100% found this document useful (2 votes)
284 views103 pages

06 AfroAtlanticGraphic-Writing

This document summarizes Kongo graphic writing systems used in Central Africa and the Afro-Atlantic world. It discusses the key components of Kongo graphic writing, including ideograms, pictograms, and cosmograms. It also outlines the origins and historical study of Kongo graphic writing, noting key scholars like Clémentine Faïk-Nzuji, Robert Farris Thompson, and K.K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau who have researched and written about these symbolic communication systems. The document concludes by mentioning the transmission of Kongo graphic writing traditions to the Caribbean through the slave trade.

Uploaded by

rnj1230
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (2 votes)
284 views103 pages

06 AfroAtlanticGraphic-Writing

This document summarizes Kongo graphic writing systems used in Central Africa and the Afro-Atlantic world. It discusses the key components of Kongo graphic writing, including ideograms, pictograms, and cosmograms. It also outlines the origins and historical study of Kongo graphic writing, noting key scholars like Clémentine Faïk-Nzuji, Robert Farris Thompson, and K.K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau who have researched and written about these symbolic communication systems. The document concludes by mentioning the transmission of Kongo graphic writing traditions to the Caribbean through the slave trade.

Uploaded by

rnj1230
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 103

Temple University Press

Chapter Title: Afro-Atlantic Graphic Writing: Bidimbu, Bisinsu, and Firmas

Book Title: Kongo Graphic Writing and Other Narratives of the Sign
Book Author(s): Bárbaro Martínez-Ruiz
Published by: Temple University Press. (2013)
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt14bt6nd.7

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms

Temple University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access
to Kongo Graphic Writing and Other Narratives of the Sign

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
C H A P T E R   4

Afro-Atlantic Graphic Writing:


Bidimbu, Bisinsu, and Firmas

Kongo Graphic Writing Systems: Overview of


Character and Origins
The term graphic writing systems can be credited to Gerhard Kubik. Build-
ing on existing scholarly work on particular writing traditions that facil-
itated an awareness of graphic expression in Africa,1 Kubik was the first
scholar to study and explain in systematic terms graphic writing traditions.2
He argued that graphic writing must be understood as a “visual commu-
nication system whose constituent parts are graphemes, the smallest mean-
ingful unit in the system.”3 In the context of Kongo graphic writing, these
constituent parts include ideograms, pictograms, and cosmograms, which
can be differentiated as follows:
• Ideograms: Visual signs or abstract graphic representations of an
idea or mental image. A character or symbol representing ideas or
things without expressing a particular word or phrase for it.4
• Pictograms or pictographs: Visual signals or figurative graphic repre-
sentations that depict objects and produce mental images that give
direct access to the objects and ideas. More simply, pictures used to
represent words or ideas.5
• Cosmograms: Compounds of two conventional signs represented
using another, nonfigurative form of representation or notation of
the thought. This form of notation has the function of alluding
to knowledge with implications in the metaphysical, philosophical,
and religious realm. This kind of knowledge is known as cosmol-
ogy, reports about the origin of life, and as cosmogony, reports
about human conception and the existence of God.
In Kongo writing, these constituent graphic units have no form of inde-
pendent phonetic expression but can generally be identified by their proper
names. In addition to using ideographs, pictograms, and cosmograms as
their basic building blocks, Kongo graphic writing systems incorporate
mnemonic elements and letters from the Latin alphabet. Much like any type
of language, these components are combined in both simple and compound
sequences to convey recognizable meaning. Far more than mere ­collections
47

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
48 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

of visual signs, Kongo graphic writing systems are complex codes of shared
knowledge that develop and communicate cosmology, mythology, and phi-
losophy and defi ne aesthetic realities. They perpetuate and validate collective
memories, epics, legends, myths, and ancient knowledge and play an integral
role in the defi nition and development of African and Kongo-Caribbean
cultures and in the practice of traditional and contemporary African-based
religions. The ancient Bakongo called graphic writing Sinsu kia Nguisami, a
phrase that translates as “communication by code and symbol.” Still in use
today in many parts of Central Africa, graphic writing includes signs known
as bidimbu (symbols) and bisinsu (codes).
Although numerous scholars have studied the use and design of graphic
traditions across a range of cultures, including pre-Columbian (Mayan scrip-
ture), Asian (Chinese, Japanese, Indian, Vietnamese calligraphies), and
North African (Egyptian hieroglyphs), there is a relative dearth of academic
work that examines African graphic writing systems in great depth or in so-
cial context. The imprecision of available historical documents and the lack
of clear reference to graphic writing in Africa before the nineteenth cen-
tury result in limited solid ground on which to build a study of the role of
graphic writing in Kongo culture. Early works on the subject, such as schol-
arship by Joseph H. Greenberg, David Dalby, Lucien Lévy-Bruhl, Marcel
Mauss, Paul Rivet, Georges Balandier, J. K. MacGregor, Jacques Fédry, and
J. Lacouture, have demonstrated the diversity of graphic designs but have
neither explained the way graphic writing can be read nor imbued this tra-
dition of communication with an understanding of its religious context.
Although several contemporary writers have made reference to religious
forms and uses of minkisi and fi rmas, only a couple have begun to systemat-
ically explore the meanings and uses of these communicative forms.
The most complete references to Kongo graphic writing are found in
the works of linguist Clémentine Faïk-Nzuji, in her book Arts africains:
Signes et symboles; African art historian and anthropologist Robert Farris
Thompson, in his book The Four Moments of the Sun; and priest and philos-
opher of Kongo culture K. K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau, who has written extensively
about Kongo writing, most notably in Self-Healing Power and Therapy: Old
Teachings from Africa.
Faïk-Nzuji introduces the notion of bidimbu as a mode of expression
and graphic tradition in Central and West Africa and explores the concept
of symbol in the context of African culture and language.6 Faïk-Nzuji’s most
important contributions are her attempt to explain the semantic complex-
ity of this graphic tradition through an exploration of basic linguistic ques-
tions such as the formal structure of the graphic system and her explanation
of the manner in which graphic elements and symbols are used within the
semantic and syntactic structure. However, while her work successfully
introduces a range of forms of visual expression found among Central Afri-
can cultures, it does not adequately explore the relationship between these
communicative forms or situate them within the broader cultural context
in which they exist.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 49

Robert Farris Thompson has provided the most thorough study of


the various components of graphic writing systems. Thompson’s work ex-
plains the notion of bidimbu while exploring the implications of the devel-
opment of this tradition across forms of visual expression in the Bakongo
world in Central Africa and its extension in the Atlantic diaspora. Thomp-
son also provides substantial examples of graphic expression and documents
their interaction with and usage within religious, philosophical, artistic,
and historiographic contexts.7 The forms explored by Thompson include
early rupestrian art and graphic depictions recorded at Central African sites;
three-dimensional art forms such as funerary sculptures and terra-cotta
urns; inscriptions on religious objects, swords, canes, and domestic items;
and engravings on figures and graphic notions expressed through surface
painting, textile design, architectural decoration, and forms of body scarifi-
cation, tattoo, and body language such as poses and gestures.8
K. K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau’s detailed scholarship on the culture, religion,
and philosophy of the Bakongo provides a critical foundation for under-
standing the cosmology underlying the culture’s graphic writing. According
to Fu-Kiau, writing (soni) is a way to achieve the varied goals of communi-
cation but is itself rooted in philological and cosmological knowledge and
cannot be effectively utilized without an understanding of such knowledge.
Indeed, writing is an essential mode of codifying a person’s nature from
the moment he or she is conceived, with one type of writing believed to
transmit energy inside the womb to form ma (matter).9 Fu-Kiau has also
contributed immeasurably to the study of graphic writing through his de-
tailed descriptions of how symbols and other forms of graphic signs con-
nect to establish links and associations between rituals, institutions, and
social processes.
Kongo graphic writing systems are also found throughout the Carib-
bean as a result of three centuries of slave trade that brought memories and
beliefs to the region along with Bakongo slaves. Although rich and var-
ied graphic writing traditions are also found in Haiti, Trinidad, Jamaica,
Suriname, Brazil, and Belize, this book focuses on the origins, form, and
uses of graphic writing in Cuba, where demonstrably strong ties with past
and present Central African traditions form a critical part of complex Afro-
Cuban religious and cultural practices. Kongo-Cuban religious practice
utilizes graphic writing in a single narrative system, known as firmas (signa-
tures or ganzus), that integrates distinct written symbols and is used in con-
junction with religious objects and oral traditions.
Robert Farris Thompson was the fi rst scholar to understand and docu-
ment the manner in which multiple forms of visual communication relate
to one another within a single cultural system. His initial study of the ways
various graphic forms were and are used by practitioners of Kongo religions
in both Central Africa and the Caribbean has been instrumental in estab-
lishing links across time and space.
The additional research presented here seeks to continue Thompson’s
work and aims to create a more complete and detailed understanding of

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
50 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

Kongo systems of graphic communication on both sides of the Atlantic. An


examination of the historical roots of such communication modes is fol-
lowed by an exploration and detailed examination of the ways graphic writ-
ing systems are used and understood among modern Bakongo in Central
Africa and a parallel investigation of the fi rma system used widely in con-
temporary Cuba.

ancient memory: rUpeStrian art in centraL africa


Any discussion of the uses of written symbols among the Bakongo in the
present and recent past would be incomplete without an understanding of
the historical origin of these communicative marks. The earliest evidence of
Kongo graphic writing is found in multiple archaeological sites around the
border between Angola and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, an area
that covers close to two hundred kilometers. The cave system in this region
is known as Lovo and is located in the Macizo Calcario of Christ mountains.
The archaeological site starts in the north of Kimpese province in the Dem-
ocratic Republic of the Congo and extends south into the Zaire province
of Angola, ending in the city of Mbanza Kongo, the former capital of the
Kongo kingdom (see Figure 3).
The rupestrian designs found in the Lovo complex were the fi rst visual
evidence of graphic communication in the region and were recorded by
Paul Raymaekers and Hendrik van Moorsel in their work “Lovo: Dessins
rupestres du Bas-Congo,” published in 1963. Their catalog of signs and
symbols included numerous features that have allowed for ongoing study of
the signs’ diversity, their use in space, and a comparison of types and forms
of signs across locations. Raymaekers and van Moorsel’s pioneering work
has been complemented by that of Carlos Ervedosa, José Redinha, Henri
Breuil, and G. Mortelmans, each of whom identified additional archaeolog-
ical sites and documented symbols at multiple Central African rupestrian
locations. Invaluable for their collected material, these initial publications
on the graphic tradition evidenced in the caves did not, however, attempt to
decode the meanings of the signs or investigate their usage in and beyond
the sites; nor did they explore a wider range of past and present Kongo cul-
tural practices in Central Africa or the Caribbean.
Around the same time that Raymaekers and van Moorsel were con-
ducting their work on rupestrian art in Central Africa, Marcel Griaule was
documenting and examining rupestrian signs in West Africa as part of his
detailed work with the Dogon. Le renard pâle (The Pale Fox), which Gri-
aule published in collaboration with G. Dieterlen, catalogs a large num-
ber of rupestrian signs and symbols and explores the Dogon notion of the
cosmos and its interplay with oral history and religious practices.10 As dis-
cussed in Chapter 1, Griaule’s sweeping work was groundbreaking inso-
far as it reflected fi ndings from extensive fieldwork and went beyond mere
documentation of rupestrian signs and other forms of visual expression to
explore the cosmogony underlying and expressed through such forms as

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 51

K e y: 
1 lovo 
2 Kiantapo 
3 Caninguiri 
4 Tchitundo-hulo

f i g U r e 3 map of rupestrian art sites throughout angola and the


democratic republic of Congo. (adapted by the author from a publication
by manuel Jordan, 1996.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
52 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

well as the manner in which graphic expression was part of the very founda-
tion of Dogon cultural principles.
More recently, Fu-Kiau and Thompson built on the work of the ear-
lier scholars documenting rupestrian signs in the Kongo region and made
the fi rst attempts to understand their meanings and explore their relation-
ship with and implications for the study of Kongo morality, philosophy, and
religion. Both authors argue that the rupestrian signs represent the early
history of present-day Kongo graphic expression, but Fu-Kiau contextual-
izes the signs within the Kongo cultural system and uses religious beliefs
and moral philosophy to distinguish between them while Thompson situ-
ates his analysis of the rupestrian signs within a study of art, viewing their
use in a plural system of graphic codification and aesthetic form. Impor-
tantly, Thompson also attempts to link the symbols to present-day signs
used in the Bakongo diaspora. A more detailed comparison across the rup-
estrian symbols documented at Lovo and other regional sites and between
such images and varied forms of contemporary graphic communication fur-
ther highlights their similarities in form and function and traces the devel-
opment of this Kongo language form.
Geometric shapes figure heavily in the designs documented in Lovo,
leading Thompson to characterize the graphic expression as “geometric of
the spirit.”11 As seen in Figure 4, the designs encompass a range of geomet-
ric forms and features, including squares, rectangles, and circles; straight,
convex, and concave lines; and notched, serrated, rounded, and pointed
shapes. These geometric forms and the composition style that dominates at
Lovo are also seen in the decoration of ceramic work unearthed around this
same area and, as discussed later in this chapter, across a variety of graphic
expressions documented in the Mbanza Kongo region in the present day.12
Unfortunately, given the importance of the link these paintings repre-
sent in the history of Central African graphic writing systems, precise in-
formation on their age is unavailable. Raymaekers and van Moorsel noted
aesthetic parallels between the Lovo drawings and cave paintings in Alta-
mira, Spain, that date back approximately twenty thousand years, but no
tests have been conducted to corroborate or disprove such speculative age.
Raymaekers and van Moorsel also argue that the Lovo drawings were made
during the evangelization of the Kongo kingdom, which began with the
conversion of the Mani Kongo Nzinga a Mvemba (Nkuvu) and his wife
in 1491 and continued with the role of their son Mvemba a Nzinga I
(1507–1542).13 To support this argument, the authors reference multiple
fragments of ceramic unearthed at the Lovo site during archaeological ex-
cavations that scientific testing dates to around A.D. 1600.14 Archaeologists
have noted the existence of burial yards containing ceramic remnants, pre-
sumably of funerary character,15 similar to those found at rupestrian sites
in Angola and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, which indicates that
further study of the objects encountered in and around the Lovo caves will
be a critical component of any investigation into the history of the rupes-

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 53

f i g U r e 4 lovo rupestrian painting. (adapted by the author from paul raymaekers and
hendrik van moorsel, “lovo: dessins rupestres du Bas-Congo,” Ngonge, Carnets de sciences
humaines, nos. 12, 13, and 14 [léopoldville, 1962]. image courtesy of paul raymaekers/
hendrik van moorsel.)

trian sites and the role they played for the region’s people. Scientific dating
of other rupestrian sites in Angola discussed in this chapter may provide
some insight into Lovo’s history, but even with the lack of proof of the age
of the rupestrian drawings in Central Africa, their antiquity is undoubted.
More importantly, as discussed later in this chapter, the deep history of

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
54 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

these drawings can be directly connected to symbols that today form part
of a complex system of graphic communication that is informed by Ba-
kongo religious beliefs and moral philosophy.
Before focusing on the actual symbols found in Lovo and more recently
cataloged sites in its immediate vicinity discussed later in this chapter, it is
worth exploring briefly the similarities between these symbols and paint-
ings and carvings discovered in southern Angola and the southern Demo-
cratic Republic of the Congo. Principal sites include Tchitundo-Hulo and
Caninguiri in southern Angola and Kiantapo in the Democratic Republic
of the Congo.
The sites in southern Angola have been dated more precisely than their
northern counterparts, with the Caninguiri drawings found in the Alto
Zambezi zone in southeastern Angola believed to be 7,840 ± 80 years old
and those documented at Tchitundo-Hulo believed to be 2,596 ± 53 years
old, perhaps indicating the time period during which production of rupes-
trian art began to be widespread in Central Africa.16
More importantly, the sites in southern Angola demonstrate continu-
ity with the Lovo site in the subject matter that is portrayed, the relational
positioning of visual vocabulary, and the manner in which the drawings
are conceptualized. For example, all three sets of images contain numer-
ous depictions of figures striking poses and making gestures. The common-
alties in the gestures themselves are informative, as is the common theme
and apparent importance ascribed to body language, an importance that
continues in contemporary Kongo communities, as detailed in Chapter 3.
Another critical area of overlap between the images documented across the
different cave sites is the utilization of single, contained signs as well as
groupings of integrated images that combine different types of communica-
tive elements or linguistic components in the same frame.
The symbols documented at Kiantapo in the southern Democratic Re-
public of the Congo also share important aesthetic traits with those re-
corded at Lovo. Several signs involve arrows indicating directions; others
appear to involve planetary symbols; and the designs at Lovo and Kian-
tapo both contain numerous animal and human images. The primary dif-
ference between the two is the mode of composition: in Lovo the symbols
are drawn with steady solid lines and are painted on the cave wall, whereas
many of those in Kiantapo are created using dotted lines carved into the
stone surface, as seen in Figure 5.
Table 1 compares a wider range of key symbols found in Lovo, Tchi-
tundo-Hulo, and Kiantapo.
Except for Lovo and selected sites in the south of Angola, Central Afri-
can rock art has rarely been incorporated into the broader discussion of
African prehistory, colonial history, and postcolonial history, and no recent
works have been published that document new sites, explore the historic
functions of rock art, or investigate its present and historical relationship
with religious and cultural practices in or beyond Central Africa. The lack
of recent documentation of and research into rock painting and carving in

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 55

f i g U r e 5 rupestrian painting from the Kiantapo site, democratic republic of the


Congo. (adapted by the author from henri Breuil and G. mortelmans, Les figures incisées
et ponctuées de la grotte de Kiantapo [Brussels: Tervuren, 1952]. image courtesy of
henri Breuil.)

