QAR Report 2010 - 2
QAR Report 2010 - 2
North Central Association Commission on Accreditation and School Improvement (NCA CASI) and the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools Council on Accreditation and School Improvement (SACS CASI) are accreditation divisions of AdvancED.
Page 2 of 26
Page 3 of 26
A key aim of the Quality Assurance Review is to verify that the school is operating with institutional integrity that it is fulfilling its vision and mission for its students. School Preparation. To prepare for the Quality Assurance Review, the school community engages in an in-depth self assessment of each of the seven AdvancED standards. The school identifies and describes the evidence that demonstrates that it is meeting each standard. Through this internal review, the school examines how its systems and processes contribute to student performance and school effectiveness. Summary of Team Activities. The Quality Assurance Review Team is led by an AdvancED certified team chair and comprised of professionals from outside the school. The team reviews the findings of the school's internal self-assessment, conducts interviews with representative groups of stakeholders, reviews student performance data and other documentation provided by the school, and observes practices and daily operations. The team engages in professional deliberations to reach consensus on the school's adherence to the standards for accreditation. The team provides an oral exit report and prepares a written Quality Assurance Review Team Report designed to help the school improve. The Quality Assurance Review Team Report. Following the visit, the review team completes the Quality Assurance Review report. After review by a nationally-trained reader, the report is submitted to the school. The report contains commendations and required actions for improvement. Using the Report - Responding to the Required Actions. The school uses the report to guide its improvement efforts. The school is held accountable for addressing the required actions identified in the report. The NCA CASI/SACS CASI State Office is available to assist schools in addressing the required actions. At prescribed intervals, the school must submit a progress report detailing the actions and progress the school has made on the team's required actions. The report is reviewed at the state and national level to ensure the school is addressing the required actions. Accreditation Recommendation. The Quality Assurance Review Team uses the findings from the onsite visit to make an accreditation recommendation that is reviewed at the state level and by the national AdvancED Accreditation Commission. Accreditation is granted by the AdvancED Accreditation Commission and communicated to the school following action from the commission.
Page 4 of 26
Summary of Findings
A Quality Assurance Review Team representing the NCA CASI Department of Defense (NCA-CASI-DODEA), a division of AdvancED, visited the Daegu American School in APO, US-AP, US on 02/01/2010 - 02/04/2010. During the visit, members of the Quality Assurance Review Team interviewed 2 members of the administrative team, 98 students, 13 parents, and 80 teachers. In addition, Base Command, Support Staff and School Improvement Leadership Team were interviewed. The team also reviewed documents, student performance data, and other artifacts provided by the school. Specifically, the team examined the school's systems and processes in relation to the seven AdvancED standards: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Vision and Purpose Governance and Leadership Teaching and Learning Documenting and Using Results Resource and Support Systems Stakeholder Communications and Relationships Commitment to Continuous Improvement
The AdvancED standards focus on systems within a school and systematic methods of attaining high student performance and organizational effectiveness. The power of the standards lies in the connections and linkages between and among the standards. The Quality Assurance Review Team used the AdvancED standards to guide its review of the school, looking not only for adherence to individual standards, but also for how the school functions as a whole and embodies the practices and characteristics of a quality school. Through its examination of the school's adherence to the standards, the Quality Assurance Review Team identified the following commendations and required actions.
