Forensic 2 - Personal Identification Techniques
Forensic 2 - Personal Identification Techniques
TECHNIQUES
Personalities and History of Personal Identification
7000 BC Jericho:
Neolithic bricks from the ancient city were discovered to contain thumbprints of bricklayers.
This information was reported in a modern publication in Archeology of the Holy Land, a
book researched and written by Dame K. Kenyon.
3000 BC Northwest Europe at New Grange, Republic of Ireland, and Brittany, France:
Artifacts have been found in these locations to contain carvings of fingerprints. Artifacts such
as the inner burial chamber passages and tombs possess images of fingerprint ridges.
Although some say that the prints were coincidentally placed on the artifacts by the artisans
the Stockis theory states that the placement of prints was intentional.
Kia Kung-Yen, a Chinese historian of the Tang period mentions fingerprints being used to
seal contracts and legal documents.
Yung-Hwui, a law book, specified that in order to divorce a husband must present a
document giving the reasons for the action.
All letters must be in his handwriting, but if unable to write, he must sign with his
fingerprints. It is also said that sales of children were to be sealed with their sole and
handprints.
A fellow of the Royal College of Physicians and a plant morphologist, commented on the
ridge formations of the fingers.
He is seen as the first pioneer to study and describe sweat pores, epidermal ridges and
furrows, and their various arrangements on both the hands and feet, his work also included
publications with accurate drawings. Dr. grew died in 1712.
A German scientist, became the first to expound on the theory that the arrangement of skin
ridges is never duplicated in two individuals. “although the arrangements of skin ridges are
never duplicated in two persons, nevertheless the similarities are closer among some
individuals.
In others the differences are marked, yet in spite of their peculiarities of arrangement all
have a certain likeness”.
1823 Johannes Purkinje (or John Evangelist Purkinje or Jonnes Evangelista Purkinje)
A Prussian, published a thesis in which he described friction ridge patterns and classified the
fingerprints, dividing them into nine categories and laying down the rules for their
interpretation.
This was the first time prints were classified into patterns. Four basic patterns emerged:
arch, tent, loop, and whorl.
He is known as the “Father of Dactyloscopy”
German anthropologist of the University of Halle led the way in the study of friction ridge skin
permanence.
Welcker began by printing his own right hand in 1856 and then again in 1897 to prove that
the prints do not change, thus gaining credit as the first person to start a permanence study.
British chief administrative officer of the Hooghly District, Bengal, India, is credited with the
first known official use of fingerprints on a large scale. He required natives to affix their
fingerprints as well as signatures to contracts.
In 1877, Herschel submitted a request to the Home Office to use fingerprints extensively
throughout India. He failed, however, to establish an effective fingerprint classification
system. Herschel also published an article in 1880 after reading articles by Dr. Henry Faulds
which led to allegations of plagiarism.
From the US Geological Survey, recorded his own prints to prevent their forgery on
commissary orders. The first such known use of fingerprints in the United States.
Devised anthropometry (also known as Bertillonage) while clerk in the Paris Police
Identification Bureau. Later named head of Surete Nationale, his system of identification was
adopted throughout France.
Bertillon claimed one of the first identifications using his system in February 20, 1883.
Bertillon’s system of body measurements was supplemented by the presence of fingerprints
registered on the rear of his anthropometry cards, which are alleged to have led to more
identification than his system anthropometry.
He is known as the “Father of Personal Identification”
In his book “Life on the Mississippi”, Twain refers to the identification of a murderer by his
thumbprint.
Ten years later in another book, “Pudd’nhead Wilson”, a theme centered on a fingerprint
identification demonstrated during a court trial in which the infallibility of fingerprint
identification was espoused. What is remarkable about this notation is its date and Twain’s
knowledge of fingerprints.
Was employed as statistician with the Central Police Department, La Plata, Argentina.
Ordered to set up the Bertillonage system. He read an article by pioneer Francis Galton,
formulated his own identification system and implemented the system in September 1891.
His system became known as “Vucetichissimo”. Subsequently he was ordered to discard
his system and revert back to Bertillonage. Fortunately, in 1896, before the revision could
take place, Argentina abandoned Bertillonage and Vucetichissimo was retained.
Vucetich’s system is still used in South America. Vucetich claimed to make one of the first
criminal identifications in 1892 in La Plata, Argentina.
