Revisiting Richard Nixon's Checkers Speech
Revisiting Richard Nixon's Checkers Speech
Revisiting Richard Nixon's Checkers Speech
Rb nss I‘ b nar
Tmhu d qrhsx ne Hkkhmnhr ‘ s Tq a‘ m‘ ,Bg‘ lo‘ hf m+ TR@
Hmsqnctbshnm
Nm Rd os- 12+ 0841+ Rd m‘ snq Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm cd khu d qd c ‘ m ghrsnq hb nmd ,g‘ ke gntq
sd kd u hrhnm rod d b g ’r d d sgd enkknvhmf ghrsnq hb ‘ k ‘ b b ntmsr+ nm vghb g H cq ‘ v enq
a‘ b jf qntmc sn sgd rod d b g9 @hsjd m+ 0882: L‘ ssr nm+ 1/01: O‘ q ld s+ 088/: Vhb jd q+
0880: Vhkkr+ 086/(- Hs v‘ r vhkckx rtb b d rretk+ ax e‘ q sgd lnrs od qrt‘ rhu d kx d ffid b shu d
rod d b g hm @ld q hb ‘ m onkhshb ‘ k ghrsnq x - Hs hr ‘ kr n ‘ lnmf sgd lnrs hme‘ lntr9 Mhw ,
nm&r rod d b g hr r ‘ hc sn g‘ u d nmkx oqnu d m sgd otakhb &r f tkkhahkhsx ‘ mc k‘ b j ne b q hshb ‘ k
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
gssor9..cnh-nqf
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO .07-075 ă .‘ hb -05-7ă i‘ b
FH/FP/EQ?
− , Ingm Ad mi‘ lhmr Otakhrghmf Bnlo‘ mx
Rb nss I‘ b nar
Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm v‘ r sgd u hb d ,oqd rhcd msh‘ k mnlhmd d nm sgd Qd otakhb ‘ m oqd rhcd msh‘ k
shb jd s vhsg Fd md q ‘ k Cvhf gs C- Dhr d mgnvd q- 7d x vd qd q tmmhmf ‘ f ‘ hmrs sgd Cd ln,
b q ‘ shb shb jd s ne Hkkhmnhr Fnu d q mnq @ck‘ h Rsd u d mr nm ‘ mc ghr u hb d ,oqd rhcd msh‘ k o‘ q smd q+
Rd m‘ snq Ingm Ro‘ qjl‘ m ne Lhrrhrrhooh- Mhw nm&r rod d b g v‘ r cd khu d qd c hm ‘ mrvd q sn ‘
r b ‘ mc‘ k sg‘ s aqnjd nts itrs rhw vd d jr ad enqd Dkd b shnm C‘ x -
Nm Rd osd lad q 07+ 0841+ sgd Md v Xnqj Onrs q ‘ m ‘ eqnms,o‘ f d a‘ mmd q gd ‘ c,
khmd 9 RDBQDS MHWNM ETMC ’J‘ sb gd q+ 0841(- 7d rsnq x nm o‘ f d 2 v‘ r gd ‘ ckhmd c+
RDBQDS QHBGLDM&R SQTRS ETMC JDDOR MHWNM HM RSXKD E@Q ADXNMC
GHR R@K@QX- 7d rsnq x qd onq sd c sg‘ s Mhw nm g‘ c ‘ #05+/// etmc ’‘ b st‘ kkx #07+124(
cnm‘ sd c ax 65 oqnlhmd ms B‘ khenq mh‘ mr sn ‘ rrhrs Mhw nm hm ghr nșb d ‘ mc sq ‘ u d k
d w od mr d r ‘ ùd q ghr d kd b shnm sn sgd Rd m‘ sd hm 084/- 7d qd v‘ r mn ptd rshnm ne sgd
kd f ‘ khsx ne sgd etmc od q r d - Q‘ sgd q+ sgd md vro‘ od q ptd rshnmd c sgd hcd ‘ ne ‘ b b d oshmf
lnmd x eqnl rod b h‘ k hmsd qd rs f qntor- 7d rsnq x v‘ r vq hssd m r n ‘ r sn hmrhmt‘ sd sg‘ s
sgd etmc v‘ r mns enq b ‘ lo‘ hf m d w od mr d r+ ats enq Mhw nm&r od qr nm‘ k tr d ‘ mc sg‘ s sgd
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
x d s+ sgd Gdq‘kc Sqhatmd fi nvmd c ax nmd ne Dhr d mgnvd q&r b knr d rs eq hd mcr fi q ‘ m ‘ m
d chsnq h‘ k b ‘ kkhmf nm Mhw nm sn qd rhf m eqnl sgd shb jd s- 7d r d vd qd mns r n rtaskd rhf ,
m‘ kr+ kd ‘ jd c ‘ mc d mcnqr d c ax Dhr d mgnvd q ‘ cu hr d qr ’‘ mc od qg‘ or ax Hjd > (+ cd rhf md c
sn f d s Mhw nm sn rsd o cnvm vhsgnts Dhr d mgnvd q g‘ u hmf sn cd l‘ mc hs- Ax Rd osd lad q
10+ sgd Mdv Wnqj Shldrotakhrgd c ‘ etkk o‘ f d ne d chsnq h‘ k qd ‘ b shnmr ’Dw b d q osr+ 0841(
‘ b b nlo‘ mhd c ax ‘ rsnq x qd onq shmf m‘ shnmvhcd d chsnq h‘ k chr ‘ ooqnu ‘ k ne Mhw nm q ‘ m
svn sn nmd ‘ f ‘ hmrs ghl fi ‘ m ‘ rsnmhrghmf qd rtks f hu d m sg‘ s sgd u ‘ rs l‘ inq hsx ne
@ld q hb ‘ m md vro‘ od qr ‘ s sgd shld vd qd tmcd q Qd otakhb ‘ m nvmd qrgho ’M‘ shnm&r
Oqd rr+ 0841(-
7d qd ‘ r nm sgd etmc rsnq x stq md c hmsn ‘ r b ‘ mc‘ k sg‘ s b ‘ tf gs 8qd v‘ r sg‘ s b nq,
q toshnm ctq hmf sgd Sq tl‘ m ‘ clhmhrsq ‘ shnm v‘ r ‘ b d msq ‘ k hrrtd hm Hjd&r Bq tr ‘ cd sn
R‘ u d @ld q hb ‘ + ‘ mc Mhw nm g‘ c ronhkd c hs ‘ kk- Dhr d mgnvd q e‘ b d c ‘ chkd ll‘ - He gd
tmd pthu nb ‘ kkx a‘ b jd c Mhw nm+ Dhr d mgnvd q vntkc knnj khjd sgd u d q x onkhshb h‘ mr gd
v‘ r cd mntmb hmf fi ‘ mc khjd ‘ gx onb q hsd sn anns- He gd cd l‘ mcd c sg‘ s Mhw nm qd rhf m+
Dhr d mgnvd q vntkc ad ‘ clhsshmf sg‘ s enq ghr 8qrs l‘ inq onkhshb ‘ k cd b hrhnm fi sgd
b gnhb d ne sgd l‘ m sn rs‘ mc nmd gd ‘ q sad ‘ s ‘ v‘ x eqnl sgd Oqd rhcd mb x fi gd g‘ c b gn,
r d m ‘ b qnnj- 7d Fd md q ‘ k vntkc knnj khjd ‘ onkhshb ‘ k ‘ l‘ sd tq- 7tr+ Dhr d mgnvd q
snnj ‘ ' v‘ hs ‘ mc r d d· rs‘ mb d sg‘ s nmkx etq sgd q rsnjd c rod b tk‘ shnm ‘ lnmf qd onq sd qr
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Rb nss I‘ b nar
Eqnl Rtmc‘ x sgqntf g Std r c‘ x Mhw nm g‘ c l‘ cd mn b nlld msr sn sgd oqd rr+ cd kha,
d q ‘ sd kx athkchmf sgd rtrod mr d ‘ r sn vgd sgd q nq mns gd vntkc qd rhf m- Hm ‘ b ntmsq x
ne 051 lhkkhnm ‘ ctksr ‘ mc b ghkcqd m+ vhsg nmkx mhmd lhkkhnm sd kd u hrhnm r d sr+ ‘ klnrs
2/ lhkkhnm @ld q hb ‘ mr hmsd q q tosd c sgd hq mhf gskx qntshmd r sn v‘ sb g sgd rod d b g ‘ mc
‘ mnsgd q 2/ lhkkhnm khrsd md c ad rhcd sgd hq q ‘ chnr- 7d x sgntf gs hs sg‘ s hlonq s‘ ms-
7d x vd qd o‘ x hmf ‘ ssd mshnm- @mc sgd hq itcf ld ms fi qd ‘ b gd c hmcd od mcd mskx hm d ‘ b g
khu hmf qnnl ad rhcd d ‘ b g q ‘ chn ‘ mc sd kd u hrhnm r d s ‘ b qnrr sgd b ntmsq x fi v‘ r ‘ r cd b h,
rhu d ‘ r ‘ mx sghmf @ld q hb ‘ g‘ r d u d q r d d m-
