BC - Lesson 4
BC - Lesson 4
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
This lesson explores the waste management hierarchy, clarifying the advantages of environmentally
sound management of plastic waste at source.
It highlights the objectives and key elements of efficient and effective waste prevention and
minimization strategies, such as decoupling, resource efficiency and eco-design, and linkages with
the Stockholm Convention measures in this respect, illustrated by concrete examples.
To allow you to apply the knowledge to specific national and/or local circumstances, the lesson
explains which type of strategies can be applied, approaches per sector and the involvement of
stakeholders.
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
1. explain the waste hierarchy and its Questions are posed throughout the text for you
benefits; to check own understanding. The questions are
2. identify options for waste prevention in various formats, from open (reflection points)
and minimization policies; and to multiple choice, true/false, ranking, and/or
matching. The answers can be consulted at the
3. describe the key steps in designing
end of the journal.
and implementing such policies.
1
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
WHAT ARE the goals and purposes of plastic waste prevention and minimization?
Prevention and minimization strategies can help ▪ reducing energy consumption and
to protect human health and the environment greenhouse gas emissions (such as from
as well as stimulate economic growth and landfills)
the transition towards circularity. Concrete ▪ improving material and resource efficiency
benefits include:
▪ reducing the use of harmful substances in
▪ decoupling resource use (and associated the production of plastics, such as POPs
costs) and waste generation from chemicals listed in Annexes A, B and C to
economic the Stockholm Convention
▪ growth ▪ stimulating the development of sustainable
▪ reducing environmental impacts of products and services
resource extraction, manufacturing and ▪ creating jobs
distribution
Which of the above benefits would you place higher than others, given the context of your
country?
2
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
The waste management hierarchy is based on managing it. The waste management hierarchy
the idea that it is less costly, more efficient and sorts different interventions in addressing
more sustainable to prevent waste in the first waste from most to least preferred, as shown in
instance, instead of generating and subsequently the diagram.
3
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
A 2018 UNEP report found a strong momentum of plastic bags and 61 countries had adopted
towards regulating the manufacture, distribution, manufacturing and import bans. Moreover, 51
use and trade of plastic bags: 83 countries countries had adopted recycling targets for
had adopted a ban on free retail distribution plastic bags.
4
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Life cycle thinking means considering reducing resource use and emissions to the
environmental, social and economic impacts environment while at the same time improving
across the entire life cycle with the aim of socio-economic performance.
* Annex IV A lists all operations which do not lead to the possibility of resource recovery, recycling, reclamation,
direct re-use or alternative uses
A product life cycle ranges from the extraction the use of a plastic product aids the prevention of
of raw materials to recycling, reuse, recovery or plastic waste. This also applies for reducing the
final disposal. In each life cycle stage there is the use of polymers that are less easy to recycle and
potential to reduce resource consumption and replacing them by other materials in the design
improve the performance of products. Extending and production phase.
Sources: UNEP (2018), UNEP (2019), EEA (2020), Geyer (2020). Illustration by Levi Westerveld / GRID-Arendal
(2021). Research by Maria Tsakona.
5
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
While the waste management hierarchy generate the most environmental, social and
highlights the benefits of prioritising front- economic benefits. This often needs to be
of-the-pipe to end-of-the-pipe solutions, determined on a case-by-case basis, as illustrated
the integrated life cycle approach can help to in the following example:
determine at which stage an intervention will
A meta-analysis by the UNEP Life Cycle Initiative compared single-use plastic bags with
alternatives, such as reusable and bio-based LDPE bags, paper bags, biodegradable bags,
etc. The analysis found that the environmental impacts of the different options varied across
environmental categories.
For example, the single-use plastic bag was considered a poor option in terms of litter on land,
marine litter and microplastics, but it scored well in other environmental impact categories, such
as climate change, acidification, eutrophication, water use and land use. Overall environmental
rankings, therefore, depend on what environmental aspects are relevant for a specific case or
what aspect is given the highest priority.
6
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
The analysis points out that reusable bags need to be used multiple times for optimum reduction
of environmental impacts. Policymakers should, therefore, give adequate attention to the
design of bags for durability, incentivizing the reuse of bags, the provision of adequate waste
management and end-of-life solutions, and the accessibility and affordability of such alternatives.