Angola is arguably attributable at least in part to the lack of access to the


region during its extended fi fty-year civil war, to the logistical and techni-
cal difficulties associated with reaching the sites and conducting high-level
visual and sound recordings, and to significant cultural barriers to entry
throughout the region.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
56 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 1 Comparison of a wide range of key symbols found in lovo (luvo),


Tchitundo-hulo, and Kiantapo

Lovo tchitundo-hulo Kiantapo


(paul raymaekers) (carlos ervedosa) (henri breuil)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 57

ta b L e 1 (continued)

Lovo tchitundo-hulo Kiantapo


(paul raymaekers) (carlos ervedosa) (henri breuil)

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
58 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 1 (continued)

Lovo tchitundo-hulo Kiantapo


(paul raymaekers) (carlos ervedosa) (henri breuil)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 59

ta b L e 1 (continued)

Lovo tchitundo-hulo Kiantapo


(paul raymaekers) (carlos ervedosa) (henri breuil)

Despite these challenges, research conducted over the course of several


extended trips undertaken since 2002 throughout the Mbanza Kongo-Kin-
shasa area of northern Angola has succeeded in the gathering of additional
physical evidence of past graphic writing and documentation of present-day
use of graphic communication by the Bakongo. Multiple previously unre-
corded rupestrian sites in the region have been identified and documented,
each containing large quantities of rock carvings and paintings that appear
to be dated primarily before the twentieth century. These sites contain
clearly identifiable symbols that are markedly similar in form and style to
both rupestrian art documented elsewhere in Central Africa and symbols
documented in contemporary use. For example, selected geometric shapes
and repeated patterns found at the sites are replicated in contemporary reli-
gious markings, pottery and textile designs, architectural details, and tomb
designs, as explored in more detail in this chapter and the next.
Table 2 tracks, by principal site, the motifs documented in the region
between 2005 and 2007.17 The numbers represent the approximate count
of given motifs recorded in situ.
The site shown in Figure 6, known as Tadi dia Mfuakumbi, or the
“First Engraving,” illustrates an unrivaled fusion of form, aesthetics, and

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
60 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 2 Fifteen categories of representations documented in mbanza Kongo rock-painting sites


between 2005 and 2007 and the number of each category at each site

ne- mfua- nvila- Lu-


motif description mongo kumbi tezua Lovo ntuta yidi kingu

Anthropomorphic
anthropomorphic The human figure is 4 25 1 4 1
represented in its entirety
Fragmentary Only a portion of a human 2 12 2 1
anthropomorphic figure is depicted, e.g.,
torso, headless figure
human foot The figure depicts the 5
human foot, positive or
negative image

Zoomorphic
mammalian figure The figure seemingly
represents a mammal 18 2
mammalian “tracks” The foot (or feet) of a
mammal is represented
Bird figures The figure seemingly 2 6 2 1
represents a bird
Bird “tracks” The foot (or feet) of a bird 2 2
is represented
reptilian figures The depiction suggests 3 6 6
a reptile, e.g., snake, lizard

Geometric; 
Body Ornaments; 
Incised Stones, 
Bowls, and Tools; 
Architectural 
Decorations
rectilinear nonrepresentational figures 15 23 17 3
characterized by straight
lines; formed or bounded
by straight lines
Curvilinear nonrepresentational figures 1 25 37 14 5
consisting of or bounded
by curved lines
Concentric Figures having a common 18 30 27 12 2
center or common axis,
e.g., circle, spiral
abstract geometric motifs or outlines that are 50 9 40 40 28 3
characterized by both
straight and curved lines but
that bear no resemblance to
natural form

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 61

ta b L e 2 (continued)

ne- mfua- nvila- Lu-


motif description mongo kumbi tezua Lovo ntuta yidi kingu

Narratives, 
Dancing Scenes,
Painting,
Drawing
simple composition The depiction is charac- 12 12 5 13 2
terized by a combination
of a few figures and signs
as part of a whole
Complex narratives The depiction is charac- 6 17 3 8
terized by an elaborate
combination of figures
and signs in order to
suggest a story or storyline
palimpsests motifs or outlines that 3 2 2 3 2 2
are characterized by
being redrawn over a
previous form

f i g U r e 6 Tadi dia mfuakumbi, angola, 2004.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
62 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

subject matter and is one of the most complex and well-preserved sites doc-
umented. The images and signs depict numerous Bakongo concepts and are
best described as the material expressions of local oral traditions, including
proverbs, songs, and funeral and wedding chants. For example, an abstract
depiction of the dikenga cross at Tadi dia Mfuakumbi represents the order
of things in the cosmos and the human world and symbolizes the soul. It
is further understood to refer to the proverb “Where it is closed, it cannot
be opened.”18
The location of the Tadi dia Mfuakumbi site is itself culturally signifi-
cant; the site is associated with a local myth that tells of
a young couple a long time ago who liked to swim in the river. Soon after
they were married, they went to the river to celebrate the almighty union.
The village elders learned during the traditional council that the couple
must die in order to honor the spirit who empowered the river. There was
a specific Sîmbi spirit that controlled the river who had requested these
young lives in an appearance in the dreams of the village chief. Accord-
ing to the village priest, the couple had to drown themselves in the water
as a gift to this Sîmbi spirit, but they would later be honored and remem-
bered for their sacrifice and would return in the afterlife as manifestations
of yisimbi themselves.19

The iconography documented at Tadi dia Mfuakumbi is varied, and,


although certain elements—such as the depiction of the human body using
diamond shapes and the depiction of eyes in the form of coffee beans to sig-
nify clairvoyance—are unique and appear somewhat idiosyncratic, many of
the designs demonstrate significant parallels with other depictions in the
area. The images contain several types of iconic motifs that can be catego-
rized into groups of abstract, zoomorphic, and anthropomorphic motifs,
comprising geometric shapes, animals, and humans, respectively. In addi-
tion to such distinct motifs, the Mfuakumbi carvings use an iconic narra-
tive to encode a miscellany of overlaid, superimposed signs and symbols
to allude to a set of key themes central to Bakongo religion, including cre-
ation, nature, the environment, life, death, hunting, and rites of passage.
Mfinda a Ntuta is another prime example of newly documented rock
art, capable of invigorating a discourse on religious meaning, cultural leg-
acy, communication, and literacy among the Bakongo as expressed through
graphic writing practices. The vast number of examples of graphic writing
present at this single site show the breadth and depth of visual forms used in
a ritual context, illustrate a consistency in form with examples documented
at other Central African sites, and suggest that the same site was used and
reused by the local religious community over a significant period of time.
In addition to being central to a contemporary study of past and pres-
ent uses of graphic writing among the Bakongo, these sites continue to
be of material cultural and spiritual significance to the local communities
where they are found. Figure 7 shows the performance at the mouth of the
Nemongo cave of a libation necessary to authorize entry to the site and a

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 63

f i g U r e 7 miguel moises at the mouth of the nemongo cave performing the libation
necessary to authorize the proposed research. right in front of miguel moises is clearly
visible an example of the graphic form depicting a dikenga cosmogram made out of
kaolin (luvenva). palm wine and cola for the libation were critical components of the
performance used to call the spirit of moises’s uncle during my visit to the site. The
dikenga cosmogram is the most frequently observed symbol in Central africa. Tadi dia
nemongo site, angola, 2004.

similar ceremony over a clear example of the dikenga sign (discussed in the
next section).
Sites also continue to be used by initiation societies active in and around
the Mbanza Kongo area, with signs indicating certain societies depicted in
various locations. For example, the flower symbol pictured in the Mfi nda a
Ntuta site (Figure 8) is the emblem of the Lemba society and is frequently
depicted on a range of objects used by and symbolic of its membership.20

f i g U r e 8 luvunisa (contradict), emblem


of the lemba initiatory society. mfinda a ntuta
site, angola, 2005.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
64 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

Many of the signs carved into rupestrian sites documented near Mbanza
Kongo represent local proverbs and form part of a broader fabric of oral tra-
ditions and local religious practices. Two clear concepts in graphic writing,
inventory, and complex narrative are visible in the rupestrian sites and cor-
respond to two phases in the development of Kongo culture. The building
of inventory was the pooling by Bantu agricultural settlers of visual tools
for conveying meaning in early rupestrian sites. In addition to the simple
pooling of symbols, the gathering and organizing of visual concepts facil-
itated the development of complex iconic narratives, which in turn played
an essential role in the religious cognition and further organization of soci-
ety through the extended family, the creation of specialized societies, and
the later formation of the Kongo organizational hierarchies. The location
of the graphic writing at specific, presumably strategic sites in the rain for-
est, gallery forest, and savanna highlights the central role of graphic writing
in early Bantu cultural and social organization and suggests the impor-
tance of such sites to the Bantu of the region, and it may indicate potential
migratory routes. The use of increasingly complex graphic expression rep-
resented a communication breakthrough and required a more significant
degree of coordination and contextualization. Its fi rst stage required a con-
ceptual leap that permitted users to connect a common set of abstract and
pictographic representations to a unique meaning grounded in Kongo cul-
tural principles. The distinct geometric and pictographic signs and symbols
were later contextualized in a broader visual narrative that incorporated the
objects and ritual practices discussed elsewhere in this book.
The examples shown in Figures 9 through 21 are representative of the
manner in which the symbols depicted both incorporate and reference ele-
ments from such traditions and highlight the richness of meanings embed-
ded in and conveyed by graphic writing. Although precise dating of the
specific sites has not been done, the choice of signs, along with the knowl-
edge regarding their meanings among members of the community, speaks
to a continuity in understanding and use of the practice as a mode of com-
municating community concerns and cultural lessons.
Other scholars interested in the social and historical context surround-
ing the production of rupestrian art have explored alternative theories to
explain the use and meaning of documented signs and symbols. David
Lewis-Williams and Thomas Dowson, in connection with their work on
rock art in southern Africa, have posited that geometric motifs found across
a range of rupestrian sites are representations of images seen in the dis-
sociative state of a divinatory or similar trance. Although such a thesis is
intriguing and can be helpful in understanding basic prehistoric human
biology, I believe that this notion of an “altered state of consciousness” is
limited insofar as it makes a generalized assertion that all humans can and
will understand the specific meanings of early rock painting iconography
in the same manner because we share the same basic biology and brain cir-
cuitry. Furthermore, an inquiry into Kongo culture in Central Africa and
the diaspora requires an understanding of the process of cognition and the

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 65

f i g U r e 9 “Tuna mvovela lendo lua nzambi” is


a proverb meaning, “We are talking about God’s
power.” The double arrow indicates masculinity,
lightning, fecundity, and power. The northeast
direction of the arrow symbolizes ascent to the
ancestral realm and communication with those
responsible for bringing fertility and healing rain.
The double arrow signifies the transcendence of
an earthly state during the initiation rite. Tadi dia
mfuakumbi site, angola, 2004.

f i g U r e 10 “vena owu kevakadi owu ko” is a


proverb meaning, “Where it is closed, it cannot
be opened.” The cross represents the order of
things in the cosmos and the human world and
symbolizes the soul. Tadi dia mfuakumbi site,
angola, 2004.

f i g U r e 11 Zoomorphic motif.
“O nsusu vokelaya nga makiko ngola
negola” is a proverb meaning, “The
hen that does not warm up its eggs
will lose its chicks.” Tadi dia mfuakumbi
site, angola, 2004.

f i g U r e 12 anthropomorphic motif. “disu


muna disu, mena muna meno.” Traditional law
(nsiku) and system for justice (ndembo). Tadi dia
mfuakumbi site, angola, 2004.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
66 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

f i g U r e 13 “mvu ke mvu mia nkundalala” is f i g U r e 14 “Wanda wa lufua” is a proverb


a proverb meaning, “years of glory have forever meaning, “We all face death.” mfinda a ntuta site,
passed.” mfinda a ntuta site, angola, 2005. angola, 2005.

f i g U r e 15 Wanda: the cosmos, f i g U r e 16 “vena o mbuta vena mpe a nlenke


universe, and world. mfinda a ntuta vena mpe diadi o yalanga” is a proverb meaning,
site, angola, 2005. “Where are adults, are children.” mfinda a ntuta
site, angola, 2005.

17 18 19
f i g U r e S 17–19 17: “nduakilu za mbote,” Welcome and hospitality. 18: The universe is just one,
everything is connected. 19: Futumuka, resurrection. mfinda a ntuta site, angola, 2005.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 67

f i g U r e 2 0 an iconic motif: “ndiata a lunwenya” is a proverb meaning, “Warning sign;


wisdom.” Tadi dia lukingu site, angola. (drawing in situ by Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, 2006.)

f i g U r e 21 The triangle that joins the right edge of the ladder represents the
ancestors in relation to the family. The ladder represents a family or a family’s history.
The ladder represents people. Tadi dia lukingu site, angola. (drawing in situ by Bárbaro
martínez-ruiz, 2006.)

mechanics of writing that is not addressed by Lewis-Williams and Dowson.


More useful than a generalization about altered consciousness is an expla-
nation focused on the nature of graphic forms and on how humans acquire,
produce, and use knowledge and a study of the emancipatory political and
cultural functions associated with writing in a society faced with a hege-
monic cultural system. Although there is no defi nitive way of knowing how
symbols were originally designed or where early rupestrian artists got their
inspiration from, and although divinatory practices involving dissociation

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
68 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

are an important part of traditional religious practice, the clear continuity


of designs across Bakongo sites and with symbols used in a range of other
religious and cultural practices argues for the existence of a more complex
and cognizant process underlying the development and continued use of
the most prominent rupestrian signs.

the almighty dikenga

The most powerful example of the graphic continuity between the Lovo
paintings, the engravings at the newly documented sites, and contemporary
symbol usage among the Bakongo in Central Africa and their descendants
in Cuba is the frequent appearance of dikenga. Dikenga is a cosmogram
considered crucial to Kongo cosmology in that it represents the conception
of all living beings in the universe.21 In addition, dikenga is itself believed
and understood to be the energy of the universe, the force of all existence
and creation.
The basic graphic structure of dikenga is four cardinal points at the tips
of two lines arranged in cross formation, similar to a compass. The tremen-
dous diversity in the documented representations of dikenga illustrates sub-
stantial design flexibility, but the consistent inclusion of the cosmogram’s
basic principles confi rms the central meaning and use of the cosmogram.
Fu-Kiau highlights the diversity in representations of dikenga in Figure 22.
Like Fu-Kiau, Thompson has illustrated a range of dikenga represen-
tations, as seen in Figure 23. Thompson perceptively includes a diamond-
shaped dikenga, arguing that the dikenga’s meaning is maintained with or
without dots in the corners and holds constant whether depicted in cross,
circle, or diamond form. In Kongo culture, the diamond shape is used to
signify Nzambi Mpungo, God, and is used as the heart of sacred objects.22

f i g U r e 2 2 Bunseki Fu-Kiau series of signs. (adapted by the author from K. K. Bunseki


Fu-Kiau, Cosmogonie Congo [Kinshasa: Onrd, 1969].)

f i g U r e 2 3 robert Farris Thompson series of signs. (adapted by the author from


robert Farris Thompson, The Four Moments of the Sun [Washington, dC: national Gallery
of art, 1981]. image courtesy of robert Farris Thompson.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 69

24 25 26 27

f i g U r e S 2 4 –27 dikenga and yowa crosses. (adapted by the author from


K. K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau, Cosmogonie Congo [Kinshasa: Onrd, 1969].)

Dikenga is often shown in a form more similar to that of a traditional


Christian cross. In such a form, it is called yowa or kilisu, and is most often
used in the context of initiation rituals. For example, individuals initiated
into the Bakongo Lemba society generally wear a yowa to indicate their
membership. Although they maintain the basic meaning of dikenga, yowa
cosmograms tend to be understood as closer to the Western crucifi x, a ten-
dency resulting from syncretic religious practices in Central Africa.23 The
examples seen in Figures 24 through 27 were documented by Fu-Kiau in
the southern Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Bakongo culture ascribes to each cardinal point of the dikenga cos-
mogram an ontological meaning that symbolizes a segment of the broader
transition between various stages of life. The four points of dikenga tell of a
journey of the community’s accumulation, interpretation, and transmission
of knowledge. The cosmogram represents each human as “a living sun”24
and marks the phases through which individuals progress as they develop a
conscience, take on responsibility, and assume a sense of belonging to reli-
gious, political, cultural, familial, and national communities. Faïk-Nzuji’s
work among the Luba-Kasai people echoes this representation, describing
dikenga as illustrative of life’s principles as seen through the biological, psy-
chological, and spiritual journey of a human life.25
In the form of a circle, the points of the cosmogram will be read coun-
terclockwise, beginning at the bottom, the southernmost point on the
dikenga. The counterclockwise motion represents a rising in the east and
a movement toward the west, then back again. Fu-Kiau explains that the
counterclockwise motion is believed by religious practitioners in Mbanza
Kongo to indicate the path the living take to meet their ancestors.
As described by Fu-Kiau, the southern cardinal point indicates not
birth but the moment of conception of a child or the beginning of a per-
son in the community. Like a sunrise, it illuminates human life, recognizes
the power of fertility, and symbolizes the moment of entering the world of
the living and exchanging power with the ancestors in nature. The eastern
cardinal point symbolizes the beginning of an individual’s transformation
into a full member of society through the learning of social rules and the
accepting of responsibility within the family and community. The north-
ern cardinal point stands for the transformation of accumulated experience

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
70 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

into intellectual power facilitated by interaction between the individual and


other members of the community. Finally, the western cardinal point rep-
resents the transmission of society’s accumulated critical knowledge to the
younger generation, the moment of departure, comprehension, and under-
standing.26 Dikenga’s four points are also recognized by and incorporated
into religious practices in present-day Mbanza Kongo: the southern point
is called ngutuka, which means “to be born”; the eastern point, kindende,
which represents adolescence; the northern point, nvuta, which means
adulthood; and the fourth position, vunda, which means “to rest” and im-
plies the moment of death.27
The circular motion through the four points is repetitive, implying
both a transition beyond death to another stage and the continued involve-
ment of the ancestors with the ongoing cycle of life. A similar cyclical con-
cept of life and regeneration is expressed in a Kongo proverb that states,
“We are leaves in the tree of the human race.”28 Dikenga’s allusion to the
principal stages of life makes it an ideal sign to mark or otherwise signify
the passing from one stage to another; hence it is frequently used in Kongo
tomb decoration.
Fu-Kiau expands on the understanding of each of dikenga’s positions as
stages in the journey of human life by comparing them to the path taken by
the sun, stating that “the way of the sun is without end around the world,
the life of the human is another sun in his outline.”29 Because the sun rep-
resents Nzambi Mpungo, or God, this metaphor is particularly powerful
and confi rms the importance of the dikenga in Bakongo culture. The four
suns that correspond to the cosmogram’s cardinal points and their symbolic
meanings and associated colors are as follows:

