7 Crim 2 @3

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 93

1

CHAPTER I

THE PROBLEM AND ITS SCOPE

INTRODUCTION

Rationale

Every minute of the day, violence is devastating the lives of millions of

women and girls around the world. Violence against women and girls knows no

boundaries of geography or culture but those living in poverty face higher levels

of abuse. It is rooted in the inequality between men and women that women and

girls face throughout their lives.

It is one of the most widespread violations of human rights and has long-

term devastating effects on the lives of women, their communities and wider

society. 35 percent of women will experience violence at the hands of their

current or former partners in their lifetime, up to 70 percent according to some

national studies.

Violence locks women and girls into poverty. It limits women’s choices;

their ability to access education, earn a living and participate in political and

public life. Poverty exposes them to further violence and a lack of options when

violence occurs (1:2022).

A close analysis of the data uncovers that violence against women starts

at an early age, nearly a quarter of all girls have faced gender-based violence by

the age of 19, if they’ve been in a partner relationship. Physical and sexual
2

assaults are now a threat to female well-being to such a degree that it could be

called a pandemic. One of the defining moral challenges of our times will be to

eradicate violence against women.

International organizations should collaborate with local government

authorities to empower women to consider sharing their stories. Offering

protection for survivors is indispensable and the international community should

provide adequate material resources to lower-income regions to build gender-

based abuse shelters. Promoting access to feminine care is also critical to the

process of empowering women (2:2022).

It is on this aspect that the researchers would like to assess and propose

a preventive and safety measures to mitigate crime occurrences against women.

Theoretical Background

Theory. This study is premised on Feminist Theory by Jo Ann Arinder.

Feminist theory proposes that when power and oppression

are acknowledged and disrupted, understanding, advocacy, and change can

occur.

The core concepts in feminist theory are sex, gender, race, discrimination,

equality, difference, and choice. There are systems and structures in place that

work against individuals based on these qualities and against equality and equity.

Feminist theory considers the lived experience of any person/people, not

just women, with an emphasis on oppression.  While there may not be a


3

consensus on where feminist theory fits as a theory or paradigm, disruption of

oppression is a core tenant of feminist work. As hooks states, “Simply put,

feminism is a movement to end sexism, sexist exploitation and oppression

(3:2020).

The study is also anchored on Social Learning Theory by Edwin H.

Sutherland. Social learning theories emphasize the importance of the social

context and posit that individuals can learn by observing others’ actions and

whether these individuals are positively or negatively reinforced when exhibiting

aggressive behaviors.

Social Learning Theory proposes that individuals learn by observing the

behaviors of others (models). They then evaluate the effect of those behaviors

by observing the positive and negative consequences that follow. Social learning

theorists assert that members of the adolescent's social network who use

substances serve as models for adolescents. If adolescents see role models, such

as parents or friends, using substances with positive consequences, they are

more likely to develop positive expectations of substance use, which increases

the likelihood that the adolescent will use substances. Learning not to use

substances occurs in a similar fashion when adolescents who observe negative

consequences of use expect negative outcomes and are less likely to use

substances. Self-efficacy, an individual's confidence in their own capabilities, is

also thought to be learned socially. 


4

According to social learning theory, much of human behavior is learned

through modeling (4:2021). 

Theory: Legal Basis:

Feminist Theory by Jo Ann Arinder Republic Act No. 9262

Social Learning Theory by Edwin H. Republic Act No. 11313 or Safe


Sutherland Spaces Act

Feminist theory proposes that It is hereby declared that the State


when power and oppression values the dignity of women and children
are acknowledged and disrupted, and guarantees full respect for human
understanding, advocacy, and change can rights. The State also recognizes the need
occur. to protect the family and its members
particularly women and children, from
According to social learning violence and threats to their personal
theory, much of human behavior is safety and security.
learned through modeling. Individuals It is the policy of the State to value
learn by observing the behaviors of others the dignity of every human person and
(models). They then evaluate the effect of guarantee full respect for human rights. It
those behaviors by observing the positive is likewise the policy of the State to
and negative consequences that follow. recognize the role of women in nation-
building and ensure the fundamental
Self-efficacy, an individual's equality before the law of women and
confidence in their own capabilities, is men.
also thought to be learned socially. 

The Women’s desk adheres in the mandate of the State to provide protection for the
women. However, programs must also be implemented that would help the officers and women
to have good harmonious relationship to prevent the Violence against women.
5

Figure 1
Theoretical Framework

Legal Basis. The study is anchored on the legal framework of Republic

Act No. 9262 “an Act Defining Violence against Women and their Children,

providing for Protective Measures for Victims, prescribing Penalties therefore,

and for other purposes.

It is hereby declared that the State values the dignity of women and

children and guarantees full respect for human rights. The State also recognizes

the need to protect the family and its members particularly women and children,

from violence and threats to their personal safety and security.

Towards this end, the State shall exert efforts to address violence

committed against women and children in keeping with the fundamental

freedoms guaranteed under the Constitution and the Provisions of the Universal

Declaration of Human Rights, the convention on the elimination of all forms of

discrimination Against Women, Convention on the Rights of the Child and other

international human rights instruments of which the Philippines is a party.

The crime of violence against women and their children is committed

through any of the following acts: (a) Causing physical harm to the woman or

her child; (b) Threatening to cause the woman or her child physical harm; (c)

Attempting to cause the woman or her child physical harm; (d) Placing the

woman or her child in fear of imminent physical harm; (e) Attempting to compel

or compelling the woman or her child to engage in conduct which the woman or

her child has the right to desist from or desist from conduct which the woman or
6

her child has the right to engage in, or attempting to restrict or restricting the

woman's or her child's freedom of movement or conduct by force or threat of

force, physical or other harm or threat of physical or other harm, or intimidation

directed against the woman or child.

This shall include, but not limited to, the following acts committed with

the purpose or effect of controlling or restricting the woman's or her child's

movement or conduct: (1) Threatening to deprive or actually depriving the

woman or her child of custody to her/his family; (2) Depriving or threatening to

deprive the woman or her children of financial support legally due her or her

family, or deliberately providing the woman's children insufficient financial

support; (3) Depriving or threatening to deprive the woman or her child of a

legal right; and (4) Preventing the woman in engaging in any legitimate

profession, occupation, business or activity or controlling the victim's own

mon4ey or properties, or solely controlling the conjugal or common money, or

properties. (f) Inflicting or threatening to inflict physical harm on oneself for the

purpose of controlling her actions or decisions; (g) Causing or attempting to

cause the woman or her child to engage in any sexual activity which does not

constitute rape, by force or threat of force, physical harm, or through

intimidation directed against the woman or her child or her/his immediate family

(5:2004).

Additionally, the study is based on Republic Act No. 11313 or the Safe

Spaces Act. An act defining gender-based sexual harassment in streets, public


7

spaces, online, workplaces, and educational or training institutions, providing

protective measures and prescribing penalties therefor.

It is the policy of the State to value the dignity of every human person

and guarantee full respect for human rights. It is likewise the policy of the State

to recognize the role of women in nation-building and ensure the fundamental

equality before the law of women and men. The State also recognizes that both

men and women must have equality, security and safety not only in private, but

also on the streets, public spaces, online, workplaces and educational and

training institutions (6:2018).

Related Literature

The following readings were associated in the study in order to give

important information that can help gain profound insights into the study.

Violence against women (VAW) violates human rights and continues to be

one of the country’s perennial social problems. It manifests and perpetuates

discrimination and gender inequality. It violates the fundamental right of women

to live a life free from violence as upheld in international commitments and their

local translation. VAW also affects women and girls’ general well-being, leaving

long-term physical, psychological, sexual, and mental consequences, thereby

hampering women from achieving their full potential.


8

Global estimates by the World Health Organization indicate that about 1 in

3 women (35%) worldwide have experienced either physical and/or sexual

violence from intimate partner or non-partner in their lifetime.

In the Philippines, the 2017 National Demographic Health Survey

(NDHS) released by the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA), showed that 1 in 4

Filipino women, aged 15-49, has experienced physical, emotional or sexual

violence from their husband or partner. Since the onset of COVID-19 quarantine

restrictions in March 2020 to August 2021, a total of 18,945 VAW cases have

been reported to the PNP Women and Children Protection Center. 

Aside from domestic and intimate partner violence, women and girls also

experience various forms of sexual and gender-based violence in public spaces,

workplaces, schools, and even online. Even men, boys, and members of the

LGBTQIA community are not spared from these forms of abuse which render

public spaces unsafe for them. 

According to the global research entitled “Free to be online? Girls’ and

young women’s experiences of online harassment,” released by Plan

International, sixty-eight percent (68%) of girls and young women in the

Philippines have experienced online harassment on social media. 

A 2016 Social Weather Stations (SWS) survey reported that three in five

women have experienced sexual harassment at least once in their lifetime. The

survey was done as part of the UN Women’s Safe Cities Metro Manila

Programme. Of the 800 respondents from two barangays in Quezon City, one in
9

seven women experienced sexual harassment at least once every week in the

past year, while one in seven men have admitted to committing an act of sexual

harassment at least daily in the past year. Seventy percent (70%) of these

harassment incidents happen during the day. The survey also revealed that fifty-

eight percent (58%) of sexual harassment are experienced on the streets, major

roads, and eskinitas with majority of physical harassment happening in public

transport vehicles. 

Enacted into law in 2019, the Safe Spaces Act (SSA or Republic Act No.

11313), which defines and penalizes gender-based sexual harassment in the

streets and public spaces, workplace, educational and training institutions, and

online. Its Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) was approved on October

28, 2019. PNP data shows that from its effectivity in August 2019, there were

148 violations of RA 11313 reported to the police (7:2021).


10

According to report of the WHO of the “Trend of calls denouncing VAW

during the current COVID-19 pandemic”. In many countries all over the world a

huge increase has been reported in the number of calls from women subjected

to violence by their intimate partner from the COVID-19 pandemic declaration in

March 2020, when the recommendation for social distancing first issued in many

countries. The World Health Organization reported that, comparing April 2020

with the same month last year, the online inquiries to violence prevention

support hotlines had also increased as much as fivefold (8:2020).

Violence against women can cause long-term physical and mental health

problems. Violence and abuse affect not just the women involved but also their

children, families, and communities. These effects include harm to an individual's

health, possibly long-term harm to children, and harm to communities such as

lost work and homelessness (9:2021).

