Statement & Arguments

Chapter

Statement & Arguments

24
Directions (1-27): In making decisions about important Arguments/rdZ%
questions, it is desirable to be able to distinguish between I. Yes, this is the only way to check the ever-
‘strong’ arguments and ‘weak’ arguments. ‘Strong’ arguments

re
increasing population of India.
are those which are both important and directly related to the
question. ‘Weak’ arguments are those which are of minor gk¡] Hkkjr dh yxkrkj c<+rh tula[;k dks fu;af=kr djus dk ;gh

nt
importance and also may not be directly related to the question ,dek=k rjhdk gSA
or may be related to a trivial aspect of the question.
II. No, this type of pressure tactic is not adopted
funsZ'k (1&27)%egÙoiw.kZ iz'uksa ds ckjs esa fu.kZ; djrs le; Bksl rdZ vkSj

Ce
by any other country in the world.
fucZy rdZ buesa tgk¡ rd mudk ml iz'u ls laca/ gks] izHksn dj lduk okaNuh;
gksrk gSA Bksl rdZ egÙoiw.kZ vkSj iz'u ls lh/s lacaf/r gksrs gSaA fucZyugha]
rdZ bl
os rjg dh nokc Mkyus dh uhfr fo'o esa fdlh Hkh ns'k
gksrs
gSa tks fdedegÙoiw.kZ vkSj iz'u ls lh/s lacaf/r ughagSaA
gks ldrs }kjk ugha viukbZ tkrh gSA
Each question below is followed by two arguments Statement/dFku%Should there be complete ban

ng
3.
numbered I and II. You have to decide which of on mining of coal in India?
the argument is a ‘strong’ argument and which is
a ‘weak’ argument. D;k Hkkjr esa dks;ys ds [kuu ij iw.kZ izfrca/ gksuk pkfg,\
lwpuk% uhps fn, x, izR;sd iz'u ds cknI nks hi
vkSjrdZ
II fn, x, gaSaA
vkidks r; djuk gS fd dkSu&lk rdZ Bksl rdZ gS vkSj dkSu&lk
Arguments/rdZ
I. rdZ
Yes, the present stock of coal will not last long
ac
fucZy rdZ gS\ if we continue mining at the present rate.
Give answer/mÙkj nhft,
gk¡] ;fn ekStwnk jÝrkj ls [kuu dk;Z pyrk jgk rks dks;ys dk
a. if only argument I is strong. /;fn dsoy rdZI Bksl gS
Co

orZeku HkaMkj vf/d fnu ugha pysxkA

b. if only argument II is strong. /;fn dsoy rdZII Bksl gS
II. No, we do not have alternate energy source of
c. if either I or II is strong. /;fn ;k rks rdZI ;k II Bksl gS sufficient quantity.
d. if neither 1 nor II is strong. /;fn u rks rdZ I u ghII Bksl gS ugha] gekjs ikl oSdfYid ÅtkZ Ïksr i;kZIr ek=kk esa ugha gSaA
ce

e. if both I and II are strong. /;fn rdZI vkSj II nksuksa Bksl gS

4. Statement@dFku% Should all the slums in big cities
1. Statement/dFku% Should sex determination test be demolished and the people living in such slums
during pregnancy be completely banned?
en

be relocated outside the city limits?

D;k xHkkZoLFkk ds nkSjku fyax fu/kZj.k ijh{k.k ij iwjh rjg ls izfrca/
D;k cM+s 'kgjksa dh lHkh >qXxh >ksaifM+;ksa dks fxjk fn;k tkuk pk
yxk fn;k tkuk pkfg,\
buesa jgus okys yksxksa dks 'kgj dh lhek ds ckgj clk;k tkuk pkfg,\
ud

Arguments/rdZ%
I. Yes, this leads to indiscriminate female foeticide Arguments/rdZ%
and eventually will lead to social imbalance. I. No, all these people will lose their home and
Pr

gk¡] blls eknk Hkwz.k dh vfoosdiw.kZ gR;k gksrh gS vkSj

livelihood and hence they should not be
varr% ;g lkekftd vlarqyu dh vksj ys tkrk gSA relocated./ ugha] ;s lHkh yksx vius ?kj vkSj thfodk [kks nsaxs]
II. No, people have a right to know about their blfy, mUgsa ubZ txg ugha clk;k tkuk pkfg,A
unborn child.
II. Yes, the big cities need more and more space
ugha
] yksxksa dks muds vtUes cPpksa ds ckjs esa tkuus dk vf/dkj gSA
to carry out development activities and hence
2. Statement/dFku% Should the parents in India in future these slums should be removed.
be forced to opt for only one child as against two or
many at present? gk¡] cM+s dks'kgjksa
fodkl xfrfof/;k¡ pykus ds fy, vf/
dkf/d
D;kHkfo"; esa Hkkjr esa orZeku ds nks ;k dbZ cPpksa dks tUe nsus dh NwV txgdsdh t:jr gS vkSj blfy, bu >ksifM+;ksa dks gVk
fo:¼ dsoy ,d cPps dks tUe nsus ds fy, ckè; fd;k tkuk pkfg,\ fn;k tkuk pkfg,A

Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd. 291

Statement & Arguments

5. Statement/dFku% Should there be an uniform for 8.Statement/dFku% Should the right of employees
students in colleges in India as in schools? to strike work be banned and the violators be
D;k Hkkjr esa egkfo|ky;ksa ds fo|kfFkZ;ksa dh Hkh fo|ky;ksa dh rjgpunished?
severely
fuf'pr iks'kkd gksuh pkfg,\ D;k deZpkfj;ksa ds gM+rky djus ds vf/dkj ij izfrca/ yxk;k tkuk
Arguments/rdZ% pkfg, vkSj mYya?ku djus okyksa dks dM+h ltk nh tkuh pkfg,\
I. Yes, this will improve the ambience of the colleges Arguments/rdZ%
as all the students will be decently dressed. I. Yes, this is the only way to ensure smooth
gk¡] ;g egkfo|ky;ksa ds ifjos'k esa lq/kj yk,xk D;ksafd lHkh
functioning of the organisations and prohibit the
fo|kFkhZ vPNh iks'kkd igus gq, gksaxsA

re
employees from taking the organizations for
II. No, college students should not be regimented granted.
and they should be left to choose their clothes. gk¡] ;g laxBukasa ds lqpk: lapkyu dks lqfuf'pr djus dk ,d

nt
ugha] egkfo|ky;ksa ds fo|kfFkZ;ksa dks vuq'kkluc¼ ugha fd;k tkukjkLrk gS vkSj ;g deZpkfj;ksa }kjk laxBu ls viuh dksbZ Hk
ek=k
pkfg, vkSj mUgsa euialn iks'kkd igu dj dkyst vkus dh NwVek¡x euok ysus dh izo`fr dks jksdsxkA

Ce
gksuh pkfg,A II. No, this will lead to autocratic organizational
6. Statement/dFku% Should the use of nuclear energy administration and the organisation may grossly
to generate electricity be completely banned in India? violate the basic rights of the employees.
D;k Hkkjr esa fo|qr mRiknu ds fy, ijek.kq ÅtkZ ds mi;ksx ij iw.kZr%
ugha] ;g,dra=kh; laxBukRed iz'kklu dh vksj ys tk,xk vkSj laxBu

ng
izfrca/ yxk fn;k tkuk pkfg,\ vius deZpkfj;ksa ds ewy vf/dkjksa dk iw.kZr% vfrØe.k djsaxsA
Arguments/rdZ% 9. Statement/dFku% Should all the level crossings on
hi
I. Yes, India does not have enough resources to
generate adequate level of electricity using
nuclear energy and should concentrate on
the railway lines in India be closed down and
flyovers or subways be built?
D;k Hkkjr esa jsy ykbuksa ij cus lHkh iQkVd can dj fn, tkus pkfg,
ac
harvesting its natural resources.
vkSj vksojfczt ;k lcos cuk, tkus pkfg,\
gk¡] ijek.kq ÅtkZ ds mi;ksx ls i;kZir Lrj rd fo|qr mRiknu ds
fy, Hkkjr ds ikl i;kZIr lalk/u ugha gS vkSj bls izkÑfrd lalk/Arguments/rdZ%
Co

uksa dk iz;ksx djus ij è;ku dsfUnzr djuk pkfg,A I. Yes, this will substantially minimise the
II. No, conventional energy sources are depleting number of accidents resulting into death of
rapidly in India and hence it should use large number of people.
nuclear energy to generate electricity. gk¡] blls ,slh nq?kZVukvksa dh la[;k esa dkiQh deh vk,xh ftuds
ugha]
Hkk
jr esa ÅtkZ ds ikjaifjd Ïksr rsth ls lekIr gksrs tk jgs gSa vkSjifj.kkeLo:i cM+h la[;k esa yksxksa dh e`R;q gksrh gSA
ce

blfy,] fo|qr mRiknu gsrq ijek.kq ÅtkZ dk mi;ksx djuk pkfg,A II. No, the government does not have sufficient
7. Statement@dFku% Should all the senior members fund to construct so many flyovers/subways.
en

of the Indian cricket team be replaced by ugha] brus lkjs vksojfczt@ lcos ds fuekZ.k ds fy, ljdkj ds ikl
energetic young players? i;kZIr fuf/ ugha gSA
D;k Hkkjrh; fØdsV Vhe ds lHkh ofj"B lnL;ksa dk ÅtkZoku~ ;qok dFku%
ud

