STS Midterm
STS Midterm
Verification Theory
The earliest criterion that distinguishes philosophy and science is verification
theory or also known as verificationism, verification principle, or verification criterion of
meaning. The idea proposes that a discipline is a science if it can be confirmed or
interpreted in the event of an alternative hypothesis is accepted. The verification theory
of meaning claims that the meaning of a sentence is the method of its verification. It is
the philosophical doctrine that only statements that are empirically verifiable through
senses are cognitively meaningful, or else they are truths of logic. This was espoused
by a movement in the early twentieth century or1920s called the “Vienna Circle”, a
group of scholars who believed that only those which can be observed should be
regarded as meaningful and reject those which cannot be directly accessed as
meaningless. It was a central thesis of logical positivism by the efforts of a group of
philosophers who sought to unify philosophy and science. Its shortcomings, however,
proved to be somewhat too risky – several budding theories that lack empirical results
might be shot down prematurely, causing slower innovation and punishing ingenuity of
newer, novel thoughts. Aside from discoveries in physics, Einstein’s theory, and
quantum mechanics critique, this theory completely fails to weed out bogus arguments
that explain things coincidentally. A classic example is an astrology, whose followers
are able to employ the verification method in ascertaining its reliability. The idea is that
since one already has some sort of expectation on what to find, they will interpret events
in line with said expectations. American philosopher Thomas Kuhn warned us against
bridging the gap between evidence and theory by attempting to interpret the former
according to our own biases, that is, whether or not, we subscribe to the theory.
According to verification theory, only statements that can be verified by sight,
sound, touch, taste, and smell can have true meaning. The only exceptions are
"tautologies" of logic, for example, "God is God," "Beauty is Beauty," and "Morals are
Morals." In other words, we may speak of metaphysical objects if we make useless
tautologies of them. Verification theory rejects cognitively "meaningless" statements
specific to entire fields such as metaphysics, theology, ethics, and aesthetics. Such
statements may be meaningful in influencing emotions or behavior, but not in terms of
conveying truth value, information, or factual content.
Falsification Theory
The Falsification Theory, proposed by Karl Popper, is a way of demarcating
science from non-science. It suggests that for a theory to be considered scientific it
must be able to be tested and proven false. In a series of famous works starting in the
late 1950s, Popper criticized some (supposedly) scientific fields of study as insufficiently
rigorous. It seemed to him that some researchers were focused only on finding positive
evidence that could be used to confirm their favorite theories rather than really
challenging their theories by trying to find evidence against those theories. Falsifiability
is the capacity for some proposition, statement, theory or hypothesis to be proven
wrong. That capacity is an essential component of the scientific method and hypothesis
testing. The requirement of falsifiability means that conclusions cannot be drawn from
simple observation of a particular phenomenon. For example, the statement “all swans
are white” would be falsified by observing a black swan (or admitting the possibility of a
black swan somewhere in existence). If the statements are proven false, then it
becomes unreasonable to support the theory any longer.
Science as Education
Science, along with mathematics, were perceived as the most in-demand track
as people thought that these will land them high-paying jobs and lucrative careers after
graduation. In the Philippines, schools mostly use science and mathematics in entrance
exams at the secondary and tertiary levels to ensure the adeptness of students in the
aforementioned fields. This can be reflected in the number of students enrolled in STEM
(Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics)-offering schools.
However, when one student who came from a science high school was asked
to report Paul Feyerabend’s work How to Defend Society Against Science, he strongly
refused the idea of the author and critiqued him instead. This only proves that the
former kind of academic environment made students unwelcoming objections against
science. The idea of Paul Feyerabend aims to hone and preserve students’ capacity to
entertain other options and will allow students some level of unorthodoxy. It means that
his idea encourages students to accept facts other than what’s usual or accepted by
society. Innovations are brought by visionaries and not the prude legalists, which means
the creative ones are those who have wider perspectives and higher scale of
imagination and not those who just stick to norms. Similar to Aristotle’s concept of
Eudaimonic where a person is required to be knowledgeable not only on science but
also on other things of equal importance. He should not focus on one aspect alone but
rather as a whole. The reason why it is called science is because of the variety of
procedures it offers in an experiment to come up with the result.
