GitamJournalofMgmt Article JKRamRNSubudhi 2015
GitamJournalofMgmt Article JKRamRNSubudhi 2015
GitamJournalofMgmt Article JKRamRNSubudhi 2015
net/publication/273100184
CITATION READS
1 5,794
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Rabi Narayan Subudhi on 04 March 2015.
Social Responsibility and its Impact on NPA Level of Jayanta Kumar Nandi
Selected Public and Private Sector Banks in India:
A Comparative Study
COMMUNICATIONS
m II GITAM JOURNAL OF
IIiI MANAGEMENT
January-March 2015 Number 1
Volume 13
RESEARCHPAPERS
Human Capital Management Practices in Higher Education 1
A Case Study of Addis Ababa University in Ethiopia,
Worku Mekonnen Tadesse
11
l
Introduction:
In a world of increasing corporatization and privatization, emphasis
is now more on how to improve efficiency through better governance. Good
governance is one which is accountable, transparent, responsive, equitable
and inclusive. effective and efficient and which follows the rule of law (Sinha,
2013). Many studies can be found on .good corporate governance' in literature.
Studies are. also found on 'status of governance' in banking sector. Here
we focus our discussion. on the state of affairs in the Indian banking sector,
particularly in case of Regional Rural Banks (RRBs).
In the following sections. we first summarize briet1y the development
in banking industry and the reforms measures taken after liberalization. Then
different financial indicators are analyzed to know if the governance-reforms
have improved its operational efficiency. and also the customer perception.
Operational efficiency is analyzed through secondary data, and customer
perception is analyzed by a survey of customers of RRBs in Odisha.
Amalgamation in RRBs in Odisha is taken as a major reform, aimed at improving
governance. which includes operational efficiency.
Mr. J. Ram is Doctoral Research Scholar and Senior Manager (Personnel Adrnn. Dept). Odisha Gramya
Bank (OGB). Head Office. Bhubancswar (Odi sha j, e-mail: [email protected]
GlTAM Journal of Management Vol.13 No.l 1'1'153-165 Jan-Mar 2015 © 2015 GIM. GlTAM
154 G ITAM JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT
Let us first take a look at the evolutions and land-marks, in the history
of Indian financial and banking sector.
Between 1969 and 1980. total deposits increased six times and between
1980 and 1991 the increase was five times.
The substantial increase in total deposits was because of the rise in
the term deposits and saving deposits. which represents the savings of the
community. These two categories of deposits recorded a six fold increase
in each of the periods 1969-1980 and 1981-1991.
156 GITAM JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT
Credit Operation
One of the objectives of nationalization was to ensure adequate credit
now to genuine productive sectors. To fulfill the plan priorities. banks went
on extensive credit operation after nationalization. This was made possible
by the enlarged resource base of banks during the period. The RBI's credit
policy, over the years. emphasized on channeling bank credit to preferred
sectors and borrowers of small means. Annual targets were laid down for
lending to priority sectors as a whole with sub targets for weaker sections
of the society. It was also stipulated that a major portion of the deposits
mobilized in rural and semi-urban areas should be deployed in respective
areas.
The credit operations of banks during the period are summarized below.
Bank credit increased seven fold between 1969 and 1980 and by five
times between 1980 -91. Within the priority group the share of agriculture
was 39 percent in 1969, 42 percent in 1980 and it remained at that in 1991
by 40 percent. The share of SSI sector in total bank credit was 52.66 percent
in 1969 showed a relative decline to 38 percent in 1980 and 40 percent
in 1991.
Classification of Priority Sector Advances: 1969-1980
Liberalization Period
Banking sector reform was started by the Government of India in 1991.
The regime of reforms began with a radical departure from "regulated banking'
towards "market oriented banking".
The objective of reform, at the macro-level, was removing the external
constraints of the banking system as a whole and thereby creating a climate
in tandem with liberalization. At the micro-level, the liberalization aimed
at enabling the banking system to overcome the internal constraints on the
functioning of banking organization. The foundation of banking reforms was
laid by the Committee on Financial Reforms (Narasimham Committee) which
published its recommendations in November, 1991.