Commendations
The Quality Assurance Review Team commends the school for the following strengths and accomplishments. While additional strengths are noted in the detailed review of each standard that appears later in this report, the commendations listed below are the strengths that the team believes are most deserving of being highlighted. The school leaders and staff are dedicated to promoting and supporting an environment that celebrates and honors a diverse population. The school engages in several activities that honor and support its multi-ethnic students. Schools with diverse populations can help students excel by building a climate that engages the whole community working together in a spirit of understanding, accepting, and utilizing each others differences to prepare students for the diverse world in which they live. Support for students at all grade levels is in place through the guidance/counseling program. Parents, teachers, and students indicated strong support for the guidance program, as evidenced through AdvancED Quality Assurance Review Report Page 5 of 26
Daegu American School interviews conducted by the QAR team. Counselors begin working with career decisions in the elementary school; design six year plans for middle school students; and four year plans for high school students. Students who are encouraged to explore and engage in career and course planning in the early grades and continue through graduation are well prepared and able to transition better from one level to the next. This type of continuous planning leads to student success. An orderly learning environment is evident at the school. Traffic flow is deliberately planned to integrate all grade levels to avoid problems and is successful in eliminating confusion and traffic problems. Students at all grade levels PreK-12 exist in the same buildings, and the team observed that all students are very orderly while passing in the hallway. Former students who were surveyed reported that discipline problems were addressed quickly and fairly. Research is very clear that an orderly environment is essential and necessary before students can truly apply themselves to their learning. Daegu American School has created an orderly environment. The school effectively communicates student learning expectations aligned with the Department of Defense Education Activity (DoDEA) standards. As evidenced by various documents such as course syllabi and homework assignments, there has been an emphasis to make students and parents aware of student learning expectations. Teachers and parents explained how various methods are used to communicate student learning expectations during interview sessions. Nearly 78% of 2009 Daegu American School graduates received scholarships. Clear communication with students, parents, and community which outline expectations for student learning is essential to ensure that the entire school community understands, embraces, and commits to an unrelenting focus on student achievement. Students will begin to take ownership of their own learning when they see and understand what they are trying to achieve.
Required Actions
In addition to the commendations, the Quality Assurance Review Team identified the following required actions for improvement. The team focused its required actions on those areas that, if addressed, will have the greatest impact on improving student performance and overall school effectiveness. The school will be held accountable for addressing each of the required actions noted in this section. Following this review, the school will be asked to submit a progress report on these required actions. Analyze stakeholder survey results and prioritize and act on the findings. In June 2009 a questionnaire was conducted with parents, students, and staff. The survey results do not include how many students were surveyed, and the number surveyed is critical in understanding the data with regard to scope and analysis. The results are very mixed, and a thorough review and analysis of the data are required to understand issues that may need to be addressed to improve the school. Data from stakeholders are very important to assist a school with its overall school effectiveness. These data can reveal to a school how its programs, processes, and procedures are working.
Page 6 of 26
Daegu American School Establish a formalized structure and ongoing professional development program in which teachers are purposefully and regularly convened to discuss student performance expectations and results so as to inform their practice. The team heard through interviews with faculty that there has been technology-based training to aid in their understanding in how to use the data from the Terra Nova. It has not been widely understood and used by all staff to impact instruction in the classroom. Professional development activities to support the use of data to impact instruction and student achievement at the classroom level are critical to increase student achievement results. Understanding the power and use of data is an essential component that will not only help ensure fidelity of implementation of the school improvement plan, but will also increase the overall effectiveness of teaching and learning. Establish student performance targets and gather, analyze and use student performance data to validate the curriculum and make sure all assessments are aligned with and measure curricular and school improvement goals. The team observed a lack of understanding by school leadership and faculty regarding the use of data to monitor and ensure fidelity of implementation of school improvement interventions and strategies as well as the use of data to impact instruction in the classroom beyond school improvement plan activities. The single intervention for reading and the single intervention for mathematics may be rigorous enough to achieve the results desired using the assessments selected for each goal area, but the school must monitor these results in an ongoing manner and adjust, as needed, if the results are not achieved. Specified targets should be set for any assessment that will be used so that everyone has a clear understanding of what should be achieved. Additional rigorous interventions or strategies may be necessary. Work with constituencies to identify and prioritize resource needs that will be necessary to implement the planned growth of the school population. Daegu American School has reached its capacity to serve additional students. The team heard through interviews with the Base Commander and school leadership that there are plans to renovate additional existing buildings to house school programs for students in certain grade levels. It will be necessary to plan carefully for this expected increase in student population to ensure a seamless, smooth transition for students to ensure no disruption to the learning process. The budget process will be enhanced through systematic and detailed requests that have strong stakeholder support. Monitor and evaluate the implementation and understanding of the mission and vision and the goal that supports the vision in order to determine if the school operations reflect the stated intent and if the system supports that effort. Various constituencies see the mission of the school differently. During interviews with various stakeholder groups it was clear that people are aware of the mission and vision of the school, but it was not clear that the mission and vision statements are more than words on a chart or wall and are used to drive decisions in the classroom and the school overall. It is critical that clarity of purpose and mission be established in order for effective implementation to occur.