1. Musoni sun (yellow sun)—sun of perfection


2. Kala sun (black sun)—sun of vitality
3. Tukula sun (red sun)—sun of warning (danger)
4. Luvemba sun (gray/white sun)—sun of death and change

The core signs that build on the dikenga cosmogram are Sînsu kian-
gudi kia nza-kongo,30 described as the general symbol of Kongo cosmog-
ony, and Dingo-dingo dia Luzîngu,31 which represents life’s spiral motion
and the manner in which a “human being’s life is a continuous process of
transformation, of going around and around” and “being in continuous
motion through the four stages of balance between a vertical force and hor-
izontal force.”32
Thompson, in Faces of the Gods, explains the meaning of dikenga in
terms similar to those used by Fu-Kiau. Describing its function in moral
and philosophical terms, Thompson writes that dikenga

charts the soul’s timeless voyage. Soul cycles as a star in heaven. To the Ba-
kongo it is a shining circle, a miniature of the sun. [Dikenga marks] the
sun’s four moments—dawn, noon, sunset, and midnight (when it’s shining

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 71

in the other world)—by small circles at the end of each arm of the cross,
mirroring the immortal progress of the soul: birth, full strength, fading,
renaissance. The four corners of a diamond tell the same sequence.33

For Thompson, the dikenga sign tracks the “Bakongo geometry of


spirit,” using circles, diamonds, spirals, and crosses to portray spiritual fl ight
across each corner of the world.34 This discussion of dikenga highlights the
function of the graphic form as a foundation of the Bakongo cultural sys-
tem and, by indicating that the graphic form is more than mere decoration,
alludes to its importance in linking communicative structures, art, religious
expression, and philosophy.
The dikenga cosmogram is defi ned largely by two important elements
of its design, the intersecting lines, kalûnga and mukula,35 and the cosmo-
gram cannot be fully understood without a discussion of their meaning.
Kalûnga is the horizontal line stretching from east to west. As discussed in
greater detail in Chapter 3, kalûnga plays a complex yet fundamental role in
Bakongo cosmology and cosmogony. It is the energy that is believed to have
created all life, the boundary that divides this world from that of the ances-
tors, a source of power, a sensation of movement, and an agent for spiritual
cleansing. Although this entire broad and multilayered concept is contained
within the horizontal line of dikenga’s cross, different components of its
meaning are emphasized depending on the context and manner in which
the cosmogram is used. For example, when the dikenga sign is used to
indicate a family unit, the kalûnga line merely signifies the union between
husband and wife, whereas when dikenga is used in divination, kalûnga rep-
resents the division between the realms of the living and the dead. Refer-
ring to the Bakongo creation myth in which the kalûnga force creates the
world out of the emptiness, Fu-Kiau explains the force’s depiction and role
in dikenga as a line or space of emptiness. The Kongo conception of emp-
tiness is vastly different from Western understandings of the term in that
the Kongo believe that it is in the so-called emptiness that the spirits reside.
While empty of physical human life, such space is full of energy and spir-
itual forces so that “man’s life is surrounded by diverse forces and waves
which govern it.”36
Vertically intersecting kalûnga in the dikenga cosmogram is the mu-
kula line. Mukula means “to grow” and “[to gain a] full understanding of
the principles of life or living (N’kîngu miazîngila), principles that could as-
sist in keeping [life’s] potential power and passing it on safely to one’s off-
spring.”37 These principles are taught by ancestors and transferred along
mukula, traveling upward to the land of the living. Mukula is understood in
Palo Monte as “the axis of time” and can be described as the corridor of the
spirits, a pathway that is used by the ancestors to cross the land of the dead
and assist their beloved people over Kalûnga.38 The junction where these
two lines cross is called muntu ya kuluzu, which means “to grow up in the
cross,”39 and is believed to represent a unique personal identity for each in-
dividual, signifying such an individual’s destiny in life.40

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
72 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

dikenga in cuba: the circle of new Life

The dikenga cosmogram and the complex set of meanings it conveys also
play a central role in Kongo-descended religious and cultural practices in
Cuba, where it is known as nkuyu and is referred to by Palo Monte practition-
ers as “the abstract thing from Congo.”41 It is used to depict the belief in
powerful spirits of nature and to represent cosmological elements, and, like
dikenga in Africa, nkuyu is itself understood to be a spiritual force. It is a
manifestation of the power of creation and the energy of the universe, thus
becoming the ultimate affi rmation of God, the ancestors, and other spiri-
tual forces. The term nkuyu itself comes from Kikongo, although its precise
etymological origin and meaning are unclear. Laman describes nkuyu as a
kind of nkisi among the Bembe and neighboring cultures and writes that
the term nkuyu is generally used to refer to “the spirit of a deceased person
that has been captured and incorporated into a sculpture.”42
Nkuyu has similarly been associated with an nkisi in Cuba, with Lydia
Cabrera describing an nkuyu as “a wooden doll of about sixty centimeters
into which the priest makes the spirit enter.”43 Cabrera notes that the main
function of nkuyu in Palo Monte is to protect the worshiper, but recognizes
that other forces intervene in the religious performance.44 Describing a sim-
ple cosmogram, Cabrera writes, “The circle signifies security. In the cen-
ter of the circle, the cross is the power; the power of all the spiritual powers
called by the priest (nganga).”45
Building on references provided by Fernando Ortiz in the early 1950s,
Wyatt MacGaffey writes about dikenga in Cuba: “Across the Atlantic,
Kongo ritual experts in Cuba represent the cosmos as a circle divided into
four segments by a cross inscribed in it.”46 MacGaffey’s account is consis-
tent with those of other scholars and experts on Cuba, including Cabrera,
Argeliers León, and Thompson. It is also confi rmed by Palo Monte priests
Fresneda Bachiller and Garcia Villamil, who describe contemporary styles
of nkuyu depiction. Whereas the basic form is the circle and cross, shown
in Figure 36, numerous design modifications are made that add fi nesse or
detail to the cosmogram in different contexts, as explored in further detail
later in this chapter.
The circular shape of nkuyu is significant insofar as a circle is a par-
ticularly meaningful sign in Palo Monte; it is most closely associated with
the world of the ancestors. It symbolizes protection, time, perfection, the
receipt of energy, balance and existence, and the realm of initiation. Like
dikenga, the circle is the pathway through which spiritual fl ight crosses the
frontier that divides the living from the dead. For this reason, nkuyu is
also known by the term lucero, which means “star” or “circle of new life.”
The lucero is believed to be a gateway through which change occurs, and
it is used within the religion to represent the crossing from one world to
another and the beginning of a new life.47
Like their counterparts in Angola, graves in Cuban cemeteries display
numerous depictions of dikenga to mark the passage from one world to the

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 73

next. The use of dikenga at grave sites has also been recorded in other parts
of the Americas. Robert Farris Thompson writes about the grave-marking
tradition in the southern United States in Faces of the Gods. He specifically
references African American graves in Virginia, Florida, and southwestern
Mississippi, writing:
The circle of the soul around the interesting worlds—the rhetorical point
of the Kongo cosmogram (dikenga, “the tuning”)—echoes throughout
the black Americas. The circle is “written” in a curved length of green
garden hose on a headstone in black Austin and echoed by other exam-
ples. Another instance of cryptic sparking of the soul and continuity, with
an image of the sun in motion, is an object-studded inner garden built
around a cedar tree.48

The cross within the lucero’s circle maps the forces of the universe,
dividing the space into four parts that represent the cosmos, nature, the
atmosphere, and humans and human creation. The four positions them-
selves are symbols of power: the north represents God or the almighty
forces of creation; the south represents animals; the east represents plants
and trees; and the west represents minerals.49 These positions are collec-
tively called “The Four Winds” by Fresneda Bachiller and Garcia Villamil,
who describe the unity of the four parts as responsible for the creation of all
existence and describe the parts collectively as the principles of the universe.
As noted earlier, while the circle and cross form the basic structure of
the lucero, a wide range of different designs have been documented as being
used across Cuba. The fourteen examples in Figures 28 through 41, drawn
by Fresneda Bachiller and Garcia Villamil over the past two decades, illus-
trate this range.

28 29 30 31

32 33 34 35

f i g U r e S 2 8 –35 Circle-of-new-life signs in the palo monte religion in Cuba. (From


Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1988.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
74 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

36 37 38

39 40 41

f i g U r e S 3 6 – 41 more circle-of-new-life signs in the palo monte religion in Cuba.


(From Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1988.)

In Palo Monte, the lucero is always used in practice in conjunction with


a spiritual force. In Cuba each religious object (prenda) needs a lucero in
order to function. It is the lucero that gives the spirit inhabiting the prenda
the ability to travel and communicate with other forces and Palo practi-
tioners. The lucero is described as a guiding light, the eyes of the pren-
da’s spirit. To be guided in this way, all prendas must physically sit on a
depiction of the lucero. Cabrera describes this arrangement, writing, “The
Prenda sits on a circle that represents the ocean (Kalûnga). In the middle,
another circle is the earth. The cross is the ‘four winds.’”50 Figures 42 and
43 show two examples of luceros on altars documented, respectively, by
Fresneda Bachiller in the Cotorro municipality in Cuba, 2000, and by Gar-
cia Villamil in Los Angeles, California, 2001.
While all functioning prendas must sit on a lucero cosmogram, not all
luceros are used for such purpose. Instead, they are employed in a wide
variety of contexts for a range of purposes. In the fourteen examples in
Figures 28 through 41, the modification of the design reflects the cosmo-
gram’s partner force, its function, and the location where it is used. The
distinct characteristics of the signs in each of these figures and their uses are
given in Table 3.
The use of nkuyu exemplifies a type of religious practice in Palo Monte
that is based on the notion of contract (nkandu). This type of contract re-
fers not to a legal commitment but to an agreement between humans, an-
cestors, and natural forces. It alludes to ritual methodology used in Palo
Monte in order to establish the principles underlying the manipulation of
vibrations during a ritual performance and forms a contractual commitment
between the forces and vibrations controlled by a priest and endorsed or ac-
tivated within the prenda. In the nkuyu, each of the cardinal points and the
center of the cosmogram represent one of the following types of contract.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 75

figUre 42
example of a lucero,
provided by Osvaldo
Fresneda Bachiller.
(photograph by lisa
maya Knauer, 2000.)

South: contracts with animals, with the energy


of the animals that represents natural and
cosmic forces
East: contracts with vegetation, with the energy
of plants, herbage, and trees
North: contract with the psychic world, energy
of psychological manifestation as dreams,
hallucinations, intuitions, and spirit com-
munication
West: contracts with the elements, energy of
nature and cosmos manifested as fi re, vol-
canic eruptions, tornadoes, earthquakes,
and bodies of the universe such as planets,
stars, and comets
Center: contracts of combination, energy as
the result of combining two or more of
the other modalities
The colors used in luceros in Cuba are also im-
portant to an understanding of their role and con- f i g U r e 4 3 example of a lucero from
textual meaning. Each cardinal point, as well as Felipe Garcia villamil, 2002.
the center of the lucero, is associated with a color
and a meaning. The associations are similar to those described by Bunseki
Fu-Kiau in his work on dikenga among Kikongo-speaking cultural groups
in Central Africa and are described by Fresneda Bachiller and Garcia Villa-
mil as follows:
South: Yellow—fresh water, the river or Sîmbi spirit
North: Red—change, transformation, dangerous situation

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
76 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 3 in the fourteen examples in Figures 28–41, the modification of the design reflects the
cosmogram’s partner force, its function, and the location where it is used. This table gives the distinct
characteristics and uses of each figure.

figure description

28 The most basic form of lucero. marks the place where the spirit will land. Generally used under a
prenda, under the bed, or under a glass of water.
29 Used to interact with the spirit using gunpowder or sulfur. To clean and protect physical locations,
such as the four corners of a home or the crossroads.
30 Used in the course of a graphic narrative, as part of a larger firma. Used in war or to defend against
a spiritual threat, to win the battle.
31 Used to convey a treaty or partnership between nkuyu and sarabanda and Gurufinda.
Joins together the healing and communication powers of all three spirits to be expressed
through nkuyu.
32 Used to resolve situations related to housing, to bring harmony and protection to a home.
33 lucero partnered with Tiembla Tierra, or “earthquake.” Used to cool down or relax a person.
34 Called Cuatro Vientos (Four Winds) Kangome Nfuiry, it is made out of vegetable fibers and
functions as a guide for the prenda spirits.
35 Used for marking the location of the prenda inside the religious room and to anchor or ground
the power of the prenda. also means a graveyard; used to call spirits resting in a graveyard.
36 represents long life, peace, and living in harmony. Used to protect the longevity of humans.
37 Used in the course of a graphic narrative, as part of a larger firma. Used to invoke the power of the
four cardinal points as one.
38 Used in the course of a graphic narrative, as part of a larger firma. Used only at night. When
rituals are performed outdoors, used to prevent disruptions or interference from other spirits or
problems and keep concentration focused in the ritual.
39 represents the earth and all its forces.
40 Used in the course of a graphic narrative, as part of a larger firma. represents the earth and all
its forces.
41 Used in the course of a graphic narrative, as part of a larger firma. Used “to take the corner of
the enemy,” to target a rival location, and to take control of that place. palo monte practitioners
believe that the corner is what protects an individual. To take control over a person’s life, it is first
necessary to take possession of this corner and then to penetrate the spirits that command the
individual’s house.

West: White—purity, perfection


East: Black—underground or death
Center: Blue—(Egáno) indestructible, pure energy, such as morning
dew or rays of the sun, and wholesomeness. It marks the beginning
of the motion of energy and the spiritual journey in the circle.
And like dikenga in Central Africa, nkuyu is linked conceptually to
the sun and its stages. The sun represents the strongest and most brilliant
lucero, or star, and its various points, or stages, are believed to signify indi-
vidual human development and to illustrate the journey through one world
and into the next. In an ever setting and rising cycle, the sun represents the
infi nity of life.
The image in Figure 44, from the Palo Monte Loango branch practiced
in the Cuban provinces of Pinar del Rio and Matanzas, shows a sequence
of different representations of the sun in its five critical stages. These suns,

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 77

figUre 44
example of a
sequence of different
representations of
the sun, provided by
Osvaldo Fresneda
Bachiller. (From
Bárbaro martínez-
ruiz, personal
collection, 1989.)

representing different times of day, can be used in one of two ways. First,
the suns serve as a form of announcement, a mode of displaying when a cer-
emonial event will take place. Second, when they are drawn within a divi-
nation ritual, the suns inform the subject the time of the day at which an
important approaching event will occur.
From left to right, the fi rst, Lemba, represents from 6:00 A.M. to 10:00
A.M.; the second, Cuna Lemba, from 10:00 A.M. to noon; the third, Dia-
lemba, from noon to 1:00 P.M.; the fourth, Ndoki Lemba, or Brave Sun,
from 1:00 P.M. to 5:45 P.M.; and the fi fth, Vasco, or Winter Sun, from 5:45
P.M. to midnight. In addition, each representation of the sun is related to a
series of numbers that add further meaning in the context of a divination
ritual. In this case, the picture represents God as officiate of the transaction
of energy through the graphic. It also means that an extraordinary thing
will happen in one’s own home by order of God.

dikenga’s journey

The conceptual, theological, and aesthetic parallels in form and meaning


of dikenga between present-day Central Africa and Cuba are clear. Dikenga
can also be used as a powerful example to demonstrate the strong aesthetic
ties between ancient cave paintings and contemporary signs on both sides of
the Atlantic. Because dikenga represents the ultimate graphic design, con-
taining key concepts of Bakongo religious belief, oral history, cosmogony,
and philosophy, and depicting in miniature the Bakongo conceptual world
and universe, it is particularly telling that, as seen in the drawings from
Lovo in Figure 45, dikenga was also centrally and frequently represented
among the signs made by the ancient users of the caves.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
78 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

f i g U r e 4 5 lovo rupestrian painting. (adapted by the


author from paul raymaekers and hendrik van moorsel,
“lovo: dessins rupestres du Bas-Congo,” Ngonge, Carnets
de sciences humaines, nos. 12, 13, and 14 [léopoldville,
1962]. image courtesy of paul raymaekers and hendrik
van moorsel.)

Adding to the complexity of the study of


this sign is the multitude of ways it has been rep-
resented in the caves. Among the dikenga signs
found in Lovo, the six representations shown
in Figures 46 through 51 illustrate this range
of designs.
Seen collectively, and when compared to the
dikenga signs pictured earlier by Fu-Kiau and
Thompson, it is clear that each of these symbols
illustrates the dikenga cosmogram. Although
the designs are fundamentally similar, the dif-
ferences between them, discussed in the series of examples that follows,
highlight the manner in which such changes are used to convey certain
meanings and to emphasize different component features of dikenga. These
subtle and important differences among the Lovo depictions are partic-
ularly telling insofar as they indicate a high level of comprehension and
a complex process for assigning meaning among the ancient artists who
made them.

46 47 48

49 50 51

f i g U r e S 4 6 – 51 examples of lovo signs, lovo rupestrian painting. (adapted by the


author from paul raymaekers and hendrik van moorsel, “lovo: dessins rupestres du Bas-
Congo,” Ngonge, Carnets de sciences humaines, nos. 12, 13, and 14 [léopoldville, 1962].
image courtesy of paul raymaekers and hendrik van moorsel.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 79

Example 1
The Lovo dikenga shown in Figure 46 includes several important features.
The horizontal line is sharply drawn, with three lines that cross in the cen-
ter and two concentric circles at each endpoint. The vertical line is crowned
by multiple smaller circles at its two endpoints, a set of three circles at its
north end and two more at its south end. It is believed that three circles
control one’s life, so safety is found in three circles. The image of three cir-
cles is related to the Bakongo proverb that holds, “If something will hap-
pen, you will be told three times.”51 The idea of three is also associated
with love, truth, and justice. Marking the southernmost point with two cir-
cles in this example indicates completion or an ending. The placement of
circle pairs in this design shows the counterclockwise motion of the circle
from this point to its resting place in the west. Two other elements in this
cosmogram are clearly emphasized: the demarcation of the northern point,
which represents the moment of physical, spiritual, and intellectual growth,
and the emphasis of the horizontal kalûnga line reaching beyond the main
circle. The emphasis on the northern point suggests that this represents a
dikenga in the Tukula position, symbolizing the moment of growth, forma-
tion of society, and the highest moment of spiritual and physical develop-
ment. This dikenga shares features with two contemporary representations:
the example in Figure 52 also emphasizes the circular endpoints and is con-
tained within a double circle, while the example in Figure 53 illustrates the
singling out of one cardinal point.

