Introduction To RR Signaling
Introduction To RR Signaling
to
Railroad
Signaling
Table of Contents
Table of Contents................................................................................................. 1
Chapter 1 - History and Purpose of Railroad Signaling.................................................. 3
1.1 Operational Requirements ............................................................................... 3
1.2 Train Braking Characteristics ......................................................................... 4
1.3 Time Separation................................................................................................ 4
1.4 Train Orders ...................................................................................................... 5
1.5 Manual Block .................................................................................................... 6
1.6 Automatic Block .............................................................................................. 10
Chapter 2 – Concept of Track Circuits ........................................................................... 11
2.1 Mechanical Track Structure .......................................................................... 11
2.2 Closed Loop Principle..................................................................................... 12
Chapter 3 – Basic Block Signals..................................................................................... 13
3.1 Types of Signals ............................................................................................... 13
3.2 Signal Drawing Symbols................................................................................. 18
3.3 Signal Structures............................................................................................. 19
3.4 Signal Aspects and Indications ...................................................................... 23
3.5 Information Flow Between Signals................................................................ 24
Chapter 4 – Basic Interlockings...................................................................................... 26
4.1 Purpose and General Concept of an Interlocking ....................................... 26
4.2 Track Components.......................................................................................... 26
4.3 Track Orientation........................................................................................... 28
4.4 Types of Operation ......................................................................................... 30
4.5 Other Track Components .............................................................................. 33
4.6 Signals .............................................................................................................. 39
4.7 Signal Aspects and Indications ...................................................................... 41
4.8 Safety-Critical Requirement .......................................................................... 45
4.9 Locking and Check Functions ....................................................................... 46
4.10 Drawing Symbols ............................................................................................ 47
Chapter 5 – Introduction to Railway Signal Equipment ................................................ 48
5.1 Relays ............................................................................................................... 48
As soon as the early railroads found themselves with more than one train
operating in a given area, the need for some form of management over the movement of
trains became apparent. Trains offered much faster transportation than had been
available by any other means, and the pressures were generated from every direction to
take advantage of this capability to the greatest extent possible.
This balancing act between safety and expediting traffic was a slow, painful
process. There were no models to follow. Every step had to be invented from scratch.
Many of these inventions failed for one reason or another, while others succeeded and led
to further advances. It was truly a trial-and-error process, and the errors were often
deadly to train crews, passengers, and the general public. In the modern era, we think in
terms of capacity enhancement, increasing efficiency of movements, and improved asset
utilization. In the early days, the questions revolved more around “How can I get this
train from A to Z without spilling it all over the landscape and killing people?”
One of the underlying reasons why train movement needed special management is
the physics of braking and stopping a train. Three factors join forces to make trains a
prime candidate for accidents, in the absence of some means to manage the process. One
factor is the constraints placed on movement by the track. Unlike automobiles and
trucks, or even the horse-drawn wagons of the early railroad era, a train cannot veer
sideways to avoid hitting something in its path. It follows the rails, whether there is an
obstruction or not. The second factor is the large momentum resulting from having a
long string of cars, or even a short one, stretched out behind the locomotive. Simple laws
of physics dictate that, as the mass of the moving object increases, it packs more energy,
and becomes harder to stop, slow, or change course. The third factor is the adhesion, or
relative lack of it, between smooth steel wheels and the smooth steel rails they run on.
Rubber tires on concrete have very good adhesion, which results in an ability to
accelerate or stop a road vehicle in relatively short time and distance.
The end result, in an automobile, is that you can quite easily come to a stop from
a speed of 60 mph in less that 6 seconds on dry pavement. That is a deceleration rate of
greater than 10 miles per hour per second (mph/s) and results in a total stopping distance
of a little more than 300 feet. A modern transit train with disk brakes and electric control
of those brakes has a typical deceleration rate of 2 mph/s. A heavy freight train comes
closer to a rate of 0.5 mph/s, often requiring more than 2 miles to stop from a speed of 50
to 70 mph.
Comparing the train with the automobile, we drive our cars with the understanding
that if we see an obstruction in the road, we can either go around it or stop short of it.
Control of the vehicle can take place within the visual range of the driver. With a train,
this is very seldom the case. Except at very low speeds, the assumption is that the
engineer cannot stop the train within the range of vision. This situation is compounded in
the case of two trains moving toward each other on the same track. In this case, even if a
train could be stopped short of a stationary object within the range of vision, a train
moving toward you is not stationary and the distance to collision shrinks at the closure
speed between the two trains.
The earliest method used to manage railroad traffic was a time separation scheme.
Schedules were established and printed timetables were distributed as the guideline for
train operation. Trains were expected to arrive and depart certain points according to the
timetable. The schedules allowed for some margin of error, but adherence to the
schedule was an absolute must. A train would run at full speed, confident that it was still
30 minutes or an hour behind the train ahead. Or, if two opposing trains were to meet at
a passing siding, the timetable showed that and assumed that both would be on their
scheduled time.
Train orders were written documents following one of the many prescribed forms,
or in some cases were strictly free form. Orders were issued by a dispatcher with
operating authority over the division, and communicated to one or more operators at
individual stations or towers along the line. The operators would write down the
instructions, filling in the blanks on the proper form, and each one would then read it
back to the dispatcher, spelling out all critical details for clarity. When approved by the
dispatcher, the operators would take the written order and physically deliver it to the
crews of the affected trains as the trains passed the operator’s location.
Typical train orders would define meet locations, hold times, limits of authority,
and various other special instructions. A train order was required to authorize any train
movement in the areas designated as train order territory. A simple meet order might say
something like “No. 15 meet No. 12 at A, No. 8 at C”. Reference to the timetable would
indicate which train takes the siding at each meet point, based on superiority. Other train
orders would specify which train takes the siding or which one holds the main track. If
conditions changed, a new order could be written that annulled the prior order and
replaced it, or in some cases new orders could amend an existing order.
Manual block operation was the next improvement to come along, especially in
areas where the amount of traffic exceeded the capacity of a train order system to
function efficiently. In manual block operation, the line was divided into sections called
blocks and the boundary between two adjacent blocks was staffed with a person called a
block operator. Block operators had to communicate with adjacent operators and with
the division dispatcher to agree on how to handle the traffic. Rules required that a train
could be authorized to enter a block under certain conditions, and responsibility for
assuring those conditions and for communicating authority to the train crews was the job
of the block operator.
A B C
Block Block
In short, dialog between the adjacent block operators, originally by telegraph and
later by telephone, established whether and when authority could be granted for a train to
use the block. Once this was determined, the authority was conveyed to a train crew by
Many different means were used to accomplish this visible signal. One of the
early ones was something similar to a flagpole next to the block operator’s shanty or
station. A large round object resembling a big beach ball was tied to a rope and could be
raised to the top of the pole or lowered by the operator. If the block was clear and the
train had authority to proceed, the ball was raised to the top of the pole. Being visible for
quite some distance, the engineer could see the ball high in the air and know that he could
keep moving without slowing down. If the ball was not at the top of the pole, the train
had to stop for further instructions. This was the source of the old slang term highball
referring to full speed ahead.
Another early form of signal was a large brightly painted board situated on a pole
next to the track, mounted on a horizontal pivot. The operator could move the board to a
vertical position on the pivot to signal that the train could proceed. If the train was
required to stop, the board was rotated to a horizontal position that extended partway
across the track as a visual barrier. If the train did not stop, it would hit the board and
break it off, which would be evidence that the train violated the signal. The impact of
hitting and smashing the board was also supposed to alarm the crew in case they had been
inattentive. This device was called a smashboard. The rotating board concept was later
modified into what we came to call the semaphore signal, some of which are still in use
today.
A railroad track consists of two steel rails attached by spikes or other fasteners to
cross-members called ties (or sleepers in Europe), and laid on the ground with lots of
small stones called ballast, packed around the ties to hold them in place. Where pieces of
rail meet end-to-end, the ends are fastened together either by welding or by the use of a
pair of steel joint bars, one on each side of the rail. These joint bars are bolted together
through holes in the rail. In most main line areas today, rail is welded into very long
strings as one continuous piece of steel. This is called continuous welded rail sometimes
abbreviated as CWR. Branch lines, short lines and low speed sidings generally still use
jointed rail in which the rail itself is supplied in short lengths, commonly 39 feet. It is
spliced together using the rail joints described above.
A track circuit is a simple means used for over 100 years to automatically detect a
train in a section of track. The concept of a track circuit is the use of the two rails as
conductors to complete an electrical circuit. There is an energy source or feed at one end
of a section of track, and a device to detect or receive that energy at the opposite end of
the same section. Under most conditions the limits of the section of track involved in a
track circuit are defined by placing a special electrically insulated rail joint in both rails at
both ends of the section. This defines a single track circuit. Feed wires and receive wires
are then connected to the rail close to the ends to obtain the maximum benefit of the
continuity check provided by the circuit. If the track is comprised of jointed rail rather
than CWR, a short length of wire called a track bond must electrically bypass each bolted
Energy supplied from the feed end is detected at the receive end and keeps the
receiver energized, unless something happens to break the current flow to the receiver.
This break in current flow could be caused by a break in a wire somewhere in the circuit,
a broken rail, a loss of power, failure of the source or receive device, or the presence of a
train. The train wheels and axles form a short circuit, which absorbs most of the energy
from the feed and allows the receiver to become de-energized. This arrangement,
illustrated in Figure 2.2.1, forms a continuous closed loop in which any interruption
results in a safer condition. Any failure causes the same effect as the presence of a train:
the receiver becomes de-energized. This is known as the closed loop principle, which
forms the foundation of all the fail-safe design practices used in signaling.
