Knowledge 02 00031

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 14

Article

Factors Affecting Success and Survival of Small and Medium


Enterprises in the Middle East
Khalid Ismail Albalushi 1 and M. Muzamil Naqshbandi 2, *

1 Institute of Policy Studies, University of Brunei Darussalam, Jalan Tungku Link BE1410, Brunei
2 School of Business and Economics, University of Brunei Darussalam, Jalan Tungku Link BE1410, Brunei
* Correspondence: muzamil.naqshbandi@ubd.edu.bn

Abstract: SMEs are one of the leading solutions for reducing unemployment and poverty and
boosting economic growth. Due to this, the determinants of the survival and success of SMEs have
received increasing scrutiny in recent years. Empirical evidence has been uncovered in different
countries. Enriching this growing body of evidence, this paper explores the internal and external
factors that affect the survival and success of SMEs in the middle eastern country of Oman. We
used a quantitative approach to collect the data by distributing a survey questionnaire among SME
owners and prospective entrepreneurs. The survey was distributed in different industries throughout
Oman. The findings, based on 344 responses, show that for SME survival and success, the education
system needs intervention. Other areas of intervention include transforming Omani business culture,
focusing on managerial skills, and improving the procedures required for establishing a business.
These findings offer vital implications for Oman’s economy and for SME owners. The findings of
this study can help policymakers make the appropriate interventions at various levels to enhance
SME survival and success in Oman. The study also provides insights for existing and prospective
entrepreneurs to bridge the skillset gaps to keep pace with ever-changing market demands.

Keywords: SME sector; small business; SME challenges; entrepreneurship education; culture;
Citation: Ismail Albalushi, K.;
Naqshbandi, M.M. Factors Affecting
entrepreneurship development centers; managerial skills; business establishment procedures; SME
Success and Survival of Small and growth; Oman
Medium Enterprises in the Middle
East. Knowledge 2022, 2, 525–538.
https://doi.org/10.3390/
knowledge2030031 1. Introduction
Academic Editor: Gwanggil Jeon Governments worldwide realize the critical role that small and medium enterprises
(SMEs) play in fostering and strengthening economies. In both developed and developing
Received: 26 August 2022 countries, SMEs are regarded as the economic backbone [1,2]. Unlike big enterprises, SMEs
Accepted: 12 September 2022
are easy to establish and do not require massive resources in terms of large capital to prepare
Published: 14 September 2022
the business location, procure the needed technology or machinery, or attract the required
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral talent to run the business. SMEs usually require small offices with minimal preparations,
with regard to jurisdictional claims in such as computers and telephone lines, with a limited number of essential employees.
published maps and institutional affil- Recent research shows that SMEs are considered one of the leading solutions for
iations. reducing unemployment and poverty and boosting economic growth [3,4]. SMEs are an
important sector of the global economy, contributing significantly to the gross domestic
product (GDP) and job creation globally [5]. Generating approximately 60 percent of
employment, SMEs have been the key drivers of employment growth [6]. Most importantly,
Copyright: © 2022 by the authors.
SMEs are crucial for the development and growth of the local economy by generating
Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland.
employment, which helps to alleviate poverty [7,8]. Most SMEs often do not require a
This article is an open access article
highly educated workforce with higher education degrees. As a result, SMEs can easily
distributed under the terms and
employ less-educated citizens of a community. This consequently improves their standard
conditions of the Creative Commons
of living and alleviates poverty. Moreover, a flourishing SME sector in a community usually
Attribution (CC BY) license (https://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/
promotes a culture of self-dependency among the population, rather than depending
4.0/).
on the government and its public sectors to provide jobs and secure sources of income.

Knowledge 2022, 2, 525–538. https://doi.org/10.3390/knowledge2030031 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/knowledge


Knowledge 2022, 2 526

Therefore, it reduces the pressure on governmental agencies to create jobs while increasing
the standard of living of business entrepreneurs [9]. At the same time, SMEs are an excellent
opportunity to develop necessary managerial and human resource skills essential in the
marketplace, especially in big enterprises and companies.
According to the United Nations Industrial Development Organization, SMEs form
approximately 99% of enterprises in Japan, 99.7% in Singapore, and 96% in Malaysia.
Universally speaking, 90% of businesses worldwide consist of SMEs that directly contribute
to the employment of not less than 60% of the total global workforce [3]. Moreover, SMEs
contribute significantly to the GDP of the world’s significant economies, such as 90% in
America, 97% in Japan, and 95% in the United Kingdom [3].
However, despite the significant contribution of SMEs to economies worldwide, their
contribution towards the GDP of Oman, a country on the south-eastern coast of the Arabian
Peninsula, is only 20% [10]. Conscious of the importance of SMEs to the economy, the Omani
government has taken multiple steps towards diversification of its economy, which is
primarily (85%) oil-dependent [1]. The government has also been looking for other sources
to boost the economy and find opportunities to reduce unemployment among the youth,
which stands at 13.1% [11]. These efforts have resulted in policies that support the SME
sector and aim at turning it into a robust and efficient participant in the national economy.
As part of Oman Vision 2040, through the National Programme for Enhancing Economic
Diversification (Tanfield), Oman has undertaken measures to realign its focus and diversify
the economy, emphasizing entrepreneurship development [12,13]. While the efficacy of
the programs introduced by the Omani government is still unclear, several studies suggest
that the SME sector in Oman has not yet matured enough. Al Balushi, Locke [14], however,
note that the potential for growth of the SME sector in Oman is tremendous.
SMEs face more impediments that affect their survival than larger businesses [15]. The
SME sector in Oman faces several challenges that can hinder the government’s ambitious
plans for it to thrive. Many internal factors can be identified in Omani SMEs which play a
crucial role in impeding them and forcing them backwards, eventually towards closure.
Ramachandran and Yahmadi [16] highlight that some internal challenges facing SMEs
are related to the capabilities of entrepreneurs and the society they live in, such as a lack
of managerial skills, human resource management skills, marketing strategies, and the
inadequacy of operation management.
On the other hand, external factors also play a significant role in the survival and suc-
cess of SMEs in Oman. Such factors are characterized in Oman’s economic and investment
environment and the extent to which governmental organizations play a role in making
the business environment conducive. These factors play a significant role and include, but
are not limited to, the rules and regulations introduced by the government in facilitating
business establishments [17], and the ease of providing loans to entrepreneurs and different
supporting programs targeting business owners’ capacity development [18].
Against this backdrop, this study examines the factors responsible for the survival
and success of SMEs in Oman. This study focusses on Oman as the Omani government
has recently taken a keen interest in developing entrepreneurship in the country. Several
programs have been launched to facilitate entrepreneurs. Such programs include those
aimed at financing entrepreneurial ventures of the entrepreneurs, providing training and
mentoring, and promoting the products produced by the SMEs. However, as noted above,
several internal and external factors affect the survival and success of SMEs in Oman [19].
Hence, this study focuses on the internal and external factors that determine the survival
and success of SMEs in Oman. Specifically, our study attempts to provide answers to
the following four research questions: (1) How can the government improve the proce-
dures of establishing, funding, and financing SMEs? (2) How can the government and
entrepreneurs overcome challenges related to self-development in terms of managerial
skills and capabilities? (3) How can the education system be improved to encourage an
entrepreneurial culture? (4) How can the government and society promote initiatives
towards self-employment and independence in the SME sector?
Knowledge 2022, 2 527