10. Statement/ Should all the students up to

f[kykfM+;ksa }kjk izfrLFkkiu fd;k tkuk pkfg,\ standard five be exempted from taking final
Arguments/rdZ% examination every year?
Pr

I. No, the experience of the senior players will D;k d{kk ik¡p rd ds lHkh fo|kfFkZ;ksa dks izR;sd o"kZ vafre ijh{kk
be essential to excel in the forthcoming cSBus ls NwV nh tkuh pkfg,\
cricket World Cup. Arguments/rdZ%
ugha] vkxkeh fo'o di esa Js"B izn'kZu gsrq ofj"B f[kykfM+;ksa I. Yes, dsthis will considerably reduce the burden
vuqHko dh vko'drk gksxhA on the parents.
II. Yes, the young players should be brought in gk¡] blls vfHkHkkodksa dk cks> i;kZIr :i ls de gksxkA
now to groom them to take on the other teams II. Yes, the teachers should evaluate such students
in the forthcoming cricket World Cup. on continuous basis throughout the year.
keh fo'o di fØdsV esa vU; Vheksa dk lkeuk djus gsrq ;qokgk¡] f'k{kdksa dks ,sls fo|kfFkZ;ksa dk o"kZ Hkj fujarj ewY
gk¡] vkx
f[kykfM+;ksa dks rS;kj djus ds fy, mUgsa Vhe esa yk;k tkukdjuk pkfg,A
pkfg,A

292 Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd.

 Statement & Arguments

11. Statement/dFku% Should the teenagers be denied 14. Statement/dFku% Should all the universities in
access to the Internet? the country switch over to grade system rather
D;k baVjusV rd fd'kksjksa dh igq¡p dks fuf"k¼ fd;k tkuk pkfg,\
than awarding marks?
Arguments/rdZ% D;k ns'k ds lHkh fo'ofo|ky;ksa dks vad nsus dh O;oLFkk ds ctk, xzsM
I. Yes, most of the children, particularly the O;oLFkk 'kq: dj nsuh pkfg,\
teenagers, are found indulging in accessing Arguments/rdZ%
pornographic contents. I. Yes, with this the students falling in a particular
gk¡] vf/dka'k cPps] fo'ks"kdj fd'kksj] v'yhy fo"k;&oLrq ns[krs
range of marks can be treated on par.

re
gq, ik, x, gSA gk¡] blls vadksa dh ,d fuf'pr lhek ds Hkhrj vkus okys Nk=kksa
II. No, denying access to the Internet would mean dks ,d leku Lrj dk ekuk tk ldrk gSA

nt
denying access to a lot of useful information; II. No, it will be difficult to rank the students when
instead the access may be controlled. required to be short-listed.
ugha] baVjusV rd igqap ls oafpr j[kus dk vFkZ gksxkA cgqr&lh ugha] blls p;fur fo|kfFkZ;ksa dh lwph cukrs le; mudk LFkku

Ce
mi;ksxh tkudkjh ls oafpr djuk_ blds ctk, igqap dks fu;af=kr r; djus esa dfBukbZ gksxhA
fd;k tk ldrk gSA 15. Statement/dFku% Should there be a complete ban
12. Statement/dFku% Should computer education be on telecast of Adult movies on television?

ng
made a compulsory subject at school level by the D;k Vsyhfotu ij Ok;Ld fiQYeksa ds izlkj.k ij iw.kZ izfrca/ gksuk
Government? pkfg,\
D;k ljdkj }kjk fo|ky; ds Lrj ij daaI;wVj f'k{kk dks ,d vfuok;Z
Arguments/rdZ%
fo"k; cuk fn;k tkuk pkfg,\
Arguments/rdZ%
hi I. Yes, such movies adversely affect the children
and their interests are to be given top priority.
ac
I. No, it may be difficult to teach computers in the gk¡] ,slh fiQYesa cPpksa ij izfrdwy izHkko Mkyrh gSa vkSj muds
schools located in rural parts of the country. dks loksZPp izkFkfedrk nh tkuh pkfg,A
Co

ugha] ns'k ds xzkeh.k {ks=kksa esa fLFkr fo|ky;ksa esa II. daI;wVj i<+kuk
No, instead they can be telecast at certain fixed
dfBu gks ldrk gSA time when children are generally away from home.
II. Yes, it is difficult to function without computer ugha] bldh txg budk izlkj.k fdlh ,sls fu;r le; ij fd;k
in the era of modernisation. tk ldrk gS tc cPps vke rkSj ij ?kj ls ckgj gksrs gSaA
ce

gk¡] vk/qfudrk ds ;qx esa daI;wVj ds fcuk dke djuk eqf'dy gks
16. Statement @dFku% Will introduction of quota for
ldrk gSA backward classes in the institutes for higher
en

studies be the right move to do social justice?

