Stress Testing of SBL, Word
Stress Testing of SBL, Word
On
Prepared by-
Submitted to:
Sonia Munmun
Lecturer
Department of Finance
Jagannath University, Dhaka
Submitted by:
Preface
Anyone can gather theoretical knowledge by learning. But practical knowledge and
theoretical knowledge is fully different. Practical knowledge is required to be achieved to
match theoretical knowledge. In order to gather practical knowledge, all of the Universities
should take effective steps such as internship program for the BBA students.
1
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Internship program is one kind of experience. It is the combined arrangement between the
educational institutions and business organizations operating in the practical field. So the
student of BBA should be pragmatic and should have a firsthand view of the real life
business environment. The objective of the internship program is to produce the learners
with practical organizational environment so that they can tune up themselves for the job in
future and can get an opportunity to reconcile the theoretical knowledge with real life
situation. For this reason, internship program is an indispensable for the BBA program.
As a student of Finance, I was placed in Sonali Bank Limited, Savar Branch, Dhaka. I
decided to write an internship report on “Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited” after
three months of internship program.
The best feature of my internship program was the access to a motivated and hard-working
team of highly knowledgeable banking professionals. The most important skill that I learnt
was the ability to work in a team. I also picked up considerable skills in team
communication, communication with the customers, training others, getting trained me,
and the ability to adapt to the ever-changing banking scenario.
I have tried my best to make this report effective and realistic and my attempt will be
fruitful at that time if anybody is benefited from this one.
Acknowledgement
In the name of Almighty Allah, the most Beneficent, the most merciful.
It is indeed a great pleasure and honor on my part to have the opportunity to submit
internship report after three months practical orientation at Sonali Bank Limited, Savar
2
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Branch, Dhaka. First of all thanks to almighty Allah for enabling me to complete internship
report with good and sound health. I am pleased to express my gratitude to placement
committee for arranging such a program from which I have carried a practical experience.
Internship program is one of the important requirements for the completion of four years
BBA program. I have completed my internship in Sonali Bank Limited (Savar Branch). In
this regard I would like to express my heartiest appreciation to my honorable supervisor
Sonia Munmun, Lecturer, Department of Finance, Jagannath Iniversity for his guidance,
care and valuable suggestions to prepare this report. I would also like to pay my gratitude
to another supervisor, Shamim Ara Begum, Senior Faculty Member, Sonali Bank Staff
College, Sonali Bank Limited for her guidance and cooperation.
This report is being prepared with assistance and support from, Md. Mojibur Rahman
(Senior Officer), Rezwana Parvez, (Senior Offiecr), Muhammad Shamim (Officer-Foreign
remittance), Md. Mosharraf Hossain (Officer & Remittance Management In charge), Md.
Abdul Aziz (Officer-Cash), Rabaka Sultana (Officer-trainee) and specially my beloved
wife Sayeda Hosneara Akter (Student of BBS) for giving me support all the moment of my
attachment time and also for make an attractive working environment which I have really
enjoyed very much.
I feel very pleased to thank all my fellow friends for their cordial cooperation in preparing
this report. Then at last I shall be grateful to those persons who read this report and who
will
Letter of Transmittal
02 June 2015
3
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Sonia Munmun,
Lecturer,
Department of Finance,
Jagannath University, Dhaka.
With due respect, I would like to state that it is a matter of great pleasure and honor for me
to submit my internship report on “Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited” assigned as
my topic of internship report. In preparation of this report I have followed and maintained
the format and rules of a formal internship report. The internship program gave the
opportunity to have an insight on the Banking sector of Bangladesh through Sonali Bank
Limited.
The Consignment was of great worth and appeal, as it helped me hone my analytical skills
abilities and practical knowledge in the field of credit management and helped me become
familiarized with the corporate world. I have tried heart and soul to make the report
effective and useful.
The internship program was very much valuable to me as it helped me to gain experience
from the practical field. I am grateful to you for providing me this opportunity of gaining
such practical experiences and to know how theoretical knowledge is applied in the real
world.
I, sincerely hope that you will be satisfied with this report. Please accept my report and I will
be glad to clarify any discrepancy that may arise.
Sincerely Yours
4
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
I confirm that, the report is only prepared for my academic requirement not for otherwise
purpose. I also assure that this report is not submitted anywhere in the universe before me.
Department of Finance
Jagannath University, Dhaka
5
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
I, Sonia Munmun
, hereby very pleased to declare
Sheikh
thatSalah Uddin
, ID no.: 115290,
Registration No: 1101335290, 4th year 2nd semester, Department of Finance, Jagannath
University, Dhaka has been given with the topic “Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited”
for researching and writing an internship report on the subject. He has reviewed relevant
literatures and has surveyed for three months to collect both of primary and secondary data.
I have supervised him throughout the preparation of the internship paper.
I certify that the internship paper is an original one and has not been submitted elsewhere
previously for publication in any form.
Sonia Munmun
Lecturer
Department of Finance
Jagannath University, Dhaka
6
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
I, hereby, declare that Sheikh Salah Uddin, ID no.: 115290, 4th year 2nd semester,
Department of Finance, Jagannath University, Dhaka has been given with the topic “Stress
I also certify that the internship paper is an original one and so this is really a tremendous
effort from him as a student of BBA.
Executive Summary
During my stay at the office as an intern, I never felt vague or ambiguous. The
environment of the Sonali Bank Limited is work-friendly. The staffs are specialized in their
respective fields. Each of them works on their own and their id supervised from the top
management. The motivation of the staff, I believe, comes from the very sense of
responsibility.
My report is on the basis of the fundamental analysis rather than the general banking. So, I
actually worked there full time, but prepared my report in my room after my work time.
