Effects of Kinesiotaping With and Without Pelvic Tilts On Pain and Menstrual Distress in Females With Dysmenorrhea-Merged
Effects of Kinesiotaping With and Without Pelvic Tilts On Pain and Menstrual Distress in Females With Dysmenorrhea-Merged
Effects of Kinesiotaping With and Without Pelvic Tilts On Pain and Menstrual Distress in Females With Dysmenorrhea-Merged
NameofStudent:IZZAWAHEED
Registration Number: --------------
InPartialFulfillmentofRequirementsfortheAwardof Degreeof
Master of Science in Physical Therapy (Women’s Health)
RiphahCollegeofRehabilitation&AlliedHealth
Sciences
RIPHAH
INTERNATIONAL
UNIVERSITYLAHORE
I
RIPHAH INTERNATIONALUNIVERSITY
ACADEMICPROGRESSREPORT
As on
FortheperiodfromOctober2020toJune2022
1. PersonalInformationofScholar:
Name: IzzaWaheed
RegistrationNo.:
Program: MS-WHPT
Faculty/Department:
Email: [email protected]
2. AcademicProgress:
remaining):
ExpectedDateof June2022
Completion of
ResearchWork:
ExpectedDateof June2022
Completionof
Program:
LastGPAandCGPA 4.00
(Pleaseattachresult of
each semester):
3. ResearchTopic:
menstrualdistressinfemaleswithdysmenorrhea
DateofApproval 5thNov, 2021
Nameof Supervisor Dr.GhulamFatima
NameofCo-
Supervisor(ifany):
II
Statusof Research
Work
4. EmploymentStatus:
Unemployed
Employed(jobplace,
title,andstatus—i.e.,
onstudyleaveor
otherwise)
Please Note: The scholars under HEC Indigenous 5000 Fellowship Program shall not
undertakeanyemploymentwhetherpaidorotherwiseatanystageduringtheircourseof study of the
program.
5. Remarksofthe Supervisor:
6. Overallprogress:(pleasetickonlyone)
Verified/Certifiedby Countersignedby
Supervisor HODPhysical Therapy
Dr.GhulamFatima Prof.DrMuhammadSalmanBashir
Name: Name:
Signature: Signature:
Date: Date:
III
Author’sDeclaration
I,IzzaWaheedherebystatethatmyMSthesis titled,
NameofStudent:IzzaWaheed
Date:
IV
PlagiarismUndertaking
I solemnly declare that research work present in the thesis titled “Effects of Kinesiotaping
withand without pelvic tilts on Pain and Menstrual distress in females with dysmenorrhea”
is solely my research work with no significant contribution from any other person. Small
contribution/help wherever taken has been dulyacknowledged and that complete thesis has been
written by me.
I understand the zero tolerance policy of the HEC and University Riphah
InternationalUniversity,Lahoretowardplagiarism.Therefore,IasanAuthoroftheabovetitledthesis
declare that “no portion of my thesis has been plagiarized and any material used as reference is
properly referred/cited”.
IunderstandthatifIamfoundguiltyofanyformalplagiarismintheabovetitledthesisevenafter award of
MS degree, the University reserves the rights to withdraw/revoke my MS degree and HEC and
the University has the right to publish my name on the HEC/University Website on which names
of the students are placed who submitted plagiarized thesis.
Student/AuthorSignature:
Name: Izza Waheed
V
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
IamoverwhelmedinallhumblenesstoexpressextremegratitudeinalldepthtotheHighestbeing, Allah
Almightywho has bestowed immense blessings on me. Allah Almightyalone is worthyof
allpraise.Heguidedmythroughouttheprojectandinstalledbrilliantideasinmymindtocomplete this
project titled “Effects of Kinesiotaping with and without pelvic tilts on Pain and Menstrual
Distress in females with dysmenorrhea”.
Second, I would like to acknowledge with extreme thanks the patronage, loving inspiration and
timely guidance which I have received from my supervisor Dr. Ghulam Fatima. I would like to
convey my heartfelt appreciation and gratefulness to her for providing me the wonderful
opportunity to work on this very project. She has been a source of constant guidance the project.
Her willingness to share her vast knowledge and constructive criticism was my source of
inspiration throughout the project.
I am highly indebted to my parents for their unconditional support emotionally and financially.
My parents owe the entire credit in myself proudly completing Masters of Science in Women
HealthPhysicalTherapy.Theybelievedinmeandmypassion.Anunshakeableandwholehearted
thankstomyparentsforinvestingzealandzestinmymindtoencounterlifehappenings.Iexpress deep
gratitude to myparents forteachingme that lifeis all about growth, happiness and struggle. I
would also like to extend my gratitude towards mysiblings for their outright support during all
times of life.
VI
DECLARATION
VII
SIGNATURES
Title:EFFECTSOFKINESIOTAPINGWITHANDWITHOUT
PELVIC TILTS ON PAIN AND MENSTRUAL DISTRESS IN
FEMALES WITH DYSMENORRHEA
RegistrationNo:------------------------------------
1. Dr.GhulamFatima(Supervisor)
2. Dr. (Internal)
DefenseCommittee(Name&Signatures)
1. Dr. (Supervisor)
2. Dr. (External)
3. . Dr. (Internal)
VIII
SUPERVISOR’SCERTIFICATE
NameofStudent:IzzaWaheed Signature:
Date:
Supervisor’sName:Dr.GhulamFatima
Signature:
Date:
IX
ABSTRACT
Background
Dysmenorrheaisaconditiondescribedaschroniccrampingpainassociatedwithmenstrualcycle.
Dysmenorrhea is categorized as being primary (absence of pelvic pathology) and secondary
(presence of pelvic pathologies i.e. endometriosis, fibroids and ovarian cysts). Various treatment
strategies exist to cope with this treatment i.e., pharmacological interventions and exercise. Two
most commonly used treatment approaches are active stretching and application of kinesiotape.
KT is believed to alleviate symptoms of dysmenorrhea through neural and muscular stimulation.
Activestretchingofpelvicareai.e.pelvictiltsisthoughttobringpelvicregioninproperalignment and
contribute to lessen dysmenorrhea symptoms
Objective
The main aim of study was to investigate effects of KT with and without pelvic tilts on pain and
menstrual distress in females with dysmenorrhea
Methods
The study was a randomized controlled trial conducted in University of Sialkot, Kashmir road
CampusSialkot.Thestudydurationwas6months.Thestudyincluded30participants.Participants were
equally divided and randomly allocated to two groups; Group A (KT with pelvic tilts) & Group
B (KT without pelvic tilts). Pre-intervention data was collected through NPRS, WaLIDD tool &
MDQ in the first menstrual cycle. Interventions were carried for the next two consecutive
menstrual cycles. Post-intervention data was collected in the fourth menstrual cycle.