Gendered violence against women can be classified based on the lifespan

of the victim when violated, on the type of consequence on the survivor, on who

the perpetrator is, and on the space where violence takes place. Women are

victimized at every stage of their lifespan: pre-birth, infancy, childhood,

adolescence, young adulthood, middle adulthood, late adulthood, and old age.

The consequences on the survivors are physical, sexual, psychological, and

economical. The perpetrators could be strangers, acquaintances, friends or

relatives including intimate partners of the victimized women. Women are


11

victimized in public spaces, at workplaces and educational institutions, and at

homes.

Attitudes and beliefs are significant predictors of behavior. Violence

supportive attitudes and beliefs are a result of the sociocultural background of

the individual and the influence of media and pornography. Studies have

examined the nature of those violence supportive attitudes as well as the

relationship between these attitudes and factors such as substance use and

sociocultural background (10:2019).

Violence does not merely mean application of physical force, it can be

mental, psychological and emotional as well. Violence in its broadest sense has

been described as an act of a person, which encroaches upon the freedom of

another.  Violence can be an overt threat or an overt application of force, which

aims at harming or destroying a person or his reputation. Even the intent of

causing harm and injury, to someone is considered as an act of violence. The

other problems being bias in job, sexual harassment, domestic violence, marital

discord which hamper the women’s development.

Violence against women can be categorized under three broad categories

(i) Criminal Violence as rape, abduction or murder (ii) Domestic Violence which

includes dowry deaths, wife battering, sexual abuse, maltreatment of widows or

elderly women and lastly (iii) Social Violence which includes forcing a wife or

daughter-in-law to go for female foeticide, eve-teasing, refusing to give a share

to women in property, forcing a woman to commit Sati, forcing her into marriage
12

for business interests or family honor or harassing a woman for any other

reason.

Today, women always have to be on their guard be it in park, public

transport, cinema hall, educational institute or work place. The condition of the

rural women is even worse as in the absence of education and awareness, they

are greater victims of the injustices meted out to them. The government ushered

in the new millennium by declaring 2001 as the ‘Women Empowerment Year’.

True, with economic independence women are making their mark in many areas

like sports, literature, science, arts, journalism, politics and business world

(11:2020).

Related Studies

The following relevant studies are being presented as basis for the

conduct of this study.

In the study of Dexter C. Claus et.al. (12:2017) on “Effects of Violence

against Women” noted that majority of the victims were aged 16-20, single, do

not have children, often abused by the offender/abuser, most of them were

unemployed, high school graduate, and the relationship with the offender was
13

adulteress/concubine. The abuses affected much the psychological condition of

the victims. There is significant relationship between the effects of violence and

the age in the physical and social condition and relationship and frequency of

abuse in the psychological condition suffered by the respondents.

Additionally, the study recommends to intensify the implementation of RA

No. 9262 to protect women and children particularly the young ones and

defenseless through the initiative of barangay officials, DSWD and the Children

and Women’s Desk Section of the PNP. The LGU in coordination with the Women

and Children’s Desk Police Personnel may assist the victims through referral to

psychologist for counseling or caring centers or agency for temporary shelters to

recover from trauma suffered by the victims. Local government officials may hold

regular barangay-level women empowerment orientations and Anti-VAWC Law

seminars to teach women and children their rights and protection guaranteed by

the Anti-VAWC Law to prevent abuses and other forms of violence against

women and children. Support the efforts of the Punong Barangay in the

experience of his authority to issue Barangay Protection Order as immediate

relief to women and children who reported incidence of violence against them.

According to the study on “Domestic Violence against Women” by

Abantika Bhattacharya (13:2020). The study revealed the high prevalence of all

forms of violence against women in an urban area. Older age, lower age at

marriage, longer duration of marriage, lower education of husband and wife,


14

lower family income, unemployment of the husband, and alcohol consumption of

husband were associated with the occurrence of domestic violence.

Ending violence against women needs to be addressed at various levels.

The coordinated efforts of various sectors such as social, legal, educational,

medical, etc., are essential to address the various economic and sociocultural

factors that foster a culture of violence against women by

strengthening women's human and economic rights and reducing gender gaps in

relation to employment and education.

Moreover, a study on “A Scoping Review of Measurement of

Violence against Women and Disability” by Sarah R. Meyer, et.al.

(14:2022), concluded that globally, violence against women remains

unacceptably high, and women with disabilities may be at higher risk of exposure

to violence, as well as being exposed to different forms of violence. Disability as

a risk factor for exposure to violence is poorly understood, and this scoping

review provides a first step towards understanding the current status of

measurement of both violence and disability within relevant bodies of literature.

Our findings indicate several gaps in evidence, including lack of comparison of

how women with different types of disabilities experience violence differently,

and indicate future directions for research and analysis.

Furthermore, the study of Tria Marie R. Garcia (15:2020), entitled

“Violence against Women in the Philippines” concluded that VAW is a


15

widespread issue in the Philippines. Although there is poor data on the

prevalence of VAW, the existing data shows that it affects women of all ages,

socioeconomic status, and all regions of the country. This qualitative study

answers the two main research questions 1) How do UN Women, relevant NGOs,

academics, and government services for GBV in the Philippines perceive gender-

based violence? and 2) How do UN Women, relevant NGOs, academics, and

government services for GBV in the Philippines address gender-based violence?

This study conducted semi-structured, in-person interviews with 11 respondents

to represent the various stakeholders. The data was then analyzed using a

combination of the Public Health Model and the Integrated Ecological Model.

The country has several laws and services to address VAW and various

GBV issues. However, the poor implementation and high unawareness of laws

and government services, in combination with cultural factors, affect the help-

seeking behavior of VAW victims and can pose as risk factors for VAW rather

than protective factors. Moreover, the VAW data is limited, erratic, and unreliable

because there is no central data bank to consolidate the reports from the

different government services. This makes it difficult to grasp the full extent of

the issue throughout the country. There are numerous aspects of the Philippine

culture that are risk factors, protective factors, and factors that affect reporting

behavior.
16

The study also reveals that the different government services not limited

to the PNP and DSWD are uncoordinated and the personnel undertrained, which

affects reporting behavior, leads to a general distrust in the public system, and

hones the persistence of negative stereotypes and risk factors for VAW.

Additionally, UN Women ensures that the government adheres to normative

frameworks by working with the local government and civil society, and by

providing technical guidance and capacity building.

Despite this study’s limitations in terms of scope and methodology, it

opens up several starting points for future research. This study focused on the

cultural aspects that negatively affect GBV in the Philippines, either as risk

factors or factors that affect reporting behavior. However, it shows how aspects

of the culture can also serve as protective factors. Moreover, this study provides

cultural factors specific to the Philippines that can be used by various

stakeholders in addressing GBV through campaigns, programs, policies, and

services.

Additionally, the study of Claire Metz, PhD., et.al. (16:2018) on “Women

Subjected to Domestic Violence: The Impossibility of Separation”, noted

that all these women grew up in an environment of emotional insecurity, which

meant that they were unable for many years to distance themselves from the

violent partner. The strength of this study lies in the fact that it highlights the

deeply buried issues within these relationships that persist in spite of

considerable violence. However, one of the limits identified is that our population
17

was recruited mainly through organizations providing social welfare support, so

that the number of immigrant women and women from underprivileged socio

professional categories is overrepresented. A new research study is underway

with a supportive association catering mainly to financially independent women

of French origin in order to explore the variations with the population of this first

study. The specific interest of the psychoanalytic approach is to go beyond the

current conjugal relationship and to enable us to identify its roots in the infantile

history; in particular, the unconscious issues in which the women are trapped,

without realizing it. Our hope is that these elements will serve to orient

professionals in the task of adapting structures of care for the better. It is

necessary for society to struggle to eliminate violence toward women; this

struggle can only be effective from the moment when all the issues at stake are

taken into account, and in particular singular issues.

Conceptual Background

Violence against women is a public issue and encompasses virtually all

spheres of public relations. It influences various spheres of social life, including

public health, protection of juvenile’s rights and social and economic welfare.
18

The conceptual framework viewed in the schematic diagram in Figure 2

shows the flow of the study. The inputs consist of the data of the profile

of the respondents in terms of their age, gender, civil status, circumstances of

violence that received from their parents, rank, frequency in handling VAW

cases.

The process involved the descriptive normative method of

research. A self-made questionnaire was used to collect data relative to

responses of the law enforcers and community respondents. The results from

the data gathered were tallied, tabulated and processed for analysis through

statistical treatment to test the hypotheses.

The output of the study includes a proposed program for preventive and

safety measures.

INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT

Data gathered from the:

* Profile of the Respondents

* Causes of Violence
19

 Distribution /
Collection of data
 Tabulation
A Preventive
 Data Analysis
and Safety
 Statistical Treatment
Measures
 Findings
 Conclusions
 Recommendations

Figure 2
Conceptual Framework

THE PROBLEM
20

Statement of the Problem. The main objective of this study is to make

an analysis on the protection of women on violence in the City of Tagbilaran.

This study will be conducted in Tagbilaran City, Bohol during the year 2022 –

2023 with an end view of proposing a preventive and safety measures.

Specifically, it aimed to discover the following questions:

1. What is the profile of the respondents in terms of:

A. Women Community Residents

a. Age;

b. Civil Status;

c. Educational Attainment;

d. Employment Status;

e. Do you have Children;

f. Relationship with the Offender; and

g. How often does your abuser/offender abuse you?

B. Women’s Desk / Women Law Enforcers

a. Age;

b. Gender;

c. Rank; and
21

d. Frequency in handling VAW cases?

2. What are the causes of violence experienced by women?

3. What are the effects of violence to the well-being of abused women?

4. What are the actions conducted by law enforcers in order to reduce

violence against women in the City of Tagbilaran?

5. Is there significant degree of difference in the responses of the

respondents in the following context:

a. Causes of violence experienced by women;

b. Effects of violence to the well-being of abused women; and

c. Actions conducted by the law enforcers in order to reduce violence

against women in the City of Tagbilaran?

6. What proposed preventive measures could be offered to enhance the

FREE VAW community and for the safety of every woman in the City of

Tagbilaran?