Example 2
The example from Lovo in Figure 48 has a much larger center than other
representations. A large center, emphasizing the center point of the dikenga,
represents perfection and is seen frequently in Chokwe culture. This Lovo
image also differs from the others in that in this position it is not aligned
with a traditional cross, but is instead rotated 45 degrees. Despite this shift,
it is likely that the meaning is the same.

Example 3
The diamond shape in the center of the Lovo dikenga shown in Figure
49 is a sign of God. A diamond signifies Nzambi a Mpungu, and its loca-
tion inside the dikenga indicates protection. The oversized triangles that

f i g U r e S 52 – 53 Two examples
of dikenga sign. (adapted by the
author from K. K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau,
Cosmogonie Congo [Kinshasa:
52 53 Onrd, 1969].)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
80 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

represent the dikenga’s cardinal points in this example are notable in that
triangular shapes also represent God and imply perfection, a message of
accomplishment emphasized by their size. The large triangles also suggest
a propeller wheel, indicating motion of the sign in the counterclockwise
direction of the ancestors. The propeller is formed by two combinations:
one is composed of the two triangles joined vertically across the diamond’s
center, representing the joining of humans and ancestors with God; the
second is made up of the horizontally facing triangles, which also indicate
motion, dialectic change, and transformation. Together the two axes allow
humans and ancestors to spin and move together as one, protected by God
as they move toward the underworld.
The example of dikenga in Figure 54, from Kuba, shares these char-
acteristics. The diamond center indicates God, and the oversized cardinal
points, although not triangular, form propellers and indicate collective mo-
tion toward the world of the ancestors. The dual spirals in the center of the
diamond also demonstrate centripetal and centrifugal movement. Clémen-
tine Faïk-Nzuji explains the spiral, stating that coming up to the center
from below conveys positive evolution, progress, and growth, and the com-
ing into the center from outside indicates regression and fleeing.52

Example 4
The Lovo dikenga in Figure 50 emphasizes, through its absence, the north
cardinal point. As described earlier, this position on a dikenga represents
maturity or adulthood and can also be used to indicate a warning of dan-
ger.53 The vertical mukula line is depicted here as a tunnel from the world
of the ancestors opening up into the realm of the living. The large circles
representing the remaining three cardinal points indicate protection. Fi-
nally, as in the above depictions, the diamond structure and the emphasized
four triangles represent the force of God. The dikenga in Figure 55, pro-

f i g U r e 5 4 Kuba lembéta sign. (adapted by the


author from Clémentine Faïk-nzuji, Arts africains: Signes et
symboles [Brussels: deBoeck Université, 2000].)

f i g U r e 55 dikenga sign documented by robert Farris


Thompson. (adapted from robert Farris Thompson, The Four
Moments of the Sun [Washington, dC: national Gallery of art,
1981]. image courtesy of robert Farris Thompson, 1969.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 81

vided by Robert Farris Thompson, also involves four large, prominent cir-
cular points framing a perfect diamond comprising four triangles.

Example 5
The depiction of a Lovo dikenga in Figure 51 is also unique in a couple of
respects. First, it emphasizes the western cardinal point by making it larger
and farther from the center. The western point indicates death and regen-
eration, the reincarnation of living beings, and is also emphasized, through
its absence, in the Cuban dikenga in Figure 32, drawn by Osvaldo Fresneda
Bachiller. Second, the Lovo example strongly demonstrates its counter-
clockwise motion through its streaming, curving points. This sense of mo-
tion is echoed in Fresneda Bachiller’s example as well as in the dikenga
examples by Thompson (Figure 55) and Garcia Villamil (Figure 56).

f i g U r e 5 6 Circle-of-new-life sign. (By Felipe Garcia


villamil. Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1988.)

manual of rupestrian Signs

Although the sign of dikenga may be the most important of the signs found
in Lovo that are widely used in the present day, it is by no means the only
such example. Table 4 illustrates forty-eight signs found in Lovo and com-
pares them with signs used today in Mbanza Kongo, Angola, and by Palo
Monte priests in Cuba.
A fi nal rupestrian site worthy of mention is Tadi dia Sîmbi (or Ntadi dya
Simbi) (Figure 57). According to Ntinu Nzaku Nevunda, Tadi dia Sîmbi is
a large rock shelter located in the Lovo mountains near the Angola–Dem-
ocratic Republic of the Congo border. Unlike other rupestrian art found
in the Lovo region, the written symbols found in Tadi dia Sîmbi have not
been seen elsewhere. This site is mentioned here for contrast and to further
emphasize both the role played by graphic writing among the ancient peo-
ple of Central Africa and the complexity of its form and use evidenced in
the archaeological record.
Tadi dia Sîmbi is also known as Kuna Mboma (Two Bells) and, accord-
ing to surviving members of the royal family and to local traditional priests,
it was the location used to prepare the body of the deceased king before
passing his power on to the new king. The ceremony in the sanctuary is
called Mpindi a Tadi and is used to elevate the spirit of the king through
a mummification process that takes between five and seven years. It is only

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
82 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 4 Forty-eight signs found in lovo compared with signs used today in mbanza Kongo,
angola, and by palo monte priests in Cuba

Lovo bidimbu firmas firmas (osvaldo


(paul raymaekers) (mbanza Kongo) (felipe garcia villamil) fresneda bachiller)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 83

ta b L e 4 (continued)

Lovo bidimbu firmas firmas (osvaldo


(paul raymaekers) (mbanza Kongo) (felipe garcia villamil) fresneda bachiller)

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
84 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 4 (continued)

Lovo bidimbu firmas firmas (osvaldo


(paul raymaekers) (mbanza Kongo) (felipe garcia villamil) fresneda bachiller)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 85

ta b L e 4 (continued)

Lovo bidimbu firmas firmas (osvaldo


(paul raymaekers) (mbanza Kongo) (felipe garcia villamil) fresneda bachiller)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
86 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

f i g U r e 57 Tadi dia sîmbi rock art. (adapted by the


author from a publication by robert Farris Thompson, Le
geste Kôngo [paris: musée dapper, 2002]. image courtesy of
robert Farris Thompson.)
57.1: rebirth in reference to the king’s soul crossing into
the other world, compromise; 57.2: good guidance,
offering; 57.3: long life and health, intimacy; 57.4: the center
cosmogram that activates the whole drawing and links all
of its parts; 57.5: good agricultural season, seriousness; 57.6:
maturity, wealth, prosperity, and generosity; 57.7: death,
protection.

57.1

57. 2 57. 3 57. 4

57.7

57. 5 57. 6

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 87

after the process is completed that the body can be interred in the ground,
at which point the lemba ceremony is performed to crown the new king
and connect him with the traditional spirits. The complex graphic writing
engraved on the surface of the rock in the cave contains instructions for the
performance used to elevate the spirit through the seven levels of existence
of the human soul and both guides and expresses the community’s wishes
for the rule of the new king.
The design is subdivided into seven major parts (see Details 57.1
through 57.7), corresponding to wishes that are expressed during the cere-
mony and are expected to be satisfied during the fi rst year of the new king’s
government. The seven parts symbolize the seven levels of existence, and,
taken as a whole, they represent the constant changes in the two worlds (the
worlds of the living and the dead). The meanings associated with each level
are as follows:

1. Rebirth in reference to the king’s soul crossing into the other world,
compromise
2. Good guidance, offering
3. Long life and health, intimacy
4. The center cosmogram that activates the whole drawing and links all of
its parts
5. Good agricultural season, seriousness
6. Maturity, wealth, prosperity, and generosity
7. Death, protection

Thompson describes in more detail the meaning and use of the center
of the Tadi dia Sîmbi cosmograms (Detail 57.4), writing that the four rect-
angular compartments of this part represent the journey of the spirit of the
dead person during his previous life and into his future as mwanda. The
symbolization

starts in the southwest, moving clockwise in Vumuna state which means


to be born; moves southeast into the Vova stage, which means beginning
and language as a way to start communicating and interacting; moves
northeast into the Vanga state, which means action or the moment of
change and learning, and concludes its journey in the northwest, in the
Vunda state, which means rest or just the arrival to the closing stages
or life.54

Their ornate design, complexity, and continued use, and the systematic,
narrative manner of reading, make the carvings in Tadi dia Sîmbi unique
among known rupestrian sites. Although their age is unknown, their exis-
tence demonstrates a substantial history of complex graphic writing in the
Lovo region. Deserving of far greater study, Tadi dia Sîmbi is particularly
interesting for its foreshadowing of the complex systems of graphic writing
that would later be seen in the New World.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
88 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

The ancient visual signs and symbols uncovered in archaeological sites


in Central Africa demonstrate the long history of graphic writing among
the Bakongo and their forebears. The continued use in Angola and Cuba
of many of these signs, along with the complex meanings ascribed to them
in both places, makes it clear that their appearance in ancient caves is more
than a coincidence, but rather a demonstrable continuity over time.

Writing to preServe: bidimbU and biSinSU


In this section we explore in detail the way a wide range of written graphic
symbols, known as bidimbu and bisinsu (pl.), with strong similarities to signs
found in the Lovo caves, continue to be used today by the Bakongo peo-
ple who inhabit the region. In particular, we focus on the manner in which
such symbols are used and understood in and around the town of Mbanza
Kongo in northwestern Angola and how they are utilized by the inhabitants
to organize daily activities, communicate with one another, worship God,
and perform and participate in a range of religious ceremonies.

etymology and meaning of dimbu and Sinsú

In Western culture a sign or symbol is generally understood as an evocation,


a representation, and an analogy to, or abstraction of, “reality.” In examin-
ing the use of signs in Bakongo culture, it is useful to explore the more com-
plex and nuanced meaning ascribed to the notion of a symbol. In Kikongo,
the terms dimbu and sinsú (sing.) are both used to mean “symbol,” but they
can be differentiated from one another in a manner important to an under-
standing of the manner in which they graphically express meaning.
The term dimbu comes from the verb dimba, which means “to mark,
signify, imprint, or indicate,”55 and carries spiritual associations, implying
a way of perceiving or recognizing “reality.” The term is used to describe
a symbol that is a metaphor that in turn connotes a manifestation of natu-
ral and spiritual forces and the recognition and recording of such an event.
Matuku Ngame, a Bakongo professor at Yale University, describes bidimbu
as the conceptualization of natural phenomenon such as shooting stars and
a full moon seen during a walk through the rain forest; the understanding
of these events depends on the location in the rain forest and the person
who was able to read and understand the meaning of shooting stars and a
full moon.56 These two independent happenings can be read individually as
well as collectively, but full comprehension is possible only in a certain loca-
tion and by a person who knows the dimensions of the event in relation to
his culture and existence.
For example, among the Luba-Kasai, the “full moon” is associated with
female power, maternity, fecundity, love, beauty, and fertility, and when
used in scarification designs, it symbolizes what women would like to ac-
complish in their lives.57 Similarly, among the Yombe in Cabinda, the moon
is used to allude to female characteristics and is often depicted with the sun

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 89

in the designs on carved pot lids to represent the contrast between female
and male identities. When the symbols of the moon and sun appear in the
same frame, they also mean a personal encounter and indicate the differ-
ences between husband and wife. The contrasting yet complementary sym-
bols are seen in the following proverb recorded by José Martins Vaz in his
book Filosofia tradicional dos Cabindas.
Ntangu i Ngonde: The Sun and the Moon:
ba mana dengana, When they are to meet,
bi kundama va mbata. They are in the highest point.58

In other designs the moon is used to indicate a relationship of unequal


power through the way it is positioned in relation to the sun. When the
moon is located near, but below, the sun, the notion that “the moon cannot
pass over the sun”59 delivers the message that people should respect their
position in the hierarchy of society. In a common tomb design (tuziku), the
moon, depicted alongside the symbol of a star, shows that the decedent was
a married man, while the representation of the sun in the same frame means
that he was a noble or had a higher position in society than his wife.60
This abbreviated example of the complex meaning associated with a
viewing of the moon illustrates the breadth and depth of submeanings
brought to bear on the interpretation of the type of symbolic communi-
cations known as dimbu. The previous example of a dimbu symbol con-
notes the entire picture of a person walking through a forest and observing
shooting stars and a full moon. Just as the moon within that picture is laden
with complex meaning, so too are the stars and the forest. Bidimbu thus
act as shorthand for the entire picture, connoting through single symbols
specific events, with all their contextual meaning and cultural implications.
In contrast to dimbu, sinsú conveys more limited meanings. Derived
from the verb sinsa, which means “to commemorate,” “to symbolize,” and
“to remember through a souvenir or vestige,”61 sinsú is used to describe
actual signs that are depicted materially through written marks or carved
physical representations.62 While bidimbu are nonphysical and metaphoric,
bisinsu are used by the Bakongo as a physical register or notation of a concept
and are displayed, among other places, as paintings on a variety of surfaces,
as markings or patterns on textiles, as statuary engravings, or as components
of tomb designs and the carved ornamentation of terra-cotta monuments.63

contemporary bidimbu and bisinsu Usage

Contemporary usage of dimbu and sinsú symbols in Central Africa has not
been thoroughly cataloged or examined, and, with the exception of work
published on Sona writing among the Bachokwe people of eastern Angola
by scholars including Gerhard Kubik, no scholarship has addressed the con-
tinuing role of graphic writing in Bakongo communities. This lack of de-
tailed study has led some to believe erroneously that no comprehensive
graphic writing traditions other than Sona writing remain. Although John

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
90 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

Desmond Clark, Carlos Ervedosa, Camarate França, Henri Breuil, Jef Mor-
telmans, José Redinha, Joaquim Martins, John Turkey, Mário Fontinha,
and Paul Raymaekers and Hendrik van Moorsel have documented archaeo-
logical evidence of sign usage, and Faïk-Nzuji, Fu-Kiau, and Thompson
have recorded the contemporary existence of numerous graphic symbols
in Central Africa, no work has attempted to fully document the systematic
usage of such writing by modern Bakongo.
Research conducted between 2002 and 2010 in Angola’s Zaire province
and part of Bas-Zaire province in the Democratic Republic of the Congo
has documented the use of a wide range of graphic writing forms and dem-
onstrated their systematic organization. There is widespread continued use
of, and community enthusiasm for, graphic writing, particularly among the
elders and other members of contemporary religious organizations in and
around Mbanza Kongo, and the research demonstrates that graphic writing
has long been, and continues to be, an important part of the religious and
political lives of members of the royal family, religious leaders, and laypeo-
ple in the wider Mbanza Kongo community.
This research on contemporary uses of graphic writing among the Ba-
kongo has involved close work with numerous traditional political and reli-
gious figures near Mbanza Kongo. These include surviving members of the
former royal government of the Kongo kingdom who, despite official de-
struction of the Kongo kingdom by Portuguese colonialists and the banning
of public religious and social organizations under Angola’s socialist regime,
have continued to safeguard traditional cultural and religious knowledge and
today form a self-described “Traditional Group.” They include Ntinu Nzaku
Nevunda, a priest who was once the royal councilor to the king; Alvaro Bar-
bosa, head of the traditional council; Alfonso Seke, the court’s oral histo-
rian; Paulino Polar, chief of Kwanza Maya (village); and Pedro Savão, chief
of Kinzau Niemo Maya. Other holders and institutions of traditional knowl-
edge in the area include the religion Bundu dia Kongo (BDK), whose priests
include Ne Lisimana Zola, Ne Wanzinga Mpangu, Ne Nzinga Wasiwadimbu,
Ne Keva Difua, and Ne Katembo Zola; the religion Mpeve ya Nlongo and its
prophet, Mayifwila Rafael Rivals; the Botanical House of Spirit and Tradi-
tion and its priest (nganga nkisi), Francisco Lusolo; the Church of Black Peo-
ple in Africa and its prophetic mother (ngudia nganga), Nsenga Alabertina;
and the Kimbanguista Church. These local churches fuse traditional beliefs
with elements of Catholic or Protestant religious scripture.64
Fu-Kiau defi nes communication in the Bakongo world through the con-
cept “Bidimbu ye Nsonokolo za Kongo,” a phrase that translates roughly as
“symbols and ancient Kongo pictographs.”65 Residents of Mbanza Kongo
use a similar concept, “Sinsu kia nguizami,”66 or writing signs, when asked
to defi ne or describe their notion of communication. A fuller translation of
the term nguizami incorporates the concept of symbols of understanding,
the willingness to listen to each other and be reasonable, and friendly dis-
course.67 A less formal term used to refer to graphic writing is “Ndinga i
Sinsu” or “Ndinga Bisinsu,” which literally means “graphic language.”

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 91

Examples of the complex uses and understandings of graphic writing


across different religious institutions, secular users, members of the royal
family, and government figures demonstrate a continuity in the aesthetic
and conceptual features of the component signs. Their use across such a
range of distinct yet overlapping realms of society, from secular to religious,
can be organized into three distinct categories:
1. Signs used in agriculture, in hunting, and for the expression of arith-
metic values related to those activities
2. Signs used for location and traveling purposes
3. Signs used to express religious and moral meanings
Among these categories, numerous differences in meaning, style, and
usage of a particular sign exist. Table 5 illustrates the variation in mean-
ing of a selection of signs across religious and secular uses as described by
local priests and members of the traditional Kongo government in Mbanza
Kongo, Angola.
In keeping with their role of holding and expressing specialized knowl-
edge about several traditional and syncretic religious practices, graphic sym-
bols representing the spiritual realm are drawn by hand on the ground in
sacred spaces, painted on walls, engraved in wood and terra-cotta, and used
in the designs of brass objects, musical instruments, tools, bottles, neck-
laces, crowns, and textiles. Another common drawing technique uses natu-
ral clay that is found in four basic colors—white, yellow, red, and black—and
the colors can be used to convey different meanings. Signs are also often
codified through body language, within or outside of a religious perfor-
mance, and by tattoo and scarification procedures. Secular use of the sym-
bols is often more direct and immediate, with signs typically drawn by hand
or drawn on the ground with the use of a stick or branch. Graphic writing
is also used as a way to record information within Bakongo political institu-
tions and economic systems by tying and untying knots on a rope to broad-
cast the state of social problems to the community. This tradition is called
kinkete kia kânga ye Kutulu mâmbu.68
Another important difference between the use of signs in secular and
spiritual contexts is that the style and complexity of graphic writing shifts
substantially between the two realms. In general, graphic symbols em-
ployed in secular settings such as farming, hunting, or traveling are used
as single units, whereas symbols used in religious contexts tend to be used
in a more complex manner. More often than not, in religious contexts mul-
tiple signs are used in a single integrated system to be read holistically.
Within the system, the primary meaning of each sign may be modified as it
is merged with other signs or depicted multiple times. Visual components,
such as the proportion of the elements, repetition of the parts, direction of
the sign, and colors it employs, all function to engage and shape a narra-
tive. In some extreme examples, such elements can be used as charms or bi-
directional amulets for protection against calamity, illness, wild animals,
demons, and insanity.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
92 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 5 Comparison of meanings for a selection of signs, as offered by local priests and members
of the traditional Kongo government in mbanza Kongo, angola

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 93

ta b L e 5 (continued)

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

.
.

