Chairperson Vice-Chair

DETROIT BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS Minutes of the Board of Police Commissioners Meeting Thursday, April 21, 2011 The regularly scheduled meeting of the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners (BOPC) was held at Detroit Police Headquarters, 1300 Beaubien, room 328-A, Detroit, Michigan, on Thursday, April 21, 2011. Commission Chair Jerome L. Warfield, Sr. in the chair, and Mr. George N. Anthony as secretary, convened the meeting at approximately 3:05 p.m. Present: Commissioners Adela Rivera, Toney Stewart and Donnell R. White The presence of all four (4) members established a quorum. Assistant Chief (AC) Chester L. Logan represented the Department. The invocation was given by Evangelist Dora Hatcher. On motion by Commissioner Rivera the BOPC approved the meeting agenda with the following addition under item 7: vote on meeting minutes for April 14, 2011. On motion by Commissioner Rivera the BOPC approved the meeting minutes for April 7, 2011 and April 14, 2011. Chairman Warfield announced that the BOPC office will be closed on Friday, April 22, 2011 because of the Good Friday holiday, and again on Monday, April 25, 2011 as a budget required furlough day. The office will reopen on Tuesday, April 26, 2011. Secretary Anthony reported on the number of citizen complaints received in and through March 2011. The total number of complaints received in March 2011 was 143 which represented a 13% decrease when compared to March 2010s figure of 165. The year to date total through the end of March 2011 was 341 which represented a 10% decrease from last years total of 381. The BOPC received the report.

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 2

The BOPC prepared resolutions for members who were retiring from the Department. Commissioner White read the members names: Sergeants Jerry Shoate and Maria CoxBorkowski, as well as Police Officer Michael Hughes. On motion by Commissioner Rivera the BOPC approved the resolutions. Chairman Warfield also recognized the retirement of Officer Myra Gracey. Chairman Warfield announced the next meeting date for the BOPC as being Thursday, April 28, 2011 at 3:00 p.m., police headquarters, 1300 Beaubien, #328-A. In addition, he announced that Chief Godbee will present the Departments 1st Quarterly Report on Wednesday, April 26th, at Charity Lutheran Church, 17220 Kelly Rd., from 6:00 p.m.8:00 p.m., and that the Detroit Police Chaplain Corps will host a Gospel Concert on Friday, April 29th, at 6:00 p.m., at Greater Mt. Zion Church, 15600 Evanston. Commissioner Rivera made a statement commending Department members for their response to a recent incident involving her aunt. The BOPC entertained oral communications from the public: Mr. R. Ector indicated that he and others recently held an open carry event and made other statement regarding openly carrying a firearm. Mr. E. Moore, liaison to Councilman Kenyatta, acknowledged the retired officers. Ms. B. Smith commented on a newspaper report that police wanted to cease testing bullets due to being overloaded with work and observed that this action could hinder investigations. She also commented on Michigan Supreme Court Justice Robert Youngs proposal to reduce the number of judges in the state. Evangelist D. Hatcher commented on the need for bigger jails; that inmates can do things in the community; and that prayer works. Ms. S. Pannell stated that she expected police to help when called and that the courts are letting criminals go. Mr. O. Collins said that he had been stopped by officers approximately 10 times over the last 3 months regarding open carry. He did not understand why he was being stopped and wanted to know the procedures for approaching citizens who openly carry. AC Logan read the Departments procedure. Ms. M. Lacy asked about Department reforms that could take an additional 2 years. She observed that the community was not receiving information except in the newspaper. AC Logan responded that the Department has made considerable progress last year and indicated that there are nuances in technology improvements. He also stated that the monitors and DOJ were excited about the Departments progress and that the goal is to be in compliance this year. The 2 years extension gives the Department a cushion for maintenance.

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 3

Mr. R. Scott commented on the consent decrees. He stated that he was disappointed in the Judge Cook and that the monitor is being paid good money and should come before the community. Mr. C. Brown addressed the issue of open carry and noted that officers can be sued for violating citizens civil rights. Mr. Brown asked that the city ordinances be amended to conform to state law. Mr. Brown was advised that the city council has the authority to change ordinances. Ms. J. Semma (7 Ds Tow) wanted to know the status of the towing permits. DC Ben Lee advised that the Zoning Department should complete their letters on Tuesday. Mr. N. Wilson complained that he was arrested for armed robbery and on a weapons charge March 10, 2011, but the armed robbery charge was dropped. He claimed that the officer lied on the witness stand and that his complaint filed with Internal Affairs was dropped. Mr. Wilson was referred to OCI representatives as well as to DC James Tolbert and Lieutenant Herbert Miles. On motion by Commissioner Rivera the meeting adjourned at approximately 4:00 p.m.