7
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
First of all I described all functions and present position of Sonali Bank, then gradually I
entered into the main part of the report through describing the newly invented process of
measuring the financial situation or position of a bank/FI, named Stress Testing.
This report is intended to answer some of the basic questions that may arise as part of the
process of stress testing. The report begins with a discussion of stress testing in a financial
system context, highlighting some of the differences between stress tests of systems and of
individual portfolios and then ends up with the stress test on the basis of financial system
of Sonali Bank Limited. The paper provides an overview of the process itself, from
identifying vulnerabilities, which are called ‘shock’ to constructing scenarios to
interpreting the results.
The remaining part consist the analysis (page-56), findings (page-82), recommendations
(page-83) and conclusion (page-86).
I tried to make the report perspicuous and comprehensible for the students and the other
persons who are not related to any part of business and so I used graphical presentation
besides data & calculation tables. As CAR is the main capital risk 1 measurable function, all
the risks are converted to CAR (%) to understand the company position if they can recover
that shock using their own capital or not.
I’ve done lots of financial calculations, observed their financial reports & from my working
experience I also gathered knowledge about their administrative processes of managing
different issues. Summarized findings can be found in chapter-6.
1 I expressed capital risk, which means the shortage of existing amount of capital than the
required amount of capital
8
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
9
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Table of Contents
10
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
11
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
12
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
13
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
14
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Abstract
Stress testing is one of the effective and popular ways to alert bank management with
regard to adverse unexpected outcomes related to variety of risks and provides an
indication how much capital adequacy ratio (CAR) might be needed to absorb losses if any
large shocks occur. In this paper, Sonali Bank Limited is considered, operates in
Bangladesh based on BB rules. Besides that, several indicators for conducted stress testing
of non-performing loan (NPL), non-performing loan in two major sectors, equity price risk,
liquidity shocks and Interest rate shocks. This study has been used the data for the years of
2013 and 2014 taken from the annual report of SBL. Finally, this study has some
interesting implications that might help the senior management, policy makers, depositors,
owners as well as stakeholders of the bank.
15
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Key words
Stress Testing, Credit Risk, Non-performing loan, NPL in major sectors, Equity Price Risk,
Liquidity Risk, Interest Rate Risk, Financial soundness, Sonali Bank Limited
1.2 Initiative:
Banks play the most important role in the economy. Banks collect money from the
individuals and lend them to others. Now banks offer the widest range of financial services
and perform lots of financial functions. Thus banks have proven that they are the key factor
for the business and economy as well. It is of vital importance to understand and appreciate
the risks the banking industry is exposed to so that soundness and sustainability of the
industry can be ensured.
In the regulatory and supervisory sphere, the Central Bank's activities in banking
supervision have often been determined by exogenous elements deriving mainly from the
changes in the structure and scope; activities and risks that the financial sector is facing and
the changes in regulatory standards occurring internationally. The recent financial turmoil
in the US financial system has augmented the importance of establishing more developed
risk management regime in the financial industry. Present risk management culture based
on normal business conditions and historical trends is not enough to cope with the
disorders that have happened in the financial systems globally. This required an
appropriate response in the regulatory and supervisory activities of the Central Bank.
16
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Financial institutions around the world are increasingly employing stress testing to
determine the impact on the financial institution under a set of exceptional, but plausible
assumptions through a series of battery of tests. Bangladesh Bank has designed a stress
testing framework for banks and FIs to proactively manage risks in line with international
best practices. Keeping in view with the divergence of skill levels and available resources
among banks and FIs, a modest beginning focused with simple sensitivity and scenario
analysis considering only credit risk and market risk is suggested in the Stress Testing
Guideline published from BB, eventually to develop into a more comprehensive approach.
All banks and FIs are expected to carry out stress testing on half‐yearly.
Stress Testing has got the impressive attentions in the last few decades as to measure the
level of economic confrontation and to alert bankruptcy hazard caution of the financial
institutions, commercial banks.
The internship report comprises a brief study on the financial system of Sonali Bank
Limited during three months internship. The report is divided in many departments
according to nature and requirement of the topic and according to the instructions of my
supervisors.
• To understand and analyze the financial strength of SBL through Stress Testing.
• To point out the major findings of the report & provide some valuable
recommendations based on them.
18
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Type: As I am going to test the stress of Sonali Bank Limited to manage its risks, so I have
to describe its whole management process of stresses over risk by analyzing some financial
and statistical data.
So, from my point of view, it is an analytical report.
Data collection and analysis were made during the Internship period at Sonali Bank
Limited.
The methodology framework is likely as the flowchart shown below-
19
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Methodology Framework
Internship under
Internship at SBL
Supervisors
Reporting the
Findings &
Recommendations
In order to analyze collected data, I have used statistical software that can run different
statistical test. Also I have used MS-Excel to calculate and generate charts and graph of
different analysis. The data has been presented through graphs for better visual
understanding.
20
Website of SBL.
Brochures.
Text books
creation of data base, literature review and analysis of data. While doing so, many
limitations arise even though I always tried my best to avoid these limitations. In
conducting the present study, the following limitation has been faced:
The main constrain of the study was insufficiency of information. The personnel of
the organization did not want to disclose the classified information to maintain
bank restrictions.
I have faced major limitation in the financial projection as my estimate was rather
informative base than of actual one.
As I worked full time during the internship period, time is another hindrance to
make
an in depth study on such a critical issue
I had to attend the final examination of 4th year 2nd semester during the internship
period and so it was not possible to prepare report or collect data during these
weeks.
21
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Due to time limitation many of the aspects could not be discussed in the present
report. Learning all the functions within just 90 days is really tough.
Since the bank personnel were very busy, they could not provide enough time to
me,
lack of opportunity to visit more than one branch.
