Accenture A Resilient Future For Cities

A resilient
future for cities

How technology and co-creation can
propel a better future for cities.
1
Executive A resilient future for cities
Cities have developed with the support of communities and societies,
Summary continually evolving to respond to newer urban challenges. In their current

stage of development, cities are becoming “smarter”.
By leveraging cutting-edge technology, cities can deliver a new possibility of

connected infrastructure and layers of intelligence that will continuously
learn, adapt, and respond to our individual needs and consequently provide
citizen-centred experiences and services.
Cities need to evolve towards empowering co-creation where all stakeholders-

citizens, private sector, academia, and government take part in creating the
future of their city, alongside driving civic innovation. This strategy allows the
city to accelerate the impact of citizen-centred approaches, in turn, improving
all inhabitants’ quality of life.
Now, Covid-19 is driving a new wave of changes, and these recent behavioural
changes have created new challenges. Nevertheless, it has unlocked new
opportunities for innovation both in urban and rural areas and drive further
integration between these areas.
This document concludes by looking at how a holistic approach is essential

when driving sustainable developments, as well as how the future of a resilient
city is to believe in an ecosystem where all stakeholders and the environment
have a symbiotic relationship. Furthermore, as the world transitions to adopt
the learnings from recent responses to emerging challenges at scale, we
come to see more resilient and sustainable strategies to drive the growth of
cities around the globe.
Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 2

This means that Design
Table of contents Experience is now one of
our business’s four
central pillars.
01 From A Citizen’s Perspective

02 Evolution Of Cities
03 The Next Step
04 Technology is The Enabler
05 Cocreation a Future
06 Examples of smart services around the world
07 Future Vision for Smart City in Japan
08 Challenges Along The Way
09 Looking Into The Future

01
From a citizen’s perspective
Changing the perspective when thinking about cities is

essential if we want to understand new ways to
support the people that reside there.

Humans are by nature
social animals
Beyond survival
We are all ‘by nature social animals’ as Aristotle put it. The reason
seems to be obvious, considering the fact that the world used to
be much more severe place to live. Living in groups allowed us to
protect each other and share food, water and knowledge. It gave a
survival advantage to those who belong to groups, and eventually,
they could achieve development and advancement of
their civilization as a collective.
The ability to work and live in a community has created an

evolutionary advantage for the human race, and became
embedded as something at the core of humanity. Creating the
need to belong to a community as a deep desire inside
every human.
In Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the sense of belonging is

considered to be one of the psychological needs, which arises
naturally after we get fulfilled with the physical needs such as
water, food and security. We need to have regular contact with
others who we feel connected with to avoid the feeling of isolation.
Consequently, there is no surprise that with the evolution of

humans, there would be the creation of tools, structures and
systems to enhance the benefits of living in a community.

The city, a structure
to support and serve
its community
Cities are a consequence of human evolution, a structure
created over thousands of years to support human & societal
needs and propel further development of technology, culture
and intellect.
The complexity of cities has increased throughout history and

the need to establish ways of working, regulations, and
infrastructure has changed the perspective of who is at the
centre of the relationship between the citizen and the city.
Modern society has implemented city management roles to
efficiently run the city and left behind the real citizens’ point
of view.
There is a need to go back to the original role of

the city in order to create a future that works in a symbiotic
way for all city stakeholders, the collective community, and
especially the people.

The challenges we are
facing today reveal a
growing demand for
rebuilding our cities
with a citizen-centric
approach

02
Evolution of Cities
Cities have developed over the thousands years to support growth of communities
and societies. Dealing with an increasingly challenging environment, cities continue
to evolve and respond to newer modern demands.

Evolution of Cities - from hunting
society, to post information society
How cities were born and evolved overtime
About 5,000 years ago, our ancestors finally got released from the
burden of the hunter-gather nomadic lifestyle by developing
agriculture and irrigation techniques. This steady food supply allowed
them to settle in a specific place, one that eventually became a city
over time. The development of cities accelerated, especially with the
advent of industrialization and modernization, enabling them to fulfill
human needs more efficiently and broadly.
However, demographics in the 21st century look different to how they

did in the past. Because of the urbanization and the expansion of the
global population, we have many more people living in cities today
than what our current infrastructure can comfortably accommodate.
Alongside this, an aging global society exacerbates the need for
reformation of infrastructure.
In 2016, the Japanese government announced the plan for the post-
information society, also known as Society 5.0. Society has evolved
over time from hunting society and agrarian society, to industrialized
society and now to the information society. As the challenges we face
are getting even more severe, there is a growing need to take our
society to the next phase, leading to the emergence of a post-
information society.

Cities at the forefront of
global challenges
The role of the city in achieving Global Goals
The 11th goal of the ‘Sustainable Development Goals’ established by the

United Nations General Assembly in 2015, is to build “Sustainable cities
and communities”. Achieving its aims – to make cities inclusive, safe,
resilient and sustainable places – will significantly impact the other goals
that address the social, economical, and environmental challenges we
face globally.
Because of the accelerated urbanization that has progressed in the past

decades, cities face a large number of today’s global challenges. For
example, cities significantly impact climate change. Urban areas are
calculated to account for approximately two-thirds of the demand of
primary energy and produce 70% of the global carbon dioxide emissions,
making them responsible for reducing CO2 emissions and improving
energy efficiency.
Cities are expected to contribute to solving the most critical global

challenges by cooperating with national governments and international
organizations, as they are the decision-makers closest to people.

Cities begin to
take action
Cities are in a unique position to drive change
Cities themselves are also becoming aware of their missions and

responsibilities.
In 2017, when President Donald Trump announced the USA

withdrawal from the Paris Agreement on climate change, cities in
the USA quickly took action.1 They implemented new policies and
programs for climate action to show their positive stance and
commitments to the agreement. This was a significant turn of
events that demonstrated their leadership at a local level.
Amsterdam has published roadmaps for circular economies,

showing their leadership to demonstrate how the future city
should be. They began to put the necessary policies, partnerships,
and infrastructure in place. In Barcelona, more than 800
organizations participated in citizen-led initiatives on
climate action.
As cities are directly responsible for issues faced today and have a
closer relationship with their citizens, they have started to make a
difference in this world by embracing their unique position.
Copyright©
Copyright©2020
2021 Accenture.
Accenture. All
All Rights
Rights Reserved.
Reserved. 11
03
The Next Step Technological advancement in human
history has had a significant impact on
our lives. Smart cities will take us even
further, not only with technology but also
with the power of communities and
data-driven governing.

Smart Cities use connected technology and
data to improve the efficiency of city service
delivery, enhance quality of life for all, and
increase equity and prosperity for residents
and businesses.

Combining technology,
citizen-centric solutions,
and data-driven
governing to tackle the
challenges that cities
face while providing for
basic human needs
more efficiently.

A city consists on
a set of layers that
Social and Culture
serve its citizens Citizen and Communities
directly and indirectly Business, Employment & Value Creation
City Layers
Each layer holds essential parts for a service to come to life,
City Services
additionally, it faces its own challenges.
When looking at ways that a smart city can come to life, each layer Soft Infrastructure
can benefit from “smart” technologies to perform more efficiently
and effectively support citizen’s lives.
Hard Infrastructure (ICT & Digital Based)
However, when communication and data transcend each layer, a
city can behave and grow in a new way.
Hard Infrastructure (Non-ICT Based)
Government Policies and Laws
Natural Environment

A smart city can leverage its
layers to build a future where
they sense, think, collaborate
and respond cohesively to
further enable citizens to live a
more fulfilling life.
Copyright©
Copyright©2020
2021 Accenture.
Accenture. All
All Rights
Rights Reserved.
Reserved. 16
The key factors Social and Culture
Business, Employment and
Value Creation
for smart services Citizens & Communities (Urban & Rural)
Participation
City operating system and city management
Seen from the municipals’ perspective, the most critical City Operating
Enable Sustainable
Smart
Environment Data
System
Enable Sustainable
components within a smart city project are the city operating City Smart
Smart
Data Provision
City (Digital Open
Formulate
Management Service
Delivery
system as hard infrastructure and city management as soft
Delivery
Strategy City
s Platform) Natural
infrastructure. Based on Smart City Reference Architecture Soft infrastructure
Asset
Policies
City
Hard Infrastructure
Environ
introduced by the Japanese Cabinet Office in 20202, the and
Services
Hard ment
diagram shows that those two play essential roles in enabling Guidelines Infrastruct
ure, Digital
smart services. + Non
digital
City operating system realizes the integration of data and

services brought from smart city assets, allowing the freedom Government Policy & Legislation
of cooperation across different fields. City management is Smart City Rules
equally important to deliver smart city services continuously

and sustainably. Interoperate Interoperate
Regional Partners
Connecting to other cities and the wider region (City MS, City OS)