Feed Receive
Because of inertia and relatively poor braking ability of a moving train, a train is
usually unable to stop within the range of the driver’s vision. This fact creates a need for
signals to provide the driver with information not obtainable by looking down the track.
Photo Courtesy of James Mitchell
These examples illustrate upper quadrant semaphore signals. Another design that
was relatively common was lower quadrant semaphores, where the arm tilted downward
from the horizontal or stop position to indicate a caution or proceed. While the upper
quadrant models relied on gravity acting on the arm to drop it to the most restrictive state
(the stop indication), the lower quadrant models used a counterweight that
overcompensated for the weight of the arm itself. Thus the gravity effect on the
counterweight was sufficient to pull the arm up to the horizontal position, indicating stop.
Semaphores, mounted on tall poles next to the track, allowed good daylight
visibility by the locomotive operator, however, visibility at night was a serious problem.
To compensate for this, a portion of the semaphore arm close to the pivot point was
equipped with colored lenses mounted in round openings. A single lamp (early designs
used oil lamps) was placed behind the arm so that each arm position would place a
different colored lens in front of the lamp. At night, when the arm was difficult to see,
light from the lamp would pass through one of the colored lenses; the resulting color
indicated the arm position. Green was used for the vertical position (clear), amber or
yellow for the diagonal (caution), and red for the horizontal (stop).
When the electric lamp was invented, it was used in place of the oil lamp and
night visibility of the semaphore became much improved. As electric lamps and optics
were improved, the colored lights became more visible from a greater distance than the
semaphore arm itself, even in daylight. New signals were developed using lights without
arms, becoming known as color light signals. The result was improved communications
and big savings in maintenance and mechanical problems. Modern color light signals
consist of separate lamp chambers, each with its own optics and color filter to display one
of the three basic instructions—clear, caution, or stop.
Photo Courtesy of James Mitchell
Another variation of the original semaphore design was called the searchlight
signal, (see Figure 3.1.6). A searchlight is a miniature semaphore mechanism without the
arm. It has one lamp in an enclosed housing with powerful optics, leading to a single
opening. Between the lamp and the external lenses is a moving vane that contains three
small colored filters. The vane rotates on an axis that puts one of the three color filters
between the lamp and the optics. Voltage applied to a coil in the mechanism causes the
vane to rotate one direction to display yellow and the opposite direction to display green.
The last design, devised and used only by the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, is the
color-position light signal, depicted in Figure 3.1.8. As the name implies, the signal uses
the standard colors, but each color is presented using two separate lamps arranged in a
vertical, diagonal or horizontal row depending on the lamps lighted.
Even though the majority of signals currently in use in North America are the
color-light type, drawing symbols generally still rely on the semaphore arm positions to
illustrate signal status. This is because hand drawn semaphore symbols eliminate the
need to convey instructions in color. The same symbols apply, regardless of the actual
type of signal used, since there is a consistent relationship between the colors and the arm
positions. The symbols shown in Figure 3.2.1 represent the accepted drawing symbols.
Each design shows the location and status of any kind of signal. When it is not necessary
to show what color combinations a signal may display, the common drawing symbol
choice is the circle on a base (1). It represents the presence of a signal, but does not
indicate what type of signal it is or what colors it is equipped to display.
1 2 3 4 5
When it is necessary to indicate what colors a particular signal can display, stick
symbols are used. The symbol shown in (2) can display any of the three standard
colors. Symbol (3) is equipped for red and green only, while symbol (4) only shows
Applying these symbols to a track plan requires laying them on their side since
track is usually shown as a horizontal line. Figure 3.2.2 shows both types of symbols
applied to a section of track. Symbols shown above the track are signals viewed by a
train moving from the right to the left. This is represented by the orientation of the
symbol; a person looking in the direction of travel would see the symbols right side up,
while a person looking in the opposite direction would see them upside down. Symbols
shown below the track are signals viewed by a train moving from left to right.
In the past, a common practice was to show signals to the right of the track to
which they applied. This was logical because for many years the requirement was to
physically install signals on the right side of the track. This requirement no longer exists,
so in modern practice the only clear indication of the applicable direction of a signal is its
orientation on a track plan and cannot be inferred from placement to the left or right. Left
or right side placement on the plan generally corresponds to the physical installation in
the field, which is determined by visibility, clearances, accessibility, and other factors.
Most signals are installed alongside or over the track at a height that puts them at
or above eye level for the locomotive engineer. A typical installation on single track
where there is only one signal involved will find the signal mounted at the top of a pole
or mast approximately 15 to 20 feet tall. The signal will face oncoming traffic down the
track, and the mast will be equipped with a ladder on the back side, leading to a small
platform located just below the signal itself allowing for maintenance access. In some
cases, where the track is signaled for traffic in both directions, there may be two signals
that are mounted on the same mast -- one facing in each direction down the track.
In double track areas, where a signal must be provided for each track, two
separate masts are generally provided, located on opposite sides of the right-of-way.
Trains moving on the right hand track will read the signal on the right side, and trains
moving on the left hand track will read the signal to the left of the left hand track.
Signals cannot be placed in the space between the two tracks due to physical clearance
restrictions.
For many years, federal regulations required that signals be installed to the right
of the track centerline, due to visibility restrictions from the right side of the locomotive
cab. This is no longer the case, and the installation of signals was greatly simplified by
this change. You will still find many installations dating back to that earlier time, which
led to the creation of some interesting looking structures.
Photo Courtesy of James Mitchell
Another structure that has been used for supporting signals where several tracks
are involved is the cantilever structure. This uses a supporting mast outside the track area
with a horizontal structure extending across the track to support the necessary signals.
This maintains them in the proper position relative to the track to which they pertain.
Servicing of the signals is generally done from a platform built into the horizontal portion
of the structure, which can be reached by a ladder mounted to the mast portion.
Photo Courtesy of James Mitchell
Where more tracks are involved or the distances make a cantilever structure
impractical, a signal bridge is sometimes used. As the name implies, a signal bridge is a
In yard and terminal areas, and on sidings where train moves are quite slow,
signals may be mounted at ground level, attached directly to a buried foundation. These
are called dwarf signals, as contrasted to the high signals, which are any of those
mounted on poles, cantilevers, or bridges. Dwarf signals are accessed from the ground
for maintenance work.
In many situations, signals are built with more than one lamp group so that
combinations of colors may be displayed, for example, green over red, yellow over green,
or red over flashing green. Each of those examples, are aspects used for special
applications. In many cases, the same combinations mean different things on different
railroads. Some of the more complex aspects will be discussed in our study of
interlockings. For now, the four listed above will adequately illustrate basic block
signals.
Where there is more than one lamp group, allowing several colors to be displayed
at the same time, each individual lamp group is often referred to as one arm of the signal.
Clearly this term relates back to the semaphore, where a single semaphore arm could be
in any of two or three positions. When the semaphore arm is replaced with a group of
colored lights, in which only one of the group is lit at any one time, that group
corresponds to an equivalent semaphore arm. Arms or lamp groups are sometimes called
heads or units as well. You may hear references to a 3-arm signal, or to the upper head
or lower head of a 2-arm signal, etc.
The operation described above clearly requires some means for communication
between signals, so that the proper sequences of aspects can be displayed for following
moves and traffic direction can be managed for opposing moves. The original method of
performing this communication was the use of wires strung along the track on poles,
linking one signal to the next. A number of different schemes were used, depending in
part on the type of operation desired and on individual railroad standard practice. While
the wire link method works reasonably well, maintenance cost is quite high and reliability
becomes a problem whenever the area is hit with severe storms, falling trees, ice and
snow, floods, etc. Theft of the wire and vandalism are common problems in metropolitan
areas.
At the time of this writing, there is some testing of spread spectrum radio data
links for this application. However, the feasibility of this is not yet proven on a
widespread basis. The radio link and its associated I/O would replace the pole line and
possibly some of the relays at a signal location, but would leave the original track circuits
intact.
The track components of most concern are the switches (sometimes called turnouts) that
route a train from one track to another (see Figure 4.2.1). The key elements of a track
switch are the switch point rails, which are anchored at one end (the heel) and move at
the other end (the points). Point rails are tapered to a very thin edge at the point end to
allow them to be moved against the edge of a regular rail to divert a passing wheel
smoothly onto the point rail. In typical American railroad practice, the two points are
connected together at the moving end by a series of rods that maintain the proper spacing
between the points. Lateral movement of the points result in one point or the other being
pressed firmly against its associated stock rail, which does not move. When one point is
Normal Route
Reverse
Stock Rail Route
Normal Position Guard Rail
Right-Hand Switch
Figure 4.2.1 - Parts of a Track Switch
If a train movement over a switch is in the direction such that the train approaches
the points first, it is called a facing point move. If the movement is in the opposite
direction, approaching the frog end first, it is called a trailing point move.
Most switches have a straight route and a diverging route. Standard terminology
calls the straight route the normal route and the diverging route the reverse route. Even
in switches where both routes are curved, a normal and reverse position must be assigned
for control purposes.
Facing Point
Move Right-Hand Switch Right-Hand Switch
In Normal Position In Reverse Position
The diverging route at a switch includes a curvature between the point and the
frog, and the curve crosses through the frog at some small angle to the normal route.
This angle can vary depending how the switch is used. Obviously, the sharper the angle,
the slower a passing train must travel to get around it safely. Switch curvature is
measured in terms of the tangent of the angle at the frog. The resulting number is
sometimes referred to as the switch size. Smaller numbers are sharper angles. See
Figure 4.3.2. A number 8 switch has a deflection of 1 in 8 (1 inch of deflection ‘D’
occurs in 8 inches of travel ‘T’).