The functions and activities of Sonali Bank Limited are too vast, so fully classified
capable of visiting those places, in spite of my home is in savar, there was a huge
time-waste while visiting those places twice or more times during the preparation of
information could not be collected without being the head accountant or DGM. As
a result I can’t collect updated or very recent information & strategy. report.
22
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
23
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Authorised Capital
: Taka 6,000.00 core
As in SBL Monthly ‘At-a-Glance’ of February 2015.
a) Officers : 19,199* (Decreased 693 in this year)
24
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
i. Rural : 860 *
Representative Offices : 3*
Contact:
SWIFT : BSONBDDH
Website : www.sonalibank.com.b d
E-mail : [email protected]
As in SBL Monthly ‘At-a-Glance’ of February 2015.
2.2 Goal of SBL:
There are three levels of goal of Sonali Bank Limited. Such as-
2.2.1 Vision:
Socially committed leading banking institution with global presence.
25
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
2.2.2 Mission:
Dedicated to extend a whole range of quality products that support divergent needs of
people aiming at enriching their lives, creating value for the stakeholders and contributing
towards socio-economic development of the country.
2.2.3 Slogan:
Your trusted partner in innovating banking.
The bank has been converted to a Public Limited Company with 100% ownership of the
government and started functioning as Sonali Bank Limited from November 15, 2007
taking over all assets, liabilities and business of Sonali Bank. After corporatization, the
management of the bank has been given repaired autonomy to make the bank
competitive& to run its business effectively.
26
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
1972
National Bank
1949
of Pakistan
2. Ancillary Services:
4
Sonali Bank Limited offers multiple special services with its network of branches throughout
the country in addition to its normal banking operations.
2.4. Collection:
1 o Gas bills.
o Electricity bills.
o Telephone bills.
o Water/Sewerage bills.
27
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
o Army pension.
o British pension.
o Students' stipend/scholarship.
o Prize Bonds.
28
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
29
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Under Process 7
ABB 1184 increased
(
2
3 in this )year
2.5. ATM:
3
Sonali Bank Limited is a member of Q-Cash ATM network. At present the bank has 53
ATM booths. Sonali Bank's ATM cardholders enjoy the access to the ATMs and POS of
Dutch
2
* As in SBL Monthly ‘At-a-Glance’ of February 2015.
Bangla Bank Ltd. and Brac Bank Ltd. besides those of Q-Cash consortium. Sonali Bank
recently launched Credit Card.
30
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
2.5. Online and SMS Banking: At present109 branches of Sonali Banks are included
4in the Online Any Branch Banking (ABB) network. SMS Banking service is running in 73
branches. The bank is seriously working on connecting all branches in the Real-time Online
Banking network gradually. Branches having ABB facility are also rendering SMS banking
services.
3
As in SBL Monthly ‘At-a-Glance’ of February 2015.
4
As in SBL Monthly ‘At-a-Glance’ of February 2015.
2.6 Card Facilities of Sonali Bank Limited:
31
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Limited
Debit and Credit card holder of Sonali Bank Limited can use under mentioned ATM Booth
and shopping center and Point of Sale (POS):
32
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Other Information:
Card Division ,
Dhaka - 1000.
33
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Credit Limit
Conditions:
Yearly charge for Credit Card (Bank Employee) Tk = 345.00 (Including VAT)
Credit card holder can enjoys 100% of loan limit either from ATM or POS.
In case of POS no interest will be charged if outstanding liabilities are paid within
the stipulated time. This time is 50 days from date of statement.
34
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
35
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Total no. of exchange houses/banks = 54, (bank = 12 and Exchange house = 42)
2.8 Credit Rating Report of Sonali Bank Limited:
The credit rating report of Sonali Bank Limited is published by the head office of the
organization. The report is very simple to understand and very significant for the investors.
So, the report is given below without any changes made, same to the real report published
or announced from the head office of the organization.
Head Office,
36
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
scholars, Economists & Bankers, has been working for proper & fair Islamic Banking
activities.
Sonali Bank Limited as the largest state owned commercial bank has commenced its Islamic
Banking operation since 29 June 2010 at the following five branches with separate window.
Fakirapool branch,Dhaka
To facilitate the online Shariah based banking at the door step of the religious
Muslims
& public welfare Banking, ensuring a proper & developed financial Management,
based on Islamic Shariah.
To bring dynamism in Islamic banking by utilizing the well versed experience &
1. Collection of Deposits
37
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
2. Investment Assistance
a) Al-Wadeeah A/C
b) Mudaraba A/C
2.9.3.1
.a. Al-Wadeeah Current A/C
:
Islamic Banking Windows operates Al- Wadeeah current A/C, based on Al- Wadeeah policy
of Islamic Shariah. In this policy bank undertake to make payment of A/C holders money on
demand & A/C holders permits the bank to utilize his/her money. A/C holders can make
transactions randomly No profit given by the bank & no loss beared by the A/C holder.
2.9.3.1
.b. Mudaraba A/C
:
As per Mudaraba policy of Islamic Shariah the following A/Cs are being maintained.
In these accounts ‘Bank’ is treated as ‘Mudarib’ and client is treated as ‘Sahib Al Mal’.
Bank receives deposit from the depositors and invest it as per Shariah Law and distribute
(minimum 65%) profit earned for the Mudaraba fund as weigtage basis at the end of the
year.
38
2.9.3.1
.b.iv. Mudaraba Haj Savings A/C
:
(Pilgrim) but unable to manage the required fund at a time, by savings fixed monthly
installment for the particular period of time from 1 year to 20 year, the person concerned can
build the fund. Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
A. Trading:
i. Bi-Murabaha
ii. Bi-Muazzal
iii. Bi-Salam
iv. Bi-Istisna
2.9.3.2
.A.i. Bai-Murabaha (Sale in profit as per contact
):
Sale in profit on purchased value in consent of both Bank & Client, Called Bi- Murabaha.