Null Hypotheses

There is no significant degree of difference in the responses of the

respondents in the following context:

a. Causes of violence experienced by women;

b. Effects of violence to the well-being of abused women; and


22

c. Actions conducted by the law enforcers in order to reduce violence

against women in the City of Tagbilaran.

Significance of the Study

The output of the investigation arrived with numerous advantages and

benefits to the following parties:

Women’s Desk. The result of the study would provide awareness

program designed for their benefits in order to upgrade their patrolling and

investigation skills as well as to maintain the firm relationship with their own

family, relatives and friends.

Community Residents. The output of the study would give them self-

competence, self-confidence and self-awareness to protect themselves and be

aware of their right as a woman.

Students. The study would give them information regarding violence

against women which they may aware in the future. Hence, they would then

learn to protect themselves.

Future Researchers. The ideas presented may serve as a reference to

the future researcher’s data in testing the validity of other related findings.

Scope and Limitations of the Study


23

The study covered the Women’s desk of the Philippine National Police

Tagbilaran Office and women community residents in Tagbilaran City. The

researchers gathered five (5) women law enforcers and forty (40) women

community residents to respond in their study.

The study has limitations brought about by the nature of the study. The

primary limitation of this study was the concentration and consistency on the

responses of the law enforcers and community residents in answering the

questionnaires. It caused anxiety to the researchers whether it can affect the

findings and conclusions which would represent the groups as a whole. The

researchers rely on the respondent’s honesty and sincerity in answering the

questions. Such constraint was averted by securing the official permit from the

Chief of the Philippine National Police, and the City Mayor of Tagbilaran City,

Bohol.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Design

The researchers employ the descriptive-normative survey method using a

self-made questionnaire as the main data gathering tool to obtain the objectives

of the inquisition. This method is used in order to ascertain the normal condition,

to practice or to compare research results with a standard norm.


24

Research Environment and Subjects

The study covered the Philippine National Police (PNP) Office situated at

Tagbilaran City, Bohol. The subjects were the police patrolwomen and women

community residents. The researchers gathered five (5) women law enforcers

and forty (40) women community residents to respond in their study. A total of

forty-five (45) respondents participated the study.

Research Instrument

A self-made questionnaire which was constructed by the researchers with

the assistance of their thesis adviser was used as the main data gathering

instrument. This questionnaire obtain data regarding the demographic profile

and their responses were used for this study. This consists of three parts, Part I

focuses on the profile of the respondents; Part II, Causes of violence

experienced by women; Part III, Effects of violence to the well-being of abused

women; and Part IV, Actions conducted by law enforcers to reduce violence

against women.

Data Gathering Procedure

The researchers secured the permission for the distribution and

dissemination of the questionnaires to the Philippine National Police Office and

the City Mayor of Tagbilaran City, Bohol. After securing the needed consent, the

researchers personally distributed the questionnaire to the respondents to get

the data desired for the study. The respondents were given enough time to
25

answer the questionnaire and requested to return the accomplished form on the

agreed date.

Data Analysis

The data gathered were tabulated, interpreted and analyzed in order to

establish the norms of occurrence through the simple percentage of

computations. To obtain the percentages, the frequency of responses to each

item was divided by the total number of cases and then multiplied by one

hundred, thus: Percent = f/n x 100; where f = frequency and n = number of

cases. The data on the demographic profile was obtained using the mean as

basis of the profile table: M=∑x/n; where ∑x is the summation of all data and N

is the number of respondents.

The following weights were assigned to the scales with their

corresponding equivalents.

Weight Scale Range

4 Very Much Experienced (3.26-4.00)

3 Experienced (2.51-3.25)

2 Less Experienced (1.76-2.50)

1 Not Experienced (1.00-1.75)


26

Statistical Treatment

The data gathered through the use of the questionnaire were subjected to

statistical treatment, computation and analysis. The purpose was to determine

the difference of the responses of the two different group of respondents. It was

subjected to a t- test using the formula.

Formula:

t= X1+ X2

S1 +S2

N1+ N2

where:

t= t –test

X1= mean of the first group

X2= mean of the second group

S1= variance of the first group

S2= variance of the second group

N1= number of cases of the first group

N2=number of the cases of the second group


27

DEFINITION OF TERMS

The following terms used in the study are operationally defined because

they are essential to the understanding of the information presented in this

research.

Battered

It refers to a person who suffered repeated violence from a spouse,

partner, or parent.

Cases

It is an instance of a particular situation; an example of something

occurring.

Enemy

It refers to a person who is actively opposed or hostile to someone or

something.

Feminist

It refers to belief that women and men should have equal rights and

opportunities. 

Mitigate

It refers to lessen the gravity of an offense or mistake.


28

Naggers

It refers to someone who annoys people by constantly finding fault.

Physical Violence

Refers to acts that include bodily or physical harm.

Protection

It refers a person or thing that prevents someone or something from

suffering harm or injury.

Sexual Harassment

Any form of unwelcome sexual behavior that’s offensive, humiliating or

intimidating. It is a behavior characterized by the making of unwelcome and

inappropriate sexual remarks or physical advances in a workplace or other

professional or social situation.

Victim

It refers to a person harmed, injured, or killed as a result of a crime,

accident, or other event or action.

Violence

Defined by the World Health Organization as “the intentional use of

physical force or power, threatened or actual, against oneself, another person, or


29

against a group or community that either results in or has a high likelihood of

resulting in injury, death, psychological harm, maldevelopment, or deprivation.

Violence against Women and their Children

Refers to any act or a series of acts committed by any person against a

woman who is his wife, former wife, or against a woman with whom the person

has or had a sexual or dating relationship, or with whom he has a common child,

or against her child whether legitimate or illegitimate, within or without the

family abode, which result in or is likely to result in physical, sexual,

psychological harm or suffering, or economic abuse including threats of such

acts, battery, assault, coercion, harassment or arbitrary deprivation of liberty.


30

ORGANIZATION OF THE STUDY

This study is composed of three chapters:

Chapter I. The Problem and Its Scope, contains the introduction, the

rationale, the theoretical background, the theoretical framework, the scope and

limitation of the study, the research methodology which includes the research

design, research environment and subjects, the research instrument, the data

gathering procedure, the statistical treatment and the definition of terms;

Chapter II. Presentation and Analysis of Findings, contains reports,

analysis and interpretation of the data gathered in the light of the different

aspects of the problems; and

Chapter III. Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations,

presents summary of the problem, the research methodology, the findings, the

conclusions drawn from the recommendations which includes a proposed

preventive and safety measures.


31

CHAPTER II

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This part of the study analyzes and interprets the data gathered in the

light of the different aspects of the problem raised in Chapter I. It encompasses

the findings based on the perception of the respondents. The following aspects

of the study were treated: Profile of the respondents which are the women

community residents and women’s desk / women law enforcers and their

responses on the causes of violence experienced by women, Responses on the

effects of violence to the well-being of abused women, Responses on the actions

conducted by law enforcers to reduce violence against women in Tagbilaran City,

Bohol. For sensible presentation of the data, the percentage, weighted mean,

and T-test were used in the study. For continuity of purpose, the interpretation

presented follows the sequence of the problem.

Distribution of Respondents

Table I shows the distribution of respondents subjected in this study. A

total of forty five (45) respondents participated in the study. This consists of

forty (88.88 percent) women community residents and five (11.11 percent)

women law enforcers.


32

Table I
Distribution of the Respondents
(N=45)
Respondents Frequency Percentage Rank
Women Community Residents 40 88.88 1
Women Law Enforcers 5 11.11 2
Total 45 100 %

Profile of the Respondents

Table II presents the profile of the respondents included in this study. A

look was taken in the aspects of age, civil status, educational attainment,

employment status, do you have children, relationship with the offender, how

often does your abuser/offender abuse you and for the women community

residents; and age, gender, ranks and frequency in handling VAW Cases.

A. Women Community Residents

Age. As shown in the table, twenty sis (65.00 percent) aged 30 years old

and below, ten (25.00 percent) aged 31-40 years old, three (7.50 percent) aged

41-50 years old and one (2.50 percent) aged 51 years old and above. Majority

of the women community residents belonged to age group 30 years old and

below.

Civil Status. As to their civil status, out of forty (40) women community

residents, data reveals fifty (50.00 percent) were single, fifteen (38.00) were

married, three (8.00 percent), and four (5.00 percent). Most of the women

community residents were single.


33

Educational Attainment. As to their educational attainment, eighteen

(45.00 percent) were elementary undergraduate, seven (18.00 percent) were

elementary graduate, six (15.00 percent) were high school undergraduate, three

(8.00 percent) were high school graduate, four (10.00 percent) were college

undergraduate and two (5.00 percent) were college graduate. Majority of the

women community residents were elementary undergraduate.

Employment. As to their employment, twenty eight (70.00 percent)

were self employed, twelve (30.00 percent) were unemployed. Majority of the

employment were unemployed.

Do you have Children. As to their having of children, thirty (75.00

percent) were yes, ten (25.00 percent) were no. Majority of do you have children

were yes in having a child.

Relationship with the Offender. As to their relationship with the

offender, thirty (75.00 percent) were husband, five (12.50 percent) were

mother/father, three (7.50 percent) were brother/sister, two (5.00 percent) were

adulteries/concubine. Majority of the relationship with the offender were

husband.

How often your abuser. As to their how often your abuser, twenty five

(62.50 percent) were often, seven (17.50 percent) were always, five (12.50

percent) were rarely, three (7.50 percent) were never. Majority of the how often

your abuser were often.