Blurring the
boundary between
rural and urban,
neighboring cities
With a standardized platform, smart cities in rural and urban areas,
as well as neighbouring cities, will be more connected, blurring
the boundaries of cities. This will allow all areas to be connected
in several layers, enabling them to share resources, collaborate
for better services, and support each other.
Regional collaboration enhances services like traffic congestions

management, smart mobility, smart lighting, and smart grid
energy. The scale of projects multiplies the effect of the success
of smart city initiatives. Collaboration across regions will bring the
advantage of scale, and at the same time, will give cities the
opportunity to work together across borders on regulations, and
test service ideas on the experimental stages.
Smaller cities suffer from insufficient resources, lacking of know-

how, rudimentary infrastructures, and funds to invest in smart city
initiatives. However, larger cities can help them deliver smart
services by sharing the knowledge and resources that they
otherwise couldn’t get access to.
Copyright©
Copyright©2020
2021 Accenture.
Accenture. All
All Rights
Rights Reserved.
Reserved. 18
One must also
be resilient
The concept of leveraging new technologies within a smart
city environment improves and accelerates the governing,
economic, social, and environmental decision-making
alongside delivery of services to enhance the benefits of its
inhabitants.
A city that can detect, adapt, and respond to changes in its

environment will produce smart solutions to the layers,
resulting in resilience and, consequently, providing more
intelligent services.
Also, cities can share resources and knowledge, and give

support to each other through smart city infrastructure.
The collaboration accelerates the progression of services
and digital governing. It will also make it easy to help each
other in an emergency, making them more robust and
resilient.

04
Technology Is The Enabler

A smart city relies heavily on technology to improve the lives of its inhabitants. Playing an
essential role in enabling optimization and delivering smart services and pushing the
frontier of capability.

Technology powers
smart services,
making them more
coherent and
data-driven
Smart digital technology enables us to gain insights, monitor and
manage city activities, and make better use of current city
infrastructure. The Internet of Things is proliferated with new
emerging digital devices and bringing new connected
experiences to citizens’ daily life activities.
Sensor technology can collect data; City OS uses that data and
makes it accessible to the public on an open platform. Smart city
initiatives can utilize this open-sourced data to improve the quality
of inhabitants’ lives, help governments make decisions, and
deliver improved intelligent infrastructures in the city.

"Fairest way for technology to advance is
for local communities to be included in its
development, and rewarded by clear
evidence of how technology can improve
their quality of life"
Francesca Bria,
Chief Technology Officer for the City of Barcelona3

Technology & data
infrastructure in
three core parts:
Smart Sensors / Data collection Open Platform - City OS Interfaces for analysis
Collecting, processing and making data
For smart cities, collecting data and accessible is essential to creating value This is the most visible layer for citizens
comprehending what is happening within from the data collected in a city or region. where solutions enable easier access to
a city for big data analysis makes them In the future, a growing number of the data and allow citizens to take action.
intelligent and different. technologies will become available at a
lower cost, which provides a requirement It could take various form, from data
that any solution in this space is open, easy
Smart sensors can collect data from visualization on a city’s website, to a
to integrate and scalable to ensure a future-
parking and transportation, to trash proof smart city. healthcare app or to a hazardous map
collection, air quality, and parkland providing guidance in the case of
irrigation, as well as a platform for City OS is a platform that fits those an emergency. Additionally, the easier
citizens for opt-in data. requirements as it integrates the data with city data is to access, the more
horizontal platforms allowing data flows transparent it is to citizens.
across different domains creating
opportunities for innovation.

City OS is a core
for digital
sovereignty
The realization of the digitalized government requires the
incorporation of smart sensors and big data analytics. City
OS is an open, new public management system that
enables the integration of pre-existing municipal
information systems. It improves efficiency using AI to
better understand the inhabitant's behaviors and using
collected data through sensors to improve the
government’s decision making.
Therefore, City OS, which integrates data from various

input sources and analyzes for more intelligent solutions, is
one of the vital elements for smart cities. The use of
available data strengthens open government policies and
enriches the ecosystem of smart city solutions.

City OS also
plays a pivotal role
within smart city Citizens & Communities (Urban & Rural)
architecture
Participation
City OS
City Management
Service Federation
Smart Smart City Business Smart Authentication
Enable Sustainable
Enable Sustainable
City OS plays a vital role as hard infrastructure, City Services
Environment Data
Data Provision
Experience Design Service Management
Formulate
which is pivotal in Smart City Reference Strategy
Delivery
Delivery
Business Model
Smart
Architecture2. City OS takes over data Management Rubbish Asset Management City
management and the management of assets and collection, Asset
Set Traffic
Objectives Smart City Promotion
services within cities as well as the federation of Organization
Monitoring,
Healthcare,
Data Management
service and external information, enabling the Role & Function

Management
Policing, External Data Federation
Public
collaboration between different stakeholders. Set KGI &
KPI Services,
Player Management Security
etc.
& Operation
City OS provides standard functions needed for Deregulations &

Rules & Deregulations &
smart cities, enabling cities to save time and Rules & Guidelines
Guidelines
Government Policy & Legislation Special Zones
Special Zones
Utilization
resources and focus on responding to Smart City Rules Utilization
citizens' needs.
Interoperate Interoperate
Regional Partners
Connecting to other cities and the wider region (City MS, City OS)

Sentilo, open-source sensor
Technologies that make network platform
Sentilo is a real-time open-source
cities ‘smarter’ IoT sensor network platform

designed to allow Barcelona’s
citizens to monitor, control, and
manage an active and diverse
The constant evolution of technology and the ongoing reduction in community. Barcelona installed
its cost, allows cities to adopt and adapt technology for their benefit. thousands of sensors to track
The encouragement of technology that enhances the smart city energy usage in public spaces and
layers and experiences is indispensable in delivering street lighting. By using this
smart services. collected data, the city succeeded
in reducing 30% of its energy
It is not only data sensing or analysis that technology can bring. But consumption.4 Barcelona’s smart
also, from transforming old infrastructure into new, to offering the bins detect the amount of waste,
and workers can plan their
simulation of city’s future, technology contributes to making city
collection route according to the
‘smarter’ in various perspectives. data they receive from bins.5
Zhaga socket transforms

Singapore protypes city with
streetlight lamps in Brescia
digital twins
Virtual Singapore is using 3D

In Italy, the province of Brescia
semantic modeling to create a
has managed to group 28 small
virtual replica of the physical city,
municipalities to connect a "smart
enabling the urban planners to test
light" transition on 23,000 light
solutions and prototype on the
virtual city. By having real-time poles. For individual remote
management, they installed the
information, planners can optimize
Zhaga sockets and transformed
traffic and improve the urban
streetlights into smart lights. It
system. For example, the height of
enables completely autonomous
buildings and the rooftops' surface
area can calculate the estimated lighting and detailed street
lighting information alongside
amount of sunlight generated in
real-time malfunction alerts to
Virtual Singapore. This allows urban
Copyright© 2020 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. increase their capacity to identify,
planners to see where the potential
repair, and even anticipate
solar panels can be placed.6
lighting malfunction.7
05
Co-creating a future
Beyond establishing technology and capturing data, a smart city needs to adopt different ways of
working to drive positive impact for its citizens.

Co-creation is the
key to accelerating
a citizen-centred
approach and
driving innovation
The blend between technology, citizens, the private
sector and academia is key to driving success,
accelerating a human-centered approach, and driving
innovation led by citizens for regional revitalization.
Leading to the next step towards a future of the resilient
smart city.

The protagonists of a smart city are
the citizens, not the government
or corporates.
Shojiro Nakamura
Center Lead Accenture Innovation Center Fukushima

Using technology to enable citizen
participation and transparency
The increasing amount of data being captured in cities allows the
government to sense, understand and respond to citizens’ needs in
a more relevant, connected and agile way.
‘Smart-ness’ builds on the sum of individual active citizens

contributing to the community that enables the creation and
adoption of solutions, which leads to an efficient transformation of
the local community to be a strong smart city solutions ecosystem.
Open data is a powerful tool to facilitate citizen innovation and to

foster citizen participation and co-creation.
Transparency refers to the availability of information the

government shares with its citizens. As more governments ensure
citizens' data is safely analyzed and reused, it leads to greater civic
engagement and trust between government and citizens.