The Strategic framework for the implementation best overall environmental outcome, taking into
of the Basel Convention, adopted by the COP account life cycle thinking. Objective 2.2 of the
through decision BC-10/2 (see also lesson 1), strategic framework is to pursue the prevention
features among its guiding principles the need and minimization of hazardous waste and other
to recognize the waste management hierarchy. waste generation at source.
It encourages treatment options that deliver the
In 2013, the COP adopted the Framework for the emphasises that waste prevention should be
ESM of hazardous wastes and other wastes. The the preferred option in any waste management
ESM framework calls on stakeholders to promote policy. The framework also recognises that
an integrated life cycle approach and highlights some wastes are already, or will inevitably be,
that stakeholders should respect the waste generated and such wastes should be managed
management hierarchy. The ESM framework in an environmentally sound manner.
7
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
HOW DOES the Basel Convention address the prevention and minimization of
plastic waste?
By bringing the listed types of plastic waste under increase resource efficiency and the importance
the provisions pertaining to waste prevention of the waste management hierarchy. The Plastic
and minimization, the Amendments will stimulate Waste Partnership, through project group 1 on
innovation, such as in the design of alternatives prevention and minimisation, has developed a
to plastic and in the phasing out of toxic additives. “Draft compilation of information, best practices
Decision BC-14/13 emphasizes the need to and lessons learned on measures taken to
adopt a life cycle approach to plastics and to prevent and reduce single use plastic waste”.
This draft output of the PWP project group 1 on prevention and minimization features many
examples that could inspire action to reduce the generation of plastic waste. It covers bans,
market-based instruments, plastic taxes, extended producer responsibility schemes, etc. as well
as several country case studies. One of the country case studies concerns China. China’s new
plastic bag ban adopts a gradual approach, banning different kinds of non-degradable single-use
plastics between 2020 and 2050.
• Prohibiting by 2020, the production and sale of ultra-thin plastic shopping bags, polyethylene
agricultural mulch and disposable foam plastic tableware.
• Prohibiting by the end of 2022, the production and sale of household chemicals containing
plastic beads, non-degradable plastic bags and non-degradable disposable plastic tableware
and others.
• Prohibiting by the end of 2025, the production and sale of non-degradable plastic bags
(expanded to villages, etc.) and non-degradable disposable tableware in the food and
beverage delivery area of cities by 30% above the prefectural level etc.
8
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Waste prevention and minimization strategies fall into four broad categories:
These aim at changing behaviour and enabling The ‘Feels Good to Refill’ campaign in
informed decisions. This could include providing New Zealand
information on hazardous substances contained
New Zealand ran a ‘Feels good to refill’ campaign,
in plastic products; undertaking awareness
which promoted refilling bottles over the summer
campaigns on the benefits of switching to
period, educating people on the benefits of
alternatives; and education and training
refilling and providing a website to allow them
programmes for stakeholders from the private
to find their nearest free refill station. The
and public sector, for example, on technologies
government is also funding a design project
available for reducing the use of plastics.
for a New Zealand container return scheme for
Examples from around the world:
beverage containers. This has included looking at
Recyclability labelling in Chile options for refilling, recognising that reuse should
be prioritised over recycling.
Chile has launched a public-private initiative to
trial a recyclability label for packaging. The first
products with the label were due to enter the
market in 2021.
Promotional strategies
These involve providing incentives for Disposable cup deposit fees in the US
behavioural change as well as providing
An American coffee multinational measured a
financial and logistical support for beneficial
2.8% reusable rate in company-operated stores
initiatives. For instance, businesses could set
in the US and saved 105 million disposable cups
voluntary recycling targets and, governments
by tracking discounts provided when customers
and the businesses could enter into public-
brought their own cup. In the United Kingdom,
private partnerships to advance research on non-
a trial of a 5-pence disposable cup fee and a
plastic alternatives, etc. Examples from around
25-pence reusable cup incentive increased
the world:
reusable cup usage for hot drinks sold in stores
from 2.2% to 5.8%.