34

Table II
Profile of the Respondents
(N=45)
Item Women Community Women’s Desk
Residents Officers
(n=40) (n=5)
Age F % R F % R
30 years old and below 26 65.00 1 2 40.00 2
31 – 40 years old 10 25.00 2 3 60.00 1
41 – 50 years old 3 7.50 3 0 ===0.00 3
51 years old and above 1 2.50 4 0 0.00 4
Total 40 100% 5 100%
Civil Status
Single 20 50.00 1 - - -
Married 15 38.00 2 - - -
Widowed 3 8.00 3 - - -
Separated 2 5.00 4 - - -
Total 40 100%
Educational Attainment
Elementary Undergraduate 18 45.00 1 - - -
Elementary Graduate 7 18.00 2 - - -
High School Undergraduate 6 15.00 3 - - -
High School Graduate 3 8.00 5 - - -
College Undergraduate 4 10.00 4 - - -
College Graduate 2 5.00 6 - - -
Total 40 100%
Employment
Self Employed 28 70.00 1 - - -
Unemployed 12 30.00 2 - - -
Total 40 100.00
Do you have children
Yes 30 75.00 1 - - -
No 10 25.00 2 - - -
Total 40 100%
Relationship with the
offender
Father/Mother 5 12.50 2 - - -
Husband 30 75.00 1 - - -
Brother/Sister 3 7.50 3 - - -
Adulteries/Concubine 2 5.00 4 - - -
Relatives 0 0.00 5 - - -
Total 40 100%
How often does your
abuser/offender abuse
you
35

Always 7 17.50 2 - - -
Often 25 62.50 1 - - -
Rarely 5 12.50 3 - - -
Never 3 7.50 4 - - -
Total 40 100%
Gender
Male - - - 0 0.00 2.5
Female - - - 5 100.00 1
LGBTQ - - - 0 0.00 2.5
Total - - - 5 100%
Rank
PAT – PSGT - - - 3 60.00 1
PMS - PEMS - - - 2 40.00 2
Total 5 100%
Frequency in handling
VAW Cases
Once a week - - - 3 60.00 1
Twice a week - - - 2 40.00 2
Total - - - 5 100%

B. Women’s Desk Officer

Age. With regard to age, three (60.00 percent) aged 31 - 40 years old,

two (40.00 percent) aged 30 years old and below. Majority of the women’s desk

officer aged 31 - 40 years old.

Gender. As to their gender, five (100.00 percent) were females. Most of

the women’s desk officer were females.

Rank. As to their rank, three (60.00 percent) were PAT - PSGT, two

(40.00 percent) PMS - PEMS. Majority of the rank were PAT - PSGT.

Frequency in handling VAW Cases. As to their frequency in handling

VAW Cases, three (60.00 percent) were once a week, two (40.00 percent) were
36

twice a week. Majority of the frequency in handling VAW Cases were once a

week.

Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by Women


Table III presents the responses of the respondents on the causes of violence
experienced by women.

A. Women Community Residents

Seven items were rated as Very Much Experienced by the women

community residents, the items were presented along with their weighted means

and ranks to wit: 1.5) Unemployment with a mean rating of (4.00); 1.5)

Extramarital relation (4.00); 3) Gender inequality and norms (3.75); 4) Unequal

distribution of power and resources (3.65); 5) Illiteracy (3.63); 6) Sexual

dissatisfaction (3.50). 7) Suspicious attitude with a mean rating (3.30).

One item were rated as Experienced. 8) Economic dependency with a

mean rating (3.10).

Two items were rated as Less Experienced. 9) Patriarchal society

(2.50); 10) Gambling with a mean rating (2.45).

The responses of the women community residents obtained an average

weighted mean of 3.39 or Very Much Experienced. The result implies that the

women community residents is most of them are unemployed. It is evident in the

result that one of the reasons of couples are being of their wives/common law

wives. Specially, nowadays the goods are very expensive and its hard for the

men to supply all the needs in the family.


37

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers


All items were rated Very Much Experienced by the Women’s Desk

Officer/Women Law Enforcers, the items were presented along with their

weighted means and ranks to wit: 4) Unequal distribution of power and

resources with a mean rating of (4.00); 4) Gender inequality and norms (4.00);

4) Illiteracy (4.00); 4) Economic dependency (4.00); 4) Patriarchal Society

(4.00); 4) Suspicious attitude (4.00); 4) Gambling; 8.5) Sexual dissatisfaction

(3.60); 8.5) Unemployment with a mean rating (3.60).

In conclusion, the average weighted mean of 3.86 rated as Very Much

Experienced was gathered by the responses of the respondents. The results

clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers see that

gender and inequality and norms is the primary reason why unemployment is

existing. That, women are not given more opportunities than men. That, unlike

men wherever they applied for work they can be easily hired.
38

Table III

A. Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by Women


Women Community Residents (n=40)
VME E LE NE
Items 4 3 2 1
F % F % F % F % W Des Ran
M c. k
1. Unequal distribution of power and resources. 2 65.00 1 35.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.6 VME 4
6 4 0 5
2. Gender inequality and norms. 3 75.00 1 25.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.7 VME 3
0 0 0 5
3. Illiteracy. 2 62.50 1 37.5 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.6 VME 5
5 5 0 3
4. Economic dependency. 1 40.00 1 40.0 4 10.0 4 10.0 3.1 E 8
6 6 0 0 0 0
5. Patriarchal society. 1 25.00 1 25.0 1 25.0 1 25.0 2.5 LE 9
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
6. Sexual dissatisfaction. 2 50.00 2 50.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.5 VME 6
0 0 0 0
7. Unemployment. 4 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.0 VME 1.5
0 0 0
8. Extramarital relation. 4 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.0 VME 1.5
0 0 0
9. Suspicious attitude. 1 45.00 1 40.0 6 15.0 0 0.00 3.3 VME 7
6 0 0 0
10. Gambling. 9 22.50 1 25.0 1 27.5 1 25.0 2.4 E 10
39

0 0 1 0 0 0 5
Average Weighted Mean 3.3 Very Much
9 Experienc
ed
Legend
Scale Description Symbol Range
4 Very Much Experienced (VME) 3.26-4.00
3 Experienced (E) 2.51-3.25
2 Less Experienced (LE) 1.76-2.50
1 Not Experienced (NE) 1.00-1.75

37
40

Table III

B. Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by Women


Women Desk Officers (n=5)
VME E LE NE
Items 4 3 2 1
F % F % F % F % W Des Ran
M c. k
1. Unequal distribution of power and resources. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
0 0 0 0
2. Gender inequality and norms. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
0 0 0 0
3. Illiteracy. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
0 0 0 0
4. Economic dependency. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
0 0 0 0
5. Patriarchal society. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
0 0 0 0
6. Sexual dissatisfaction. 3 60.00 2 40.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.6 VME 8.5
0 0 0 0
7. Unemployment. 3 60.00 2 40.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.6 VME 8.5
0 0 0 0
8. Extramarital relation. 2 40.00 3 60.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.4 VME 10
0 0 0 0
9. Suspicious attitude. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
0 0 0 0
10. Gambling. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 4
41

0 0 0 0
Average Weighted Mean 3.8 Very Much
6 Experienc
ed
Legend
Scale Description Symbol Range
4 Very Much Experienced (VME) 3.26-4.00
3 Experienced (E) 2.51-3.25
3 Less Experienced (LE) 1.76-2.50
2 Not Experienced (NE) 1.00-1.75

38
42

Statistical Treatment. The computation in Table IV resulted a t-value

-2.49 which was found to be higher than the tabular t-value of 2.101 at 18

degree of freedom (df) and at 0.05 level of significance. There was a

significant degree of difference, leading to the rejected of the null hypothesis.

Table IV

Difference of Responses of the Respondents on the Causes of


Violence Experienced by Women
X1 X 21 X2 X 22
3.65 13.32 4.00 16.00
3.75 14.06 4.00 16.00
3.63 13.14 4.00 16.00
3.10 9.61 4.00 16.00
2.50 6.25 4.00 16.00
3.50 12.25 3.60 12.96
4.00 16.00 3.60 12.96
4.00 16.00 3.40 11.56
3.30 10.89 4.00 16.00
2.45 6.00 4.00 16.00
∑ X 1 =¿33.88 2
∑ X 1 =¿117.52 ∑ X 2=¿3.63 2
∑ X 2=¿149.48
Computation

Σ x1 Σ x2
x̄ 1= x̄ 2=
N1 N2

33.88 38.60
x̄ 1= x̄ 2=
10 10

x̄ 1=3.39 x̄ 2=3.86

n ( Σ x 1) − ( Σ x 1) n ( Σ x 2) − ( Σ x 2)
2 2 2 2
2 2
S=
1 S=
2
n ( n−1 ) n (n−1)
2 2
10 ( 117.52 ) −( 33.88 ) 10 ( 149.48 )−( 38.60 )
= =
10 ( 10−1 ) 10 ( 10−1 )
43

1175.2−1147.85 1494.8−1489.96
= =
10 ( 9 ) 10 ( 9 )

27.35 4.84
= =
90 90

S21=0.3039 S21=0.05379

Thus:

x̄ 1−x̄ 2
t=


df =N 1+ N 2−2 S21 s 22
+
n1 n 2

3.39−3.86
t=
=10+10 – 2
√ .3039 0.05379
10
+
10

−0.47
t=


df =18 .35769
10

−0.47
t=
√ 0.035769

t=−2.49
Computed T-Value = -2.49

Tabular T-Value = 2.101 @18 df and 0.05


level of significance

-2.49 < 2.101, insignificant, rejected the


hypothesis
44

Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of Abused


Women
Table V presents the responses of the respondents on the effects of violence to
the well-being of abused women.

A. Women Community Residents

All items were rated as Very Much Experienced by the women

community residents, the items were presented along with their weighted

means and ranks to wit: 2.5) I had the idea of attempting a suicide with a

mean rating of (4.00); 2.5) I experienced having diminished interest or

avoidance of sex (4.00); 2.5) I experience nervousness (4.00); 2.5) I have

feeling of distrust of others (3.65); 5.5) I experience shock (3.88); 5.5) I felt

shame or guilt (3.88); 7) I experienced generalized anxiety (3.75); 8) I suffer

denial and confusion (3.70); 9) Low self-esteem/self-blame (3.63); 10) I

endured depression with a mean rating of (3.50).

The responses of the women community residents obtained an average

weighted mean of 3.83 or Very Much Experienced. The result implies that the

women community residents is most of them are experienced having diminished

interest or avoidance of sex. It is evident in the result that one of the basic
45

needs of marriage life is sex. If the woman doesn’t want to have sexual

intercourse with their husband some of them it is the primary reason why men

hits women.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers


Seven items were rated Very Much Experienced by the Women’s Desk

Officer/Women Law Enforcers, the items were presented along with their

weighted means and ranks to wit: 4) I endured depression with a mean rating of

(4.00); 4) I experienced generalized anxiety (4.00); 4) I had the idea of

attempting a suicide (4.00); 4) I experienced having diminished interest or

avoidance of sex (4.00); 4) Low self-esteem/self-blame (4.00); 4) I experience

nervousness (4.00); 4) I have feeling of distrust of others (4.00); (8.5) I

experience shock (3.60); 8.5) I suffer denial and confusion with a mean rating of

(3.60); 10) I suffer denial and confusion (3.40).