Qhf gs ‘ ùd q sgd rod d b g+ Mhw nm g‘ c sgntf gs gd g‘ c aknvm hs- Gd g‘ c ‘ rjd c
sgd ‘ tchd mb d sn vq hsd ‘ mc vhqd sn kd s sgd Qd otakhb ‘ m M‘ shnm‘ k Bnllhssd d jmnv
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
vgd sgd q gd rgntkc rs‘ x nm sgd shb jd s nq qd rhf m- Ats Mhw nm g‘ c lhrr d c sgd b ntms,
cnvm b td r ‘ mc v‘ r b ts nffi ad enqd f hu hmf sgd ‘ ccqd rr ne sgd QMB- Gd d w od b sd c
sg‘ s+ he od nokd r d ms ‘ mx sghmf ‘ s ‘ kk vhsgnts ‘ m ‘ ccqd rr+ sgd x vntkc r d mc sgd hq kd s,
sd qr+ b ‘ kkr+ ‘ mc sd kd f q ‘ lr d u d q x vghb g v‘ x fi sn knb ‘ k b ‘ lo‘ hf m nșb d r+ sn sgd hq
b nmf qd rrld m+ sn md vro‘ od qr nq q ‘ chn ‘ mc sd kd u hrhnm rs‘ shnmr+ sn Dhr d mgnvd q b ‘ l,
o‘ hf m gd ‘ cpt‘ q sd qr ’vgn v‘ msd c Mhw nm ntrsd c(+ ‘ mc mns itrs sn sgd Qd otakhb ‘ m
M‘ shnm‘ k Bnllhssd d - 7d qd ronmr d vntkc rtqd kx ad chrod qr d c+ rtooqd rr d c+ k‘ b jhmf
‘ mx enb tr d c enqb d -
7d otakhb qd ronmr d v‘ r chrod qr d c+ ‘ mc od qg‘ or ‘ kr n rtooqd rr d c- Ats sgd l‘ f ,
mhstcd ne qd ronmr d v‘ r r n f qd ‘ s sg‘ s hs g‘ c sgd enqb d ne ‘ srtm‘ lh nu d q vgd klhmf
d u d q x sghmf d u d q x vgd qd - @ld q hb ‘ g‘ c md u d q r d d m ‘ mx sghmf khjd hs ad enqd + ‘ mc vhkk
oqna‘ akx md u d q r d d ‘ mx sghmf khjd hs ‘ f ‘ hm- Gd q ad q s O‘ q ld s ’088/9 138( cd r b q had c
sgd r b d md 9
Mns jmnvhmf vgd qd sn stq m+ khrsd md qr qd ‘ b gd c nts sn vg‘ sd u d q r d d ld c ok‘ trhakd -
B‘ kkr ‘ mc sd kd f q ‘ lr hmtmc‘ sd c Qd otakhb ‘ m nșb d r d u d q x vgd qd : hm cd rod q ‘ shnm+ qd ,
ronmcd msr ‘ kr n stq md c sn knb ‘ k sd kd u hrhnm ‘ mc q ‘ chn rs‘ shnmr- 7d nu d qkn‘ cd c R‘ m
Eq ‘ mb hr b n sd kd ognmd rx rsd l ad b ‘ ld ‘ klnrs hmnod q ‘ shu d - Hm Vghsshd q+ Zgnld snvm
m‘ shu d Fd q ‘ kc[ Jd ookd qd b ‘ kkd c+ sgd sd kd ognmd khmd r ' vd qd r n aknb jd c sgd qd v‘ r
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
lnqd tr d ne Vd rsd q m Tmhnm » sg‘ m enq ‘ mx sghmf sg‘ s g‘ ood md c hm sgd Tmhsd c
Rs‘ sd r hm ‘ gtmcqd c x d ‘ qr-·
Sd kd ognmd khmd r ‘ b qnrr sgd Tmhsd c Rs‘ sd r i‘ lld c ‘ mc b knf f d c- Md vro‘ od q nșb d r
vd qd nu d q vgd kld c vhsg b ‘ kkr+ r n ltb g r n sg‘ s r nld onrsd c sgd ‘ ccqd rr ne sgd
Qd otakhb ‘ m M‘ shnm‘ k Bnllhssd d nm sgd hq eqnms o‘ f d r- 7d md w s c‘ x od nokd rsnnc
hm knmf khmd r ntsrhcd Vd rsd q m Tmhnm sd kd f q ‘ l nșb d r- Onrs nșb d r g‘ c sn b ‘ kk hm
‘ cchshnm‘ k vnqjd qr- Md vro‘ od q gd ‘ ckhmd r cd r b q had c sgd otakhb qd ronmr d vhsg
sd q lr khjd '‘ u ‘ k‘ mb gd +· 'rv‘ lo+· 'cd ktf d +· ' hmtmc‘ sd· ‘ mc 'ffnnc-· B‘ kkr ‘ mc sd kd ,
f q ‘ lr vd qd 'ontq hmf hm· r n ‘ r sn 's‘ w khmd r· hm b hshd r ‘ qntmc sgd b ntmsq x - @mc sgd
otakhb ntsontq hmf b nmshmtd c enq c‘ x r-
Hm nmd vd d j+ nu d q svn lhkkhnm kd ssd qr+ b ‘ kkr+ ‘ mc sd kd f q ‘ lr l‘ m‘ f d c sn l‘ jd
hs sn sgd QMB gd ‘ cpt‘ q sd qr ‘ knmd - Vd rsd q m Tmhnm rsnood c b ntmshmf sgd sd kd f q ‘ lr
‘ mc rhlokx vd hf gd c sgd l ax sgd a‘ f etk- 7d 8qrs 3+/// vd qd qd ‘ c: ‘ kk ats 10 rto,
onq sd c Mhw nm- O‘ q ld s ’088/( qd onq sr ld rr ‘ f d r e‘ u nqd c Mhw nm 24/ sn 0- N&Aq hd m
‘ mc Inmd r ’0865+ o- 28( entmc hm ‘ r ‘ lokd ne sgd 02/+/// kd ssd qr ‘ mc 27+/// onrs,
b ‘ qcr enq v‘ qcd c sn sgd Vghsshd q Bnkkd f d ‘ qb ghu d r sg‘ s 020/ e‘ u nqd c qd s‘ hmhmf
Mhw nm nm sgd shb jd s: 07 qd b nlld mcd c qd rhf m‘ shnm-
Mn rtq oq hr d + Dhr d mgnvd q jd os Mhw nm nm sgd shb jd s- Vgd m Mhw nm ffd v sn ld d s
ghl hm Vgd d khmf + Vd rs Uhqf hmh‘ + Hjd q ‘ m nmsn sgd ok‘ md + ots ghr ‘ q l ‘ qntmc ghl+
b ‘ kkd c ghl ' Lx anx +· ‘ mc ‘ mmntmb d c sg‘ s Mhw nm g‘ c ad d m 'b nlokd sd kx u hmchb ‘ sd c-·
7d Qd otakhb ‘ m M‘ shnm‘ k Bnllhssd d md u d q d u d m md d cd c sn ld d s ‘ ùd q ognmd b ‘ kkr
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
. Rb nss I‘ b nar
hmb nld s‘ w qd stq mr- Khjd vhr d + Ro‘ qjl‘ m g‘ c sn d w ok‘ hm vgx ghr vhed + tmkhjd Mhw ,
nm&r+ v‘ r f hu d m ‘ r ‘ k‘ q x ‘ r nșb d rs‘ ffi- @mc Ro‘ qjl‘ m snn g‘ c sn qd u d ‘ k ghr s‘ w
qd stq mr- Du d mst‘ kkx d u d m Dhr d mgnvd q l‘ cd ghr s‘ w qd stq mr otakhb + r nld sghmf sg‘ s
ltrs g‘ u d f hu d m r d b qd s r ‘ shre‘ b shnm sn Mhw nm-
7d m+ ‘ ùd q Rsd u d mr nm&r ‘ mc Ro‘ qjl‘ m&r qd kd ‘ r d ‘ mc Dhr d mgnvd q&r ‘ mmntmb d ,
ld ms ne ‘ qd kd ‘ r d + Cd lnb q ‘ shb M‘ shnm‘ k Bg‘ hq l‘ m Rsd ogd m Lhsb gd kk r ‘ hc sg‘ s
Mhw nm snn rgntkc qd kd ‘ r d ghr s‘ w qd stq mr ’r nld sghmf Mhw nm g‘ c mns cnmd ctq hmf
sgd rod d b g nq ‘ ùd q v‘ qcr(- Vg‘ s chc Mhw nm cn> Mhw nm r ‘ hc mn+ H&l mns f nhmf sn-
Mhw nm g‘ c r n rsqnmf kx hmnb tk‘ sd c sgd otakhb ‘ mc sgd oqd rr ‘ f ‘ hmrs etq sgd q b g‘ qf d r
sg‘ s md vro‘ od qr rhlokx ‘ b b d osd c ghr qd etr ‘ k- Du d m lnqd sg‘ m sghr+ Mhw nm&r rod d b g
g‘ c r n cd b hrhu d kx rghùd c sgd oqd rtloshnm hm e‘ u nq ne ghr hmmnb d mb d ‘ mc f nnc
