Kyoto Protocol
Kyoto Protocol
Kyoto Protocol
Challenges
Although the Kyoto Protocol represented a landmark diplomatic
accomplishment, its success was far from assured. Indeed, reports issued in
the first two years after the treaty took effect indicated that most
participants would fail to meet their emission targets. Even if the targets
were met, however, the ultimate benefit to the environment would not be
significant, according to some critics, since China, the world’s leading
emitter of greenhouse gases, and the United States, the world’s second
largest emitter, were not bound by the protocol (China because of its status
as a developing country and the United States because it had not ratified
the protocol). Other critics claimed that the emission reductions called for
in the protocol were too modest to make a detectable difference in global
temperatures in the subsequent several decades, even if fully achieved with
U.S. participation. Meanwhile, some developing countries argued that
improving adaptation to climate variability and change was just as
important as reducing greenhouse gas emissions.