straight-
forward elements such as questions, statements, and emphasis but for understanding
more subtle messages like sarcasm, endearment, insult, solicitation, praise, etc.
o Interaction: conversation is especially subject to all the rules of interaction. So, to learn to
listen is also to learn to respond and to continue a chain of listening and responding. Stu -
dents need to understand that good listeners are good responders.
Microskills and Macroskills of Listening
Brown distinguishes microskills from macroskills in listening. The former pertain to skills at
the sentence level and the latter to skills at the discourse level.
Microskills
1. Retain chunks of lge of different lengths in short-term memory
2. Discriminate among the distinctive sounds of English
3. Recognize English stress patterns, words in stressed and
unstressed positions, rhythmic structure, intonational contours,
and their role in signaling info.
4. Recognize reduced forms of words
5. Distinguish word boundaries, recognize a core of words, and
interpret word order patterns and their significance
6. Process speech at different rates of delivery
7. Process speech containing pauses and errors
8. Recognize grammatical word classes, systems, patterns and rules
9. Detect sentence constituents and distinguish between major and
minor ones.
10. Recognize that a same meaning may be expressed in different
grammatical forms.
Macroskills
11. Recognize cohesive devices in spoken discourse
12. Recognize communicative functions of utterances
13. Infer situations, participants and goals using real-world
knowledge
14. Infer links and connections between events
15. Distinguish between literal and implied meanings
16. Use non-verbal clues to decipher meanings (facial, kinesic, body
lge)
17. Develop and use listening strategies such as detecting key
words, appealing for help, etc.
Types of classroom listening performance
1. 2.
3.
4.
5.
Reactive: It requires little meaningful processing. About the only role that reactive listening
can play in an interactive classroom is on brief choral or individual drills that focus on pro-
nunciation.
Intensive: Techniques whose only purpose is to focus on components (phonemes, words,
intonations, discourse markers, etc.). Students are asked to single out certain components
of spoken language.
Responsive: Activities that consist of short stretches of teacher language designed to elicit
immediate responses (asking questions, giving commands, seeking clarification, checking
comprehension, etc.)
Selective: The task of the students is to scan the material selectively for certain info, such
as ask Ss to listen for people’s names, dates, certain facts or events, locations, situations,
context, main ideas and/or conclusion, etc.
Extensive: These tasks aim to develop a top-down, global understanding of spoken lan-
guage (listening to lengthy structures, conversations etc., and deriving a comprehensive
message or purpose). Extensive listening may require students to invoke other interactive
skills (note taking, discussions, etc.) for full comprehension.
6. Interactive: This one include all five of the above types as learners actively participate
in discussions, debates, conversations, role plays and other pair and group work.
Principles for teaching listening skills
1. 2.
3. 4.
Include a focus on listening on an integrated-skill course
Use techniques that are intrinsically motivating: Take into full account the experiences,
goals and abilities of your students
Utilize authentic language and contexts
Carefully consider the form of the listeners’ responses: Lund (1990) offered nine different
ways that we can check listeners’ comprehension:
*doing: the L (listener) responds physically to a command *choosing: the L selects from al-
ternatives such as pictures, objects and texts
*transferring: the L draws a picture of what is heard
*answering: the L answers questions about the message *condensing: the L outlines or
takes notes on a lecture. *extending: The L provides an ending to a story heard *duplicat -
ing: the L translates the message into the native lge. *modeling: the L orders a meal, for
example, after listening to a model order
*conversing: the L engages in a conv that indicates appropriate processing info.
5. Encourage the development of listening strategies. Draw their attention to the values of
strategies such as looking for key words, looking for non-verbal cues to meaning, predict -
ing a speaker’s purpose by the context, associating info with one’s existing cognitive struc-
ture, guessing meanings, seeking clarification, listening for the general gist, etc.