Results
NPRS score Between group analysis via Independent Samples T-test of group A and group B
shows pre-treatment p-value as 0.393 and 0.453 respectively. Both groups A and B exhibited
decreased p-value post-treatment to 0.000 and 0.002 respectively. Moreover, MDQ score Between
group analysis via Mann-Whitney Testpost-treatment of both group A and Bhadp-
value<0.05forallsymptomsi.e.pain,concentration,behavioralchanges,autonomicreactions,waterrete
ntion,negativeeffect, arousal and control
Conclusion
X
BothgroupA(KTwithpelvictilts)andgroupB(KTwithoutpelvictilts)exhibitedimprovements
XI
in NPRS and MDQ post-treatment. However, group A whose participants were given KT in
combination with pelvic tilts exhibited significantly greater improvements in NPRS and MDQ
score than group B
Keywords
Activestretching,Kinesiotape,Painfulmenstruation,Menstrualpain
XII
TABLEOF CONTENTS
Contents
EFFECTS OF KINESIOTAPING WITH AND WITHOUT PELVIC TILTS ON PAIN AND
MENSTRUALDISTRESSINFEMALESWITH DYSMENORRHEA........................................I
ACADEMICPROGRESSREPORT....................................................................................................II
AUTHOR’S DECLARATION.........................................................................................................IV
SIGNATURES................................................................................................................................VIII
SUPERVISOR’SCERTIFICATE......................................................................................................IX
ABSTRACT.......................................................................................................................................X
TABLEOF CONTENTS............................................................................................................XVII
LIST OF FIGURES……………………………………………………………………………XIV
LIST OF TABLES………………………………………………………………………………XV
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS…………………………………………………………………..XVI
1. INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................1
2. LITERATUREREVIEW.......................................................................................................4
3. MATERIAL&METHODS:...................................................................................................9
3.1 STUDYDESIGN..........................................................................................................................9
3.2 SETTING.....................................................................................................................................9
3.3 DURATIONOFTHESTUDY.......................................................................................................9
3.4 SAMPLESIZE.............................................................................................................................9
3.5 STUDYGROUPS......................................................................................................................10
3.6 SAMPLINGTECHNIQUE........................................................................................................10
3.7 SAMPLESELECTION..............................................................................................................10
3.7.1 INCLUSIONCRITERIA.....................................................................................................10
3.7.2 EXCLUSIONCRITERIA....................................................................................................10
3.8 RANDOMIZATIONMETHOD:...............................................................................................11
3.9 TREATMENTAPPROACH......................................................................................................11
3.9.1 Pre-interventionapproach:...................................................................................................11
3.9.2 Intervention:........................................................................................................................11
3.9.3 GroupA Interventions:........................................................................................................11
3.9.4 GroupB Interventions:.........................................................................................................12
XIII
3.9.5 Post-interventionapproach:.................................................................................................12
3.10 DATACOLLECTIONTOOL...................................................................................................13
3.10.1 NumericPainRatingScale(NPRS):.....................................................................................13
3.10.2 WaLIDDTool:...................................................................................................................13
3.10.3 MenstrualDistressQuestionnaire(MDQ):..........................................................................13
3.11 DATACOLLECTIONPROCEDURE:.....................................................................................14
3.11.1 CONSORTFLOWCHART...............................................................................................14
3.12 DATAANALYSISPROCEDURE:..........................................................................................15
4. RESULTS..............................................................................................................................16
5. DISCUSSION:.......................................................................................................................37
6. CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................................40
7. LIMITATIONSOFTHESTUDY:........................................................................................41
8. RECOMMENDATIONS:....................................................................................................42
9. REFERENCES:....................................................................................................................43
ANNEXUREI:ENGLISHCONSENTFORM..............................................................................48
ANNEXUREII:URDUCONSENTFORM...................................................................................49
ANNEXUREIII:NUMERICPAINRATING SCALE.................................................................50
ANNEXURE V:WALIDDTOOL.................................................................................................51
ANNEXUREV:MENSTRUALDISTRESSQUESTIONNAIRE(MDQ)...................................52
XIV
LISTOFFIGURES
Figure4.3SOCIOECONOMICSTATUS…………………………...18
Figure4.4MARITALSTATUS………………………………….….19
Figure4.5REGULARITYOFMENSTRUALCYCLE………….....20
Figure4.6LIFESTYLE……………………………………………...21
Figure4.7PAINLOCATION……………………………………….22
Figure4.8PAINCHARACTER…………………………………….23
Figure4.9FIRSTEXPERIENCEOFPAIN………………………...24
Figure4.10PAININITIATION…………………………………….25
Figure4.11PAINLENGTH………………………………………...26
Figure4.12OTHEREXPERIENCES………………………………27
XV
LISTOFTABLES
Table4.1TESTOF NORMALITY…………………………………………….16
Table4.2DEMOGRAPHICDETAILS…………………………………………17
Table4.13WaLIDDBETWEENGROUPANALYSIS(MANN-WHITNEY TEST)
……………………………………………………………………………28
Table 4.14 MDQ (PRE-TREATMENT) BETWEEN GROUP ANALYSIS
(MANN-WHITNEY TEST) …………………………………………………….29
Table4.15 MDQ(PRE-TREATMENT)BETWEEN GROUPANALYSIS
(MANN-WHITNEY TEST) …………………………………………………….30
Table 4.16 MDQ (POST-TREATMENT) BETWEEN GROUP ANALYSIS
(MANN-WHITNEY TEST) …………………………………………………….31
Table 4.17MDQ (POST-TREATMENT) BETWEEN GROUP ANALYSIS
(MANN-WHITNEY TEST) …………………………………………………….32
Table4.18 NPRS BETWEEN GROUP ANALYSIS
(INDEPENDENT SAMPLES T-TEST) ……………………33
Table 4.19 WaLIDDWITHINGROUPANALYSIS
(WILCOXON SIGNED RANK TEST) ……………………34
Table 4.20NPRS WITHIN GROUP ANALYSIS (PAIRED
SAMPLE T-TEST) ………………………………………….35
Table 4.21MDQ WITHIN GROUP ANALYSIS
(WILCOXON SIGNED RANK TEST)…………………………36
XVI
LISTOFABBREVIATIONS
1. KT Kinesiotape
2. NPRS NumericPainRatingScale
3. MDQ MenstrualDistress
Questionnaire
4. WaLIDD Workingability,Location,
Intensity,Daysofpain,
Dysmenorrhea
5. VAS VisualAnalogueScale
XVII
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
1. INTRODUCTION
Dysmenorrhea is a chronic pelvic pain associated with menstrual cycle. Quite often,
dysmenorrhea is termed as cramping pain in below the umbilical region during or before
menstruation. Initial presentation of dysmenorrhea occurs at menarche and continues with
regular ovulation (1).
There is some evidence that elevation or reduction in Prostaglandin levels leads to primary
dysmenorrhea. Therefore, non-steroidal anti-inflammatorydrugs (NSAIDS)arethe first line
oftreatmentoption.Thepain-relievingeffectsofNSAIDSarethoughttobeduetoinhibition of
cyclooxygenase enzyme & reduced menstrual blood volume. They also exert a direct
analgesiceffectonthecentralnervoussystem.However,Long-termuseofNSAIDShasbeen
documented to increase the risk of cardiovascular abnormalities. Therefore, alternative
treatment options such as physical activity and mild exercise have been proposed to reduce
dysmenorrhea (4).
Various treatment approaches exist to cope with dysmenorrhea. Most commonly used are
medications & Yoga. Physical therapy intervention options include TENS, IFT, hot packs,
massage,tapingand gentleexercises (5).Stretchingexerciseshave alsobeendocumented to
exert beneficial effects on pain intensity of dysmenorrhea. Stretching exercises aid to relax
musclesintension.Anumberofstretchingexerciseshavebeendocumentedinevidencesuch as
heel raise, chin touch, forward bend and much more (7).
Thereisevidencethatpelvicalignmenthasaneffectonmenstrualpainduetodysmenorrhea.
1
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Kim,BaekandGoodescribedthattherewasasignificantdifferenceinpelvictorsionbetween
women with menstrual pain and women who did not have, which suggests that pelvic
alignment may have an effect on dysmenorrhea (34). This finding complies with the earlier
accountthatwithdysmenorrhea,thereisarestrictionintherangeofmotionofposteriorpelvic tilt in
relation to the legs and the spine (33). Studies have shown that women with higher
pelvictorsionhavehigherrateofdysmenorrheabecauseofspinalmalalignment,whichleads to an
imbalance in the amounts ofoxytocin and prostaglandin (34). A changein theposition of the
uterus caused by an excessive amount of prostaglandin produced could be one explanation
for the pelvic imbalance (31). Females with dysmenorrhea may be able to
minimizetheirpainiftheirspinalalignmentisrestoredtonormal.Itisthoughtthatcutaneous
sensations elicited by spinal segment motion, such as that experienced with pelvic tilts, can
cause changes in the activity of the internal organs, so alleviating dysmenorrhea (32).
Posterior pelvic tilts combined with tape can aid in the correction of a pelvic imbalance and
inappropriate restriction of mobility of the lumbosacral vertebrae, which is caused by
increased bodily fluids within the pelvis, as well as uterine contractions that intensify
menstruation pain.
2
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
approachestocopewiththepain&distressin menstruation.
3
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
2. LITERATUREREVIEW
The effectiveness of kinesiotaping has already been described in various studies. Patel and
Dhupkar conducted an experimental study to compare the effect of only kinesiotaping and
kinesiotapig with pelvic tilts on primary dysmenorrhea. Their study included 42 nulliparous
unmarriedwomanofagegroup18-30.Subjectswererandomlydividedintwogroups.Group A
received taping alone while Group B received taping & pelvic tilt exercises. They concluded
that taping had immediate effects only while taping with pelvic tilts exerted positive effects
both immediately and in the next menstrual cycle (8).
Koo et al. conducted a case study to discover effects of kinematic taping therapy on
dysmenorrhea. A 25-year-old women with no history of allergic reactions to tape was
selected. The studyfound beneficial effects of kinematic taping therapyapplication on pain,
menstrual distress and Prostaglandins (9).
Roozbahani and Najad conducted a quasi-experimental study to compare the effects of
stretching exercises & kinesiotaping. Thirty female high school students were selected and
dividedintothreegroups.Firstgroupreceivedstretchingexerciseinterventions,secondgroup was
given kinesiotape application and third group was not given any intervention. They
concluded that kinesiotaping had better effects than stretching exercises in reducing the
cramping pain of dysmenorrhea however, stretching exercises were more useful in terms of
increase in range of motion (10).