The Regional Rural Banks which came into existence on October 2,
1975. became popular as 'small man's bank'. The period 1975-1990, the
first fifteen years can be termed as period of 'inception and expansion' in
the history of RRBs. This period witnessed large scale increase in the number
of banks, branches and districts covered. Many committees, instituted by authority
(list given as an annexure), mainly aimed bringing in a better governance
structure.
Policy Measures to Strengthen RRBs
Various policy measures were initiated to allow RRBs to lend for Non-
Target Group (NTG) beneficiaries to the extent of 40 percent of their fresh
advances with effect from September 1992. This limit was raised to 60 per
cent in January 1994. Similarly RRBs were also allowed to lend to non-
productive purposes to the extent of 10 per cent of the fresh lending. RRBs
were also permitted to engage into non-fund based activities like issuing
guarantees, purchase/discount of demand drafts and cheques, and to install
safe deposit lockers.
As of March 2012 total deposits and advances of RRBs were Rs
I.S7J51crores and1.20,551 crores respectively. The deposits were mobilised
through over 11.57 crore accounts and the advances were outstanding to over
2.06 crore borrowers. Thus RRBS have expanded their reach in terms of
spatial coverage. rural savings mobilisation and credit purveyance especially
under the rural development programmes for amelioration of poverty.
Development of commercial banks in Odisha during the post
nationalization period (1970-1979) deserves a special mention. Firstly, the
period succeeds implementation of Lead Bank Scheme on the recommendations
of the National Credit Council set up by the Government of India in the
158 GITAM JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT
year 1968. Under this scheme, the Lead Banks were required to concentrate
on the banking business and resource development in the districts assigned
to them in collaboration with other developmental agencies. Secondly, the
period also witnessed nationalization of commercial banks on 19th July, 1969.
Promoting banking habits among the people is one of the important
objectives of branch expansion. An analysis of the data on branch expansion
by commercial banks in Odisha revealed from secondary data that there has
been significant growth.
Amalgamation of RRBs in Odisha
The Government of India initiated the process of amalgamation of the
Regional Rural Banks sponsored by the same commercial bank and functioning
in the same state. The objective of the amalgamation was to strengthen the
RRBs. The process, in Odisha started in February, 2006 and ended in August,
2007.
Performance of RRBs in Odisha
There were five regional Rural Banks working in Odisha as on 31.03.2012.
They were operating through 875 branches spread in 30 districts of the State.
The Key indicators like number of branches, deposits and advances outstanding
and Credit-deposit ratios from 1996 to 2012 have been provided in the following
table.
Performance of RRBs in Odisha: Key Indicators
1 2 3 4 5 6
1996 9 819 816 364 44.61
1997 9 816 768 421 54.82
1998 9 823 958 462 48.25
1999 9 838 1194 578 48.41
2000 9 839 1429 716 50.10
2001 9 834 1770 859 48.53
2002 9 832 2155 1124 52.16
2003 9 836 2455 1331 54.21
2004 9 832 2891 1616 55.90
2005 9 834 3196 1999 62.55
2006 7 835 3594 2328 64.77
2007 5 849 4151 2699 65.02
2008 5 857 5298 3080 58.13
2009 5 871 6557 3372 51.42
2010 5 875 7887 3913 49.61
2011 5 875 8823 4689 53.14
2012 5 885 9648 5645 58.55
REGIONAL RURAL BANKS OF OOISHA:... 159
Significance-difference Test
We conduct hypothesis testing, to verify, if amalgamation has improved
the situation. Among many other ratios, we have taken here Net interest margin
(NIM) ratio, to study whether there is any significant improvement, post-
amalgamation. A bank earns interest on its loans and investment. At the same
time it pays interest on the deposits mobilized by it and on the funds borrowed
from other institutions. Net interest margin is the difference between the total
interest income earned by a bank and total expenditure made in the interest
head by the bank. It reflects the capacity of the management in generating
surplus.
