Chapter 1
Chapter 1
CHAPTER I
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Film songs are not only an aspect of cinema, but also an essential part of
film music in today’s Tamil cultural life. Some years back, the centre of social
research conducted a survey and came out with the information that 77% of
those who view films go for songs in the films. Films songs are also dubbed
into other regional languages and bring in lot of revenue thus reducing the
other important aspects of film and paying overdue attention to film songs - for
example, Sankarabaranam, 1979 (Baskaran, 2010:118).
melody is known for haunting tune which sinks into the listener’s
consciousness, repetition of certain passages at intervals, background harmony
which is rich with variety of instruments, the creative counter melody back up
and the appropriate mood it creates suiting to the theme chosen.
These aspects form the basis for our ability to recall lines of songs that
we had heard during our childhood. A few songs occupy prime place in our
memory. One of the main reasons for film songs becoming popular is that they
are associated and remembered for the scenes and the characters that are
potrayed in it. Especialy, the songs that come in romantic scenes are heard
individually they have a sexual impact on people. Those who hear such songs
have also viewed the respective sequences of the scenes as well. For example,
the song ‘Anubavam Puthumai’ from the film Kaadhalikka Neram Illai (1964)
(Baskaran, 2010:119). And for some, either hearing from outside or hearing it
internally become a healing process, a sigh of relief from psychological or
physical stress, strain and pain.
Chennai is one of the cities in the world where numerous films are
made. About more than 5000 commercial films have been produced in Tamil
Nadu in the past. The influence of films on people has been so intense, that
they have elected so far five Chief Ministers, namely C.N.Annadurai,
M.Karunanidhi, M.G.Ramachandran, V.N.Janaki and J.Jayalalitha from the
film world. All of them entered into politics after their successful career in film
industry.
Dravidian movements with their stong roots in Tamil Nadu, have made
use of the films for achieving their political purposes. Many leaders of
Dravidian movement who entered politics came from the world of drama
where dialogues played an important role. C.N.Annadurai wrote story and
dialogue for the film Nallathambi (1949), Karunanidhi wrote Parasakthi
3
(1952), Manohara (1954) which were well known for long dialogues and
literary richness. It is a strong belief among people and politicians of Tamil
Nadu even now that one who has the fluency in Tamil language and one who
can eloquently speak for long hours in public meetings will be a seasoned
politician one day.
In Tamil Nadu, film songs are released long before the release of the
film and they determine the success of the film. The songs are shot with utmost
care with huge budgets. At times, the audience may not have seen the film, but
would have listened to the songs and seen in television or video. For these
4
reasons, music directors enjoy a special place in the hearts of Tamils. There are
fan clubs for music directors like Ilayarajaa and A.R.Rahman.
In 1913, on the 3rd May, the India’s first film Harichandra produced by
Dada Saheb Palke was screened in Coronation theatre in Mumbai. This was the
birth of Indian cinema. It was a silent film. In 1931 March 14, the first talking
film Alam Ara produced by Ardeshir was screened in Majestic theatre in
Mumbai. This was a revolution in Indian cinema. Ardeshir produced the first
Tamil and Telugu film Kalidas in 1931 and released it in Chennai on 31st
October. A book titled Song and Story Book of Kalidas was also released. The
heroine TB Rajalaxmi sang two kirtanas and two national anthems in the film
(Tamil Cinema Deepavali Edition, 1956).
5
descending of Naradar with stunning song from clouds to the earth is a magical
scene’. This film was shown ten weeks in Chennai and six weeks in Madurai.
In the early years of Tamil cinema, only actors who could sing well
became the heroines and heroes. This trend was overlooked by A.V.M when
6
they introduced an actress who could not sing and matched her lip movements
attuned to the recorded songs.
Another significant trend began in Tamil film industry in 1935. Till then
the stories of the films were mainly from epics and religion. The films
Dambacharry, Meneka, and Rajambal were totally based on social novels. In
1936 Ellis Dungan came to Chennai from America to make films. He produced
Seemanthani, Sathileelavathi and Iru Sagotharargal. National leader Rajaji
appreciated the film Iru Sagotharargal. Surprisingly, this film did not have
many songs like earlier ones.