This is about as severe as you will find in normal practice and would be used for
slow speed switching only. Main line switches to be used by through trains are generally
a number 16 or a number 20. Special track work for use with really high-speed trains
may have switches of number 40 or higher. Since safe speed over a switch depends on
switch size (angle), this becomes a factor that must be included in interlocking logic.
The primary function of the switch machine is to move the switch points. This
involves a motor, some gearing, a clutch, and a throw bar connected to the switch point
assembly by means of a throw rod. Another function of switch machines involves
contacts that check for proper positioning of the points (using a point detector rod to the
switch point assembly).
Since a track switch has the ability to route a train in alternate directions or to
derail the train if the point rails is not firmly closed against the stock rail; switch points
must be locked in place. There is a mechanical interlock built into each switch machine
At interlockings where one track crosses another, there are four places where
wheel flanges must have a gap to cross the other rails. As with switches, these are also
called frogs and have similar construction. Frogs used in crossings may have various
angles, from 90 degrees to as low as 15 degrees. The group of four frogs used to
accomplish a crossing is generally called a diamond (see Figure 4.5.1)
Crossing diamonds and turnouts are sometimes combined to reduce the amount of
space needed. One common form of combination in transit work where space is often at
a premium is the scissors crossover. Their typical application is around stations or at the
end of a line, where trains may be required to approach on one track, then change
directions and return on the other track. Illustrated in Figure 4.5.3, this is comprised of
two crossovers overlaid on top of each other with their diverging routes crossing at a
diamond.
Probably the most complicated piece of trackwork is the double slip switch,
sometimes called a puzzle switch. Figure 4.5.4 illustrates the idea of the double slip
switch, but does not attempt to detail it down to individual parts. There are so many
inter-related moving parts that even a person studying it on the ground has trouble
visualizing how it works.
Like the scissors crossover, it is really four turnouts and one diamond, but packed
into a much smaller space than the scissors crossover. Routes can be lined either straight-
ahead or diverging from each of the four entry points, but only one route can be used at a
time. The scissors crossover allows two trains to pass over at the same time provided all
switches are lined normal. Double slips are sometimes found at entrances to major
terminals where a 4 or 6 track “throat” may expand into 15 to 20 separate station tracks.
There is a short gap to cross at a switch frog and the possibility exists that a wheel
flange might hit the tip of the frog and rise up to the top rail surface. Therefore, a special
feature is added to minimize that potential. It is called a guardrail and consisting of a
very short piece of rail mounted adjacent to the stock rail directly across from the frog, as
shown in photo 4.5.6. If a wheel is rolling with its flange snug against the rail containing
the frog, the companion wheel at the other end of the axle will have a gap of
approximately 1 inch between its flange and the opposite stock rail. Beginning with
tapered ends, the guardrail will gently drag this companion wheel over closer to its stock
rail by applying pressure to the back side of the wheel. This opens a small gap between
the flange and the rail at the other end of the axle to prevent that flange from hitting the
tip of the frog. Similar guardrails are used around diamonds and in other situations where
safety requires tighter control of exactly where the wheel rides with respect to the rail.
Interlocking signals, commonly called home signals, define the limits of the
interlocking and stand at the end of the OS track circuit on each track entering the
interlocking. The signals may be of any type (searchlight, color light, position light, etc.)
and may be either high signals or dwarf signals. High signals are mounted 15 to 20 feet
above rail level on a mast or other structure to allow visibility from a considerable
distance. A dwarf signal is viewed by slow trains at a close range. It is mounted in a
short housing attached directly to a buried foundation, with no mast or pole under it.
Aspects and indications are generally similar between the two types, although more
aspects are generally available on high signals.
Depending on application, a home signal may display an aspect that only governs
a train movement through the interlocking. In more common applications it also serves
as a block signal controlling entrance into a main line block. Because there are more
conditions to display on an interlocking signal, they are usually more complex than the
typical block signal. Many of them have two or even three groups of lamps (arms),
allowing them to display a wide variety of color combinations, each of which is defined
as a certain aspect in the rule book. This will be discussed further in the next section.
Rather than leave it up to the crews to remember which signals require absolute
stop and which ones allow stop and proceed, the distinction is generally done with a fixed
marker placed on the block signal and not on a home signal. The most common form of
marker is a number plate, which identifies the signal by its number. Signal numbers are
usually based on the milepost number to the nearest tenth. This is a fail-safe scheme in
that the possibility of a number plate falling off of a signal is much more likely than one
appearing on a signal where it was not initially installed. If a plate falls off, the signal
Another difference in operation between home signals and block signals is that
the normal state or default position of a block signal is usually a clear state, the actual
aspect being based on conditions ahead. Block signals are controlled automatically and,
in the absence of a train in the area, will display the best aspect permitted by safety
controls. The normal or default state of a home signal is to indicate stop until a specific
request is made, either by an operator or, in some automatic operations, by a train in the
track circuit approaching the signal. The specific request will cause the signal to display
the best aspect it can, subject to safety controls, until the train has passed. As soon as the
front of the train passes, the signal returns to the stop aspect until another request is made
to clear it.
Because block signals are located between interlockings, they are often called
intermediate signals. The last intermediate signal that a train passes before reaching a
home signal is called a distant signal or an approach signal (not to be confused with
Approach aspect) for the interlocking.
The home signal often serves a second function as a substitute block signal.
When this function is combined with the requirement to convey instructions about
movement through the interlocking, the result leads to some rather complex indications.
It can be pretty simple if the move through the interlocking is a normal, straight route. In
that case, the only information to convey is the status of the block ahead (clear,
approach or advance approach). In other situations, the route through the interlocking
takes a diverging route through one or more switches. This must be indicated on the
signal, since there are speed restrictions associated with most diverging routes.
To put some order to the possible combinations, the railroads have defined most
diverging moves as falling into one of three speed categories, each of which relates to a
certain range of switch sizes. Railroads are not consistent on the definitions or on the
limits for a particular switch size, but a typical example would be:
As a result, the home signal must be able to display indications calling for one or
more of these three speeds, depending on the route to be followed. Many installations
have only one switch size at a given interlocking, so a signal may not need to display all
three speeds. However, in some of the more complex interlockings there may be
different possible routes beyond a signal, with different speed restrictions. In any case,
the aspects will generally be different for each route.
When you combine this with the requirement to display conditions in the block
beyond the signal, there are many possible combinations. Adding to the complexity of
the subject, not all railroads use the same signal aspects and rules. The same aspect may
have different meaning from one railroad to the next. The examples given here are taken
from the NORAC rules applying to Amtrak, Conrail, and a number of smaller
northeastern roads.
When electrical devices came along, the mechanical semaphore signals were
replaced with electric lamps. The direct-motion switches were fitted with electric or, in
some cases, pneumatic powered machines to move the switch points. This was like
adding power steering to a heavy truck. The operator no longer had to apply enough
muscle to move the switch or semaphore through all the mechanical linkage; he only had
to operate an electrical contact to operate the signal or activate the switch machine. But
the interlocking logic was still performed mechanically, with a smaller but otherwise
similar set of mechanical rods equipped with similar notches and protrusions that
prevented any of the unsafe combinations from occurring. This combination of electrical
power operation and mechanical locking was called electro-mechanical interlocking.
Beginning in the 1920s, the use of relays became very common. The entire
interlocking logic could be performed using various combinations of contacts connected
in series and parallel to achieve the required interlocking results. This greatly reduced
the size, cost and maintenance requirements for interlocking control, and made it much
easier to make changes and additions compared to any of the mechanical schemes.
In relay circuits, the same logic is performed using series and parallel
combinations of contacts. However, the relays themselves introduced new possibilities
for failure. Overcoming or at least minimizing this possibility is accomplished in part by
the special design of the relay itself, which makes the possibility of sticking in the
energized position extremely unlikely. In addition, a closed-loop design practice is
followed which requires that a de-energized circuit always produce conditions more
restrictive than the energized state in the same circuit. All the safety involved in
protecting train movements is achieved in the vital portion of the control logic, and does
not depend on the operator pushing the right button or moving the right lever. The
operator must enter commands into the system to operate the switches and clear signals.
These commands will be executed only if the vital interlocking logic determines that it is
safe to do so.
Processor-based controls largely emulate the logic of the relay systems. In fact,
the creation of logic equations for interlocking control in most processor-based
controllers is developed in an off-line compiler using relay contact symbols. However,
the combination of a solid-state controller and its internal software add a whole new
realm of potential failure modes. These possible failures must be addressed in the design
of both the electronic hardware and the software, just as the vital relay had to be carefully
designed to limit the possible failure modes that it could introduce to the system.
If all of these conditions are met, the route is then locked (logical locking applied
to all switches). When the locking is complete and verified, the requested signal will
clear with the appropriate aspect based on the route and exit block conditions. If it is a
home signal, the aspect is based on the safe speed through the interlocking (maximum,
limited, medium, slow, or restricted). If it is also a block signal, the aspect is impacted by
conditions of the block ahead and by the aspect of the next signal.
Figure 4.10.1 illustrates some typical drawing symbols frequently used in connection
with interlockings.
(1) Two equivalent versions of a block signal, distinguished from the interlocking
absolute signal in item (2) by the presence of the number plates.
(2) Two equivalent versions of an interlocking absolute signal with no number plates
(3) Power operated switch machine without dual control
(4) Power operated switch machine equipped for dual control.
(5) Track switch equipped for power switch machine operation.
