Harvard Psy - 1 Syllabus
Harvard Psy - 1 Syllabus
Spring 2021
Harvard University
Instructor:
Steven Pinker
Johnstone Family Professor
Department of Psychology
William James Hall 970
x5-0831
[email protected]
www.stevenpinker.com
Twitter: @sapinker
Course Description (unofficial): What could be more interesting than the human mind? This is
not just a first course in psychology but an opportunity to explore some of the deepest and
most fascinating issues in intellectual life. Is there such a thing as human nature? How does the
activity of the brain result in intelligence, consciousness, will? How do we see, think, learn, talk,
feel, relate to one another? Why do we fall in love, find babies cute, crave sex, experience
disgust and fear, distrust other races, kill each other? And why do we differ: women from men,
gay from straight, one individual from another, the mentally healthy from the pathological?
Professor Pinker has spent his career writing and teaching about these topics and the
controversies they have set off, and will explore them in lectures, demonstrations, and
discussions.
Office Hours: Thursday, 5-6pm and by appointment. Professor Pinker is happy to meet by Zoom
or other channels with any student for any reason. Please send him an email if you would like to
set up an appointment, or have a question; all emails will be answered within 24 hours.
1
During each live class meeting, Prof. Pinker will provide background and bonus information on
the lecture topic, offer additional explanation, share personal reflections, answer questions on
the lecture or readings or anything else, and engage in discussions on controversies.
Web Sites:
Course Canvas site: https://canvas.harvard.edu/courses/81098
This site will contain links to the recorded lectures, recordings of the live class meetings,
handouts, copies of the lecture slides, assignments, information about sections and exams, and
other relevant links.
Preceptor:
Nicole E. Noll, Ph.D.
[email protected]
Office hours: Tuesday 5-6pm and by appointment. Dr. Noll encourages any student to drop by
her Zoom room or make an appointment to talk about assignments, readings, projects, or
anything else (e.g., psychology, research, college) . You are not interrupting if you visit—I set
time aside for these visits and I look forward to getting to know many of you throughout the
semester. I care about your learning, success in the course, and overall development as a
human being. You may also email me; I do my best to reply to emails within 24 hours during the
week.
Sections:
One 1 ¼ -hour discussion section. Sections will be assigned by Monday, February 1. Discussion
sections will be scheduled on Tuesdays and Wednesdays and students will be able to rank their
preferences the first week of the semester. Discussion sections will first meet the week of
February 1.
Texts:
Psychology, Eighth Edition. By Peter Gray and David Bjorklund. Required. Available from the
publisher (https://store.macmillanlearning.com/us/product/Psychology/p/1319015891) at the
Coop (https://tinyurl.com/W21-PSYC-1-1) and on reserve at Lamont Library
(https://canvas.harvard.edu/courses/81098/external_tools/33436) . Please note that the
current edition of the textbook is not the same as older editions. Older editions cannot be used
in lieu of the current edition.
How the Mind Works by Steven Pinker. New York: W. W. Norton, 1997, reprinted with a new
edition in 2009. Much of the lecture material that is not in the textbook may be found here. It
is
2
therefore recommended, though optional. HTMW is available at the Coop, through the Library
Reserves link, and all online retailers. Inexpensive used copies are plentiful.
3-D Brain. The brain visualization tool on this website http://www.g2conline.org/2022 and
iPhone/iPad app (http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/3d-brain/id331399332?mt=8) is an excellent
supplement to the textbook for learning about the structure of the brain.
For the lecture on visual perception, please purchase a pair of Red/Cyan cardboard glasses
(around $7), such as these from Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01CUIXHVS/ref=cm_sw_em_r_mt_dp_baCaGbYVAXVJP
There is also a helpful library research guide specifically for this course, which includes a
number of tools for the kind of research you will be doing, and can be found here:
https://guides.library.harvard.edu/psy1.
• The grades of students will be adjusted to equalize the grading policies across TFs; that
is, no student will be penalized for having a tougher grader.
• Your final course grade will be determined by the rank of your total score; in other
words, you will be “graded on a curve.” For an explanation of how and why we do this,
see the document called “The Curve” in the EXAMS folder under the FILES tab.
• The approximate proportion of students who will receive each letter grade is as follows:
25% = A, 50% = B, 20% = C, 5% = D or E.
• Students whose grades fall close to the dividing line between two letter grades will be
given the higher grade if, in the opinion of the TF, they have performed well in sections
and assignments.
3
Accessibility:
Any student needing academic adjustments or accommodations is requested to present a letter
from the Accessible Education Office (AEO) and speak with the Preceptor by February 5th.