The first sound engineer in Tamil film industry was Mrs. Narayanan.
She entered to sound world mainly because, the sound engineers were from
non-Tamil world and they could not sing the songs and speak the dialogues of
the artists with the dubbed tracks. The number of production centres kept
increasing as the days passed by. S.Soundararaja Ayyangar started Tamil Nadu
Talkies in 1934. Sundaram Talkies started Sundaram Studios in Chennai, in
1935. M.T.Rajan of Vel Pictures started ‘Vel Pictures Studio’ in 1934. His
interview in Anandavikatan in 1936 discussed the business motives of the
producers and moral issues arising out of films in those days. According to
him, the film industry had people with profit motives by showing obscene
scenes. He opined that “the studio owners should have purpose and should not
aim only to grab money from the viewers. Three fourth of the actors who join
film industry aim at money only and not on the growth of the industry. Today
the meaning of ‘Social films’ has become meaningless. In all the social stories
we see the same type of alcoholism, sex, murder, robbery etc… There is no
scarcity for obscenity” (Anandavikatan, 1936: September 6).
7
shown in one theatre for more than a year. Ambigapathi ran for several months.
In 1937 Modern Theatres Studio was constructed in Salem by Sundaram. Three
films were produced in the first year itself, Sathi Agalya, Padma Jyothi and
Purandara Doss.
The film director Asandoss had increased the production expenses from
eighty thousands to three lakhs for the film Bakta Nandanar in 1935.
K.P.Sundarambal’s fee was one lakh rupees in this film. In 1937, for the film
Nava Yuvan he had the shooting in London. In 1937, film director C.V.Raman
portrayed the life of a Harijan girl in the film titled ‘Laxmi or Harijan woman’.
In 1938, the Tamil film industry had a setback reducing the number of
the Tamil films. Actors did not have job. Producers could not get back their
investment. Six studios in the region were about to be closed. Technicians did
not have sufficient work. The film magazine Silver Screen gave a call to all the
producers to come together and bring out at least one good film a month.
In 1940 S.S.Vasan steps into the industry with historical films. The
dance he introduced in Mangamma Sabatham and the role played by
T.R.Rajakumari in Chandraleka (1948) with uncovered blouse became a
controversy. People remember the dance sequence in front of the huge palace
where hundred men and women would dance over drums. The unit spent
almost two months for this five minute song.
8
and Kittappa occupied their primacy later with their acting and singing skills.
Songs of the film Srivalli by T.R.Mahalingam were heard throughout the State.
He was at peak during early fifties. Another singer cum actor who came to
limelight was K.R.Ramasamy. N.S. Krishnan had exposed social issues
through his film Manamagal in 1951.
Although many music directors composed music for Tamil films from
1931 to 1949, the star music director was S.V.Venkatraman. He was succeeded
by G.Ramanathan. Songs like, ‘Vaarai nee varai’ (Mandiri Kumari),
‘Nadagamellam Kanden’ (Madurai Veeran), ‘Masilla Nilave Nee’
(Ambigapathi), ‘Yaradi Nee Mohini’ (Uthimaputhiran), were by
G.Ramanathan.
10
A.R Rahman made his entry with the film ‘Roja’(1992) where he fused Indian
music with Sufi and Western. He became the first one to receive the world’s
prestigious Oscar award.
At the dawn of talkie films, the songs in the films were not necessarily
connected to the stories. They were either religious songs or patriotic songs.
This trend got changed later with the advent of story based films that
highlighted social and family issues. From 1960’s to 1990’s we see this trend
although these films never reflected reality but were meant purely to provide
entertainment.
During the last two decades, we find hundreds of film songs that do not
reflect social realities, instead they lead the audience into artificial realities.
They revolve around violence, sexual obscenity and love to support the
formula stories. We can also see songs that are not in good taste.
The lyrics get drowned in the tune and we are not able to understand the
verses. Our involvement in the tune makes us miss the meaning of the songs.
The songs by and large are merely for entertainment with no agenda of positive
transformation of life.