39
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
The business contract in which bank made advanced payment against the supply of
commodities in a future stipulated period of time is called Bi- Salam. On taking delivery of
the commodities on the specified time the bank can sale these to other party.
2.9.3.2.A.iv. Bi-Istisna:
A contract between seller & Buyer under which seller/supplier undertake to supply on
manufacturing the particular goods to the buyer/receiver is called Bi-Istina. The details of
contract i,e, value, nature, pattern, class, Amount, Place, Time & mode of payment,
carrying cost etc must be mentioned in the contract.
People can contact to have any information or discussion/suggestion at any time to our
nearby window or Islami Banking Department.
Tel: 88-02-9556608,
website:www.sonalibank.com.b
d
40
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
People can contact to have any information or discussion/suggestion at any time to our
nearby window or Islami Banking Department.
Tel: 88-02-9556608,
website:www.sonalibank.com.b
d
41
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
At the system level, stress tests are primarily designed to quantify the impact of possible
changes in economic environment on the financial system. The system level stress tests
also complement the institutional level stress testing by providing information about the
sensitivity of the overall financial system to a number of risk factors. These tests help the
regulators to identify structural vulnerabilities and the overall risk exposure that could
42
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
However, one of the limitations of this technique is that stress tests do not account for the
probability of occurrence of these exceptional events. For this purpose, other techniques,
for example VAR (value at risks) models etc. are used to supplement the stress tests. These
tests help in managing risk within a financial institution to ensure optimum allocation of
capital across its risk profile.
In depth, Stress tests focus on a few key risks – such as credit risk, market risk, and
liquidity risk – to banks' financial health in crisis situations. The results of stress tests
depend on the assumptions made in various economic scenarios, which are described by
the International Monetary Fund as "unlikely but plausible." Bank stress tests attracted a
great deal of attention in 2009, as the worst global financial crisis since the Great
Depression left many banks and financial institutions severely under-capitalized.
Large international banks began using internal stress tests in the early 1990s. In 1996, the
Basel Capital Accord was amended to require banks and investment firms to conduct stress
tests to determine their ability to respond to market events.
However, up until 2007, stress tests were typically performed only by the banks
themselves, for internal self-assessment. Beginning in 2007, governmental regulatory
bodies became interested in conducting their own stress tests to insure the effective
operation of financial institutions. Since then, stress tests have been routinely performed by
financial regulators in different countries or regions, to insure that the banks under their
authority are engaging in practices likely to avoid negative outcomes. In India, legislation
was enacted in 2007 requiring banks to undergo regular stress tests. In October 2012, U.S.
43
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
regulators unveiled new rules expanding this practice by requiring the largest American
banks to undergo stress tests twice per year, once internally and once conducted by the
regulators. Starting in 2014, midsized firms are also being required to conduct Dodd-Frank
Act Stress Testing. In 2012, federal regulators also began recommending portfolio stress
testing as a sound risk management practice for community banks or institutions that were
too small to fall under Dodd-Frank's requirements. The Office of the Comptroller of the
Currency (OCC) in an October 18, 2012, Bulletin recommends stress testing as means to
identify and quantify loan portfolio risk. The FDIC made similar recommendations for
community banks.
Extreme market movements or crises in the past reveal the inadequacy of managing risks
based only on normal business conditions and historical trends Current financial turmoil
have augmented the importance of better understanding of potential vulnerabilities in the
financial system and the measures to assess these vulnerabilities for both the regulators and
the bankers. The regulators and managers of the financial system around the globe have
developed a number of quantitative techniques to assess the potential risks to the individual
institutions as well as financial system. A range of quantitative techniques that could serve
the purpose is widely known as ‘stress testing’. IMF and Basel Committee on banking
supervision have also suggested for conducting stress tests on the financial sector.
Its impact will be measured only on the dependent variable i.e. capital in this case, while
the impact of this change in interest rate on NPLs or exchange rate or any other risk factor
is not considered.
44
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Scenarios can be designed to encompass both movements in a group of risk factors and the
changes in the underlying relationships between these variables (for example correlations
and volatilities). Stress testing can be based on the historical scenarios, a backward looking
approach, or the hypothetical scenario, a forward‐looking approach.
The Stress Testing at this stage is only a single factor sensitivity analysis. Each of the five
risk factors has been given shocks of three different levels. The magnitude of shock has
been defined separately for each risk factor for all the three levels of shocks.
45
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
e) Liquidity Risk
So, we can see the Procedure of Stress Testing through this relation figure:-
BS Positions
Interest DGAP
Rate Risk MVE
Exchange
Rate Risk
Liquidity Equity
Risk Price Risk
So, there are main four work-steps to complete Stress Testing, best seen as a process: part
investigative, part diagnostic, part numerical, and part interpretive. Ideally, this process
begins with the identification of specific vulnerabilities or areas of concern, followed by
the construction of a scenario in the context of a consistent macroeconomic framework.
The next step is to map the outputs of the scenario into a form that is usable for an analysis
of financial institutions’ balance sheets and income statements, then performing the
numerical analysis, considering any second round effects, and finally summarizing and
interpreting the results. We can see these steps as following figure:
46
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Investigatio Diagnostic
n s
Interpretio Analytics
n
Figure 6: Parts of Stress Testing
The Stress Testing for credit risk assesses the impact of increase in the level of
47
nonperforming loans of the bank/FI. This involves six types of shocks:
The first deals with the increase in the Non-Performing Loans and the respective
performing loans directly downgraded to bad/loss category having 100% provisioning
requirement.