13. Statement/dFku% Should hand baggage on all
international flights be permanently banned? D;k mPp f'k{kk ds laLFkkuksa esa fiNM+s oxks± ds fy, dksVk vkja
lkekftd U;k; djus dh lgh ;qfDr gksxh\
D;k lHkh varjkZ"Vªh; mM+kuksa esa gkFk ds FkSyksa ij LFkkbZ :i ls jksd yxk
ud

nh tkuh pkfg,\ Arguments/rdZ%

I. No, with this very few seats will be left for
Arguments/rdZ%
Pr

unreserved classes which is unfair to the

I. No, it causes a lot of inconvenience since items deserving candidates and particularly to those
of minimum requirement need to be carried who are economically backward.
during long- haul flights.
ugha] blls vukjf{kr oxks± ds fy, cgqr de LFkku cpasxs tks ;ksX;
ugha] blls cgqr vlqfo/k gksrh gS D;ksafd yach nwjh dks mM+kuksa esa
mEehn~okjksa] fo'ks"kdj vkfFkZd :i ls fiNMs+ fo|kfFkZ;ksa] d
U;wure t:jrksa dh phtsa ys tkuh iM+rh gSA vuqfpr gksxkA
II. Yes, it is necessary to ensure security of II. Yes, it is necessary to give them opportunities to
passengers on board.
rise upto the level of general category candidates.
gk¡] ;k=kk dj jgs ;kf=k;ksa dh lqj{kk lqfuf'pr djus ds fy, ;g gk¡] mUgsa volj iznku djuk vko';d gS rkfd os lkekU; oxZ ds
vko';d gSA mEehn~okjksa ds Lrj rd vk ldsaA

Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd. 293

Statement & Arguments

17. Statement/dFku% Should there be a complete ban 20. Statement/ dFku%Should there be a ban on
on bursting crackers including fireworks barring affiliation of students’ unions to political parties?
a few occasions in our country?
D;k Nk=k la?kksa ds jktuSfrd nyksa ls laca¼ gksus ij izfrca/ gk
D;k gekjs ns'k esa dqN voljksa dks NksM+dj vkfr'kckth lfgr iVk[ks
pkfg,\
pykus ij iw.kZ izfrca/ gksuk pkfg,A
Arguments/rdZ%
Arguments/rdZ%
I. Yes, the political parties take undue advantage
I. No, people should be allowed to enjoy on all occasions of the students’ unions to fulfil their own selfish
according to their interests and priorities. interests.

re
ugha] yksxksa dks lHkh voljksa ij viuh :fp;ksa vkSj izkFkfedrkvksa
gk¡] jktuSfrd ny vius LokFkZ ls tqMs fgrksa dks iwjk djus ds fy,
ds vuqlkj vkuan mBkus dh vuqefr gksuh pkfg,A Nk=k la?kksa dk vuqfpr ykHk mBkrs gSaA

nt
II. Yes, bursting crackers causes a lot of sound II. No, without the support of political parties
and air pollution which is hazardous to health. students’ unions will not be able to survive.
ugha]jktuSfrd
tks nyksa ds leFkZu ds fcuk Nk=k la?k ugha cp ik,axsA

Ce
gk¡] iVk[ks pykus ls cgqr T;knk èofu vkSj ok;q iznw"k.k gksrk gS
LokLF; ds fy, [krjukd gSA 21. Statement/ dFku% Should graduation be made
18. Statement/dFku% Should the use of calculators be minimum educational qualification for entry-level
jobs in any public sector organisation?
permitted in all university examinations?

ng
D;k fdlh Hkh ljdkjh {ks=k ds laxBu esa izos'k Lrj dh ukSdfj;ksa ds fy,
D;k fo'ofo|ky; dh lHkh ijh{kkvksa esa dSYdqysVjksa ds iz;ksx dh
Lukrd mikf/ dks U;wure 'kSf{kd vgZrk cuk;k tkuk pkfg,\
vuqefr nh tkuh pkfg,\
Arguments/rdZ%
Arguments/rdZ% hi
I. Yes, there is no need to do manual calculations
I. Yes, graduates always perform better than non
graduates by virtue of their higher level of
ac
in the era of computers; only the knowledge of education.
method should be given importance. gk¡] viuh mPp Lrjh; f'k{kk ds vk/kj ij xSj&Lukrdksa ds
eqdkcys Lukrdksa dk fu"iknu vPNk gksrk gSA
gk¡] daI;wVj ;qx es gkFk ls x.kuk,¡ djus dh t:jr ugha gS vkSj
Co