(6) Track switch equipped for spring switch operation
(7) Hand throw track switch equipped with electric lock
(8) Hand throw track switch equipped with circuit controller only
(9) Block derail
(10) Split point derail
(11) Insulated joints with track circuits on both sides of joints
(12) Insulated joints with track circuits on one side only (left side)
5.1 Relays
Since the early part of the 20th century, the most fundamental component of
railway signal systems has been the electro-mechanical relay. Relays are used to directly
control all operating equipment (signals, switch machines, crossing gates, etc.) and to
develop the logic networks necessary to execute the controls in a fully safe manner.
Although newer installations are making extensive use of computerized controls, the vast
majority of existing installations at the end of the 20th century are still based on relays,
and some new ones are still being built. There are some jobs that a relay just does better
than solid state, and until that changes, there will always be some relays to deal with in
signaling.
The chapter on interlockings addressed the separation of control functions into the
categories of vital and non-vital, depending on whether that function had safety-critical
implications. These same categories impact the design of the relays used in signal
control systems. Non-vital applications have used a wide array of relays normally
classified as commercial, industrial or telephone relays. Although reliability is important
in any application, the nature of potential failure modes is of no particular concern. No
safety is compromised if a non-vital relay fails to release when energy is removed, or if a
contact fails to open or close when it should. By contrast, vital applications are restricted
to a very specific series of relays that are designed with very particular requirements
stemming from the allowable failure modes. The bedrock principle behind any vital relay
used in American or British signal practice is that when the energy is removed from the
§ Special iron used in core and armature material that will not retain magnetism that
could cause the armature to remain in the energized position
§ Special contact material made of silver-impregnated carbon that cannot weld
closed even with extreme surges in current
§ Wide spacing between contact and structural framing around the contact arms to
prevent contact bending to the point of touching another contact at the wrong time
§ Enclosures that, although not exactly sealed, are largely impervious to dirt,
moisture and insects
§ Use of gravity as a factor in assuring release of the armature when energy is
removed
See Figure 5.1.2 for a generic summary of the main components of a relay. Primary
parts are the magnetic structure consisting of the stationary core and the moveable
armature, the coils wound around the core to create the magnetic field when energized,
and the contacts, both stationary and moveable. The armature is connected to the
moveable contacts and moves them with respect to the stationary contacts. Using typical
signal terminology, the movable contacts are called the heel contacts. In the energized
position, the heel contacts are closed against the front contacts, which are stationary. In
the de-energized position, the heel contacts are closed against the stationary back
contacts. Not all relays have all three types of contacts in every position. Some
applications require only a heel-front combination; sometimes called a Form A contact,
and some require only the heel-back combination, sometimes called a Form B contact.
Where all three are used, it may be called a heel-front-back combination, or sometimes a
Form C contact.
Industrial relays use terminology like Single Pole Single Throw (SPST) for a relay
with only a single Form A or Form B contact set, or Double Pole Double Throw for one
with two Form C contact sets. Most signal relays use considerably more contacts than
that, depending on the special version. There are many different styles and special
versions of the relays used in signaling. Most of the following discussion will address the
design of vital relays only.
The earliest relays were designed to set on a shelf. Photo 5.2.1 shows several
typical shelf-type relays. The cores and associated coils mount vertically on the top, and
the armature and contacts are arranged horizontally below the cores. The armature and
contact grouping are enclosed in a heavy rectangular glass bowl that permits viewing the
contacts clearly from the front. In the de-energized state, the armature is hanging
downward on a rear-mounted hinge, holding the heel contacts against the back contacts
across the bottom. When the coils are energized, the magnetic flux pulls the armature
upward against the pole faces, and the heel contacts are lifted to make contact with the
front contacts mounted across near the top of the bowl. All contacts are electrically
connected to terminal posts on the top of the relay. The stationary front and back
contacts are part of a stiff arm and contact assembly that is actually secured in place by
the underside of the terminal posts. The heels are electrically connected to the terminal
posts using short lengths of soft copper braid or ribbon that will carry the needed current
but is soft enough to have no bearing on the movement of the contacts.
Shelf relays typically have all Form C contacts, but because of the cost of these
rather delicate contact assemblies, different size relays are offered. The 2-point relays are
the smallest, having only two sets of Form C contacts. Larger standard designs are the 4
point and 6 point versions. A unique characteristic of the shelf type relays is that the
armature release is strictly gravity-dependent. There is no spring action involved. As a
result, the orientation is critical. If a relay is inverted, the front contacts close as though
the coils were energized. This has been both a blessing and a curse over the many
decades that shelf relays have been used.
One serious downside of the shelf relays is the fact that all external wires attach
directly to the terminal posts on top of the relay. If a relay has to be replaced, or removed
The two main U.S. signal companies each developed their own version of plug-in
vital relays, and, of course, the two are not interchangeable. With the plug-in relay, all
external wiring is attached to terminals on a socket called a plugboard. The relay is
simply plugged in, with no disturbance of the wiring, and can readily be removed for
service, testing or replacement without impacting the security of the wiring. The only
danger with this approach is the possibility of plugging in a different type of relay with a
different contact arrangement or different operating characteristics than the one that was
intended. To minimize this danger, manufacturers came up with a keying scheme that
mounted a little metal plate on the plugboard. This plate contains a matrix array of metal
pins that exactly matches a hole pattern in a corresponding plate on the relay when the
relay is inserted in the plugboard. If someone tries to plug the wrong relay into a
plugboard, the key will prevent it from making contact with the electrical connections.
Both manufacturers developed a wide range of plug-in relays with many specialty
applications. In both cases, they adopted two standard sizes; one being twice the width of
the other, so rack-mounting combinations could be made up using multiples of the single
or double width relays. The GRS models were called Type B relays, and the sizes were
B1 (standard size) or B2 (double size). US&S called theirs the PN series, with PN-1xx
being the standard and PN-2xx being the double size. Photo 5.3.1 shows the typical Type
B relays and Photo 5.3.2 shows some typical PN-150 and PN-250 relays.
5.4 Batteries
Except for certain urban transit systems and areas with electrified railways, most
signal systems in North America make extensive use of batteries in their power source.
Both primary and storage batteries have been used, although storage batteries are the vast
majority of those in use. Primary batteries serve as stand-alone power sources that can be
used for limited power needs where there is no commercial source of power. When the
battery is exhausted, it is simply thrown away and replaced. In signal work, these clearly
could not be used where there is a significant need for power, as the continuing
replacement cost would be prohibitive. They have been used in some cases for DC track
circuits in very remote areas where there is just no convenient source of commercial
power. However, the advent of solar power has all but eliminated the use of primary
batteries in the signal business.
Almost all new signal work uses some form of storage batteries, which can be
recharged repeatedly from an outside power source. The most common application uses
a commercial AC power source and a charger that keeps the battery at full charge while
supporting the normal load of equipment. In the event of a loss of AC power, the battery
continues to support the load for a number of hours until normal power service can be
restored. A less common but growing application uses solar panels to charge the battery
during bright daylight conditions, and the battery supports the load during the night and
on darker days. Batteries for this type of application must generally have a much higher
storage capacity than those needed to back up commercial power.
Cell capacity is rated in ampere-hours, which defines how much current can be
delivered for a given number of hours before depleting a fully charged battery. The
deliverable power will vary with the discharge rate. For example, an 80 amp-hour battery
could deliver 10 amps continuously for 8 hours. This is called an 8-hour discharge rate.
If discharged with an 80-amp load, it would last somewhat less than 1 hour. With a 1
amp load, it would last somewhat longer than 80 hours. To establish some form of
standard, capacities are defined based on the 8-hour rate, which is a current draw that
totally discharges the battery in 8 hours. Various sizes are used in different signal
applications. One popular series is built in multiples of 40 amp–hours, with common
sizes of 80, 120, 160 and 240 amp-hour batteries. Actual sizes will be different among
different manufacturers.
The most common types of storage batteries in railroad signal use are called lead-
acid batteries, based on their chemical makeup. The positive electrode consists of Lead
Dioxide and the negative electrode is sponge lead. The electrolyte is sulfuric acid. They
have a nominal voltage of around 2.2 volts per cell at full charge, so the typical 12 volt
system which uses 6 cells actually has a fully charged voltage just over 13 volts. This is
similar to the automotive application, which also generally uses lead-acid batteries. In
automotive batteries, the 6 cells are combined into a single container and connected in
series internally. Most railroad signal applications use much higher capacity cells, which
Another battery type that has had considerable use in signal systems is the Nickel-
Cadmium battery, more commonly called NiCad. Its construction uses Nickel Hydrate
for the positive electrode and Cadmium Oxide for the negative, with an electrolyte of
water and Potassium Hydroxide. It performs similarly to the lead-acid batteries but has a
lower terminal voltage per cell at around 1.45 volts instead of 2.2 volts. As a result, a
nominal 12-volt application most often uses 9 cells of NiCad where it would have used 6
cells of lead-acid. Like lead-acid batteries, the NiCad batteries used in signal systems are
generally made as individual cells. One characteristic of NiCad batteries that has made
their use a little less common is a tendency to lose capacity if they go through a series of
small discharges. A lead-acid battery can be discharged anywhere from a few percentage
points to nearly 100%, and when recharged, will recover its initial full capacity. A NiCad
cell that is subjected to near full discharge will recover fully, but if recharged several
times from a shallower discharge state, may no longer have the full original capacity. It
may take several complete discharges to restore that original capacity. However, the
NiCad batteries can handle more full discharge and recharge cycles than most lead acid
batteries. This characteristic, plus their ability to be made into small packages, makes the
NiCad cells good for rechargeable power tools, portable telephones, and other household
applications.