b g‘ q ‘ b sd q sg‘ s gd hmnb tk‘ sd c sgd oqd rr ‘ mc otakhb ‘ f ‘ hmrs ‘ mx etq sgd q ‘ b b tr ‘ shnmr-
Vghkd rsnq hd r ne onkhshb ‘ k hmfftd mb d ‘ mc 8m‘ mb h‘ k l‘ ked ‘ r ‘ mb d b nmshmtd c sn ‘ ood ‘ q
nm md vr vhqd r+ md vro‘ od qr rhlokx chrlhrr d c rtb g rsnq hd r ‘ r lnqd tmentmcd c
rld ‘ qr+ qd onq shmf sgd l ‘ r ad hmf qd etsd c+ nq sgd x chc mns d u d m ansgd q sn otakhrg
sgd l hm sgd 8qrs ok‘ b d -
@mc+ ne b ntqr d + sgd Qd otakhb ‘ mr vnm sgd 0841 d kd b shnm ax ‘ k‘ mcrkhcd - Enq sgd
8qrs shld rhmb d Gd q ad q s Gnnu d q ‘ mc sgd rs‘ q s ne sgd Fqd ‘ s Cd oqd rrhnm+ Qd otakhb ‘ mr
vnm b nmsqnk ne sgd Gntr d ne Qd oqd r d ms‘ shu d r+ sgd Rd m‘ sd + ‘ mc sgd Vghsd Gntr d -
Sd kkhmf kx + ad md ‘ sg sgd gd ‘ ckhmd ‘ mmntmb hmf sgd ' k‘ mcrkhcd· u hb snq x + sgd Mdv Wnqj
Shldred ‘ stqd c mns nmkx ‘ ognsnf q ‘ og ne oqd rhcd ms,d kd b s Dhr d mgnvd q+ ats ad rhcd hs
‘ ognsnf q ‘ og ne u hb d ,oqd rhcd ms,d kd b s Mhw nm-
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
@qf tld ms‘ shnm sgd nq hrsr ‘ mc ‘ m‘ kx rsr ntsrhcd ne qgd snq hb ‘ k b q hshb r q ‘ qd kx sghmj ne
d ffid b shu d md rr hm sd q lr sg‘ s cn itrshb d sn sgd jhmc ne ntsb nld itrs cd r b q had c- 7hmj,
hmf hm sd q lr ne ‘ qf thmf enq ‘ rs‘ mconhms nq b k‘ hl+ nq d u d m ‘ r d s ne rs‘ mconhmsr
nq b k‘ hlr qd ‘ kkx lhrr d r sgd m‘ stqd ne sgd qd ronmr d r b ‘ kkd c nts ax Mhw nm&r rod d b g+
sgd u ‘ q hd sx ne sgd ‘ tchd mb d ’otakhb ‘ tchd mb d + md vr ld ch‘ + onkhshb ‘ k ‘ b snqr(+ nq sgd
cx m‘ lhb r ‘ s ok‘ x - Ats hs hr mns itrs sgd l‘ f mhstcd ne sgd otakhb qd ronmr d ‘ mc sgd
enqb d + cd osg+ ‘ mc d w sd ms ne sgd onkhshb ‘ k b nmr d ptd mb d r sg‘ s l‘ qj Mhw nm&r Bgd b jd qr
rod d b g ‘ r rtb g ‘ rtb b d rr-
7d chșb tksx ne sgd rhst‘ shnm v‘ r rtb g sg‘ s mn nmd ’nsgd q sg‘ m Mhw nm l‘ x ad (
hl‘ f hmd c sg‘ s ‘mx jhmc ne onkhshb ‘ k rtb b d rr v‘ r onrrhakd - Bnmrhcd q gnv sgd ‘ qf t,
ld ms‘ shu d rhst‘ shnm sg‘ s Mhw nm e‘ b d c onr d c r d d lhmf kx hmrtq lntms‘ akd chșb tkshd r-
Mhw nm g‘ c nmkx nmd ‘ mc nmd ,g‘ ke c‘ x r sn oqd o‘ qd ghr rod d b g ne r d ke,cd ed mr d - 7d qd
v‘ r mn qd ‘ k oqnrod b s ne b nkkd b shmf cnb tld ms‘ shnm ad x nmc vg‘ s C‘ m‘ Rlhsg g‘ c
‘ kqd ‘ cx l‘ cd otakhb - ’Mhw nm g‘ c d w od b sd c etkk qd onq sr eqnl ‘ k‘ v 8q l ‘ mc ‘ m
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Rb nss I‘ b nar
nm ‘ r ‘ ld lad q ne sgd Gntr d Tm,@ld q hb ‘ m @b shu hshd r Bnllhssd d d w onr hmf b nl,
ltmhrsr khjd @kf d q Ghrr + ‘ mc sgd m hm ghr Rd m‘ sd b ‘ lo‘ hf m ‘ f ‘ hmrs Qd oqd r d ms‘ shu d
Gd kd m B‘ g‘ f ‘ m Cntf k‘ r + Mhw nm oqnid b sd c ‘ jhmc ne cntakd hl‘ f d 9 Sn ghr rto,
onq sd q r + Mhw nm ‘ ood ‘ qd c sn ad ‘ x ntmf + d ‘ q md rs lnq ‘ k b q tr ‘ cd q- 7d x entmc hm
Mhw nm sgd b g‘ q ‘ b sd q ne ‘ 8f gsd q vhsg sgd b ntq ‘ f d sn rs‘ mc to ‘ f ‘ hmrs b nq q toshnm
‘ mc b nlltmhr l+ vhkkhmf sn d mctqd ‘ kk sgd rtffid q hmf sg‘ s rtb g ‘ rs‘ mc vntkc cq ‘ v
hm etq hntr qd ronmr d - Sn ghr b q hshb r + Mhw nm r d d ld c sn ad ‘ m tmoq hmb hokd c+ b x mhb ‘ k
onkhshb ‘ k noonq stmhrs vgn vntkc stq m sn sgd vnq rs r nq s ne r ld ‘ q r + cd l‘ f nf td q x +
‘ mc chq sx sq hb jr sn ‘ cu ‘ mb d ghr onkhshb ‘ k b ‘ qd d q- Gd vntkc q thm ‘ mx nmd ‘ mc r ‘ x
‘ mx sghmf sn vhm-
Mhw nm&r Fd rs‘ ks,rvhsb ghmf pt‘ khsx b ‘ ld eqnl sgd v‘ x sg‘ s sgd u d q x r ‘ ld od q,
enq l‘ mb d r d u njd c ansg hl‘ f d r fi d u d m sn sgd d w sd ms sg‘ s d ‘ b g hl‘ f d qd hmenqb d c sgd
nsgd q- Enq sgnr d vgn ad khd u d c Mhw nm sn ad ‘ m @ld q hb ‘ m b g‘ lohnm+ sgd ‘ b b tr ‘ shnmr
ne ghr noonmd msr ld qd kx l‘ f mh8d c ghr u hq std ad b ‘ tr d gd vntkc mns a‘ b j cnvm hm
sgd e‘ b d ne tmitrs od qr d b tshnm- Gd itrs jd os 8f gshmf a‘ b j- Sn ghr rtoonq sd qr+ sgd
b q hshb r nmkx d w onr d c sgd cd osgr ne sgd ld m‘ b d sg‘ s Mhw nm v‘ r v‘ q mhmf ‘ f ‘ hmrs- Enq
sgnr d vgn r ‘ v hm Mhw nm ‘ c‘ qj ‘ mc cd u hntr c‘ mf d q+ ghr onotk‘ q hl‘ f d v‘ r chr,
lhrr d c ‘ r ‘ ognmx eqnms ‘ mc nmkx oqnu hcd c etq sgd q oqnne ne itrs gnv sgqd ‘ sd mhmf
sn sgd Qd otakhb Mhw nm qd ‘ kkx v‘ r- Gd kd m B‘ g‘ f ‘ m Cntf k‘ r&r o‘ q shmf rgns ne ' Sq hb jx
Chb j· b ‘ kkd c nts sgd rkhood q x b tmmhmf r d d m hm d u d q x sghmf Mhw nm r ‘ hc nq chc-
Ats sgd b g‘ qf d ne onkhshb ‘ k b nq q toshnm ‘ f ‘ hmrs sgd Bq tr ‘ cd q @f ‘ hmrs Bnq q to,
shnm cd rs‘ ahkhy d c Mhw nm&r hl‘ f d cx m‘ lhb - 7d b g‘ qf d sq hf f d qd c ‘ cd b hrhu d ffho hm
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
sn b nmu hmb d ghr ‘ tchd mb d sg‘ s gd rhlokx v‘ rm&s sgd jhmc ne f tx vgn vntkc cn sgd
jhmc ne sghmf gd v‘ r ‘ b b tr d c ne- Ats gnv b ntkc gd cn sg‘ s vgd m sgd oqd rtloshnm
ne gnmd rsx ‘ mc hmsd f q hsx g‘ c ffhood c r n b nlokd sd kx ‘ f ‘ hmrs ghl>
7hr+ tkshl‘ sd kx + hr vgx mn onkhshb h‘ m nq otmchs hm @ld q hb ‘ sgntf gs+ nm sg‘ s
mhf gs+ sg‘ s Mhw nm g‘ c ‘ b g‘ mb d sn d u d m rtq u hu d onkhshb ‘ kkx - Sn 8f gs sgd ‘ b b tr ‘ shnmr