Failure to do so may result in our being unable to respond to your needs in a timely manner. All
discussions will remain confidential, although AEO may be consulted to discuss appropriate
implementation.
Policies:
Late papers: Ordinarily, mini-assignments that are late will get a grade of zero. Papers that are
late will be subject to a late penalty of ten percentage points (about a letter grade) per day. A
little arithmetic will show that getting a zero for a mini-assignment, or losing points for a paper,
will have a good chance of lowering your letter grade for the course as a whole.
Our usual policy is that the late penalty is waived only in cases of sickness, inescapable
conflicts, or other emergencies, and only with a letter from your Resident Dean.
Since we are living through the extraordinary challenge of the Covid-19 pandemic, we will
entertain requests for extensions, within reason. Please contact your TF if you feel you need
more time for an assignment.
Academic integrity: This course adheres to the university’s standards regarding academic
integrity. Suspected cheating or plagiarism will be referred to the Honor Council of Harvard
College, as is required by the university. Students are responsible for knowing what constitutes
plagiarism; please refer to the Harvard Guide to Using Sources
(http://usingsources.fas.harvard.edu/) for a detailed description of the different types of
plagiarism.
Collaboration: You are permitted (indeed, encouraged) to discuss the content of your
assignment with other students, and to make suggestions about sources. You are also
permitted to show a draft of your work to other students for general feedback about coherence
and style (e.g., “This claim doesn’t seem to follow logically from that one,” or “This paragraph is
clumsy and hard to understand.”) You are also encouraged to solicit feedback on writing style,
unclear wording, and errors in spelling, punctuation, and grammar. However, this feedback
should consist of the reader pointing out problems to you and offering guidance on how to fix
them, including editing two or three paragraphs as an example. But it may not consist of
another person (including a fellow student, friend, parent, significant other, teaching assistant,
tutor, or counselor) reworking or editing your entire draft by adding, deleting, or rewriting
sentences, or by fixing errors in spelling, punctuation, or grammar. Finally, you are not
permitted to share or divide up the work of finding, reading, and summarizing sources. And you
are not permitted to collaborate on the planning, researching, or writing of papers with similar
content.
Midterm: An absence from the in-class midterm exam will ordinarily be excused only in two
circumstances. One is if the regularly scheduled exam falls on a religious holiday. Please look at
the calendar now: if this affects you, please notify the Preceptor by Friday, February 5th. The
other is if you are ill on the day of the exam and present a signed form from Harvard University
4
Health Services or your doctor to your House Dean or the Assistant Dean of First-year Students,
who then provides a letter of excuse to the Preceptor. In either case, the Preceptor will ensure
that you are not penalized for your absence.
Except in highly unusual circumstances, we do not administer make-up exams for other
reasons, such as students traveling on the date of the exam. Please check the schedule for your
other classes and any extracurricular activities and ensure that you will be able to take the
midterm exam on March 11th.
Remarks: This is a first course in psychology, and is also designed to give you broad education
in spheres of knowledge that are relevant to the human mind. Here is what I hope you will take
from the course:
• I hope to put you in the habit of thinking about your own minds as you live your lives
and react to the world around you. When you are in the throes of an emotion, or carried
away with an enticing idea, or puzzled by an unusual memory or paradox or sight or
sound, you should be able to reflect on how these reactions may arise from design
features of your own minds, rather than naively taking them at face value.
• I hope that you will see how questions about the functioning of the mind connect to
other disciplines in biology, the social sciences, and the arts (and hence every other
realm of human activity). Politics and history are directed by human motives, decisions,
and social interactions. The arts are shaped by human perception, memory, language,
and emotion. Biological evolution itself is often led by behavior.
• You will learn basic facts about your own brains: how perception and learning are
implemented in brain circuitry; the different kinds of memory; the basic emotions; the
major stages of human development.
• You will acquire a familiarity with some of the touchstones of literate intellectual culture
that come from psychology, including Freud and psychoanalysis, Skinner and
behaviorism, Darwin and the emotions, the Turing Test, the Milgram experiment,
cognitive dissonance, and the “hard problem of consciousness.”
• I hope you will develop a feel for how the scientific mindset can be applied to human
affairs. You should be able to think about the mind in mechanistic terms (as a product of
evolved neural circuitry interacting with the physical, social, and cultural environment),
and should appreciate that hypotheses about human nature are claims that can be
made precise and submitted to empirical test.