In answering the above research questions, this research contributes mainly in three
ways. Firstly, the study discovers the difficulties SME owners face in Oman at different
levels. The study examines the challenges that SME owners face and proposes methods
that can be used to overcome such challenges. The study looks at specific challenges, such
as SME owners’ lack of expertise and experience in running a business. Secondly, the study
examines the process and procedures that the Omani government can either incorporate
or improve to make the entrepreneurship experience desirable, especially for the young
generation who represent the country’s future. Lastly, this research will help in policymak-
ing related to improving the procedures of granting funds and support to business owners
(financial and non-financial) from the setup stage until the business flourishes.
In the next section, we present a literature review and the theoretical background. We
then present the methods and procedures used in this study, followed by data analysis.
In the last section, we discuss the findings, recommendations, limitations, and future
research directions.

2. Literature Review and Background


There is no single universal definition of SMEs around the globe [3]. This is because
different countries have different criteria depending on the developmental status of their
economies and the size of their population. Accordingly, the number of employees in
SMEs varies in each country, and it determines whether an enterprise is a micro-, small-, or
medium-sized enterprise. According to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
Development [20], the standard number of employees for SMEs is (a) micro-enterprises
with less than 10 employees, (b) small enterprises with less than 50 employees, and (c)
medium-sized enterprises with less than 250 employees. As per another classification,
the European Union defines SMEs as businesses employing less than 250 persons with an
annual income of up to 50 million euros [9]. On the other hand, the American definition
classifies any company employing less than 500 persons as an SME [9]. According to the
Ministry of Commerce and Industry in Oman (Table 1), SMEs are defined, as per the latest
update in 2016, depending on the number of employees and the annual sales as shown in
the following figure [16].

Table 1. Classification of SMEs in Oman.

Classification No. of Employees Annual Sales (OMR)


Micro 1–5 Less than 100,000 (~USD 260,000)
Small 6–25 100,000–500,000 (~USD 260,000–1,300,000)
500,000-less than 3,000,000
Medium 26–99
(~USD 1,300,000–7,800,000)
Source: Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Oman.

2.1. Policy Interventions by the Omani Government to Support SMEs


According to the National Centre for Statistics and Information [21], Oman’s number
of registered SMEs stood at 42,698 enterprises in 2019. This figure has seen a steady growth
from just 9118 companies in 2015. This highlights the potential opportunities in the market
that is developing at a fast pace. At the same time, the Oman government has placed
a strong emphasis on the SME sector, listing its development as a key goal in its ninth
five-year development plan.
Among the facilitating measures the Omani government has taken is establishing the
Public Authority for Small and Medium Enterprises Development (Riyada) in 2013, an
agency that looks after the development of the SME sector in the country [16]. Riyada is
considered an advisory organization that provides non-financial support to entrepreneurs
and helps them through training, consultancy, feasibility studies, and marketing SME
products in local and international exhibitions. Furthermore, Oman established the Al Raffd
Fund to enable Omani youth to establish and develop their own small- and medium-size
projects. The government also established funding agencies, such as the SME Development
Knowledge 2022, 2 528

Fund (SMEF) in 2014, with the objective of developing entrepreneurship and financing
small and medium enterprises in the country [16]. Along with these initiatives, the Oman
government, through the Public Establishment for Industrial Estates, promotes the products
produced by Omani SMEs at various national, regional, and international platforms.

2.2. Challenges Facing SMEs in Oman


The challenges facing SMEs have been discussed in several studies (e.g., [22]). Al-Tit,
Omri [23] identified four main challenges facing SMEs: firstly, difficulties related to financial
resources with the time-consuming procedures of obtaining loans and a lengthy list of
guarantees; secondly, lack of critical knowledge regarding local, regional, and international
market variables and changing circumstances; thirdly, the inability of entrepreneurs to
reach customers beyond local markets, be it regional or international due to their lack of
marketing strategies; and finally, inadequate managerial skills in areas such as human,
financial, and administrative fields. Similarly, Alqassabi [10] reported that SMEs face
several constraints that hinder their success and limit their chances of growth. One such
constraint is the lack of managerial skills among enthusiastic business pioneers. Such
managers lack the necessary skills required to drive the company forward, resulting in
poor management of financial, human, or other resources available. Another pitfall is
a lack of marketing strategies and an inadequate understanding of the market in which
they operate. One of the reasons behind weak marketing could be a poor feasibility study.
Some businesses fail to thoroughly study all aspects of the market comprehensively, which
is reflected in their inability to maintain constant growth or expansion. Alqassabi [10]
also cites the inadequate availability of funds, which is directly reflected in the ability
of organizations to provide other necessities, such as technology and infrastructure. We
discuss in detail below the challenges faced by SMEs. We have divided the factors affecting
the SME sector into two types—external and internal factors. External factors are related
to the business environment, such as regulations, the education system, and culture, and
internal factors are related to the readiness and capabilities of business owners.

