APPENDIX A - ECM415 – CDIO (CO2 – PO10)

COMMUNICATION LEARNING EVALUATION – PRESENTATION (20%)

Student’s Name: Matric Number: Group: 1A5

1. MUHAMMAD ZAHIN HAKIM BIN AZHAR 2022478322

Performance
1 2 3 4 5 MARKS
Criteria
Poor Moderate Satisfactory Good Excellent
(E, F) (D, D+) (C-, C, C+) (B-, B, B+) (A-, A, A+)
1 2 3 4 5
Ability to orally deliver new/creative/innovative ideas/concepts/solutions to solve the problems clearly, effectively and confidently.
Delivery of creative
and innovative idea Able to deliver common
of the concept or ideas with lack of creativity Able to deliver a moderately Able to deliver a new, Able to deliver a new, very
5 Unable to deliver
conceive of Ideas and innovativeness ONLY creative and innovative ideas creative and innovative creative and very
(EA3-Innovation) new/creative/innovative
with constant prompting. with limited clarity, ideas clearly, confidently, innovative ideas clearly,
ideas clearly, effectively,
Delivery of ideas is still not confidence and and effectively most of the confidently, and effectively
and confidently.
clear, not confident and effectiveness. time. at all times.
not effective.
1 2 3 4 5
Ability utilize the futuristic design that has consequences to society and environment and subsequently able to respond with justification
Response critical on constructively.
consequence of Able to utilize futuristic Able to utilize futuristic
Unable to utilize Minimal ability to utilize
project design to Limited ability to utilize design that has design that has
5 futuristic design that has futuristic design that has
environment and futuristic design that has consequences to society consequences to society
consequences to consequences to society
society consequences to society and and environment and and environment and
society and and environment.
(EA4-Consequences) environment. Responses respond constructively respond constructively
environment. No Responses lack of
with acceptable justification. with substantial with excellent
justification. justification.
justification justification
1 2 3 4 5
The ability to present clearly, confidently and appropriately the resources used in implementation of project activities (man,
Clear presentation on machineries/equipment, money, materials, information technology and IT tools, etc.
the resources used to Unable to present
implement the project 5 clearly, confidently, and Able to present only with Able to present BUT with Able to present clearly,
activities (EA1- Able to present clearly,
appropriately to level of constant prompting. limited clarity, little confidently, and
Resources) confidently, and
target audience no Presentation is frequently confidence on 3 resources appropriately to more than
appropriately 3 resources
explanation and not clear on the resources used with acceptable 3 resources used with
used with good justification.
justification on the used justification. excellent justification.
resources used
 1 2 3 4 5

Ability to demonstrate clear presentation of project operation to address the issues/problems/ requirements practical and relevant to the
current engineering practices
Clear presentation of
project operation to
address the
issues/problems/ Not able to Lack of ability to Able to demonstrate very
Able to demonstrate Able to demonstrate clearly
requirements demonstrate the demonstrate the clearly presentation of
moderately the presentation presentation of project
(EA5- Familiarity presentation of project presentation of project project operation to
of project operation to operation to address the
Issues) operation and failed to operation to address the address the
address the issues/problems/
address the issues/problems/ issues/problems/
issues/problems/ requirements that have
issues/problems/ requirements with lack of requirements that are very
requirements that are quite substantial practicality and
requirements that are practicality and irrelevant practical and very relevant
practical and relevant to the relevancy to the current
irrelevant to the current to the current engineering to the current engineering
current engineering practices engineering practices
engineering practices practices practices

*TOTAL MARKS /20

Comments (if any):

Evaluated by (name and signature

CO2 – Ability to utilize engineering drawing as a communication tool between parties in construction project.

PO10 – Communicate effectively on complex engineering activities with the engineering community and with society at large, such as being able to
comprehend and write effective reports and design documentation, make effective presentations, and give and receive clear instructions.