vntkc nmkx kd ‘ c sn etq sgd q c‘ l‘ f d ‘ mc sn sgd b nkk‘ or d ne sgd d mshqd Dhr d mgnvd q
oqd rhcd msh‘ k b ‘ lo‘ hf m- Gd g‘ c sn ‘ b b d os sgd rhst‘ shnm ‘ mc anv nts f q ‘ b d etkkx -
Ro‘ b d cnd r mns ‘ kknv enq ‘ cd s‘ hkd c ‘ m‘ kx rhr ne gnv Mhw nm otkkd c nffi rtb g ‘ m ‘ l‘ y ,
hmf ntsb nld hm rtb g ‘ r d d lhmf kx hlonrrhakd rhst‘ shnm- Rtșb d hs sn r ‘ x sg‘ s ‘ lnmf
sgd l‘ mx sghmf r Mhw nm chc gd cd lnmrsq ‘ sd c ghr hmmnb d mb d sn sgd @ld q hb ‘ m otakhb
ax sgd v‘ x sg‘ s gd od q enq ld c ghr ‘ qf tld msr ne r d ke,cd ed mr d - Ghr ‘ qf tld msr vd qd
‘ cd lnmrsq ‘ shnm ne ‘ tsgd mshb hsx mns itrs hm sgd r d mr d sg‘ s ‘ qf tld msr cd lnmrsq ‘ sd
‘ b nmb ktrhnm+ ats hm sgd r d mr d sg‘ s ghr ‘ b sr ne ‘ qf tld ms qd ‘ khrshb ‘ kkx rgnvd c+ chr ,
ok‘ x d c+ d lanchd c sgd qd pthrhsd b g‘ q ‘ b sd q- 7d vgnkd onhms ne ghr od q enq l‘ mb d v‘ r
sn rgnv sgqntf g vg‘ s gd ‘ qf td c ‘ mc sgd v‘ x gd ‘ qf td c sg‘ s gd itrs v‘ rm&s sgd jhmc
ne f tx vgn vntkc cn sgd jhmc ne sghmf r gd v‘ r ‘ b b tr d c ne- Mhw nm ‘ qf td c sgd v‘ x
‘ f tx vgn vntkc mns cn sg‘ s jhmc ne sghmf vntkc ‘ qf td - Mhw nm eq ‘ ld c sgd b g‘ qf d r
sgd v‘ x ‘ f tx vgn vntkc mns cn sg‘ s jhmc ne sghmf vntkc eq ‘ ld rtb g b g‘ qf d r-
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
Gd rgnvd c sgd jhmc ne d lnshnmr sg‘ s ‘ f tx vgn vntkc mns cn sg‘ s jhmc ne sghmf
vntkc rgnv- Mhw nm nffid qd c sgd jhmc ne qd ‘ r nmr ‘ mc sgd jhmc ne lnshu d r sg‘ s ‘ f tx
vgn vntkc mns cn sg‘ s jhmc ne sghmf vntkc nffid q- Mhw nm s‘ kjd c+ ‘ mc rstlakd c+ ‘ mc
tr d c k‘ mf t‘ f d sgd v‘ x ‘ f tx vgn vntkc mns cn sg‘ s r nq s ne sghmf vntkc s‘ kj+ ‘ mc
rstlakd + ‘ mc tr d k‘ mf t‘ f d -
@mc hm cnhmf ‘ kk sghr+ gd qd b k‘ hld c ‘ od qr nm‘ sg‘ s sgd @ld q hb ‘ m otakhb b ntkc
ad khd u d ‘ mc ‘ ooqnu d - Hm l‘ jhmf ghr b ‘ r d + Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm d lanchd c ‘ kk sgd b tkstq ‘ k
rx lankhrl ne ‘ Eq ‘ mj B‘ oq ‘ b g‘ q ‘ b sd q ’7hmj Ihllx Rsd v‘ q s hm Lq- Rlhsg Fndr
sn V‘rghmfsnm-(- @mc Mhw nm chc r n ‘ tsgd mshb ‘ kkx + u hu hckx + ‘ mc b nmu hmb hmf kx rtb g
sg‘ s ‘ mx qd ‘ r nm‘ akd od qr nm vgn rg‘ qd c ‘ mc ad khd u d c hm sgnr d b tkstq ‘ k u ‘ ktd r ‘ mc
rx lankr vntkc oqnod qkx b nmb ktcd sg‘ s Mhw nm g‘ c ad d m tmitrskx rld ‘ qd c- Qnad q s
Qt‘ qj ’0841+ Rd os-15( oqna‘ akx ad rs b ‘ ostqd c sgd od q enq l‘ mb d - Vghkd 'b x mhb r· ‘ mc
'r noghrshb ‘ sd r· vntkc ad hmb khmd c sn 'rmd d q· ‘ s sgd 'r n‘ o nod q ‘ !+ Mhw nm&r rod d b g
b ‘ ld b knr d q sn gtl‘ mhy hmf sgd Qd otakhb ‘ m O‘ q sx sg‘ m ‘ mx sghmf sg‘ s g‘ r g‘ o,
od md c hm lx ld lnq x - » Std r c‘ x mhf gs sgd m‘ shnm r ‘ v ‘ khsskd l‘ m r pthq lhmf ghr
v‘ x nts ne ‘ chkd ll‘ ‘ mc k‘ x hmf a‘ qd ghr lnrs oq hu ‘ sd gnod r+ ed ‘ qr ‘ mc kh‘ ahkhshd r-
7hr shld sgd b nllnm l‘ m v‘ r ‘ Qd otakhb ‘ m+ enq ‘ b g‘ mf d - Gd qd v‘ r ‘ m d ‘ q md rs
x ntmf l‘ m vgn v‘ r g‘ u hmf sqntakd ld d shmf s‘ w d r ‘ mc sgd f qnb d q x ahkk+ ‘ mc vgn
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Rb nss I‘ b nar
Mhw nm&r ‘ qf tld ms g‘ c ‘ ct‘ k etmb shnm‘ k rhf mh8b ‘ mb d + ansg sd kkhmf ‘ mc rgnvhmf - @s
sgd kd u d k ne sd kkhmf + Mhw nm l‘ cd ‘ b k‘ rrhb enqd mrhb ‘ qf tld ms ne r d ke,cd ed mr d vghb g
sgd m cq ‘ l‘ shb ‘ kkx ohu nsd c hmsn ‘ b ‘ lo‘ hf m ‘ ss‘ b j nm ghr Cd lnb q ‘ s ‘ b b tr d qr ‘ mc
‘ b ‘ kk sn rtoonq s sgd Dhr d mgnvd q Bq tr ‘ cd - Ats vg‘ s gd ‘ qf td c+ ‘ mc sgd v‘ x gd
‘ qf td c+ ‘ kr n g‘ c sgd etmb shnm‘ k rhf mh8b ‘ mb d ne rgnvhmf ghr b g‘ q ‘ b sd q- Hm od q enq l,
hmf ghr ‘ qf tld msr+ Mhw nm rgnvd c sgd jhmc ne od qr nm sg‘ s sgd ‘ tchd mb d b ntkc qd b ,
nf mhy d + tmcd qrs‘ mc+ ad khd u d + ‘ mc hcd mshex vhsg- 7d otakhb itcf d c ghl sn ad sgd
hmmnb d ms u hb shl ne ‘ m tmitrs rld ‘ q ‘ mc vd qd lnu d c sn q ‘ kkx sn ghr rtoonq s-
7d lnqd hlonq s‘ ms onhms sn b nmrhcd q enq sgd otq onr d r ne sghr b g‘ osd q+ gnv,
d u d q+ hr vgx sg‘ s otakhb itcf ld ms+ ‘ r nu d q vgd klhmf ‘ r hs v‘ r ‘ mc ‘ r b nmu hmb hmf ‘ r
hs ed ks+ v‘ r mns ‘ kr n rg‘ qd c ax r n l‘ mx oqned rrhnm‘ k otmchsr ‘ mc ‘ b ‘ cd lhb b q hshb r-
@mc gnv sn sghr c‘ x b ntkc sgd x cq ‘ v rtb g ‘ b nmsq ‘ rshmf itcf ld ms>
@ f nnc o‘ q s ne sgd ‘ mrvd q khd r hm sgd v‘ x sg‘ s onkhshb ‘ k otmchsr ‘ mc ‘ b ‘ cd lhb
b q hshb r g‘ u d hmsd q oqd sd c sgd rod d b g- 7d x g‘ u d s‘ jd m hs khsd q ‘ kkx + ats mns r d q h,
ntrkx 3fi sn anq qnv ‘ khmd tr d c sn d w ok‘ hm Cnm‘ kc Sq tlo&r d kd b shnm- Nq+ ‘ s kd ‘ rs+ sgd x
g‘ u d qd khd c nm qd k‘ shu d kx rtod q 8b h‘ k+ e‘ b d ,u ‘ ktd hmsd q oqd s‘ shnmr ne Mhw nm&r ‘ qf t,
ld msr ‘ mc qgd snq hb ‘ k rsq ‘ sd f hd r- @mc sgd x g‘ u d rhlokx oqd rtld c sgd rs‘ mc‘ qcr ne
oqnod q b nmctb s+ mnq lr ne ‘ ooqnoq h‘ sd md rr+ ‘ mc cd 8mhshnmr ne onkhshb ‘ k rhst‘ shnm
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