Ownership of
data and
transparency in
Estonia
Estonia is one of the most forward-thinking countries in the area
of digital governance, being famous for X-Road infrastructure and
more recently its e-citizenship. Estonia has built a secure, efficient
and transparent ecosystem where 99% of the services are online.
E-service infrastructure runs on X-Road, which is a data exchange

platform authorized by users and organizations. Data remain
confidential and protected from unauthorized parties. Users can
access an overview of what data the government has on
themselves to ensure transparency within the systems.8
Everyone in this digital nation: citizens, residents, and e-residents

own their individual personal data, not the government. The
inhabitants have control over who can access their data. Estonia
builds trust in their digital society by using technology as a tool
and make the process as transparent as possible.

The importance
of opt-in data
and participation
What we can learn from a failure
Sidewalk Labs, Alphabet’s smart city subsidiary, decided to

walk away from its Toronto project in May 2020. They
confronted privacy concerns by attempting to collect data
from unwilling citizens. What we can learn is that it was a
pricey and dangerous road to go down, and the necessity of
listening to citizens’ voices while respecting their privacy is
essential.9
Citizens are willing to help each other
Residents can and will provide valuable personal data on

their own if municipal authorities make the platform more
convenient. People are willing to help themselves by sharing
information with the rest of the city, and that can be a way
for them to participate and become a contributing part of the
change in city services.

Opt-in data to
shift mindset in
AizuWakamatsu
In AizuWakamatsu, residents control data, making the sharing of
personal information optional. In order to build residents’ trust,
one needs to state the benefits of opt-in, increasing transparency,
and assuring people that their personal information will not be
misused.
Through the AizuWakamatsu+ portal, citizens can share any

information, and the more they share, the more tailored the
services will become in the future. Currently, more than 18% of
local citizens have opted-in.10
The increase in participants who opted-in data means there is an

increase in the number of people whose mindset has shifted.
Those are the ones who provide their own data for benefit of their
neighbours and the next generations. This is also becoming
another way to participate and contribute to city development in
addition to more traditional ways such as voting.

Citizens / Residents /
3 way satisfaction
Visitors
mutual benefit
philosophy Personalized
service / QoL
Consuming
Products and
improvement Servies
by data Smart service /
Japanese business principles of shared success products
Opt-in /
3-way satisfaction is a Japanese business principle of triple Participation
success. Referring to the meaning of ensuring benefits for all
stakeholders: citizens, industry, and the local community. The
Local Region
mindset of 3-way satisfaction is vital for smart city services, Industries/ Companies
focusing on improving civil life with data and Deep Regional Data /
intelligent technologies. opportunities for
employees to commit
to local region
Data utilization will lead to regional revitalization, by using the
public- private data, citizens will benefit by receiving personalized
services in return. Companies service areas use the analysed data
to create functional services. AizuWakamatsu values this mutual Local government, local Healthcare, Education,
community, local business
collaboration and new framework for Data from services / Mobility, Tourism
human-centric development. responsible business
The key to realize the 3-way satisfaction is a system architecture.

Smart City Architecture enables city management that connects
all the stakeholders, and makes human-centric approach possible.
Scale out to other regions (In Japan and worldwide)

Co-creation – Citizen’s Participation
01
All city stakeholders must come together and
leverage technological developments to
solve the problems cities are facing today
The technology sector is advancing at a rapid pace, but that also means it’s accompanied by citizens’
expectation of ‘smarter’ services. Redefining the boundaries between government and citizens will
help to provide transparent, inclusive and valuable services.
Introducing more citizens to cutting-edge technology while embedding transparency into the
journey will reshape the citizens' mindset and a step towards gaining their trust. It is important to
promote active co-creation participation among citizens, private sectors, and academia’ contribution
will be the backbone to the smart city innovations.

Valuing the
co-creation
process
We are currently in the age of human-centered society, it
balances economic advancement with solving social problems by
incorporating innovations brought by the fourth industrial
revolution.
Newly acquired digital technologies, combined with data and

citizen-centric approach, can develop smart services for citizens,
enabling new value co-creation opportunities. Collaborative
creation is a way to successfully give back ownership to citizens
and solve society’s challenges together.
Involving citizens in the creation process, from beginning to end,

will result in creating a more robust service through a diversity of
thinking and experiences.

“Government has to stop treating
citizens as customers or as recipients
of a service and allow them to be
co-creators of a city”
Lauren Macpherson
Head of UK Eli511

Melbourne is
empowering a
Smart
Community
Open Innovation Competition inviting communities to
problem-solve together
Melbourne’s local government focuses on the changing needs

of the community, environment, and economy. They have built
a system where it empowers community where creativity
flourishes.
Melbourne is developing its understanding of the community

engagement process, looking out for co-created solutions with
communities to address the local challenges and empower
communities with the skills they need to thrive in the future.
Every year, the Open Innovation Competition invites community

members and encourages participants to incorporate city data
and smart service ideas to address urban challenges. These
initiatives are also critical in bridging the divide between
disability and accessibility while designing inclusive city
experiences.12
Barcelona is
fostering a
participative
culture
Decidim: Empowering local communities and decisions
Residents can detect the city’s requirements far quicker

than administrators can. By working collaboratively, they
can come up with the solutions faster.
Provides an experimental, open, secure, and free

democratic digital platform to crowdsource ideas and test
their viability; citizens can participate directly in
government by suggesting ideas, debating them, and
voting with their thumbs.13

Co-creation – Private Sector
02
One of the key players is the private sector by
leveraging technologies to improve city
services and infrastructure all while driving
economic growth
The private sector can assist governments by supporting startups, developing local capabilities, and
establishing a smart city ecosystem. Technology service providers allow startups to expand their
networks. The company is also uniquely positioned as a partner to governments, finding the best
answers to policy changes.
A partnership between government, cities, and private companies will benefit citizens and help
accelerate the momentum of change and adopt desired smart infrastructures that meet peoples’
basic needs and local economic development.

“Investing in public-private partnerships that
enhance the economic vibrancy of our
communities will be core to stabilizing and
increasing our population because residents
feel like they have what they need to succeed in
their City. Citizens are more likely to stay to see
more and more businesses choosing Chicago as
their home, people will follow.”
Lori Lightfoot
The City of Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot14

Amsterdam Corporates Startups
accelerating
collaborative nature Investors Scale-ups
Startup Amsterdam Ecosystem

Governments Tech Talent
Currently, there are 1500 - 2000 startups in Amsterdam
directly involving citizens in collaborating with creatives Startup Amsterdam
and developers to accelerate the innovation processes. Ecosystem
Startup Amsterdam aims to build and amplify the startup
ecosystem and connect them to key players, mentors,
investors, engineers, and launching customers.14 Researchers Accelerators
One of the initiatives is ‘Startup in Residence’, the

municipality evaluates the people's concerns and creates
social challenges for startups to solve using the
open-city data.15
Universities Incubators
Tech Academies Co-Working Space

Innovation hubs to
drive regional
revitalization
AizuWakamatsu promotes human-centric
development and regional revitalization
Smart cities need a local environment of collaboration,

putting innovation hubs in the center. In 2019, Aizu opened
the Smart city AiCT office, attracting investment from
global companies including Accenture, SAP, Mitsubishi
corporation, Microsoft, NEC, Softbank, and Coca-Cola
Bottlers Japan etc.
Shojiro Nakamura, Lead of Accenture Innovation Centre

said, has once said “we need to create opportunities to
encourage talent to stay in the region and further their
careers locally.” Attracting talents into the city will drive
innovation and build strength in the local area.
Accenture Innovation Center is collaborating with a local

university and private companies making citizens the drive
of open-innovation and success in their city and choosing
Aizu as their home.
Copyright©
Copyright©2020
2021 Accenture.
Accenture. All
All Rights
Rights Reserved.
Reserved. 45
Providing the private
sector with an
opportunity to work with
governments and smart
city initiatives is a
mutually beneficial
partnership.

Co-creation - Academia
03
Universities play a neutral yet catalytic role in
social innovation and the knowledge economy
Education is at the heart of smart cities; these institutions prepare students to innovate within the
smart cities of the future. Universities can become testing grounds to test out new technologies, turn
ideas into prototypes, and experiment before implementing large scale smart services to the city.
By seeking out specific opportunities, Universities can attract students from other parts of the
country to work and live in the city. Increasing the synergy between universities, government, and
businesses, in turn promoting a thriving knowledge economy.

Smart research
powers the smart
city of Adelaide
The University of Adelaide launches smart city
Consortium, working with governments, industry, and
entrepreneurs to improve the city experience
University faculties understand the civic role of helping social and

economic activities, being a good neighbour, and positively
shaping the city they are in by strengthening their teaching
and research.
The University of Adelaide plays a vital role in transforming the

city into a smart city. The consortium allows anyone to bring their
ideas and problems and work together with experts to produce a
intelligent service outcome.16
There are also intelligent communities which approach societal

problems and aim at developing long-term solutions. They are
citizen-driven through engagement with the community,
educational institutions and industry in the planning and
implementation of project. This approach does not only save
money and time but also generate a return on investment.