dsoy i¼fr ds Kku dks egRo fn;k tkuk pkfg,A II. No, there are quite a few people who cannot afford
to remain unemployed till the completion of
II. No, students should do the manual calculations
graduation and are capable of performing equally
so as to understand the concepts.
well as the graduate candidates.
ugha Nk=kksa ds gkFk ls x.kuk,¡ djuh pkfg, rkfd os vo/kj.kkvksa
ce

ugha] ,sls dbZ yksx gSa] tks viuh Lukrd mikf/ iwjh djus rd
dks le> ldsaA csjkstxkj ugha jg ldrs gSa vkSj Lukrd mEehn~okjksa ds leku g
19. Statement/ dFku% Should the city development vPNk dk;Z fu"iknu djus esa leFkZ gSA
en

authorities encourage construction of shopping malls 22. Statement/dFku% Should the examination bodies for
which may result into closure of smaller shops? all university examinations permit the use of
ud

D;k uxj fodkl izkf/dkj dks 'kkWfiax ekWyksa ds fuekZ.k dks izksRlkfgr
calculators?
djuk pkfg, ftlds ifj.kkeLo:i NksVh nqdkusa can gks tk,axh\D;k lHkh fo'ofo|ky; ijh{kk,a ysusokys ijh{kk fudk; dks dSYdqysVj
ds mi;skx dh vuqefr ns nsuh pkfg,\
Arguments/rdZ%
Pr

Arguments@rdZ%
I. Yes, in shopping malls one can get everything
under one roof at a cheaper rate. I. No, it is necessary for the students to know
the methods of manual calculation to make
gk¡ 'kWfiax ekWy esa lHkh phtsa ,d gh Nr ds uhps lLrh nj ij fey
their concepts clear.
ldrh gSaA ugha] viuh ladYiukvksa dks Li"V djus ds fy, fo|kfFkZ;ksa dks gkF
II. No, it will not be convenient for many people to ls x.kuk djus dks i¼fr dk Kku gksuk vko';d gSA
go to a shopping mall for purchases of day-to- II. Yes, manual calculations are no more required
day requirements. with extensive use of computers in all fields.
ugha] cgqr ls yksxksa ds fy, jkstejkZ dh [kjhnkjh ds fy, 'kkWfiax
gk¡] lHkh {ks=kksa esa dEI;wVjksa ds O;kid mi;ksx ds lkFk g
ekWy esa tkuk lqfo/ktud ugha gksxkA x.kuk djus dh vc vko';drk ugha gSA

294 Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd.

 Statement & Arguments

23. Statement/dFku% Should the knowledge of Hindi 26. Statement/dFku% Should all beggars on the roads in
language be made compulsory for all the the big cities in India be forcibly sent to villages?
employees of public sector organisations? D;k Hkkjr ds cM+s 'kgjksa esa lM+d ds fdukjs jgus okys lHkh fHk[k
dks tcju
D;k lkoZtfud {ks=k ds laxBuksa ds lHkh deZpkfj;ksa ds fy, fgUnh xk¡oksa esa Hkst nsuk pkfg,\
Hkk"kk
dk Kku vfuok;Z cuk;k tkuk pkfg,\ Arguments/rdZ%
Arguments/rdZ% I. No, this is grossly unfair and these people may
die of hunger if they are sent to villages.
I. Yes, it is necessary for dealing with people from
ugha] ;g loZFkk vuqfpr gS vkSj ;fn mUgsa xk¡so Hkst fn;k x;k r
the educationally backward strata of the society.
;s Hkw[kksa ej tk,axsA

re
gk¡] lekt ds 'kSf{kd :i ls fiNM+s oxZ ds yksxksa ds lkFk II.
O;ogkj
Yes, these people create a bad impression of our
djus gsrq ;g t:jh gSA country in the eyes of the foreigners who visit

nt
our country and hence should be removed.
II. No, it is not necessary for every employee to
gk¡] gekjs ns'k esa vkus okys fonsf'k;ksa dh utj esa bu yksxksa

Ce
have the knowledge of Hindi language.
dkj.k cqjk izHkko iM+rk gSA blfy, bUgs fudkyk tkuk pkfg,A
ugha] lHkh deZpkfj;ksa ds fy, fgUnh Hkk"kk dk Kku gksuk t:jh ugha gSA
27. Statement/dFku% Should all those who are found
24. Statement/dFku% Should it be made compulsory guilty of committing homicide or abetting
for all the private sector organisations to reserve homicide be either given capital punishment or

ng
quota for socially backward classes? kept in jail for the entire life?