The United Nations (1995) define youth as persons between the ages of
15 and 24. The UNESCO understands that young people are a heterogeneous
group in constant evolution and that the experience of ‘being young’ varies
enormously across regions and within countries
Many countries also draw a line on youth at the age at which a person is
given equal treatment under the law – often referred to as the ‘age of majority’.
11
This age is often 18 in many countries, and once a person passes this age, they
are considered to be an adult. However, the operational definition and nuances
of the term ‘youth’ often vary from country to country, depending on the
specific socio-cultural, institutional, economic and political factors according
to United Nations Division for Social Policy and Development (2000).
This Policy will cover all the youth in the country in the age group of 13
to 35 years. It is acknowledged that all the persons within this age group are
unlikely to be one homogenous group, but rather a conglomeration of sub-
groups with differing social roles and requirements, the age group may,
therefore, be divided into two broad sub-groups viz. 13-19 years and 20-35
years. The youth belonging to the age group 13-19, which is a major part of the
adolescent age group, will be regarded as a separate constituency.
Notably, not all definitions refer to only the age group 15-24 as youth.
The National Youth Policy of India, Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports
(2003) defines the youth population as those in the age group 15-29.
As per the 2001 Census of India, population age 15-24 years accounts
for 195 million of the 1,029 million of India‘s population. In other words,
every fifth person in India belongs to the age group 15-24 years. This
population is identified by the United Nations Population Fund (2009) as youth
or the youth population. By 2011, this age group is expected to grow to 240
million according to the Office of the Registrar General (2006) and account for
a slightly higher proportion of the total population than in 2001.
12
skills that will help to renew and improve the country‘s stock of human capital.
The Youth also represent the age group that forms the basis of demographic
renewal, as these young people form unions and begin child bearing.
The Policy recognizes the prevailing gender bias to be the main factor
responsible for the poor status of health and economic well-being of
women in our society and that any discrimination on grounds of sex
violates the basic rights of the individual concerned and it, therefore,
stands for the elimination of gender discrimination in every sphere. The
Policy enunciates that:
Every girl child and young woman will have access to education and
would also be a primary target of efforts to spread literacy.
13
14
programmes and for reviewing on-going activities / schemes to fill in gaps and
remove unnecessary duplication and overlap.
students to gain leadership skills to face life in future and apply them for nation
building processes.
In the words of Dr. Kalam (2002) India needs young leaders. The first
vision for India was that of independence, which was achieved. We need a
second vision now — to make India economically strong. That vision ignites
particularly the young mind.
Leadership training and modules need not come only from schools and
colleges, but also from parents, media, especially films and film songs.
16
More often the youth are consulted through focus groups, interviews
and surveys as a means to establish programs to reduce youth violence. In
some cases, academics base their violence reduction programs on theory, past
research, and so-called best practices. Both approaches suffer from what is best
described as adult-centric. (Greene, 2009)
In all the programmes meant for the youth, we make them as passive
listeners or recipients rather than active participants in the programme. As a
result, we see lack of dedication and commitment on the part of the youth in
fulfilling the objectives of the programmes. We need to change the method
move towards ‘bottom-up’ rather than ‘top-down’ communication.
The youth need to own the programmes we launch for their growth so
that accountability is taken care of. Without the active participation of youth
and families in the development, operation, and ownership of programs
designed to create pro-social and peaceful climates, social change efforts will
revolve toward the paternalism and fail to create the kind of transformative
functions social change programs are meant to create. These three
complementary traditions dramatically embrace the power of youth as agents
of social change.
17
but should help the community in solving social problems of India’. Vision and
aim of the youth should be high because, when youth interact in community,
then it is possible they will not stand longer, if they have not set high vision
and aim. It is the dream of the President Smt. Pratibha Devisingh Patil who
addressed to the nation on the eve of Independence Day 15th Aug. 2009 that
weaker sections of country can be uplifted by creating large number of youth
communities with the help of the NGOs.
In recognition of the important role for the youth in nation building, the
preamble of India‘s National Youth Policy (2003) reiterates the commitment of
the entire nation to the composite and all-round development of the young sons
and daughters of India. It further seeks to establish an All-India perspective to
fulfil their legitimate aspirations so that they are all strong of heart and strong
of body and mind in successfully accomplishing the challenging tasks of
national reconstruction and social changes that lie ahead. The thrust of the
policy is youth empowerment in different spheres of national life (National
Youth Policy, 2003). Education, employment, and health, including sexual and
reproductive health, are all key elements of youth empowerment.