Promoting
University-Industry
Collaboration
The University of AizuWakamatsu is enhancing the
partnership with industries
The University of Aizu has talent development programs allowing

students to have an opportunity to take up an internship program
with partnered up companies.
One of the programs the student can join is the Innovation & Start-
up Education Program, supporting students to apply their newly
learned skills in the form of a startup. Students can receive support
for ideas, financial support after completing this program,
promoting university-based entrepreneurial ecosystems.17
They also host innovation meetings called Aizu Open Innovation

meeting(AOI ), where citizens, students, and people from both the
public and private sector come together and discuss possible
solutions for all sorts of topics. There are usually about 10 working
groups, and more than 300 meetings are hosted annually. AOI
meeting has created different kinds of projects within
AizuWakamatsu, enabling university-industry collaboration.
Copyright©
Copyright©2020
2021 Accenture.
Accenture. All
All Rights
Rights Reserved.
Reserved. 49
Universities play a
pivotal role in a smart
city’s future success by
being a neutral party in
the co-creation process
to generate
opportunities that are
beneficial for all
stakeholders

“As a city, we’ve built active and collaborative
relationships across all levels of government,
universities, and the private sector. This has
supported innovation and entrepreneurship, fueling
investment and economic growth”
Sandy Verschoor
Lord Mayor of Adelaide18

06
Examples of smart services

around the world
Smart cities have a relatively short history, however, learning from the failures of the past,
smart city initiatives have started to drive changes for realizing a the citizen-centric
society. This section focuses on 4 areas: healthcare, education, agriculture and
disaster management.

Denmark universal
preventive healthcare
Healthcare Denmark focuses on providing

free and equal universal access to
healthcare. Considering the
health and well-being of all
These smart city innovations have great potential in improving and Danish citizens. The Danish
redesigning the future of healthcare services. Companies are focusing on healthcare system is undergoing
launching new applications in order to establish smart hospitals through AI. a transformation focusing on
According to Coherent Market Insight (CMI)’s analysis, it is expected to drive reinforcing primary care and
the growth of the global smart hospitals market, surpassing $103billion by population health, and preventing
2027.19 When smart cities’ stakeholders use cutting-edge technologies, diseases before they becomes
healthcare challenges will turn into opportunities, making the future of severe. Denmark also focuses on
healthcare efficient and effective. Furthermore, rising demand of home early detection and supporting
related healthcare products like smart pills and remote patient monitoring mental health, reducing the taboo
will be the driver of the market. associated with mental
illnesses.20
Estonia’s e- health and mHealth Lifepod Cardiac care:

e-ambulance solutions Improving remote
patient monitoring
The Estonian insurance system is a
solidarity-based social insurance mHealth's Lifepod partnered up
system, providing healthcare for with the American Heart
everyone. Estonia’s healthcare is
Association to use an interactive
using innovative e-solutions, ensuring
data integrity. The e-health records voice-powered platform to
can be tracked anywhere. Patients can improve care management for
access the e-patient portal with an patients living with chronic heart
electronic ID. In case of an conditions. This AI-powered
emergency, a patient can call an e- health platform enables virtual
ambulance, a quick-response solution interactions with doctors, family,
that can detect and position the and friends. 22
phone call for the ambulance within
30 seconds. A doctor can use a
patient’s ID code to read time-critical
information. 21
Fablab
Education Fablab is digital fabrication
laboratory where individuals
Smart education is one of the critical ingredients in smart city can create, mentor, and invent
development. Smart education will be enabled by virtual learning, a place for learning and
digitalization, and augmented reality making the learning experience innovation. Fablab provides
more interactive and collaborative, while also increasing student access to 21st-century skills,
engagement. A smart city needs to implement e-learning materials, and advanced
infrastructure and universities inclusively, leaving no one behind. technology to allow anyone to
turn their ideas into a real
product. 23
Vincles BCN Huawei Digital education

partnered with Shenzhen
A social innovation project government
designed to strengthen the
“With a unified teaching cloud
social connections of elderly platform, Huawei provides an End
people over 65 who feel to End (E2E) solution“ making
lonely, improving their well- real-time interactive teaching
being by using new possible from home.25 The tablets
technologies. The elderly are sold to schools for use in class
people on this programme will and at home. By 2022, the
learn how to use a tablet Chinese government aims to
independently.24 create a unified platform that
combines internet with
education. This could change the
Copyright© 2020 Accenture. All Rights Reserved.
future of education forever.
Milan’s intervention model of
sustainable food system
Agriculture Milan city hall, Politecnico di

Milano, and other partners co-
created a hub for stocking and
According to United Nations projections, the world's population will distributing food. The aim is to
reach 9.7 billion by 2050, causing global agricultural production to cut food waste and child food
rise by 70%.26 The industry is increasingly facing global challenges to poverty in Milan. This
meet food demand, which can be addressed by information university conducted
technologies. Using cutting-edge technology, the future of feasibility study, monitors the
agriculture can have access to real-time information about planting, hub and the impact of the
harvesting, and predicting the food quality and quantity in turn project, building logistical
decreasing food loss. models that can be replicated
to other part of the city.27
Smart Farm Area X.O in Nara Spread-Vertical farming

Ottawa, Canada
Spread Co. is making the
Smart farm Area X.O is a future-
world’s largest automated
plex of collaboration and
innovation. By using cutting-edge
leaf-vegetable factory. The
AI and data analytics technology, robotic arms transplant
it accelerates productively, lettuce seeds, grown under
performance, and profitability of LED lights, in a sterile
producers. Sensors monitor soil environment. A sealed room
conditions and crop performance, protects the vegetables from
while on-farm weather stations pests and diseases, and dirt,
track important weather creating a perfect condition
conditions like temperature, wind
for the vegetables while also
speed, and rainfall etc. Together
this support more sustainable
reducing waste to almost
agriculture and build resilience.28 zero.29
Linux and IBM collaborating with
Disaster Management Mexico City Earthquake

detector, Grillo
Grillo gives early warning for

Japan is particularly vulnerable to natural disasters, experiencing everyone, generating real-time
alerts when an earthquake is
countless earthquakes, tsunamis, typhoons, floods, etc., every year.
detected. An open-source
The city must be prepared for future catastrophes, monitoring the community can accelerate social
environment, responding to recover quickly, and designing a impact, contributing to advancing
connected and manageable community during the disaster. the sensor hardware design, while
improving detection and
characterisation of earthquakes
through machine learning.30
Fujisawa Off-grid Energy The Department of

Transportation (DOT) in Iowa
If there was a natural disaster that estimate future flooding
created a power outage in Japan,
Fujisawa system, which stores 3 Working with Iowa State
days worth of power in off-grid University and the University of
operation, would come to effect. Iowa Flood Center, the DOT uses
This allows communities to run historical data of rainfall, climate
independently of the main grid forecasting, and streamflow
during disasters, providing extra modeling to forecast peak
layers of security to the discharge and estimate future
infrastructure and inhabitants in flooding. This enables the DOT to
that area.31 identify risky roads, bridges, and
other infrastructure to reduce
their vulnerability to
future flooding.32
NEOM's The Line project creates an
invisible transportation infrastructure
The Line extends over 170km providing
Mobility an underground sustainable

transportation system, creating the
connection between 4 communities
and powered by an AI system that
continuously learns ways to improve
Smart mobility can be any transportation mode, such as an citizens' quality of life. The AI system
autonomous vehicle, public transit, bike, bicycles, scooters, car- also enables autonomous
sharing, etc. The future of mobility will be transformed by cities and transportation by harnessing city-data.
Citizens will use the ultra-high-speed
people’s lifestyles. As urbanization has increased, traffic congestion
transportation system to transit,
has become a big problem. By using AI and cutting-edge technology, logistics of cargos, and diverse mobility
smart mobility solutions can identify collision spots and recommend solutions running under the city.
a safer route for users. The future of mobility will make citizen’s Citizens can access their nearby
communities within 20 minutes, and all
journey safer and provide a better quality of life.
the essential daily services on a
pedestrian layer will be accessible
within 5 minutes walking distance.33
Mayo Clinic uses autonomous Muji Gacha autonomous shuttle

shuttles to help transport bus in Espoo, Finland
covid-19 tests
The driverless Gacha bus uses
Jacksonville Transportation digital maps and sensors to
Authority (JTA) has partnered up function in all weather conditions.
with Beep and NAVYA to transport The Gacha shuttle self-navigates
covid-19 tests collected at a drive- in heavy traffic and urban
through testing location to Mayo surroundings, offering safe and
Clinic. This reduces physical smart on-demand transit
contact, exposure to the virus, anywhere. This is a new kind of
and reduces labour costs. This public transportation that anyone
community partnership and who lives in the area can
collaboration has strengthened all use easily.35
of the teams during this
uncertain time.34
Watson IoT Headquarters,
Munich
Smart Offices / Buildings The headquarters of IBM’s IoT
department and cognitive
computing system is situated
Smart offices and buildings show us the future of working experience Munich. The building utilizes a
and how buildings will contribute to energy reduction for both the system to manage building
environment and city management. Offices and buildings are also services, and fulfill tenants’ needs
becoming smarter, learning and enhancing services, and bringing a by consistently learning what is
better experience for people. best for them. It can learn the
preference of brightness and
temperature in rooms, as well as
identifying which person is sitting
where throughout the floorplan.36
The Edge in Amsterdam