.
(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
94 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 5 (continued)

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 95

ta b L e 5 (continued)

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
96 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 5 (continued)

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 97

ta b L e 5 (continued)

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
98 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 5 (continued)

mbanza paulino pedro joan paulino bundu dia


Kongo bisinsu nieves Savão polar Kongo

Although the contrast in complexity between religious and secular uses


is immediately apparent, it is not absolute. Hunting and traveling signs are
indeed depicted individually, but this individual positioning does not elim-
inate all systematic qualities. On the contrary, the singular arrangements
use space and motion as elements in the system’s completion and activation.
An example that illustrates and clarifies this concept is the arrangement
of symbols along the trail through a village, valley, field, or rain forest. Peo-
ple who travel that way pass their eyes over each sign, collecting the detail
and making the associations that guide them. Using this method, the direc-
tion does not matter, but the meanings collected along the way are abso-
lutely crucial. Thus it is the motion through the space that becomes the
linking element in the writing system. Only a person physically walking
through the space sees the signs in relation to one another and grasps the
collective meaning.

Examples of Secular Usage


The secular use of signs for agricultural, hunting, and traveling purposes
is collectively known as ndinda i sinsú, and these signs share certain char-
acteristics and interpretative techniques. Alvaro Barbosa, the head of tra-
ditional government in Mbanza Kongo and the chief of the Ne Dundua
family in Mangola village in the municipality of Madimba, to the north-
east of Mbanza Kongo, explained these to me with the following example.
Figure 58 illustrates the symbol of a hunter. This sign is used by a
hunter after he has successfully killed an animal. It is drawn along the way
back to the village in a variety of ways in order to let other villagers know
where to fi nd the kill, as the hunter himself never brings it back. The full
symbol is not depicted along the path; instead the hunter conveys his mes-
sage through a series of actions, including the following:

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 99

• Leaving objects such as branches in the path


• Drawing symbols in the dirt of the path
• Bending or breaking stalks or branches and marking
remaining leaves with certain patterns
• Cutting symbols or notches on trees
The notations left are elements of a codified and widely un-
derstood system. Each mark is read by the follower for informa-
tion about which way to turn. The general combination of sharp
and gentle turns toward an identifiable point is illustrated by the f i g U r e 5 8 symbol of
cross and curve of the graphic symbol. This comparison is clear a hunter. (From Bárbaro
in the way the varied marks, individually or in combinations, im- martínez-ruiz, personal
part a particular instruction. For example, every time a branch collection, 1986.)
is left on a path, a line is drawn in the dirt (Figures 59 through
61), and together the signs indicate that such a path must be taken. Leav-
ing a branch in the path also indicates that the path taken is temporary, that
it is not the path that will lead all the way to the kill. In contrast, when the
distinctive pink flower (Figures 62 and 63) is left on a path, this indicates
that the path is to be followed the entire way to the location of the prize.
The pink flower is also represented by a separate symbol, seen in Figure 64.
In addition to marking the beginning of the journey, this technique of leav-
ing things on the path corresponds to the vertical arrow in the symbol. Sim-
ilarly, when a branch or stalk is bent or broken, and the leaves are marked at

59 60 61

f i g U r e S 5 9 – 61 alvaro Barbosa drawing on the ground in mbanza Kongo,


angola, 2003.

64

figUreS 62– 64
distinctive pink flower and
the graphic writing that
62 63 represents it, 2003.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
100 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

65 66 67

f i g U r e S 6 5 – 67 Bent branches or stalks and a mark on a tree, 2003.

an intersection (Figures 65 and 66), it indicates which way to turn. In such


cases, the direction is never straight, but rather a curve, thus linking the
technique to the curved line in the hunter’s symbol. Finally, when notches
or marks are cut into a branch or tree trunk (Figure 67), it informs follow-
ers that they are approaching another intersection where the body of the ani-
mal will be found. This technique corresponds to the location on the symbol
where the horizontal line meets the arch.
Examples of the systematic use of signs in a secular context, such as Bar-
bosa’s, belie the apparent lack of complexity in the secular setting and em-
phasize the point that although appearing individually, the signs give no
meaning until read as a whole, a reading that requires motion, specialized
knowledge, and general awareness.
In addition to their use in Mbanza Kongo, hunting symbols have long
been seen throughout the African continent.69 The symbol of the bow and
arrow, for example, is one of the most common drawings in rupestrian art
and has been found in several sites in Africa, including at a neolithic rock
shelter at Safar, Tassili n’Ajjer, Algeria, dating from before 4500 B.C.70 One
of the earliest representations of the hunter symbol among Bakongo and
Chokwe peoples in northern and eastern Angola is seen below from the
rock shelter of Caninguiri in the Muxiku province in eastern Angola near
the Zambian border, where paintings have been dated to around 7,840
years ago. Similar images are also found much farther south, among, for
example, the many engravings and paintings documented in the Brandberg
area of the Namib Desert, Namibia. These date back at least 2,700 years
and include pictograms of a female figure holding a bow and arrow as well
as various zoomorphic representations.
An example of the way bisinsu are used in agriculture is the drawing of
a symbol representing a man on the ground as a symbol of fertility, a way of
asking for a prosperous harvest.71 Another quotidian manner in which bi-
sinsu are employed in secular village life is the use of symbols to inform vil-
lagers of the best location in the river for bathing and to inform them that
in a certain place women and men are not supposed to bathe together. Table
6 illustrates the forms and meanings of a broad range of symbols used in
daily life in present-day Mbanza Kongo.72

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 101

ta b L e 6 Forms and meanings of a broad range of symbols used in daily life in


present-day mbanza Kongo as described to the author by alvaro Barbosa, a priest
and traditional chief from Zaire province. (illustrations by Bárbaro martínez-ruiz from
drawings by alvaro Barbarosa.)

mbanza
Kongo bisinsu meaning

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
102 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 6 (continued)

mbanza
Kongo bisinsu meaning

Three ways without exit. The necessary road zigzags, but must be followed
to the desired destination. There is no shortcut.

Two straight ways without curves and with no exit. The main road does
not have shortcuts.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
.
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 103

ta b L e 6 (continued)

mbanza
Kongo bisinsu meaning

A way that always rises and crosses water and rivers. A river throughout
the way.

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
104 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 6 (continued)

mbanza
Kongo bisinsu meaning

Examples of Religious Use


As noted previously, the use of graphic writing in a religious context is gen-
erally more complex and laden with multilayered meanings than its secular
counterpart. The religious mileu in and around Mbanza Kongo is var-
ied, and multiple distinct spiritual practices—including Bundu dia Kongo
(BDK), Mpeve ya Nlongo, the Botanical House of Spirit and Tradition, the
Church of Black People in Africa, and the Kimbanguista Church—incorpo-
rate more or less extensive ranges of traditional Kongo beliefs, practices, and
expressive forms, in many cases fused with elements of Catholic or Protes-
tant religious scripture.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 105

Practitioners of the religion Mpeve ya Nlongo73 conceptualize graphic


expression as Masona Mambasi Samalulu,74 a phrase that means “the writ-
ing of God’s guardian spirits.” Done mostly on the ground and on doors,
interior walls, objects that are part of the religious performance such as
drums and vessels, and, in some circumstances, the human body, the
graphic writing used in Mpeve ya Nlongo comes in two forms. The fi rst,
Sinsu Kamienga Mayeso,75 meaning “red writing,” is named for the use of
red chalk, tukula. This type of writing comprises signs that embody a prac-
titioner’s personal identity and is used to depict such a person’s spiritual
path. The second, Ndinga Sambasu Samalulu,76 is a secret language of rev-
elation. Unlike Sinsu Kamienga Mayeso, Ndinga Sambasu Samalulu has
evolved into a phonetic language related to Kikongo that involves graphic
depictions known only to the prophet and to the person who becomes the
ancestral spirit at the moment of its landing inside the Kilongo (ancestor’s
dwelling in the community). The graphic components of each of these
forms are used extensively to engage revelation, healing formulas, predic-
tions, and simple messages from the ancestor. In describing graphic writing
in Mpeve ya Nlongo practice as it is used in relation to the divine sign of the
church itself, Ngudi N’ganga Mama Isabel Lufuakenda, the prophet of the
Mpeve ya Nlongo church in Mbanza Kongo, provided examples of how it is
utilized, including as an external marker of location, within the space of the
church, and formed by physical materials.
As an external marker the sign of the church is painted with chalk on
the front exterior door (Figure 68). In this use the image is read merely as
a sign, as a means to identify where something is taking place, but the same
image is replicated within the church interior, formed on the ground in the
center of the room by natural white clay (called luvemba), where it is read
in more detail and carries more than representational meaning (Figure 69).
Mpeve ya Nlongo practitioners believe that the meaning is given when the
image is activated. The sign is activated when it is placed within a larger

figUre 68 figUre 69
drawing on drawing on
the front door the floor inside
of mpeve ya the mpeve ya
nlongo church, nlongo church,
mbanza Kongo, mbanza Kongo,
angola, 2003. angola, 2003.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
106 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

circle, believed to symbolize and confer the power of the earth. This circle
grants access to the meaning of the symbols that constitute the image.
The sign comprises several interdependent parts that the observer must
look at in turn, reading the sign from the bottom toward the top. At the
base is a symbol in the form of a large letter M. This signifies compromise,
commitment, and meetings or gatherings. Above the M is a large V-shape,
which signifies the union of all practitioners and is a sign of life. Together
the M and the V mean initiation and symbolize belonging to the church.
They also indicate the arrival of Mpeve ya Nlongo, the primary guardian
spirit. Each arm of the V is capped by a five-pointed star, and a third star
is nestled where the two arms meet. This middle star symbolizes the reli-
gion’s youngest generation, its recent initiates, who are protected in the
arms of the faith. The star capping the right arm symbolizes strong, wise
leadership by the elders and spiritual guidance, while the star atop the left
arm represents a strong and powerful priest with a great deal of experience.
Seen together the three stars represent the illumination of knowledge, the
brightness of the entire congregation, and the basic pillars of the religion.
Indicative of the syncretic belief structures in the region, the stars are also
associated with the Christian belief in the trinity.
In the center of the V is a circle that represents the earth. Framed by
tiny rays, the circle is associated with the Christian crown of David and
is intended as a symbol of authority. Finally, as a perfect geometric form
within which all occurs, the circle is believed to offer protection for the
soul, a concept illustrated further by the depiction of the bird within the
circle. The figure of a bird is a metaphor for the fl ight of the ancestors, who
are believed to make possible the continuity between their world and the
world of the living, and whose presence implies the protection of life and
health. The bird is further associated with Christian notions of peace, often
represented by doves in churches and on robes and tablecloths. At the very
top of the sign is a cross depicted in what looks like a glass, also resplendent
with Christian overtones. This symbolizes Nzambi a Mpungu, or God, and
replicates the common traditional practice of placing a crucifi x in a glass of
water. Water is a symbol of life’s creation and is believed to empower the
spirit of God. In this context, the crucifi x is used as dikenga. Once activated
through its location in the circle, the image is central to religious practice
within the church. Practitioners position themselves to the south (at the
bottom) of the sign, facing north. Praying with the arms open is a pose
known as nevuanda, a way to open one’s body to receive spiritual energy.
While praying, practitioners chant religious songs (mambos) meant to call
forth the spirit.
Another representation of this sign in Mpeve ya Nlongo hangs from
the building’s rafters in the center of the church, above the sign’s depic-
tion on the floor. This structure is constructed from flowers, leaves, and
branches, tied together and arranged in a pattern. Each part of the design
is made up of elements carefully selected for their medicinal value. In addi-
tion, flowers are arranged by color to reflect and correspond with the mean-

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 107

ings of the symbols on the ground. For example, palm fronds are used in
the hanging version in place of the letter V, and yellow flowers are linked to
the star symbols.
Nganga Nkisi Francisco Lusolo of the Casa Botanica de Espiritu e
Tradiçao (Botanical House of Spirit and Tradition) 77 in Mbanza Kongo
describes how the notion of graphic writing as used by his practitioners
encompasses two practices. The fi rst, ndinga a ntima,78 which translates
as “the language of the heart,” involves the signs that are provided by the
spirits (nlongo) and ancestors (bakulu). As such, this sign system is used for
divination, revelation, and the decoding of religious messages. The second
kind of graphic expression is called ndinga i sinsú79 and involves the draw-
ing of unique signs that represent individual people on interior walls, doors,
and flags and on the ground.
A type of the highly individualized ndinga i sinsú signs that represent
personal identity and an individual’s spiritual strength is called muntu ya
kuluzu,80 which means that each person has his or her own cross (Figure
70). Because each sign is drawn slightly differently, a practitioner is able to
identify his or her own cross and see within it his or her own soul or per-
sonality. To use his or her cross, an individual must touch it and receive
its energy.
Another sign with specific meaning is called ovo bata didi and is used to
indicate a marriage through the joining of two crosses, the symbolic union
of two people becoming one (Figure 71). Divorce is similarly represented
through movement of individual crosses.
A third example of ndinga i sinsú graphic writing is seen in the sign for
the Botanical House (Figure 72). The sign comprises a heart enclosing a
cross and the letter S. The heart (ntima) is a symbol of generosity, humility,
and spiritual cleansing. A related proverb in Mbanza Kongo alludes to the
vast generosity of the heart: “The heart of a Bakongo cannot be touched

f i g U r e 70 Cloth design inside the f i g U r e 71 interior wall drawings of


Botanical house of spirit and Tradition, the Botanical house of spirit and Tradition,
mbanza Kongo, angola, 2002. mbanza Kongo, angola, 2002.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
108 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

f i g U r e 72 divine sign on the front wall of the f i g U r e 73 divine sign of the Church
Botanical house of spirit and Tradition, mbanza of Black people in africa, mbanza Kongo,
Kongo, angola, 2002. angola, 2003.

by a fi nger because you will never reach its bottom.”81 The heart also rep-
resents human beings in their mortal condition, as people without super-
natural power. The cross (muntu ya kuluzu) within the heart represents
individual people, and the overlapping S, called sadisa, calls upon the power
of healing or curing. Together these three graphic elements are intended to
illustrate the power of the religion.
Teachings of the Igresia de Negros en Africa (Church of Black People
in Africa or INAF) in Mbanza Kongo, as described by Nsenga Alabertina,
the Ngudia Nganga or priest, use graphic writing in the church’s mix of
traditional beliefs with those of Christianity, Islam, and Judaism. The sign
shown in Figure 73 is located on the exterior of the INAF church and is
used to indicate what takes place inside. At the bottom the circle with a dot
in the center represents the beginning of all existence, the source of all life.
It implies strength, security, and protection. Two bold lines stretch upward
from this point, forming an arrowhead at their tip. This arrowhead indi-
cates the route humans have traveled and the way of life in Mbanza Kongo.
Practitioners believe that this city was created by twelve families, each rep-
resented by a triangle around the central circle. These triangles are seen
as cardinal points that encircle and protect the city. They reference similar
markings—fountains providing fresh water—located at each of the four car-
dinal points of the actual city of Mbanza Kongo. The S in the center of the
sign’s circle and overlapping the two vertical lines represents people empow-
ering the guardian spirit (mpeve ya nlongo). Above the circle a wavy line
indicates water, which, in INAF, represents the sîmbi spirit and conveys
the belief that sîmbi has the power to hold the city together and ensure its
survival. The sign above the water line contains a triangle used to symbol-
ize the fertility of women and the earth. Finally, the image as a whole has
meaning: the sign on top and the central triangle-ringed circle both repre-
sent stars and together are believed to represent all of Bakongo civilization.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 109