2.3. External Factors


Despite the government’s efforts, many studies suggest that the SME sector in Oman
is still struggling with significant issues which hinder its full potential.

2.3.1. Processes and Procedures


Firstly, the procedures and processes that must be followed to establish new organi-
zations are complex [24]. The entrepreneurs are required to go through an administrative
bureaucracy that is highly centralized and requires authorization from the Ministry of
Commerce’s main office in the capital, Muscat. As a solution, such a bureaucratic setup
and decision-making process could be decentralized to regional and governorate levels
to expedite the process [18]. The procedures of licensing different types of businesses,
which vary and could take a long time, do not complement a modern globalized business
environment [10].
Another procedure-related difficulty facing SMEs in Oman is the long bureaucratic
measures involved in granting loans and funding to newly established companies [10]. The
processes used by government agencies, banks, and financing companies are complicated
and lengthy. These processes are time-consuming due to the scheduling of meetings and
obtaining approvals from central offices, which are located in the capital, Muscat. At the
same time, regional managers are not given full autonomy to make decisions. Business
owners are also constrained by the long and complicated measures imposed by public and
private financing agencies Ramachandran and Yahmadi [16]. The demanding conditions
and guarantees are challenging for businesses in the establishment phase to meet, which is
sometimes made worse by loan disbursement delays that directly result in delays in setting
up a business [25]. In 2016, approximately 50–70% of the loan applications from SMEs
in Oman were rejected by the banks since the risk associated with the small-scale sector
Knowledge 2022, 2 529

is higher, and the applicants failed to provide collaterals and fulfil other conditions [26].
Loans are typically associated with high-interest rates and short reimbursement periods
that burden business owners and impede steady development in the initial phases of the
establishment [16].

2.3.2. Education System


The education system is one of the critical factors that helps to establish an en-
trepreneurial mindset in citizens. It initially shapes their attitudes and approaches and
how they perceive business and then sharpens their skills towards success in a sector.
The education system in Oman has been recently reformed into “basic education,” which
consists of two cycles: cycle one, from grades one to four, and cycle two, from grades
five to ten, after which students move on to two more grades, then to colleges and uni-
versities [27]. However, the reformed education system has not considered the necessary
strategies and methods to develop an entrepreneurial mindset among Omani students [28].
The Omani government has taken many steps to reform the education system and intro-
duce the knowledge of entrepreneurship through different interventions. For instance, it
has started forming committees and developing curricula that aim at improving student
abilities. Other measures have also been taken to incorporate new programs such as Injaz
Oman and Intiqala into the education system. These programs are collaborations between
the government and the private sector aimed at higher education students to increase
their awareness and support them in creating their private businesses [29]. However,
Al-Mataani [29] concludes that the effectiveness, coverage, and reach of these programs
are questionable. In a similar conclusion, Yarahmadi and Magd [28] doubt the efficacy of
these programs as they lack the core fundamentals of entrepreneurship, such as knowledge
and skills.
The extant studies have also shown that the current education system is not designed
to encourage an entrepreneurial mindset and culture among students; this applies to all
levels, from primary education to colleges and universities (both public and private) [30].
Educational institutions only provide academic degrees that are in a way related to the
field but do not instil the necessary motivation and enlightenment towards pioneering in
the business area. They do not provide entrepreneurship education, such as the required
training or technical assistance [31]. Overall, the education system in Oman does not
promote an investment mentality among students to become pioneers in the field [32].

2.3.3. Culture
Omani society shares many cultural features and characteristics with its neighboring
Gulf countries, such as the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia, which, according to
Hofstede [33], score high on uncertainty avoidance, both scoring 80. Sharing the feature
of uncertainty avoidance with their Emirati and Saudi counterparts, most Omanis tend to
depend on the government to provide employment opportunities in the public sector. They
feel reluctant to pursue their future towards entrepreneurship due to the risks involved in
the latter. Consequently, this is directly reflected in avoiding initiatives that can potentially
lead to the growth of the SME sector [34].

2.4. Internal Factors


One of the main internal factors that affects SME survival and success in Oman is
the poor managerial experience of business owners. This results in low performance of
SMEs as business owners are not aware of the best modern approaches for conducting
business [5]. The extant literature highlights that business owners falter in managerial
experience and entrepreneurial capabilities, especially in the field of marketing. SMEs in
Oman are impeded by the lack of comprehensive and professionally conducted market
research, resulting in most business owners establishing their SMEs without performing
feasibility studies [26]. In addition, Al Bulushi and Bagum [35] reported that SME owners
in Oman lack other managerial skills, such as those related to human resource management,
Knowledge 2022, 2 530

financial management, marketing, and operation management. They conclude that SMEs
in Oman face problems as they do not allocate a specific budget for marketing their
products in the local and regional market, and the majority do not conduct any research
and analysis of the market needs and demands [35]. Lack of marketing knowledge results
in failure to attract the attention of the SMEs’ target market since marketing acumen is
essential, particularly in the competitive business environment [26]. Furthermore, many
SME owners are unfamiliar with outsourcing skills that can lead to cost reduction. Bilal
and Al Mqbali [18] further reported that the lack of administrative capabilities and skills
are among the main issues entrepreneurs face, as these skills are essential for the smooth
functioning of their business.