Marina bay sands in Singapore
enhances its efficiency
According to Bloomberg, the
through technology
Edge is described as “the
smartest building in the world”37,
One of the most famous hotels in
the building uses renewable
the world, Marina bay sands,
energy that makes it remarkably
utilizes sensors and data to
sustainable. The building also
monitor electrical usage and the
provides services like guiding
status of facilities. The system
visitors to an available parking
reduced energy consumption by
space automatically.
over 15,900,000kWh and lowered
their carbon footprint by over 9%
in 2013 as compared to 2012.38
Amazon Go’s palm reader
Payments and Commerce payment
In Amazon Go stores, customers

can use their palms which are
The power dynamics in the payment industry are changing as pre-scanned into the system to
consumers shift from cash to digital payment methods. Nowadays, pay with their digital signature.
digital payments have been reshaping the retail landscape with The customer can hold one or
consumers moving towards a cashless society. The tech-savvy both palms in front of the cashier
generation, like Generation Z, is digitally literate and has a high and make the shopping journey
dependency on technology and automated seamless services. As a seamless and replace the need to
scan or tap physical payment
result, the demand for digital payment systems will grow in the
methods.39
coming years.
CapitaLand and Shopee

collaborate to accelerate the
‘Smile to Pay’ facial recognition
digitalization and offline
payment system in Hangzhou activation of Singapore retailers
In China, the digital payment
CapitaLand is partnering with
system is becoming the ’new retailers to adapt to the new
normal,’ and now, Alipay uses a
normal, creating a holistic retail
3D facial recognition camera and ecosystem integrating offline and
biometric identification online channels. CapitaLand mall
technology for payments.40
is using gamification to drive
Alipay users can authenticate offline sales and engagement
their payment through facial
with customers to their physical
scanning and their mobile stores and online. CapitaLand’s
number. The user don’t even digital twin platforms empower
need to bring their wallet or
retailers in enhancing their in-
smartphones to pay for what they store customer experience with
ordered.
pre-ordering and click-and-collect
options.”41
Data platform that integrates
sightseeing experience in
Tourism Valencia
Since 2015, Spain’s national

government has been
researching smart tourism
It is not easy for visitors who are not familiar with their holiday
following announcement of a
destinations to enjoy and get the best out of it in such a short stay. smart tourism destination project.
However, utilizing data and delivering an integrated experience is the The city of Benidorm in Valencia
key to increasing their satisfaction. The collaboration between is working with national
different stakeholders, again, is vital to realizing a government, the Valencian
stress-free experience. community, local universities,
hotels, and start ups, to deliver
integrated experiences to visitors
by utilizing data.42
Dunhuang in China drives its city Visi+Aizu supports visitors

development by smart tourism through the whole journey
Working with tech giant, Huawei, Visi+Aizu, a Destination

Dunhuang has been constructing Management Organization, in
a new model through which they AizuWakamatsu is utilizing data
can maximize the limited for better promotion and
resources available with marketing, in addition to
communities and corporates providing services from users’
working together. In Dunhuang, point of view. It suggests
digitalization is happening rapidly sightseeing spots tailored to the
– from selling 35% of tickets users’ profile, while supporting
online and to using facial travel planning and helping them
recognition for entrance. with any language problems.
Resulting in high visitors Through this, they are enhancing
satisfactions of 96.5%.43 visitors’ experiences.44
07
Future Vision for Smart City

in Japan
Citizen-centric cities will empower people even further, enabling
them to achieve things beyond imagination. We can learn from
other countries’ smart city case studies and design better future
smart city services for the future of Japan.

A future vision of
smart city services
Taking inspirations from other case studies, Japan can drive
changes and create a future vision for smart cities. For a smart
city to be truly smart, one must use diverse approaches to
leverage technology to improve citizens' overall quality of life.
The smart reference architecture brings city layers together to

build the smart city of the future in Japan. Each areas needs to
achieve individual goals in order to obtain the four main points of
smart city advancement:
1. All smart city project participants must be aware of citizen-
centric principles.
2. To sustainably manage Smart city, the city needs a governance
and management mechanism.
3. Smart city services via city OS, data and services must be
regulated.
4. In order to efficiently develop and implement Japan-wide
smart cities, City OS and City management must be
interoperable with other rural regions.

Healthcare
Innovative life-cycle platform to

better manage community health
Personal Healthcare Record (PHR) improving healthcare
experience and patients’ well-being
In the PHR platform, medical records, and DNA test data from beginning
to end of life stages will be stored in one unified medical record system,
allowing patients smarter and better healthcare experiences.
When the patient’s body and/or mental state worsens, the patient will
receive a notification through PHR to consult a healthcare expert. By
using an app, the patient will have options of an in-person consultation,
online consultation, or order over the counter medicine. When the patient
decides to go for an in-person consultation, the patient will book the
consultation and enter symptoms online. Only having to stay in the
hospital for 15 minutes to receive their consultation and medicines,
eliminating waiting time. After consultation, the PHR will record the
consultation data to improve personalization of patient care, better
managing community health, and encouraging patients to live
healthier lifestyle.

Healthcare
Preventative
Healthcare
for everyone
Preventing diseases and improving quality of life
The future of healthcare should shift its focus on to preventative

healthcare, detecting and preventing diseases, and at the same
time improving healthcare experts' efficiency, and decreasing
healthcare costs. Preventive care is a vital step to manage and
enhance an individual's quality of life.
Technologies can enable universal healthcare to the patients at a

low cost, improving individual health quality outcomes and
independent living wellness solutions with remote healthcare and
telemedicine. By utilizing AI and voice recognition, medical
records can be automatically filled out in a matter of minutes,
making the whole experience smoother.
Citizens should manage, secure, and access their electronic

health records and e-prescriptions, sharing them across borders.
By sharing health data, it will benefit patient treatment, diagnosis,
and also help to prevent future diseases. Furthermore, future
healthcare should facilitate feedback and interaction between
patients and healthcare providers to empower them to take
responsibility for their own management of health.

Education
Seamless learning ensuring

continuity of education
Smart education can be accessed anywhere, anytime
Every student learns in different ways and paces; and they will benefit
from individually personalized tasks in mixed digital and physical
environments continuously learning across different scenarios. The future
education will seamlessly integrate private and public learning data in a
virtual learning system. Seamless learning uses immersive, collaborative
and interactive virtual learning platforms; designed for better student
engagement, making continuous learning possible.
Education needs to equip students with the 21st century skills to thrive in
the future’s world. Which means, technology is at the heart of the future’s
education. With distant learning becoming the new normal, the learning
environment is not limited to classrooms anymore, so students can learn
anywhere, anytime. Some educators and technology evangelists believe
that eventually, education will be an entirely digital pursuit fortified by
artificial intelligence and virtual learning. AI can play roles as diverse as
checking homework to voice identification. Students can simply
communicate through voice recognition to ask questions, making their
learning experiences better.

Education
Tailored learning
experience for
all children
Utilising Life Time Data to deliver tailored
education model
In the future of education, connecting the regional integrated

education model using children-centered approaches could mean
all of the education data can be stored and accessed in a unified
platform. This will involve kindergarten to secondary school,
private tutoring schools, universities, and industries. Collecting
lifetime data in Learning Record Store (LRS) allows students to
receive a tailored education model fitted to the individual’s needs.
Digital learning infrastructure will allow students who are ill or

refuse to attend school to get tailored learning experiences fitted
to their unique environment. Computer-based modules enable
students to participate in remote lectures from the ‘best’
teacher online.
Additionally, safety net model will detect neglect and abuse at

home. This same model also allows parents to check their
children’s GPS history and check if he/she is walking home safely
from school. When in trouble, the emergency alarms go off and
prevent kidnapping before it happens.