Practitioners of Bundu dia Kongo in Mbanza Kongo call the religion’s


form of graphic expression sinsú dia nguzami,82 which translates literally as
“communication or sign writing.” The symbols used in Bundu dia Kongo
are contained in a three-volume book, known as Makáva or Makongo.
These volumes present the depictions and meanings of the symbols, as well
as formulas for healing and other spiritual performances of cleansing, con-
trition, or concession. According to Bundu dia Kongo priests, this book is
drawn wholly from traditional religion and is unrelated to the Bible and
Christianity.83 The sinsú dia nguzami symbols are used to teach the “phi-
losophy of return” (vutukila), which has four different components: spiritu-
ality, moral recommendations, instructions for living, and information on
how to become a prophet or spiritual leader.84 Sinsú dia nguzami uses many
colors (named lèndo) and assigns each color a function. For example, red is
used to engage the power or energy of the ancestors, yellow (ngangu) artic-
ulates meaning as revelation and advice, blue (nzola) indicates charity, green
(luniaza) represents guardian spirits, white (mpeve) calls forth harmony and
peace, and black (kifuiti) is used for matters relating to death.85
Graphic writing is also used for religious purposes outside the context of
organized religion in contemporary northwest Angola. The clearest exam-
ple of this is the Imbondeiro tree (Figure 74). The tree is near the village of
Nkwanza Vata, thirty-five kilometers north of Mbanza Kongo, near the bor-
der with the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and is located in the cem-
etery of the elders, nearly eight kilometers from the center of the village and
near a system of caves and rock shelters known as Tadi dia Mpemba. At the
northern edge of the site, the tree marks the location of the graveyard. The
engravings on the surface of the tree face south and look over the graves.
The symbols are carved on the tree during a ceremony to mourn the
death of a chief and bless the new leader of the village. The year 1976 has
been carved on the trunk to indicate the last time a ceremony was performed
at this site, and it was at that time that the
current chief, Pedro Zavão, ascended to the
position. Zavão, together with his nephew
and successor-to-be, Miguel Moises, ex-
plained the meanings of the symbols. The
upside-down triangle at the top of the se-
ries is the sign of death and of the grave-
yard, indicating what lies before the tree
and, as it is not connected to any other
symbol, symbolizing incompleteness of
being. The line below the point of the tri-
angle is kalûnga and represents the frontier
between this world and that of the an-
cestors. Farther down the trunk, the two
triangles facing one another indicate com- f i g U r e 74 engraving on the bark of the
pletion, with the top triangle representing imbondeiro tree near nkwanza vata, mbanza
the living, including the family and friends Kongo, angola, 2003.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
110 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

of the deceased, and the smaller triangle symbolizing the ancestors already
departed. Collectively, the tree’s symbols illustrate the Bakongo belief that
humans are incomplete if they do not have ongoing interaction with their
ancestors. The sequence of symbols implies that in order to become whole,
humans must cross over kalûnga to meet with their ancestors.
In addition to the religious understandings and uses of graphic writing
documented in Mbanza Kongo and described here, Fu-Kiau has provided
a large amount of information on spiritual uses and meanings of graphic
symbols among the Bakongo in the southern Democratic Republic of the
Congo. Table 7 illustrates a selection of his work.

comparison of bisinsu

Although the preceding material is drawn from practices documented in


the area surrounding Mbanza Kongo, similar use of graphic writing sys-
tems has been observed elsewhere throughout the Bakongo region. Table
8 illustrates a range of symbols recently documented in use in northern
Angola and the southern Democratic Republic of the Congo. Examples
include a broader range of contemporary bidimbu used in Mbanza Kongo,
Chokwe Sona scripture, and Luba Lembéta writing, and are compared to
symbols recorded by Thompson and Fu-Kiau. The comparison illustrates
the strong similarities across these different but related systems and empha-
sizes their common genesis.

access to bidimbu and bisinsu

Graphic writing is central to traditional Bakongo culture but it is not fully


accessible to all members of society. Access to graphic writing varies accord-
ing to its use, with greater restrictions placed on access to religious graphic
expression and wider access given to symbols employed systematically in
daily activities such as hunting and agriculture. This distinction is more pro-
nounced in modern times than it used to be, as hunting traditionally held
a privileged place in Bakongo society and was reserved for the noble class, a
class also generally privy to graphic writing in the more protected religious
context. Modern forms of government and changing economic realities,
however, have begun to change this situation, and, as the class of hunters
has expanded to include individuals across all strata of society, so too has
access to coded forms of communication as part of hunters’ daily routines,
while access to religious graphic writing remains tightly controlled..
In the religious sphere contemporary access to graphic writing is lim-
ited to priests, prophets, and traditional village chiefs. Graphic writing
use within religious practice requires a high level of knowledge regard-
ing Kongo cosmology, cosmogony, and philosophy—knowledge that is far
more restricted than the meaning of symbols within a secular context. Even
practitioners of the religious groups discussed earlier have limited knowl-
edge of graphic writing. They know enough to respond to the use of signs

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 111

ta b L e 7 a selection from the work of K. K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau (1962–2003), including the meanings of
the signs shown (“Bidimbu ye nsonokolo za Kongo” [symbols and ancient Kongo pictography], 2003)

bidimbu meaning

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
112 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 7 (continued)

bidimbu meaning

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 113

ta b L e 7 (continued)

bidimbu meaning

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
114 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 8 Comparison of the strong similarities among different but related systems, emphasizing
their common genesis

chokwe Sona Lembéta bidimbu


bidimbu (mário fontinha, (clémentine (r. f. thompson,
(mbanza Kongo) josé redinha) faïk-nzuji) bunseki fu-Kiau)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 115

ta b L e 8 (continued)

chokwe Sona Lembéta bidimbu


bidimbu (mário fontinha, (clémentine (r. f. thompson,
(mbanza Kongo) josé redinha) faïk-nzuji) bunseki fu-Kiau)

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
116 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 8 (continued)

chokwe Sona Lembéta bidimbu


bidimbu (mário fontinha, (clémentine (r. f. thompson,
(mbanza Kongo) josé redinha) faïk-nzuji) bunseki fu-Kiau)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 117

ta b L e 8 (continued)

chokwe Sona Lembéta bidimbu


bidimbu (mário fontinha, (clémentine (r. f. thompson,
(mbanza Kongo) josé redinha) faïk-nzuji) bunseki fu-Kiau)

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
118 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 8 (continued)

chokwe Sona Lembéta bidimbu


bidimbu (mário fontinha, (clémentine (r. f. thompson,
(mbanza Kongo) josé redinha) faïk-nzuji) bunseki fu-Kiau)

during ceremonies and weekly worship but lack a full understanding of all
the symbols or their relationship to one another. Instead, it is the religious
leaders and priests who have the requisite specialized knowledge for the
selective use of graphic writing.
To study Kongo cosmogony at the highest level, one must be a mem-
ber of an initiation society. Within the social and religious structure of a
society, initiates learn the location of the symbols; their position, form,
color, and direction; and the way they relate to the specific society.86 In Self-
Healing Power and Therapy, Fu-Kiau discusses modes of transmission of
this knowledge, writing, “Because of the lack of printed material, teaching
constituted passing down of key principles of life through bikûmu (repeated
mottoes), ngana (proverbs), n’kûnga (songs), and nsonokono zabândulwa
(iconographic writing).”87 This dialectic is described as a kinzônzi pattern,
the “process in which the master enunciates one portion of a given principle
and the audience in chorus completes the rest. Everything is either repeated,
sung, bândulwa (iconographically written), or proverbialized (sokwa mu
ngana).”88 Although originally only secret society initiates learned the use
of graphic writing in a religious sense, the advent of syncretic religions in
Mbanza Kongo and the gradual shifting of cultural roles have resulted in a
wider use of graphic writing. For example, it is not uncommon for uniniti-
ated priests and prophets of syncretic churches such as Bundu dia Kongo,
the Kimbanguista Church, and Mpeve ya Nlongo to incorporate a range of
graphic writing into their practice, as detailed earlier in this chapter.
Among those who have gained access to restricted religious and phil-
osophical knowledge, certain individuals take responsibility for the writ-
ing and reading of bidimbu and bisinsu. Priests exclusively hold the right
to write with graphic signs, but while there are a number of different kinds
of priests, all of whom have access to graphic writing, some types are more
actively engaged in using it. In particular, the Ngânga-Nkôndi takes on this
role. The title Ngânga-Nkôndi means “priest of the notebook,” indicating
this priest’s role as the religious recorder. This type of priest is a specialist in

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 119

fi nding and implementing solutions for all spiritual issues that arise within
Kongo religious institutions such as the Lemba society.89
In addition to religious figures, there are social and political counter-
parts who are responsible for administering the use of graphic writing in a
secular setting. One such position, which Fu-Kiau describes as a “scribe,” is
someone whose role is to archive information inside the traditional govern-
ment (mbôngi).90 This person is called Na-Makolo or Makolo and is charged
with keeping for the community records of government decisions, agree-
ments (mandaka) with other traditional governments, such as economic
contracts and political alliances, and other important events.91 The Makolo
does this by braiding a cord and tying knots onto this rope (n’sing’a makolo)
or simply by cutting marks (makènko) into a piece of wood made for the
purpose.92 The Makolo also has the related obligation of decoding the mes-
sage symbolized by each mark or knot on his ropes.
Another important figure in the process of codifying and deciphering
graphic writing is the Mabika (announcer), whose function is to speak to
the community and notify the public of the resolution of particular prob-
lems. The Mabika does this by untying or cutting the knots that represent
the date on which the problem was discussed by the Mbôngi or that indi-
cate known events such as anniversaries, the signing of agreements, and
other important events in the community.
It is not possible to generalize about the extent to which these traditional
roles are still being performed in Central Africa. The Angolan government’s
attempts to systematically break down the structures of the traditional Ba-
kongo government have been more successful in more densely populated
towns and cities. As a result, in Mbanza Kongo itself, although only a mid-
size town, the traditional information-providing responsibilities of the Ma-
kolo and the Mabika are rarely seen. Only when the members of the last
traditional government are assembled, usually for national cultural awareness
events,93 are these figures active. Outside of Mbanza Kongo, however, the
traditional responsibilities of the Makolo and Mabika have been preserved to
a greater extent. The same is true among the Bakongo of the southern Dem-
ocratic Republic of the Congo, where during the past fi fty years the national
government has been less overtly hostile to traditional roles.
The foregoing is intended to illustrate, through a selection of detailed
examples, the degree to which graphic symbols continue to be used by Ba-
kongo residents in and around Mbanza Kongo, Angola, and, by exploring
the range of contemporary secular and religious uses of bidimbu and bisinsu,
to demonstrate that the approach to graphic writing is at once complex and
fluid, allowing the system to remain strong throughout changing times.

Writing to remember: firmaS


Firmas (literally translated into English as “signatures”) are a form of
graphic writing and performance used by priests of Palo Monte (pale-
ros) in Cuba that embody a complex code of cultural knowledge. Directly

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
120 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

f i g U r e 75 Firma that represents a divination board


called The Congo magic Circle, provided by Osvaldo
Fresneda Bachiller, personal documents, havana, Cuba.
(From Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1989.)

related to and descended from the bidimbu and bi-


sinsu symbols used among the Bakongo of Central
Africa, fi rmas comprise a variety of distinct writ-
ten elements (see, for example, Figure 75). Criti-
cal to Palo Monte religious practice, fi rmas are used
within ritual contexts as a form of divination and
mode of communication and can be made on the
floors, doors, walls, and front of the house as well as on religious objects.
An examination of the development of fi rmas in Afro-Cuban society and
their forms, meanings, and uses clearly demonstrates the continuity be-
tween them and Kongo graphic writing in Central Africa.
A number of branches of Palo Monte are practiced within Cuba, each
using a somewhat different style of fi rma. These branches include, among
others, Mayombe,94 Loango, Brillumba, and Kimbisa. In this chapter we
concentrate on the Mayombe and Loango branches, comparing and con-
trasting their writing styles. With more than five thousand signatures iden-
tified in each branch, and an infi nitely dynamic linguistic structure and
vocabulary, selected representative examples are intended to illuminate
common threads rather than to comprehensively catalog the fi rmas used
in each branch. I draw heavily on the expertise of several paleros, including
Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller, a priest in Palo Monte Mayombe for more than
fi fty years; Francisco de Armas, a priest of the Loango tradition for seventy
years; and Felipe Garcia Villamil, an Abakua and Palo Monte Mayombe
priest from Matanzas currently residing in the United States.95

history and origin of firmas

The word firma literally means “signature” in Spanish, and its use can be
traced back to colonial times. No available information indicates how or
when the term firma began to be used to describe graphic writing in Cuba,
but there is a clear association between the Kongo understanding of graphic
writing and the notion of a signature. A signature is something personal, a
graphic representation of what is unique and distinctive about the person
making it. This individual notion suggests connections to the spirituality of
the person and can be seen as an example of overlapping the literal mean-
ing of the word with a deeper functional dimension within the intercul-
tural social context. Firmas are more abstractly understood in the religious
context, where they are used to depict and call forth spiritual forces, com-
municate with ancestral spirits, and facilitate divination. In this sense, the

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 121

concept links immediate human destiny with worlds beyond our own and
serves as an emblem for the expression of metaphysical ideas.
Though most commonly referred to as fi rmas, Cuban graphic writ-
ing is also known as fimba,96 engángo, or anaforuana.97 Engángo and
anaforuana, terms used within Cuban Abakuá initiatory societies of Efi k
and Ekoi origins, mean literally “the passageway of the mpúngu (force or
energy).”98 Engángo comes from the word ngango, which means “intelli-
gence” or “knowledge” in Kikongo.99 Interestingly, the African-descended
population in Cuba chose to describe a communicative medium and form
of religious and cultural transition using the term intelligence instead of
the seemingly more logical choice ndinga, which means “language” in
Kikongo. The term for knowledge is certainly a more accurate expression of
the Bakongo concept of communication—the holding and sharing of cul-
tural information—and can arguably be seen as a celebration of this orig-
inal meaning within their Kongo culture rather than a literal translation
of what would have been expected within the colonial language imposed
upon them.
Just as there exists little information on how fi rmas got their name, so
too no conclusive evidence yet demonstrates from where or what the graphic
system developed, or how such a process occurred. Many Cubans, even
those who use fi rmas in their religious life, know little about the writing’s
African origins. Similarly, scholars of Cuban history have paid little atten-
tion to African communication modes and have focused instead on catalog-
ing and describing pre-Columbian graphic traditions and daily life rather
than on the cultural tools of the African population brought to the island
after conquest. A similar lack of attention is notable in traditional linguis-
tic studies within Kongo-based religious practice by Afro-Cubans, in which
scholars nearly uniformly disregard fi rmas as an actual form of language.
According to oral accounts, graphic writing appeared for the fi rst time
in Cuba around the eighteenth century.100 The earliest documentation of its
use came in the nineteenth century, ironically in the form of Spanish cigar
labels, when the tobacco company Susuni used fi rmas in its label designs,
seemingly without any awareness of their meaning or use.101 It was not
until the beginning of the twentieth century that this graphic tradition
caught the attention of scholars, most notably Fernando Ortiz and Lydia
Cabrera, whose pioneering work has provided a foundation for subsequent
analysis. Ortiz’s work cataloged signs and symbols, songs, poems, and oral
history as specific cultural markers but did not fully connect these markers
to a wider tradition of religious practice. Cabrera collected oral traditions
that she believed related to an understanding of religious and cultural prac-
tices of African peoples and their descendants in Cuba and openly empha-
sized her aim of recovering the memory of Africans and their contributions.
Subsequent work by a range of writers continued to note the existence
of graphic writing in the practice of Kongo religion in Cuba but, with few
exceptions, added relatively little to the basic knowledge established by

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
122 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

Ortiz and Cabrera. One exception is the work of the musicologist Argeliers
León in his classic essay “De paleros y fi rmas se trata” (About Paleros and
Firmas), published in 1986 in the Revista Unión (Union Journal). León ac-
knowledges at the beginning of his essay that fi rmas comprise “an outline
system,”102 with its origin in Africa, and notes the religious and social func-
tions of the tradition. León describes the development of fi rmas by slaves
and their descendants as a response to their new circumstances in colonial
Cuba and asserts that this development was enabled by the grouping of
Africans into social and fraternal organizations called Cabildos. León de-
scribes fi rmas as being used “to perform religious work, spiritual cleaning,
and protection, [and] to fight witchcraft” and emphasizes the importance
of understanding the system from within, from the perspective and culture
of the practitioners. He notes that the process for learning the meaning of
the signs takes a long time and involves detailed religious education, and he
goes on to characterize the fi rma tradition as “signing sets”103 that can be
understood only among a restricted social group that has been educated to
decode the signs’ meanings: “The decoding of this sign system responds to
a semiotic pragmatism that becomes oscillating, personal, conventional, and
ultimately idiosyncratic, compact, and delimited.”104 León’s greatest contri-
bution is his documentation of a wide array of fi rmas and his attempts to ex-
plain a select few, but while his work is informative in its description of the
performance of fi rmas, it is limited by his failure to fully understand fi rmas
as a complex language, a form of communication that goes beyond the sim-
plistic system used only to “represent” mystical forces.
Other than general acknowledgments of the African character of fi rmas
and occasional, noncontextualized references to their usage within Afro-
Cuban religious practice, information on the way African culture informed
and continues to shape the use and meaning of graphic writing in Cuba
has been largely absent from existing literature on the subject, as have been
discussions regarding the importance of the writing form to Afro-Cuban
identity. Instead, the tendency has been to treat the pictorial tradition as
a minor form of graphic expression, an art form barely meriting explana-
tion within the understanding of other art practices such as the colonial
academia, “Cuban vanguardia” in the early twentieth century, and Cuba’s
postrevolution artistic movements.
In contrast to this general absence of such an understanding, Robert
Farris Thompson’s work has celebrated the strong link between Kongo be-
lief and communication systems in Central Africa and the use of fi rmas
in Cuba and has added significantly to the foundation laid by Ortiz and
Cabrera. Thompson argues that the Kongo culture of Central Africa was
the main source of the Palo Monte tradition, writing, “Kongo metaphys-
ical writing provides a hidden impetus behind African-American writ-
ing systems [such as] fi rmas in western Cuba.”105 Although his focus is
on the Kongo influence, Thompson also recognizes the inevitable influ-
ence of the Spanish language during colonial times, as well as other Afri-

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 123

can influences in Cuba, including Abakuá and Yoruba, and the peripheral
effects of numerological systems from Cabala Hebrew and Chinese astro-
logical understandings.106
Consistent with Thompson’s work, the following close examination of
the role fi rmas play in Afro-Cuban culture, the way they are written, and
the forms they take demonstrates the close and continuing cultural ties to
Kongo belief and practice, proves that fi rmas in Cuba serve a purpose that
goes far beyond mere representation, and has significant implications for
wider Cuban belief systems and cultural identity. The continuities between
the graphic writing systems in Cuba and Central Africa should not, how-
ever, obscure the contrasts, and it is worthwhile to take note of the pro-
cess of adopting and learning the tradition in the New World, a process
with parallels to the adaptation of sacred Chinese writing in India described
by John Stevens in Sacred Calligraphy of the East: “Every letter is a sacred
symbol, yet [it is] understood that each people must recreate the symbol
and sound in their own idiom.”107 The resulting Palo Monte religious be-
liefs and the fi rmas that express them are at once deeply rooted and unde-
niably unique.

role of firmas in Society

Among practitioners of Palo Monte, the fi rma system fulfi lls a number of
roles that collectively highlight the variety and depth of its relevance to past
and present Cuban culture. At their most basic level, fi rmas, or single sym-
bols, are used as a mode of identifying facts such as practitioners’ names or
roles inside the religion, family, or spiritual association and the location of
the religious house. The primary role of a signature is to facilitate the inter-
action between peoples and, in more secret spaces, the interaction between
the priest, spiritual forces, God, and practitioners. As noted earlier, the
fi rma system is also known as Ngángo, literally “the passageway of mpungo;
the signal and the essence of God are working down on the earth.” As such,
the signatures function as a type of map or electrical circuit whereby the
electricity and force of God, like the cosmic vibrations manifested through
religious objects, circulate and materialize. Signatures are used to convey
feelings, intentions, and desires to spiritual forces and serve as a means for
a practitioner to visualize and communicate with the powers of the spirits.
Like a text that conveys holy scripture, signatures enable both aesthetic and
conceptual understandings of religious values.
Signatures are also used to energize people with the forces summoned
by the signature. When the people supplement the motion of the fi rma
through dance and gesture, the result is a graphic in motion that becomes
a perfect symbol of God as a unifying and active spirit. Similarly, fi rmas are
used for healing and meditation and for the facilitation of mutual transac-
tions of energy between priests, practitioners, and God or the forces rel-
evant to a particular religious experience. Firmas are also used to teach

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
124 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

practitioners religious values and the history of Palo Monte and to pro-
vide outright instruction in the organization of time and the sequencing of
ritual components within the religious ceremony.
In yet another capacity, fi rmas exemplify the manner in which writing
as art and scripture is utilized in Kongo-Cuban culture in the resolution of
confl ict between individuals and within and between communities. When
a confl ict arises, an individual goes to a priest for assistance. The priest cre-
ates a unique signature, and a ceremony is performed to bring the issue to
the attention of the ancestors and deities. The signature in this case is not
just a representation of the problem but instead becomes the vehicle for its
resolution, as it has the ability to engage the problem and identify the spiri-
tual energy or force necessary for a solution.
In addition to the many religious roles fulfi lled by fi rmas in Cuba, there
are social motivations for the use of graphic writing that can be traced from
its inception to the present. As distinct from usage in Central Africa, there
is no clear and absolute way to distinguish between religious and secular
uses because of the extent to which religious beliefs and moral philosophy
have fi ltered into the daily life and understanding of society. Firmas origi-
nally provided the Kongo-Cuban people with a sense of belonging to a new
space, became vital to social-religious consciousness, and, in placing the
individual at the service of the group, increased the power of the group as a
whole. This heightened group consciousness became visible with the emer-
gence of Palo Monte in Cuba.108 In the face of the social repression during
colonial times, the social prejudice of the Cuban society during the era of
the republic, and the intolerant ideological extremism of “Marxism” in the
present day, the fact that fi rmas have survived intact from colonial times is a
testament to the effectiveness of the structure of the graphic system and the
social forces that preserved it.