When storage batteries are used, they must be used with battery chargers to
maintain the normal state at full charge. There is a wide assortment of charger
technologies, ranging from extremely simple to highly sophisticated. Capacities also
must vary to take care of the different applications. In general, the system is designed to
allow the charger to supply all of the current for the normal load, plus enough additional
current to recharge the battery within a limited time depending on application. Once the
battery is fully charged, the battery itself should only draw a slight trickle charge current
to make up for internal losses, while the charger delivers essentially all of its current to
the load.
The very simple, lowest cost chargers do not provide much in the way of
regulation. They typically consist of a transformer and simple rectifier that can be set for
the desired terminal voltage. Setting the charge rate on such a charger is a compromise
between overcharging a battery in normal operation or not allowing enough recharge
capability after a discharge has occurred. Such chargers are usually quite reliable, due in
part to their simplicity, but may result in excess battery maintenance due to the difficulty
in establishing the proper charge rate. A slightly more sophisticated type uses a saturable
reactor that tends to minimize the effect of varying AC input voltage. This gives better
regulation than a simple transformer, but does not provide for fine-tuning the charge rate.
There are some rather sophisticated chargers including various types of regulators
that will adjust the charge rate automatically to compensate for battery condition and load
variations. These typically use electronic controls. Some have built-in temperature
compensation, since the natural cell voltage at full charge will vary with ambient
temperature. The more exotic chargers will do a better job of keeping the batteries in
proper balance, but may have lower reliability due to the more fragile electronic controls
within the charger itself. Also, depending on application, the failure modes of the
chargers may have very undesirable consequences.
Common practice for many years has been to use low voltage AC to drive signal
lights except when the power source fails. A power transfer relay is used to detect when
the AC power is lost, and the contacts of that relay then transfer the lighting circuits to
the battery. Since the batteries are typically a nominal 12 volts, the AC source used must
also provide a very similar voltage level to give equivalent illumination on the lamps.
This is done with a lighting transformer that operates from a 120 volt primary and has a
series of secondary taps to allow relatively fine adjustment of the final voltage. Figure
5.6.1 shows a typical terminal setup for a transformer that allows for setting the voltage
anywhere between 8 volts and 15.5 volts in steps of 0.5 volt.
A major concern in signal equipment is the effect that lightning has on the
circuits. Signal equipment is typically exposed to lightning surges due to long external
cable runs or open wire between equipment locations. The track is also a very effective
antenna for collecting lightning surges, and power brought into the equipment location to
operate the system is subject to surges. Arresters that attempt to drain off excessive
power to the ground and protect both the equipment and the personnel who may be in the
area generally protect circuits leaving the controlled environment of the equipment house
or case.
Typical lightning arresters consist of two electrodes separated by a small air gap,
each electrode being connected to a wire terminal. The working circuit to be protected is
connected to one terminal, and earth ground to the other terminal. When the line-to-
ground voltage on the working circuit rises high enough, it will arc across the air gap and
discharge the current to ground. The general class of devices is called air-gap arresters.
Most signal hardware is anything but compact. The bulky nature of the
equipment is largely driven by the perceived relationship between size and ruggedness,
and the need for signal equipment to survive unattended in a potentially hostile
environment for years on end. Given the rather large wire sizes and heavy wire
insulation applied, wire terminations on most signal equipment uses a standard terminal
post that is generally called the AAR Terminal, named for the Association of American
Railroads whose standards define the specifications of the terminal. It is a plated 14-24
bolt and thread, which is not a common industrial standard. The nuts used have a
standard outside hex shape compatible with a standard ½inch socket wrench. When used
with solid wire, the wire is formed into a loop that circles the terminal, and is secured in
place by a washer and nut. Stranded wire is crimped into a wire eye that is properly sized
to fit the terminal post and be secured by the nut. Standard spacing between terminals in
a group is based on a 1 inch grid, which allows ample space for the socket wrench with
no danger of shorting to adjacent terminals. The terminal is solid enough to support very
large wire, and it is common to use wire as large as AWG #6 solid for certain
applications. The same terminal, in combination with a wire eye, can be used with very
small wire when necessary.
Various other hardware is made for use with these terminals, including buss links,
buss straps, and special test links that allow a circuit to be opened for testing without
removing any wires. Terminal strips are made in single rows and double rows, and the
same terminal posts are used on most chargers, transformers, signals, switch machines,
and various other equipment. Some newer electronic equipment uses plug connectors, or
other more compact approved terminals to conserve space, but the old AAR terminal is
still very predominant in signal housings.
5.9 Signals
Some of the more common types of signals were discussed briefly in an earlier
chapter. Actual design and construction of the common types will be explored here.
The most common type of signal on American railroads is the colorlight signal.
The signal unit itself generally is mounted on top of a mast, bridge or other structure to
position it 15 to 20 feet above the rail for best long range viewing from the front window
of an approaching locomotive. The signal unit may be a single cast housing with up to
three separate lamp compartments inside, each having its own round opening toward the
front where the colored light appears, and its own internal mounting brackets for the lamp
socket and any other needed hardware. One hinged back door can be opened to provide
access to all the lamp compartments. Depending on the manufacturer and model, these
one-piece signals may be a vertical combination of the three lamp compartments, or may
be a triangular combination with two lamp compartments side by side on top, and the
third centered between and below the other two.
Behind the clear outer lens is a second, smaller lens called the inner doublet. This
lens is colored to create the desired signal color: red, yellow, green, or lunar white. It is
about 5 inches in diameter and its optical role is to gather as much light as possible from
the bulb and direct it in a conical patter toward the outer lens.
The lamp itself is mounted in a bayonet style socket fairly close to the inner
doublet, and in most signals the socket position is adjustable over a small range to allow
for precise focusing of the signal by setting the filament at the exact focal point of the
inner lens. This adjustment is quite critical, as very small deviations can cause major
reductions in light output. The lamps themselves are made to very exacting standards so
that the location of the filament is very tightly controlled, avoiding the need to refocus the
assembly when replacing a lamp. Lamps in North American practice are typically 18 or
25 watts, rated at 10 volts.
Maintenance of the signals is accomplished using the rear access door, which
provides easy access to the lamp and the inner doublet from behind. Until the mid 1990s,
any cleaning or replacement of the outer lens required getting around to the front of the
unit to reach the front of the lens. If the lens had to be removed, a retaining ring had to
be removed from the front side. This is rather awkward, since there is generally no
service platform in front of the signal. Newer models of signals provide for removing the
entire lens assembly, including the outer lens, from the rear.
Finally, most signals include a built-in peephole sight that allows an installer to
look through the sight, similar to a gun sight, to aim the signal at the proper location on
the track. The aiming process usually includes a fine-tuning stage that requires an
observer some distance down the track to communicate adjustment instructions back to
the person aiming the signal.
Position light signals and color-position light signals consist of an array of smaller
units similar to the modular colorlight in that they each contain a single lamp. Where a
colored output is needed, there is a colored inner lens in addition to the clear outer lens.
All the individual units are interconnected and equipped with a single round background
plate that enhances the visibility of whatever combination is lighted. Typically each
individual outer lens has its own sun hood over it to minimize glare from reflected light.
The most common form of signal mast is a 5 inch diameter steel or aluminum
pipe, with a cast base to secure it to a concrete or galvanized steel foundation that is
buried about 5 feet deep. Many of the cast bases include a junction box area with a
removable cover, containing terminals to allow separating the internal signal wiring from
the underground supply cable. Internal wiring then extends up through the mast and is
brought out to each individual signal unit. Where multiple signals are mounted to the
same mast, specialized side mounting brackets are used and flex conduit is typically used
to bring the wiring from the mast to the signal. Where a mast supports only one signal
head, it is generally attached with a top-of-mast bracket that covers the open top of the
mast and allows wiring to run directly into the signal without a conduit.
For maintenance access, most signal masts are equipped with an attached ladder
and a service platform at the appropriate location for access to the back of the signals.
Given the concern for unauthorized tampering, some railroads have eliminated the built-
in ladder and have developed alternative means for servicing the signals. One of the
newer concepts is to mount the signal mast on top of the equipment housing that encloses
the track circuits and other control equipment. There is a short ladder reaching from the
housing roof to the service platform, but you need to have a portable ladder to get to the
roof. This arrangement also saves on cable installation since the wiring to the signals can
extend directly up from the control equipment without ever going underground. The
Foundations for signals are generally either welded steel assemblies, galvanized
for rust proofing, or modular pre-cast concrete assemblies. In either case, a round hole
must be dug about 5 feet deep, the foundation set into the hole, and then back filled and
tamped to make it solid.
One final signal type that needs to be mentioned is a new technology that is just
being introduced as this is written. It is a solid-state signal that eliminates the
incandescent lamps and colored filters, and uses instead an array of Light Emitting
Diodes (LEDs), which emit the proper color directly when energized. This technology
has been rather widely adopted by the traffic signal industry as a means to dramatically
improve lamp life while reducing power consumption. In the railroad environment, the
main incentive is lamp life improvement, since the railroad signal already operates at a
relatively low power level (18 or 25 watts) compared to traffic signals where the lamps
are generally 120 to 150 watts each. There are technical hurdles to be crossed in the rail
application, which, in addition to the economic questions, have seriously limited the
widespread use of this technology in the early years following its initial development.
5.14 Housings
Most railroad signal equipment is not located close enough to existing structures
to allow the control equipment to share space with other facilities. As a result, most such
equipment finds itself enclosed in a dedicated enclosure provided purely for the housing
of the signal controls. Housings could be roughly divided into two general categories:
houses or bungalows, with “walk-in” capability, and cases, where access is from standing
on the ground.
Most such housings are made of metal, the popular forms being aluminum,
painted steel and CORTEN steel, which develops a natural weatherproof rust coating.