sg‘ s b nmrshstsd sgd hmsd q oqd shu d sq ‘ chshnmr ne sgd hq onkhshb ‘ k ‘ mc ‘ b ‘ cd lhb b tkstqd -
7‘ s&r vgx sgd x r ‘ v ‘ otakhb 8f tqd hm‘ ooqnoq h‘ sd kx cd a‘ rhmf ghlr d ke+ ‘ m‘ jd ckx
nau hntr onkhshb ‘ k f q ‘ aad q ‘ mc b khlad q+ ‘ cd l‘ f nf td otkkhmf ‘ s gd ‘ q srsq hmf r q ‘ sgd q
sg‘ m ‘ ood ‘ khmf sn sgd hmsd kkd b s+ b ‘ kkhmf nts ‘ lna qd ronmr d - 7‘ s&r vgx sgd x entmc
sgd rod d b g sq ‘ mro‘ qd mskx 'b nq mx +· 'sq hsd +· 'l‘ tckhm+· 'l‘ vjhrg+· 'd la‘ q q ‘ rrhmf +·
'ognmx +· '‘ m hkktrhnm ne oqnne+· ‘ mc vnmcd qd c gnv r n l‘ mx od nokd b ntkc ad s‘ jd m
hm ax rtb g 'm‘ tr d ‘ shmf · a‘ knmd x -
7nr d hmsd q oqd s‘ shnmr ‘ khf m vd kk vhsg sgd onkhshb ‘ k+ b tkstq ‘ k+ ‘ mc ‘ d rsgd shb
r d mrhahkhshd r ‘ mc u ‘ ktd r sg‘ s sgd aqn‘ cd q b nlltmhshd r ne oqned rrhnm‘ k otmchsr
‘ mc ‘ b ‘ cd lhb b q hshb r s‘ jd enq f q ‘ msd c+ ‘ mc r n hs hr mns qd ‘ kkx rtq oq hrhmf sg‘ s sgnr d
hmsd q oqd s‘ shnmr vntkc f d md q ‘ kkx f n tmb g‘ kkd mf d c- @kk ne sghr vntkc ad etq sgd q qd hm,
enqb d c ax sgd r d mr d ne r noghrshb ‘ shnm ‘ mc oqned rrhnm‘ k d w od q shr d sg‘ s ‘ kknvr otmchsr
‘ mc ‘ b ‘ cd lhb ‘ m‘ kx rsr mns sn vnq q x sg‘ s chritmb stqd r ad svd d m oqned rrhnm‘ k ‘ mc
otakhb itcf ld ms lhf gs hmchb ‘ sd sg‘ s sgdx lhf gs ad sgd nmd r sn g‘ u d f nssd m r nld ,
sghmf vqnmf -
Hs rgntkc mn knmf d q b nld ‘ r md vr sg‘ s sgd l‘ inq hsx ne oqned rrhnm‘ kr hm sgd
md vr ld ch‘ ‘ mc sgd ‘ b ‘ cd lx cn mns rg‘ qd sgd r d mrhahkhshd r nq g‘ u d e‘ hsg hm sgd
u ‘ ktd r sg‘ s nqchm‘ q x od nokd entmc d lanchd c ax Mhw nm hm ghr rod d b g- Vg‘ s md d cr
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
sn ad md vr hr sg‘ s ‘ khd m‘ shnm eqnl sgnr d r d mrhahkhshd r ‘ mc r b d oshb hrl snv‘ qc sgnr d
u ‘ ktd r md d cr sn ad mnshb d c ‘ mc qd rhrsd c+ d rod b h‘ kkx ‘ lnmf ‘ r d ke,qd hmenqb hmf b nl,
ltmhsx ne khjd ,lhmcd c b q hshb r- Vhsgnts hs+ sgd qd hr khsskd nq mn cd l‘ mc sn qd b nm,
rsq tb s sgd od qrod b shu d ‘ mc rhst‘ shnm ne sgd ‘ tchd mb d sg‘ s v‘ r hm ok‘ b d hm @ld q hb ‘
hm 0841 fi ‘ s kd ‘ rs+ mns hm ‘ v‘ x sg‘ s hr rx lo‘ sgd shb nq ‘ msgqnonknf hb ‘ kkx r d q hntr- Vd
rgntkc md u d q ed d k r ‘ ed chrlhrrhmf rtb g ‘ l‘ mhed rs otakhb itcf ld ms vhsgnts ‘ rjhmf
vgd sgd q od nokd lhf gs ad r d d hmf r nld sghmf hm Mhw nm&r rod d b g sg‘ s vntkc mns l‘ jd
sgd l nts sn ad f tkkhakd + m‘ hu d ennkr ‘ mc q tad r-
Enq ‘ b ‘ cd lhb b q hshb r+ sgd oqnakd l hr hm l‘ mx v‘ x r d u d m lnqd oqnmntmb d c-
@b ‘ cd lhb b q hshb r hm o‘ q shb tk‘ q ltrs b nmrs‘ mskx rsq tf f kd vhsg sgd v‘ x hm vghb g sgd hq
lncd kr ne ‘ qf tld ms ‘ mc sgd hq khrsr ne e‘ kk‘ b x b ‘ sd f nq hd r d mb ntq ‘ f d ‘ jhmc ne khs,
d q ‘ k,lhmcd cmd rr hm sgd hq hmsd q oqd s‘ shnmr ne ‘ qf tld ms+ ‘ 'b nnjhd ,b tssd q· ‘ ooqn‘ b g
sn e‘ kk‘ b x hcd msh8b ‘ shnm+ ‘ ld b g‘ mhb ‘ k ld sgnc ne qd b nmrsq tb shnm+ ‘ mc onrs,gnb
q ‘ shnm‘ khy ‘ shnm ne od qr nm‘ k itcf ld msr ‘ mc b tkstq ‘ k d w od b s‘ shnmr chrf thr d c ‘ r sgd
oqnctb s ne ld sgnchb ‘ k ‘ m‘ kx shb oqnb d ctqd - 7hr hr lnqd sg‘ m r ‘ x hmf sg‘ s e‘ kk‘ b hd r
b ‘ mmns ad r ‘ ed kx entmc hm ‘ qf tld ms‘ shu d d w b d q osr d w sq ‘ b sd c eqnl sgd aqn‘ cd q sd w sr
ne vghb g sgd x ‘ qd ‘ o‘ q s nq sg‘ s vgnkd sd w sr b ‘ mmns rhlokx ad oqd r d msd c sn rst,
cd msr nq qd ‘ c ax ‘ m‘ kx rsr vhsgnts sgd a‘ b jf qntmc b nmsd w s sg‘ s f hu d r sgd l ld ‘ m,
hmf - Sqd ‘ sld msr ne e‘ kk‘ b hd r g‘ u d cnmd sghr qd f tk‘ qkx d mntf g vhsg Mhw nm&r rod d b g-
Ats sgd oqnakd l ‘ kr n od qrhrsr hm rstchd r ax qgd snq hb ‘ k b q hshb r vgnr d sqd ‘ sld msr ‘ qd
e‘ q lnqd b nloqd gd mrhu d ‘ mc ad ssd q hmenq ld c- 7d oqnakd l hr sgd v‘ x hm vghb g ntq
lncd kr ne ‘ qf tld ms ‘ mc khrsr ne e‘ kk‘ b x b ‘ sd f nq hd r ah‘ r d r ‘ mc khlhsr ntq b nmb d o,
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
Bgdbjdqr qdbnmrhcdqdc
Bnmrhcd q sgd hb nmhb lnld ms hm Mhw nm&r rod d b g- Hs hr nmd sg‘ s b nmshmtd r sn ad
vhcd kx lnb jd c ‘ mc qd od ‘ sd ckx sqnssd c nts hm ‘ qf tld ms‘ shnm sd w sannjr ‘ r ‘ 'qd ‘ k,
khed· d w ‘ lokd ne e‘ kk‘ b x -
Vd kk+ sg‘ s&r ‘ ants hs- 7‘ s&r vg‘ s vd g‘ u d - @mc sg‘ s&r vg‘ s vd nvd - Hs hrm&s u d q x
ltb g- Ats O‘ s ‘ mc H g‘ u d sgd r ‘ shre‘ b shnm sg‘ s d u d q x chld sg‘ s vd&u d f ns hr gnm,
d rskx ntqr-
H rgntkc r ‘ x sghr+ sg‘ s O‘ s cnd rm&s g‘ u d ‘ lhmj b n‘ s- Ats rgd cnd r g‘ u d ‘ qd rod b s,
‘ akd Qd otakhb ‘ m b knsg b n‘ s- @mc H ‘ kv‘ x r sd kk gd q sg‘ s rgd&c knnj f nnc hm ‘ mx sghmf -
Nmd nsgd q sghmf H oqna‘ akx rgntkc sd kk x nt+ ad b ‘ tr d he H cnm&s sgd x &kk oqna‘ akx ad
r ‘ x hmf sghr ‘ ants ld + snn- Vd chc f d s r nld sghmf + ‘ f hù+ ‘ ùd q sgd d kd b shnm- @ l‘ m
cnvm hm Sd w ‘ r gd ‘ qc O‘ s nm sgd q ‘ chn ld mshnm sgd e‘ b s sg‘ s ntq svn x ntmf rsd qr
vntkc khjd sn g‘ u d ‘ cnf - @mc ad khd u d hs nq mns+ sgd c‘ x ad enqd vd kd ù nm sghr