The course will expose you to five streams of information. The Psychology textbook presents
the smorgasbord known as psychology in all its wondrous variety. The recorded lectures weave
this material into a coherent story, based on the syntheses I have fashioned in my books How
the Mind Works, The Blank Slate, The Stuff of Thought, The Better Angels of Our Nature, and the
forthcoming Rationality. The class sessions provide informal background and reflections, a
forum for exploring controversies, and an Ask Me Anything session. The discussion sections will
drill down into the lecture material to probe and reinforce your understanding with problems
and small-group discussions. The readings for your papers will introduce you to competing
viewpoints and the primary scientific literature.
5
Recorded Lectures: Required. Anything mentioned in a lecture may be on the exams, including
material that is not in any of the readings. The handouts are intended to spare you from having
to write down every diagram and term mentioned in the lecture; they are not a substitute for
attending to the lecture and taking notes.
Live Class meetings: Not strictly required, but it would be silly to skip them. What’s the point of
being a Harvard student, rather than watching a bunch of YouTube videos or signing up for a
MOOC, if you blow off the opportunity to interact with your professor—to hear the material
clarified and contextualized, get the background and gossip, engage in some debate on the
controversies? You’ll also get additional information on what I consider the key points of each
lecture—the ones likely to be questioned on the exam.
Discussion sections: Required. The main purpose of the section is discussion of the topics in the
preceding week’s lecture and readings. Sections give you the opportunity to probe and clarify
your understanding of concepts and terms introduced in the lectures and readings. To facilitate
the weekly discussions and to provide a regular feedback mechanism about your mastery of the
course material, short quizzes will be given at the beginning of each section meeting. Ten
percent of your grade will come from section participation, including completion and discussion
of the quiz questions (which will not themselves be graded). In addition, your Teaching Fellow
will get to know you in the sections, will be your main contact with the subject, and will
influence your final grade and other decisions.
Textbook: Any material in the assigned passages from the Gray and Bjorkland textbook may be
quizzed in the exam. Read the assigned chapters every week, preferably before your section;
don't try to save them all for the week before the exam. It will be more fun, and you'll
remember more. Exam questions will cover major ideas, major findings, and major thinkers,
and will tap your deep understanding of the ideas (as opposed to superficial familiarity with the
words). We won’t nitpick, for example, about the names of the people who did particular
experiments (though of course we may provide them in a question to help you as memory
prompts).
Backup readings: The optional passages from How the Mind Works are a backup to the
lectures, and will overlap with them in part. They are not a substitute for the lectures. Many
sections of the recommended chapters will not be covered in the lectures (or exams), and you
won't know what they are if you haven't been to the lectures. And many parts of the lectures
will not be in any of the readings.
Papers: Forty percent of your grade will be determined by written assignments. The primary
paper, about ten pages for the first version and fifteen pages for the final version, will require
you to research some topic in greater depth than you will find in the readings. These
assignments have a number of goals. Research on the human mind can be controversial. I have
opinions on many of these controversies, which are reflected in the lectures and the selection
of readings. The assignment presents you with an opportunity to explore contrasting opinions.
In addition, the assignment will force you to immerse yourself in an empirical literature on a
topic and to read articles in the primary scientific literature.
6
You will also be asked to submit three short assignments during the semester. They include
requests for you to think about some issue, a preview of your major paper, and reports of your
participation in psychology department experiments. Serving as a participant is an excellent
way to get a feel for what research on the human mind actually consists of, and to learn about
areas of ongoing research that are not covered in the lectures or textbook.
You will receive detailed guidelines about the writing assignments, beginning in the second
week of the semester.
Exams: The purpose of the exams is to increase the incentive for you to learn the material of
the course in a deep and comprehending way, as opposed to just being acquainted with
buzzwords. The questions on the exam are intended to test a sample of the knowledge we
hope you will take away; they cannot cover every fact or idea we hope you will learn. Though
we strive to have the test reflect the readings and lectures, please note that PSY 1 is not a test-
prep course, designed to coach you for a high-stakes exam. The content of the course is
selected for its intellectual importance and interest, and the exams are a sampling of that
content.
Both exams are open--book. The midterm exam will cover the first part of the course. It will be
given during class period on March 11th and will last about 75 minutes. The final exam will cover
the entire course. It will be given during the exam period on May 14th and will last three hours.
Both exams will consist of a mixture of short-answer and multiple-choice questions. Each exam
question is graded by a single TF, to ensure consistent grading across all students.
7
How to Get a Good Grade in PSY 1:
One of the many benefits of knowing psychological science is improving your ability to learn
and remember. Here are some tips on how to get a good grade in the course, based on our
experience with the practices of more and less successful students in the past, and on research
in cognitive psychology on attention, memory, and learning.