Seven items were rated Experienced by the Women’s Desk

Officer/Women Law Enforcers, the items were presented along with their

weighted means and ranks to wit: 8.5) I suffer denial and confusion (3.20); 8.5)

I felt shame or guilt (3.20); 10) I experience nervousness (3.00).

In conclusion, the average weighted mean of 3.70 rated as Very Much

Experienced was gathered by the responses of the respondents. The results

clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers see that
46

some of the women endured depression when there husband hits them

physically. They can’t even think positively on what they are going to do just to

surpass this kind of violence in their lives.


47

Table V

Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of Abused Women


A. Women Community Residents (n=40)
VME E LE NE
Items 4 3 2 1
F % F % F % F % W Des Ran
M c. k
1. I endured depression. 20 50.00 2 50.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.5 VME 10
0 0 0 0 0
2. I experienced generalized anxiety. 30 75.00 1 25.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.7 VME 7
0 0 0 0 5
3. I had the idea of attempting a suicide. 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 2.5
0 0 0 0
4. I experienced having diminished interest 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 2.5
or avoidance of sex. 0 0 0 0
5. Low self-esteem/self-blame. 25 62.50 1 37.5 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.6 VME 9
5 0 0 0 3
6. I experience shock. 35 87.50 5 12.5 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.8 VME 5.5
0 0 0 8
7. I suffer denial and confusion. 28 70.00 1 30.0 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.7 VME 8
2 0 0 0 0
8. I felt shame or guilt. 35 87.50 5 12.5 0 0.0 0 0.0 3.8 VME 5.5
0 0 0 8
9. I experience nervousness. 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 2.5
0 0 0 0
10. I have feeling of distrust of others. 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 0 0.0 4.0 VME 2.5
48

0 0 0 0
Average Weighted Mean 3.8 Very Much
3 Experienc
ed
Legend
Scale Description Symbol Range
4 Very Much Experienced (VME) 3.26-4.00
3 Experienced (E) 2.51-3.25
4 Less Experienced (LE) 1.76-2.50
3 Not Experienced (NE) 1.00-1.75

43
49

Table V

Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of Abused Women


B. Women’s Desk Officers (n=5)
VME E LE NE
Items 4 3 2 1
F % F % F % F % W Des Ran
M c. k
1. I endured depression. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.0 4.0 VME 3.5
0 0 0
2. I experienced generalized anxiety. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.0 4.0 VME 3.5
0 0 0
3. I had the idea of attempting a suicide. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.0 4.0 VME 3.5
0 0 0
4. I experienced having diminished interest 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.0 4.0 VME 3.5
or avoidance of sex. 0 0 0
5. Low self-esteem/self-blame. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.0 4.0 VME 3.5
0 0 0
6. I experience shock. 3 60.00 40.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 3.6 VME 7
2 0 0 0
7. I suffer denial and confusion. 2 40.00 2 40.0 1 20.0 0 0.0 3.2 E 8.5
0 0 0 0
8. I felt shame or guilt. 2 40.00 2 40.0 1 20.0 0 0.0 3.2 E 8.5
0 0 0 0
9. I experience nervousness. 2 40.00 1 20.0 0 0.00 0 0.0 3.0 E 10
0 0 0
10. I have feeling of distrust of others. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.0 4.0 VME 3.5
50

0 0 0
Average Weighted Mean 3.7 Very Much
0 Experienc
ed
Legend
Scale Description Symbol Range
4 Very Much Experienced (VME) 3.26-4.00
3 Experienced (E) 2.51-3.25
5 Less Experienced (LE) 1.76-2.50
4 Not Experienced (NE) 1.00-1.75

44
51

Statistical Treatment. The computation in Table VI resulted a t-value

-0.91 which was found to be higher than the tabular t-value of 2.101 at 18

degree of freedom (df) and at 0.05 level of significance. There was a

insignificant degree of difference, leading to the accepted of the null

hypothesis.

Table VI

Difference of Responses of the Respondents on the Effects of


Violence to the Well-being of Women
X1 2
X1 X2 2
X2
3.50 12.25 4.00 16.00
3.75 14.06 4.00 16.00
4.00 16.00 4.00 16.00
4.00 16.00 4.00 16.00
3.63 13.18 4.00 16.00
3.88 15.05 3.60 12.96
3.70 13.69 3.20 10.24
3.88 15.05 3.20 10.24
4.00 16.00 3.00 9.00
4.00 16.00 4.00 16.00
∑ X 1 =¿38.34 2
∑ X 1 =¿117.52 ∑ X 2=¿37.00 2
∑ X 2=¿138.44
Computation

Σ x1 Σ x2
x̄ 1= x̄ 2=
N1 N2

38.34 37
x̄ 1= x̄ 2=
10 10

x̄ 1=3.83 x̄ 2=3.70

n ( Σ x 1) − ( Σ x 1) n ( Σ x 22) −( Σ x 2)
2 2 2
2 2
S=
1 S=2
n ( n−1 ) n (n−1)
52

2 2
10 ( 147.28 )−( 38.34 ) 10 ( 138.44 )−( 37 )
= =
10 ( 10−1 ) 10 ( 10−1 )

1472.8−1469.96 1384.4−1369
= =
10 ( 9 ) 10(9)

2.84 15.4
= =
90 90

S21=0.03156 S21=0.1711

Thus:

x̄ 1−x̄ 2
t=


df =N 1+ N 2−2 2
S1 s 2
2
+
n1 n 2

3.83−3.70
t=
=10+10– 2
√ .03156 0.1711
10
+
10

0.13
t=


df =18 .20316
10

0.13
t=
√ 0.020316

t=0.91

Computed T-Value = 0.91

Tabular T-Value = 2.101 @18 df and 0.05


level of significance

0.91 < 2.101, insignificant, accepted the


hypothesis
53

Responses on the Actions conducted by Law Enforcers to reduce


Violence Against Women
Table VII presents the responses of the respondents on the actions conducted
by Law Enforcers to reduce Violence Against Women.

A. Women Community Residents

Three items were rated as Very Much Experienced by the women

community residents, the items were presented along with their weighted

means and ranks to wit: 2) Develop a responsive plan to address violence

against women, including support services, capacity building, and referral

system with a mean rating of (4.00); 2) Coordinate and refer VAW cases to

government agencies, nongovernment organizations (NGOs), institutions, and

other service providers as necessary (4.00); 2) Passionate and resourceful in

helping the victim-survivors (4.00).

Seven items were rated as Experienced by the women community

residents, the items were presented along with their weighted means and

ranks to wit: 4.5) Assist VAW victim in securing Protection order and

accessing necessary services (3.25); 4.5) Record the violence cases handled

and submit a report to the DILG/Social Welfare Development Office (3.25); 6)

Lead advocacies on the elimination of VAW in the community (3.15); 7)


54

Address other forms of abuse committed against women, especially senior

citizens, women with disabilities, and other marginalized groups (3.08); 8)

Respond to violence cases (2.85); 9) Keep VAW cases records confidential

and secured (2.75); 10) Sensitive to the situation and needs of the victim-

survivors with a mean rating of (2.68).

The responses of the women community residents obtained an average

weighted mean of 3.30 or Very Much Experienced. The result implies that the

women community residents must develop a responsive plan to address violence

against women, including support services, capacity building, and referral

system. It is evident in the result that the women will easily to respond and keep

away to their husband that gives them a problem in their relationship.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers


Eight items were rated Very Much Experienced by the Women’s Desk

Officer/Women Law Enforcers, the items were presented along with their

weighted means and ranks to wit: 4.5) Assist VAW victim in securing Protection

order and accessing necessary services with a mean rating of (4.00); 4.5)

Respond to violence cases (4.00); 4.5) Record the violence cases handled and

submit a report to the DILG/Social Welfare Development Office (4.00); 4.5) Keep

VAW cases records confidential and secured (4.00); 4.5) Develop a responsive

plan to address violence against women, including support services, capacity

building, and referral system (4.00); 4.5) Coordinate and refer VAW cases to
55

government agencies, nongovernment organizations (NGOs), institutions, and

other service providers as necessary (4.00); 4.5) Address other forms of abuse

committed against women, especially senior citizens, women with disabilities,

and other marginalized groups. (4.00); 4.5) Lead advocacies on the elimination

of VAW in the community (4.00).

Two items were rated Experienced by the Women’s Desk Officer/Women

Law Enforcers, the items were presented along with their weighted means and

ranks to wit: 9.5) Sensitive to the situation and needs of the victim-survivors

(3.00); 9.5) Passionate and resourceful in helping the victim-survivors (3.00).

In conclusion, the average weighted mean of 3.80 rated as Very Much

Experienced was gathered by the responses of the respondents. The results

clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers see that

some of the women lead advocacies on the elimination of VAW in the

community. Some of them are one of the victims of VAW and they want to be

the voice of other women to prevent VAW in the community.