D;k uhft {ks=k ds lHkh laxBuksa ds fy, ;g vfuok;Z cuk;k tkukD;k ekuogR;k ;k ekuogR;k ds nq"izs"k.k ds fy, nks"kh ik, tkusokys
pkfg,
lHkh vijkf/;ksa dks ;k rks e`R;qnaM fn;k tkuk pkfg, ;k reke mez tsy
fd lkekftd :i ls fiNM+s oxks± ds fy, dksVk dk vkj{k.k djsa\
Arguments/rdZ%
hi esa j[kk tkuk pkfg,\
Arguments/rdZ%
ac
I. No, the private sector should not be governed I. Yes, only such severe punishments will make
by the Government rules. people refrain from committing such heinous
ugha] futh {ks=k ds laxBuksa dks ljdkjh fu;eksa }kjk 'kkflracts
ughaand the society will be more safe.
Co

fd;k tkuk pkfg,A gk¡] ,slh dBksj ltk ls gh yksx ,sls Hk;kud ÑR; djus ls ckt
vk,axs vkSj lekt vf/d lqjf{kr gksxkA
II. Yes, private sector organisations should also
II. No, those who are repentant for the crime they
contribute in upliftment of socially backward classes.
committed should be given a chance to lead a
ce

gk¡] uhth {ks=k ds laxBuksa dks Hkh lkekftd :i ls fiNM+s oxks±

normalds life outside the jail.
mRFkku esa ;ksxnku nsuk pkfg,A ugha] tks vius }kjk fd, x, xqukg ds fy, i'pkrki djrs gSa mUgsa
tsy ls ckgj lkekU; thou thus dk ,d volj fn;k tkuk pkfg,A
en

25. Statement/dFku% Should the women be advised

not to travel alone at night in view of the increasing 28. Statement/dFku: Should the oil companies be
incidences of rape and sexual abuse? allowed to fix the price of petroleum products
ud

depending on market conditions?

D;k cykRdkj vkSj ;kSu mRihM+u dh c<+rh gqbZ ?kVukvksa ds dkj.k
D;k rsy daifu;ksa dks isVªksfy;e mRiknksa dk ewY; cktkj dh fLFkf
efgykvksa dks jkr esa vdsys ;k=kk ugha djus dh lykg nh tkuh ds
pkfg,\
vk/kj ij r; djus dh vuqefr nsuh pkfg,\
Pr

Arguments/rdZ% Arguments/rdZ:
I. No, instead the Government should take I. Yes, this is the only way to make the oil com-
measures to control such incidences. panies commercially viable.
gk¡] ;gh ,dek=k rjhdk gS ftlls rsy daifu;ksa dks okf.kfT;d
ugha] blds LFkku ij ljdkj dks ,slh ?kVukvksa dks fua;f=kr djus
:i esa liQy cuk;k tk ldsA
ds mik; djus pkfg,A
II. No, this will put additional burden on the
II. Yes, it is difficult even for the police department retail prices of essential commodities and
to control such cases. will cause lot of hardships to the masses.
ugha] blls vke yksxksa dks cgqr dfBukbZ gksxh D;ksafd bl vuqe
gk¡] iqfyl foHkkx ds fy, Hkh ,slh ?kVukvksa ij fu;a=k.k j[kuk
eqf'dy gSA ls vko';d oLrqvksa ds [kqnjk dherksa ij vfrfjDr cks> vk,xkA

Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd. 295

Statement & Arguments

29. Statement/dFku: Should capital punishment be 32. Statement/dFku: Should the reservation of jobs
abolished altogether in India? for weaker sections of the society be extended
D;k e`R;q n.M Hkkjr esa iwjh rjg ls lekIr dj nsuk pkfg,\ to the private sectors also?
Arguments/rdZ: D;k futh {ks=kksa es Hkh detksj oxks± ds fy, vkj{k.k dks c<+kok f
I. Yes, countries belonging to European tkuk pkfg,\
Union have abolished capital punishment. Arguments/rdZ:
gk¡] ;wjksih; la?k ds lHkh ns'kksa us e`R;q n.M lekIr djI.fn;kNo,
gSAthe management of the private sector
II. No, this is one way to instill fear in the mind undertakings would not agree to such

re
of the criminals which will restrain them compulsions.
from committing heinous crimes. ugha] futh {ks=k dk izca/u bl iz'u ij rS;kj ugha gksxkA

nt
ugha] vijk/h ds eu esa Hk; cuk, j[kus dk ,d rjhdk gS] tksII. Yes, this will significantly improve the
mUgsa t?kU; vijk/ djus ls jksdrk gSA economic conditions of the weaker sections