Agriculture
Using data-driven farming to create

efficiency in agriculture
Using data to increase efficiency and production quality
and quantity
The farming industry will become more critical than ever in the next few
years. To feed the growing population amid labor shortages, IoT can play
a role in increasing efficiency, reducing human labor, and cutting down
food wastages by involving them in the farming processes.
The internet of things, including sensors, will collect information to

monitor soil conditions, define weather forecasts that can predict
conditions like temperature, wind speed, and rain, and detect and
monitor infestation through drones and AI. By making the whole process
transparent and visualized from production to consumption, society can
respond to the food loss problem efficiently and attract young successors
through productivity development, making them more willing to work as
farmers. The future of smart agriculture will be more sustainable,
increasing production quantity and quality all while minimizing
environmental impact.

Agriculture
Digitalized food
supply chain model
will benefit producers
Delivering products to those who need them directly
The problems related to agriculture in this country are getting

ever more severe, due to the downsizing of the domestic farm
production market, as the country’s population is decreasing, and
the farmers are aging.
The supply chain of farm products is not digitalized, which leads

to a mismatch of supply and demand as well as inefficiency within
the system, eventually causing a significant amount of food loss.
Digitalization allows the optimization of the food supply chain.

Instead of aggregating farm products to central location, they can
be sent to each area directly, including the local area that they
are produced.
By connecting the digital supply chain with City OS, producers

and consumers can match directly supply and demand, enabling
a better understanding of production in order to reduce food loss.

Disaster Management
Building robustness and redundancy in cities

makes them become a safer place to live
Smart services shine in the occurrence of a disaster
Smart cities also bring a difference to those who live in the area in the
event of an emergency. Utilizing opt-in data and reading the situation,
governments can give people live updates on the status of an emergency,
personalized instructions for evacuation, and rescue if they happen to be
unable to evacuate by themselves or go missing.
Smart cities also store resources and energy for an emergency that are
saved by its efficient system in every day's operation. This enables cities
to function during emergencies and provide essential services to citizens.
In the future, the system will predict an incoming disaster and give
citizens instructions beforehand. Some cities have already started to use
climate and environmental data to predict possible disasters to create a
more resilient city.

Disaster Management
A companion
during an
emergency
Utilizing GPS information for giving instruction and
facilitating rescue
In the case of disaster, local governments only provides

generalized updates on the situation, which is often not enough
for those who are unfamiliar with the area and local processes.
My hazard app, by utilizing opt-in GPS information gives tailored

live updates and instructions of evacuation. The opt-in GPS
information can then also be used for rescuing people who are
missing in the event of a disaster.
This system is integrated into City OS. Although each city has
their own city OS system, these are usually connected to one
another. In the event of a disaster, they can run off-grid in order to
provide essential services in that area. Furthermore, cities
surrounding the hazardous area can provide help.

08
Challenges The need to make cities more resilient has
been proven in 2020 with a global pandemic
along the way that has tested cities around the globe.
Climate is also posing another big treat in the
coming years, there is a bigger sense of
urgency than ever before.

COVID-19 has deeply challenged
the pursue for smart cities to be
more resilient.

People’s behaviours and
priorities has shifted
since Covid-19
45
The cost of confidence The Virtual Century Cocooning
The pandemic enforced a sudden The desire for cocooning has been
Pandemics can deeply affect people’s rapidly increasing since the pandemic,
acceleration of virtual technologies,
lives with decision-making skills with people spending more money on
influencing ways of working,
becoming an anxious process. An safety-related products, technology,
communication, transaction, and health products, and masks etc.
explicit message of covid-19 is that socializing. People tend to retreat to a safe space
other people/ places can carry an “Covid-19 offers proof of the benefits where the threat is the least. People will
invisible threat. People are of smart cities because cities with a stay and enhance the sense of belonging
postponing purchase decisions due digital platform in place, are able to in their local community just to feel safe
to uncertainty. Individualism has collect and analyze data, can more during this difficult time. Cocooning is
risen, with people adopting a look- rapidly understand where making households more prepared for
adjustments need applying,” Gartner future pandemics and giving them the
after-yourself-first policy. mental comfort they need. This creates a
predicts that by 2022, digitization, or
community-centric society, and
the internet of things, will save
community response to a pandemic will
consumers and businesses $1 trillion be remembered as a vital approach of
a year in maintenance, services and flattening the curve.
consumables on a global level.

The impact of
loneliness and
isolation
In the US, more than half of people reported that their
mental health had been negatively impacted by social
isolation. Also, in one study 19% responded that they felt
isolated. The impact of loneliness and isolation should not
be understated; research has shown that it can be “twice as
harmful to physical and mental health as obesity.46
There’s more people who suffer from mental health issues

in Japan as well. According to the ministry of health, labour
and welfare, the number of people who seek advice from
mental health support centers has spiked in April
and May.47

Covid-19 is shifting city priorities
Covid-19 has played a disruptor role in smart cities, with

citizens experiencing different isolation levels, lack of
connectedness, and differing response to the pandemic and
economic crisis. Cities are responding to the pandemic in very
different ways. Governments have implemented measures to
address economic impact of the pandemic such as promoting
remote work.
Some cities are taking a different approach during this

pandemic trying to keep the outbreak under control while
providing stable paying jobs during this time.

Inclusion Chicago project helping people in need during
this pandemic
The covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated social and economic

inequalities in the world. In Chicago, there is a disproportionate
impact on the low-income residents of color.48 To resolve that, they
have increased access to stable paying jobs for residence of color.
Chicago has also provided housing assistant for people in need.
Seoul contains Covid-19 by using pre-existed smart city data base
Seoul, South Korea is one of the first countries to bring covid-19

outbreak under control. The South Korean government made all new
arrivals download a government app that tracks their location.
South Korea is using their existing smart city database that tracks air
quality and traffic data, alongside existing infrastructure to track
covid-19 patients.49

Covid-19 is testing
city level resilience
Cities are using technology to better manage this pandemic

and support citizens during this challenging period. Local
authorities are funding the development of a social-support
communities, creating a safe space for individuals within
the community.
Resilience enables individuals and communities to cope with

the stress, promoting well-being, and enhancing the sense of
belonging and community together.
Cities should seize the moment and focus on the

new possibilities.

Emerging
opportunities
post Covid-19
More opportunities triggered by Covid-19
Covid-19 has changed the global economy, businesses, and way

of life. The normalization of remote work has decentralized the
workforce, making it easier for people to work from rural areas.
Digitalization has been accelerated by covid-19, and this has
triggered changes in online consumption habits forever. Remote
and distance learning will provide students to learn in interactive
and engaging ways by using technology; this also allows students
to study flexibly and re-watch the lectures anywhere
they want. Concerts are all held online using cutting edge
technology to create an unrealistic sci-fi world, creating a new
type of entertainment.
Japan’s authorities are promoting a new way of living and rural

migration to prevent the spread of covid-19, while making huge
opportunities for rural areas to drive rural migration and improve
quality of life.

Work from Bermuda certificate
Bermuda took an ambitious response to Covid-19, launched

a "work from Bermuda" one-year residential certificate while
working and studying remotely on the island.50 Bermuda is
one of the countries that successfully managed the first
wave of pandemic. Now attracting foreign nationals to stay
as a tourist to stimulate the local travel-based economy. In
coming years, as covid-19 boosts remote working, the digital
nomad lifestyle could provide inspiration for new ways of
working for location-independent individuals.
Seattle and San Francisco Slow Street project
Due to the pandemic, there’s reduced bus services and use

of cars, resulting in an overall decreased in traffic on city
roads. Seattle and San Francisco took this as an opportunity
for people to get out, and be safe and secure, in an urban
environment, expanding cycling and pedestrian
infrastructure. Discouraging cars from using so-called ‘slow
streets’, pedestrians and cyclists have more space and are
not limited to using sidewalks for their journeys.51

09
Looking into the future
The next decade will be posing big challenges that
cities will have to overcome, but with challenges comes
opportunities for innovation.

The realignment
of priorities
New expectations and opportunities are emerging at a
rapid pace
People have become more concerned and vocal about environmental,

sustainable, equality and social matters, placing a spotlight on
companies, institutions, and governments that are not acting in
accordance with the current values that citizens hold to heart.
For instance, the growing trend of governments being sued for

climate inaction shows that citizens aren’t only concerned, they are
taking action to drive government behaviour towards what they
consider a better version of the future.
Alongside people’s demands and expectations changing, what is

possible with new technologies empowers the creation of new
solutions that were not possible in the past. Additionally, what is
deemed as a viable solution is changing too. New citizen
expectations and new technologies enable the creation of new ways
of delivering services and governing cities.