Aluminum is the lightest and requires essentially no long-term maintenance, but is also
more susceptible to damage from vandalism. Painted steel looks good while the paint is
new, but needs to be repainted periodically to preserve appearance and prevent weather
damage. CORTEN steel is supposed to be low maintenance if left alone to weather, but it
looks so bad in its natural state that some users apply paint, which then leads to the same
concern as standard steel housings.
Houses are generally built from modular sections that result in sizes being
multiples of 2 feet. The smaller ones are usually 4x6 or 6x6. There is no top end to the
available sizes, although anything larger than 12x20 is fairly rare. Width is limited by
transport restrictions, whether carried by rail or by truck. Houses, regardless of size,
generally have two walk-in access doors, one at each end.
Cases come in a wide variety of sizes and shapes. There are tiny ones that mount
to a pole and have only one door. Most cases attach to foundations consisting of
galvanized steel or pre-cast concrete piers. Other than the pole-mounted cases, most have
at least two doors, one front and one rear, to permit mounting equipment on one side of a
backboard or rack and wiring from the other side. Low cases may be only around 4 feet
tall, while high ones are typically around 6 feet tall, allowing equipment access from a
comfortable standing position. Low narrow cases with one front door and one back door,
approximately 40 inches wide, are called low singles. A tall narrow case with a similar
door arrangement will be called a high single.
The selection of house or case is not always based simply on the amount of
equipment to enclose. Many railroads, especially those operating in hostile climates,
prefer houses to provide better shelter to both equipment and staff when servicing the
equipment. Also, if environmental conditions are such that limited heating or air
conditioning is required, this pretty well drives the selection to a house, complete with
insulation.
Other facilities often provided include utility outlets, ceiling lights, vent fans,
insulation, heaters, air conditioning, and sometimes bullet-resistant lining. Overhead
cable trays allow wiring to be run neatly from the center racks to equipment and
terminations along the ends and sides.
Cases don’t offer quite as much flexibility, but here there are also a fair number of
options. Most common are some combination of backboards, shelves, and rack space.
Cases also are usually equipped with utility outlets and lights, providing for easier use of
tools and night work. Some cases also provide battery trays at floor level to keep the
batteries together with the control equipment.
Doors on both houses and cases are secured with some kind of padlock, and the
door is usually equipped with an integral 3-point locking mechanism that secures the top
and bottom of the door to the house or case frame along with the edge nearest the handle.
Screened and louvered air vents are commonly installed in the doors for ventilation, with
sliding covers to allow vents to be closed in winter if desired. Also it is common in
houses to have one or more chimney-style air vents at the roof peak, with or without vent
fans. Heat buildup inside a closed metal building on a hot sunny day can be pretty
intense, making the use of ventilation a necessary step to protect equipment as well as
service personnel.
Some railroads prefer to keep their batteries separate from the control equipment.
One reason for this is the presence of corrosive fumes from the batteries, and the potential
for spilling the corrosive electrolyte on the floor of a case or house, which would cause
damage to the metal structure. Keeping the batteries separate is accomplished by use of a
battery box or battery tub, most typically a pre-cast concrete container with a lockable
lift-off lid that is partially buried in the ground close to the house or case where the
battery power is to be used. Cable is run between the battery tub and the house or case
that it supports, either underground or through a solid conduit extending between the
house/case wall and the near wall of the battery tub.
Most of the discussion of this group of equipment will be saved for the class on
crossings, but a brief introduction will be summarized here. Only 25 to 30% of all rail-
highway grade crossings in the United States are equipped with active warning devices of
any kind. Of the other 70 to 75%, many are either secondary roads or private crossings,
or roads crossing branch lines or industrial spurs. The facilities at these crossings are
called passive warning systems, consisting generally of the railroad crossing signs (called
a crossbuck) mounted on a post, and sometimes a stop sign. They warn the motorist that
the road is crossing a track, but give no warning of the approach of a train.
The crossings with active warning systems provide some means of detecting a
train and will activate some combination of visual and audible warning that may be
supplemented by a physical barrier across the roadway. Typical flashing light signals
consist of a metal pole mounted in the near right quadrant of the rail-highway intersection
as seen from the roadway. The standard crossbuck sign is mounted near the top of the
pole, and below it a set of crossarms supporting the flashing light units. The pole is
secured to a foundation by means of a 2-piece cast base that often includes a junction box
with a removable cover, allowing cable from the control housing to be terminated. In
current practice, most of the poles and castings used for bases and crossarms are made of
aluminum to minimize maintenance.
The flashing light unit most commonly used has a 12 inch diameter red lens on
the front, called a roundel, and a 10 volt signal lamp rated at 18 or 25 watts. Behind the
lamp is a parabolic mirror designed to collect most of the light from the bulb and direct it
forward through the roundel. As with railroad signals, the optics are rather refined and
placement of the lamp filament in exactly the right spot at the focal point of the mirror is
essential to achieve proper light intensity. To achieve this, lamp socket mounting
brackets provide for adjustment in several planes. Older signals used a smaller housing
and a roundel measuring 8 inches in diameter. Service access to the light unit itself is
accomplished though the front, with a front door that is hinged at the bottom and secured
in place at the top with a bolt. The front door is essentially a supporting ring for the
roundel, and mounting for the black background and sun hoods which serve the same
function as they do on the railroad signal, providing contrast and glare reduction.
Where roadways are several lanes wide, or where visibility from the road is
limited, a cantilever structure is often used to mount one or more sets of flashing lights
over the roadway in addition to the set on the pole to the right of the roadway. These
cantilever structures can be quite long, up to 40 feet in length, and are made in several
styles. The longest ones contain a walkway and railing along the cantilever arm, with an
integral ladder mounted to the mast, so that maintenance can be performed on the lights
from the arm without blocking the roadway. Most cantilever structures are made of
aluminum to minimize maintenance and weight. The obvious stresses resulting from the
unbalanced load on the base and from wind forces on the arm require a very sturdy
foundation and mounting base. Mounting bases on most cantilevers are factory welded to
the mast with extensive gussets and bracing. The foundations are concrete and are
Some of the smaller cantilevers have been installed using a different concept
where, instead of a rigid structure with a walkout platform for maintenance, the arm can
be rotated 90 degrees to the side of the road and accessed with a ladder directly from the
ground.
The gate arm is raised and lowered by a gate mechanism consisting of a 12-volt
DC motor and gear box, along with a magnetic latch and a series of cam-driven contacts.
The direction of motor rotation is determined by the current polarity applied by the
control circuits. The gate arms are attached to the shaft on the mechanism by an offset
mounting called a conversion bracket, and an adjustable counterweight is mounted to the
opposite end of the bracket. The shape of the arrangement is such that the
counterweights have maximum impact when the gates are horizontal, and minimum or no
effect with the gate vertical. This allows the gate arm to free-fall by gravity from the
vertical position if the magnetic hold-clear device in the mechanism is released. In
normal operation, power is applied to help drive the gates down to around the 45 degree
position, and snubbing circuits provide dynamic braking to soften the stop as they reach
the horizontal position.
For audible warning, most crossings are equipped with a bell that operates at
somewhere between 100 and 225 strokes per minute. The bell is generally mounted at
the top of one of the flasher poles and is intended mostly to warn pedestrians when the
crossing is activated. Mechanical bells have been used for many years, but recently many
railroads have converted to an electronic bell that sounds exactly the same as mechanical
one but is smaller, less costly and requires less maintenance.
Advance warning signs are often used to give drivers advance notice that they are
approaching a railroad crossing. These are generally just a round yellow sign installed by
the highway department, and provide no active warning based on train presence.
All of the signals, switch machines, track circuits, and crossing gates we have
been talking about have one thing in common, they all must be connected electrically to
some control facility using wire and cable. Electrical cable is a major component of any
signal system.
Wiring inside a control housing is mostly done with individual wires, using
stranded copper wire ranging in size from AWG #6 for heavy power circuits to AWG
#19 for serial communications. The most common house wiring for vital circuits
involving relays or solid state controllers uses stranded wire AWG #14 or #16, while
track circuits and signal lighting circuits will more often use #10 for the in-house wire.
This wire must be covered with a substantial insulation to minimize any chance of arcing
between wires from voltage surges. There are various industry specifications for wire
and insulation used for different applications, and these, in many cases, vary by customer.
Wiring outside the housings is generally solid copper wire packaged in various
configurations of multi-conductor cables. The vast majority of signal cable is buried in
the ground, and must meet appropriate industry specifications for direct burial cable.
High voltage insulation is applied to the individual wires in the cable, and the group is
then enclosed in one or more layers of outer insulating jackets and sometimes a metallic
sheath. In most signal cable, the individual conductors are laid in parallel fashion within
the outer jacket. When required, cable can be made with “twisted pairs” of conductors to
Special cable construction is often used for specific applications. Two conductors
#9 or #6 are common for connection to individual track circuits. For track circuits other
than simple DC, these are often done as twisted pairs to minimize coupling with other
pairs serving other track circuits. Switch machine cable is generally made up with more
than one wire size contained within the same outer jacket. Combinations like 3
conductors of #6 and 9 conductors of #14 are useful to provide the larger current capacity
needed for driving the switch motor, while using the smaller sizes for low current
functions like point position monitoring.
For situations where cable needs to be above ground, a different design is used.