How Firmas Are Written


The fi rma system is a mode of linguistic communication that uses a vari-
ety of written elements that are classifiable under the family of signs, sym-
bols, ideograms, “logographics,” and “logounits.” These units are called
sellos in Spanish, a name that translates as “stamps” or “seals” and alludes
to their purpose in officially marking something and sending information.
As building blocks of each fi rma, stamps individually represent not a letter
but a concept. Some represent actions, others stand for objects or places,
still more relate to ideas or feelings. While some stamps are recognizable
pictures with clear associations, countless more are not, and their meaning
must be memorized. Individually or in small groups, stamps represent com-
plex thoughts, instructions, names, or particular forces that convey energy
and meaning into the rest of the writing. For example, the stamps shown in
Figures 76 through 83 represent, respectively, ancestor, life, heart, moon,
star, water, God, and fi re.
In addition to their representative roles, stamps are themselves instru-
ments and vehicles for communication, for attracting multiple forces, and

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 125

76 77 78

79 80 81 82 83

f i g U r e S 76 – 8 3 These firmas represent, in numerical order, ancestor, life, heart,


moon, star, water, God, and fire. (From Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1999.)

for meditation. It is in such capacities that stamps are occasionally used to


teach the initiated how to attract and receive special types of forces, to artic-
ulate fragments of the mythological literature, and to understand the his-
tory of the religion.
The total number of individual stamps used in the fi rma system in its
current form is unknown but is believed to fall somewhere between four
thousand and five thousand. Clearly vastly more complicated than the
twenty-six-letter Roman alphabet, the fi rma system is made still more com-
plex by the fact that each sign can have more than one meaning and each
meaning can change with the positioning of a stamp within the signature.
This variation is due to the energy that is created by the vibrations in the
interior of the prenda and inside the practitioner. Furthermore, the individ-
ual elements are modified each time they are repeated.
Firmas use these individual stamps to record the spoken sacred sequence
of multiple functions. The form this expression takes is one of art, where
value is placed on the aesthetic development of important social and reli-
gious themes. A coherent and well-designed fi rma is at the center of a sys-
tem that records a succession of visual cues that directly relate to a kind of
body language and can thus be seen as the graphic components of, or coun-
terparts to, music and verbal expression. A more detailed discussion of these
multidimensional connections and interactions is presented in Chapter 5.
It is the structure of the signature, determined by context, biographi-
cal details, religious training, and other influences, that organizes and gives
meaning to the collection of stamps of which it is composed. The graphic
elements, taken collectively, change in meaning from one fi rma to another
because each fi rma’s unique structure defi nes which force will primarily
communicate through the writing. Together with structure, a fi rma’s style
and the sequence of basic graphic elements affect the signature’s capacity to
communicate and effect change.
The primary recognizable form in an example of a signature is the
enclosure of a principal design that carries in it the general function of the

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
126 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

f i g U r e 8 4 Firma provided by Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller,


personal documents, havana, Cuba. (From Bárbaro martínez-
ruiz, personal collection, 1989.)

graphic or drawing. At the same time, at the periph-


ery of the primary signature there are often multi-
ple stamps referred to as affi xes. These individual
units act as modifiers that give meaning to the main
graphic, clarifying what is otherwise a generic symbol and allowing the sig-
nature to be read as a whole. An example is shown in Figure 84, where the
central fi rma is modified by the stamps to its left and right.
In addition to the combination of central and peripheral elements,
fi rma structure generally follows one of three basic forms. The most com-
mon form is that of a linear narrative, read from the top of the signature to
the bottom. The second form is centripetal, with the story told in a circular
fashion, read from the outside into the center. Third, a centrifugal reading
pattern tells the story from the center outward. In both types of spiral read-
ing, the interpreter must proceed from left to right. The signatures shown
in Figures 85, 86, and 87 illustrate, respectively, these three patterns of
reading meaning. Though other modes of interpretation exist, these three
forms are a useful platform from which to focus on further variety and
meaning within these structures.
In addition to understanding the patterns of reading, it is critical to
emphasize the range of meanings across different contexts. Although the
essential components and structures may remain the same, the contextual-
ized creation and use of a signature must be known for one to understand
its full message and role. For example, a signature drawn to serve a heal-
ing purpose differs from a similar combination and construction of sym-

85 86 87

f i g U r e S 8 5 – 87 examples of three firmas: siete rayos (85), sîmbi (86), and remolino
(87), provided by Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller, personal documents, havana, Cuba. (From
Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1989.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 127

bols used for divination. Besides location and broad purpose, a number of
other contextual factors related to a fi rma’s creation are also critical to its
meaning. Several of these are discussed in detail in Chapter 5 and include
the words spoken, accompanying music, the gestures and positions of those
involved, and the type of religious objects with which the fi rma is designed
to interact.
It is also important to highlight the variety of forms the signature
itself can take and note the wide array of mediums through which it can
be employed. In general, signatures are made with white chalk (luvemba or
cascarilla), though other colors may be used depending on the function of
the graphic. These signatures are influenced by location and material and
can vary depending on whether they are drawn on the floor, on the wall, at
a point of entrance or exit, in a path, on wood, paper, metal, or stone, or on
religious objects or a person’s body.
Finally, the styles of the stamps and fi rmas vary depending on the art-
ist or priest making them and the Palo Monte branch within which they
are used. For example, in Matanzas province, fi rmas are written in what
is known as a “sharp style,” so named because of the practice of holding
the chalk very fi rmly against the surface in order to make every angle or
geometric form as straight as possible. The angular shape of the regular
character is then alternated with emphatic lines and some circular forms.
In contrast, the “soft style,” favored in Havana province, results when the
stamps and fi rmas are written with more circular shapes that are occasion-
ally interrupted by sharp geometric figures. The difference between the
styles is evident in the examples of complex signatures shown in Figures
88 and 89.

88 89

f i g U r e S 8 8 – 8 9 Two firmas that represent nzambi a mpungu, from Felipe Garcia


villamil (88) and Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller (89). (From Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal
collection, 2000.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
128 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

How Firmas Are Used


Given the wide range of functions fulfi lled by fi rmas in Afro-Cuban soci-
ety, there is no simple or precise description that fully encapsulates how this
writing is used. Different religious activities, including divination, initia-
tion, and healing, all require fi rmas to be used in specific and varied ways.
For example, in a divination ceremony, the fi rma becomes the divination
board, with every stamp representing particular spiritual forces or astro-
nomical entities. Each of these forces is also associated with a number or
series of numbers. Once it is determined which force the ceremony needs to
address, other objects, such as cowry shells, are thrown. The way the shells
fall in turn provides a series of numbers, which, when interpreted with the
numbers and powers identified with the force in question, serve to predict
the future and counsel the practitioner.
As we saw in certain of the religious practices documented in Mbanza
Kongo, in Kongo-Cuban initiation ceremonies each initiate has his or her
own unique fi rma that represents that individual’s identity. This personal
fi rma is identified and fi rst drawn through a divination ceremony in which
the priest determines a design that both matches the individual and fits with
the religious house. In addition to representing the initiate’s identity, the
fi rma becomes a vehicle by which the new practitioner can interact with dif-
ferent forces or spirits. During the initiation ceremony itself this individual
fi rma is drawn on the initiate’s partially covered body with white chalk. A
second fi rma is drawn on the ground, also in chalk, and this fi rma repre-
sents the religion’s power to engage the forces. This second signature marks
the physical space where the forces will land and thus comprises stamps that
represent and call the necessary spirits. A third kind of fi rma, the Muana,
is also used in the initiation process. Unlike the other fi rmas, which, al-
though forever remembered by the initiate, physically vanish after the cere-
mony concludes, the Muana is permanently cut into the body, leaving a scar
that marks the individual as initiated into the fi rst level of Palo Monte (an
Ngueye).109 In addition to these three primary signatures, throughout the
course of the initiation other minor fi rmas are used to provide instructions
for the performance.
A third type of religious ceremony involving fi rmas is one designed for
healing an illness or injury. In this context signatures are used as spiritual
maps, with each stamp representing a type of medicinal plant. The cere-
mony works on two levels, enabling both spiritual healing, during which
forces actually engage with specific stamps, and physical healing, through
the instruction of the healer as to which plants and physical medicines are
needed and where these elements must be found. Firmas used in a healing
context are drawn with white chalk on the ground of the religious house.
In some cases, fi rmas are also drawn on the sick person as a way of getting
spiritual medicine inside the body.
Whatever its intended use, for a signature to function it must be acti-
vated. Activation is essentially asking for and receiving the spirit’s approval

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 129

for the use of the fi rma and making that spirit a tangible force for the dura-
tion of the fi rma’s use. Activation can take place in a number of ways. Lydia
Cabrera documented this basic way to activate a simple graphic sign:

In order to know if the spirit (nganga) accepts, fi rst place seven piles of
gunpowder in a straight line in front of the Prendas, and ask “If you are in
agreement lift them all to the foot of . . .”—say the name of the Nganga
and light the gunpowder. If all are swept up, the spirit is understood to
be in agreement, but to confi rm the answer in a more affi rmative manner,
the Ngagulero (specialized priest) reorganizes the gunpowder and draws
a cross next to the last little pile. The drawn cross is that of Nzambi, a
cross of God that is believed to be a fi rm word by which to swear. The
ngagulero says “Holy word, if you are in agreement take seven and leave
me one. Gunpowder, do not pass the cross.” Lit, six piles explode, and that
of the cross, the seventh does not, a result in which the nganga expresses,
without a doubt, its acceptance.110

Cabrera emphasizes that in graphic communication “fula and mpemba,


gunpowder and white chalk, are inseparable.”111 Because the signature
must be drawn to link the practitioner with the spirit, and gunpowder must
be used to activate this link, neither element alone can open the neces-
sary sacred communication. Like gunpowder, sulfur is a material commonly
used to ask the nganga about daily life, health, work, and fortune. Gunpow-
der, which burns quickly, is ideal for jobs that need an immediate resolu-
tion, such as protecting people, the village, or the flora and fauna, and for
divination, health, and the destruction of evil forces (bandoki). Sulfur, on
the other hand, which combusts more slowly, is preferred in less urgent sit-
uations, where a delayed response is better because it implies that time has
been taken to ensure the accuracy of the response.
Other ways of activating a signature include pouring animal blood
over the signature, blowing cigar smoke, spraying rum from one’s mouth,
and applying ginger or spicy pepper to the fi rma.112 Finally, as discussed in
detail in Chapter 5, lyrics that are sung or spoken (mambos) are the fi nal
critical component in the activation of a fi rma and an important factor in
its success.

Access to Firmas
Although fi rmas are widely used within Afro-Cuban culture, relatively few
people can actually read and write this form of graphic writing. Their rar-
ity is in part a result of the system’s complexity, which demands a profes-
sional religious education; close work with a Tata nkisi (priest) to learn the
range of symbols, the syntax, and structural components; and many years
of practice. Secrecy regarding the uses and meanings of fi rmas further lim-
its who has access to the requisite religious education in the reading and
writing of the signatures. Unlike in Central Africa, where members of lay
society learn select elements of graphic writing, in Cuba the information

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
130 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

is found and used exclusively within the religious realm. Religious knowl-
edge in Palo Monte is held and protected by Tatas (Fathers) and is made ac-
cessible to practitioners in adherence to a certain hierarchy. Occupying the
lowest rung of the religious hierarchy are guests, who are permitted only
to witness certain activities and benefit from the rituals performed. These
guests are generally related in some way to others deeper within the reli-
gion. The second level, called ngueye, is reserved for individuals who have
been initiated into the religion. At this level, individuals are able to climb
higher by taking the initiative to learn more about the religion and by
showing their knowledge through interactions with priests and other mem-
bers of the religious society. As more knowledge is gained by initiates on
this track, they are given greater access to sacred knowledge. Progression is
also marked by ascension to positions of power and the assumption of their
accompanying responsibilities. From highest to lowest, these specific posi-
tions include Tata, Mayordomo, Baconfula, Manzanero, Guardiero, Pati-
fula, Talanquero, Sabanero, Guatoco Sambe, Ensila, and Lindero Kongo.113
It is not necessary to progress through all stages in order or according to a
rigid schedule, and individuals often skip ahead as soon as they are consid-
ered prepared.
Among the individuals occupying such positions with access to fi rmas,
there is a further specialization insofar as certain individuals are responsible
for writing and reading fi rmas in their ritual context. Whereas graphic writ-
ing and reading functions are distinct in Kongo society in Central Africa
(performed respectively by the Makongo and Makâba), in Cuba the roles
were combined and one religious position became responsible for both writ-
ing/recording and reading/decoding fi rmas. In Palo Monte, the baconfula
(spelled bakonfula in Kikongo)114 is such a figure. The title bakonfula is a
combination of two Kikongo words, bako and fula, which were fused dur-
ing colonial times.115 The word bako refers to a stimulus, sting, tingle, or
throb, or something that causes smarting pain.116 Fula means “gunpow-
der,”117 the substance that has been used for centuries in Kongo-Cuban
divination. Together, in the Kongo-Cuban way of thinking, bako and fula
imply the action of divining through fi re, decoding spiritual communica-
tions using flames, engaging the forces through the body, and understand-
ing through sensation.
Another possible meaning of the term bako is related to the term boko,
the root in the verb bôka, which means “to break, to cut” in the sense of
deciding and solving problems.118 The term boko is central to the proverbial
tradition used in divination and by the village council in Kongo society in
Africa. Examples of some of the proverbs about boko compiled by Fu-Kiau
in his book Mbôngi are given in Table 9.
According to Garcia Villamil and Fresneda Bachiller, the baconfula has
the full right and responsibility to use the graphic writing system and to
draw the signatures used during Palo Monte ceremonies. In addition to the
physical act of writing, which is believed to be the conduit for the release

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 131

ta b L e 9 proverbs about the term boko

Kikongo english

mbil’a boko ni beto kulu. The call of boko belongs to all of us.

Boko wabôka mu kânda. it is the boko that calls up everything in the community.

Boko wabokula mâmbu mu it is the boko that “breaks” (solves) the social problems
(ma) kânda. within the community.

Boko ka ditûngwanga ku The boko is not built “aside” (from the physical
lutèngo ko. and spiritual community).