18
19
age, 16 percent use some form of tobacco and 6 percent consume alcohol. The
survey further has shown that substance use can directly compromise young
people’s health. For example, evidence suggests that the use of alcohol and
drugs among youth is associated with physical fights, risky sexual activity,
depression and suicide as well as irregular school or work attendence and other
negative outcomes.
One in every 1,000 youth in India is HIV positive. About 2 per 1,000
young women and men suffer from diabetes and 9 per 1,000 suffer from
asthma; 5 per 1,000 women suffer from goitre or other thyroid disorders.
20
The most common form of media accessed by both women and men is
television, followed by radio for women and newspapers/magazines for men.
The majority of youth (59 percent of women and 70 percent of men) watch
television regularly. Gender differentials are evident for each type of media.
Consistent with the gender gap in literacy, the gender gap is also very wide in
exposure to print media. Only 27 percent of young women, compared with 57
percent of young men, read a newspaper or magazine regularly. Compared
with the older cohort of persons age 25-49, exposure to each medium of
communication is higher among youth, particularly for men.
21
Nearly one third of film viewers in India are children and youth. Music
and youth are inseparable entities. Songs being the integral part of the film,
‘film viewing’ and ‘listening to film songs’ are important activities of college
youth.
This study focuses on the relationship between film songs and identity
formation of college youth. Youth is a crucial period in which they are actively
engaged in carving out an identity for them. Identity is important for any
human being, especially at a crucial period for college youth, who are trying to
mould themselves into responsible citizens and leaders of the country.
Television now has emerged as the most powerful and all pervading
cultural force throughout the world. As researchers like George Garner, a
pioneer in television shows has proved over and over again that media
influences our opinion and attitudes about ourselves, our relationships, our
place in the world. But what we see and hear in the media is a selective output
reflecting certain priorities and views of the world.
22
23
For some adolescents, the changes, expectations, and new demands are
perceived as a challenge. For them, confusion and stress are part of a process
that leads to a higher level of integration. They quickly recover from setbacks
and minor disappointments. For others, the changes have a more threatening
quality, causing temporary or more prolonged periods of disruption, fear, mood
changes, rebellion and despondency.
It is in this context, the study engages itself in finding out the contribution of
film songs on the identity formation of youth in Chennai.
24
In the present electronic age, the sensual, emotional and audio visual are
dominant sources of communication. Perceptual and emotional knowledge is
considered more important than conceptual and intellectual knowledge.
Emotional enjoyment, personal experiences, freedom of expression and
experiential approaches have become the catch phrases in the society as the
electronic media has spread its reach in all directions. In the media scenario
today, media controllers are mighty few and they hold complete control over
information flow leaving less scope for the people to think independently and
creatively. They decide what to give and what not to give to people.
Knowingly or unknowingly the youth encounter with media and undergo a
change in their understanding of life and its values.
The influence of the media on our lives is subtle yet deep. Unknowingly
and imperceptibly we begin to accept the values to which we are constantly
exposed. The media presentations are so powerful that we the listeners
gradually begin to become unsuspecting victims of the media influence and
start to think and feel as the media suggests.
Once we have surrendered our senses and nervous systems to the private
manipulation of those who would try to benefit from taking a lease on
our eyes and ears and nerves, we don’t really have any rights left.
Leasing our eyes and ears and nerves to commercial interests is like
handing over the common speech to a private corporation, or like giving
the earth’s atmosphere to a company as a monopoly (McLuhan,
1964:73).
Some people are strong in nature and keep their views and ideologies
untouched by the media. “There are growing numbers of persons who
consciously choose their programmes, and for whom the content is the
fundamental criterion. There are also some producers who believe that the
making of a film primarily involves having something to say and saying it
forcefully” (Babin, 1970:17).
The younger ones are far ahead of the elders in receiving and processing
information. According to Babin, there is no communication without
involvement. ‘Young people’s senses are more alert and they react to the media
with greater interest and personal involvement’ (Babin, 1970:25).