3. Research Methods and Procedures


To meet the objectives of this study, we used a quantitative approach to collect data. A
questionnaire survey was distributed among SME owners who had spent a considerable
amount of time in the market and experienced the procedures of establishing their busi-
nesses from the beginning. This category of participants is the most appropriate for this
study as they are witnesses to the areas of strength, difficulty, and weakness in the system.
The survey was also distributed among the unemployed youth to identify their future
interest in self-employment and to gauge their awareness of different support programs to
establish a business. The researchers used an online survey developed using “Qualtrics”.
This saved time in data collection and provided convenience to the respondents in filling
out the survey.
The survey was conducted across the length and breadth of Oman. It covered the
capital city Muscat, where most Omani SMEs operate, and other remote locations to
understand the readiness and understanding of local citizens in these areas. The survey was
directed towards individuals operating in diverse industries and business environments,
such as retail, health, recreation, and food industries. Moreover, the survey focused on
entrepreneurs with diverse educational backgrounds to enrich the variety of respondents
in the study. The survey was distributed randomly using a convenience sampling approach
among eligible Omani citizens of different backgrounds and ages, and in total, 344 valid
responses were received.
The survey comprised of three sections: the first section asked questions related to
the participant’s personal information, such as age, gender, and education level. The
second section asked questions related to the causes of current barriers to establishing
businesses (external factors); procedures and facilitating factors (external factors), and
entrepreneurial skills and capabilities (internal factors). The third section elicited the
suggestions of respondents on the interventions that can be made to mitigate the internal
and external challenges facing SMEs in Oman. In addition to collecting primary data via
the survey technique, the study also reports on secondary data by analyzing the extant
literature on the topic.

4. Analysis and Findings


The data collected using the first section of the survey instrument was analyzed using
descriptive statistics. As shown in Table 2, 77.03% of the respondents were male and
22.97% were female. The largest group of respondents (51.16%) comprised of youths aged
between 26 and 35 years old, while 36.92% were aged between 36 and 45 years. Most of
the respondents (36.63%) had bachelors degrees, followed by diploma holders (27.91%).
Most respondents (46.8%) were employed in the public sector, while 27% worked in the
private sector. A total of 18.02% of respondents were entrepreneurs who ran their own
private businesses. The survey also shows that only 8.13% of the total respondents were
unemployed. The findings also show that most of the respondents (89.83%) were more
inclined toward jobs in the public sector than pursuing entrepreneurship.
Knowledge 2022, 2 531

Table 2. Demographic profile of participants (n = 344).

Variable Category Frequency Percentage


Male 265 77.03%
Gender
Female 79 22.97%
25 or less 15 4.36%
26–35 176 51.16%
Age
36–45 127 36.92%
46 or above 26 7.56%
Secondary or below 68 19.76%
Diploma 96 27.91%
Educational Background
Bachelor 126 36.63%
Master or above 54 15.70%
Public sector only 161 46.80%
Private sector only 93 27.04%
Employment
Entrepreneurs 62 18.02%
Unemployed 28 8.14%
Public sector 309 89.83%
Job Preference Private sector 11 3.20%
Entrepreneurs 24 6.97%

4.1. Four-Dimensional Analysis


The second part of the survey instrument helped us collect data on the procedures and
practices affecting SMEs in Oman. Exploring these procedures and practices is expected
to help us better understand the internal and external factors that affect the survival and
success of SMEs. Specifically, the study used a four-dimensional approach to understand
the dynamism of SMEs in Oman. The four dimensions are the education system, culture,
business establishment procedures, and managerial skills. The first three of these dimen-
sions represent the external factors that affect SMEs, while the fourth dimension captures
the internal factors that affect the survival and success of SMEs. As shown in Table 3,
the respondents of this study believed that the education system (mean, 4.29) is the most
critical dimension that requires intervention to enhance SMEs survival and success. The
findings also show that culture (mean, 4.28), managerial skills (mean, 4.25), and business
establishment procedures (mean, 4.08) are other significant areas that need attention to
improve the success and survival of SMEs in Oman.

Table 3. Four determinants of SME survival and success (n = 344).

Dimension Mean Rank


Education system 4.29 1
Culture 4.28 2
Managerial skills 4.25 3
Business establishment procedures 4.08 4

We looked deeper into each of the above dimensions to understand how they affect
SMEs (see Table 4).

4.1.1. Education System


We firstly analyzed how the respondents perceived the education system in Oman.
The findings show that 86.63% of the respondents agreed with the need to start basic
entrepreneurship education at early stages (at grade 10 of basic education) to help im-
bibe an entrepreneurial mindset among young generations. Some respondents suggested
starting entrepreneurial education even earlier than grade 10. A majority (93.9%) of the
respondents also stressed that colleges and universities should start teaching a course in
entrepreneurship to all students regardless of their disciplines to help them develop and
Knowledge 2022, 2 532

enhance their confidence and skills in entrepreneurship. The respondents were almost
unanimous (90.99%) in suggesting that higher education institutions should further their
efforts to introduce non-academic events, such as organizing networking sessions with
successful local entrepreneurs, to inspire and encourage students. Most of the respondents
(91.86%) also supported the idea of having specialized entrepreneurship development
centers on campus to assist and guide students who would like to take the path of private
business after their graduation.

4.1.2. Culture
A detailed examination of the participants’ perception of culture and its effect on the
survival and success of SMEs in Oman revealed that 91.86% of the participants believed that
the education system should be transformed to reduce uncertainty avoidance, encourage
risk-taking, and minimize fear of failure among young generations.
Most of the survey participants (90.40%) also revealed that the negative societal public
perception of those who fail in business for the rest of their lives should be eliminated.
The findings suggest that any failures in entrepreneurship should instead be embraced by
society without stigmatization. Most respondents (92.74%) also emphasized the need for a
national strategy to shift the public attitude away from public sector jobs and more towards
private businesses and entrepreneurship.

Table 4. Support for interventions in determinants of SME survival and success (n = 344).

Determinants of SME Survival and Success Respondent Support for Reforms


Interventions in the education system
• Basic entrepreneurship mindset should start at least at grade 10
86.63%
(Cycle 2-Basic Education).

• Universities and colleges should introduce an “easily understood” course to


develop confidence and know-how in entrepreneurship to all students of 93.90%
all disciplines.