Page 7 of 26
Daegu American School Review of AdvancED Standards for Quality Schools: The team reviewed the school's adherence to each of the AdvancED standards. The findings from this review are provided in the next section of this report.
Next Steps
The school should: 1. Review and discuss the findings from this report with all stakeholders. 2. Ensure that plans are in place to embed and sustain the strengths noted in the commendations section to maximize their impact on the school. 3. Develop action plans to address the required actions made by the team. Include methods for monitoring progress toward the required actions. 4. Use the report to guide and strengthen the school's efforts to improve student performance and school effectiveness. 5. Following the Quality Assurance Review, submit the Accreditation Progress Report detailing progress made toward addressing the required actions. The report will be reviewed at the state and national level to ensure that significant progress is being made toward the required actions. Lack of progress can result in a change in accreditation status. 6. Continue to meet the AdvancED accreditation standards, submit required reports, engage in continuous improvement, and document results.
Resources
AdvancED offers a range of resources to support your school as it acts on the findings in this report. The AdvancED Resource Network, available at www.advanc-ed.org/resourcenetwork, provides an online network of peer-to-peer practices, best practices, and resources and tools designed to help schools with their improvement efforts. Available any where, any time, the network can be queried for information on a variety of school improvement subjects. The AdvancED Research and Development division provides research, handbooks, and tools to assist schools with continuous improvement. In addition, your state office provides hands-on professional development and ongoing technical assistance. Contact your state office for more information on the range of resources available to you.
Celebrating Accreditation
Following the visit, the Quality Assurance Review Team submits an accreditation recommendation to AdvancED for state review and for action at the national level by the AdvancED Accreditation Commission, which confers accreditation and communicates it to the school. Upon receiving its accreditation, the school should celebrate its achievement with the school community. The NCA-CASI-DODEA accreditation seals are available at www.advanc-ed.org/communicationskit for accredited schools and districts to post on their website and to use in school communications. Flags, door decals, diploma seals, and lapel pins are also available and can be ordered from the website to help you share your accomplishment with your community.
Page 8 of 26
Summary
The accreditation process engages the school in an ongoing journey of continuous improvement. The next steps in this journey are to build on the strengths and address the required actions noted in this report. Doing so will enable the school to advance in its quest for excellence and deepen the fulfillment of its mission for all students.
Page 9 of 26
Daegu American School grade level. Daegu American School is mostly committed to a shared purpose and direction, but it is not totally understood and embraced across the entire school at this time. The school has clearly defined expectations for student learning, aligned with the schools vision that is supported by most school personnel and external stakeholders. The school has an annual systematic process to look at and revise their mission and vision; however, careful monitoring is necessary to help the faculty understand what is expected and needed for full implementation across the entire school. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: The school has a process which involved all stakeholders to link the school's goals to its vision. Students have a good working knowledge of the school vision. Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: Develop core understanding of the mission and vision to drive all school decisions, especially in teaching and learning. Parents need a better understanding of how the mission and vision is being used to help their children learn. For example, students have critical thinking with technical skills What does this mean? Which technical skills? Once identified, what is the school going to do to fulfill this part of the vision? Secondary grades need to embed the interventions into their instruction on a deeper level.
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Operational" and has met this
standard for accreditation.