Jerdy-S.S et al. conducted an experimental study to assess effect of one term of stretching
exercises on primary dysmenorrhea of high school girls. 179 single girls were recruited and
divided into groups. The intervention group was requested to complete session of stretching
exercises for 8 weeks. Theyconcluded that stretchingexercises arebeneficial to reduce pain
intensity, pain duration and amount of painkillers used during primary dysmenorrhea (11).
Barati et al. carried out a semi-experimental study to compare the effects of stretching
exercises and combination of massage-stretching exercises on primary dysmenorrhea. 90
students were recruited for the study and divided into three groups to practice the protocol.
According to their results, stretching exercises & massage-stretching combination is equally
effective as other noninvasive methods (12).
VaziriF.etal.conductedarandomizedclinicaltrialtocomparetheeffectsofaerobicand
4
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
stretchingexercisesonseverityofprimardysmenorrhea.105participantswererecruitedand
divided into three groups. One group received aerobic exercise program, second group
received stretching exercise program while third group received no exercise program. The
studydiscoveredthatbothaerobicandstretchingexerciseprogramswereequallyeffectivein
reducing the pain intensity of dysmenorrhea however, women opted for one intervention
based on their lifestyle and interest (13).
Gamit S.K et al. conducted a quasi-experimental study to demonstrate effects of stretching
exercise on primary dysmenorrhea. 30 participants diagnosed with primary dysmenorrhea
weredividedintotwo groups.Group Areceived stretchingexercise programwhile Group B
received no exercise program. The study concluded that stretching exercises are effective in
reducing the pain associated with dysmenorrhea (14).
Arshad S. et al. conducted a survery-based quasi experimental study to demonstrate and
comparetheeffectivenessoftapingtechnique &hydrotherapyonprimarydysmenorrhea.50
menstruating women were randomly divided into two groups. The study discovered that
taping technique was more effective than hydrotherapy technique in reducing the pain
intensity of primary dysmenorrhea (15).
GuruprasadP.etal.conductedanexperimentalstudytoshowtheimmediateeffectsofYoga
postures versus physiotherapyexercises with K-tapingon pain in dysmenorrhea. 30 subjects
were divided into two groups. The study concluded that yogic postures and physiotherapy
exercises with K-taping were both effective in immediate reduction of pain associated with
primary dysmenorrhea (16).
Gil-M E. et al. conducted a pilot study to demonstrate and compare the effectiveness of
kinesiotaping and auricular acupressure on primary dysmenorrhea. 114 participants were
randomlyallocatedtoakinesio-tapegroup,placebokinesio-tapegroup,auricularacupressure
group & auricular acupressure placebo group. The study concluded that both interventions
wereeffectiveinreducingthepainintensityofprimarydysmenorrheahowever,theresultsof
auricular acupressure were observed to last longer (17).
Toprak Celenay, Kavalci, Karakus and Alkan investigated the effects of kinesiotaping on
pain, anxiety, and menstrual complaints in women with primarydysmenorrhea. The authors
randomized 51 women with primarydysmenorrhea into three groups, namelykinesiotaping,
shamtaping,andcontrol,andfoundoutthatkinesiotapinghadbeneficialeffectsonthese
5
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
areas. Specifically, kinesiotaping application was found to have greater effects on the stated
parameters (e.g. pain intensity and anxiety levels) when compared to the control and sham
taping.Additionally,therewerelowerreportsoflowbackpain,abdominalswelling,fatigue,
nausea, insomnia, nervousness, and depression in the subjects who received kinesiotaping
than in the other two groups. The reduction in menstrual complaints was found to be greater
inthekinesiotapinggroupthaninthecontrolandshamtapinggroups.Ofthesepositiveresults
fromkinesiotaping,however,theauthorsfailedtodescribedegreesofpelvictilt,iftherewere (22).
Doğan, Eroğlu and Akbayrak comparatively examined the effects of kinesiotaping and
lifestyle changes and lifestyle changes alone on pain, body awareness, and quality of life in
women with primary dysmenorrhea, and found out that although there were positive results
seen in both groups, reduction in pain severity and improvements in body awareness and
quality of life was greater in the group that received both types of interventions. However,
there was no description of the amount of pelvic tilt mentioned (23).
Bhosale, Golhar and Shende studied the effect of kinesiotaping on pain in women with
primarydysmenorrheaandmeasuredtheoutcomeusingtheVisualAnalogueScale.Thetrial
included40womenwithprimarydysmenorrheawhoreceivedkinesiotaping,whichafforded the
subjects a significant reduction in pain. The amount of pelvic tilt was not, as well,
documented. However, the kinesioptaping was described to be applied to the subjects in the
area below the navel and above the pubic hairline (24).
Lim,ParkandBaecomparedtheeffectsofkinesiotapingandspiraltapingonmenstrualpain
andpremenstrualsyndromein34unmarriedwomenwhowererandomizedintothreegroups,
including the kinesiotaping group, spiral taping group, and control group. Both the
Kinesiotapingandspiraltapinggroupsreportedareductioninmenstrualpain,butthesubjects who
received the spiral taping described additional beneficial effects on premenstrual
syndrome.Therewasnoreportontheamountofpelvictiltuponapplicationofkinesiotaping (25).
Abdelaziz, El-Kosery, Refaye and Mohamed investigated the effect of kinesiotaping on
primary dysmenorrhea in girls and compared it against pilate exercises. The study involved
60 girls with menstrual pain and discomfort.Both groups exhibited statistically significant
improvementsintheVisualAnalogueScale,qualityoflifeenjoymentandsatisfaction,
6
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Menstrual Distress Questionnaire, and Spielberger questionnaire, although the pilates group
showedastatisticallysignificantimprovementoverthekinesiotapinggroup.Bothgroupshad a
considerable drop in working ability, location, intensity, days of pain, and dysmenorrhea
(WALIDD)scoreaftertreatmentcomparedtobeforetreatment,buttherewasnostatistically
significant difference between them. Also, both groups had a significant reduction in
prostaglandin levels after treatment compared to before treatment, with the pilates group
having a greater reduction than the kinesiotaping group. The authors concluded that pilate
exercisesappeared tobemoreeffectivethankinesiotapingonprimarydysmenorrheaingirls (26).
A recent study by Boguszewski et al. investigated the effectiveness of kinesiotaping on
44womenwithmenstrualpain.Thesubjectswererandomlyassignedtokinesiotaping,inelastic
taping, and control. In all groups, pain intensitywas reduced by50%, occurring 2 to 4 hours
afterapplicationingroups1and2,andafter11hoursinthecontrolgroup.Thestudy concluded that
Kinesiotaping was effective at reducing the severity of menstrual pain andlevel ofanxiety,
and whilesham taping also produced similarly, theresults werefoundtobe weaker
therapeutically. There was no information as to the amount of pelvic tilt given (27). Pazare,
Sawant and Ingale compared the effects of kinesiotaping against isometric exercises
inthetreatmentofpaininprimarydysmenorrhea.OnVASandMDQ,boththekinesiotaping and
isometric groups showed pain reduction. Kinesiotaping, on theotherhand, was foundto
besuperiortoisometricworkoutsinapost-treatmentexamination.Therewasnoinformation on the
amount of pelvic tilt that was described (28).
Roozbahani and Mahdavinajad compared the effectiveness of stretching exercises and
kinesiotaping in menstrual pain in high school students, specificallyon their effects on back
and abdominal pain and back range of motion. This study involved an operational, quasi-
experimental, and two-stage study where 30 female high school subjects were randomized
into stretching, kinesiotaping, and control groups.The authors concluded that although
Kinesiotapinghadbetter effectsinthereductionofmenstrualpain,stretchingexerciseswere found
to be better than kinesiotaping in increasing back range of motion. There was no information
on the amount of pelvic tilt upon the application of kinesiotaping (29).
Bandara, Kularathne , Brain and Weerasekara conducted a systematic review and meta-
analysisontheeffectsoftherapeutictapinginprimarydysmenorrheaanddescribedthat
7
Effects of kinesiotapingwithpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Kinesiotapinghadfavorableeffectsonqualityoflife,andpainintensity(30).
According to the researcher’s knowledge, individual studies have been conducted to
demonstrate the effect of kinesiotaping and pelvic tilts on dysmenorrhea. However, a
combined&comparativestudyontheseinterventionsdoesnotexistinevidence.Theaimof this
study is to explore the effects of kinesiotaping with and without pelvic tilts on pain and
menstrual distress in females with dysmenorrhea.