Source: K. K. Bunseki Fu-Kiau, Mbôngi: An African Traditional Political Institution (Omenana, d.r.C.: nyangwe-
roxbury, 1985), pp. 2–7.

of spiritual energy, the baconfula’s responsibility for reading the fi rmas is


extraordinarily important.119 Given that the signs’ flexibility allows for a
range of possible uses and interpretations, the meaning of any given fi rma
is assigned through the reading process. As described earlier with respect to
how fi rmas are written, there are three principal modes of reading: linear,
centripetal, and centrifugal. In addition to these basic patterns, in choos-
ing the combination of stamps and interpreting the detailed design of the
fi rma, the baconfula has substantial interpretive flexibility and, as a result,
control over the clarity and strength of the fi rma’s message.
Outside of his responsibilities related to the production of fi rmas, the
baconfula introduces initiates to the fi rma writing system, teaches them
how to understand and use fi rmas, and assists in their exploration of re-
ligious secrets. Firmas are taught to new students holistically; without an
understanding of the underlying belief system and an awareness of the mul-
tiplicity of meanings and layering techniques used in fi rma construction,
knowledge of stamps and their formulaic uses means little. Once students
are steeped in the religion itself, the style of teaching relies heavily on in-
dependent learning and what is called “self-explaining,” where students are
taught the basic stamps and assembly techniques, then left to further ex-
plore and explain things to themselves. Initiates are given a religious note-
book or “libreta”120 to be used as a tool with which to document their
self-education in the fi rmas system. The fi rst signs that have to be memo-
rized and written repeatedly are ngueye, “the circle of new life,” the initi-
ates’ own personal fi rma or graphic name provided during initiation, the
graphic name of the religious house, and the fi rma for their godfather. The
initiates practice in their notebooks the basic meanings of the signs and
take notes on variations in the form, use, and meaning of stamps learned
through their formal religious education and through their observation of
or participation and assistance in performances by the priest and other more

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
132 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

experienced users. Although this act of copying and repetition is critical


to continuing education, students are also encouraged to consider graphic
signs according to their personal and unique understanding.
In “The Effects of Self-Explaining When Learning with Text or Dia-
grams,” Shaaron Ainsworth and Andrea Th Loizou studied learning ability
using two different kinds of visual materials: text alone and text in con-
junction with graphics.121 They argued that the use of diagrams and other
visual aids led to significantly more self-explanations than observed in
people learning from text only and explained that a “diagram can promote
the self-explanation effect, results are interpreted with references to the
multiples differences in the semantic, cognitive and affective properties of
the texts and diagrams studied.”122 The coupling of graphic symbols with
religious beliefs, fi rma usage, and a range of Palo Monte narratives makes
the traditional method of teaching fi rmas particularly effective for new ini-
tiates and experienced practitioners alike. The fi nding that “graphical rep-
resentation preserves geometric and topographic information [whereas] text
has an arbitrary relationship to the object that it represents”123 also aids
in understanding the strength of graphic tradition as a cultural preserva-
tion technique. By helping to “integrate visual and verbal knowledge,”124
the varied forms of graphic representation seen in the fi rma system have fa-
cilitated self-learning about the cultural traits of the African population in
Cuba. This learning of graphic and textual elements is further facilitated
within the religion by accompanying songs, music, and repeated proverbs.
A similar process of teaching cultural knowledge and moral philosophy
through oral expression and repetition was noted earlier in Fu-Kiau’s work
on Kikongo-speaking cultural groups in Central Africa.
Although exceedingly complex conceptually, fi rmas are not bound as
tightly by rules as other linguistic systems. Because fi rmas are designed to
be flexible and to carry meanings that vary from one context to the next, it
is sufficient for a student to fully understand the range of potential stamp
meanings and know the effects of different combinations, arrangements,
and structural positions. From this foundation of knowledge, the writing
takes on the character of an art form and allows the writer to individually
engage the aesthetic and tailor its forms to particular situations.

manual of Stamps

The scope of the stamps that make up the fi rma system is far too vast to
be explained or documented in a single work. Instead, Table 10 presents
a collection of the more important and most commonly depicted graphic
signs currently in use in Palo Monte. The stamp depictions and meanings
included here were represented by Garcia Villamil and Fresneda Bachil-
ler. In addition, depictions of stamps as published by Cabrera are included
to provide a comparative historical perspective. With meanings consistent
across the sources, the strong similarities in stamp design are informative.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 133

ta b L e 10 a comparative historical reference of stamps from Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller, Felipe


Garcia villamil, and lydia Cabrera

osvaldo felipe
fresneda garcia Lydia
bachiller villamil cabrera meaning

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
134 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 10 (continued)

osvaldo felipe
fresneda garcia Lydia
bachiller villamil cabrera meaning

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 135

ta b L e 10 (continued)

osvaldo felipe
fresneda garcia Lydia
bachiller villamil cabrera meaning

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
136 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 10 (continued)

osvaldo felipe
fresneda garcia Lydia
bachiller villamil cabrera meaning

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 137

ta b L e 10 (continued)

osvaldo felipe
fresneda garcia Lydia
bachiller villamil cabrera meaning

(continued on next page)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
138 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

ta b L e 10 (continued)

osvaldo felipe
fresneda garcia Lydia
bachiller villamil cabrera meaning

reading firmas: Selected examples

The enormous complexity of the fi rma system in Cuba described in this


chapter presents a challenge in both writing and reading about the signa-
ture. To further and more clearly illustrate the forms and meanings seen in
the system, in this section we examine in depth a few frequently used and
important fi rmas.

Insancio, or Siete Rayos


Through the signature Insancio (Siete Rayos) we can observe the syllables
that conform to the combination of diverse stamps (Figure 90, with details
on following pages). The syllables contain the forces that, in their totality,
give life to the signature. The principal stamp in Detail 90.1 combines the
symbols of the sun, the moon, and four stars. The sun represents Nzambi a
Mpungu (Almighty God). The moon, or more specifically luna nu (moon
of water), attracts the forces (mpungo) Saca Empeño, Sarabanda, Baluande,
and Kubayende and ensures that the divinatory ceremonies stay absolutely
secret and the members of the house maintain the necessary discretion.
This stamp is also used to release any negative thoughts that may arise dur-
ing the course of the ceremony on the part of the witnesses. The four stars,
often depicted as six or twelve in the context of divination, symbolize the
impulsive creativity of the cosmos materializing through the force of Nzazi.
This fi rst stamp includes a simple graphic of the sun as a force that is re-
quired in all religious ceremonies and whose simplicity belies the complex
concept embodied by the sun. We are able to fi nd its parallel in the mambo

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 139

f i g U r e 9 0 Firma of the contract of siete rayos (seven rays


of lightning), provided by Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller, personal
documents, havana, Cuba. (From Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal
collection, 1989.)

9 0 .1

90.2

90.3

“Nzambe above, Nzambe below, and Nzambe in all corners.” God is in


the upper part of the signature, “Nzambe above,” mediating between the
prenda, the tata nkisi, and the children.
Another stamp represents a knife crossing an eye (Detail 90.2). The
blade in this case signifies that the signature must be drawn on the leaf of
a blade in order to control the negative forces (bandoki). This stamp must
be made at the entrance of a cave, which is represented by a convex half cir-
cle (Detail 90.3), and is used to control destructive forces known as “bad
winds” that represent illnesses, ghosts, fierce animals, social discord, and
hallucinations. The eye represents the action of visualizing the divine pow-
ers through the vititi messo (divination mirror). The vititi menso is repre-
sented by the cross formed by the vertical line of the blade, the horizontal
line representing the hilt of the blade, and the combination of the two
crosses and two diagonal circles. The crosses also signify sacrifice, death,
and birth (in a dialectic sense) of all initiates into the religion. Finally, this

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
140 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

90.4 90.5

stamp marks that this ceremony must be made in a vititi menso so the par-
ticipants can visualize and confi rm the arrival of the divine messages in
the crystal.
Detail 90.4 represents the entrance of the bandoki, which controls the
bandoki of the enemy. The stamp in Detail 90.5 signifies protection, ensur-
ing that the enemy does not touch the paths or change the character of the
work that is being done. This stamp can also be inverted and used to sur-
round the course or prevent the enemy from following the trail. It also rep-
resents the map of where the greatest ancestors descend, the spirits of plants
and animals (the flora and fauna). This symbol also alludes to the piedra de
rayo (kind of rock that can be found under a palm tree after being struck
by lightning) and the piedra iman (magnetic rock), which must be present
over this signature to give it strength.
Detail 90.6 represents earth in all its manifestations. The circle is di-
vided into five parts:

1. The symbol of a skull and crossbones (Subdetail 90.6A), which repre-


sents the Kongo ancestors
2. The symbol of the flower (Subdetail 90.6B), which is drawn as three
diagonal lines
3. A cross, alternated with two little crosses and two circles that represent
the guiro (the fruit of the calabash tree) (Subdetail 90.6C), which marks
the sacrifice of animals such as a goat and two doves
4. A cross signifying life, light, and prosperity (Subdetail 90.6D)
5. The central symbol of a double triangle joined at the base, representing
“four winds” that are used to steal the good fortune and energy inside
the enemy’s temple (Subdetail 90.6E)

The fi nal part of this stamp consists of the lines that come from the
lower part of the circle (Subdetail 90.6F). These lines represent the radia-
tion of energy from the prenda (nganga) toward the godsons. For example,
the straight line crossed with multiple diagonal lines represents the spirit of
Mambe, a principal spirit that must be called in order to give strength to
the work. The irregular line represents the rest of the ancestors who protect
the cave, and in the center of the base of the circle (Subdetail 90.6G) is a
cross, illustrating both the division between the two realms (the earth and
the sky) and the connection between them.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 141

90.6a 90.6b

90.6 90.6c 90.6d

90.6e 90.6f 90.6g

Contract of the Secret Cavern


The signature Contract of the Secret Cavern (Fig-
ure 91, with details on following pages) represents
a treaty one enters into in order to gain access to the
cave where the ancestors have hidden important reli-
gious mysteries. The contract is expressed by a stamp
(Detail 91.1) composed of three basic elements: the
star on the right (lucero prima, or fi rst star), a symbol
of the sun as an attribute of Nzambi a Mpungu; the
star on the left (lucero madrugador, or last star); and
the half circle as a symbol of a vititi messo in the cen-
ter. The stars guide the mpungu and, as Palo Monte
tradition holds that human existence originated in
a star, are said to contain the creative force of the
universe. The symbol of vititi messo in this stamp is
believed to see through time and can provide infor-
mation regarding the behavior of living creatures and
predict social changes. The symbol in Detail 91.2 rep-
resents a triangle divided into four parts, with these
parts marked with crosses representing the power of
the ancestors who are blessed by Nzambi a Mpungu.

f i g U r e 91 Firma of el Contracto de la Caverna secreta


(Contract of the secret Cavern), provided by Osvaldo Fresneda
Bachiller, personal documents, havana, Cuba. (From Bárbaro
martínez-ruiz, personal collection, 1989.)

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
142 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

91. 2

91.1

The symbol in Detail 91.3 contains an irregular circle within which a


perfect circle is divided into five parts, and these in turn contain symbols in
each division. A triangle in the lower part of the vertical line divides the cir-
cle, whereas between the two circles the space is partly covered by crosses
and circles. This symbol represents the force of the living beings and the
minerals (Subdetail 91.3A) that live beneath the surface (earthworms, rats,
rabbits, microorganisms, and so on). The symbol on
the right (Subdetail 91.3B) represents members of the
religion that care for the secrets of the religion. The
symbol within the left upper part of the lower circle,
the skull with a cross underneath and three S’s in the
spaces (Subdetail 91.3C), represents the spirits of the
dead Kongo person. On the right part of that circle is
Subdetail 91.3D, representing the force of the fauna
that communicate through the dead Kongo through
this stamp, with crosses that represent the positive na-
ture of the specified action in the lower part of the
91. 3 circle. Finally, inside the circle is a triangle (Subdetail
91.3E) with alternating crosses and circles that repre-
sents the force of Nzazi. This force complements the

91. 3a 91. 3 b 91. 3c 91. 3 d 91. 3 e

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 143

stars of the upper part of the signature, which also


speak in this symbol.
The bottom part of the signature (Detail 91.4)
represents the type of mpungo that protects this sig-
nature by taking the form of animals and people to
camouflage the entrance to the cave. This stamp also
represents the actions taken by Nzambi a Mpungu in
the form of a ghost to distract attention and keep hid-
den the location of the cave.
91. 4
Saca Empeño, or Pledge Elicitor
Saca Empeño is used for protection, for liberation, to engender hope, and
for the creation of well-being in society. More specifically, it is used to
defend one from sorcerers and is considered one of the strongest fi rmas.
Working with the spirit of Zarabanda, the Saca Empeño signature gives its
user the strength to persevere during difficult times and endeavors to fi nd
solutions to problems of justice, marriage, and other family matters.
This signature of Saca Empeño (Figure 92, with details on following
pages), with protection as its central function, is used in a wide variety of
contexts and, although the details of
the situation and the necessary com-
ponents of the ceremony may vary,
the basic reading of the fi rma is main-
tained. It is an example of a fi rma that
is read from outside to inside in con-
centric form until its conclusion in
the center is reached and that is di-
vided into three fundamental parts.
The fi rst is the upper and outer part,
which we can interpret by reading
the stamps from right to left along
the horseshoe.
Observing this sequence, the fi rst
stamp (Detail 92.1) can be described
as an arrow pointed toward the east,
which represents the distance between
the sky and the earth. This concept
is also illustrated by the projection
of the solar rays, whose position in f i g U r e 92 Firma of saca empeño, provided by
the upper right of the arrow indi- Osvaldo Fresneda Bachiller, personal documents,
cates positive energy coming through havana, Cuba. (From Bárbaro martínez-ruiz, personal
the signature. The solar rays signify collection, 1989.)
that the action of the fi rma and the
spirits serve a protective role for the
fi rma and its owner. In addition, the
sun’s rays mean that the occurrences 92 .1

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
144 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

92 . 2 92 . 3 92 . 4 92 . 5

foretold in the fi rma will take place on the earth, between the sky and the
ground, not beyond. It should also be noted that the number of small ar-
rows at the base of each of the stamps is significant, as each marks the pres-
ence of a spirit. For example, Nzazi is represented by six arrows, Nzambi a
Mpungu (God) by two arrows, and Chola Nguengue by five arrows.
The second stamp (Detail 92.2) is represented by an arrow and an
S-shaped figure marked by alternating circles and crosses. This stamp rep-
resents the thunder that signifies that the spiritual force of Nzazi is behind
the action of the fi rma. The third stamp (Detail 92.3) is represented by a
simple arrow that indicates the time when the fi rma’s action will be exe-
cuted. The nine marks in the upper left portion of the arrow mean that it
will take place within nine days. The fourth stamp (Detail 92.4) represents
the religious community and all the members who are blessing and autho-
rizing the fi rma’s action.
The fi fth stamp (Detail 92.5) comprises two arrows, between which
is a representation of a human skull. At the skull’s base is a cross with four
S’s entwining the arms. The arrows to the left and right of the fi rma rep-
resent the guardians that are protecting a benevolent spirit. This spirit, or
ndoki,125 is represented by the skull itself and has the power to control the
enemies of the stamp’s owner. The four S forms stand for the stars that will
guide the ndoki during this activity. The cross and the circle to the left
and right, respectively, are also for protection, while the crosses and cir-
cles that form a vertical line below the skull signify that this ndoki comes in
the form of a spirit of the community and arrives by crossing the kalûnga
line, the line that represents the separation between the living and the dead.
Finally, the sixth and last stamp in the upper part of the fi rma represents the

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 145

92 . 6 92 .7 92 . 8

92 . 9 92 .10

embodiment of a force with the ability to affect the health of a person or


protect one from physical problems and affl ictions.
The second part of Saca Empeño forms a horseshoe, a curved shape that
indicates the secret, private nature of that which is contained within and
emphasizes that access is prohibited to outsiders.
The third part, within the horseshoe, comprises a series of stamps that
must be read from left to right. Beginning with the fi rst stamp, we see a
skull with a cross underneath. This stamp (Detail 92.6) represents the an-
cestors and spirits of Kongo origin that manifest themselves through this
stamp. The stamp (Detail 92.7) at the far left represents the rebirth of the
spirits that cross the kalûnga line in order to offer help and assistance.
The third stamp (Detail 92.8) is made up of a single cross within an
inverted triangle that represents Saca Empeño, the spiritual force that com-
mands the fi rma. The cross in the center shows that Saca Empeño controls
the flow of energy in the signature and simultaneously creates a second fig-
ure that alludes to the secrecy of this fi rma. This purpose is accomplished
through the inclusion of arrows that act as invisible extensions and permit
the creation of another stamp (Detail 92.9), one represented by a smaller
inverted and subdivided triangle containing crosses; this forms a cave and
implies invisibility and the presence of a deep forest.
The fourth stamp (Detail 92.10) shows a circle at the extreme right
with three vertical lines that cross the line of kalûnga. This represents the
energy of the flora and the fauna that, in the context of the fi rma, permits

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
146 K o n g o G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g a n d O t h e r N a r r a t i v e s o f t h e S i g n

92 .11

92 .12

only Kongo ancestors to cross the line and fi nd rebirth. This stamp also
indicates that action must be taken by creating a specific medicinal for-
mula from a specified combination of plants and performing an animal
sacrifice.
The fi fth stamp (Detail 92.11) represents the cemetery, the space where
the ancestors rest. In the context of this fi rma, its inclusion means that the
ancestors will be reborn in the cemetery, so the fi rma must be used in a
cemetery. The fi nal stamp (Detail 92.12) is the center of the cross that re-
sults from the entwining of two principal lines. The fi rst of these is the hor-
izontal kalûnga line, the division between the two worlds, the frontier, the
point of encounter between the living and the dead. This line creates on its
top flank a triangle divided into two equal parts that symbolize the ances-
tors. The lower side of the kalûnga line contains another triangle, an in-
verted version of its counterpart above. This mirrored image signifies the
multiplicity of many ancestors. The second line is mukula and represents
the path from under the water to the surface of the world. This central
stamp tells the story of this entire third part of the signature by indicating
the quantity of ancestors called upon and echoing the fi rma’s name.
When we read the story of this part, we are able to interpret the dialogue
between different stamps and see how the meanings of graphic elements
can change as they relate to one another. For example, the skull, when un-
derstood in conjunction with the central stamp, signifies that multiple spir-
its are coming to assist and are of Kongo origin. We can continue reading
the stamps, complementing their meanings with that of the central stamp
in order to gain a more complete understanding of the fi rma’s meaning.
The detailed overview of the ways in which fi rmas are understood and
used in contemporary Afro-Cuban religious practice articulates the differ-
ences and highlights the overwhelming similarities between this graphic
writing system and its counterpart in Central Africa. Firmas in Cuba contain
a reservoir of Kongo knowledge and beliefs that were brought to the coun-
try over a period of more than three centuries. In the signatures remain the
memories and beliefs of these ancestors and the evidence of lasting spiritual
links with Central Africa. Yet, despite the substantial congruity between

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
A f r o - A t l a n t i c G r a p h i c Wr i t i n g 147

fi rmas and the bidimbu and bisinsu of past and present Central Africa, the
ways in which the practices have diverged and the complex manner in which
fi rmas are now constructed, employed, and understood demonstrate high
levels of creativity and cultural adaptation. That this dual process of preser-
vation and transformation has been documented by graphic writing systems
demonstrates the power and strength of innovation.

This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
This content downloaded from 130.212.18.96 on Sat, 11 Apr 2020 18:50:30 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms

You might also like