Above ground cable is generally hung from poles or bridge girders, or maybe anchored to
supports in a tunnel wall. Since copper wire is not terribly strong in physical strength,
these aerial cables need some physical support to avoid having the entire weight of the
cable borne by the copper conductors between supports. In these cases, a separate steel
wire called a messenger wire is generally used to support the cable. The steel wire is
hung from the supports on the poles, bridge girders etc. and the electrical cable is then
tied to it at closely spaced intervals. To reduce installation costs, a popular version of
aerial cable is made with the messenger wire attached to the electrical cable at the
factory, so the field installation does not require the separate operation of attaching the
two together. Since the messenger wire in this type cable is attached parallel to but
external to the electrical wire grouping, a cross-section of this cable would look like two
circles side by side with a small link between them. For this reason it is often referred to
as figure eight cable.
Cable made for direct burial has its outer jacket made of material that is
particularly resistant to constant moisture, insects, sharp objects (rocks) and other hazards
that might be expected in a buried environment. This cable is seldom installed in
conduit, being instead laid in an open trench along the track or simply sliced into the
ground with a plow. Aerial cable, on the other hand, must be jacketed with material that
has maximum resistance to variations in temperature and to the damaging effects of
ultraviolet rays from the sun, in addition to the obvious need for being waterproof. Once
installed, cable is expected to give trouble-free operation for decades.
The vast majority of signal facilities in North America operate from a commercial
power source. There are some very isolated areas where access to commercial power is
just not practical. These areas may be served by solar panels, primary batteries, or power
distributed by the railroad on their own cable. However, most installations are equipped
with an electric meter mounted on the house, case, or utility pole nearby, with service
being either 110 volts or 220 volts single phase 60 Hz.
Until the 1990s, many signal facilities were wired for AC power using a railroad’s
typical signal practice for wire, cable and terminations. Newer facilities, especially
bungalows, generally follow the National Electrical Code practices including standard
commercial circuit breaker panels and steel conduit for all power wiring. The breaker
panel will contain a main breaker and a number of branch circuits feeding different parts
of the system -- each one having its own branch breaker. Individual branches will be
assigned for functions like house lights and utility outlets, and where used, heater and
vent fans or air conditioning. In addition, one or more branches may be designated for
battery chargers, signal lighting transformers, and specialized power supplies as needed.
Most signal power equipment like chargers and lighting transformers are designed
to operate from a 110 volt source. If the supplied line voltage were higher than that, the
first stop would be a transformer to step down the source to 110 volts. The commercial
power is always grounded on one side and this is maintained through the distribution
It was mentioned earlier that some electrified railways and transit lines might not
use battery backup for some of their signal facilities. There are several reasons for this.
For one, these lines are generally in or around metropolitan areas where commercial
power is readily available and quite reliable, as opposed to remote areas that may be at
the far end of a single distribution feeder that is far from the nearest substation. Also,
electrified railway and transit lines require so much power for the running of trains that a
very substantial power infrastructure is generally built as part of the railway installation
to support the propulsion needs of the system. In many cases, the infrastructure is
designed to be fed from more than one point in the metropolitan power grid, primarily for
reliability of rail service. The same power source that serves train operation is generally
tapped for support functions like signaling. If there is a major power outage that takes out
the railway’s power source, trains will not run, so there is no need to spend extra money
to assure that signals will work. Even in these cases, some level of battery backup is
required for crossing warning systems and is generally provided to support certain
microprocessor control equipment. Without some level of battery backup, software could
be upset and data lost in the event of even a very short interruption in power that would
have no impact on train operation.
In some cases, railroads will decide to install their own power distribution cable to
serve certain locations where the cost of having commercial power service is excessive
due to the distance from existing sources. This railroad-owned cable may be buried
along the track, or it may be suspended from poles. Railroads have also installed backup
diesel generators in certain situations where extended outages could not be tolerated, and
adequate backup service from batteries is not feasible. The generator would ordinarily be
Another alternative that makes sense in some isolated locations is solar power.
The 12-volt operating level of signal equipment is ideal for the application of solar
power. The photovoltaic panels deliver low voltage DC to a bank of batteries through a
regulator that can very easily be set to run at 12 volts. Even for a relatively small
installation, solar will cost substantially more than a commercial service, providing
commercial service is available. But in places where the nearest commercial service may
be several miles away, solar may make economic sense. Each installation of solar power
must be analyzed for capacity requirements, available sunlight, weather patterns, etc.
Batteries must be sized to handle the entire load through the longest nights and partial
loads through periods of gloomy days and low sun angle. Solar panels must be sized in
combination with the batteries to provide not only the full load current during peak
daylight hours, but also to generate adequate power from less-than-ideal sun conditions.
They must also have the ability to recharge the batteries at the same time they are
delivering load energy, even under these less-than-ideal conditions. Solar power supply
experts generally do this analysis process, and this expertise is neither common nor
expected within the signal engineering profession. Needless to say, solar power makes
more sense in places like Texas and Arizona than it does in Oregon and Alaska.
A power source that has not yet found its way into the signal world but may in the
future is fuel cells. Fuel cells have been used in space missions for years and are
beginning to be tried on automobiles and other land vehicles. Using hydrogen as a fuel,
they create electrical energy with no moving parts and no emissions other than water
vapor. Obstacles to widespread application as this is written are cost and availability of
AC and DC voltages are used all around us in our world today at home, work and
most assuredly in railroad signaling.
DC stands for “Direct Current” and always has a steady positive state. DC is the
type of voltage we get from a battery. AC stands for “Alternating Current” and is the
type of energy we get from the power generating companies. Due to the mechanical
physics of generating this type energy, the output is always changing from positive to
negative and back again.
+5 V
A.C. 0V
-5 V
+5 V
D.C.
0V
+5 V
Positive
Alternation
0V
Negative
Alternation
-5 V
The number of times the voltage completes one cycle from 0 volts through its
peak positive and peak negative values and back to 0 volts in one second is referred to as
the frequency of the AC signal and is expressed in Hertz. The AC signal supplied by
power generating companies in the United States is 60 Hertz.
By changing the duration of the positive and negative alternations the frequency
of an AC signal can be changed. Using a variety of AC frequencies, allows for multiple
AC voltages to be applied to the same circuit and these signals can be used for different
functions. Components can be used in an AC circuit to filter only the frequency required
for any particular use.
Step-Down
Transformer
Diode
Output
+12 V
0V
On the left side of the drawing in Figure 7.3.1, is the plug that plugs into the wall
socket and on those lines that represent the wires hooked to the plug is an AC voltage
(notice the sine wave symbol). This AC voltage is then passed to a step-down
transformer. A transformer is a device used to convert an AC source voltage to a
different level of AC voltage. A step-down transformer will take a higher AC voltage
and convert it into a lower AC voltage, while a step-up transformer does the opposite.
The step-down transformer, in Figure 7.3.1, converts the 120 VAC source to 12 VAC.
On the right side of the transformer, the 12 VAC is sent through a diode (the arrow
pointing to a line symbol). The diode will pass the positive alternation and block the
negative alternation. The output is the pulsed 0 to 12 volts positive voltage shown in the
lower right of Figure 3. Any load attached to the output terminals, the motor for instance,
will have a pulsating DC voltage applied to it. The motor will operate in a single
direction because the supplied voltage is pulsed, with each pulse the same polarity.
Using a single diode, only the positive alternations are supplied to the load for use
and the negative alternations are not used. Only half of the usable voltage from the AC
source or the sine wave is used, this is called half-wave rectification.
The output as shown in Figure 7.3.2, is a more consistent energy source then the
source using half-wave rectification illustrated in Figure 7.3.1. As one alternation turns
off the other is turning on. The motor does not recognize the off time between pulses and
will operate just as if it were attached to a steady 12-volt battery. Using the full-wave
rectifier, an AC voltage can be converted into a nearly steady DC voltage.
Step-Down
Transformer
+ +
Output
- 12 VAC
-
120 VAC
+12 V
0V
Step-Down
Transformer
- +
Output
+ 12 VAC
-
120 VAC
+12 V
0V
In electrical circuits, DC current will flow from the source through the wires and
components of the circuit and back to the battery. The circuit shown in Figure 7.4.1 is an
example of a simple circuit consisting of a source of electrical energy (the battery), a path
for current flow (the wires), and a load (the light bulb).
Load
Source
Path
The battery can be described as any source of direct current or a source where a potential
difference of polarity exists. If a potential difference exists, there is a possibility for
current to flow from one polarity to the other. Battery or voltage level is expressed in
Volts or V or E.
Current flow can be described as the movement of electrons within the materials that
compose the circuit. Only the materials through which it must pass to get to the opposite
potential limit current flow. Current flow is expressed in Amps or I.
Resistance can be described as the opposition to current flow. The more resistant a
material is, the less current will be allowed to flow. Resistance to DC current flow is a
physical property of the materials or components of the circuit. Resistance is composed
of all components in the circuit including the resistance added to the circuit by the wires
of that circuit. In most cases, the resistance added by the wires in negligible and is not
included in any calculations relating to the circuit. Resistance is expressed in Ohms or Ω.
When multiple paths for current flow exist, current will divide between the paths
and different quantities of current will flow through each of the paths depending on the
resistance of the loads attached. This type of circuit is called a Parallel Circuit.
Circuits that use a combination of series and parallel components are called
Series-Parallel Circuits.
Load
+
Current
Flow
Source
Series Circuit
Load
Source
Parallel Circuit
Figure 7.4.2 – Simple Series and Parallel Circuits
A set of rules called Ohm’s Law describes how the load and the DC source
interact, and provides a means to predict or calculate where and how much current will
flow in any electrical circuit.
That statement can be written as equations that can then be used to calculate any value in
any DC circuit.
E
I =
R
E
E = IR
R=
E I R
I
If there is 1 volt present with a path and a 1 ohm load there will be 1 amp of current.