It proves that there is little capacity for our ancestors to contemplate and perceive things outside
themselves in a more reflective matter, with little to no access to written accounts except several cave
drawings and unearthed artifacts, It is hard to pinpoint where exactly this all started but the early
ancestors’ primal need to survive paved the way for the inventions using their wits to utilize abundant
materials for their ease and comfort. For an instance:
Homo Erectus -used fire to cook without realizing the law of friction and heat by tools from stone and
flints that marked the Stone Age Era.
Minerals-metalwork; substances that are more malleable, durable, and luster.Fur clothing and animal
skin -primarily used for comforts from harsh winds.
Early accessories-found in excavations that suggest an engagement to the concept of beauty. An initial
order of primitive God's
-ceremonial figures found in excavations pertained to prior civilizations honoring deities for things out of
their control.
-in windy places like mountains, there are mountain gods to explain wind currents and ask for
provisions.
-in coastal areas, there are water gods when asking for a good catch.
Elephants and Mammoths majestic creatures that might have been awed by their size and worship as
the owners of the land.
-On the contrary, might’ve hunted them for the entire community to eat.
The earliest case of man-made extinction occurred 12,000 years ago brought by hunting and territorial
disputes.
-pertains to the ongoing extinction of several species both flora and fauna due to human activity.
Growing population
-necessitated overhunting and overfishing which were endemic to the era causing several species to lose
competitors in food and territory.
Formation of communities
-paved the way for civilizations as it caused humans to expand for in every factor.
The constant need for resources taught the early civilizations to engage in less bloody negotiations
through trade leading to cross towns and cross-cultural interactions. Wealth became the main goal for
survival, it triggered producing things in the prospect of profit. As humanity became more complex, the
primary goal was not merely to survive, but to live a good life.
Martin Heidegger
-a philosopher in the advent of postmodernism who argued that the essence of purpose and being of
technology are different from each other.
-Expounding a point that can be perceived; First, a means to achieve man’s ends. Second, paints
technologythat each period reveals a particular character regarding man’s being.
In conclusion, the Human condition improved but as to initial aims things did not much make a
difference as it is only a rehashed version of its formal self. Some people still battle for their daily
survival. The two paradigms; Religion and technology are still being used as an attempt to understand
circumstances. Aristotle’s conception of human flourishing entertains the idea of holistic enrichment of
person situated in his society which starters could consider for other concepts enlivened with
technological advancements through the notable distinction would fall under the consideration of
virtues and their role in achieving a good life. Regardless, technological advancements although offering
us a compelling notion of the truth and the good, it still occurs at a rapid pace that morality cannot seem
to keep up with, with no consideration given in achieving the good life.
Introduction
In the ancient Greece long before the word “science” has been coined, the need to understand the
world and the reality was bound with the need to understand the self and good life. For Plato, the task
of understanding the things in the world runs parallel with the job of truly getting into what will make
the soul flourish.
In an attempt to understand reality and the external world, man must seek to understand himself, too.
It was Aristotle who gave the definitive distinction between the theoretical and practical science
Biology; Metaphysics
Ethics; and
Politics
Every attempt to know is connected in some way in an attempt to find the “good” or as said in the
previous lesson, attainment of human flourishing.
Rightly so, one must find the truth about what the good is before one can even try to locate that which
is good.
We have seen how a misplaced or an erroneous idea of humanflourishing can turn tables for all of us;
And, draw chasm between the search for truth and for the good.
We endeavor to go back a little and answer these questions:
ARISTOTLE
First philosopher who approached the problem of reality from a “scientific” lens as we know now
First thinker who dabbed into the complex problematization of the end goal of life: happiness which he
claims to be all and end all of everything that we do
Every action that emanates from a person is the function of the purpose (telos)that he has
Human flourishing, a kind of contentment in knowing that one has maxed out his potentials in the
world; meet the crux of humanityPLATO
Accordingly, there are two aspects of reality namely world of formsandworld of matter
He recognized that change is a process and a phenomenon that happens in the world and it is constant
Despite the reality of change, things remain and they retain their ultimate “whatness”WORLD OF
FROMS
Wherein the entities are only copies of the ideal and the models, and forms are the only real
entitiesWORLD OF MATTER
Things are changing and impermanentHappiness as the Goal of a Good LifeJOHN STUART MILL (18 TH
CENTURY)
Declared the greatest happiness principle, an action is right as far as it maximizes the attainment of
happiness for the greatest number of people.