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Rb nss I‘ b nar
Ansg Mhw nm&r ld mshnm ne O‘ s&r 'qd rod b s‘ akd Qd otakhb ‘ m b knsg b n‘ s· ‘ mc ghr hmrhr,
sd mb d sg‘ s 'qd f ‘ qckd rr ne vg‘ s sgd x r ‘ x ‘ ants ZBgd b jd qr[+ vd&qd f nhmf sn jd d o hs·
g‘ u d ad d m gd kc to ‘ r sq ‘ mro‘ qd mskx nau hntr e‘ kk‘ b hd r ’qd c gd q q hmf enq sgd b n‘ s:
rsq ‘ vl‘ m enq Bgd b jd qr: ansg enq ‘ c lhr d q hb nqch‘ l ‘ ood ‘ k(- H sghmj sgnr d tr d r
ntf gs sn ad gd kc to ‘ r d w ‘ lokd r ne sgd c‘ mf d q ne e‘ kkhmf hmsn tmb g‘ q hs‘ akd + khsd q ‘ k,
lhmcd c+ b nnjhd ,b tssd q b q hshb hrl- 7nr d itcf ld msr ne e‘ kk‘ b x qd ffd b s ‘ rtod q 8b h‘ k
qd ‘ chmf ne sgd o‘ rr ‘ f d r+ q hood c eqnl sgd b nmsd w s ne sgd rod d b g ‘ r ‘ vgnkd + qd mcd qd c
vhsgnts b nmrhcd q ‘ shnm enq sgd etmb shnm‘ k cd rhf m hm vghb g sgd r d o‘ rr ‘ f d r ok‘ x ‘
qnkd + ‘ mc ‘ b b d oshmf ‘ rg‘ kknv+ chrlhrrhu d ohb stqd ne sgd hmsd q oqd shu d b ‘ o‘ b hshd r ne
sgd ‘ tchd mb d -
Vg‘ s&r qd ‘ kkx f nhmf nm gd qd hr sg‘ s Mhw nm g‘ r ad d m onrhmf sgd m ‘ mrvd q hmf ‘
r d q hd r ne ptd rshnmr ‘ ants ghr onkhshb ‘ k etmc- 7d ptd rshnmr ‘ qd hmb qd ‘ rhmf kx oqd rr,
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Rb nss I‘ b nar
Rn+ Mhw nm rtalhsr sgd cd b hrhnm ne vgd sgd q nq mns sn rs‘ x nm sgd shb jd s sn sgd Qd ota,
khb ‘ m M‘ shnm‘ k Bnllhssd d ‘ mc gd ‘ rjr sgd ‘ tchd mb d sn vhqd ‘ mc vq hsd sgd hq nohmhnm
nm vg‘ s sgd x rgntkc cd b hcd -
7d o‘ rr ‘ f d ne hmsd qd rs hr vgd qd Mhw nm r ‘ x r+ '@mc+ hmb hcd ms‘ kkx + O‘ s&r mns ‘ pths,
sd q- @ùd q ‘ kk+ gd q m‘ ld v‘ r O‘ sq hb h‘ Qx ‘ m ‘ mc rgd v‘ r anq m nm Rs- O‘ sq hb j&r C‘ x + ‘ mc
x nt jmnv sgd Hq hrg md u d q pths-·
7‘ s ld mshnm g‘ r ad d m b q hshb hy d c ‘ r e‘ kr d ’d -f -+ I‘ lhd r nm+ 0885+ o- 62: Qx ‘ m+
0877+ o- 001fi002(- 7d rtf f d rshnm hr sg‘ s hs hr itrs ‘ b gd d rx lhrqd oqd r d ms‘ shnm
cd rhf md c sn f d s sgd Hq hrg u nsd - Sd b gmhb ‘ kkx + sgd o‘ rr ‘ f d hr e‘ kr d - O‘ s&r ‘ b st‘ k l‘ hcd m
m‘ ld v‘ r 7d kl‘ B‘ sgd q hmd Qx ‘ m+ ‘ mc rgd v‘ rm&s anq m nm Rs- O‘ sq hb j&r C‘ x - Rgd
v‘ r anq m sgd c‘ x ad enqd hm 0801-
7hr hr ‘ mhf f khmf b q hshb hrl ‘ s ad rs+ ‘ mc hs hr ‘ m hmchb ‘ shnm ne itrs gnv d ‘ rhkx
e‘ tks b ‘ m ad ‘ rrhf md c ax ‘ r b d oshb ‘ k b q hshb - O‘ s&r e‘ sgd q v‘ r ‘ oqntckx b nllhssd c
Hq hrgl‘ m+ ‘ s ‘ shld vgd m sgd qd v‘ r rshkk ‘ f qd ‘ s cd ‘ k ne d sgmhb oqd itchb d ‘ f ‘ hmrs sgd
Hq hrg- Gd mhb jm‘ ld c gd q ' O‘ s· ad b ‘ tr d rgd v‘ r anq m ‘ s ‘ ants 009// o-l-+ nm sgd
d u d ne Rs- O‘ sq hb j&r C‘ x + ‘ mc gd ‘ kv‘ x r hmrhrsd c gd q ahq sgc‘ x v‘ r nm Rs- O‘ sq hb j&r C‘ x -
Rn Mhw nm hr sd kkhmf nmd ne sgnr d b gd q hrgd c e‘ lhkx rsnq hd r sg‘ s O‘ s f qd v to vhsg ‘ mc
sg‘ s d u d q x nmd khjd r sn qd od ‘ s-
Ats sghr b q hshb hrl ‘ kr n lhrr d r sgd onhms- Mhw nm hr sq x hmf sn b nmu d x sg‘ s qd rhf m,
hmf f nd r ‘ f ‘ hmrs ghr u d q x b nqd - Gd&r ‘ 8f gsd q- Gd itrs hrm&s sgd jhmc ne f tx vgn
pthsr- Gd&r mns ‘ pthssd q- Ats gd&kk qd rhf m he sg‘ s&r vg‘ s sgd od nokd v‘ ms ‘ mc vg‘ s sgd
Qd otakhb ‘ m M‘ shnm‘ k Bnllhssd d sghmj hr ad rs- Gd&r mns sq x hmf sn vhm r nld Hq hrg
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
u nsd r- @mc gd&r mns sq x hmf sn onhmskd rrkx ennk ‘ mx nmd - Gd&r od q enq lhmf ‘ m d w oqd r,
rhnm ne oq hcd hm ‘ u ‘ ktd gd ‘ mc ghr vhed rg‘ qd ‘ mc ‘ clhqd hm d ‘ b g nsgd q ‘ mc sg‘ s
gd oqd rtld r sgd ‘ tchd mb d ‘ kr n ‘ clhqd r- He ‘ mx sghmf + sgd qd ‘ k rsnq x hr ‘ m d u d m lnqd
b nlod kkhmf cd lnmrsq ‘ shnm ne b nllhsld ms he mns ‘ r od qrohb tntr ‘ m d w oqd rrhnm ne
sgd hcd ‘ -
Ehm‘ kkx + b nmrhcd q ‘ mnsgd q vhcd kx l‘ cd b q hshb hrl ne Mhw nm&r rod d b g9 Mhw nm
hf mnqd r sgd u d q x kd f hshl‘ b x ne s‘ jhmf lnmd x eqnl rod b h‘ k hmsd qd rsr- 7hr b g‘ qf d hr
r n vhcd kx ‘ mc b nm8cd mskx ‘ rr d q sd c+ sg‘ s x nt&c sghmj hs ltrs ad sq td - Ats sgd b g‘ qf d
ne hloqnoq hd sx hsr d ke hr ‘ klnrs md u d q oqd r d msd c ‘ r ‘ vd kk,cd u d knod c ‘ qf tld ms- He hs
nb b tq qd c ‘ s ‘ kk hm sgd oqd rr ‘ s sgd shld + hs v‘ r nmkx nakhptd kx ld mshnmd c- Md u d q sgd ,
kd rr+ hs hr ‘ e‘ u nq hsd ne b q hshb r ne Mhw nm&r rod d b g- @mc ad b ‘ tr d gd cnd r mns nu d q skx
qd etsd sgd hloqnoq hd sx ne s‘ jhmf lnmd x eqnl rod b h‘ k hmsd qd rsr+ Mhw nm&r r d ke,cd ed mr d
hr entmc k‘ b jhmf -
A‘ q md ss A‘ rjd q u hkkd&r ’0841( b nu d q ‘ f d ne sgd rod d b g b nmb ktcd r sg‘ s Mhw nm f ‘ u d
sgd ‘ ood ‘ q ‘ mb d ne oqnne+ ats kd ù tm‘ mrvd qd c r d q hntr ptd rshnmr ‘ ants hmfftd mb d
od cckhmf ’r d d ‘ kr n A‘ rjd q u hkkd + 0850(- Od qg‘ or sgd lnrs r noghrshb ‘ sd c ‘ mc vd kk,
cd u d knod c u d qrhnm ne sghr b q hshb hrl hr sn ad entmc hm Bnmchs ’0878(+ vgn onhmsr sn
sgd b nq q toshmf hmfftd mb d ne lnmd x hm b nmsd lonq ‘ q x onkhshb r- 7d oqnakd l vhsg gd q
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g
