April 2001 Spot News
April 2001 Spot News
April 2001 Spot News
Vol 6, No. 2 April 2001 A publication of the East Tennessee Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists
on the Web at http://www.korrnet.org/etspj
Inside
GPC Menu. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . page 2
Delicious
SPOT NEWS
Page 2
Following is a the text of a letter sent to Richard Hollow, attorney for the Knoxville News-Sentinel, by Bonnie Riechert on behalf of ETSPJ. The East Tennessee Chapter, Society of Professional Journalists, wishes to go on record supporting your client, The Knoxville News-Sentinel, in a case currently pending before Knox County Criminal Court Judge Richard Baumgartner. Attorneys for a Knoxville man accused of killing a UT student five years ago have moved to bar the media from coverage of their clients murder trial. Javvor Marquis Thomas is accused in the 1995 shooting death of Ashley Browning Carden in the Christenberry Heights housing development. Attorneys for Thomas argued in a recent motion that extensive media coverage will prevent Thomas from receiving a fair trial. The Society of Professional Journalist supports the constitutional premise that the media have the right to publish information disseminated during the course of an open, public trial. We believe that truth is best served by open and public argument in our legal courts and that the motion to bar media coverage of this trial is unconstitutional, improper, and illegal. We are hopeful that the judicial hearing on Thursday will keep this trial open to the media and the public. Please contact us if we may provide any assistance in this important issue.
SPOT NEWS
February meeting
Page 3
A codes of ethics is a guide. Sometimes it helps. Sometimes it doesnt, said Brian Trauring, news director of WATE-TV, Channel 6, and a board member of the Radio Television News Directors Association. Trauring was one of four panelists from local media outlets who participated in the ETSPJ February 19 meeting, Media and Ethics in the New Age. Others were Lara Edge, managing editor of the Knoxville News-Sentinel; Bob Benz, director of online content and development for Scripps new media at Digital Crossing; and Margie Nichols, news director of WBIR-TV, Channel 10. Dorothy Bowles, professor of journalism at UT served as moderator. The panelists discussed the different approach taken by their groups in handling coverage of a Powell High School student who took a homemade bomb to the school. The newspaper and WATE-TV did not identify the student, while WBIR-TV identified him and showed his photograph. Nichols defended her stations position, saying, He put a school full of children in danger. Why are we protecting people doing adult things? There are absolutely no right and wrong answers, she added, because you can only do the best with the information you have at the time. In the case of her station, she said that it was not aware that the student had mental problems. Since the killing at Columbine, things are looked at differently, Trauring said. You must use special caution in dealing with children. Benz suggested that it seems easier to push ethical boundaries online. As an example, he told of WXYZ in Detroit, which streamed video of a hostage situation on its Web site. How do you handle live video on the Internet? he asked. Benz said that online should not be held to a double standard. The Internet is criticized and made out to be an unsafe place for children; yet those same pedophiles are placing ads in newspapers and magazines and hanging out at malls. Is advertising content on front pages a breech of ethics? Edge doesnt think so, but she has changed her views. The way she was raised in journalism, Every section front was sacred. But today, readers know an ad when they see it. Its not a breech of ethics because ethics is being honest, she said. Approximately 75 people attended the program on the UT campus.
From left, Lara Edge, Margie Nichols, Bob Benz, Brian Trauring
SPOT NEWS
Page 4