Does mining result in more people getting happy rather than sad?If the answers to that questions are
affirmative then mining is ethical.
History has given birth to different schools of thought, all of which aim for the good and happy life.
MATERIALISM
First Materialist were the atomists in Ancient Greece.
Democritus and Leucippus led a school whose primary belief is that world is made up of and is
controlled by the tiny indivisible units in the world called atoms or seeds.
HEDONISM
STOICISM
Another school of thought led by Epicurus, the stoics espoused the idea that to generate happiness,
one must learn to distance oneself and be apathetic.
.For the stoics, happiness can only be obtained by a careful practice of apathy.
THEISM
Most people find the meaning of lives using God as a fulcrum in their existence.
Philippines as a predominantly Catholic country, is witness how people base their life goals on beliefs
that hinged on some form of supernatural reality called heaven.
HUMANISM
The freedom of man to carve his own destiny and to legitimate his on laws
For humanists:
Scientists today are ready to confront more sophisticated attempts at altering the world for the benefit
ofhumanity.
In modern times, there are different technological advancements in all forms and sizes may it be inside
the home, workplaces, schools, or simply on the streets. It is now very accessible to almost anyone in
the world owns at least one technological devices. However, despite its usefulness and beneficial
characteristics, there are still some problems faced by the different technological advancements. Let us
discuss to you those disadvantages that these modern technologies may have given us. Technology
affects everyone! Whether positive or negative, we are all affected. It transformed our everyday lives
with a great reliance to the different technological advancement that is already available to the masses.
It is with great effort that people were able to achieve such great inventions, makes life so much easier
and more convenient than ever before. In general, technology keeps on progressing due to not only the
changing times andenvironment but also to the ever-progressing mind of mankind. Now, there are
several technological devices will be properly introduced such as:
•Paul Gottlieb Nipkow (send images through wires with the aid of a rotating disk)
• Alan Archibald Campbell-Swinton and Boris Rosing (created a new system of television by using
cathode ray tube in addition to the mechanical scanner system)
• The Ipos Media Atlas Philippines Nationwide Urban 2011-2012 showed that there are 30% of the
Philippine urban population nationwide said that mobile phone are necessities in life.
• April 3, 1973, Martin Cooper (made the world’s first mobile phone call)
• Computers and laptops • Have also become part of the Filipino households.
• In 2010, 3.6 trillion was the estimated total value output of all manufacturing establishments.
• Charles Babbage (designed the Analytical Engine which was used as the basic framework of the
computers even until the present time)
• Lastly, each generation of the computers was used for a certain period of time and each gave people a
new and improve version of the previous one.
Technology has infiltrated every aspect of our lives, changing how we work, how we learn and how we
shop. It’s inevitable that our devices begin to reflect our civic aspirations, our desires to connect with
others and to contribute to the world around us. Their roles played by these technologies/devices in our
lives such as:
1. Television
•It is mainly used as a platform for advertisements and information dissemination.
•remains to be the most used avenue by different advertising companies all over the world
•serves as a recreational activity and good stress reliever to most families
•also a good platform for different propagandas and advocacies
•It is a good way to bond with one's family member.
2. Mobile Phones
•primarily used for communications (texting and calling)
•used for internet surfing, and selfie’s (taking pictures)
•offers different applications such as: music player, calendar, radio, television and other photo
editor
•it is a all-in-one device that most of the people used
•portable and very convenient because it can fit in any space
3. Personal Computer and Laptops
•can be used to surf the internet and communicate
•people prefer PC's or laptops in doing their jobs because it has a wide keyboard, wide screens
•hase separate keyboards
•availability of a mouse or touchpad made these two technological devices easier to maneuver