8
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
3. MATERIAL&METHODS:
3.1 STUDYDESIGN
Thestudywas arandomizedcontrolled trial.
3.2 SETTING
ThestudywasconductedinUniversityofSialkot,KashmirroadCampus,Sialkot.
3.3 DURATIONOFTHESTUDY
Thestudywascompletedinsixmonthsafterapprovalofsynopsisfrom BASR.
3.4 SAMPLESIZE
A sample size of 30 was taken for this project. Sample size was calculated
usingopen epi tool.
*Differencebetweenthemeans
ResultsfromOpenEpi,Version3,opensourcecalculator—SSMean (18).
9
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
3.5 STUDYGROUPS
GroupA:Kinesiotapingwithpelvic tilts
GroupB:Kinesiotapingwithoutpelvic tilts
3.6 SAMPLINGTECHNIQUE
Non-probabilityconvenientsamplingtechniquewasusedtocollectdata.
3.7 SAMPLESELECTION
3.7.1 INCLUSIONCRITERIA
1. Age18-30years
2. Nulliparous
3. Regularmenstrualcycles
4. Primarydysmenorrhea(diagnosed viaWaLIDDtool)
3.7.2 EXCLUSIONCRITERIA
5. Allergictokinesiotape
6. Skindisorders
7. Uterine fibroids
8. Endometriosis
9. PolycysticOvarianSyndrome
10
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
3.8 RANDOMIZATIONMETHOD:
Once the above mentioned inclusion & exclusion criteria were satisfied, potential
participants were considered. They were requested to participate in the study via
informed consent. Patients were randomlyallocated to either Group A or Group B via
random number generator.
3.9 TREATMENTAPPROACH
3.9.1 Pre-interventionapproach:
The first visit was made during the first menstrual cycle of each subject. Baseline
interventions was taken using three tools. Pain status was recorded using Numeric
PainRatingScale(NPRS).Symptomsregardingmenstrualcyclewererecordedusing
WaLIDD tool and Menstrual Distress Questionnaire (MDQ). Afterwards, the
subjects werecontacted in theirsecond and third menstrual cyclefor interventions.
3.9.2 Intervention:
Thesecondvisit&thirdvisitweremadeduringthesecond&thirdmenstrualcycleofeach
subject. Interventions were applied to each groupaccordingly.
Kinesiotape was applied to patients. Patients were instructed to inhale while tape
application. Tape was applied in vertical direction from just below the navel to pubic
region, another tape was applied over the initial tape in horizontal direction with
minimal stretch. Another tape was applied over the lumbosacral region making a V-
shape. The arms of V lied over the lumbar region while the base rested over caudal
region. Taping was maintained for at least 48 hours.In addition, patients were
instructedtoperformpelvictilts.Patientswereaskedtolieinsupinepositionwithlegs bent
and toes facing forward. Afterwards, they were instructed to pull their belly inwards
whilepushingpelvistowards the ceilingand keep hipmusclestightened. This position
was maintained for 5 seconds with 3 sets of 20 repetitions. Pelvic tilts were performed
throughout the menstrual cycle.
11
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Kinesiotape was applied to patients. Patients were instructed to inhale while tape
application. Tape was applied in vertical direction from just below the navel to pubic
region, another tape was applied over the initial tape in horizontal direction with
minimal stretch. Another tape was applied over the lumbosacral region making a V-
shape. The arms of V lied over the lumbar region while the base rested over caudal
region.Tapingwasmaintainedforatleast48hours.Theinterventionswereappliedfor two
consecutive menstrual cycles.
3.9.5 Post-interventionapproach:
Fourthvisitwasmadeduringfourthmenstrualcycleasafollow-uptorecordpainstatus via
Numeric Pain Rating Scale, Menstrual Distress Questionnaire & WaLIDD tool.
All participants received02 treatment sessions over a period oftwo menstrual cycles,one
treatment per cycle.
12
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
3.10 DATACOLLECTIONTOOL
3.10.1 NumericPainRatingScale(NPRS):
3.10.2 WaLIDDTool:
3.10.3 MenstrualDistressQuestionnaire(MDQ):
13
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
3.11 DATACOLLECTIONPROCEDURE:
3.11.1 CONSORTFLOWCHART
14
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
3.12 DATAANALYSISPROCEDURE:
The data has been analyzed using SPSS for Windows software, version 21.
Statistical significance was set at P=0.05. Normality of data was checked through
Shapiro Wilk’s test. Following tests have been used:
Descriptive Statistics: Frequency tables, pie charts, bar charts have been
used to show summary of group measurements measured overtime.
Changes between successive visits: Change between successive visits:
Wilcoxonttestandpairedt-testhavebeenusedtoshowtheprogressoftwo groups
betweenanytwo successive visits interms of subjective and objective
measurements.
Difference between Groups: Independent sample t test & Mann-Whitney
testhavebeenused.Thesearenon-parametricteststhatareusedtocompare two
populations at different various intervals.
15
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
4. RESULTS
Shapiro-Wilk
Tool Statistic df Sig.
NPRS_1_value .929 24 .093
WaLIdD_1_vaule .773 24 .000
Table shows the result of normality test. Shapiro Wilk’s test was performed to determine the
distributionofdatainNumericPainRatingScale(NPRS)andWaLIDDtool.SincetheP-valuefor NPRS is
greater than 0.01 which means that the data is normally distributed therefore, parametric tests
wereperformed for NPRS to analyze the data. On the other hand, the P-valueforWaLIDD is less
than0.01 which means that thedatais not normallydistributed therefore, non-parametrictests were
performed to analyze the data.
16
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
GroupA(KTtapewithpelvictilts)
Age 17 27 22.15±2.478
Weight 43 85 58.92±11.42
Height 4.11 5.70 5.21±0.41
Menarche 11 15 12.69±1.03
Avg.Durationof 3 8 5.46 ±1.66
menstrual cycle
GroupB(KTtapewithoutpelvictilts)
Age 19 24 22.18±1.60
Weight 47 80 58.54± 10.65
Height 4.11 5.70 5.12±0.46
Menarche 11 17 14.09±1.64
Avg.Durationof 5 8 6.09±1.04
menstrual cycle
In the above table, the mean age of participants in Group A was 22.15 ±2.478 with age ranging
from17-27years.MeanageofparticipantsinGroupBwas22.18±1.60withagerangingfrom19-24
years.In GroupA,meanweightofparticipantswas58.92±11.42withaweight rangeof43-85
kgs.InGroupB,mean weightofparticipantswas58.54±10.65withaweightrangeof47-80kgs. In Group
A, the mean height of participants was 5.21 ± 0.41 with minimum height being 4 feet 11 inches
while maximum height being 5 feet 70 inches. In Group B, the mean height of participants was
5.12 ± 0.46 with minimum height also being 4 feet 11 inches while maximum height being 5
feet70inches.InGroupA,themeanmenarcheofpatientswas12.69±1.03withmenarcheranging from 11-
15 years. In Group B, the mean menarche of patients was 14.09 ±1.64 with menarche
rangingfrom11-17years.InGroupA,themeanaveragedurationofmenstrualcyclewas5.46±
1.66 with the range of 3-8 days for average duration of menstrual cycle. In Group B, the mean
averagedurationofmenstrualcyclewas6.09±1.04withtherangeof5-8daysforaverageduration of
menstrual cycle
17
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
18
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Bar chart shows the marital status of participants in both groups. In Group A, 10 participants
(76.9%) were single while 3 participants (23.1%) were married. In Group B, all 11 participants
(100%) were married.
19
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
FIGURE
FIGURE 4.5 4.5 REGULARITY
REGULARITY OFOF MENSTRUALCYCLE
MENSTRUAL CYCLE
The clustered bar chart expresses information regarding the regularity of menstrual cycle in both
groups. 13 participants (100%) in Group A marked ‘yes’ regarding regularity of menstrual cycle
and 11 participants (100%) in Group B also marked ‘yes’ regarding regularity of menstrual cycle.
20
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Theclusteredbarchartrevealsinformationregardingthelifestyleofparticipantsinbothgroups.In Group
A, 4 participants (30.8%) had sedentary lifestyle while 9 participants (69.2%) had active lifestyle.
In Group B, 4 participants (36.4%) had sedentary lifestyle while 7 participants (63.6%) had active
lifestyle.
21
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
The clustered bar chart provides information regarding the pain location in both groups. In Group
A, 2 participants (15.4%) experienced pain in each area of lower back, right side of abdomen &
lower abdomen+backache+left side. 3 participants (23.1%) experienced pain in lower
abdomen+backacheonly.4participants(30.8%)experiencedpaininlowerabdomenonly.InGroup B, 1
participant (9.1%) experienced pain in each area of lower abdomen and lower back. 9 participants
(81.8%) experienced pain in lower abdomen+backache.