India ranks as the highest producer of Cinema from the early seventies.
Television now has emerged as the most powerful and all pervading cultural
force throughout the world. As researchers like George Garner, a pioneer in
television shows has proved over and over again that media influence our
opinion and attitudes about ourselves, our relationships, and our place in the
world. But what we see and hear in the media is a selective output reflecting
certain priorities and views of the world.
27
Film Songs are remembered because of their melodies. When songs are
sung, at times they do not remember or understand what they sing but they are
interested in the tune. Songs are popular for their harmonious blend of good
melodies with meaningful lyrics. Lyrics are known for deep and profound
meaning, rhyme and rhythm, choice of words appropriate to the sense the lyrics
intend to convey, the unity of meaning, emphasis in the harmony and tune. A
good melody is known for haunting tune which sinks into the listener’s
consciousness, repetition of certain passages at intervals, background harmony
which is rich with variety of instrumentation, the creative counter melody back
up and the appropriate mood it creates suiting to the theme chosen.
These aspects form basis for our ability to recall a few lines of songs
that we heard during our childhood. A few songs occupy prime place in our
memory. And for some, either hearing from outside, or hearing it internally
become a healing process, moving away from psychological or physical stress,
strain and pain.
negative thinking, values and attitude towards life, this study will create an
improvement in constructive identity formation and affirming orientation
among college youth.
29
How important is the role of story tellers and lyric writers in helping the
students to form a healthy identity?
What are the ways and means to enable youth to form a healthy identity,
using film songs in a constructive way?
The city of Chennai has been chosen for the study as it is one among the
four largest cities in India. Chennai is well known for having educational
institutions of high quality which accommodate youth from all strata of the
society. It is also well-known for advanced communication technologies, film
productions in South India and a place of fashion and continuous change in the
lifestyle of youth. Hence, a study on the impact of films on identity formation
of college youth in Chennai is desirable and would provide useful findings that
would help the youth and society at large. The researcher has decided to
remain in Chennai during the period of research for participant observation.
30
31
Life coping skills are necessitated because of the new expectations and
demands from within and outside. Fresh assumptions about self, value, and
identity must ultimately be confronted. During this time of intense and often
rapid change, the early learning, resourcefulness, and adaptive nature of the
individual are severely tested. Some degree of conflict, stress, frustration and
confusion is inevitable. Adolescents or young adults perhaps, find themselves
to be in complete harmony with themselves, their peers, parents and with
society at all times.
32
Films and film songs being an influencing factor for youth, have a role
in shaping the personalities of youth with suggestions on moral, social,
spiritual, cultural and economic issues pertaining to youth. Songs can inspire
them, enlighten them, relieve their tensions, provide alternatives to their issues,
rebuild broken relationships, and also lead them into unpleasant experiences.
The present study is an enquiry into these aspects.
33
Films and film songs being an influencing factor for youth, have a role
in shaping the personalities of youth with suggestions on moral, social,
spiritual, cultural and economic issues pertaining to youth. Songs can inspire
them, enlighten them, relieve their tensions, provide alternatives to their issues,
rebuild broken relationships, and also lead them into unpleasant experiences.
The study is an enquiry into these aspects.
medium of organisers were some of his ideas. Nivethitha (2010) in his ‘Dances
of Dreams’ critically looks at Tamil film industry. At one stage, he says that
the films by Shankar are a symbol of deteriorating culture of Tamil Nadu.
36
Baskaran (2009) brings out the connection between films and present
life, its impact on people over a century with historical perspective in his work
‘The Rest on Silver Screen’. Kaviri Mainthan (2008) describes how lyricist
Vaali during his forty five years of presence in Tamil film industry, makes
people to reflect on piety, motherhood, moral values, love, affection and
philosophy of life through his film songs in his work titled ‘Vaalum Thamile
Vaali’. Chinnaponnu (2010) in her work titled ‘Tamil films, Culture and
Politics’ suggests that all films need to undergo cultural analysis and more
study need to be undertaken on how Tamil films use dialogues related to caste
and religion. She also suggests that relationship between Tamil films and
portrayal of vulgarity, people’s protests, the urban-rural myths constructed by
Tamil film industry.