Ce
of the society.
30. Statement/dFku: Should the persons below the
gk¡] ;g detksj oxks± dh vkfFkZd fLFkfr esa dkiQh gn rd
age of 18 years be allowed to join armed forces?
lq/kj yk;sxkA
D;k 18 o"kZ ls de mez ds yksxksa dks lsuk esa HkrhZ djuk pkfg,\
33. Statement/dFku: Should liquor companies be

ng
Arguments/rdZ: held liable for alcohol related accidents caused
I. No, persons below the age of 18 do not have by underage youth?/D;k de mez ds ;qokvksa }kjk dh tkus
hi
physical and mental maturity to shoulder
such burden.
okyh 'kjkc ls tqM+h nq?kZVukvksa ds fy, 'kjkc daifu;ksa dks ftEe
Bgjk;k tkuk pkfg,\
ac
ugha] 18 o"kZ ls de mez ds yksx ml rjg dk Hkkj mBkus ds fy,
Arguments/ rdZ:
ekufld ,oa 'kkjhfjd :i ls rS;kj ugha jgrs gSaA I. Ye s, the y do not adve rtise the
Co

II. Yes, this will help the country to develop consequences of consuming alcohol.
such armed forces which will serve the gk¡] os 'kjkc ihus ds ifj.kkeksa dk foKkiu ugha nsrsA
country for a longer time. II. No, fake identity cards and licenses are
gk¡] ;g ,sls lSfudksa dks rS;kj djus esa enn djsxk] tks yacs le; easily available to the youth allowing them
ce

rd ns'k dh lsok djasaxsA to obtain alcohol.

31. Statement/ dFku: Should all the surrogate ugha] tkyh igpku i=k vkSj ykblsal vklkuh ls fey tkrs gaS
en

adve rtise me nts re le ase d by companie s ftlls ;qokvksa dks 'kjkc fey tkrh gSA
manufacturing tobacco products be banned? 34. Statement/dFku: Should there be legislation to
ensure
D;k rEckdw cukus okyh daifu;ksa }kjk izfrfuf/Ro izpkj ij jksd yxkuk that children provide maintenance to
ud

their aging parents/D;k ;g lqfu'pr djus ds fy, dkuwu

pkfg,\
gksuk pkfg, fd cPps cw<+s ekrk&firk dks xqtkj HkRrk nsa\
Arguments/rdZ:
Pr

Arguments/rdZ:
I. Yes, this is the only way to prevent the use
I. Yes, the magnitude of the problem of abuse
of tobacco products by people.
and neglect of aged parents by their
gk¡] ;gh rjhdk gS] yksxksa dks rEckdw iz;ksx ls jksdus ds immediate
fy,A family is growing/gk¡] cw<+s ekrk&firk
II. No, these companies spend a lot of money dh muds utnhdh ifjokj }kjk mis{kk vkSj nqO;Zogkj dh leL;k
for preparing these advertisements and dk ifj.kke c<+ jgk gSA
hence they should not be banned.
II. No, the cost of implementing this legislation
ugha] ;s daifu;ka bu izpkjksa dks rS;kj djus es dkiQh [kpZ djrh
will be too much/ugha] bl dkuwu dks fØ;kfUor djus
gSaaA blfy, bu ij jksd ugha yxkuk pkfg,A dh ykxr cgqr vf/d gksxhA

296 Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd.

 Statement & Arguments

35. Statement/dFku: Should the funding for National 38. Statement/dFku: Should the admission to pro-
Space Research programmes be diverted to fessional courses in India be given only on merit
addressing the needs of the poor? without any concession to any particular group
students? D;k Hkkjr esa izksiQs'kuy dkslksZa esa izos'k fo|kfF
D;k jk"Vªh; varfj{k vuqla/ku dk;ZØeksa ds fy, nh tk jgh fuf/ dksofxjhcksa
dh t:jrksa dks iwjk djus ds fy, [kpZ dj nsuk pkfg,\ ds fdlh fo'ks"k lewg dks dksbZ fj;k;r fn, fcuk fliQZ eSfjV ij fn;k
Arguments:/rdZ% tkuk pkfg,\
I. Yes, our budget for space research is lower Arguments/rdZ:
than that of other countries. So we can not I. Yes, this will improve the quality of the pro-
compete with them and hence it can be put fessionals as they will be able to complete

re
to better use in schemes to benefit the poor. the courses successfully.
gk¡]
gekjk varfj{k vuqla/ku dk ctV vU; ns'kksa ds ctV ls de gk¡] blls Nk=kksa dh xq.koÙkk esa lq/kj vk,xk] D;ksafd ;s dkslk

nt
liQykriwoZd iwjk dj ldsaxsA
gksrk gSA blfy, ge muls izfrLi/kZ ugha dj ldrs vkSj mls xjhcksa
esa ykHk okyh ;kstukvksa ds csgrj dke ij yxk;k tk ldrk gSA
II. No, this will keep large number of socially