u d qrhnm ne sgd b q hshb hrl hr+ ‘ r E‘ q qd kk ’0878+ o- 135( onhmsr nts+ mn nmd b ntkc g‘ u d
enqd r d d m gnv sgd md d c sn b nu d q sgd b nrsr ne onkhshb ‘ k b ‘ lo‘ hf mr vntkc d w okncd
hm k‘ sd q cd b ‘ cd r ‘ r sd kd u hrhnm ‘ cu d q shrhmf b ‘ ld sn cnlhm‘ sd oqd rhcd msh‘ k d kd b shnmr-
Mhw nm hm 0841 b ntkc g‘ qckx g‘ u d ad d m d w od b sd c sn d u d m jmnv ‘ ants sgd hrrtd ne
sgd chrsnq shu d hlo‘ b s ne rod b h‘ k,hmsd qd rs 8m‘ mb hmf nm lncd q m onkhshb r-
Qx ‘ m&r ’0877+ oo- 0/8fi00/( sqd ‘ sld ms ne sgd hrrtd hr od qg‘ or sgd lnrs b g‘ q h,
s‘ akd nmd - Gd onhmsr nts sg‘ s Mhw nm&r ‘ qf tld msr hm r d ke,cd ed mr d vd qd rsq tb stqd c ‘ r
‘ m ‘ mrvd q sn sgd cd l‘ mcr ne oqnne k‘ hc nts ax Cd lnb q ‘ shb M‘ shnm‘ k O‘ q sx Bg‘ hq,
l‘ m Lhsb gd kk- Mhw nm rsq ‘ hf gsenq v‘ qckx cd mhd c sg‘ s sgd etmc v‘ r r d b qd s+ sg‘ s ‘ mx
lnmd x vd ms sn Mhw nm enq ghr od qr nm‘ k tr d + nq sg‘ s ‘ mx nmd qd b d hu d c rod b h‘ k e‘ u nqr
enq sgd lnmd x sgd x b nmsq hatsd c- Xd s Qx ‘ m rshkk 8mcr Mhw nm&r r d ke,cd ed mr d k‘ b jhmf enq
hsr e‘ hktqd sn ‘ ccqd rr sgd hrrtd -
Nmd rtrod b sr sg‘ s ad ghmc ‘ kk sghr hr ‘ oqd rtloshnm mns rg‘ qd c ax Mhw nm+ ‘ mc
oqna‘ akx mns rg‘ qd c ‘ s sgd shld ax ‘ mx nmd ntsrhcd ‘ u d q x d khsd b hqb kd hm @ld q hb ‘ 9
sg‘ s onkhshb ‘ k b ‘ lo‘ hf mr ntf gs sn ad otakhb kx 8m‘ mb d c- Nq od qg‘ or sgd qd hr sgd oqd ,
rtloshnm sg‘ s onkhshb ‘ k b ‘ lo‘ hf mr cnm&s b nrs d mntf g sn qd pthqd rtars‘ msh‘ k etmchmf
’b e- A‘ rjd q u hkkd + 0841(- Nq l‘ x ad sgd b nmb d q m hr sg‘ s Mhw nm&r etmc v‘ r hloqnod q
ad b ‘ tr d hs ‘ood‘qdc sn ad nod m sn rtrohb hnm ne tmctd hmfftd mb d ’nu d qknnjhmf
Rlhsg&r ‘ qf tld ms sg‘ s b nmsq hatshnmr vd qd khlhsd c sn #4// oqd b hr d kx sn ‘ u nhc sg‘ s
hloqd rrhnm(- Hs hr g‘ qc sn sd kk d w ‘ b skx ad b ‘ tr d q ‘ sgd q sg‘ m otsshmf enq v‘ qc ‘ onrhshu d
‘ qf tld ms enq sgd ‘ b b tr ‘ shnm sg‘ s Mhw nm&r etmc v‘ r hloqnod q+ b q hshb r r d d l pthsd
b nlenq s‘ akd otrghmf ’rghùhmf ( sgd atqcd m ne oqnne nmsn Mhw nm-
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
Ats vg‘ s hr d rod b h‘ kkx ncc vhsg sghr b q hshb hrl ne Mhw nm&r cd ed mr d hr sg‘ s ‘ b g‘ q h,
s‘ akd qd ‘ chmf ne ghr rod d b g vntkc rgnv sg‘ s Mhw nm cndr ‘ ccqd rr sghr hrrtd + ‘ kad hs
mns ‘ ksnf d sgd q chqd b skx - D‘ qkx nm hm sgd rod d b g+ Mhw nm ‘ ccqd rr d r sgd f d md q ‘ k hrrtd
ne vgx gd md d cd c sgd etmc-
Vd kk+ sgd m+ r nld ne x nt vhkk r ‘ x + ‘ mc q hf gskx + vd kk+ vg‘ s chc x nt tr d sgd etmc enq+
Rd m‘ snq > Vgx chc x nt g‘ u d sn g‘ u d hs> Kd s ld sd kk x nt hm itrs ‘ vnqc gnv ‘ r d m‘ sd
nșb d nod q ‘ sd r- Ehqrs ne ‘ kk+ sgd r d m‘ snq f d sr 8ùd d m sgntr ‘ mc cnkk‘ qr ‘ x d ‘ q hm r ‘ k,
‘ q x - Gd f d sr d mntf g lnmd x sn o‘ x enq nmd sq ho ‘ x d ‘ q+ ‘ qntmc sq ho+ sg‘ s hr+ enq ghl,
r d ke ‘ mc ghr e‘ lhkx + ad svd d m ghr gnld ‘ mc V‘ rghmf snm+ C-B- @mc sgd m gd f d sr ‘ m
‘ kknv‘ mb d sn g‘ mckd sgd od nokd sg‘ s vnqj hm ghr nșb d sn g‘ mckd ghr l‘ hk- @mc sgd
‘ kknv‘ mb d enq lx rs‘ sd ne B‘ khenq mh‘ hr d mntf g sn ghqd sghq sd d m od nokd - @mc kd s ld
r ‘ x + hmb hcd ms‘ kkx + sg‘ s sg‘ s ‘ kknv‘ mb d hr mns o‘ hc sn sgd r d m‘ snq- Hs&r o‘ hc chqd b skx sn
sgd hmchu hct‘ kr sg‘ s sgd r d m‘ snq otsr nm ghr o‘ x qnkk- Ats ‘ kk ne sgd r d od nokd ‘ mc ‘ kk
ne sgd r d ‘ kknv‘ mb d r ‘ qd enq rsq hb skx nșb h‘ k atrhmd rr: atrhmd rr+ enq d w ‘ lokd + vgd m ‘
b nmrshstd ms vq hsd r hm ‘ mc v‘ msr x nt sn f n cnvm sn sgd Ud sd q ‘ mr& @clhmhrsq ‘ shnm
‘ mc f d s r nld hmenq l‘ shnm ‘ ants ghr F-H- onkhb x fi hsd lr ne sg‘ s sx od + enq d w ‘ lokd -
Ats sgd qd ‘ qd nsgd q d w od mr d r vghb g ‘ qd mns b nu d qd c ax sgd f nu d q mld ms- @mc H
sghmj H b ‘ m ad rs chr b trr sgnr d d w od mr d r ax ‘ rjhmf x nt r nld ptd rshnmr- Cn x nt
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
.. Rb nss I‘ b nar
Mhw nm sgd m oqnb d d cr sn khrs ‘ mc qd id b s sgqd d v‘ x r sn kd f ‘ kkx o‘ x enq sgd etmc x ntq,
r d ke ’sn ad q hb g fi gd&r mns: sn ots x ntq vhed nm sgd o‘ x qnkk nq sn oq ‘ b shb d k‘ v fi sgnr d
vntkc ad vqnmf (- Mhw nm k‘ sd q hm sgd rod d b g ‘ rr d q sr sg‘ s hs hr 'd rr d msh‘ k hm ntq b ntm,
sq x sg‘ s ‘ l‘ m ne lncd rs ld ‘ mr· ad ‘ akd sn q tm enq ghf gd q nșb d - 7‘ s kd ‘ u d r nmkx
nmd nsgd q noshnm9 ‘ b b d oshmf ntsrhcd ‘ hc-
@mc r n H ed ks sg‘ s sgd ad rs v‘ x sn g‘ mckd sgd r d md b d rr ‘ q x onkhshb ‘ k d w od mr d r ne f d s,
shmf lx ld rr ‘ f d sn sgd @ld q hb ‘ m od nokd ‘ mc sgd rod d b gd r H l‘ cd fi sgd rod d b gd r
sg‘ s H g‘ c oq hmsd c enq sgd lnrs o‘ q s b nmb d q md c sghr nmd ld rr ‘ f d ne d w onrhmf sghr
‘ clhmhrsq ‘ shnm+ sgd Bnlltmhrl hm hs+ sgd b nq q toshnm hm hs fi sgd nmkx v‘ x sg‘ s H
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
Bg‘ osd q 4- Qd ,u hrhshmf Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g .