22
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
23
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
24
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Theclusteredbarchartprovidesinformationregardingpaininitiationinbothgroups.InGroupA,
1 participant (7.7%) experienced pain initiation on first/second day. 5 participants (38.5%)
experienced pain before period commencement while 7 participants (53.8%) experienced pain on
firstday. InGroupB,3 participants(27.3%)experiencedpainbeforeperiodcommencementwhile 4
participants (36.4%) documented pain initiation on first day and first/second day each.
25
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
The clustered bar chart reveals information regarding pain length in both groups. In Group A, 2
participants (15.4%) described 1-day pain length. 3 participants (23.1%) described 2-3 days and
entireperiodpainlengtheachwhile5participants(38.5%)described1-2-daypainlength.InGroup B, 2
participants (18.2%) described 1-2day pain length. 3 participants (27.3%) described 1-day pain
length while 6 participants (54.5%) described pain length spanning over entire period.
26
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
27
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Table provides information regarding between group analysis of WaLIDD scores. Independent
sampleMann-WhitneyTestwasapplied.MeanrankofWaLIDD_1(pre-treatment)forgroupAand group
B was 11.42 and 13.77 respectively. Median of WaLIDD_1 (pre-treatment) for both groups A and
B was 11.000. Z-scoreof WaLIDD_1 (pre-treatment) for both groups was -.848. P-value of
WaLIDD_1(pre-treatment)was0.396.MeanrankofWaLIDD_2(post-treatment)forgroupAand group
B was 7.00 and 19.00 respectively. Median of WaLIDD_2 (post-treatment) for group A &
groupBwas5.00&9.00respectively.Z-scoreofWaLIDD_2(post-treatment)forbothgroupswas
-4.183. P-value of WaLIDD_2 (post-treatment) for both groups was 0.000. There is a significant
differencebetweenWaLIDDscoreP-valueofpre-treatmentandpost-treatmentbeing0.396and
0.000respectivelyinbothgroups.SincetheP-valueislessthan0.05,henceitprovesthattreatment
significantly improved WaLIDD scores across both group A and group B.
28
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
TABLE 4.14 MDQ B/W GROUP ANALYSIS (Mann-Whitney Test, Pre-treatment Scores)
Table provides information regarding between group analysis of MDQ1 (pre-treatment) scores.
Mann-Whitney test was applied. The P-values of MDQ1_pain, MDQ1_concentration,
MDQ1_behavioralchanges,MDQ1_autonomicreaction in both groupsA and Bwere0.114, 0.039,
0.00, 0.003.
29
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
TABLE 4.15 MDQ B/W GROUP ANALYSIS (Mann-Whitney Test, Pre-Treatment Scores)
Groups N Mean Groups N Mean Groups
MDQ1_water GroupA 13 13.54 1.00 -.863 .388
retention GroupB 11 11.27 .00 -.863 .388
Table provides information regarding between group analysis of MDQ1 (pre-treatment) scores. Mann-
Whitney test was applied. The P-values of MDQ1_waterretention,MDQ1_negative effect,
MDQ1_arousal and MDQ1_control in both groupsA and Bwere0.388, 0.007, 0.049 and 0.26.
30
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
TABLE 4.16 NPRS B/W GROUP ANALYSIS (Mann-Whitney Test, Post-treatment Scores)
Table provides information regarding between group analysis of MDQ2 (post-treatment) scores.
Mann-Whitney test was applied. The P-values of MDQ2_pain, MDQ2_concentration,
MDQ2_behavioralchanges,MDQ2_autonomicreaction
inbothgroupsAandBwere0.001,0.002,0.001,0.000. Since all P-values are less than 0.05 hence, it
proves that treatment significantly improved MDQ scores in both groups.
31
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
TABLE 4.17 MDQ B/W GROUP ANALYSIS (Mann-Whitney Test, Post-treatment Scores)
Table provides information regarding between group analysis of MDQ2 (post-treatment) scores.
Mann-Whitney test was applied. The P-values of MDQ2_waterretention,MDQ2_negative
effect,MDQ2_arousalandMDQ2_controlinbothgroupsAandBwere0.001, 0.000, 0.008 and 0.006.
Since all P-values are less than 0.05 hence, it proves that treatment significantly improved MDQ
scores in both groups.
32
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Table provides information regarding between group analysis of NPRS scores. Independent
Samples T-test was applied. Mean ± Std. Deviation of both groups A and B in NPRS_1 (pre-
treatment) were 6.3077 ± 3.301 and 7.000 ±1.183 respectively. The P-value of both groups A and
B in NPRS_1 (pre-treatment) was 0.453 and 0.393 respectively. Mean ± Std. Deviation of both
groups A and B in NPRS_2 (post-treatment) were 2.769 ± 1.480 and 3.634 ± 1.206 respectively.
TheP-value of both groups A and Bin NPRS_2 (post-treatment) was 0.00 and 0.002 respectively.
SincetheP-valuesforbothgroups(NPRS_2,post-treatment)arelessthan0.05hence,itprovesthat
treatment significantly improved NPRS scores of both groups.
33
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
TABLE 4.19 MDQ WITHIN GROUP ANALYSIS (WILCOXON SIGNED RANK TEST)
Median
GroupA(N=13) GroupB(N=11)
WaLIDD_1 7.000 8.000
WaLIDD_2 1.000 2.000
Meanrank P-value Mean P-value
rank
WaLIDD_1 28.60 .0396 23.20 .030
WaLIDD_2 13.22 0.000 11.10 0.00
Table provides information regarding within group analysis of WaLIDD score in both groups.
Wilcoxon signed rank test was applied. The median of WaLIDD_1 (pre-treatment) in both groups
A and B was 7.000 and 8.000 respectively. The mean rank value of WaLIDD_1 (pre-treatment) in
bothgroupsAandBwas28.60and23.20respectively.TheP-valueofWaLIDD_1(pre-treatment)
inbothgroupsAandBwas.0396and.030respectively.ThemedianofWaLIDD_2(pre-treatment)
inbothgroupsAandBwas1.000and2.000respectively.ThemeanrankvalueofWaLIDD_2(pre-
treatment) in both groups A and B was 13.22 and 11.10 respectively. The P-value of WaLIDD_2
(pre-treatment)inbothgroupsAandBwas0.000.SincetheP-valueislessthan0.05inbothgroups
(WaLIDD_2,post-treatment)hence,itprovesthattreatmentsignificantlyimprovedWaLIDDscores
within each group.
34
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Table provides information regarding within group analysis of NPRS score in both groups. Paired
t-testwasapplied.ThemeanofNPRS_1(pre-treatment)inbothgroupsAandBwas6.3077±3.301 and
7.000 ± 1.183 respectively. Themean rank value of NPRS_1 (pre-treatment) in both groups A and
B was 29.64 and 25.3 respectively. The P-value of NPRS_1 (pre-treatment) in both groups A
andBwas0.20and0.35 respectively.ThemeanofNPRS_2(post-treatment)inbothgroupsAand B was
2.7692 ± 1.480 and 3.636 ± 1.206 respectively. The mean rank value of NPRS_2 (pre-
treatment)inbothgroupsAandBwas15.02and13.31respectively.TheP-valueofNPRS_2(post-
treatment)inbothgroupsAandBwas0.000and0.01respectively.SincetheP-valueislessthan
0.05inbothgroups(NPRS_2,post-treatment)hence,itprovesthattreatmentsignificantlyimproved
NPRS scores within each group.
35
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Median
GroupA(N=13) GroupB (N=11)
MDQ1_pain 4.00 2.00
MDQ1_concentration 2.00 2.00
MDQ1_behavioralchanges 3.00 1.00
MDQ1_autonomicreaction 3.00 1.00
MDQ1_waterretention 5.00 5.00
MDQ1_negativeeffect 2.00 1.00
MDQ1_arousal 2.50 1.00
MDQ1_control 3.00 3.00
Meanrank P-value Mean P-value
rank
MDQ2_pain 10.0 0.00 10.0 0.00
MDQ2_concentration 10.5 0.001 10.2 0.00
MDQ2_behavioralchanges 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
MDQ2_autonomicreaction 7.00 0.00 4.00 0.00
MDQ2_waterretention 5.00 0.00 5.00 0.00
MDQ2_negativeeffect 8.50 0.00 7.50 0.00
MDQ2_arousal 9.50 0.00 9.50 0.00
MDQ2_control 6.00 0.00 5.00 0.01
TableprovidesinformationregardingwithingroupanalysisofMDQscoresinbothgroupsAand
B. The P-value of MDQ2_pain, MDQ2_concentration, MDQ2_behavioral changes,
MDQ2_autonomicreactions,MDQ2_waterretention, MDQ2_negativeeffect, MDQ2_arousal and
MDQ2_controlinbothgroupsAandBwere0.00,0.001and0.00,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.00 and 0.01
respectively. Since the P-values are less than 0.05 in both groups hence, it proves that treatment
significantly improved P-values of MDQ within each group.