The school has a system that provides for review and analysis of annual student performance and school effectiveness progress. The school uses the norm-referenced Terra Nova, Scholastic Reading Inventory, Developmental Reading Assessment, McMillian Final Math Assessment, and Advanced Placement Exams. Annual assessment improvement targets have not been established at this time. Valid and reliable short cycle formative assessments are not being utilized systematically throughout the school at this time. The school fosters a learning community. Teachers are assigned cross-grade-level instructional responsibilities. Grade-level teams and content departments meet to address student performance, professional development, and school improvement issues. The student body is mixed with younger and older students on the same floors with a student population of 77% of students who are multi-racial or in the minority category. The administrators and faculty promote and support an environment that celebrates and honors this diverse population. Teachers and students are provided opportunities to lead. Staff leadership teams consist of PreK-3, 4, 5, 6 and secondary department heads that meet regularly to provide input regarding student performance and professional development issues for staff. These regular meetings could become the forum for in-depth analysis of school and student data results that could help drive important decisions for teaching and learning. In addition, the School Improvement Team consists of a facilitator and lead staff person for the comprehension and problem-solving goal areas. A third staff person leads the data analysis team. An elected student council is operational at all grade levels. Daegu American School provides stakeholders meaningful roles in the decision making process that promote a culture of participation, responsibility, and ownership. The School Improvement team invites parents and stakeholders to participate as active members in the school improvement process. During the general parent interview, parents were not clear when asked about the overall performance of students at the school. Parents and stakeholders who were interviewed did report that they felt their children were in a safe, caring, and orderly environment. The school supports curricular and extracurricular activities throughout the year. Currently, there are 19 athletic and 26 extracurricular activities provided for students. Stakeholder surveys of students, staff, and parents were conducted in June 2009. In speaking with the School Improvement Team, improvement strategies to deal with issues arising from a review of the results have not been addressed at this time. The school implements an evaluation system that provides for the professional growth of all personnel. The personnel policies and procedures are directed by DoDEA, the Pacific Area Office (PAO), and the Korea District Superintendents Office (KDSO). Staff are evaluated as probationary status in the first two years. Each year two formal observations are conducted. Continuing contract personnel develop annual professional growth plans and are formally evaluated during the third year with two formal observations. Administrative staff share the supervision and evaluation duties for all school employees. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: The administrative team exhibits a strong moral purpose in their work. They are inclusive and collaborative in their decision making. Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: AdvancED Quality Assurance Review Report Page 12 of 26
Daegu American School Stakeholder survey results should be reviewed carefully and used to generate, implement, and evaluate improvement strategies.
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Operational" and has met this
standard for accreditation.
As observed in classrooms and through interviews, most of the teachers in the elementary grades are implementing interventions to help students meet the expectations of student learning. There are team meetings that are held monthly where the process of looking at student work is completed. Many of the teachers at the secondary level are likewise implementing the school improvement interventions, but some indicated that they do them only periodically. The process for looking at student work is not as consistently applied at the secondary level. In June 2009 a questionnaire was conducted with parents, students, and staff. The survey results in the profile do not include how many students were surveyed, and the number surveyed is critical in understanding the data with regard to scope and analysis. Responses to the survey indicate that 87% of elementary school students reported that they like the school while only 60% of middle and high school students in this survey reported that they like the school. Interviews with the SILT revealed that the results of these 2009 surveys have been discussed but not pursued. While there is not an active plan to ensure that the school climate is conducive to student learning, students indicate that they can approach teachers, the school counselor, the school nurse or the principal with their problems. The 2009 survey results must be thoroughly and completely analyzed to ascertain whether the data reveal any steps that need to be taken to improve the school. Through the interview process and review of artifacts, it was very apparent that the Educational Technologist (ET) department provides excellent support assisting teachers with their technology needs for delivering a quality instructional program. Some of these needs are met through monthly newsletters that include technology tips and website links for teachers. Surveys go out to teachers soliciting training needs which the ET department then compiles and provides training to teachers in the school computer lab. The technology committee has developed a three-year plan for purchasing equipment for the school to assist students and teachers as was evident through artifacts and mentioned through QAR team reviews. This will ensure a continuation of ready-access to technology in the school to support curricular and instructional programs. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: Curricular standards are clearly articulated to stakeholders, evident in syllabi, and posted on the Internet and in teacher classrooms. The elementary grades have established practices for articulation and alignment at the same grade level as well as above and below grade level. The elementary grades are implementing the school improvement interventions in their classrooms consistently and with fidelity to assist students in meeting learning expectations. Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: Establish practices for articulation and alignment of curriculum in the secondary grades. Implement school improvement interventions fully at the secondary level to assist students in meeting learning expectations. Initiate actions to review stakeholder survey results to improve the school climate to ensure that it is conducive to student learning.
Page 14 of 26
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Operational" and has met this
standard for accreditation.