A British anthropologist and cousin of Charles Darwin, began observation that led to the to
the publication of “Fingerprints”. This publication was the first on fingerprints. In it, Galton
made the statement that fingerprints remain unchanged for life and they are permanent.
He also devised the first scientific method of classifying fingerprint patterns into arches,
loops, and whorls. Galton also pointed out ridge characteristics and described a method for
taking prints.
In recognition of the contributions by Galton, ridge characteristics were named in his honor
and today are known as “Galton” details.
Dr. De Forest is responsible for the first large-scale documented instance of fingerprints
being used as a systematic method of identification in the United States.
Dr. De Forest installed the system to prevent cheating by applicants for the New York Civil
Service Commission. The system was installed in December 1902.
The New York State Prison system installed the first systematic use of fingerprints in the
United States for use in identification of criminals. The system was officially adopted June of
1903.
He instructed American police in the Henry system. Subsequently, a young woman named
Mary Holland, who was a student learning the Henry system, went throughout the US
teaching the Henry system to many law enforcement agencies.
Is said to have been one of the Henry system and single-handedly was responsible for the
accelerated acceptance of the Henry system throughout the United States.
She was the first American instructor in Dactyloscopy.
He wrote that if 12 points (Galton’s Details) were same between two fingerprints, it would
suffice a positive identification. This is where the often quoted (12 points) originated.
The variations of the individual friction ridge feature which he noted, has evolved into
“ridgeology”, which is a coined phrase describing the use of those features in the fingerprint
identification process.
He is also known as the father of poroscopy and edgeoscopy.
The identification division was developed and instituted in 1924 with the files drawn from the
records at Ft. Leavenworth, as was the National Bureau of Criminal Identification, which
consisted of many submissions by police departments throughout the country to the FBI.
1933 FBI
Throughout the world, technology met fingerprints, and various types of AFIS system began
making their appearance with various law enforcement agencies. With the advent of AFIS,
the process of filing and searching of fingerprints was considerably shortened.
The speed and accuracy of the various AFISs being used worldwide would only increase. As
employees became more familiar with the operating systems, the ability to solve crimes and
make identifications became astounding.
The issue of disparate operating system posed significant issues in the various system could
interface due to proprietary issues. The FBI, in establishing a super-AFIS, mandated that the
new Integrated AFIS (IAFIS) be capable of interfacing with all current AFISs. That mandate
has been a reality for several years.
Agripino Ruiz
A constabulary agent and fingerprint expert, successfully defended his finding in 10 points of
comparison based on the decision of the SC in the case of Marciano Medina y Diokno.
Isabela Bernales
The first Filipina fingerprint technician.
Plaridel Educational Institution (PEI), now the Philippine College of Criminology (PCCr),
It is the first governmental recognized school to teach the science of fingerprints and other
police sciences in the Philippines.
I. Forensic Anthropology
Is a special sub-field of physical anthropology (the study of human remains) that involves
applying skeletal analysis and techniques in archaeology to solving criminal cases.
Definition of Terms
1. Fingerprint - an impression, designed by the ridges on the inside of the end joint of the fingers
and thumb on any smooth surface through the media of ink, sweat or any reagents capable of
producing visibility.
2. Dactyloscopy – the science that deals with the study of fingerprints as a means of personal
identification that involves manual comparison of fingerprints.
3. Dactylography – the scientific study and analysis of fingerprints as a means of identification.
4. Dactylomancy –the study of fingerprints for the purpose of interpreting one’s personality.
I. Chiroscopy
The science of palm print identification.
Derived from Greek words:
1. Cheir - means “a hand” and
2. Skopein - means “to examine.”
II. Podoscopy
The science of footprints and footwear identification.
Derived from two Greek words:
1. Podo - means “the foot” and
2. Skopein - means “to examine.”
III. Poroscopy
The study of the pore structure for the purpose of identification.
Derived from the Greek words:
1. Poros - means “a pore” and
2. Skopein - means “to examine.”
IV. Edgeoscopy
The study of the edges and shapes of the ridges.
This includes the study of endings, puckering, bifurcations and others.
V. Ridgeology
combination of poroscopy, edgeoscopy and ridge characteristics.
Introduced by Sgt. David R. Ashbaugh (1946-present).