Net Interest Margin Ratio= (Interest income - Interest expenditure)/
Assets x 100
Null Hypothesis (HO):There is no significant difference in Net interest
margin ratio of pre- and post amalgamated period of KalingaGramya Bank.
Null Hypothesis (Hf j.There is significant difference in Net interest margin
ratio of pre- and post amalgamated period of KalingaGramya Bank.
Net Interest Margin Ratios of KalingaGramya Bank, Odisha
Pre-amalgamation NIM Ratio Post- amalgamation NIM Ratio
SD= 0.02. From the result of t-test above. it is seen that the p-value is 0.06.
which is more than 0.05. It implies that the difference between the mean
value of post and pre amalgamated period is not significant at 5% level.
But at higher level (6-10%). we can conclude that, there is some improvement
in NIM.
Customer Survey Data Analysis
To understand. whether there is any remarkable change/ improvement
in consumer perception. on how bank is operating (governed), a structured
questionnaire was canvassed at 10 branches of RRBs of Odisha, where a
total of 516 bank-customers have responded. Here we present only the summary
of results, particularly on the available facilities and customer expectations.
Following graph shows the brief demographic profile of the customers
surveyed.
Graph: Occupationof the Customers of RRBs (from a sample of 516)
Unemployed
occupation
stude nt 6"0
Professional
Degree
Agriculture
4""
45"",
More than
15001-20000
20000
Monthly Income
4%
7%
10001-15000
6%
5001-10000
17%
246
11 Electronic token number display and audio announcement system
2.54
12 Complaints and suggestion boxes (Importance)
2.65
13 Flooring (Importance)
2.71
14 Availability of personal assistance/guidance (Importance)
2.85
15 Display of products and sen' ices information (Importance)
3.18
16 Display of identification boards at counters (Importance)
7.9
4.9
°"°
cc..:
ee
,<;;e
,"~~
0:- c0"
"
.0.>'
",I:>d'
,ov ""OJ ~,0
,<;;V
c- 0-'
'?'
,,0"'- 01:' (5'
,,'-
(:''<
,,0 ~o " vC cC
-,' ,c
<:
s(t" ,0
c" ~~
cO
(:'
(:' "" ",e' -,""
0' (5'
<0'
,," ~e GO"
164 GITAM JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT
REFERE:\'CES
2. Gupta SB(l993). Monetary Economic Institutions and Policy. S. Chand & Company.
New Delhi.
3. Sarkar, P.c. and Das, A. (1997). "Development of composite index of banking efficiency".
The Indian Case. Reserve Bank of India Occasional Papers. V01.18. No.1. pp.679-
707.
6. Sathye. M, (2003). "Efficiency of banks in a developing economy: The case of Indian ".
European Journal of Operational Research. Vo1.148. pp.662-671
7. Sinha. Anand (May. 2(13). Governance in Banks and Financial Institutions. RBI
8. Subudhi. R.N. & Ram. Jitendra Kumar. 2012). Operational Efficiency of Regional
Rural banks and Other Commercial Banks of Odisha: A Comparative Study. In Nayak,
N, Mishra. R.K .. &Kar. S.(Eds) Organizational Performance in the Global Market
: Challenges in Excellence (pp. 131-151). :\ew Delhi. SSDr\ Publishers & Distributors.
9. Subudhi. R.N. & Ram. Jitendra Kumar: 2012). Operational Efficiency of Regional
Rural banks and Other Commercial Banks of Odisha: A Comparative Study. Arabian
Journal of Business and Management Review (Nigerian Chapter) Vol. 1. No.2. 2012
REGIONAL RURAL BANKS OF OOISHA:... 165
10 Ram, Jitendra Kumar & Subudhi. R.N. &( 2014).Customer Perception on Performance
of RRBs in OdishaParikalpana - KIlT Journal of Management, Vol - 10 (I). 2014,
pp.37-50
Reports
4 Expert committee for review of supervisory role of NABARD. 1998 (U.K. Sarma
Committee)
Annexure -II