Daegu American School only further develop the school improvement plan, but will also be necessary for effective teaching and learning. The school has collected survey data from parents, community members, teachers, and students. Although there was mention of a brief review of the results from the survey, a full analysis has not been conducted, and no actions have been taken or planned at this time. Graduation rates reflect that all students graduate on time. The school communicates the assessment results to stakeholders in a variety of ways. Teachers stated that they review and interpret individual student test data with their students and parents during parent-teacher conferences. Similarly, parents mentioned that they receive individual student information during parent conferences. Additionally, grade reports are sent to parents each quarter to show their childrens progress for each grade and subject area. The school uses a secure and safe student record system called GradeSpeed, an online system for student grades, class assignments, and other useful information. Parents reported that they like being able to go online to review their childrens assignments and grades. Additional records are kept in a student management system by office staff. Parents reported that information about overall school performance is not communicated in a clear way that is well understood and easily accessible. Many times parents have to search on the website for pieces of information that they can try to put together so as to draw inferences about school-wide performance and other measures of success. The school has access to the Department of Defense Educational Activity (DoDEA) results on the National Assessment of Education Progress (NAEP) for an overall comparison of all DoDEA schools to other states in the United States. These results are not intended for the purpose of comparing individual schools and, therefore, are not used in that manner. Parents and faculty expressed a desire to see how Daegu American School compares to other schools within the DoDEA community. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: Leadership and staff have begun the process to understand the data and plan to put a process in place for ongoing review. Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: Define clear performance targets for which the school will be assessing student progress on all assessments for the goals. Define a local assessment for the school improvement goal for mathematics.
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Emerging" and has not met this
standard for accreditation.
Page 16 of 26
Daegu American School interview groups conducted by the QAR team. Counselors begin working with career decisions in the elementary school. They design six-year plans for middle school students and four-year plans for high school students. A college prep course is offered. A college night is held annually, and all tenth and eleventh grade students are required to take the PSAT. The PSAT is available, but it is optional for ninth grade students. The special education staff is certified, and the special education population makes up 4% of the total school population. Records and reports are computerized and password protected for the CSC staff, as demonstrated online by the Educational Technologist. District leadership regularly monitors/audits special education practices, individualized education plans (IEPs), procedures, records, and provides training on EXCENT, the online software used for special education records and reports. The QAR team observed inclusive practices and co-teaching among the special education and regular education classroom teachers. Proper protocol is used in reviewing IEPs and special education files, which are located in locked file cabinets. In June 2009 a questionnaire was conducted with parents, students, and staff. The survey results in the profile do not include how many students were surveyed. The number of students surveyed is critical in understanding the data with regard to scope and analysis. Former students were surveyed, and 100% reported that they felt safe and that discipline problems were handled quickly and fairly at the school. The results at the elementary level indicate that 85% of students feel safe at school while 79% of students at the middle and high school level agreed that they feel safe at school. It will be necessary to carefully analyze the results of these surveys to fully understand what issues are present that led to these results. While these numbers include a majority of the students, there is still a significant number of students who state they do not feel safe. Additionally, while the team observed that an orderly environment exists in the school, the data are conflicting with what the team observed and what the survey results show with regard to whether students feel they are treated with respect and courtesy. The June 2009 survey reveals that 71% of elementary students feel that the school helps students get along with each other and that 83% of elementary students reported that "bullies do not bother me at school." At the middle and high school levels, only 65% of students surveyed reported that the students are treated with respect and courtesy, and only 60% of these students in this survey reported that they like the school. Once again, these numbers are lower than a school should have to ensure that the conditions are optimum for student learning. The 2009 survey results must be thoroughly and completely analyzed to ascertain whether the data reveal any steps that need to be taken to improve the school. Daegu American School has reached its capacity to serve any additional number of students. The team heard through interviews with the Base Commander and school leadership that there are plans to renovate additional existing buildings to house school programs for students in certain grade levels. It will be necessary to plan carefully for this expected increase in student population to ensure a seamless, smooth transition for students to ensure no disruption to the learning process. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: The guidance program provides strong support for students at all grade levels. Execution of the five-year facilities plan has generated nearly $2,000,000 in funding for repairs. AdvancED Quality Assurance Review Report Page 18 of 26
Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: Consolidate the supply and facilities staff reports to better articulate their respective reports and actions, possibly centralizing these reports for communication purposes. Develop a process for careful facilities planning if additional students are placed at Daegu American School. Analyze stakeholder survey results to address concerns regarding possible safety issues.