36
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
5. DISCUSSION:
This study aims to compare the effects of kinesiotaping on menstrual distress and pain severity in
women aged 18 to 30 with primary dysmenorrhea when pelvic tilts and kinesiotaping are used
through assessment of the severity of menstrual pain scale through the Numeric Pain Rating Scale
(NPRS) and Menstrual Distress Questionnaire (MDQ) before and following the intervention. The
study’s findings will contribute to developing more effective non-pharmacological coping
mechanisms for menstrual pain and distress.
One of the most typical gynecological issues is primary dysmenorrhea. It is so common that even
when their everyday activities are curtailed, females still neglect to disclose it to their primary
physicians. Female adolescents have a great deal of misunderstanding and misconceptions about
the treatment of dysmenorrhea since they are not informed about the condition or the available
treatments (36). Self-medication is a prevalent practice among adolescents with dysmenorrhea,
and albeit very few seek medical attention (41). Dysmenorrhea might make it harder for them to
go about their regular life.
According to studies, dysmenorrhea interferes with women's social and academic lives. Due to the
physical and social impairment caused by dysmenorrhea, which affects adolescent females,
sickness, absenteeism, and perceived quality of life losses are common (37). In the United States,
dysmenorrhea has been considered to be the leading cause of time missed from work and school.
Dysmenorrhea and menstrual cycle function both affect depression and/or anxiety
symptoms.Dysmenorrhea'sdetrimentalpsychologicalimpactonpsychologicalstatusmay substantially
impact women's quality of life (46).
Dysmenorrhea is more common in young and nulliparous women, and this has been observed.
Indian women reach menarche between the ages of 16 and 17, and they give birth between 18 and
35. The age range of 18 to 30 is the one in which the majority of ladies with dysmenorrhea fall.
Taping is currently being explored as a treatment option for dysmenorrhea, alongside home
remedies and traditional physiotherapeutic methods. Previous research has attempted to determine
how tape affects dysmenorrheal discomfort. Being a non-invasive procedure, taping appears to
have more compliance.
The results observed in this present study confirm the results, at least based on menstrual pain
perception, found in a previous trial about the effectiveness of kinesiotaping in conjunction with
37
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
pelvic tilting exercises applied to subjects with characteristics similar to the present study (6).
Patel and Dhupkar indicated that kinesiotaping with pelvic tilting effectively managed menstrual
pain symptoms immediately after application, and the effects seemed to carry over the subsequent
menstrual cycles. In that study, measurements of menstrual pain were evaluated using the Visual
Analogue Scale, and the descriptions of menstrual pain were assessed using the Menstrual
Symptom Questionnaire, in which subjects of that study demonstrated no significant effects pre-
treatment and immediately after the intervention. The VAS appears to be more confusing than
other assessment techniques, making it more prone to misunderstandings. The NPRS was
employed in the current investigation because it has demonstrated strong correlations with other
pain-assessment measures in several studies (55). Its practicability and high compliance have also
been established (56).
On the other hand, a widely used tool for assessing cyclical perimenstrual symptoms is the MDQ.
Premenstrual and menstrual symptoms are evaluated and treated using it. It describes the kinds
and degrees of symptoms women encounter at each stage of the menstrual cycle, which can help
researchers and medical professionals pinpoint the impact of therapeutic measures. While the
MDQ can discriminate between cyclical and noncyclical changes in arousal, mood, and behaviour
(58), the MSQ distinguishes between spasmodic and congestive dysmenorrhea (57).
The use of kinesiotaping alone as an effective treatment for primary dysmenorrhea has already
been described. It has demonstrated positive results in reducing pain, anxiety levels, and some
menstrual complaints in women with primary dysmenorrhea (52). This finding was seen when
kinesiotaping was compared with sham taping and a control group. In a separate study,
kinesiotaping significantly reduced pain and drug intake in patients suffering from primary
dysmenorrhea. However, the changes noted in the use of auricular acupressure tended to last
longer (54). It also effectively reduced menstrual complaints when applied across the abdominal
area of women with painful menstruation (27). Kinesiotaping also demonstrated better effects
when compared with stretching exercises in reducing pain associated with primary dysmenorrhea
(9).
A study evaluated the effects of kinesiotaping on menstrual distress, pain and prostaglandin using
its effects on the VAS and MDQ (59). All of these parameters were reduced after the intervention.
However, the study was conducted on the only lone subject.
38
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
In the present study, both groups reported improvement in menstrual pain perception, as indicated
in table 4.16. For group A, an NPRS changes from the mean standard deviation of 6.31 ± 3.30 to
2.77 ± 1.48 with a change of p-value from 0.45 to 0.00. Because the tape is a treatment that
directly stimulates muscles and fascia beneath the skin, it maximizes the body’s inherent healing
capacity. It corrects the equilibrium of the human body. There are three benefits of kinesiotaping:
restoration of normal muscle performance by providing assistance to weak muscles, reduction of
inflammation and pain by enhancing lymphatic and blood circulation, and improve joint range of
motion by correcting muscle fiber, myofascial, and joint misalignment (48, 49). The effects of
taping have also been attributed to increased neurofacilitation and a potential connection between
the motor unit firing of the relevant myotome and the cutaneous afferents in the area where the
tape has been applied (50). Another argument for the effectiveness of taping is the mechanical
constraint that is felt after application(39). By physically stimulating cutaneous afferents, tape
causes continual relaxation and contraction of the muscles, lowering muscular tone and reducing
discomfort (39,45). To normalize diminished muscle strength, muscularconvulsions, and tension
through homeostasis and to induce muscular equilibrium with the environment by enhancing
lymphatic circulation, taping decreases the symptoms of dysmenorrhea (35).
Strong uterine contractions, a disruption in the blood flow, and the release of the hormone
prostaglandin are the main contributors to the discomfort experienced during dysmenorrhea. A
highly innervated area of the uterus is put under pressure due to the discomfort, which is thought
to be caused by ischemia of the uterine muscles that are contracting vigorously or by hypertonicity
of the uterine isthmus. In addition, prostaglandins induce myometrial contractility, which, if too
great, results in uterine ischemia and pain (34, 40, 46). The counter-irritant effect of taping, based
on the gate control theory, describes how mechanoreceptors (A-beta fibre) are stimulated at the
site of tape application, reducing nearby menstruation pain. Additionally, tape stimulates the skin,
increasing blood flow. This rise in blood pressure results from the spine's vasomotor reflex, which
lowers the concentration of chemicals that cause pain, such as histamine and prostaglandin, in the
bloodstream, reducing discomfort.
Similar to Group A, In table 4.16 Group B's pre-treatment pain score was 7.000 ± 1.183 and
decreased to 3.634 ± 1.206 after therapy. Group B demonstrated a lower degree of pain relief than
group A. The increased impact of the pelvic tilting exercise in group A may cause this outcome.
The uterine lining experiences hormonal changes due to exercise (43). Endorphins are released
during exercise, preventing any potential reductions in endorphin levels during the luteal period.
These, in turn, increase the body's pain tolerance (47). According to studies, exercise increases
39
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
uterine blood flow and metabolism, reducing dysmenorrhea symptoms (44). They function as a
generalanalgesicforinstantaneouspainalleviation.Asaresult,itappearsthatwomenwhoexercise
experiencelessdysmenorrhea.Exercise-inducedreductionsinsympatheticoveractivityareanother
factor in alleviating dysmenorrheal symptoms (44).
Within-group analysis for groups A and B, pain perception was significantly reduced, with a more
significant reduction in pain in Group A. Likewise, both groups improved in their MDQ scores in
all areas assessed, with no statistically significant difference between the two groups. These
findings appeared similar to those seen in a study that evaluated the effects of taping and hot packs
on the premenstrual syndrome, where the change in MDQ scores was statistically significant (53).
In that trial, MDQ scores favoured more the group that received both kinesiotaping and hot pack
than just hot pack alone, particularly for pain perception. The study compared the effects of
kinesiotaping alone, hot packs, and kinesiotaping with hot packs.