56

Table VII

Responses on the Actions Conducted by Law Enforcers to Reduce Violence Against Women
A. Women Community Residents (n=40)

VME E LE NE
Items 4 3 2 1
F % F % F % F % WM Desc Ran
. k
1. Assist VAW victim in securing Protection order and accessing 25 62.50 5 12.5 5 12.5 5 12.5 3.25 E 4.5
necessary services. 0 0 0
2. Respond to violence cases. 17 42.50 10 25.0 3 7.50 1 25.0 2.85 E 8
0 0 0
3. Record the violence cases handled and submit a report to the 10 25.00 30 75.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.25 E 4.5
DILG/Social Welfare Development Office. 0
4. Keep VAW cases records confidential and secured. 5 12.50 20 50.0 1 37.5 0 0.00 2.75 E 9
0 5 0
5. Develop a responsive plan to address violence against women, 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 2
including support services, capacity building, and referral system. 0
6. Coordinate and refer VAW cases to government agencies, 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 2
nongovernment organizations (NGOs), institutions, and other service 0
providers as necessary.
7. Address other forms of abuse committed against women, especially 8 20.00 27 67.5 5 12.5 0 0.00 3.08 E 7
senior citizens, women with disabilities, and other marginalized groups. 0 0
8. Lead advocacies on the elimination of VAW in the community. 6 15.00 34 85.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.15 E 6
0
9. Sensitive to the situation and needs of the victim-survivors. 9 22.50 18 45.0 4 10.0 9 22.5 2.68 E 10
0 0 0
10. Passionate and resourceful in helping the victim-survivors. 40 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 2
0
57

Average Weighted Mean 3.3 Very Much


0 Experience
d

Legend
Scale Description Symbol Range
4 Very Much Experienced (VME) 3.26-4.00
3 Experienced (E) 2.51-3.25
2 Less Experienced (LE) 1.76-2.50
1 Not Experienced (NE) 1.00-1.75

50
58

Table VII

Responses on the Actions Conducted by Law Enforcers to Reduce Violence Against Women
B. Women’s Desk Officers (n=5)

VME E LE NE
Items 4 3 2 1
F % F % F % F % WM Desc Ran
. k
1. Assist VAW victim in securing Protection order and accessing 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
necessary services. 0
2. Respond to violence cases. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
0
3. Record the violence cases handled and submit a report to the 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
DILG/Social Welfare Development Office. 0
4. Keep VAW cases records confidential and secured. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
0
5. Develop a responsive plan to address violence against women, 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
including support services, capacity building, and referral system. 0
6. Coordinate and refer VAW cases to government agencies, 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
nongovernment organizations (NGOs), institutions, and other service 0
providers as necessary.
7. Address other forms of abuse committed against women, especially 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
senior citizens, women with disabilities, and other marginalized groups. 0
8. Lead advocacies on the elimination of VAW in the community. 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 0 0.00 4.00 VME 4.5
0
9. Sensitive to the situation and needs of the victim-survivors. 0 0.00 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.00 E 9.5
0
10. Passionate and resourceful in helping the victim-survivors. 0 0.00 5 100.0 0 0.00 0 0.00 3.00 E 9.5
0
59

Average Weighted Mean 3.8 Very Much


0 Experience
d

Legend
Scale Description Symbol Range
4 Very Much Experienced (VME) 3.26-4.00
4 Experienced (E) 2.51-3.25
3 Less Experienced (LE) 1.76-2.50
1 Not Experienced (NE) 1.00-1.75

51
60

Statistical Treatment. The computation in Table VIII resulted a t-

value -2.36 which was found to be higher than the tabular t-value of 2.101 at

18 degree of freedom (df) and at 0.05 level of significance. There was a

significant degree of difference, leading to the rejected of the null hypothesis.

Table VIII

Difference of Responses on the Actions Conducted by Law Enforcers to


Reduce Violence Against Women
X1 X 21 X2 X 22
3.25 10.56 4.00 16.00
2.85 8.12 4.00 16.00
3.25 10.56 4.00 16.00
2.75 7.56 4.00 16.00
4.00 16.00 4.00 16.00
4.00 16.00 4.00 16.00
3.08 9.49 4.00 16.00
3.15 9.92 4.00 16.00
2.68 7.18 3.00 9.00
4.00 16.00 3.00 9.00
∑ X 1 =¿33.01 2
∑ X 1 =¿111.39 ∑ X 2=¿38.00 2
∑ X 2=¿146.00
Computation

Σ x1 Σ x2
x̄ 1= x̄ 2=
N1 N2

33.01 38
x̄ 1= x̄ 2=
10 10

x̄ 1=3.30 x̄ 2=3.80

n ( Σ x 1) − ( Σ x 1) n ( Σ x 2) −( Σ x 2)
2 2 2 2
2 2
S=
1 S=
2
n ( n−1 ) n (n−1)
2 2
10 ( 111.39 ) −( 33.01 ) 10 ( 146 )−( 38 )
= =
10 ( 10−1 ) 10 ( 10−1 )
61

1113.90−1089.66 1460−1444
= =
10 ( 9 ) 10( 9)

24.24 16
= =
90 90

S21=0.2693 S21=0.1778

Thus:

x̄ 1−x̄ 2
t=


df =N 1+ N 2−2 S21 s 22
+
n1 n 2

3.30−3.80
t=
=10+10– 2
√ .2693 0.1778
10
+
10

−0.50
t=


df =18 0.4471
10

−0.50
t=
√ 0.04471

t=−2.36

Computed T-Value = -2.36

Tabular T-Value = 2.101 @18 df and 0.05


level of significance

-2.36 < 2.101, significant, rejected the


hypothesis
62

Summary of Results on the Responses of the Respondents on the

Protection of Women on the Violence against Women

Table IX presents the summary of the results on the responses of the

respondents on the protection of women on the violence against women.

In their responses on the causes of violence experienced by women;

women community residents obtained an average weighted mean of 3.39 or very

much experienced, women’s desk officers obtained an average weighted mean of

3.86 or very much experience. Their perception gained an over all mean rating of

3.63 Very Much Experienced.

In their responses on the responses on the effects of violence to the well-

being of abused women; women community residents obtained an average

weighted mean of 3.83 or very much experienced, women’s desk officers

obtained an average weighted mean of 3.70 or very much experience. Their

perception gained an over all mean rating of 3.77 or Very Much Experienced.

In their responses on the actions conducted by law enforcers to reduce

violence against women; women community residents obtained an average

weighted mean of 3.30 or very much experienced, women’s desk officers

obtained an average weighted mean of 3.80 or very much experience. Their

perception gained an over all mean rating of 3.55 or Very Much Experienced.
63

Table IX

Summary of Results on the Responses of the Respondents on the

Protection of Women on the Violence against Women

Women Women’s Overall Rating


Community Desk
Residents Officers
AWM Desc. AWM Desc. AWM Desc.
A. Responses on the Causes of
Violence experienced by Women 3.39 VME 3.86 VME 3.63 VME
B.Responses on the Effects of 3.83 VME 3.70 VME 3.77 VME
Violence to the well-being of abused
Women
C.Responses on the Actions 3.30 VME 3.80 VME 3.55 VME
conducted by Law Enforcers to
reduce Violence Against Women

Summary of Difference on the Responses of the Respondents on the

Protection of Women on the Violence against Women

Table X presents the summary of difference on the responses of the

respondents on the protection of women on the violence against women

The computation on the Responses on the Causes of Violence experienced

by Women resulted to a t- value of -2.49 which was found to be higher than the

tabular value of 2.101 at 18 df at 0.05 level of significance, there was a

significant degree of difference leading to the rejected of the null hypothesis.


64

The computation on the Responses on the Effects of Violence to the well-

being of abused Women resulted to a t- value of 0.91 which was found to be

higher than the tabular value of 2.101 at 18 df at 0.05 level of significance, there

was a insignificant degree of difference leading to the accepted of the null

hypothesis.

The computation on the Responses on the Responses on the Actions

conducted by Law Enforcers to reduce Violence Against Women resulted to a t-

value of -2.36 which was found to be higher than the tabular value of 2.101 at

18 df at 0.05 level of significance, there was a significant degree of difference

leading to the rejected of the null hypothesis.

Table X

Summary of Difference on the Responses of the Respondents on the

Protection of Women on the Violence against Women

Items Computed df Critical Level of Test of


Value Value Significance Hypotheses
A. Responses on the Causes of -2.49 18 2.101 .05 Rejected
Violence experienced by Women
B.Responses on the Effects of 0.91 18 2.101 .05 Accepted
Violence to the well-being of
abused Women
C.Responses on the Actions -2.36 18 2.101 .05 Rejected
conducted by Law Enforcers to
reduce Violence Against Women
65

CHAPTER III

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter presents the summary of findings of the study, the

conclusions and recommendations based on the analysis and interpretation of

the gathered data. It also includes a proposed improvement measures.

SUMMARY

Statement of the Problem. The main objective of this study is to make

an analysis on the protection of women on violence in the City of Tagbilaran.

This study will be conducted in Tagbilaran City, Bohol during the year 2022 –

2023 with an end view of proposing a preventive and safety measures.

Specifically, it aimed to discover the following questions:

1. What is the profile of the respondents in terms of:

A. Women Community Residents

a. Age;

b. Civil Status;

c. Educational Attainment;
66

d. Employment Status;

e. Do you have Children;

f. Relationship with the Offender; and

g. How often does your abuser/offender abuse you?

B. Women’s Desk / Women Law Enforcers

a. Age;

b. Gender;

c. Rank; and

d. Frequency in handling VAW cases?

2. What are the causes of violence experienced by women?

3. What are the effects of violence to the well-being of abused women?

4. What are the actions conducted by law enforcers in order to reduce

violence against women in the City of Tagbilaran?

5. Is there significant degree of difference in the responses of the

respondents in the following context:

a. Causes of violence experienced by women;

b. Effects of violence to the well-being of abused women; and

c. Actions conducted by the law enforcers in order to reduce violence

against women in the City of Tagbilaran?


67

6. What proposed preventive measures could be offered to enhance the

FREE VAW community and for the safety of every woman in the City of

Tagbilaran?

Null Hypotheses

There is no significant degree of difference in the responses of the

respondents in the following context:

a. Causes of violence experienced by women;

b. Effects of violence to the well-being of abused women; and

c. Actions conducted by the law enforcers in order to reduce violence

against women in the City of Tagbilaran.

Research Design

The researchers employ the descriptive-normative survey method using a

self-made questionnaire as the main data gathering tool to obtain the objectives

of the inquisition. This method is used in order to ascertain the normal condition,

to practice or to compare research results with a standard norm.

The responses were tallied and tabulated in tables for purposes of

analyzes and interpretation. The degree of difference of the responses of the

respondents was subjected to t-test.

FINDINGS OF THE STUDY


68

Based on the analysis and interpretation of the data gathered, these are

the findings:

1. On the Profile of the Respondents

A. Women Community Residents. Majority of the women community

residents were single, aged 30 years old and below, elementary undergraduate,

self employed, has children, most of them has a relationship with her husband

and often your abuser/offender abuse her.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers. Majority of the

Faculty respondents were female. Belonged to age group 31-40 years old, has a

ranked of PAT - PSGT and once a week in frequency in handling VAW cases.

2. Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by Women

A. Women Community Residents. The responses of the women

community residents obtained an average weighted mean of 3.39 or Very

Much Experienced. The result implies that the women community residents is

most of them are unemployed. It is evident in the result that one of the reasons

of couples are being of their wives/common law wives. Specially, nowadays the

goods are very expensive and its hard for the men to supply all the needs in the

family.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers. The responses of

the faculty obtained an average weighted mean of 3.86 or Very Much

Experienced. The results clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women


69

Law Enforcers see that gender and inequality and norms is the primary reason

why unemployment is existing. That, women are not given more opportunities

than men. That, unlike men wherever they applied for work they can be easily

hired.

3. Statistical Treatment. The computation for the responses of the

respondents on the different aspects raised in this study showed an significant

difference leading to rejected of the null hypothesis when it was subjected to

T-Test formula.

4. Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of Abused


Women
A. Women Community Residents. The responses of the women

community residents obtained an average weighted mean of 3.83 or Very

Much Experienced. The result implies that the women community residents is

most of them are experienced having diminished interest or avoidance of sex. It

is evident in the result that one of the basic needs of marriage life is sex. If the

woman doesn’t want to have sexual intercourse with their husband some of

them it is the primary reason why men hits women.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers. The responses of

the faculty obtained an average weighted mean of 3.70 or Very Much

Experienced. The results clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women

Law Enforcers see that some of the women endured depression when there
70

husband hits them physically. They can’t even think positively on what they are

going to do just to surpass this kind of violence in their lives.

5. Statistical Treatment. The computation for the responses of the

respondents on the different aspects raised in this study showed an

insignificant difference leading to accepted of the null hypothesis when it

was subjected to T-Test formula.

6. Responses on the Actions conducted by Law Enforcers to reduce


Violence Against Women

A. Women Community Residents. The responses of the women

community residents obtained an average weighted mean of 3.30 or Very

Much Experienced. The result implies that the women community residents

must develop a responsive plan to address violence against women, including

support services, capacity building, and referral system. It is evident in the result

that the women will easily to respond and keep away to their husband that gives

them a problem in their relationship.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers. The responses of

the faculty obtained an average weighted mean of 3.80 or Very Much

Experienced. The results clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women

Law Enforcers see that some of the women lead advocacies on the elimination

of VAW in the community. Some of them are one of the victims of VAW and they

want to be the voice of other women to prevent VAW in the community.


63

7. Statistical Treatment. The computation for the responses of the

respondents on the different aspects raised in this study showed an

insignificant difference leading to accepted of the null hypothesis when it

was subjected to T-Test formula.

6. Responses on the Actions conducted by Law Enforcers to reduce


Violence Against Women

A. Women Community Residents. The responses of the women

community residents obtained an average weighted mean of 3.30 or Very

Much Experienced. The result implies that the women community residents

must develop a responsive plan to address violence against women, including

support services, capacity building, and referral system. It is evident in the result

that the women will easily to respond and keep away to their husband that gives

them a problem in their relationship.

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers. The responses of

the faculty obtained an average weighted mean of 3.80 or Very Much

Experienced. The results clearly showed that Women’s Desk Officer/Women

Law Enforcers see that some of the women lead advocacies on the elimination

of VAW in the community. Some of them are one of the victims of VAW and they

want to be the voice of other women to prevent VAW in the community.

8. Statistical Treatment. The computation for the responses of the

respondents on the different aspects raised in this study showed an significant


difference leading to rejected of the null hypothesis when it was subjected to

T-Test formula.

CONCLUSIONS

After thorough study of the data, the researchers were able to arrive at

the following conclusions:

1. Majority of the women community residents were single, aged 30 years old

and below, elementary undergraduate, self employed,has children, and the

husband is often to abuse her.

2. Majority of the women’s desk officers were females. Belonged to age group

31-40 years old, married, has a rank of PAT - PSGT and has a once a week of

frequency in handling cases.

3. Both respondents in Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by


Women were rated Very Much Experienced.
4. There was a insignificant degree of difference on the responses of the

respondents on the Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by

Women thus the null hypothesis was accepted.

5. Both respondents in Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of


Abused Women were rated Very Much Experienced.
6. There was a insignificant degree of difference on the responses of the

respondents on the Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of

Abused Women thus the null hypothesis was accepted.

7. Both respondents in responses on the actions conducted by law enforcers to


reduce violence against women were rated as Very Much Experienced.
65

8. There was a significant degree of difference on the responses of the

respondents on the responses on the actions conducted by law enforcers to

reduce violence against women thus the null hypothesis was rejected.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on the findings and conclusions drawn, the following measures are

suggested:

1. The study recommends that women must have equal distribution of power

and resources.

2. Every woman must be economically independent. They must look for income

that would help their partners.

3. Every woman must know their worth and prevent self blame to prevent

overthinking in a particular situation.

4. The women’s desk officer must provide seminars and lectures regarding on

how women will protect themselves from violence.

5. Every women must know their strengths and weaknesses inorder to surpass

their problems in life.


66

A PROPOSED PREVENTION AND SAFETY MEASURES

Rationale

VAWC is a law the seeks to address the prevalence of violence against women

and their children  by their intimate partners like their husband or ex-husband, live-in

partner or former live-in partner, boyfriend/girlfriend or ex-boyfriend/ex-girlfriend, dating

partner or former dating partner.

A good harmony of the couples will lead to a success of the individuals.

It’s not only between the partners that will gain their success but also the

community and environment. Seeing the every family that is happy is one of the

successful moment of every country. It’s not only in the four corners of the

house will make the men/women/children will change their future but also the

people that sorrounds them.

In response to the women protection against violence realizes that

creating meaningful learning experiences for women. It means that it is

important also to have self value and worth inorder to prove to our

husband/partner to be aware that there is a law protecting to women.

The findings of the study showed of the respondents of the women

protection against violence were rated as Very Much Experienced.


67

OBJECTIVES

The following objectives have been formulated for the purpose of providing

direction to the proposed improvement measures.

1. To have a good harmony between the husband and wife or within the

family.

2. To help and protect women from violence.

3. To provide good quality service for the victims of violence and to be

prepared on the fear/depression they will encounter.

4. To give awareness to their husband/partners that there is a law

protecting to them.

Mechanics of Implementation

Once approved by the examining panel, a copy of this research study will

be presented to the School Director and subsequently endorse to the School

Director for approval, with the request that special attention will be given to the

proposed preventive and safety measures thereof. The items of this program are

merely suggestive thus, it may be modified to suit present conditions.

Schedule of Implementation

The immediate implementation of this proposed preventive and safety

measures will be as soon as it is approved. It will be advantageous and useful so

that weaknesses could be prevented and strong points could be developed.


A PROPOSED PREVENTIVE AND SAFETY MEASURES

Areas Objectives Strategies Persons Time Frame Success Indicator


Involved
Women To protect every woman Conduct Lectures/ Motivated and an
Community from violence. seminars to every All round empowered woman
Residents womwn in Baranggay. year in the society.
To give awareness and 2023 - 2024
help that there is a law Must be Present in Women
protecting to every lectures and activities in Community
woman from violence provided by the Residents
and harm. Baranggay.

Be Wise.
Women’s Desk To become prepared and Attend Orientations and All round Women will have
Officer/Women be mastery in their Seminars in Mastering Women’s Desk year more learnings after
Law Enforcers preparations in lectures their profession in Officer/Women 2023 - 2024 seminars and
for women in the protection for women. Law Enforcers awareness programs.
baranggay.
Provide time in
To mold every woman in enhancing their
their vision to be treated capablities in handling
well. cases for women.

68
69

Appendix A

BIT International College


College of Criminal Justice
City of Tagbilaran
April 21, 2022

Mrs. Charito C. Cadeliña, MAEd


Research Coordinator
BIT International College – Tagbilaran City
200 Gallares Street, Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Greetings!

The undersigned researchers hereby submitted the proposed research


study entitled, “PROTECTION OF WOMEN ON THE VIOLENCE AGAINST
WOMEN IN THE CITY OF TAGBILARAN: A PREVENTIVE AND SAFETY
MEASURES,” for your approval as partial requirement for the subject Research
and Methodology.

Thank you very much and more power.

Respectfully yours,

(Sgd.) Kriszia Mae M. Amoy


(Sgd.) Joshua T. Bantugan
(Sgd.) Jother C. Betache
(Sgd.) Jon Ernest Gomez
(Sgd.) Marvin B. Mulato

Approved:

MRS. CHARITO C. CADELIÑA, MAEd


Research Coordinator
70

Appendix B

BIT International College


College of Criminal Justice
City of Tagbilaran

July 18, 2022

Mrs. Charito C. Cadeliña, MAEd


BIT International College, Main Campus
200 Gallares Street, Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Madam:

Greetings!

The undersigned researchers hereby requesting you to be our research


adviser for the research study entitled “PROTECTION OF WOMEN ON THE
VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN IN THE CITY OF TAGBILARAN: A
PREVENTIVE AND SAFETY MEASURES,” as partial requirement for the
subject Research and Methodology.

Thank you very much and more power.

Respectfully yours,

(Sgd.) Kriszia Mae M. Amoy


(Sgd.) Joshua T. Bantugan
(Sgd.) Jother C. Betache
(Sgd.) Jon Ernest Gomez
(Sgd.) Marvin B. Mulato

Approved:

MRS. CHARITO C. CADELIÑA, MAEd


Adviser
71

Appendix C

BIT INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE


City of Tagbilaran

July 18, 2022

PLTCOL MARY CRYSTAL B. PERALTA


Chief of Police, Tagbilaran City Police Station
Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Sir:

Good day!

The undersigned are conducting a thesis entitled “PROTECTION OF


WOMEN ON THE VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN IN THE CITY OF
TAGBILARAN: A PREVENTIVE AND SAFETY MEASURES,” as partial
fulfillment of the requirements for the Bachelor of Science in Criminology.

In view hereof, the researchers are asking for your permission in the
administration of their questionnaires to the Women’s Desk Officers/Women Law
Enforcers under your jurisdiction in order to obtain necessary data for the
completion of their research. Rest assured that the responses would be treated
with confidentiality and anonymity.

Thank you so much and more power.

Respectfully yours,

(Sgd.) Kriszia Mae M. Amoy


(Sgd.) Joshua T. Bantugan
(Sgd.) Jother C. Betache
(Sgd.) Jon Ernest Gomez
(Sgd.) Marvin B. Mulato
Approved:

PLTCOL MARY CRYSTAL B. PERALTA


Chief of Police, Tagbilaran City Police Station
72

Appendix D

BIT INTERNATIONAL COLLEGE


City of Tagbilaran

July 18, 2022

HON. JANE CENSORIA CAJES-YAP


City Mayor
Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Madam:

Good day!