37
1.6.7.1 Sample
Chennai is the capital of Tamil Nadu in South India. The district city is
one of the metropolis of India and serves as the gateway of the culture of
South India. In spite of being the capital of a Tamil speaking State, it has
emerged as a cosmopolitan city playing an important role in the historical,
38
The total number of samples chosen were 1,300. The respondents were
students chosen from 15 colleges of Chennai namely, Gurunanak College,
Ambedkar College, Loyola College, Loyola College of Engineering, Stella
Maris College, Presidency College, Jain College, St.Joseph’s College, MGR
Janakiammal College, Queen Marys College, Bhrathi Arts College, Christ
College, SIGA Polytechnic, Madras Christian College and SRM Engineering
College. Random sampling technique was used covering the entire city and
sampling was taken from four directions of the city namely North, South, East,
West and Central part of the district to have an even geographical distribution.
Both qualitative and quantitative data were used for the empirical
analysis of the ‘Impact of Tamil Film Songs on The Identity Formation of
College Youth in Chennai’. A questionnaire has been prepared to find out the
personal data, media habits, impact of Tamil film songs and personal attitude
towards Tamil film songs. An in-depth interview with students was used to
probe into link between Tamil film songs and identity formation of youth.
The following tools have been used for the purpose of data collection.
Interview Schedule
In-depth Interview
Part-I was used to elicit personal information as well as the family background
of the respondents.
Part-III was used to collect data on the respondent’s personal interest towards
Tamil film songs which include:
Lyricists
Part- IV was used to collect data on the impact of Tamil film songs on the
respondents.
Life styles
Personality
Social Behaviour
40
Social Awareness
Personal Relationships
Social Relationships
Negative Thinking
Values
This part also was used to collect data on the respondent’s personal
attitude towards film songs.
A pilot study was conducted with 100 students from Chennai after
which the interview schedule was modified based on the experience and
outcome of the same.
41
discussion, eight students participated. Four such sessions were held and the
students were drawn from six colleges in Chennai.
The researcher personally visited the colleges chosen for the study and
collected the required data. The interview schedule took an average of 20
minutes per individual youth. The in-depth interview went up to two hours
each. Of the fifteen colleges chosen for the sample, twelve colleges are run by
private organisation and three are run by State Government. Five colleges are
run only for girls and three are run only for boys. Seven colleges are run for
both boys and girls. In-depth interviews were conducted with twelve students,
six boys and six girls drawn from three Government and three private colleges
in the city. Focus Group Discussions were conducted for boys and girls coming
from six colleges from city. In each FGD, eight students participated and four
discussions were conducted. The in-depth interviews and Focus Group
Discussions were audio recorded which were later transcribed for the purpose
of analysis and interpretation.
The data obtained for the study were both quantitative and qualitative in
nature. Put together, the analysis is attempted to bring out the impact of Tamil
film songs on the identity formation of college youth in Chennai. Qualitative
interpretation was done through narrative analysis which creatively combined
methods for precision and validity. Quantitative analysis of data was done
through Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) by the researcher. For
processing of data, the responses were examined carefully. After screening the
answer sheets 1266 scripts were available for final analysis.
42
Descriptive Statistics
ANOVA
Friedman Test
Regression Analysis
The First Chapter ‘An Overview of Tamil Film Songs and the
Status of Youth’ discusses about the concept of Communication, identity,
identity formation, media, film songs and their role in identity formation
among youth. It also deals with the theoretical understanding of the concept of
identity formation of Erik Erikson, theoretical framework for the study and the
relevant literature. It also brings together the objectives, research questions and
the methodology used in the study.
43
1.8 CONCLUSION
This chapter has discussed the power of film songs and their role in the
life of people, an historical overview of Tamil film songs, the status of youth in
India and the youth and Tamil film songs. The chapter also deals in detail with
theoretical perspective on the key concepts in relation to the present study. The
concept of identity formation of youth and Tamil film songs have been
discussed. The need and scope of the study and the problem have been stated.
The research questions, the main objectives and the limitations of the study
have been listed.