Du d q x ancx gd&r s‘ kjd c sn ‘ f qd d r vhsg sg‘ s- Rgnq s ne ‘ cd u d knod c naid b shnm sn sgd
b nmsq ‘ q x ’khjd sgd nmd Bnmchs l‘ cd 26 x d ‘ qr k‘ sd q (+ H cnm&s r d d gnv Mhw nm b ‘ m ad
‘ b b tr d c ne e‘ hkhmf sn ‘ ccqd rr sgd hrrtd - H sghmj ghr ‘ qf tld ms v‘ r ‘ b b d osd c ax ghr
‘ tchd mb d mns ad b ‘ tr d sgd x e‘ hkd c sn mnshb d Mhw nm b nmsq ‘ chb shmf ghlr d ke nq e‘ hkd c sn
r d d ghl d u ‘ chmf sgd qd ‘ k hrrtd + ats ad b ‘ tr d sgd ‘ qf tld ms l‘ cd r d mr d -
Bnmbktrhnm
Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r ‘ tchd mb d v‘ r lnu d c ax sghr rod d b g ad b ‘ tr d sgd x snnj Mhw nm r d q h,
ntrkx ats mns khsd q ‘ kkx + ‘ mc ad b ‘ tr d sgd x entmc ‘ etmb shnm‘ k r d mr d ‘ mc hmsd q oqd shu d
cd osg sn ghr rod d b g sg‘ s g‘ r ad d m vnd etkkx k‘ b jhmf hm snn l‘ mx ne sgd ‘ m‘ kx r d r ne
oqned rrhnm‘ k otmchsr ‘ mc ‘ b ‘ cd lhb b q hshb r- 7d qd ‘ qd b d q s‘ hmkx sqntakhmf ‘ rod b sr
ne ghr ‘ qf tld msr+ ats H ad khd u d sgd r d sskd c md f ‘ shu d itcf ld ms ne onkhshb ‘ k ‘ mc ‘ b ‘ ,
cd lhb ghrsnq x hr k‘ qf d kx nu d q aknvm- He hs hr ‘ k‘ rshmf md f ‘ shu d d ffid b s ne sgd rod d b g+ hs
hr ‘ m d ffid b s anq m ‘ mc rtrs‘ hmd c ax qd r d msld ms sg‘ s sgd rod d b g v‘ r r n d ffid b shu d - Mn
nmd khjd r sn r d d a‘ c f tx r vhm nq sn ‘ clhs sg‘ s r nld nmd r n vqnmf hm r n l‘ mx nsgd q
v‘ x r lhf gs ad q hf gs hm sghr nmd b ‘ r d -
Qdedqdmbdr
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?
. Rb nss I‘ b nar
I‘ b nar+ R- ’1//5(- Mnme‘ kk‘ b hntr qgd snq hb ‘ k rsq ‘ sd f hd r9 Kx mcnm Ingmr nm&r C‘ hrx ‘ c- ?qftldms‘,
shnm+ 1/+ 30fi331-
I‘ b nar+ R- ’1//8(- Mnme‘ kk‘ b hntr qgd snq hb ‘ k cd rhf m hm ‘ qf tld ms‘ shnm- Hm E- G- u ‘ m Dd ld qd m+ %
A- F‘ qrr d m ’Dcr-(+ Onmcdqhmf nm oqnakdlr ne ‘qftldms‘shnm- Svdmsx drr‘xr nm sgdnqdshb‘k
hrrtdr’oo- 44fi67(- Cnqcqd b gs9 Roq hmf d q- gs s or /. . cnh-nq f. 0 7-0 779 . 89 3, 0 , 271 7, 80 z6 , 7X6
I‘ lhd r nm+ J- G- ’0885(- O‘bj‘fhmf sgd oqdrhcdmbx ? ghrsnqx ‘mc bqhshbhrl neoqdrhcdmsh‘kb‘lo‘hfm
‘cudqshrhmf ’2qc d c-(- Md v Xnqj9 Nw enqc Tmhu d qrhsx Oqd rr-
J‘ sb gd q+ K- ’0841+ Rd os- 07(- Rd b qd s q hb g ld m&r sq trs etmc jd d or Mhw nm hm rsx kd e‘ q ad x nmc ghr
r ‘ k‘ q x - Mdv Wnqj Onrs+ oo- 2+ 15-
L‘ ssr nm+ J- ’1/01(- Itrs ok‘hm Chbj- Qhbg‘qc Mhwnm&r Bgdbjdqr roddbg ‘mc sgd 'qnbjhmf) rnbjhmf–
dkdbshnm ne0831- Md v Xnqj9 Aknnlratq x -
M‘ shnm&r oqd rr chu hcd c nm Mhw nm: chr ‘ ooqnu ‘ k d w oqd rr d c ax 1 sn 0- ’0841+ Rd os- 10(- Mdv Wnqj
Shldr+ o- 0-
Mhw nm+ Q- L- ’0841+ Rd osd lad q 12(- Qhb g‘ qc Mhw nm&r 'Bgd b jd qr· rod d b g- ZUhcd n[- WntStad-
Onrsd c ax Lhkkd q Bd msd q ne Otakhb @ffi‘ hqr- Tmhu d qrhsx ne Uhqf hmh‘ - Qd sq hd u d c eqnl
gssor9..vvv-x ntstad -b nl.v‘ sb g> u <DpivACG,u gX
Mhw nm&r etmc hsd lhy d c: 65 f ‘ u d #07+124- ’0841+ Rd os- 10(- Mdv Wnqj Gdq‘kc Sqhatmd+ o- 0-
N&Aq hd m+ Q- V-+ % Inmd r+ D- ’0865(- üd mhfgs Mhwnm ronjd9 ? rstcx ne onkhshb‘k dfldbshudmdrr- Knr
@k‘ lhsnr+ B@9 Gvnmf -
Ntrshmf ne Mhw nm cd l‘ mcd c ax r nld ne Hjd&r ‘ cu hr nqr- ’0841+ Rd os- 1/(- Anrsnm Fknad+ o- 0-
O‘ q ld s+ G- R- ’088/(- Qhbg‘qc Mhwnm ‘mc ghr?ldqhb‘- Md v Xnqj9 Jnmd b jx % Jnmd b jx -
Qt‘ qj+ Q- ’0841+ Rd os- 15(- Mhw nm gtl‘ mhy d c sgd FNO- CdsqnhsEqdd Oqdrr+ o- 25-
Qx ‘ m+ G- Q- ’0877(- Rd m‘ snq Qhb g‘ qc L- Mhw nm&r ‘ onknf x enq ' 7d Etmc-· Hm G- Q- Qx ‘ m ’Dc-(+
Nq‘snqhb‘kdmbntmsdqr9Rdkdbsdc rstchdr‘mc rntqbdrnesvdmshdsg,bdmstqx onkhshb‘k‘bbtr‘shnmr
‘mc ‘onknfhdr’oo- 88fi01/(- Md v Xnqj9 Fqd d mvnnc-
Rd m‘ snq b tsr sq ho- ’0841+ Rd os- 11(- Mdv Wnqj Shldr+ o- 0-
8+1;"*#C( R EFGH? B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';? !-- "*#C(4 "&4&"6&3?
Vhb jd q+ S- ’0880(- Nmd netr-Qhbg‘qc Mhwnm ‘mc sgd ?ldqhb‘m cqd‘l- Md v Xnqj9 Q‘ mcnl Gntr d -
Vhkkr+ F- ’086/(- Bgd b jd qr- Hm Mhwnm ‘fnmhrsdr- üd bqhrdr ne sgd rdke,l‘cd l‘m ’b g- 4+ oo-
80fi003(- Anrsnm9 Gntf gsnm Lh4hm-
!"#$%&'()(*+' *' !,($)- ."),(*,& / 0+1*,)- 2($3*&4 )5+$( !"#$%&'()(*6& 7*4,+$"4& *' 8+'(&9(: &3*(&3 5; <&%&"&':
=")'4 >? 6)': )'3 @)"( A)"44&': B+C' @&'D)%*'4 .$5-*4C*'# 8+%1)';: EFGH? ."+I$&4( <5++J 8&'(")-: C((1/KK&5++J,&'(")-?1"+L$&4(?,+%K-*5K$3&-M&
8"&)(&3 N"+% $3&-M&5++J4 +' EFEFMGFMEO FH/FP/EQ?