10
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Scotland has consulted on the proposal to The ‘Plastic Free Campaign’ run by the Jamaican
introduce charges for environmentally harmful government used social media to engage people
items, with single-use cups identified as a priority to support a ban on single-use plastics in Jamaica,
item. This built on previous advice of an expert use reusable bags, and imagine a Jamaica free
panel that a charge is more effective than a of expanded polystyrene foam (styrofoam). The
discount in changing behaviour and increasing campaign used incentives, such as giveaways to
reusable cup use. get people engaged, and statistics about how
styrofoam is toxic for human health.
Regulatory strategies
11
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Technology strategies
These involve the development and use of Global Commitment 2020 Progress report:
specific technologies that aim at preventing
https://articulateusercontent.com/rise/
and minimizing waste generation, e.g. when
courses/8K1F0qfaJmYFrrN1wRYvlexWKDs_
manufacturing new products or when providing
lrfl/8eH5wqk-Wsl2Xaxh-Global-Commitment-
services to consumers. This could include, for
2020-Progress-Report.pdf
example, efforts to enhance the durability of
certain plastics and improving the recyclability New technologies, such as nanotechnology,
of plastic products. A UN report on exploring genetic modification and advanced chemical
the potential for adopting alternative materials processes, can help curb plastic pollution by
to reduce marine plastic litter assessed 25 case developing natural substitutes and producing
studies on alternatives for the use of plastic. more biodegradable plastics. However,
Examples from around the world: appropriate policies are needed to maximize
the potential of new technologies for winning
Reducing the need for plastic packaging in the fight against plastic pollution. Interventions
grocery stores in the Netherlands at the production stage will have to be
A Dutch grocery retail company is using a dry complemented by interventions at other stages
misting technology to remove the need for of the plastics life cycle, including in usage and
plastic packaging around fruits and vegetables disposal, where frontier technologies can play
in 150 stores in The Netherlands, which could equally important roles.
help save 270 tonnes of plastic packaging per
year. The retailer is also using ‘natural branding’
instead of stickers to mark its organic fruits and Frontier Technology Quarterly: Frontier
vegetables, which also reduces the need to technologies for addressing plastic pollution:
wrap them, saving 13 metric tonnes of plastic https://www.un.org/development/desa/dpad/
packaging. publication/frontier-technology-quarterly-
september-2019-frontier-technologies-for-
addressing-plastic-pollution/
Enhancing recycled content in clothing
A branded clothing company, aiming for a
Q3: Enforcing limits on waste generation,
minimum of 70% recycled content in all remaining
expanding environmental obligations and
plastic packaging by 2025, has partnered with a
imposing environmental criteria on public
poly-bag manufacturer who collects poly-bags,
contracts is:
recycles them and uses them for the production
of new poly-bags. This enabled the company to □ An information exchange strategy
switch from 100% virgin LDPE to 30% recycled
□ A promotional strategy
content for this packaging, saving 96 metric
tonnes of virgin plastic each year.
□ A regulatory strategy
□ A technology strategy
12
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
HOW CAN plastic waste prevention and minimization strategies be prepared and
implemented?
An effective plastic waste prevention and 1. Providing a vision on the scope and
minimization strategy builds on existing timeframe of the strategy;
initiatives and embraces the most efficient and 2. Defining the specific objectives
effective complementary measures, both binding driving the strategy;
and voluntary. It is essential to follow a multi-step
3. Setting priority areas on which the
approach, overall, encompassing the following:
waste strategy should focus; and
4. Selecting and combining
measures that will bring about low
environmental impacts and efficient
material systems.
13
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
The preparation of a plastic waste prevention and 2. A project team which includes:
minimization strategy may be initiated with the 3. Establishment of a knowledge base
following four steps:
4. An operational plan
INITIAL ASSESSMENT
Assess the situation with regard to aspects, such as the plastic waste generation per capita; public
awareness for plastic waste prevention and minimization;
COLLECTION OF INFORMATION
Complementing the previous assessment; gather and analyse information on available
infrastructure; existing plastic waste management systems; and trade in plastic and plastic
waste, etc.