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
The second deals with the negative shift in the NPLs categories and hence the increase in
respective provisioning. The three scenarios shall explain the impact of 50%, 80% and
100% downward shift in the NPLs categories. For example, for the first level of shock
50% of the SMA shall be categorized under substandard, 50% of the substandard shall
be categorized under doubtful and 50% of the doubtful shall be added to the bad/loss
category.
The third deals with the fall in the forced sale value (FSV) of mortgaged collateral. The
forced sale values of the collateral shall be given shocks of 10%, 20% and 40% decline
in the forced sale value of mortgaged collateral for all the three scenarios respectively.
The fourth deals with the increase of the NPLs in particular 1 or 2 sector i.e. garments &
Textiles and the respective provisioning. The three scenarios shall explain the impact of
5%, 7.5% and 10% performing loans of particular 1 or 2 sectors directly downgraded to
The fifth deals with the increase of the NPLs due to default of Top 10 large borrowers
and the respective provisioning. The three scenarios shall explain the impact of 5%, 7.5%
and 10% performing loans of Top 10 large borrowers directly downgraded to bad/loss
category having 100% provisioning requirement.
The sixth deals with extreme events in which due to increase in the certain percentage of
NPLs, the whole capital position of a bank will be wiped out to offset the increased
amount of provision due to cover respective loan losses. The forced sale value of the
‐adjusted impact of the additional required provision (if any) will be
collaterals and tax
calibrated in the CAR for the each scenario under all categories.
48
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
The fifth deals with the increase of the NPLs due to default of Top 10 large borrowers
and the respective provisioning. The three scenarios shall explain the impact of 5%, 7.5%
and 10% performing loans of Top 10 large borrowers directly downgraded to bad/loss
category having 100% provisioning requirement.
The sixth deals with extreme events in which due to increase in the certain percentage of
NPLs, the whole capital position of a bank will be wiped out to offset the increased
amount of provision due to cover respective loan losses. The forced sale value of the
‐adjusted impact of the additional required provision (if any) will be
collaterals and tax
calibrated in the CAR for the each scenario under all categories.
49
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
portion of the Sensitivity in CAMELS is interest rate risk. Much of what is known about
assessing interest rate risk has been developed by the interaction of financial institutions
with their regulators since the 1990s. Interest rate risk is unquestionably the largest part of
the Sensitivity analysis in the CAMELS system for most banking institutions. When a bank
receives a bad CAMELS rating equity holders, bond holders and creditors are at risk of
loss, senior managers can lose their jobs and the firms are put on the FDIC problem bank
list.
Interest rate risk is the potential that the value of the on‐balance sheet and the off-balance
sheet positions of the bank/DFI would be negatively affected with the change in the interest
rates. The vulnerability of an institution towards the adverse movements of the interest rate
can be gauged by using duration GAP analysis.
The banks and FIs shall follow the following steps in carrying out the interest rate stress
tests:
Estimate the market value of all on‐balance sheet rate sensitive assets and liabilities
of the bank/DFI to arrive at market value of equity
Calculate the durations of each class of asset and the liability of the on‐balance
sheet
portfolio Arrive at the aggregate weighted average duration of assets and liabilities
Estimate the changes in the economic value of equity due to change in interest rates
on on‐balance sheet positions along the three interest rate changes.
Estimate the impact of the net change (both for on‐balance sheet and off‐balance
sheet) in the market value of equity on the capital adequacy ratio (CAR).
Market value of the asset or liability shall be assessed by calculating its present value
discounted at the prevailing interest rate. The outstanding balances of the assets and
50
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
liabilities should be taken along with their respective maturity or re-pricing period,
whichever is earlier.
A positive duration gap signifies that the assets are relatively more interest rate sensitive
than liabilities. Hence if the interest rates rise, the value of assets will fall proportionately
more than the value of liabilities and the market value of equity will fall accordingly and
vice versa.
The duration GAP is measured by comparing the weighted average duration of assets with
the weighted average duration of liabilities (leverage‐adjusted, this takes into account the
existence of equity as a means of financing assets).
51
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
The impact of interest rate change on interest bearing off‐balance sheet contracts shall be
separately calculated. As a first step, the actual market price of each contract shall be
determined which should represent the actual price of the contract if sold immediately.
The second step involves calculating the market price again by marking to market each
contract separately assuming a change in interest rate. The difference between the two
market prices would determine the amount of revaluation surplus or deficit. The
revaluation surplus would arise if the actual market price of the contract is less than the
price calculated after assuming a change in the interest rate and revaluation deficit would
result in, if otherwise. The revaluation surplus/deficit arising due to the change in the
interest rates of the off‐balance sheet contracts should be subtracted/ added to the fall in
52
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
market value of equity derived by the DGAP approach to arrive at the net change in the
market value of equity.
The impact of this net change in the market value of equity will then be calibrated in the
CAR. The tax‐adjusted impact of this net fall (if any) in the MVE shall be adjusted from
the regulatory capital and the risk‐weighted assets and the revised CAR shall be calculated
under each of the above scenarios.
The Stress Testing for exchange rate assesses the impact of change in exchange rate on the
value of equity. To assess foreign exchange risk the overall net open position of the
bank/FI including the on‐balance sheet and off‐balance sheet exposures shall be charged by
the weightage of 5%, 10% and 15% for minor, moderate and major levels respectively. The
overall net open position is measured by aggregating the sum of net short positions or the
sum of net long positions; whichever is greater. The impact of the respective shocks will
have to be calibrated in terms of the CAR. The tax‐adjusted loss if any arising from the
shocked position will be adjusted from the capital. The revised CAR will then be
calculated after adjusting total loss from the risk‐weighted assets of the bank/FI.
53
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
The measure of risk used in the equity markets is typically the standard deviation of a
security's price over a number of periods. The standard deviation will delineate the normal
fluctuations one can expect in that particular security above and below the mean, or
average. However, since most investors would not consider fluctuations above the average
return as risk, some economists prefer other means of measuring it.