GEORGE N. ANTHONY Secretary to the Board

Approved: 4/28/2011

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 4

1. BOPC OFFICERS REPORT 1. CHAIRPERSON 2. SECRETARYS REPORT CITIZEN COMPLAINTS RECEIVED MARCH 2011
March 2011 - Monthly Count of Complaints: 143 Year to Date 431
13% Decrease 10% Decrease

2010 - Monthly Count of Complaints:

165

381

At the end of March 2011, the Office of the Chief Investigator had: Active Investigations: Cases filed: Cases closed: 308 341 548

Of the 143 cases filed 38% involve unknown officers, of the alleged Known Units involved in complaints filed in March, 2011, the Eastern District: 12th Precinct: 6th and 8th Precincts: 9% 8% 8%

Of the 143 complaints filed in March 2011 involved allegations of: Improper Procedure: Improper Demeanor: Inadequate Service: Improper Use of Force: 33% 29% 16% 12%

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 5

2.

PRESENTATION/REPORT-CHIEF OF POLICE

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 6

April 21, 2011 V olum 7, Issue 16 e

De it Po eDe a e t tro lic p rtmn

Re port to the Board of Police Comm issione rs
Building a S afer Detroit Through Comm unity Partnerships
The Detroit Police Department is committed to uphold its mission to provide a safe environment for our residents and businesses. This effort is not possible without the joint commitment of the community and the Police Department. We appreciate and value th e role our citizens have played in helping us to take the guns and drugs off the streets of the city of Detroit.

SPECIALENFO RCEMENTACT IONS Domestic Violence

On April 11, 2011, officers of the Northeastern District responded to the 12000 block of Memorial on a Disturbance. A subject was arrested. As a result of an investigation conducted by members of Domestic Violence, the subject was charged with Assault with intent to do Great Bodily Harm Less than Murder, Assault with a Dangerous Weapon, Domestic Violence, and Assault & Battery. A weapon was recovered by the officers.
1 1 2 2 2 2 2

Special Points of Interest: Nex m t eeting :

Thursday, April 28, 2011 @3:00 P.M. Detroit PoliceDepartm ent 1300 Beaub St. ien Detroit M ig 48226 ich an

Inside this issue:

Narcotics/Ga Enforcem t ng en Dom esticV iolen ce

Engaging the Community

Citizens wishing to make a police report may do so at any District/Precinct station in the city of Detroit. Citizens may also ut ilize the following District Mini/Sub -Stations to make reports.

North rnD aste istrict Sou w th esternDistric t Six Precinc th t T enthP inct rec Cen D tral istrict

Location Hours of Operation 1300 Beaubien 24 Hours 20500 Conant * 3 p.m. to 9 p.m. 7737 Kercheval *8 a.m. to 2 p.m. 19810 Grand River *9 a.m. to 9 p.m. 13530 Lesure 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. 2575 S. Schaefer * 3 p.m. to 9 p.m. 20 Atwater 24 Hours 13206 E. Jefferson *3 p.m. to 9 p.m. 22101 Moross (St. John Hospital) *3 p.m. to 9 p.m. 14700 Mack *3 p.m. to 9 p.m. * Mini-Stations Monday Friday

Telephone 596-5100 892-5456 628-2121 870-0649 596-5300 297-9423 237-2850 821-5851 343-7506 852-4046

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11 April 21, 2011

p. 7

Police / Com unity Inte e m rv ntion

Eastern District

Pag 1 e

On April 14, 2011, officers of the Eastern Di strict responded to the 14000 block of Glenfield on a Person Shot. As a result of their inve stigation, a subject was arrested and charged with Assault with Intent to do Great Bodily Harm, Felon in Possession, and Felonious Assault, Felony Firearm, and Habitual 4th D egree..

Twelfth Precinct
On April 13, 2011, while on patrol in the area of Wyoming and Eaton, officers of the Twelfth Precinct investigated a vehicle for a traffic vi olation. Subsequent to their investigation, a subject was arrested and charged with Carrying a Concealed Weapon, Felon in Possession, Felony Firearm, and Habitual. The officers also confiscated a weapon.

Tenth Precinct
On April 11, 2011, officers of the Tenth Precinct responded to the 13000 block of LaSalle on a Kidnapping. Subsequent to their investigation, officers arrester a subject who was later charged with Felony in Possession of a Firearm, Fel ony Firearm 2nd Degree, and Habitual 4th Degree. A weapon was confiscated as a result of their inve stigation.

Northeastern District
On April 12, 2011, officers of the Northeastern Di strict responded to the 11000 block of Mound road on a Person Shot. Due to their quick response, a citizen in the area held the wanted subject until officers arrived. The subject was arrested and charged with Assault with Intent to Murder, Assault with Intent to Commit Great Bodily Harm, Felonious Assault, Carrying a Concealed Weapon, and Felony Firearm.