Load
1 ohm
+
Source
1 volt Current
1 amp
-
Series Circuit
Load
2 ohms
+
Source
10 volts Current
5 amps
-
Series Circuit
E 10 V
I = = = 5A
R 2Ω
E = IR = 5 A * 2 Ω = 10 V
E 10 V
R= = = 2Ω
. I 5A
In the previous examples, the load has been described as a single component, the
light bulb. However, most DC circuits consist of a variety of components, all of which
can be described as a resistance of some kind and of varying resistance values. How the
components are connected to the battery source determine where and how much current
will flow in the circuit.
As described earlier, the series and parallel connections allow current to flow in
different portions of the circuit and the resistance values of those portions of the circuit
will directly affect the amount of current flow.
Rules can be defined to describe how current, voltage and resistance react to
series and parallel circuits. These rules can be separated into 2 sections, those associated
with series circuits and those associated with parallel circuits.
Ø Voltage remains the same across all paths of the parallel circuit
Ø Current divides between paths of the circuit
• The total current flowing through parallel paths will equal total circuit
current.
Ø Resistance of a parallel circuit is always lower than the lowest resistance path
of the parallel circuit
Memorizing these six rules and where they apply is the first step towards solving
for values of a circuit using Ohm’s Law. Some circuits may be a combination of both
series and parallel circuits and these same rules apply.
Voltage and current can be easily calculated using Ohm’ Law. Resistance,
however, causes current to flow differently depending on its connection to the voltage
source.
Calculating circuit resistance requires additional rules for series and parallel circuits.
Resistors in series required all current to flow through all the resistance so the resistance
total would be additive.
Resistance values are added together to calculate the total circuit resistance as shown in
Figure 7.5.4.
Total Resistance (RT) = 2 Ω + 2 Ω =
4Ω
R1
+ 2Ω
10V
- R2
2Ω
Ø Product / Sum
• This can only be used with 2 parallel paths
Ø Reciprocal
• This can be used for any type of parallel circuits
+
10V R1 R2
2Ω 2Ω
-
Value 2Ω
Resistance / Number RT = = = 1Ω
# Resistors 2
Product 2*2
Product / Sum RT = = = 1Ω
Sum 2+2
1 1
Reciprocal RT = 1 1 = 1 1 = 1Ω
+ +
Value Value 2 2
In the circuit shown in Figure 7.5.6, rules for both series and parallel circuits will
be applied to different parts of the circuit.
R2
+
4Ω
2V R1 R3
2Ω 2Ω
-
In this circuit, current will flow from the battery through the conductor to the first
junction point. Some current will then flow through R1 and the remaining current will
flow through the path made up of R2 and R3 . With the current splitting between paths the
circuit exhibits the characteristics of a parallel circuit. In the parallel path made up of R2
and R3 , all the current is required to flow through both resistors, characteristic of a series
circuit. The rules for series circuits would apply to this portion of the circuit.
To calculate the total resistance of this circuit, it is necessary first to apply the
series rules to calculate the resistance of the R2 and R3 path. In Figure 7.5.7, these rules
have been applied and an equivalent circuit is shown.
2V R1 R2 + R3
2Ω 6Ω
-
A simple parallel circuit remains and the total resistance can now be calculated
using either the product/sum or reciprocal formula. Once the total resistance is
calculated, current and voltage drops can then be calculated for each component in the
circuit.
ET 2V
IT = = = 1.33 A
RT 1.5 Ω
The rules of parallel circuits state that voltage remains the same across all paths of a
parallel circuit. Using this information, the voltage drop across R1 will be 2 volts as will
the voltage drop across the series connected R 2, 3.
2V R1 R2 + R3
2Ω 6Ω
- 2V 2V
With 2 of the values for R1 , the current flow through this path of the parallel circuit can
now calculated.
ER1 2V
IR1 = = = 1A
RR1 2Ω
ER2, 3 2V
IR2, 3 = = = .33 A
RR2, 3 6Ω
With current flow calculated in the parallel path of R 2, 3, the rules for series circuits can
be applied for current flow through R2 and R3 . The series rule states current remains the
same throughout the circuit.
R2
+
4Ω
2V R1
.33 A R3
2Ω 2Ω
- .33 A
Now that 2 values for each component have been calculated, the voltage drops for each
resistor can be determined using Ohm’s Law.
Using both the rules for series and parallel circuits and Ohm’s Law, the voltage
current and resistance values of all components in a circuit can be calculated. It is
necessary to have enough information regarding the circuit to accomplish these
calculations. At least 2 of the values are required to use Ohm’s Law and all of the
resistance values are required to use the rules for series and parallel resistance.
At any load or source the voltage drop at the component is multiplied by the
amount of current flowing through the component to determine the amount of power used
at that component. It is irrelevant whether the component is in series or parallel since
power is calculated at the component using values obtained by Ohm’s Law calculations.
Load
2 ohms
+
Source
10 volts Current
5 amps
-
Series Circuit
PT = IT * E T = 10 V * 5 A = 50 W
Figure 7.6.2 shows the various formulas that can be used to calculate voltage,
current or power depending on the information provided.
P
I =
E
P
P = IE
E=
P I E
I
As in a DC circuit, current will flow from the energy source (the transformer or
generator) through the conductors (the wires) and through the load. The main difference
between DC and AC current flow is that the direction (polarity) of the current flow
changes constantly with AC, as previously described.
Resistors will react to AC current flow in the same manner that they react to DC
current flow, as resistance is a physical property of the material from which they are
constructed. Resistors will oppose current flow regardless of the direction current flows
in the circuit.
7.8 Inductors
An inductor is simply a coil of wire. A core can also be inserted into the coil to
allow the inductor become more effective. Inductors use the magnetic field that is
created when current is passed through the wire to resist AC current flow. This effect is
called inductance and is measured in Henry’s. Depending on the frequency of the AC
signal, the inductor will react differently and this resistance to AC current flow is called
inductive reactance.
N S
+
An AC signal applied to the inductor will also cause magnetic fields to be created.
When the AC signal is in the positive alternation, a magnetic field is created as shown in
Figure 7.8.2. However, when the AC signal is in the negative alternation the polarity of
the voltage on the inductor is reversed and the magnetic field created is opposite to the
field created in the positive alternation as shown in Figure 7.8.3.
S N
-
Because inductors use the changing polarity of the source to block AC current
flow, the higher the frequency of the AC signal or the more often the polarity changes,
the more effective the inductor will be.
Inductors are mainly used to block AC from passing through the circuit
containing an inductor and are often called filters or chokes.
7.9 Capacitors
Plates with
dielectric center
A DC voltage source will quickly reach this threshold and current flow will stop.
AC voltage is not affected by capacitors as the voltage changes constantly. Capacitors
can be used to block DC current while allowing AC current to pass.
Use the material covered on Ohm’s Law and solve for the following, rounding all
answers to 2 decimal places, if necessary:
R1
Problem 1
35 Ω R2
10V 10 Ω
R3
50 Ω
RT IT
ER1 IR1
ER2 IR2
R1
Problem 2
15 Ω R2
10V 25 Ω
R3
15 Ω
RT IT
ER1 IR1
ER2 IR2
10 Ω R2
2V 10 Ω
R3
20 Ω
RT IT PT
Problem 4
R1
15 Ω R2
__ V 10 Ω
R3
25 Ω
ET IT .5 A RT
50 Ω __ Ω R3
24V 10 Ω
R4
30 Ω
RT IT 120 mA R2
ER1 ER3
ER2 ER4
Problem 6
R1 R2
10V 10 Ω 10 Ω
RT IT
ER1 IR1
ER2 IR2
R1 R2
2.2V 1.1 Ω 3.8 Ω
RT IT
ER1 IR1
ER2 IR2
Problem 8
R1 R2 R3
2.2V 1Ω 3Ω 5Ω
RT IT PT
R1 3Ω R3
2.2V 1Ω 5Ω
RT IT PT
Problem 10
R2
R1 3Ω R3
2.2V 1Ω 5Ω
R4
1Ω
RT IT IR3
ER2 IR2 PT
R1 1Ω R3
2.2V 5Ω 4Ω
R4
1Ω
RT IT IR3
ER2 IR2 PT
Problem 12
R2
R1 1Ω R3 R5
2.2V 5Ω 4Ω 2Ω
R4
1Ω
RT ER3 IT IR3
R1
Problem 1
35 Ω R2
10V 10 Ω
R3
50 Ω
RT 95 Ω IT .11 A
R1
Problem 2
15 Ω R2
10V 25 Ω
R3
15 Ω
RT 55 Ω IT .18 A
10 Ω R2
2V 10 Ω
R3
20 Ω
RT 40 Ω IT .05 A PT .1 W
Problem 4
R1
15 Ω R2
__ V 10 Ω
R3
25 Ω
ET 25 V IT .5 A RT 50 Ω
50 Ω __ Ω R3
24V 10 Ω
R4
30 Ω
Problem 6
R1 R2
10V 10 Ω 10 Ω
RT 5Ω IT 2A
ER1 10 V IR1 1A
ER2 10 V IR2 1A
R1 R2
2.2V 1.1 Ω 3.8 Ω
RT .85 Ω IT 2.59 A
Problem 8
R1 R2 R3
2.2V 1Ω 3Ω 5Ω
R1 3Ω R3
2.2V 1Ω 5Ω
Problem 10
R2
R1 3Ω R3
2.2V 1Ω 5Ω
R4
1Ω
R1 1Ω R3
2.2V 5Ω 4Ω
R4
1Ω
Problem 12
R2
R1 1Ω R3 R5
2.2V 5Ω 4Ω 2Ω
R4
1Ω