ANALYSIS OF POLICIES
Identify and analyse existing policies relevant for the prevention and minimization of plastic waste
at national, regional and local level (e.g. EPR schemes, partnerships, etc.), thereby identifying gaps
and opportunities as well as potential trade-offs.
INVOLVEMENT OF STAKEHOLDERS
Involve relevant stakeholders from the public and private sector as well as civil society and
academia from the outset, both in gathering information as well as consulting on potential
measures to be implemented.
Taking into account the outcomes of steps 1 and 2, priorities can be set in terms of the following:
SCOPE
Determine how the strategy will be integrated (or not) in existing national or regional plans as
well as whether it will address plastic waste prevention and minimization by addressing key
stakeholders (e.g. households and businesses); waste streams (e.g. packaging waste); and/or
phases of the lifecycle (e.g. design, production and consumption).
14
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
KEY STAKEHOLDERS
Identify key stakeholders, such as consumers/households, specific industry sectors, workers
and trade unions, local authorities, dedicated nongovernmental organisations, academia and
other actors.
WASTE STREAMS
Identify the specific waste streams containing plastic waste, e.g. packaging waste, medical waste
and electronic waste, and sectors, e.g. fisheries, construction, tourism and that will be addressed.
TARGETS
Set quantitative goals with clear deadlines, considering existing trends as well as infrastructure.
Targets can be set at geographic scale (e.g. minimizing plastic waste generation in a certain area by
a certain percentage), be sector-specific (e.g. reducing plastic waste generation from tourism by a
certain percentage), and be time-bound (e.g. setting a deadline by which a certain plastic product
will be phased out), etc. Targets can vary in terms of whether they are quantitative or qualitative,
voluntary or binding, etc.
This phase involves identifying and listing (e.g. via a tax on the production/import of plastic
necessary resources required and mechanisms products) with a dedicated fund to implement
for mobilising them with the aim of safeguarding plastic waste prevention and minimization
their supply for the longer term. For instance, it initiatives. This can help with prioritising actions
may be necessary to set up a financing scheme and with the adoption of a stepwise approach.
15
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
A process for adoption should be pursued government might present the strategy to its
through the relevant channels. For example, the parliament for adoption.
Considering the priorities, activities and implemented. A timeframe showing the expected
measures included in the strategy, authorities duration of the different stages and the expected
should determine at which levels they should be finalization date of the strategy should be agreed.
Q6: In attempting a plastic waste prevention Q7: In a bit more detail, what would be the
and minimization strategy, what should you logical sequence of actions when preparing
do, broadly? Put the following actions in the and implementing a plastic waste prevention
right order from 1 to 4: and minimization strategy? Put the following
actions in the right order from 1 to 8:
____ Set the priority areas on which the waste
strategy should focus ____ Assess available information, policies,
barriers and drivers of change, stakeholder
____ Provide a vision on the scope and
timeframe of the strategy ____ Adoption the strategy
16
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
In the context of the project ‘Marine litter and In 2019, Ghana became the first African nation to
microplastics: promoting the environmentally join the Global Plastic Action Partnership, thus
sound management of plastic waste and establishing the Ghana National Plastic Action
achieving the prevention and minimization Partnership (NPAP). The Ghana NPAP serves
of the generation of plastic waste’ (BRS- as the national platform for multistakeholder
Norad-1), financed by the Norwegian Agency cooperation, facilitating initiatives and funding to
for Development Cooperation (Norad), Ghana scale up and accelerate in-country partnerships
seeks to prevent and significantly reduce marine that address plastic waste and pollution
litter and microplastics. Among others, it seeks while contributing to the nation’s progress
to strengthen measures for the prevention and towards achieving many of the Sustainable
minimization of the generation of plastic waste. Development Goals.
17
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
18
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
BRS-Norad-1
CONGRATULATIONS! YOU have reached the end of lesson 4, the first lesson
of Module 2.
Lesson 5 will explore the concept of which tools can be applied to promote, facilitate
environmentally sound management (ESM) of and ensure ESM of plastic waste at all stages
plastics and its criteria, as defined under the of the life cycle, through principles, policies and
Basel Convention. It will explain, among others, practical arrangements.
19
MODULE 1 MODULE 2 MODULE 3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Answers:
Q1: Q7:
20