Title of Book “Quantitative-Qualitative Friction Ridge Analysis: An Introduction to
Basic and Advanced Ridgeology.”
VI. Dermatoglyphics
The study of the lines, tracings, ridges of the skin of fingers, palms and hands.
Derived from the words:
1. “derma” - means “skin” and
2. “glyphein” - means “to study”
Papillary Structure
Papillary/Friction/Epidermal Skin
It is an epidermal hairless skin on the ventral or lower surface of the hands and feet.
The strips of skin on the inside of the end joints of our fingers and thumbs by which fingerprints
are made.
I. Ridge Formation
Friction Ridges
are found on every Friction skin/epidermal skin/papillary skin.
Development of Ridges
3rd - 4th month - ridges start to develop
About 6 months - ridges are fully developed
Fingerprints remain constant until during the decomposition stage of the skin of the corpse.
Fingerprint size - may change
Ridge characteristics and pattern - does not change
I. Visible prints
are impressions made by fingers smeared with colored substance, such as blood, ink, grease, dirt
or paint.
1. Climate/Climatic Condition – windy, sunny and wet seasons affects the stability of latent
print.
2. Subject Factor – Degree of acidity.
3. Nature of the Surface – whether the surface is smooth or rough.
Scientific way of taking fingerprints (PNP Fingerprint Examiner’s Manual Revised 2015)
Types of Impressions
Real Impressions
Impressions of the finger bulbs with the use of the fingerprint ink on the surface of the paper
through any coloring materials, which will produce visibility.
Problem in Recording Inked Fingerprint (PNP Fingerprint Examiner’s Manual Revised 2015)
Type lines
The two outermost ridges which tend to surround the pattern area.
The basic boundaries of most fingerprint patterns.
The skeleton of each pattern.
Pattern Area
The area surrounded by the typelines.
The area of a loop or whorl which contains the ridge details.
It is the area inside the type lines and the only part of a fingerprint which is of importance in
regard to interpretation and classification.
Diverging Ridges
Are two ridges running side by side and suddenly separating, one ridge going one way and the
other ridge going another way.
The bifurcation that is open towards the core is chosen as the delta.
RULE 2
If the bifurcation does not open towards the core, the ending point of the bifurcation
nearest to the core is chosen as the delta.
RULE 3
RULE 4
When there is a choice between two or more possible deltas (except bifurcation),
the delta nearest to the core is chosen.
When there is a series of bifurcations that open towards the core at the point of divergence,
the bifurcation nearest to the core is chosen as the delta.
RULE 6
RULE 7. If a ridge enters the pattern area from outside, and no other choice of delta, the ending
point of the ridge is chosen as the delta.
RULE 8. If there is no visible ridge that may be chosen as delta, the looping ridge or whorl ridge
infront of the area of divergence maybe chosen as the delta.
RULE 1. If the innermost sufficient recurve does not contain any rod or bar, the core is
placed on the shoulder of the loop farther from the delta.
RULE 2. If the innermost sufficient recurve contains odd number of rods/bars rising as high
as the shoulders, the core is placed upon the summit of the center rod, whether it touches the
looping ridges or not.
RULE 3. If the innermost sufficient recurve contains even number of rods/bars rising as high
as the shoulders, the core is placed upon the summit of the farther one of the two
center rods.
RULE 4. If the pattern is a whorl, it is a possibility that there could be two or more deltas. Most
whorls, houses the core/s in its center.
Ridge Counting
is the process of counting the ridges that touch or cross an imaginary line drawn between the
core and the delta of a loop pattern.
3 Ridge Count
Envelop
trifurcation
2 Ridge Count
An island/lake/eye, and enclosure.
Criss-crossing of ridges
Bifurcation
Converging ridge
1 Ridge Count
A short ridge, long ridge, dot ridge,
An abrupt ending of ridges is given one ridge count.
Ridge that bifurcates
Ridge Tracing
The process of tracing the ridges intervening between the tracing ridge (flows from the left
delta to the right delta) and the right delta.
Rules
In a whorl pattern, look for the left delta and trace towards the front of the right delta.
When the ridge being traced abruptly ends, drop to the next ridge just below the original tracing
ridge and continue the tracing until it reaches the point nearest to the right delta.
When the left delta is a dot, the same procedure in No. 1 shall be followed.