The undersigned are conducting a thesis entitled “PROTECTION OF


WOMEN ON THE VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN IN THE CITY OF
TAGBILARAN: A PREVENTIVE AND SAFETY MEASURES” as partial
fulfillment of the requirements for the Bachelor of Science in Criminology.

In view hereof, the researchers are asking for your permission in the
administration of their questionnaires to the women residents of Tagbilaran City
in order to obtain necessary data for the completion completing of their research.
Rest assured that the responses would be treated with confidentiality and
anonymity.

Thank you so much and more power.

Respectfully yours,

(Sgd.) Kriszia Mae M. Amoy


(Sgd.) Joshua T. Bantugan
(Sgd.) Jother C. Betache
(Sgd.) Jon Ernest Gomez
(Sgd.) Marvin B. Mulato
Approved:

HON. JANE CENSORIA CAJES-YAP


City Mayor
73

Appendix E

BIT INTERNATONAL COLLEGE


200 Gallares Street, Tagbilaran City, Bohol

College of Criminal Justice

Survey Questionnaire

PROTECTION OF WOMEN ON THE VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN


IN THE CITY OF TAGBILARAN: A PREVENTIVE
AND SAFETY MEASURES

To our Dear Respondents:

Here is a questionnaire which serves as data instruments for the study.


Kindly answer the questionnaire honestly to ensure the accuracy of the data and
for a more reliable result. All information gathered will be held confidential and
shall be used only for the purpose of research.

Thank you so much.

Researchers

Part I. Profile of the Respondents

Direction: Please indicate with a checkmark of your choice on the space

provided.

A. Women Community Residents

a.) Age
[] 30 years old and below
[] 31 - 40 years old
[] 41 - 50 years old
[] 51 years old and above
74

b.) Civil Status


[ ] Single
[ ] Married
[ ] Widowed
[ ] Separated

c.) Educational Attainment


[ ] Elementary Undergraduate
[ ] Elementary Graduate
[ ] High School Undergraduate
[ ] High School Graduate
[ ] College Undergraduate
[ ] College Graduate

d.) Employment Status


[ ] Self-employed
[ ] Unemployed

e.) Do you have Children


[ ] Yes
[ ] No

f.) Relationship with the Offender


[ ] Father/Mother
[ ] Husband
[ ] Brother/Sister
[ ] Adulteress/Concubine
[ ] Relatives

g.) How often does your abuser/offender abuse you


[ ] Always
[ ] Often
[ ] Rarely
[ ] Never

B. Women’s Desk Officer/Women Law Enforcers

a.) Age
[ ] 30 years old and below
[ ] 31 - 40 years old
[ ] 41 – 50 years old
75
[ ] 51 years old and above

b.) Gender
[ ] Male
[ ] Female
[ ] LGBTQ

c.) Ranks
[ ] PAT - PSGT
[ ] PMS - PEMS
[ ] PLT. - PCAPT.
[ ] PMAJ - PCOL.

d.) Frequency in handling VAW Cases


[ ] once a week
[ ] twice a week
[ ] once a month
[ ] twice a month
[ ] Others please specify: __________

Part II. Responses on the Causes of Violence Experienced by Women

Direction: Please indicate a checkmark (√) of your response to the column that
corresponds to your answer. Numerical choices correspond to the
following quantifiers.

4 – Very Much Experienced 2 – Less Experienced


3 – Experienced 1 – Not Experienced

Items 4
3 2 1
(VME
(E) (LE) (NE)
)
1. Unequal distribution of power and resources.
2. Gender inequality and norms.
3. Illiteracy.
4. Economic dependency.
5. Patriarchal society.
6. Sexual dissatisfaction.
7. Unemployment.
8. Extramarital relation.
9. Suspicious attitude.
10. Gambling.
76

Part III. Responses on the Effects of Violence to the Well-being of


Abused Women

Direction: Please indicate a checkmark (√) of your response to the column that
corresponds to your answer. Numerical choices correspond to the
following quantifiers.

4 – Very Much Experienced 2 – Less Experienced


3 – Experienced 1 – Not Experienced

Items 4 3 2 1
(VME) (E) (LE) (NE)
1. I
endured depression.
2. I
experienced generalized anxiety.
3. I
had the idea of attempting a suicide.
4. I
experienced having diminished interest
or avoidance of sex.
5. Low self-esteem/self-blame.
6. I experience shock.
7. I suffer denial and confusion.
8. I felt shame or guilt.
9. I experience nervousness.
10. I have feeling of distrust of others.
77

Part IV. Responses on the Actions Conducted by Law Enforcers to


Reduce Violence against Women

Direction: Please indicate a checkmark (√) of your response to the column that
corresponds to your answer. Numerical choices correspond to the
following quantifiers.

4 – Very Much Experienced 2 – Less Experienced


3 – Experienced 1 – Not Experienced

Items 4
3 2 1
(VME
(E) (LE) (NE)
)
1. Assist VAW victim in securing Protection order
and accessing necessary services.
2. Respond to violence cases.
3. Record the violence cases handled and submit
a report to the DILG/Social Welfare
Development Office.
4. Keep VAW cases records confidential and
secured.
5. Develop a responsive plan to address violence
against women, including support services,
capacity building, and referral system.
6. Coordinate and refer VAW cases to
government agencies, nongovernment
organizations (NGOs), institutions, and other
service providers as necessary.
7. Address other forms of abuse committed
against women, especially senior citizens,
women with disabilities, and other
marginalized groups.
8. Lead advocacies on the elimination of VAW in
the community.
9. Sensitive to the situation and needs of the
victim-survivors.
10. Passionate and resourceful in helping the
victim-survivors.

Thank you very much for your cooperation…..


78

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. https://www.oxfam.org/en/take-action/campaigns/say-enough-violence-
against-women-and-girls/violence-against-women-and-girls-enough-
enough

2. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2022/06/violence-against-women-is-a-
shadow-pandemic-we-must-take-action-to-stop-it/

3. https://opentext.wsu.edu/theoreticalmodelsforteachingandresearch/
chapter/feminist-theory/

4. https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/theoretical-
explanations-violence-against-women-sourcebook-violence

5. https://www.lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2004/ra_9262_2004.html

6. https://pcw.gov.ph/republic-act-11313/

7. https://pcw.gov.ph/2021-18-day-campaign-to-end-violence-against-
women/

8. www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/violence/en/

9. https://www.womenshealth.gov/relationships-and-safety/effects-violence-
against-women

10. https://journals.christuniversity.in/index.php/artha/article/view/1944/1617

11. https://www.aplustopper.com/violence-against-women-essay/

12. https://research.lpubatangas.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/CRIM-
2017-001.pdf

13. https://journals.lww.com/jfmpc/Fulltext/2020/09100/
Domestic_violence_against_women__A_hidden_and.25.aspx

14. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/
journal.pone.0263020
15. file:///C:/Users/User/Downloads/Violence%20Against%20Women%20in
%20the%20Philippines%20%20MDS%20thesis%20Tria%20Garcia 79
%202020.pdf
16. https://www.apa.org/pubs/journals/features/pap-
pap0000186.pdf
CURRICULUM VITAE

Name : Kriszia Mae M. Amoy

Date of Birth : May 2, 2000

Place of Birth : Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Address : Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Parents : Mr. Rolito B. Amoy

Mrs. Ma. Fe M. Amoy

Nationality : Filipino

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND

Elementary : Tocdog Elementary School

Tocdog Dacu, Loay, Bohol

Secondary : Lila National High School

Poblacion, Lila, Bohol

Tertiary : BIT International College

200 Gallares St., Tagbilaran City, Bohol


Course : Bachelor of Science in Criminology

80

CURRICULUM VITAE

Name : Joshua T. Bantugan

Date of Birth : May 19, 2000

Place of Birth : Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Address : Gon-ob, Loboc, Bohol

Parents : Mr. Pastor O. Bantugan

Mrs. Mrs. Rosario T. Bantugan

Nationality : Filipino

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND

Elementary : Triple Union Elementary School

Camayaan, Loboc, Bohol

Secondary : Camayaan National High School

Camayaan, Loboc, Bohol

Tertiary : BIT International College

200 Gallares St., Tagbilaran City, Bohol


Course : Bachelor of Science in Criminology

81

CURRICULUM VITAE

Name : Jother C. Betache

Date of Birth : October 9, 1999

Place of Birth : Tinago, Ozamis City, Misamis Occidental

Address : Malayo Sur, Cortes, Bohol

Parents : Mr. Sotero G. Betache

Mrs. Jocelyn C. Betache

Nationality : Filipino

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND

Elementary : San Roque Elementary School

San Roque, Cortes, Bohol

Secondary : Fatima National High School

Fatima, Cortes, Bohol

Tertiary : BIT International College

200 Gallares St., Tagbilaran City, Bohol


Course : Bachelor of Science in Criminology
82

CURRICULUM VITAE

Name : John Ernest Gomez

Date of Birth : July 27, 2000

Place of Birth : Bahay-Bahay, Sikatuna, Bohol

Address : Bahay-Bahay, Sikatuna, Bohol

Parents : Mrs. Nena S. Gomez

Nationality : Filipino

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND

Elementary : Sikatuna Central Elementary School

Poblacion, Sikatuna, Bohol

Secondary : Sikatuna National High School

Poblacion, Sikatuna, Bohol

Tertiary : BIT International College

200 Gallares St., Tagbilaran City, Bohol

Course : Bachelor of Science in Criminology


83

CURRICULUM VITAE

Name : Marvin B. Mulato

Date of Birth : January 30, 2000

Place of Birth : Bahi, Loon, Bohol

Address : Bahi, Loon, Bohol

Parents : Mr. Roy G. Mulato

Mrs. Josefina B. Mulato

Nationality : Filipino

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND

Elementary : Nueva Vida Elementary School

Nueva Vida, Loon, Bohol

Secondary : Governor Jacinto Borja National High School

Cantaongon, Loon, Bohol

Tertiary : BIT International College

200 Gallares St., Tagbilaran City, Bohol


Course : Bachelor of Science in Criminology

You might also like