• Universities and colleges should arrange events with successful local


entrepreneurs on campus to encourage networking with students and 90.99%
inspiring them.

• Universities and colleges should open entrepreneurship development centers to


91.86%
assist students who desire to take that path after graduation.

Reforms in the cultural dimension


• The education system should be strategized to encourage risk-taking traits and
minimise fear of failure among young generations (reduce 91.86%
uncertainty avoidance).

• The education system should be strategized to introduce a mindset to embrace


entrepreneurs who fail among new generations, rather than considering them 90.40%
failures all their life.

• The government should develop a strategy to change public attitude away from
92.74%
public sector jobs and more towards private businesses.

Interventions related to managerial skills


• The entrepreneur should set a clear vision for the enterprise to help him/her
96.51%
steer it towards success.
Knowledge 2022, 2 533

Table 4. Cont.

Determinants of SME Survival and Success Respondent Support for Reforms


• The entrepreneur should be trained, even roughly, to best practices in specific
areas such as planning finance, accounting knowledge, credit management,
93.90%
inventory management, cash flow management, marketing management, and
human resource management.

• The enterprise should be obliged to hire competent and qualified staff even in
74.42%
minimum critical positions such as marketing, finance, and HR.

Interventions in business establishment procedures


• A center in every governorate to finish all procedures and required by different
92.74%
regulatory agencies for all types of businesses.

• The measures taken by the government (loans, training, follow-up) are enough,
35.76%
but need more publicity.

• Different schemes of taxes and charges paid by SMEs should be reduced. 86.91%

• Loans processing and related activities should be decentralized in governorates,


88.08%
rather than centralized in the capital, Muscat.

• Interest rates on loans from finance companies for SMEs should be reduced. 79.95%

• Conditions and guarantees for obtaining loans from finance companies should be
85.48%
less complicated.

• The government should introduce a plan for longer-term loans specifically


91.86%
for SMEs.

• The government should ease some conditions on SMEs, such as reducing the
75.87%
percentage of hiring local workforce.

• The government should introduce more flexible legislation to obtain visas for
76.16%
foreign workers for SMEs.

4.1.3. Managerial Skills


Most of the respondents (96.51%) emphasized the importance of entrepreneurs setting
a clear vision before starting their businesses so that they can think strategically and
overcome future uncertainties. Furthermore, 93.9% of the respondents supported the idea
of training SME owners in basic managerial skills—such as those related to marketing,
finance, and human resource management—to help them run their businesses smoothly
and with confidence. Most respondents (74.42%) also supported having experienced and
qualified staff in administrative positions, such as marketing, finance, and human resources
management, to successfully manage the business and avoid fatal mistakes that could
jeopardize the business.

4.1.4. Business Establishment Procedures


The study participants supported the idea of reform in the business establishment
procedures. A majority (92.74%) agreed that there should be decentralized execution of
endorsing all types of businesses and granting approvals at the governorate level. The
findings revealed disagreement among the respondents regarding the measures taken by
the government to support the SME sector. A total of 35.76% of respondents felt that the
steps taken by the government were supportive enough, but more needed to be done in
terms of more publicity and marketing to reach more beneficiaries.
Most of the participants (86.91%) felt that the taxes and renewal charges imposed on
the enterprises in the initial or running stages are high and should be reduced. Furthermore,
Knowledge 2022, 2 534

a large portion of the respondents (88.08%) noted that loan processing by financing agencies
and administrative work related to it should be decentralized. The decisions should be
made at regional levels without going back to the main head offices in the capital, Muscat.
In addition, 79.95% of the respondents stressed that loan interest rates by private and
governmental financing agencies were high and should be reduced to the minimum. A
large portion of the respondents (85.48%) revealed that the conditions and guarantees
related to loans are complicated and impose high demands on SMEs that sometimes
cannot be met. Furthermore, 91.86% of the participants believed that the government
should introduce longer-term loan plans specifically designed to support SME owners to
overcome financial difficulties. Results also show that most respondents (75.87%) felt that
the conditions imposed on SME owners are complicated and should be eased. For instance,
Omanization criteria should be relaxed to allow for hiring a more significant percentage
of the foreign workforce, as engaging the local workforce involves paying higher wages
and benefits, which creates an extra financial burden on SME businesses. At the same time,
76.16% of the respondents stressed that more flexible legislation should be introduced to
grant foreign worker visas to SMEs.

5. Discussion and Implications


This study set out to examine the factors that affect the survival and success of SMEs
in Oman. We investigated the business-related internal factors and the environment-related
external factors to develop a holistic understanding of the functioning of SMEs in Oman.
The study provided insights into the varied aspects of the functioning of SMEs.
The first finding of this study revealed that the education system in Oman plays a
crucial role in SME survival and success and that the government should prioritize its efforts
towards improving the education system in a way that serves the human resource needs of
SMEs. Properly designed entrepreneurship education systems equip new generations with
the necessary skills and knowledge to develop their readiness to start private businesses.
The research results on improvements to the education system are consistent with past
studies in the context of Oman, which show that entrepreneurial education is one of the
essential enablers in encouraging students to develop their future businesses. For instance,
Belwal, Al Balushi [31] observed that “enterprise education can influence the performance
of entrepreneurs by enhancing their profitability, entrepreneurial spirit, entrepreneurial
attitudes, and chances of survival.” The research showed that most of the students were
highly interested in starting their businesses; however, reality hindered that desire as they
lacked the necessary basic knowledge, confidence, and suffered from fear of failure.
The current tertiary education system also seems to be disconnected from the market-
place needs of skills and knowledge. It does not produce students who have the necessary
know-how to establish enterprises. Al-Shanfari [36] identified the education system as one
of the obstacles in promoting the SME sector in Oman. He argued that it is based more on
memorizing than creativity. It also does not include a business-related curriculum, which
could help shape aspiring entrepreneurial characteristics among the students. Yarahmadi
and Magd [28] also spotted this gap between the output of educational institutions and
the current market demands for a skilled and knowledgeable workforce. They noted that
“despite various efforts, the quality of education in terms of 21st-century requirements of
knowledge acquisition and skills seems to be missing and is not up to the desired level”.
The second finding of this study revealed that culture affected the survival, success,
and performance of SMEs in Oman. This finding is consistent with the available literature,
which discusses the role of culture in SMEs [37]. The Omani society ranks high on uncer-
tainty avoidance in Hofstede’s cultural dimensions scale, scoring 80 [33]. The societies
that score high on uncertainty avoidance are characterized as risk avoiders and fearful of
the unknown consequences of certain decisions, such as adventurous entrepreneurship.
Omanis tend to be highly dependent on the government to provide secure jobs with a stable
income and almost guaranteed future promotions in the public sector. Al-Mataani [29]
noted that the Omani society does not support risk-takers and rarely embraces those who
Knowledge 2022, 2 535