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Operational" and has met this
standard for accreditation.
Daegu American School participates in the military Town Hall meetings and Well Being Councils. The school capitalizes on the knowledge and skills of its stakeholders to enhance the work of the school through various activities. Through the stakeholder surveys, the school gathered information on ways the school can improve and disseminate school information. The school offers a College Night to help students gather information on their future education opportunities. The Advancement Via Individual Determination (AVID) program offers a Professional Shadow Day for the AVID students to gather information on careers, and individual teachers have guest speakers come into their rooms to enhance the students educational opportunities. The Career Practicum program works with the military and offers jobs for some high school students. One student works for the Armed Forces Network in the base newspaper office to highlight the school and its staff. Partnering with the military, the school participates in an Environmental Day at Camp Carroll to clean up the environment. The school has a volunteer program where volunteers come into the classroom, read to students, attend trips, and share their expertise as class guest speakers. The school works with the local Korean University through an intern program where Korean university students come into the school and partner with some of the local Korean schools to have an exchange program to view the differences and similarities between the two school cultures. Teachers send home syllabi and the curriculum standards to communicate the expectations for student learning and goals for improvement to its stakeholders. Individual teachers send home weekly packets with the curriculum standards that are being addressed in the classroom and how they relate to the classroom work that is occurring each week. Through the parent newsletter, individual teacher newsletters, parent conferences, and teacher/student/parent specific emails, communication is effective with the parents. Parents overwhelmingly shared that communication with teachers is exceptional. However, communication between the administration and Commanders should emphasize not only the various school activities but also the schools overall performance and the goals the school has set to reach its mission and vision. The administration sends multiple emails to parents each week, and the newsletter is sent to all stakeholders monthly. The office receives approximately ten emails weekly from parents and disseminates the information to the appropriate individual(s). The school promotes clear expectations for student learning by sharing with students and parents their course syllabi and rubrics; however, stakeholders interviewed were unable to align expectations for student learning to the schools vision. The school leadership maintains and implements a master calendar and daily class schedule that promotes and protects instructional time in an effort to maximize student/teacher contact. The school provides various brochures and pamphlets regarding the different programs that are offered at the school for the students. The Parent Handbook is given to all parents and has the school information included. Parents and students were fully involved from the very beginning of the CSI processes and took part in the goal and interventions. The general expectations for students are very evident in the schools displays of samples of the interventions being implemented and were corroborated through interviews with various students. Student behavior in the halls and classes demonstrates high character expectations. The school identifies the newsletter, GradeSpeed for grades four through twelve, Gaggle accounts, teacher emails, and the schools website as important tools used to provide information about student performance and the schools effectiveness. The parents responded enthusiastically regarding GradeSpeed and appreciated the benefits of the program and teacher input to stay informed of their students academic progress. The Information Center is working on a program where Spanish students are using video-taped reading books to be available for the elementary students to view as an enhancement to their regular class AdvancED Quality Assurance Review Report Page 20 of 26
Daegu American School readings. The counselors have a program called the Information Loop where email contact lists are made up by grade level to disseminate grade level information quickly to parents and students email accounts. The school newsletter highlights student work, student activities, health information, schedules, grade level reports, and PTO and AVID information. The newsletter is sent out to all stakeholders, the Military Command, the District Superintendent's Office, AFN, and is posted on the website. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: Various methods of communication are used between teachers and parents such as sending academic packets home correlating the lessons for the week with the curriculum standards and the school improvement goals which help create a greater understanding of the school's academic expectations. Teachers respond quickly to parent emails and communicate student progress in classes. The support that parents feel from the teachers is exceptional. They feel that the staff is very willing to listen to parents and work with the students and parents to solve any problems. Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: Provide additional information to the Military Command which addresses the schools focus on school improvement and overall performance. Disseminate comparison information on how the school is doing on TerraNova scores compared to other DoDEA schools. Publicize administration information to parents/stakeholders in a more evident manner; the impression of the parents was that they received most of the schools information from the individual teachers and not administration. Offer a separate New Student/Parent Orientation for elementary and secondary students. Students and parents felt overwhelmed with the massive amount of information presented at one combined orientation. Review how new students and continuing students are assigned on the buses to ensure new students are not intimidated.