The Stress Testing for equity price risk assesses the impact of the fall in the stock market
index. Appropriate shocks will have to be absorbed to the respective securities if the
current market value of all the on balance sheet and off balance sheet securities listed on
the stock exchanges including shares, NIT units, mutual funds etc. falls at the rate of 10%,
20% and 40% respectively. The impact of resultant loss will be calibrated in the CAR.
The Stress Testing for liquidity risk evaluates the resilience of the banks towards the fall in
liquid liabilities. The ratio “liquid assets to liquid liabilities” shall be calculated before and
after the application of shocks by dividing the liquid assets with liquid liabilities. Liquid
assets are the assets that are easily turned into cash without the threat of loss. They include
cash, balances with Bangladesh Bank and balances with banks, call money lending,
lending under repo and investment in government securities. Liquid liabilities include the
deposits and the borrowings. Appropriate shocks will have to be absorbed to the liquid
liabilities if the current liquidity position falls at the rate of 10%, 20% and 30%
respectively. The ratio of liquid assets to liquid liabilities shall be re‐calculated under each
scenario.
54
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Enhanced
Stress
Prudential
Testing
Supervision
Stress tests can be applied to both the asset and liability sides of a portfolio. They can be used
to assess a variety of risks, including market risk (the possibility of losses from changes in
prices or yields), credit risk (potential for losses from borrower defaults or nonperformance on
a contract), and liquidity risk (the possibility of depositor runs or losses from assets becoming
illiquid). For example, instead of valuing a portfolio using current market values for interest
rates, foreign exchange rates, and equity prices, a Stress Testing could involve valuing the
same balance sheet using a different set of market prices.
More complex stress tests involving multiple risk scenarios or changes in the
macroeconomic environment still amount to the same thing: revaluing a portfolio under a
different set of assumptions.
55
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
All banks and FIs are expected to carry out stress testing on half‐yearly basis. Many
training programs are being arranged by different organizations and institutions.
Stress tests can involve changes in almost any aspect of a portfolio, including the prices
used to calculate market values; as well as the duration, liquidity, default rates, and
recovery rates assumed for the portfolio. Stress tests can also be used to examine the
impact of changes in the operating environment beyond changes in these parameters. For
example, stress tests can be employed to assess the impact of changes in prudential
regulations, stricter enforcement of provisioning rules, or a different accounting treatment
of allowable capital.
Stress tests usually produce a numerical estimate of the change in value of the portfolio.
This change in value is often expressed in terms of the impact on some measure of capital,
to understand the sensitivity of the net worth of the institution to the risk being considered.
Each stage of the process is important to understanding the sensitivity of a financial system
to a particular shock or vulnerability. These stages are not necessarily sequential, as some
modification or review of each component of the process may be desirable as work
progresses.
As a starting point the scope of the Stress Testing is limited to simple sensitivity analysis.
Five different risk factors namely; interest rate, forced sale value of collateral,
nonperforming loans (NPLs), stock prices and foreign exchange rate have been identified
and used for the stress testing. Moreover, the liquidity position of the institutions has also
been stressed separately. Though the decision of creating different scenarios for stress
testing is a difficult one, however, to start with, certain levels of shocks to the individual
risk components have been specified considering the historical as well as hypothetical
movement in the risk factors.
56
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
4.1.1 Duration:
Suppose, we are calculating this type of bond, semiannual, maturity of two years:
57
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
58
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
59
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
BRB Crop Loan ৳ 8,66,69,08,085.00 10% 2 10% ৳ 8,66,69,08,085.00 1.9091 0.0178 0.09%
Special Small Loan ৳ 63,55,29,829.00 12% 3 12% ৳ 63,55,29,829.00 2.6901 0.0018 0.01%
60
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
61
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
62
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
= 1.3073
= 0.2440
MVL
DGAP=DA− ×DL63
MVA
= 1.078080941
more price sensitive than that of liabilities and certain rise in interest rate would cause greater
decrease in the value of assets leading to decrease in the market value of equity.
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
4.2
Two types of capital are measured: Tier-One capital, which can absorb losses without a
bank being required to cease trading, and Tier-Two capital, which can absorb losses in the
event of a winding-up and so provides a lesser degree of protection to depositors.
T+T
CAR =
RWA
64
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
This is the main part of the calculation. Now calculate surplus/(deficit) on off‐balance sheet
items under the assumption of three different interest rate changes i.e. 1%, 2%, and 3%.
The impact of the net change (both for on‐balance sheet and off‐balance sheet) in the
market value of equity on the capital adequacy ratio (CAR) should be estimated in the next
step.
65
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
66
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
67
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
sectors
v. Increase of NPLs due to default of Top loan borrowers and vi. Increase
In those shocks, last most shock should not be calculated with other shocks because that
one removes all capital and shows CAR as 0.00%. So, in the cumulative shock scenarios,
credit shock number-vi should be avoided.
The amounts of classified mortgaged collateral can be found by using the base of provision
for every class of NPL and the percentage of provision in the annual financial report of
Sonali Bank Limited.
= −
So, the other two types are very easy, just use the values of ‘DF’ and ‘B/L’ in the place of
‘SS’.