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 8

3. NEW BUSINESS RESOLUTIONS: RESOLUTION HONORING SERGEANT JERRY SHOATE WHEREAS Mr. Jerry Shoate was promoted to the Detroit Police Department on August 12, 1985 upon graduating from the Detroit Metropolitan Police Academy. He was assigned to the Sixth Precinct; and WHEREAS Police Officer Shoates assignments also included the Special Crimes Section, Narcotics Section, and the Seventh Precinct; and WHEREAS Police Officer Shoate displayed tremendous diligence and aptitude and was promoted to the rank of Investigator on October 3, 1995 and was assigned to the Narcotics Enforcement and the Eighth Precinct Investigations Operations Unit; and WHEREAS Investigator Shoate was promoted to the rank of Sergeant on March 20, 1998 and was assigned to the Eighth Precinct Investigations Operations Unit. After successfully completing Officers Candidate School, Sergeant Shoate was assigned to Records & Identification, where he remained until his retirement; and WHEREAS Sergeant Shoate was the deserving recipient of numerous awards that included one (1) Meritorious Service Award, two (2) Departmental Commendations, four (4) Departmental Citations, five (5) Perfect Attendance Awards, one (1) Super Bowl Award, one (1) Rosa Parks Funeral Award, and one (1) All Star Game Award; and WHEREAS Sergeant Shoate diligently served the Department and the citizens of Detroit with integrity, loyalty, and dedication for 25 years. He received numerous letters of commendation from citizens, superiors and other law enforcement agencies making him the consummate professional. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED That the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners, speaking on behalf of the Detroit Police Department and the citizens of the City of Detroit recognize the lifelong commitment to Public Safety of Sergeant Jerry Shoate. His pride and dedication have been invaluable assets to the Department and merit our highest regard. We thank and congratulate you, Sergeant Jerry Shoate. DETROIT BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS RESOLUTION HONORING SERGEANT MARIA COX-BORKOWSKI WHEREAS Ms. Maria Cox-Borkowski was promoted to the Detroit Police Department on April 21, 1986 upon graduating from the Detroit Metropolitan Police Academy. She was assigned to the Fourth Precinct; and

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 9

WHEREAS Police Officer Cox-Borkowskis Enforcement Section; and

assignments

also

included

the

Narcotics

WHEREAS Police Officer Cox-Borkowski displayed tremendous diligence and aptitude and was promoted to the rank of Sergeant on August 7, 1996 and was assigned to the Thirteenth Precinct, Narcotics Enforcement Section, Homicide, Narcotics Planning and Analysis, Office of the Chief, and Homeland Security; and WHEREAS Sergeant Cox-Borkowski was the deserving recipient of numerous awards that included two (2) Chiefs Unit Awards, one (1) Chiefs Merit Award, and three (3) Perfect Attendance Awards; and WHEREAS Sergeant Cox-Borkowski diligently served the Department and the citizens of Detroit with loyalty, dedication, and integrity for 25 years. She received citations, ribbons, and letters of commendation from citizens and superiors making her the consummate professional. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED That the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners, speaking on behalf of the Detroit Police Department and the citizens of the City of Detroit recognize the lifelong commitment to Public Safety of Sergeant Maria Cox-Borkowski. Her pride and dedication have been invaluable assets to the Department and merit our highest regard. We thank and congratulate you, Sergeant Maria Cox-Borkowski. DETROIT BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS

RESOLUTION HONORING POLICE OFFICER MICHAEL W. HUGHES WHEREAS Mr. Michael Hughes was promoted to the Detroit Police Department on January 27, 1986 upon graduating from the Detroit Metropolitan Police Academy. He was assigned to the Tenth Precinct; and WHEREAS Police Officer Hughes worked in several units within the department which included the Tactical Services Section, Fourth Precinct, Narcotics Enforcement Section and Fleet Management Section where he served until his retirement in January 2011; and WHEREAS Police Officer Hughes was the deserving recipient of numerous awards that included one (1) Meritorious Service Award, six (6) Departmental Commendations, four (4) Departmental Citations, one (1) Perfect Attendance Award, one (1) Super Bowl Award, one (1) Rosa Parks Funeral Award, and one (1) All Star Game Award; and

BOPC Minutes 4-21-11

p. 10

WHEREAS Police Officer Hughes diligently served the Department and the citizens of Detroit with integrity for 25 years. He received numerous letters of commendation from the Mayor of the City of Detroit, the Mayor of Windsor, Ontario, and the Federal Bureau of Investigation in conjunction with the United States Department of Justice. Police Officer Hughes also received numerous commendations from citizens, superiors, and other law enforcement agencies making him the consummate professional. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED That the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners, speaking on behalf of the Detroit Police Department and the citizens of the City of Detroit recognize the lifelong commitment to Public Safety of Police Officer Michael W. Hughes. His pride and dedication have been invaluable assets to the Department and merit our highest regard. We thank and congratulate you, Police Officer Michael W. Hughes. DETROIT BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS 4. OLD BUSINESS There was no old business. 5. ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT MEETING Thursday, April 28, 2011 Police Headquarters 1300 Beaubien Rm. 328-A Detroit, MI 48226 6. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 4:00 p.m. Respectfully submitted,

GEORGE N. ANTHONY Executive Secretary

Board of Police Commissioners GNA/rb