Responding with
new perspectives
A new approach to create the future of cities
Adopting new ways of working and technologies are

essential steps to move forward with addressing the current
challenges and emerging needs that we have outlined.
Beyond those steps, a more remarkable change in the
perspectives considered in future solutions is needed to
reflect the complexity of growing needs.
Redefining the voices included in creating a solution for a

city is required. This is the space where co-created solutions
can shine as they combine perspectives as part of the
creation process of a solution. Therefore, providing a more
complete view of the city layers will benefit a new solution.
This will lead to transparent public participation and co-
creation between citizens, the private sector, academia, and
government are essential for a smart city's success.

Expanding smart services Neighbouring Cities and Region
beyond city borders

City Boundaries
Supporting citizens’ needs comprehensively
The delivery of smart services tends to be confined City Outskirts

within the borders of cities, as it’s municipalities that and Rural Areas
undertake smart city initiatives. However, citizens
need to go outside of where they live on several
occasions in their daily lives. Many citizens work or
may spend their time over the weekend in
neighbouring towns. This indicates that citizens can’t
benefit in the same way as they do within a municipal City Center
area once they go outside its borders.
To support citizens’ unique needs comprehensively,

we need to look at expanding boundaries of smart
services across city boundary. Defining citizens' ‘living
area’ to cluster neighbouring cities and provide smart
services beyond city borders. Furthermore, this
requires collaboration between local municipalities
regarding policies, city management, technology, How citizens may
and ecosystems. distribute their time
across city areas

Co-creating
ecosystems together
Citizens Government
For building resilient cities, all city stakeholders need to fulfill

their roles
A new approach requires new roles. Through co-creation between all

Private Sector
stakeholders, cities acquire different perspectives to redefine their
challenges and gain new opportunities.
Local city governments need to understand their responsibilities in terms

of how they impact citizens lives. In doing so, they should embrace new
opportunities to transform society. It is time for smart city initiatives to
listen to citizens, making the decision-making processes transparent, and
using citizen-centred design to address citizens’ needs. It is citizens’
responsibility to respond to it, participate, and take actions for their future
generations, understanding that each voice counts for building Academia Environment
resilient communities.
The private sector is also an essential piece in supporting smart city

projects. Creating a mutually beneficial partnership with government
agencies allows organisation to creating opportunities to encourage
employees and members of society to developing local capabilities.
Academia has a role in investing for the future by educating future
generations and fostering a testing ground for new ideas using
cutting-edge technologies.

Living ecosystem that revitalizes
communities around the globe
Everyone becomes a problem solver
The challenges we face in the 21st century are quite entangled within
the complex system we have established globally. The major
organizations' top-down approach has proved that it can not deliver
effective solutions anymore.
Rather, we need solutions at a smaller level. The fact that problems

vary from person to person and city to city shows that current cities
become the main place for devising solutions. The ownership of city
governance taken by central governments in modern society should
be given back to citizens in order to solve problems together.
By utilizing technology such as City OS, cities now can help each
other directly and more efficiently, forming an ecosystem that solves
problems more effectively and brings a lively community back
to cities.

Seizing the The 2020 covid-19 pandemic has been a once in a century
opportunity to go event that disrupted, paused, and redefined many concepts

in modern life and shook to a core the definition of “normal
life”. The outbreak has radically changed the concept of
large cities; the connectedness and density of urban areas
on a new direction were the keys to economic strength pre-covid; now, that
concept is the ‘weakness’ that puts citizens at greater risk
from the virus.
As the world transitions into the next pandemic phase, we

expect long-term changes in societies and economies
worldwide. These challenges are significant and can reset
the economic approaches in maximizing the chances of
developing more resilient and sustainable strategies. There
is no better time than now to change the game and take this
opportunity to define the processes that determine the “new
normal”. Creating opportunities to go beyond collaborating
with stakeholders through new ways of working.
Every city is unique and should consider new approaches to

transforming smart cities, reimaging a better version of the
future. It’s up to us citizens to make bold changes in society,
community, and the world.

Thank you

Contacts Contributors
Yukiyo Kanai Fjord Tokyo - Business Development Director

Shojiro Nakamura
Accenture Innovation Center Fukushima Center Co-Lead
Nao Kawashima Fjord Tokyo - Associate Service & Interaction Designer
Managing Director
[email protected]
Kento Ito Fjord Tokyo - Associate Design Researcher
Renge Ohta Accenture Business Consulting Manager
Shigeyuki Fujii
Accenture Strategy Group Managing Director Fujiko Nakasu Marketing Communication Senior Manager
[email protected]
Yuki Watanabe Marketing Communication Associate Manager
Kazumi Yamada Marketing Communication Public Relations
Eduardo Kranz S&C Research Team

Fjord Tokyo Co-Lead, Group Design Director
[email protected]
Accenture Japan Ltd

Akasaka Intercity AIR (reception: 8F). 1-8-1 Akasaka, Minato-ku, Tokyo 107-8672
Tel: 03 3588 3000 (Switchboard) Mail: [email protected]

References 14.
15.
Lightfoot, L. (2020, November 17). In CHICAGO’S INCLUSIVE RESPONSE TO COVID-19. Tomorrow. city.
https://tomorrow.city/a/chicagos-inclusive-response-to-covid-19
Machpherson, L. (2017, Sep 8). 8 Years On, Amsterdam is Still Leading the Way as a Smart City. from
https://towardsdatascience.com/8-years-on-amsterdam-is-still-leading-the-way-as-a-smart-city-79bd91c7ac13
1. One Year After Trump Decision to Withdraw from Paris Agreement, U.S. Cities Carry Climate Action 16. Startup in Residence | Bringing startups and governments together. https://startupinresidence.com/
Forward | C40. https://www.c40.org/press_releases/one-year-after-trump-decision-to-withdraw-from-
paris-agreement-u-s-cities-carry-climate-action-forward 17. Adelaide makes world's top 7 intelligent cities. https://invest.cityofadelaide.com.au/blog/adelaide-makes-worlds-
top-7-intelligent-cities/
2. Cabinet Office. (2020, Mar 18). 戦略的イノベーション創造プログラム / アーキテクチャ構築及び実証研究の成果公
表科学技術政策 - 内閣府 https://www8.cao.go.jp/cstp/stmain/20200318siparchitecture.html 18. Enhancing Partnership with NTT East Japan in the Fields of e-Sports, Cybersecurity, Etc..
3. Adler, L. (2020). How Smart City Barcelona Brought the Internet of Things to Life. The University of Aizu https://www.u-aizu.ac.jp/en/information/ntte-sports.html
https://datasmart.ash.harvard.edu/news/article/how-smart-city-barcelona-brought-the-internet-of-
things-to-life-789 19. Hartmann, I. (2020, February 21). Adelaide features in top 7 of world’s smart cities https://smart-
cities.com.au/adelaide-features-in-top-7-of-worlds-smart-cities/
4. Barcelona Smart City: By the People, for the People | HERE Mobility.
https://mobility.here.com/learn/smart-city-initiatives/barcelona-smart-city-people-people 20. Shah. (2020, October 7). Global Smart Hospitals Market to Surpass US$ 103.6 Billion by 2027, Says Coherent
Market Insights (CMI). https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20201007005443/en/Global-Smart-Hospitals-
5. Ravindra, S. (2018, July 5). The Transformation That Barcelona Had Undergone To Become A Smart City Market-to-Surpass-US-103.6-Billion-by-2027-Says-Coherent-Market-Insights-CMI
http://www.barcinno.com/barcelona-smart-city-technologies/
21. Population health and prevention · Healthcare DENMARK https://www.healthcaredenmark.dk/life-
6. Liceras, P. (2019, May 20). Singapore experiments with its digital twin to improve city life. science/denmark-a-life-science-nation/population-health-and-prevention/
https://www.smartcitylab.com/blog/digital-transformation/singapore-experiments-with-its-digital-
twin-to-improve-city-life/ 22. e-Ambulance — e-Estonia. https://e-estonia.com/solutions/healthcare/e-ambulance/
7. The first large-scale Zhaga implementation installs 10.000 inteliLIGHT LoRaWAN™ compatible street 23. Wicklund, E. (2019, August 27). Cardiac Care Project Uses mHealth Tech to Monitor Patients at Home.
lighting controllers and 600 FRCM lighting cabinet controllers bringing modern street lighting benefits https://mhealthintelligence.com/news/cardiac-care-project-uses-mhealth-tech-to-monitor-patients-at-home
to this iconic city in Italy. | inteliLIGHT®. https://intelilight.eu/zhaga-socket-used-for-a-large-scale-
lorawan-implementation-in-brescia-northern-italy/ 24. Fab Lab Barcelona https://fablabbcn.org/
8. Plantera, F. (2019, Sep). Estonia Data tracker – tool that builds trust in institutions https://e- 25. What is VinclesBCN | vinclesbcn. https://ajuntament.barcelona.cat/vinclesbcn/en/vincles-bcn
estonia.com/data-tracker-build-citizen-trust/
26. Distance Education— Huawei Enterprise. (2020). Retrieved 5 December 2020, from
9. Fox, C. (2020, May 7). Google affiliate Sidewalk Labs abandons Toronto waterfront project. https://e.huawei.com/hu/solutions/industries/education/distance-education
https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/google-affiliate-sidewalk-labs-abandons-toronto-waterfront-project-
1.4928968 27. Growing at a slower pace, world population is expected to reach 9.7 billion. (2019, June 17). UN DESA United
Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
10. A new framework for promoting Human-centric development and regional revitalization in Japan. The https://www.un.org/development/desa/en/news/population/world-population-prospects-2019.html
Wall Street Journal. Smart Cities in Japan. https://partners.wsj.com/japan-cabinet-office/smart-cities/
28. Smart Places. (2019) (p. 21). British Council. Retrieved from
11. Machpherson, L. (2017, Sep 8). 8 Years On, Amsterdam is Still Leading the Way as a Smart City. from https://www.britishcouncil.org/sites/default/files/smart_places_report.pdf
https://towardsdatascience.com/8-years-on-amsterdam-is-still-leading-the-way-as-a-smart-city-
79bd91c7ac13 29. Area X.O | Drive the Future. (2020). Retrieved 5 December 2020, from https://areaxo.com/
12. Open Innovation Competition. City of Melbourne.https://participate.melbourne.vic.gov.au/open- 30. Vertical farming finally grows up in Japan. (2020, January 23). https://www.ft.com/content/f80ea9d0-21a8-11ea-
innovation b8a1-584213ee7b2b
13. Free Open-Source participatory democracy for cities and organizations | Decidim. https://decidim.org/