68
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
69
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
The impact of shift in NPLs to next categories with no change in total NPLs shall be
accounted for as follows:
70
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
71
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Table 15: Credit Risk – increase in NPLs’ under B/L category in a sector
Figure 14: Credit Risk – increase in NPLs’ under B/L category in a sector
Table 16: Credit Shock – increase in NPLs’ due to Top 8 large loan borrowers’ failure
72
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Figure 15: Credit Shock – increase in NPLs’ due to Top 8 loan borrowers’ failure
73
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
74
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
75
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Figure 17: Imagine how stress on your pencil damages what percent of that
5.2 Cumulative Credit Shock Scenarios of SBL
Total stress from aggregate 5 types of credit shock is shown in different scenarios of SBL
below (credit shock for total loss of capital in not included, but discussed later):
76
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
If we see the impact of different levels of shock in individual credit shocks, the easiest way
to draw some pie charts and those charts are given below:
77
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
7.44%
Increase in NPLs
Downgrade of NPL Categories
Fall of FSV of Mortgage
A whole sector shifts into B/L
Top borrowers fail to repay
88.16%
13.38%
Increase in NPLs
Downgrade of NPL Categories
Fall of FSV of Mortgage
A whole sector shifts into B/L
Top borrowers fail to repay
79.26%
78
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Again, there is a huge shock in scenario-1, which represents the minor level of shock.
79
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Though this shows minor level of shock, this is really about moderate shock than the single
‘scenario-1’s of different shocks.
But total moderate level of shock in scenario-2 drives CAR to the negative side and
scenario3, which means the major level of shock is really far below from the current CAR.
Here is the graphical presentation:
5.0 % Curren
2.5 %
CAR (%)
0 tTotal Scenario-1
2
0.0 % Total Scenario-2
0 -0.63
% Total Scenario-3
-5.00
%
-6.57
%
-10.00
%
Cumulative total shock scenarios
As in cumulative credit shock, if we want to see the impact of different level of shocks in
individual shock items, the easiest way to draw some pie charts.
Those charts are given below in order to simplify the category effects of each of the total
scenario.
80
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
1.21% 2.92%
1.77% 4.25%
Credit Shock
57.29% Interest Rate Shock
36.70%
FX rate Shock
Equity Price Shock
81
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
6.02%
1.88%
Credit Shock
53.10
%
Interest Rate Shock
39.01
% FX rate Shock
Equity Price Shock
So, we can see that, with the increase of the level of shock, the impact of Interest Rate Shock
takes place of the credit shock in the Total Shock amount.
82
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
83
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
84
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
85
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Sonali Bank Limited can take long position and in more amount of foreign
currency
They should keep more mortgage collateral to reduce provision for NPLs
6.2 Recommendations
86
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
I would like to suggest, Sonali Bank should strictly follow the principles of sound
lending and they should make stronger their credit monitoring department than the
past times. Among the most important of these are honesty, reliability,
thoroughness and willingness to always be open to new ideas and new ways of
meeting customer needs.
o Repay the loan in full, at the lender's request, in certain events such as
changes in the borrower's debt-to-equity ratio or interest coverage ratio
87
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Credit insurance and credit derivatives: Lenders and bond holders may hedge
their credit risk by purchasing credit insurance or credit derivatives. These contracts
transfer the risk from the lender to the seller (insurer) in exchange for payment. The
most common credit derivative is the credit default swap.
Tightening: Reduce credit risk by reducing the amount of credit extended, either in
total or to certain borrowers. For example, a distributor selling its products to a
troubled retailer may attempt to lessen credit risk by reducing payment terms from
net 30 to net 15.
Sonali Bank Limited may adopt alternative strategies to financial hedging for managing
their economic or operating exposure, by carefully selecting production sites with a mind
for lowering costs, using a policy of flexible sourcing in its supply chain management,
diversifying its export market across a greater number of countries, or by implementing
strong research and development activities and differentiating its products in pursuit of
greater inelasticity and less foreign exchange risk exposure.
88
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
process/procedure to carry out Stress Testing. This framework should be flexible enough to
adopt advanced models for stress testing. It involves:
Defining the coverage and identifying the data required and available.
Identifying, analyzing and proper recording of the assumptions used for stress
testing.
Calibrating the scenarios or shocks applied to the data and interpreting the results.
Ensuring a mechanism for an ongoing review of the results of the Stress Testing
exercise and reflecting in the policies and limits set by management and board of
directors.
Taking this Stress Testing as a starting point and developing in‐house Stress
Testing model to assess the bank/FI’s specific risks.
Conclusion
89
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
occur in different adverse scenarios. By doing Stress Testing top management of financial
organization will be able to know how to take the edge off risk, what should be the
combination of banks portfolio, in which area bank can be more flexible and in which area
bank should reduce investment. One of the alarming areas is stock market collapse in
December 2010.
It is the tool that provides risk managers with additional information on possible portfolio
losses arising from extreme, although plausible, scenarios. In addition, stress scenarios can
often be an effective communication tool within the firm and to outside parties, such as
supervisors and investors.
After completing this report, I am amazed seeing the fact that Sonali Bank Limited is the
largest government commercial bank, its credit policy is not so adequate because some
industries can hamper the regulatory capital up to 1% fall in CAR if they fail to pay 50% of
their borrowed amounts. In the recent past, Sonali Bank Limited suffered from lack of RC
and the reason behind that was the same.
Other than the credit policy, management is not so strong in the branches and so banking is
hampered sometimes and the customers are losing their belief of banking in Sonali Bank
Limited. To make and keep a vital capital in Sonali Bank Limited, stress testing should be
comprehensively used for both internal and external purposes and may be maintained by
individual branches.