In this present study, such findings maybe attributed to the basis for the improvements seen in
NPRS in the intergroup analysis. There are several causes for this. First, the lumbar spine could be
less stressed due to posterior pelvic tilts, which would reduce sympathetic activity and relieve
pain. Second, the interspinous ligaments are less stressed because of the posterior pelvic tilt
reduction in lumbar lordosis. Third, the erector spinae may be relaxing post-isometrically, which
would lessen pain. The fact that these activities were continued throughout the research period
may have resulted in the conditioning of these muscles, improving their functionality and lowering
pain during the next menstrual cycle. Finally, the combination of posterior pelvic tilts and tape
may have an additive effect on correcting the alignment of the spine, which may explain why there
was improved pain relief in this group.
Becauseoftheirimproperspinalalignment,studieshaverevealed that women with higher levels of
pelvic torsion experience dysmenorrhea at a higher incidence. As a result, there is an imbalance in
the levels of the chemicals prostaglandin and oxytocin (34). Incorrect movement of the
lumbosacral vertebrae caused by increased bodily fluids in the pelvis, an imbalance of the pelvis,
and contraction of the uterus that worsens menstrual discomfort can all be corrected with posterior
pelvic tilts and tape when used in conjunction. The shifting position of the uterus caused by an
excessive amount of prostaglandin secreted during pregnancy may be a cause of the pelvic
imbalance (42). It is hypothesized that discomfort could be diminished in women with
dysmenorrhea if their spinal alignment reverted to normal. It is hypothesized that spinal segment
mobility, which happens with pelvictilts, might trigger cutaneous sensations, can alter the activity
of the internal organs, and can therefore relieve dysmenorrhea (Kim, Baek and Goo, 2016).
40
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
The pain experienced during dysmenorrhea, referred from the abdomen, may be brought on by
tension in or inflammation of the pelvic peritoneum, the release of the hormone prostaglandin, and
a forceful contraction of the uterine musculature (34). Because the low back and lower abdomen
share dermatomes, an intervention in one of these areas may impact the other. Therefore, taping
the abdomen may also stimulate the low back muscles, enhancing the effects of taping and
posterior pelvic tilt exercises. Exercises involving the pelvic tilt are especially beneficial in
reducing lumbar pain, and tape combined with pelvic tilting exercises is a successful way to treat
low back pain in pregnant women. Similar findings were made in the current investigation, which
shows that posterior pelvic tilts and taping can both lessen dysmenorrheal pain. Due to its ability
to reduce muscular tension and improve blood flow in the area where it is applied, taping is
effective for both the congestive and spasmodic types of primary dysmenorrhea (39). Following
the use of tape, this physiological alteration may have an impact on muscle and myofascial
functions. The activation of cutaneous mechanoreceptors at the taped area caused by taping may
impact how pain is perceived.
41
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
6. CONCLUSION
The study concludes that both group A (Kinesiotape with pelvic tilts) and group B (Kinesiotape
without pelvic tilts) improved in terms of Numeric Pain Rating Scale (NPRS) and Menstrual
DistressQuestionnaire(MDQ)post-treatment.However,greaterimprovementswereseeninGroup
AwhoseparticipantsweregivenKinesiotapingincombinationwithpelvictilts.Therefore,wereject the
null hypothesis and accept the alternate hypothesis which states that “Kinesiotape with pelvic tilts
is more effective than kinesiotape without pelvic tilts on pain intensity and menstrual distress in
females with dysmenorrhea and vice versa”.
42
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
7. LIMITATIONSOFTHESTUDY:
Thestudyhad certainlimitations:
1. Smallsamplesize
2. Shorterdurationofstudy
3. Inclusionofprimarydysmenorrheaalone
43
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
8. RECOMMENDATIONS:
4. The study recommends researchers to conduct randomized controlled trials with larger
sample sizes in future to investigate the combined effect of Kinesiotape with other physio
therapeutic interventions to provide evidence-based strategies in order to cope with the
condition of both types of dysmenorrhea.
44
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
9. REFERENCES:
1. ReddishS.Dysmenorrhea.Australianfamilyphysician.2006;35(11).
2. Ju H, Jones M, Mishra G. The prevalence and risk factors of dysmenorrhea.
Epidemiologic reviews. 2014;36(1):104-13.
3. Johnston L. Menstrual pain (dysmenorrhea). Professional Nursing Today.
2014;18(1):13-4.
4. Smith R, Kaunitz A. Primary dysmenorrhea in adult women: clinical features
and diagnosis. Alphen aan den Rijn: Wolters Kluwer. 2015.
5. Lundeberg T,BondessonL, LundströomV.Reliefofprimarydysmenorrheaby
transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation. Acta obstetricia et gynecologica
Scandinavica. 1985;64(6):491-7.
6. Patel F, Dhupkar A. Effect of Kinesiotaping and Pelvic Tilts on Menstrual
Symptom Questionnaire and Visual Analogue Scale in Primary Dysmenorrhea in
Females Aged 18-30 Years.
7. Tomás-Rodríguez MI, Palazón-Bru A, John DRJM-S, Toledo-Marhuenda JV,
del Rosario Asensio-García M, Gil-Guillén VF. Effectiveness of medical taping
concept in primary dysmenorrhea: a two-armed randomized trial. Scientific reports.
2015;5(1):1-9.
8. Koo JP, Park JH, Um KM. Effects of Kinematic Taping Therapy on
Dysmenorrhea. Journal of International Academy of Physical Therapy Research.
2018;9(2):1442-6.
9. Roozbahani RE, Najad RM. A comparison of the effect of stretching exercises
and kinesio taping on the primarydysmenorrhea of high school girls. J Arak Uni Med
Sci. 2015;18(97):1-8.
10. Shahr-JerdyS, Hosseini RS, GhME. Effects ofstretching exercises onprimary
dysmenorrhea in adolescent girls. Biomedical Human Kinetics. 2012;4(1):127-32.
11. AhmadiBaratiA,FarhadiL, KhalilyM.ComparisonoftheEffect ofStretching
Exercises and Combination of Massage-Stretching Exercises on Primary
Dysmenorrhea of Female Students of Razi University of Kermanshah. Journal of
Clinical Research in Paramedical Sciences. 2021;10(1).
12. Mejías-GilE, Garrido-Ardila EM, Montanero-Fernández J, Jiménez-Palomares
M, Rodríguez-Mansilla J, González López-Arza MV. Kinesio Taping vs. Auricular
AcupressureforthePersonalisedTreatmentofPrimaryDysmenorrhea:APilot
45
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
RandomizedControlledTrial.Journalofpersonalized medicine.2021;11(8):809.
13. Guruprasad P, Sharma U, Palekar T, Pimpri P. Immediate Effect of Yoga
Postures v/s PhysiotherapyExercises AlongWith K-Tapingon Pain inDysmenorrhea.
IJSRST; 2019.
14. ArshadS,QureshiMF,DeebaF,SarshadS,ShirazS,FarooqS,etal.Tocompare the
effectiveness of taping technique and hydrotherapy in treatment of primary
dysmenorrhea. Inter J Endor Health Sci Res. 2018;6(3):34-42.
15. Gamit KS, Sheth MS, Vyas NJ. The effect of stretching exercise on primary
dysmenorrhea in adult girls. Int J Med Sci Public Health. 2014;3(5):549-51.
16. VaziriF, HoseiniA,KamaliF, AbdaliK,HadianfardM, SayadiM. Comparing
theeffectsofaerobicandstretchingexercisesontheintensityofprimarydysmenorrhea in the
students of universities of bushehr. Journal of family & reproductive health.
2015;9(1):23.
46
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Kinesiotapingonpaininfemaleswithprimarydysmenorrhea.IntJApplRes;6(8):187-189.
25. Lim,C.,Park,Y.andBae,Y.,2013.TheEffectoftheKinesioTapingandSpiral Taping
on Menstrual Pain and Premenstrual Syndrome. Journal of Physical Therapy Science,
25(7), pp.761-764.
26. Abdelaziz,A.,El-Kosery,S.,Refaye,G.&Mohamed,M.,2020.Kinesiotaping
versus pilate exercises on primary dysmenorrhea in girls. Int. J. Psychosoc. Rehabil.
24, 8947–8962.
27. Boguszewski,D.,Borowska,J.,Szymańska,A.,Adamczyk,J.,Lewandowska,
M. and Białoszewski, D., 2020. Effectiveness of kinesiotaping for the treatment of
menstrual pain. Physiotherapy Quarterly, 28(4), pp.20-24.
28. Pazare, S., Sawant, L. and Ingale, S., 2019. The Effects of Kinesio Taping and
Isometric Exercises on Pain in Primary Dysmenorrhea-A Comparative Study. Indian
Journal of Physiotherapyand Occupational Therapy - An International Journal, 13(4),
p.117.