6. Include bottom-up and top-down listening techniques. Bottom-up processing proceeds
from sounds to words to grammatical relationships to lexical meanings, etc., to a “final”
message. Top-down processing is evoked from a “bank of prior knowledge and global ex-
pectations and other background info that the listener brings to the text”. Bottom-up tech-
niques usually
Condensing
Write close-captio n text
Extending
Duplicating
Modeling
Conversing
Second ad in campaign
------------------ Transcrib - e the text
Create own ad
“Talk back” to the ad
He suggests that this matrix be used to design instructions so that the full range of com-
petencies in listening is practiced. The sample tasks given for purposes of illustration all
relate to listening to an authentic text type: radio advertisements.
Each function presents a potential goal of listening comprehension:
·
·
·
·
·
·
Identification: recognition or discrimination of aspects of the message rather than attention
to the overall message content. (words, words categories, phonemic distinctions, etc.)
Orientation: identification of important facts about the test, such as the participants, the sit-
uation, the general topic, the tone, the text type, and the like.
Main idea comprehension: understanding of the higher-order ideas in the listening pas-
sage.
Detail comprehension: understanding of more specific information
Full comprehension: understanding of both the main ideas and supportive detail. Lund
maintains that this level of comprehension is the goal of instruction in listening proficiency.
Replication: ability to reproduce the message in either the same modality or in a different
one.
The six listener functions were defined before.
Lud maintains that growth in listening proficiency can be understood in terms of progress -
ing through these listening functions, learning to do new functions with familiar texts or per-
forming lower-level functions with more difficult texts.
linguistics forms. Learners are thus free from keeping language in a controlled
mode and can more easily proceed to automatic modes of processing.
2) Intrinsicmotivation:Asstudentsbecomeengagedwitheachotherin
speech acts, their deepest drives are satisfied. And as they more fully appreciate their own
competence to use language, they can develop a system of self-reward.
3) Strategicinvestment:Interactionrequirestheuseofstrategiclanguage competence both to
make certain decisions on how to interpret language and to make repairs when communi-
cation pathways are blocked. The spontaneity of interactive discourse requires judicious
use of numerous strategies for production and comprehension.
4) Willingnesstocommunicate:Interactionrequiresthisattitudeonpartofthe learner, which fur-
ther implies the risk of failing to produce intended meaning, of failing to interpret it, of being
laughed at or rejected. However, the rewards are great and worth the risk.
5) Thelanguage-cultureconnection:Theculturalloadingofinteractivespeech and writing re-
quires that interlocutors be thoroughly versed in the cultural nuances of language.
6) Interlanguage:Thecomplexityofinteractionentailsalongdevelopmental process of acquisi-
tion. Numerous errors of production will be part of this development and the role of the
teacher’s feedback is fundamental to it.
7) Communicativecompetence:Allofitselements(grammatical,discourse, sociolinguistic,
pragmatic and strategic) are involved in human interaction. All aspects must work together
for successful communication to take place.
Roles
An interactive teacher is by definition one who is fully aware of the group dynamics of a
classroom. Effective interaction within the dynamics of a classroom is a gradual incremen-
tal process.According to Vygotsky, effective learning in students’ “zones of proximal devel-
opment” involves “starting out with firm leading and modeling on the part of the teacher
and shifting as students internalize more and more of the processes and teachers learn
how to let go”.
Teacher can play many roles in the course of teaching. According to Rebecca Oxford,
teacher roles are often best described in the form of metaphors.
1) Teacherasacontroller:arolegenerallyexpectedintraditionaleducational institutions, a
“master” controller always in charge of every moment in the classroom. They determine
what students do and they can often predict many students’ responses because every-
thing is mapped out ahead of time, with no option of divergent paths. But for interaction to
take place, the teacher must create a climate in which spontaneity can thrive, in which un-
rehearsed language can be performed and freedom of expression makes it impossible for
the teacher to predict everything that students
of the interactive teacher
will say or do. Nevertheless, some control on your part is actually an important element of
successfully carrying out interactive techniques. Allowing for spontaneity of expression in-
volves yielding certain elements of control to students, however, the teacher must maintain
some control simply to organize the class hour.