Annex-I
In the FS of SBL, the maturity of the deposits could be found as this table-
90
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Annex-II
Interest Rate Shock
Factors for the calculation of interest rate risk scenarios:
91
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Annex-III
92
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Annex-IV
Credit Risk – increase in NPLs Shock
Total NPLs ৳ 86,43,66,40,000.00
93
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
94
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
95
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Annex-VI
Credit Shock – Fall in the FSV of Mortgaged Collateral Calculation
of Weighted FSV of collateral:
SS DF B/L
FSV ৳ 1,61,91,46,371 ৳ 4,62,26,14,029 ৳ 21,62,30,17,743
% of Provision 20% 50% 100%
The Scenario Calculations are following:
Scenario-1 (10% Fall) Amounts % of fall
Total FSV of Mortgaged Collateral ৳ 27,86,47,78,143.45
Weighted Forced Sale Value of Collateral ৳ 24,25,81,54,031.86
Fall in the FSV of Collateral ৳ 2,42,58,15,403.19 10%
Tax adjusted provision (N/A) ৳ 2,42,58,15,403.19 0%
Revised Regulatory Capital ৳ 47,16,00,55,024.81
Revised RWA ৳ 4,02,83,84,84,596.81
Revised CAR (%) 11.71%
Fall in CAR (% points) 0.53%
Annex-VII
Credit Shock – Increase in NPLs’ under B/L category in industry sector: Calculation
of total
WC to industry Hypo. ৳ 3,11,87,62,564.00
WC to industry Pledge ৳ 26,98,11,878.00
Total Industry ৳ 3,38,85,74,442.00
102
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Annex-VIII
Credit Shock – Increase in NPLs’ due to Top 8 large loan borrowers’ failure
103
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
104
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
105
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Total liquid liability = Repay (Within a month + Within 3 months + Within 12 month)
106
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
So, those assets and liabilities are taken which have highest maturity of 12 months. The detailed calculation is given here:
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Begum, S. A. (2015, April 5). Consult about internship report on the topic named Stress
Testing of Sonali Bank Limited. (S. S. Uddin, Interviewer)
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System. (2015, March). Dodd-Frank Act Stress
Test 2015: Supervisory Stress Test Methodology and Results. Washington, DC: Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System.
Helqvist, M. (2006, May). Contagion in Payment and Settlement Systems. Expert Forum
on Advanced Techniques of Stress Testing: Applications for Supervisor (pp. 15,20,22,24).
Washington, DC: Financial Markets and Statistics Department - Bank of Finland.
Islam, M. M. (2013, October, 30). Sustainable Financial Inclusion and Poverty Alleviation
through Smart Banking: A Case of Bank Asia Ltd. Dhaka: Md. Mazharul Islam.
110
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Jones, M. T., Hilbers, P., & Slack, G. (2004, July). Stress Testing Financial Systems: What
to Do When the Governor Calls. IMF Working Paper (pp. 2,4-5,27,32). Washington:
International Monetary Fund.
Kishore. Procedure of Stress Testing. Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited. Noor Research
Centre, Savar, Dhaka.
McKinsey & Company. (2012, July). Strategic Insight Through Stress-Testing. McKinsey
& Company, pp. 2-3.
MIS & Statistics Division. (2015, March 5). Sonali Bank Limited At A Glance As on 28th
February 2015. Sonali Bank Limited Monthly At A Glance. Dhaka, Dhaka, Bangladesh:
Soali
Bank Limited.
Munmun, S. (2015, April-May). Topic of Internship Report and Submission Process. (S. S.
Uddin, Interviewer)
Nesa, J. (2015, April 26-29). Old Allowance, Disorder Allowance and Widow Allowance
process. (S. S. Uddin, Interviewer)
111
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Rahman, M. M. (2015, April 22). Interest Rates, Maturity Periods and Repricing Periods of
Different Types of Loans. (S. S. Uddin, Interviewer)
Rose, P. S., & Hudgins, S. C. (2013). Bank Management & Financial Services. New York:
McGraw-Hill.
Saunders, A., & Cornett, M. M. (2007). Financial Institutions Management. New York:
McGraw Hill/Irwin.
Shamim, M. (2015, Feb-May). Credit/Debit Limits and Depository Systems. (S. S. Uddin,
Interviewer)
Shamim, M. (2015, March 4). Foreign Remittance Receiving Procedures. (S. S. Uddin,
Interviewer)
Sonali Bank Limited. (2014, December,31). Auditors' Report and Financial Statements of
Sonali Bank Limited & its Subsidiaries. Dhaka: Sonali Bank Limited.
Sonali Bank Limited. (2015, May 14). Check-list for Internal Control & Compliance
(ICC). Core Risk Evaluation Methodology. Savar, Dhaka, Bangladesh: Sonali Bank
Limited.
Sonali Bank Limited. (n.d.). Corporate Profile. Retrieved May 24, 2015, from Sonali Bank
Limited: http://www.sonalibank.com.bd/profile.php
Sonali Bank Limited. (n.d.). Credit Rating of SBL. Retrieved February 12, 2015, from
Sonali Bank Limited: http://www.sonalibank.com.bd/PDF_file/CreaditRating/cr-13.gif
Sonali Bank Limited. (n.d.). CSR Activities. Retrieved May 24, 2015, from Sonali Bank
Limited: http://www.sonalibank.com.bd/csr/csr2014.php
Sonali Bank Limited. (n.d.). Islamic Banking. Retrieved February 12, 2015, from Sonali
Bank Limited: http://www.sonalibank.com.bd/
Sonali Bank Limited. (n.d.). Vision & Mission. Retrieved February 10, 2015, from Sonali
Bank Limited: http://www.sonalibank.com.bd/mission.php
Sultana, R. (2015, February-May). Account Opening, Cheque Issue and KYC procedures.
(S. S. Uddin, Interviewer)
112
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
Varshney, P. N. (2005). Banking Law And Practice. Delhi: Sultan Chand and Sons.
Darrel Duffie; Nicolae Gârleanu; Lasse Heje Pedersen (November 2005). "Over-the-
counter markets" (PDF). Econometrica 73 (6): 1815–1847. doi:10.1111/j.1468-
0262.2005.00639.x.
August 8, 2012.
Lopez, Jose A. (2005, June). Stress Tests: Useful Complements to Financial Risk Models
113
Stress Testing of Sonali Bank Limited
114