1. Watch the lectures. This should be obvious, but many Harvard students treat lectures as
optional, hoping to make up what they’ve missed from handouts, readings, and notes taken
by other students. The lectures are not optional. If you cut class, you are unlikely to get an
A.
2. Give the lectures your undivided attention. Do not check email, Facebook, Twitter, or other
Web sites during the lectures. If you watch the lectures on your laptop, close your other
Web browser tabs and email program, turn off notifications (good advice in life outside the
class, too), and don’t open them again until the lecture is over. This also may sound
obvious, but many people believe in a myth called “multitasking.” Research in cognitive
psychology shows that the brain is incapable of processing two streams of verbal material
simultaneously.
3. Consider printing out the handouts and taking notes on them with a paper pen or pencil.
Several studies have shown that people remember material better this way, probably
because they can more easily use spatial and visual resources of a 2-D page to organize the
material, rather than relying only on strings of text. These resources include arrows, circling,
underlining, text size, comments on diagrams, and so on. A major reason we provide
handout files with diagrams, bullet points, and white space is so that you can annotate the
handout yourselves; the handout is not a set of crib notes or a supplementary textbook. If
you’d rather annotate the PDFs with a digital tablet or pen, there are many apps that will
allow you to do so fluidly, duplicating much of the paper-and-pen experience. You can
annotate it using Adobe Acrobat, which you have free access to via Harvard (download
here), though this is slower and more limited.
4. For similar reasons, you should take your own notes; the notes of another student will
reflect that student’s assumptions, background knowledge, habits and styles, and
idiosyncratic associations, which can differ dramatically from your own.
5. As you read and study, actively organize the material in your mind; don’t try to pound it in
through repetition. Make a set of notes; don’t use a highlighter. Organize the material
hierarchically into a list of ideas, with each major idea expanded into a list of subsidiary
ideas. Close the book and see if you can recall the material, as if trying to explain it to
someone else. Actually try to explain it to someone else.
6. Distribute your learning over time. Don’t cram or binge-read in an all-nighter or a marathon
session. When you do, everything will tend to run together in your mind.
7. Aim at a deep understanding of the ideas, not a superficial familiarity with the words and
phrases. (The multiple-choice questions in particular try to distinguish these two levels of
acquaintance with the material.) Can you paraphrase the material using different words
from those in the text, lecture, or reading? As you’re reading, do you find yourself
muttering, “I think I understand this”? If you do, it means you don’t understand it.
8
8. Ask and discuss. If you think you don’t understand something, it’s not a failing; it’s an
opportunity to learn it. Ask your fellow students. Ask your TF in section, or during their
office hours. Ask your professor, particularly after the lecture, during his office hours, or in
an email. Follow through with the optional readings, or with readings from the Web or
library.
9. Read the assignments carefully. We mean what we say in them, and we grade according to
how well the students carry out the terms of the assignments.
9
Schedule of Lectures and Readings:
Gray = Psychology (obligatory); HTMW = How the Mind Works (optional). The readings are
keyed to the lectures. When page numbers are given, begin reading at the major section
heading on the indicated page.
Week 1 – No sections
Tuesday, Jan. 26: Introduction to the human mind and to Psychological Science. Making the
familiar seem strange. Reverse-engineering the psyche. Examples of remarkable feats of the
human mind: seeing, thinking, emotions about things, emotions about people.
Lecture 1
(HTMW: Chapter 1, pp. 3-21.)
Tuesday, Feb. 2: Major approaches to psychological science, cont. Components of the modern
approach: Cognition; computation; neuroscience; evolution.
Lecture 3
Gray: Chapter 4, pp. 134-138.
(HTMW: Chapter 2, pp. 59-69.)
Q ASSIGNED: Methods mini-assignment
Thursday, Feb. 4: Evolution. Where life and mind come from. Adaptations and by-products. The
Environment of Evolutionary Adaptedness.
Lecture 4
Gray: Chapter 3, pp. 59-79, 84-87.
(HTMW: Chapter 3, pp. 149-164, 186-190.)
Tuesday, Feb. 9: Nature & nurture. How genes do and don’t shape behavior. Phony
dichotomies in nature and nurture. Ethical and political controversies surrounding nature and
nurture: race, sex, & class inequality; perfectibility & social change; determinism &
responsibility; nihilism & meaning.
Lecture 5
10
Gray: Same as February 2, also chapter 10, pp. 386-397.
(HTMW: Chapter 1, pp. 44-56.)
(Students interested in these topics are also encouraged to read Chapters 6-11 and the 2016
Afterword in my book The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature.)