When the ridge that is being traced is a bifurcation, always follow the lower branch until tracing
is completed.
Determine whether the tracing ridge flows inside (above) or outside (below) the right delta.
Draw and imaginary line between the tracing ridge (refers to the left delta that was moved
towards the right delta) and the right delta and count the intervening ridge that touch or cross it.
Exclude the tracing ridge and deltas when counting the intervening ridges.
I. Loops
A type of fingerprint pattern in which one or more of the ridges enters on either side of the
impression, recurve, touch or pass an imaginary line drawn from the delta to the core, and
terminate or tend to terminate on or toward the same side of the impression from which such
ridge or ridges entered.
Types of Loop
Essentials of a Loop
It must have a core
It must have a delta
An imaginary line must pass between the core and the delta.
It must have a ridge count of a minimum of at least one (1) across a looping ridge.
II. Arches
The ridges go from one side of the pattern to another, never turning back to make a loop.
Types of Arch
a. Plain Arch - A pattern in which the ridges enter on one side of the pattern,
then flow or tend to flow towards the other side, with a rise or wave in the
center, with no angular ridge formation and no upthrust.
Plain arch
b. Tented Arch
A fingerprint pattern where majority of the ridges form an arch and one
or more ridges at the center shape a tent in outline giving an angle of
90 degrees or less;
or one with an upward thrust having an angle of 45% or more;
or a pattern similar to a loop but lacking one or two of its essential
Tented arch elements.
UPTHRUST
is an ending ridge of any length rising at a sufficient degree from the horizontal plane; i.e. is
450 or more
Types Whorls
a. Plain Whorl
A fingerprint pattern consisting of two deltas and in which at least one
ridge makes a turn through one complete circuit of 360 degrees.
Plain whorl
Accidental whorl
Fingerprint Classification
Refers to the formula derived for the complete set of ten fingerprint patterns or the arrangement of
fingerprint records into groups or subgroups for filing purposes.
Classification - is the method of obtaining a formula for a set of fingerprints whereby it may be
located in the filling cabinet.
Classification Formula - is the numerical description for a set of classified fingerprints which is
composed of figure and letters written above the horizontal line like a fraction.
Blocking – is an act of inserting the appropriate information consisting of numbers, letters, and
symbols in the appropriate places on the card.
Primary Classification
It is the sum total of all numerical values of whose found in fingerprint set expressed as the
numerator and the denominator plus the pre-established fraction of 1/1.
I. Pairing
Right Hand
N16 N8
Thumb Middle Little
Index Ring
D16 D8 D4
Left Hand
Right Hand
N16 N8
W W C
W C
D16 D8 D4
Left Hand
N4 N2 N1
D D
D D D
D2 D1
K M Primary S SS F
___________32 ____
32
IV. Summing up the numerical values of whorls assigned to the fingers plus the pre-established
fraction of 1/1
N= 16+8+4+2+1 = 31+1 = 32
D= 16+8+4+2+1 = 31+1 = 32
Secondary Classification
It is the exhibition of the pattern type of both index fingers and is always indicated by a capital
letter.
For classification purposes, the right hand is indicated above the line while the left hand is
indicated below the line.
Right Hand
N16 N8
R T C
W C
D16 D8 D4
Left Hand
N4 N2 N1
D D
U A A
D2 D1
K M P Secondary SS F
Left Hand
N4 N2 N1
D D
U A A
D2 D1
Note: When other patterns appear on the card is not included in the small letter groups (r,a,t). It is
indicated by a hyphen (-).
K M P Secondary SS F
___________ ___rWt_______ __
Da-a
Note: When two or more of the small letters occur next to each other, it is indicated by a number with
the letter.
Right Hand
N16 N8
R T C
W T
D16 D8 D4
Left Hand
N4 N2 N1
D A
U A A
D2 D1
K M P Secondary SS F
___________ ___rW2t_______ __
D3a
Loop Sub- Secondary by Ridge Counting - It is the exhibition of the resultant symbol for the ridge
counting in loops as expressed by symbol IO.
Whorl Sub- Secondary by Ridge Tracing - when the whorl is found on the index, middle and ring
fingers of both hands the ridges are traced to obtain the resultant symbol IMO.
For Tented Arch and Plain Arch - If a Plain Arch or Tented arch are present on the index, middle, and
ring fingers of both hands, just put a dash (-) for the sub-secondary classification.