29. Esmaili Roozbahani R., Mahdavinajad R.. A., 2015. Comparison of the Effect
of Stretching Exercises and Kinesio Taping on the Primary Dysmenorrhea of High
SchoolGirls.JArakUniMedSci.;18(4):1-8URL:http://jams.arakmu.ac.ir/article-1-3292-
en.html
30. Bandara,EMIA.,Kularathne,WNI.,Brain,K.andWeerasekara,I.,2021.Safety and
Efficacy of Therapeutic Taping in Primary Dysmenorrhea: a Systematic Review and
Meta-analysis.
31. Proctor, M. and Farquhar, C. (2006). Diagnosis and management of
dysmenorrhea. BMJ, [online] 332(7550), pp.1134–1138.
Doi:10.1136/bmj.332.7550.1134.
32. Murphy, O.J. (1936). PENTOTHAL SODIUM ANAESTHESIA. BMJ,
2(3964), pp.1308–1309. Doi:10.1136/bmj.2.3964.1308.
33. Billig, H.E. (1943). Dysmenorrhea: the result of a postural defect. Archives of
Surgery, 46(5), p.611. doi:10.1001/archsurg.1943.01220110027007.
34. Kim, M., Baek, I. and Goo, B. (2016). The relationship between pelvic
alignmentanddysmenorrhea.JournalofPhysicalTherapyScience,28(3),pp.757–760.
Doi:10.1589/jpts.28.757.
35. Kim, M., Baek, I. and Goo, B. (2016). The relationship between pelvic
alignmentanddysmenorrhea.JournalofPhysicalTherapyScience,28(3),pp.757–760.
47
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Doi:10.1589/jpts.28.757.
36. Choi,J.,2017.Effectsofkinesiotapingandhotpacksonpremenstrualsyndrome in
females. Journal of Physical Therapy Science, 29(9), pp.1514-1517.
37. Johnson, J., 1988. Level of knowledge among adolescent girls regarding
effectivetreatmentfordysmenorrhea.JournalofAdolescentHealthCare,9(5),pp.398-402.
38. Kazama, M., Maruyama, K. and Nakamura, K., 2015. Prevalence of
Dysmenorrhea and Its Correlating Lifestyle Factors in Japanese Female Junior High
School Students. The Tohoku Journal of Experimental Medicine, 236(2), pp.107-113.
39. Kim,M.,Baek,I.andGoo,B.,2016.Theeffectoflumbar-pelvicalignmentand
abdominal muscle thickness on primary dysmenorrhea. Journal of Physical Therapy
Science, 28(10), pp.2988-2990.
40. Lim,C.,Park,Y.andBae,Y.,2013.TheEffectoftheKinesioTapingandSpiral Taping
on Menstrual Pain and Premenstrual Syndrome. Journal of Physical Therapy Science,
25(7), pp.761-764.
41. Navvabi Rigi, S., kermansaravi, F., Navidian, A., Safabakhsh, L., Safarzadeh,
A., Khazaian, S., Shafie, S. and Salehian, T., 2012. Comparing the analgesic effect of
heatpatchcontainingironchipandibuprofenforprimarydysmenorrhea:arandomized
controlled trial. BMC Women's Health, 12(1).
42. Ortiz, M., 2010. Primary dysmenorrhea among Mexican university students:
prevalence, impact and treatment. European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and
Reproductive Biology, 152(1), pp.73-77.
43. Proctor, M. and Farquhar, C., 2006. Diagnosis and management of
dysmenorrhea. BMJ, 332(7550), pp.1134-1138.
44. Rostami, M., Abbaspour, Z. and Najjar, S., 2006. The effect of exercise on
primary dysmenorrhea. Gender Medicine, 3, p.S64.
45. Shah,S.,Verma,N.,Begani,P.,Nagar,H.andMujawar,N.,2016.EFFECTOF
EXERCISES ON PRIMARY DYSMENORRHEA IN YOUNG FEMALES.
International Journal of Physiotherapy and Research, 4(5), pp.1658-1662.
46. Tomás-Rodríguez, M., Palazón-Bru, A., Martínez-St. John, D., Toledo-
Marhuenda,J.,Asensio-García,M.andGil-Guillén,V.,2015.Effectivenessofmedical
taping concept in primary dysmenorrhea: a two-armed randomized trial. Scientific
Reports, 5(1).
47. Unsal,A.,Ayranci,U.,Tozun,M.,Arslan,G.andCalik,E.,2010.Prevalence
48
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
of dysmenorrhea and its effect on quality of life among a group of female university
students. Upsala Journal of Medical Sciences, 115(2), pp.138-145.
48. Vishnupriya, R. and Rajarajeswaram, P., 2011. Effects of Aerobic Exercise at
Different Intensities in Pre Menstrual Syndrome. The Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynecology of India, 61(6), pp.675-682.
49. Chang H, Wang C, Chou K, Cheng S. Could Forearm Kinesio Taping Improve
Strength, Force Sense, and Pain in Baseball Pitchers With Medial Epicondylitis?.
Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. 2012;22(4):327-333.rrectingovement of vascular
and lymphatic flow, and reduction of pain and suffering.
50. Nunes G, de Noronha M, Cunha H, Ruschel C, Borges N. Effect of Kinesio
Taping on Jumping and Balance in Athletes. Journal of Strength and Conditioning
Research. 2013;27(11):3183-3189.
51. Melese H, Alamer A, Hailu Temesgen M, Nigussie F. <p>Effectiveness of
Kinesio Taping on the Management of Knee Osteoarthritis: A Systematic Review of
Randomized Controlled Trials</p>. Journal of Pain Research. 2020;Volume 13:1267-
1276.f
52. Toprak Celenay, S., Kavalci, B., Karakus, A. and Alkan, A., 2020. Effects of
kinesio tape application on pain, anxiety, and menstrual complaints in women with
primary dysmenorrhea: A randomized sham-controlled trial. Complementary
Therapies in Clinical Practice, 39, p.101148.
53. Choi, J.-H. (2017). Effects of kinesio taping and hot packs on premenstrual
syndrome in females. Journal of Physical Therapy Science, 29(9), pp.1514–1517.
doi:10.1589/jpts.29.1514.
54. Mejías-Gil, E., Garrido-Ardila, E.M., Montanero-Fernández, J., Jiménez-
Palomares, M., Rodríguez-Mansilla, J. and González López-Arza, M.V. (2021).
Kinesio Taping vs. Auricular Acupressure for the Personalised Treatment of Primary
Dysmenorrhoea: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of Personalized
Medicine, 11(8), p.809. doi:10.3390/jpm11080809.
55. Jamison, R.N., Gracely, R.H., Raymond, S.A., Levine, J.G., Marino, B.,
Herrmann, T.J., Daly, M., Fram, D. and Katz, N.P. (2002). Comparative study of
electronic vs. paper VAS ratings: a randomized, crossover trial using healthy
volunteers. Pain, 99(1), pp.341–347. doi:10.1016/s0304-3959(02)00178-1.
56. Closs, S.José., Barr, B., Briggs, M., Cash, K. and Seers, K. (2004). A
comparison of five pain assessment scales for nursing home residents with varying
49
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
50
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
60.
ANNEXUREI:ENGLISHCONSENTFORM
Youarefreetowithdrawfromthestudyatanytime.Youagreetoparticipate,indicating that
you have read and understood the nature of the study, and that all your inquiries
concerning the activities have been answered to your satisfaction.
NAME………………. SIGNATURE………………
DATE ……………….
51
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
ANNEXUREII:URDUCONSENTFORM
کرتیہوںکہ
تصدیقکرتا/ میں
محترمعزاوحید
نے
اپنیتحقیق
(EFFECTSOFKINESIOTAPINGWITH&WITHOUTPELVIC
TILTS ON PAIN & MENSTRUAL DISTRESS IN FEMALES
)WITH DYSMENORRHEA
زیرنگرانیڈاکٹرغالمفاطمۂ
،کے متعلق بتا دیا ہے۔ مجھے اس تحقیق کی نوعیت ،مقاصد،
احداف،توقعات،فوائداورخطراتکےمتعلقساریمعلومات
فراہمکردیگئیہیں۔
دستخطمحقق
دستخطشرکتکار
تاریخ
52
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
ANNEXUREIII:NUMERICPAINRATING SCALE
53
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
Annexureiv:WALIDDTOOL
54
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
ANNEXUREV:MENSTRUALDISTRESSQUESTIONNAIRE(MDQ)
55
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
56
Effects of Kinesiotaping withpelvictiltsonpain&menstrualdistressindysmenorrhea
57
58