2) Teacherasdirector:teacherislikeaconductorofanorchestraordirectorof a drama. As stu-
dents engage in either rehearsed or spontaneous language performance, it’s the teacher’s
job to keep the process flowing smoothly and efficiently. The ultimate motive of such direc-
tion is to enable students eventually to engage in the real-life drama of improvisation as
each communicative event brings its own uniqueness.
3) Teacherasmanager:Theteacherissomeonewhoplanslessons,modules, courses, and who
structures the larger, longer segments of classroom time, but who then allows each indi-
vidual player to be creative within those parameters.
4) Teacherasfacilitator:alessdirectiverolethatfacilitatestheprocessof learning for students,
helping them to clear away roadblocks, find shortcuts, to negotiate rough terrain. The facili-
tating role requires that the teacher steps away from the managerial or directive role and
allow students with the teacher’s guidance to find their own pathway to success. A facilita-
tor capitalizes on the principle of intrinsic motivation by allowing students to discover lan -
guage through using it pragmatically, rather than by telling them about language.
5) Teacherasresource:theleastdirectiverole.Theimplicationofthisroleis that the student
takes the initiative to come to you. The teacher is available for advice and counsel when
the student seeks it. However, some degree of control, planning, of managing the class-
room is essential.
You should be able to assume all five of these roles on this continuum of directive to
nondirective teaching, depending on the purpose and context of activity. The key to inter -
active teaching is to strive toward the upper, nondirective end of the continuum, gradually
enabling your students to move from their roles of total dependence (upon textbooks, class
activities, the teacher) to relatively total dependence.
Questioning strategies for interactive learning
The most important key to to creating an interactive language classroom is the initiation of
interaction by the teacher. The key is for the teacher to provide the stimuli for continued in -
teraction. These stimuli are important in the initial stage of a classroom lesson as well as
throughout the lesson. Without such ongoing teacher guidance, classroom interaction may
indeed be communicative, but it can easily fall prey to small chitchat and other behaviour
that is off-course from the class objectives.
One of the best ways to develop your role as initiation and sustainer of interaction is to de-
velop a repertoire of questioning strategies. Teacher’s questions:
- Give students the impetus and structured opportunity to produce language comfortably
without having to risk initiating language themselves. It’s very scary for students to initiate
a conversation or topics for discussion.
- Can serve to initiate a chain reaction of student interaction among themselves.
- Give the instructor immediate feedback about students’ comprehension. The teacher can
use the question to diagnose linguistic or content difficulties, especially grammatical and
phonological problems.
- Provide students with opportunities to find out what they think by hearing what they say.
They can discover what their opinions and reactions are. This self-discovery can be very
useful for pre-writing activities.
Effective questions in the classroom can be display q, which attempt to elicit information
already known by the teacher, or referential q, that request info not known by the ques -
tioner. Generally, display questions are very useful in eliciting both content and language
from students. Usually, the higher the proficiency level you teach, the more you can ven-
ture into the upper, referential questions. Make sure that you challenge your students suffi-
ciently but without overwhelming them. Asking a lot of questions in the classroom will not
guarantee stimulation of interaction. Certain types of questions actually discourage interac-
tive learning:
- Too many display questions make students weary of artificial contexts that don ’t involve
genuinely seeking for info.
- Questions that insult students’ intelligence by being so obvious that they will think it’s too
silly to bother answering.
- Vague questions that are worded in abstract or ambiguous language.
- Questions stated in language that is too complex or too wordy for aural
comprehension.
- Too many rhetorical questions, they get confused if you or they have to
answer.
- Random questions that don’t fall into a logical, well-planned sequence,
sending students’ thought pattern into chaos.
Other strategies that promote interaction:
- Group or pair work.
- Giving directions.
- Organizational language (“get into groups”)
- Reacting to students (praise, recognition)
- Responding genuinely to student-initiated questions
- “Lecturing” (orally providing info) or make students read
front of you, remember that the whole class needs to be able to hear the comments. As
you speak, articulate clearly, because students need every advantage they can get when
learning English. Clear articulation is usually more of a key to comprehension than slowed
speech. You should slow down your normal rate of delivery for beginning level classes, but
only slightly. Keep as natural a flow to your language as possible.