fail; instead, it exerts pressure and blames unsuccessful entrepreneurs for taking the risk
in the first place. Al-Shanfari [36] also acknowledged that Omani culture is one of the
main contributing factors in shaping a negative entrepreneurial mindset among society
members towards not taking initiatives and risks. This societal reaction is a severe cultural
issue that needs to be thoroughly addressed and examined by the authorities in Oman.
Not doing so can impede entrepreneurship from flourishing in the country. Although it is
complicated, difficult to change, and requires an extended timeframe, it is imperative to
make interventions at different societal levels to make risk-taking acceptable and accept
failure as a regular part of the entrepreneurial process.
The third dimension that our study examined is the managerial skills of entrepreneurs.
Managerial skills play an important role in the success of enterprises [38]. The findings
revealed a consensus among the participants that there is a considerable gap between the
administrative skills and capabilities of the business owners and the market demands,
especially in the necessary skills of running organizations. This becomes particularly true
for the entrepreneurs who run businesses for the first time without proper initial training
and poor management background. The extant literature is consistent with this shortfall
among Omani entrepreneurs. One of the causes for this weakness is the lack of best
practices in administrative and vital functions such as human resource management and
filling vacancies with best fits [35]. Furthermore, Al Bulushi and Bagum [35] reported flaws
in the financial asset management of organizations regarding apportionment to different
departments in the short, medium, and long term. The usual practice is that the business
owner, who is the manager in most cases, would make these important decisions on their
own even without any prior experience [16]. Another area of weakness, particularly in
newly established enterprises, relates to the managerial lack of knowledge of the local and
regional market and the best practices for marketing their products [18,39]. In this regard,
the Omani government has taken some initiatives to train entrepreneurs. However, there is
a lack of awareness among business owners about such programs, resulting in many SME
owners not availing the benefits of such programs. This conclusion is supported by the
findings of this study which show a disagreement among the subjects about the sufficiency
of governmental services in this regard. Alqassabi [10] came to the same conclusion stating
that entrepreneurs lack awareness on the available governmental support services.
The fourth factor that our study examined relates to business establishment procedures.
SMEs in Oman are faced with complicated, lengthy procedures that require much effort,
time, and money. Some specific types of business activities require approval from certain
governmental agencies, which can be obtained only in the capital, Muscat. This is time-
consuming since the decisions are made in the capital city and are not decentralized at
the governorate level. Moreover, the financial liabilities for establishing businesses and
taxes associated with procedures such as renewal charges and worker visas are relatively
high and impose an extra burden on business owners. Similarly, access to financing is yet
another area of difficulty facing entrepreneurship in Oman. Entrepreneurs are hassled by
many administrative requirements when applying for loans to governmental or private
financing companies. The conditions to meet many requirements and provide guarantees,
which sometimes cannot be easily met, results in the loans not being granted to the aspiring
entrepreneurs. Decisions on loans are also centralized at the headquarter level of the
respective loan providers in the capital and are not taken at the regional managers level.
Furthermore, loan applicants are faced with more challenges in terms of high-interest rates
that must be met or rescheduled, which adds to their interest burden. The current body of
literature is consistent with these challenges facing entrepreneurs and agrees that business
establishment procedures and loan processing are some of the biggest challenges facing
SME owners in Oman. For instance, Alqassabi [10] cited rules and regulations and access to
finance as among the top five challenges SMEs face in Oman, while Bilal and Al Mqbali [18]
stated that finance and legislation are among the top five obstacles faced by SMEs in Oman.
Knowledge 2022, 2 536

5.1. Implications for Practice and Recommendations


The findings of this study holistically capture the main factors that affect entrepreneur-
ship in Oman. Based on the revelations of this extensive survey exercise, the following
recommendations are made for policy making at two levels: the government level and the
SME owner level. This approach assumes that the responsibility for a thriving SME sector in
Oman is a shared obligation and requires interventions at multiple levels. Accordingly, the
following recommendations cover the internal and external factors that affect the survival
and success of SMEs in Oman:
 Introducing a basic entrepreneurship mindset at early stages in basic education curric-
ula and making it mandatory for public and private schools.
 Colleges and universities could introduce entrepreneurship (breadth) courses to all
students from different disciplines and specialties.
 Colleges and universities could open in-campus entrepreneurship centers to assist
students who follow this path after graduation.
 Colleges and universities could arrange social events hosting successful local en-
trepreneurs who could share their experiences and connect with students and possibly
mentor them.
 The education system could be redesigned to help, in the long run, reduce uncertainty
avoidance among Omani new generations and encourage rational risk-taking.
 Steps could be taken to gradually transform society to be more supportive towards
entrepreneurs, especially the unsuccessful ones.
 The government could develop a strategy to change the mindset of citizens away
from public sector jobs and more towards private businesses while focusing on and
shedding more light on successful local entrepreneurship stories.
 Individuals who pursue an entrepreneurial future should seek appropriate training to
advance their necessary managerial skills before taking that path.
 Governmental support programs should be publicized more to reach the maximum
number of beneficiaries around the country. Different innovative marketing tech-
niques could be used to accomplish this outcome.
 The government could decentralize certain functions and establish a center in every
governorate to manage the procedures required by different regulatory agencies.
 Conditions, guarantees, and interest rates on loans from governmental and private
agencies could be rationalized to encourage entrepreneurship. These decisions could
also be decentralized at the governorate level.