Right Hand
19 RT=1
R W A
Left Hand
10 10 RT=2
R R W
K M P S SubSecondary F
Major Classification
It is the grouping of ridge count and/or whorl trace symbols for the index, middle, and ring
fingerprints appearing on the card.
For classification purposes, the right hand is indicated above the line while the left hand is
indicated below the line.
Loop counts must be converted into small (S), medium (M), or large (L).
Whorl trace values will be indicated by inner (I), meeting (M), or outer (O).
1) Loop Major Division – When the loop is found on the thumb of both hands, the ridges are
counted and compared to the pre- established table of Whorl Major Division.
Conversion
Smaller Larger
1 to 11 small (S) 1 to 17 small (S)
12 to 16 medium (M) 18 to 22 medium (M)
17+ large (L) 23+ large (L)
Note: when deciding which value to assign the thumbs for a loop conversion, always count the left
thumb first.
Note: where whorl appears in the left thumb print, the right thumb is converted as though the left thumb
had a ridge count of fewer than 17.
2) Whorl Major Division – When the whorl is found on the thumbs of both hands, the ridges
are traced to obtain the resultant symbol IMO.
3) Combination of Loop and Whorl Major Division – When one of the thumbs is loop, the
resultant symbol SML is used and when the other thumb is whorl, the resultant symbol IMO is
used. For T and A just put dash in the classification line.
Final Classification
It is the ridge count of a loop appearing in the fingerprints of little fingers. It is located or placed
on the extreme right of the classification line.
For T and A just put dash in the classification line.
Order of Preference:
1. The right little finger is examined first to see to if there is a loop pattern.
2. If there is no loop pattern in the right little finger, then the left little finger is examined.
3. If neither the prints from the right nor the left little fingers possess a loop, there will be no final
Rules:
1. When a whorl is found on the right little finger, ridges are counted from left delta to the core.
2. When the whorl is found on the left little finger, ridges are counted from right delta to the core.
3. If there are two cores, count from the delta to the core which is the fewest number of ridges
away.
4. If the pattern is double loop, count from the delta to the core of the upright loop.
5. If loops are horizontal, use the one nearest to the core.
Key Classification
It is the ridge count of the first loop from the right thumb to the left ring finger excluding little
fingers of both hands.
In the absence of loop, the ridge count of the first whorl will be utilized as the key treated as
ulnar loop.
The Key Classification is placed on the extreme left of the classification line and is always
represented as numerator, no matter where it is taken.
For T and A just put dash in the classification line.
Scarred Patterns
When the following cannot be determined Give
a. Pattern type and value Class of opposite finger
b. Pattern only Pattern of opposite finger with actual value and
reference
c. Count or trace value Probable with reference
d. Opposite fingers scarred Whorls with meeting (M) trace
Note:
Note:
If pattern can be seen, it can be described. For example, “Radial loop of about 5 ridge count.”
When the injury is healed, make all possible attempts to print the individual.
Referencing
Is an alternate choice that is displayed on the classification to indicate that although the
classification may be indicated a certain way, it may also be something else.
It is used when one may not be certain of interpretation of patterns, type, ridge count or trace
value.
Example:
Key Major Primary Secondary Subsecondary Final
Class 5 M 5 R III 9_
M 1 U OMO
Ref 4 MMM 8_
NCIC Classification
The acronym NCIC stands for National Crime Information Center, which is a computerized system
based in Washington D.C.
This system is a computer database of wanted person.
This system is based on the Henry system
The classification process used with this method is much easier than is than Henry system as
there are few rules to follow.
In this system, each finger will be represented by two characters.
There are four categories to this system that are considered for inclusion namely: Arches,
Whorls, Loops, and Others.
Arches
Whorls
a ridge trace value is included in the characters
I = inner, M = meeting, O= Outer
Types of Whorl Character/Symbol
Plain Whorl PI, PM, PO
Central Pocket Loop Whorl CI, CM, CO
Double Loop Whorl DI, DM, DO
Accidental Whorl XI, XM, XO
Loops
Must have two digits.
If the number is lower than 10, a 0 must be placed in front.
Others
Missing/Amputated XX
Scarred SR
Example:
PI09CI121462AAPMDMTT
I 9 I 12 14
W U C U U
12 M M
R A W D T