Q DUE by 11:59 PM (ET): Methods mini-assignment
Q ASSIGNED: Research participation mini-assignment
Thursday, Feb. 11: The Brain. The major parts of the brain and what they are for.
Lecture 6
Gray: Chapter 4; Chapter 7, pp. 225-238, 244-251; Chapter 5, pp. 156-160.
(HTMW: Chapter 2, pp. 98-111.)
Tuesday, Feb. 16: The Brain, cont. Neurons, neural circuits, and elementary information
processing.
Lecture 7
Gray: Same as 2/11.
(HTMW: Same as 2/11.)
Q ASSIGNED: Research paper preview mini-assignment and research paper
Tuesday, Feb. 23: Perception, cont.: Visual scene analysis, object recognition, Gestalt laws,
auditory scene analysis.
Lecture 9
Gray: Chapter 8, pp. 240-244; Chapter 6, pp. 213-223.
(HTMW: Chapter 4, pp. 266-284.)
Q DUE by 11:59 PM (ET): Research participation mini-assignment
11
Week 6 – Sections meet
Thursday, March 4: Concepts & Reasoning. Concepts, categories, & stereotypes. Deductive and
probabilistic reasoning.
Lecture 12
Gray: Chapter 10, pp. 365-371.
(HTMW: Chapter 2, pp. 126-129; Chapter 5, pp. 306-312, 343-351.)
Q DUE by 11:59 PM (ET): Research paper preview mini-assignment
Week 8 – No sections
Thursday, March 18: Language. Universality of language; language and thought; components of
language; how language works.
Lecture 13
Gray: Chapter 11, pp. 435-449.
S. Pinker, The Language Instinct, Chapters 2 & 4 (on course website).
Tuesday, March 23: Development. Maturation & cognitive development. Piaget. Domain-
specificity. Theory of Mind.
Lecture 14
Gray: Chapter 11, pp. 401-434.
(HTMW: Chapter 5, pp. 314-333.)
Thursday, March 25: Emotions: theory & background. Function of emotions. Darwin’s
Expression of Emotions. Ekman & universal expressions. Emotions about the physical world:
fear and disgust.
12
Lecture 15
Gray: Chapter 3, pp. 79-87; Chapter 5, pp. 300-305; Chapter 5, pp. 184-189.
(HTMW: Chapter 6, pp. 363-374; 378-389.)
Tuesday, March 30: Social emotions: Sympathy, gratitude, anger, guilt, trust, shame, passion;
reciprocal altruism; Prisoner’s Dilemma; Ultimatum Game.
Lecture 16
Gray: Chapter 3, pp. 96-97; Chapter 13, pp. 527-529, 511-516.
(HTMW: Chapter 6, pp. 396-416.)
Q DUE by 11:59 PM (ET): First version of the research paper
Thursday, April 1: Kin & socialization. Kin selection, parents & offspring, socialization and
personality development, behavioral genetics.
Lecture 17
Gray: Chapter 3, pp. 95-97; Chapter 12, pp. 472-476 Chapter 13, pp. 496-499; Chapter 14, pp.
535-552, 564-572.
(HTMW: Chapter 7, pp. 429-455.)
Thursday, April 8: Love and sex. Sexual selection, sex differences, sexual attraction. .
Lecture 19
Gray: Chapter 3, pp. 87-93; Chapter 12, 478-485; Chapter 14, pp. 552-554.
(HTMW: Chapter 7, pp. 455-502.)
Tuesday, April 13: Love and sex. Beauty, conflict, jealousy, sexual politics, romantic passion,
love and commitment.
Lecture 20
Gray: Same as 4/8.
(HTMW: Same as 4/8.)
13
Thursday, April 15: Wellness day, no class.
Tuesday, April 20: Violence. Individual aggression; Hobbes & the dynamics of aggression;
aggression between groups; group psychology; the decline of violence.
Lecture 21
Gray: Chapter 3, pp. 93-95; Chapter 12, pp. 476 (already read); Chapter 13, pp. 529-533.
(HTMW: Chapter 7, pp. 493-520.)
Thursday, April 22: Obedience to authority. Implications for expertise, the nature of evil,
emotions versus behavior, social influence, attribution theory, and the ethics of
experimentation.
Lecture 22
Gray: Chapter 13, pp. 522-526.
Tuesday, April 27: The self and others. Self-presentation, dominance, status, attribution and
attribution errors, self-deception, cognitive dissonance.
Lecture 23
Gray: Chapter 13, pp. 493-510, 513-522.
(HTMW: Chapter 6, pp. 421-424; Chapter 7, pp. 499-502.)
Q DUE by 11:59 PM (ET): Final version of the research paper
14