5.2. Conclusions, Limitations, and Future Research


The SME sector is considered a vital part of any developed economy as countries
worldwide rely on it to generate employment, raise the standard of living, and expand their
respective GDP. The SME sector in Oman is promising and can become successful to help
develop the economy further and reduce the dependence on depleting natural resources.
However, certain areas need attention for this to happen.
This research has shown that the education system in Oman is the first and most
important dimension that needs immediate remedial actions from the government. Early
interventions in the education system can help shape new mindsets and refine some
obsolete cultural aspects that obstruct successful entrepreneurship. Education plays a
vital role in shaping the cultural aspects of societies—the second obstacle to successful
entrepreneurship identified in this study. Therefore, a carefully crafted education system
could also enhance some cultural elements of the Omani society in the long term by shaping
students’ mindset to become more open to risk-taking with a positive perception of failure.
Such upbringing of new generations will subsequently help reduce uncertainty avoidance
in future generations. Generations that are equipped with necessary entrepreneurial skills
and knowledge feel more confident and willing to establish private businesses as fear of
failure gradually decreases. The third impediment to successful entrepreneurship relates to
the entrepreneurs themselves and their readiness to develop their managerial capabilities
Knowledge 2022, 2 537

before commencing their businesses. Finally, the government should ease the procedures
of establishing new enterprises and introduce new flexible conditions to financing plans
that provide attractive incentives for business owners. In conclusion, these interventions
can be a good starting point for improving entrepreneurship outcomes in Oman. Some
of these measures (e.g., business establishment procedures) could be applied in the short
term, while others (e.g., the education system) require a long-term perspective.
This study has some limitations. This study relied entirely on a quantitative dataset.
While this per se may not be a limitation, to confirm the findings of this study, we recom-
mend that future studies include qualitative data to understand further the nuances of the
issues raised in this study. Future research may also compare the Omani SME sector to a
prosperous neighboring country that shares a similar culture, such as the UAE [40]. Such a
benchmarking exercise may lead to adopting the relevant policy interventions and avoid
reinventing the wheel.

Author Contributions: Conceptualization, K.I.A.; methodology, K.I.A.; formal analysis, K.I.A.; inves-
tigation, K.I.A.; resources, K.I.A.; data curation, K.I.A.; writing—original draft preparation, K.I.A.;
writing—review and editing, M.M.N.; supervision, M.M.N.; project administration, K.I.A. All authors
have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding: This research received no external funding.
Institutional Review Board Statement: Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement: Informed consent was obtained from all subjects involved in the study.
Data Availability Statement: Not applicable due to data confidentiality.
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References
1. Madani, A.E. SME policy: Comparative analysis of SME definitions. Int. J. Acad. Res. Bus. Soc. Sci. 2018, 8, 103–114. [CrossRef]
2. Sataic, I. Attitudes About the Economic Impact of the COVID-19 Lockdown in the Republic of Croatia on Micro, Small and
Medium Enterprises. Eur. J. Econ. 2021, 1, 22–33. [CrossRef]
3. Elhassan, O.M. Obstacles and Problems Facing the Financing of Small and Medium Enterprises in KSA. J. Financ. Account. 2019,
7, 168–183.
4. Bhuiyan, M.F.; Ivlevs, A. Micro-entrepreneurship and subjective well-being: Evidence from rural Bangladesh. J. Bus. Ventur. 2019,
34, 625–645. [CrossRef]
5. Ratanova, I.; Voroncuka, I. The Aspects of Entrepreneurship and Innovation Development of SMEs. In Proceedings of the 11th
Annual International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management, Singapore, 7–11 March 2021.
6. OECD. OECD SME and Entrepreneurship Outlook 2019; OECD: Paris, France, 2019. [CrossRef]
7. Gherghina, S, .C.; Botezatu, M.A.; Hosszu, A.; Simionescu, L.N. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs): The engine of
economic growth through investments and innovation. Sustainability 2020, 12, 347. [CrossRef]
8. Vermeulen, B.; Kesselhut, J.; Pyka, A.; Saviotti, P.P. The impact of automation on employment: Just the usual structural change?
Sustainability 2018, 10, 1661. [CrossRef]
9. Haddad, M.I.; Williams, I.A.; Hammoud, M.S.; Dwyer, R.J. Strategies for implementing innovation in small and medium-sized
enterprises. World J. Entrep. Manag. Sustain. Dev. 2019, 16, 12–29. [CrossRef]
10. Alqassabi, M.A. Insights on Sustainability of Small and Medium Enterprises in Oman: A Conceptual Framework. Int. J. Econ.
Financ. Issues 2020, 10, 209–218. [CrossRef]
11. The World Bank. Unemployment, Youth Total (% of Total Labor Force Ages 15–24) (Modeled ILO Estimate)—Oman. 2020.
Available online: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.UEM.1524.ZS?contextual=region&end=2019&locations=OM&start=
1991&view=chart. (accessed on 21 September 2021).
12. Rahman, S.A.; Khan, G.M.; AlAbri, S.; Taghizadeh, S.K. The role of intellectual capital on entrepreneurial opportunity recognition
among SMEs in the Sultanate of Oman. J. Intellect. Cap. 2021, 23, 1–24. [CrossRef]
13. SustainableOman. Tanfeedh-Oman’s Initiative towards Economic Diversification. 2021. Available online: https://sustainableoman.
com/tanfeedh-omans-initiative-towards-economic-diversification/ (accessed on 15 September 2021).
14. Al Balushi, Y.; Locke, S.; Boulanouar, Z. Determinants of the decision to adopt Islamic finance: Evidence from Oman. ISRA Int. J.
Islamic Financ. 2019, 11, 6–26. [CrossRef]
15. Civelek, M.; Ključnikov, A.; Fialova, V.; Folvarčná, A.; Stoch, M. How innovativeness of family-owned SMEs differ depending on
their characteristics? Equilib. Q. J. Econ. Econ. Policy 2021, 16, 413–428. [CrossRef]
Knowledge 2022, 2 538