References
44. 観光を軸にインテリジェントな街づくりを目指すスマート敦煌 - Huawei Japan. (2018, July 6).
https://www.huawei.com/jp/publications/huawave/30/hw30_winners
45. Nakamura, S. (2018, April 19). 広域創生に向けたインバウンド戦略を支える会津のデジタルDMO【第６回】 -

DIGITAL X（デジタルクロス）. https://dcross.impress.co.jp/docs/column/column20171122-01/000489.html
31. Grillo – Earthquake Early-Warnings for everyone. Retrieved 5 December 2020, from 46. Accenture COVID-19 New Human Truths That Experiences Need To Address (Rep.). (n.d.). Retrieved
https://grillo.io/?v=24d22e03afb2 Accenture-COVID-19-New-Human-Truths-That-Experiences-Need-To-Address.pdf
32. Fujisawa: A New Type of Smart City - Safe and Smart City, https://safesmart.city/en/fujisawa-a-new- 47. Staglin G. (2020, May 17). When Home Becomes The Workplace: Mental Health And Remote Work.
type-of-smart-city/?doing_wp_cron=1607156964.3023090362548828125000 Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/onemind/2020/03/17/when-home-becomes-the-workplace-
mental-health-and-remote-work/?sh=67b2a0801760
33. Eight Ways Cities Are Building Climate Resilience, https://www.iisd.org/faq/building-a-climate-
resilient-city/ 48. (2020, July 27). コロナうつで初の実態調査厚労省、１万人規模. Nikkei News.
https://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXMZO61932630X20C20A7CE0000
34. The line, A revolution in urban living ｜NEOM. https://www.neom.com/whatistheline/
49. Inclusion Chicago. (2020). Ywca Metropolitan Chicago. https://ywcachicago.org/our-work/inclusion-
35. Autonomous vehicles helping transport COVID-19 tests at Florida Mayo Clinic | Roads & Bridges. (2020, chicago/?gclid=CjwKCAiA_Kz-BRAJEiwAhJNY72UIYsrrt0h8yATy1ZKq96V6y7qpmy6-
April 20). https://www.roadsbridges.com/autonomous-vehicles-helping-transport-covid-19-tests- RfgAyxsp86s0jmFPOarcWBoCvEMQAvD_BwE
florida-mayo-clinic
50. Holmes, A. (2020). South Korea is relying on technology to contain COVID-19, including measures that
36. GACHA Early Pilot Program｜MUJI. https://www.muji.com/muji-gacha/en/news/ would break privacy laws in the US — and so far, it's working.
https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-south-korea-tech-contact-tracing-testing-fight-covid-
37. 世界の最先端スマートオフィス５選 | Techfirm blog (2019, April 9). 19-2020-5
https://www.techfirm.co.jp/blog/smartest-offices
51. Work from Bermuda Certificate. Bermuda’s official travel resource.
38. Randall, T. (2015, Sep 23). The Edge Is the Greenest, Most Intelligent Building in the World. https://www.gotobermuda.com/workfrombermuda
https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2015-the-edge-the-worlds-greenest-building/
52. Oakland, San Francisco, and Seattle open streets to pedestrians during pandemic. Civil Engineering
39. ECO_MBS-Green-Facts.pdf. Source. (2020). https://source.asce.org/streets-opened-to-pedestrians-during-covid-19-pandemic/
https://jp.marinabaysands.com/content/dam/singapore/marinabaysands/master/main/home/compan
y-information/environmental-sustainability/ECO_MBS-Green-Facts.pdf
40. Kumar, D. (2020, September 29). Introducing Amazon One—a new innovation to make everyday
activities effortless. https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/innovation-at-amazon/introducing-amazon-
one-a-new-innovation-to-make-everyday-activities-effortless
41. BRENNAN, T. (2017, Sep 1). Alipay Launches 'Smile to Pay' for Commercial Use in China | Alizila.com
https://www.alizila.com/alipay-launches-smile-to-pay-commercial-
use/#:~:text=%E2%80%9CSmile%20to%20Pay%2C%E2%80%9D%20the,inputting%20their%20mobile%2
0phone%20numbers
42. CapitaLand and Shopee collaborate to accelerate digitalisation of Singapore retailers through
diversified retail strategies (2020). https://www.capitaland.com/international/en/about-
capitaland/newsroom/news-releases/international/2020/oct/CapitaLand-and-Shopee-
collaborate.html#menu-lang-main
43. スマートリゾートハンドブック.
https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/mono_info_service/mono/creative/downloadfiles/fy31/handbook2.pdf

Accenture A Resilient Future For Cities

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Accenture A Resilient Future For Cities

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Accenture A Resilient Future For Cities

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

A resilient

future for cities

Summary continually evolving to respond to newer urban challenges. In their current

By leveraging cutting-edge technology, cities can deliver a new possibility of

Cities need to evolve towards empowering co-creation where all stakeholders-

This document concludes by looking at how a holistic approach is essential

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 2

01 From A Citizen’s Perspective

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 3

Changing the perspective when thinking about cities is

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 4

The ability to work and live in a community has created an

In Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the sense of belonging is

Consequently, there is no surprise that with the evolution of

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 5

The complexity of cities has increased throughout history and

There is a need to go back to the original role of

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 6

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 7

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 8

However, demographics in the 21st century look different to how they

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 9

The 11th goal of the ‘Sustainable Development Goals’ established by the

Because of the accelerated urbanization that has progressed in the past

Cities are expected to contribute to solving the most critical global

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 10

Cities themselves are also becoming aware of their missions and

In 2017, when President Donald Trump announced the USA

Amsterdam has published roadmaps for circular economies,

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 12

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 13

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 14

serve its citizens Citizen and Communities

directly and indirectly Business, Employment & Value Creation

Government Policies and Laws

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 15

for smart services Citizens & Communities (Urban & Rural)

City operating system and city management

City operating system realizes the integration of data and

equally important to deliver smart city services continuously

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 17

Regional collaboration enhances services like traffic congestions

Smaller cities suffer from insufficient resources, lacking of know-

A city that can detect, adapt, and respond to changes in its

Also, cities can share resources and knowledge, and give

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 19

Technology Is The Enabler

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 20

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 21

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 22

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 23

Therefore, City OS, which integrates data from various

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 24

Smart Smart City Business Smart Authentication

service and external information, enabling the Role & Function

City OS provides standard functions needed for Deregulations &

Copyright© 2021 Accenture. All Rights Reserved. 25

Technologies that make network platform

Sentilo is a real-time open-source