Also, non verbal messages are very powerful:
- Let your body posture exhibit an air of confidence.
- Your face should reflect optimisms, brightness and warmth.
- Use facial and hand gestures to enhance meanings of words and sentences
that may be unclear.
- Make frequent eye contact with all students in the class.
- Do not plant your feet firmly in one place for the whole hour. MONITOR,
WALK AROUND.
- Move around the classroom, but not to distraction.
- Follow the conventional rules of proxemics (distance) and kinesthetics
(touching) that apply for the culture(s) of your students.
- Dress appropriately, considering the expectations of your students and the
culture in which you are teaching.
UNPLANNED TEACHING: MIDSTREAM LESSON CHANGES Classroom management
involves decisions about what to do when:
- Your students disagree or throw off the plan of the day
- You digress and do the same.
- An unexpected but pertinent situation comes up.
- Some technicality prevents you from doing an activity.
- A student is disruptive in class
- there isn’t enough time at the end of a class period to finish an activity that has already
started.
In short, you are daily called upon to deal with the unexpected. You have to engage in
what is called unplanned teaching that makes demands on you that were not anticipated in
your lesson plan. The key of learning how to deal with these events gracefully is poise (a
calm confidence in a person’s way of behaving). You will keep the respect of your students
and your own self confidence by staying calm, assessing the situation quickly, making a
midstream change in your plan and allowing the lesson to move on.
TEACHING UNDER ADVERSE CIRCUMSTANCES
NO teaching-learning context is perfect. There are always imperfect circumstances that we
have to deal with. Sequencing (what you plan) vs Pacing
(the real time of the class). How you do it is one of the most significant factors contributing
to your professional success.
1) Teachinglargeclasses
Ideally, language classes, should be comprised of no more than 12 to 15 students. They
should be large enough to provide diversity and student interaction and small enough to
give students plenty of opportunity to participate and get individual attention. Unfortunately,
with paltry educational budgets worldwide, too many language classes are significantly
larger. Large classes present some problems:
- Proficiency and ability vary widely among students.
- Individual teacher-student attention is minimized.
- Students opportunities to speak are lessened.
- Teacher’s feedback on student’s written work is limited.
Solutions:
- Try to make each student feel important and not just a member by learning
their names and using them. Name tags
- Assign students as much interactive work as possible, so that they feel part of
the community and are not just lost in the crowd.
- Optimize the use of pair and small-group work to to give students chances to
perform in English.
- Through active listening comprehension, students can learn a good deal of
language that transfers to reading, speaking and writing.
- Use peer-editing and feedback
- Organize informal conversation and study groups.
TEACHING MULTIPLE PROFICIENCY LEVELS
You are faced with the problem of challenging the higher level students and not over-
whelming lower level ones, and at the same time, keeping the middle group well placed to-
ward their goals. Most of the time, the phenomenon of widely ranging competences in your
class is a by-product of institutional placement procedures and budgetary limits, so there is
little you can do to change this situation. How can you deal with this?
- Do not overgeneralize your assessment on student’s proficiency levels by blanket classi-
fications into “bad” or “good” students. We must be very sensitive to the issue of profi-
ciency vs ability. It’s often difficult to determine whether a student’s performance is a factor
of aptitude, ability or a factor of time and effort.
- For most students, competencies will vary among the four skills, within each skill and by
context. Try to identify the specific abilities and skills of each student so that you can tailor
your techniques to individualized needs.
- Offer choices in individual techniques that vary according to needs and challenges. Sen -
sitively convey that they all have challenges and goals to pursue, and that if someone is
ahead, is due to previous instruction, exposure and motivation.
- The tenor of your classroom teacher talk (instructions, explanations, lectures, etc) will
need to be gauged toward the middle of the levels of proficiency in your class.