Ce
II. No, communication satellite s help to and economically backward students out
provide services like telemedicine. So of the reach of the professional courses.
people in rural areas can get access to the ugha] blls lkekftd vkSj vkfFkZd :i ls fiNM+s gq, vf/dka'k
best professional advice/ ugha] lapkj mixzg fo|kFkhZ izksiQs'kuy dkslksZa ls oafpr jg tk;axsA
VsyhesfMflu tSlh lsok,a nsus esa enn djrs gSaA blfy, xzkeh.k dFku: Should the State Govts. be al-

ng
39. Statement/
bykdksa ds yksxksa dk csgrjhu is'ksoj lykg fey ldrh gSAlowed to retain major shares of the central taxes
36. Statement/dFku: Should the Govt. force private collected in the respective States?

cricket matches involving the national team

with the Govt. owned national network?
hi
broadcasters to share coverage of international D;k jkT; ljdkj lacaf/r jkT;ksa esa olwys x, dsUæh; djksa ds izeq[k
fgLls dks j[kus dh vuqefr nh tkuh pkfg,\
Arguments/rdZ:
ac
D;k ljdkj dks futh izlkjdksa ij mu varjkZ"Vªh; fØdsV eSpksa I. ftuesa
No, the Central Govt. should receive the
jk"Vªh; Vhe 'kkfey gks] ds dojst dks ljdkj ds LokfeRo okys jk"Vªh;
major share as most of the developmental
usVodZ ds lkFk 'ks;j djus ij ckf/r djuk pkfg,\
Co

programmes are funded by the Central Govt.

Arguments/rdZ: ugha] izeq[k fgLlk dsUæ ljdkj dks feyuk pkfg, D;ksafd T;knkrj
I. Yes, people without access to satellite tele- fodkl dk;ZØeksa dks fuf/ dsUæ ljdkj }kjk nh tkrh gSA
vision can get to see their national team play-
II. Yes, most of the States Govts. are short of
ing in major international tournaments.
ce

funds and they badly need more funds.

gk¡] tks yksx lsVsykbV ls tqM+s yksx Vsyhfotu ugha ns[k ikrs gSa os izeq[k
gk¡] T;knkrj jkT; ljdkjksa ds ikl fuf/ dh deh gS vkSj mUgsa
varjkZ"Vªh; VwukZesaVksa esa jk"Vªh; Vhe dks [kyrs gq, ns[k ldrs gaSA
fuf/ dh csgn t:jr gSA
en

II. No, private broadcasters will take legal ac-

tion against the Govt. 40. Statement/ dFku: Should all the private sector
banks be immediately merged with the public
ugha] futh izlkjd ljdkj ds f[kykiQ dkuwuh dkjokbZ djsaxsA
ud

sector banks?
37. Statement/dFku: Should loss incurring Govt.
D;k futh {ks=k ds lHkh caSdks dk rRdky lkoZtfud {ks=k ds cSadk
airlines be merged into a single entity?
foy; dj fn;k tkuk pkfg,\
D;k ?kkVk nsus okyh ljdkjh ,;jykbuksa dk foy; djds mUgsa ,d bdkbZ
Pr

Arguments/rdZ:
cuk nsuk pkfg,\
I. No, the private sector banks are profit making
Arguments/rdZ:
entities and hence they should not be merged.
I. Yes, the merger will poor their resources allow-
ing them to expand their services and be more ugha] futh {ks=k ds cSad ykHk dekus okyh laLFkk,a gSa blfy
competitive with private and foreign airlines. mudk foy; ugha fd;k tkuk pfg,A
gk¡] foy; ls muds lalk/u bdV~Bs gks tk;asxs vkSj mudhII.
lsok,a
Yes, this will safeguard the hard earned
c<+ ldsaxh vkSj os futh vkSj fiQj os fons'kh ,;jykbuksa lsmoney of the customers and their interests
izfrLi/kZ dj ldsaxhA will be secured.
II. No, the merger will result in loss of jobs. gk¡] blls xzkgdksa dks esgur ls dek;k gqvk /u lqjf{kr gks
ugha] foy; ls ukSdfj;k¡ tk,axhA tk,xk vkSj muds fgr lqjf{kr jgsaxsA

Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd. 297

Statement & Arguments

Answer Key

1. (a) 5. (a) 9. (e) 13. (a) 17. (b) 21. (d) 25. (d) 29. (b) 33. (b) 37. (a)
2. (d) 6. (b) 10. (d) 14. (e) 18. (d) 22. (c) 26. (e) 30. (a) 34. (a) 38. (b)
3. (b) 7. (a) 11. (e) 15. (d) 19. (b) 23. (a) 27. (e) 31. (d) 35. (b) 39. (d)
4. (b) 8. (b) 12. (b) 16. (e) 20. (d) 24. (b) 28. (b) 32. (b) 36. (a) 40. (d)

re
nt
Ce
ng
hi
ac
Co
ce
en
ud
Pr

298 Rakesh Yadav Readers Publication Pvt. Ltd.