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Operational" and has met this
standard for accreditation.
Daegu American School standards. Parents communicated through interviews that they are informed and participated in the process of continuous school improvement. Parents, as stakeholders, collaborated with teachers to complete the Capacity Assessment Instrument. Parents, who attended the School Advisory Committee meeting, received the stakeholder survey and Continuous School Improvement assessment results; however, the results were not communicated to all stakeholders. The results should be shared through parent newsletters and the website. Agendas of professional development training validated that opportunity is provided to all staff members and includes parents on the implementation of interventions. Due to the lack of additional professional development days, the school improvement leaders creatively implemented training of the faculty through the use of district-provided professional development days, faculty meetings, and after school meetings. A strong mentor program is available to train new teachers to understand, embrace, and implement the continuous school improvement goals and interventions. The agendas show differentiation for participants according to the level of implementation and understanding of the interventions. Artifacts from Looking at Student Work show that all staff participated in the reflection of student work. The process for evaluating the strength of the interventions is in the beginning stage. Teachers examine the implementation of the intervention and are finding its relevance across the curriculum. Through interviews and observations, students are readily using the interventions to organize thoughts and solve problems. Data should be collected to document the growth and progress of students in their comprehension of non-fiction text and problem solving. The end of the year Algebra assessment used in Grades 7-12 was not available after the first year of the Continuous Improvement Plan. The school reported that it had been advised to continue with the Terra Nova in both elementary and secondary and to use the McGraw Hill Final Math Assessment in Grades K6. The school improvement plan should include an additional local assessment for the mathematics goal in the secondary grades in order to triangulate the data for evaluation of its effectiveness. Some teachers, through interviews, reported that they use the results of the Looking at Student Work discussion to inform and change practice. Strengths - The team noted the following successful practices deserving of recognition: The elementary grades are implementing the interventions for both the reading and mathematics goals with consistency and fidelity. Students are using the school-wide mathematics interventions without teacher direction to solve problems. Opportunities - The team offers the following opportunities for improvement for consideration by the school: Select an additional local assessment for the mathematics goal at the secondary level to triangulate data. Collect, review, and analyze data regularly to assess student progress. Use the school improvement process as more than a process checklist. It should be used to guide decision-making on a continuous basis to promote on-going improvement and effectiveness for the school and in the classrooms.
Page 22 of 26
Finding: Daegu American School has earned the overall assessment level of "Operational" and has met this
standard for accreditation.
Page 23 of 26
Conclusion
The commendations and required actions in this report are designed to focus the school on those areas that will have the greatest impact on student performance and school effectiveness. While powerful in potential, the commendations and required actions only have meaning when acted upon by the school. The strength of this report lies in the school's commitment to using the findings to continuously improve. The key is action. The school is encouraged to use the report as a call to action, a tool to sustain momentum in the ongoing process of continuous improvement. The team identified required actions for improvement that the school will need to address. Following this review, the school will be required to submit a progress report summarizing its progress toward addressing the team's required actions. The Quality Assurance Review Team expresses appreciation to the School Administration, members of the professional staff, students, parents and other community representatives for their hospitality throughout the visit. The team wishes the school and its students much success in the quest for excellence through NCA-CASIDODEA accreditation with AdvancED.
Page 24 of 26
Appendix
Quality Assurance Review Team Members
Dr. Annette Bohling, Chair (AdvancED) Joe Simpson, Vice Chair (Wyoming Department of Education) Dr. Deborah Carlson, Team Member (Amelia Earhart Intermediate School) George Man, Team Member (Ernest J King High School) Ms. Naomi Mayer, Team Member (DoDEA Pacific Area Office) Shawn Knudsen, Team Member (Osan High School) Ms. Susan Nordell, Team Member (Kadena Elementary School)
Daegu American School The school establishes, implements, and monitors a continuous process of improvement that focuses on student performance.
Page 26 of 26