16. Ramachandran, N.; Yahmadi, H.M.A.A. Challenges Faced by SMEs in Oman. Shanlax Int. J. Arts Sci. Humanit. 2019, 7, 15–25.
[CrossRef]
17. Al Maimani, J.; Johari, F. Enhancing Active Participation of SMEs and Islamic Banks towards Economic Diversification in Oman.
Procedia Econ. Financ. 2015, 31, 677–688. [CrossRef]
18. Bilal, Z.O.; Al Mqbali, N.S. Challenges and constrains faced by small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Al Batinah governorate
of Oman. World J. Entrep. Manag. Sustain. Dev. 2015, 11, 120–130. [CrossRef]
19. Joshi, S.; Sharma, M. Impact of sustainable supply chain management on performance of SMEs amidst COVID-19 pandemic: An
Indian perspective. Int. J. Logist. Econ. Glob. 2022, 9, 248–276. [CrossRef]
20. OECD. Enterprises by Business Size. 2021. Available online: https://data.oecd.org/entrepreneur/enterprises-by-business-size.
htm (accessed on 7 September 2021).
21. National Centre for Statistics and Information. Small and Medium Enterprises. 2019. Available online: https://data.gov.om/
eopqlmg/small-and-medium-enterprise?lang=en (accessed on 22 June 2021).
22. Zutshi, A.; Mendy, J.; Sharma, G.D.; Thomas, A.; Sarker, T. From challenges to creativity: Enhancing SMEs’ resilience in the
context of COVID-19. Sustainability 2021, 13, 6542. [CrossRef]
23. Al-Tit, A.; Omri, A.; Euchi, J. Critical success factors of small and medium-sized enterprises in Saudi Arabia: Insights from
sustainability perspective. Adm. Sci. 2019, 9, 32. [CrossRef]
24. Christina, B.; Neelufer, A.; Al Amri, S. Challenges and barriers encountered by the SMEs owners in Muscat Blossom Christina.
Int. J. Small Bus. Entrep. Res. 2014, 2, 1–13.
25. Al Buraiki, A.; Khan, F.R. Finance and Technology: Key Challenges Faced by Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in Oman. Int.
J. Manag. Innov. Entrep. Res. 2018, 4, 1–12. [CrossRef]
26. Sanyal, S.; Hisam, M.W.; Baawain, A.M.S. Challenges facing internationalization of SMEs in emerging economies: A study on
OECD model. J. Asian Financ. Econ. Bus. 2020, 7, 281–289. [CrossRef]
27. Ministry of Education Portal Oman. Education System in Oman. Available online: https://home.moe.gov.om/module.php?m=
pages-showpage&CatID=14&ID=16 (accessed on 15 July 2021).
28. Yarahmadi, F.; Magd, H.A.E. Entrepreneurship Infrastructure and Education in Oman. Procedia Soc. Behav. Sci. 2016, 219, 792–797.
[CrossRef]
29. Al-Mataani, R.N. Examining the Entrepreneurial Context of Oman: Multi-Layered Perspective Using the Institutional Lens. Ph.D.
Thesis, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK, 2017.
30. Bindah, E.V.; Magd, H.A.E. Teaching entrepreneurship in Oman: Successful approaches. Procedia Soc. Behav. Sci. 2016, 219,
140–144. [CrossRef]
31. Belwal, R.; Al Balushi, H.; Belwal, S. Students’ perception of entrepreneurship and enterprise education in Oman. Educ. Train.
2015, 57, 924–947. [CrossRef]
32. Taderera, F.; Al-Nabhani, S.; Karedza, G. Exploring entrepreneurship and SMEs in Oman: Opportunities, Challenges, Realities
and Pitfalls. Int. J. Bus. Manag. Stud. 2014, 3, 379–390.
33. Hofstede Insights. Hofstede’s Cultural Dimensions in Some GCC Countries. 2020. Available online: https://www.hofstede-
insights.com/product/compare-countries/ (accessed on 5 April 2020).
34. Al Badi, K. Implementation of marketing concept and organizational culture in SMEs in Al Buraimi—Oman. Benchmarking Int. J.
2019, 26, 2401–2414. [CrossRef]
35. Al Bulushi, B.H.S.; Bagum, S. Growth Strategies of SME in Oman—Issues and Challenges. Int. J. Small Bus. Entrep. Res. 2017, 5,
21–61.
36. Al-Shanfari, D.A. Entrepreneurship in Oman: A Snapshot of the Main Challenges. In Proceedings of the United Nations
Conference on Trade and Development: Multi-Year Expert Meeting on Enterprise Development Policies and Capacity-Building
in Science, Technology and Innovation (STI), Geneva, Switzerland, 16–18 January 2012.
37. Kabir, I.; Abdullahi, Y.A.; Naqshbandi, M.M. Measuring entrepreneurial orientation and institutional theory for informal
enterprises: Scale validation. Qual. Quant. 2022, 1–25. [CrossRef]
38. Naqshbandi, M.M. Managerial ties and open innovation: Examining the role of absorptive capacity. Manag. Decis. 2016, 54,
2256–2276. [CrossRef]
39. Naqshbandi, M.M.; Kaur, S. Do managerial ties support or stifle open innovation? Ind. Manag. Data Syst. 2014, 114, 652–675.
[CrossRef]
40. Naqshbandi, M.M.; Kamel, Y. Intervening role of realized absorptive capacity in organizational culture–open innovation
relationship: Evidence from an emerging market. J. Gen. Manag. 2017, 42, 5–20. [CrossRef]

You might also like