The Use and Abuse of Powerpoint in Teaching and Learning in The Life Sciences: A Personal Overview
The Use and Abuse of Powerpoint in Teaching and Learning in The Life Sciences: A Personal Overview
The Use and Abuse of Powerpoint in Teaching and Learning in The Life Sciences: A Personal Overview
A PERSONAL OVERVIEW
Allan M Jones
Pages 1-13 | Received 18 Jul 2003, Accepted 18 Aug 2003, Published online: 14 Dec 2015
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3108/beej.2003.02000004#:~:text=There%20are
%20many%20reasons%20but,presentation%20in%20a%20professional%20manner.
Abstract
The use of PowerPoint for teaching presentations has considerable potential for
encouraging more professional presentations. This paper reviews the advantages and
disadvantages associated with its use in a teaching and learning context and suggests
some guidelines and pedagogical strategies that need to be considered where it is to
be used. It summarises some of the key principles of presentation that are frequently
ignored and suggests some of the approaches that need to be incorporated into good
practice in Life Science teaching and learning. Its use is often limited to an information
transmission mode and this paper emphasises that this is a very restricted pedagogical
use of a very powerful and flexible teaching and learning support tool.
Keywords:
PowerPoint, policy, strategy, pedagogy, handouts
Introduction
So why should you consider using PowerPoint for your teaching and learning
activities? There are many reasons but the key ones include:
The electronic file format allows distribution and modification for/by students unable to
be present or who have impaired visual or auditory difficulties. PowerPoint comes with a
free viewer programme that can be distributed with the files so that the reader is not
required to have PowerPoint on their personal system. However, if they do have it, they
are able to perform a greater variety of manipulations on the PowerPoint file provided,
such as editing the text, etc before printing it out. Most Virtual Learning Environments
(VLEs) are now capable of including PowerPoint presentations if required.
Editing of each PowerPoint file is very easy with minimal associated reprinting
costs. This ease and potential immediacy of revision facilitates reflection upon, and
evolution of, teaching materials by staff whilst minimising the consequences of any
revision in terms of either workload or time. This was a major reason for my own extensive
switch of teaching materials to PowerPoint, even when the end-product was required to
be an overhead projection slide. I also find that I can add a new slide whilst in a lecture
if so required: I often use this method to present notices or create a record of the
outcome when collecting information from the class so that it can subsequently be made
available to the entire class.
Extra information can be ‘hidden’ within files for answering predicted questions or
for providing feedback to students using the file in a distance-learning context. The use
of speakers notes as an automated feedback system was described by Mottley
(2003) who also describes other ways to use PowerPoint for development of self-study
materials
The portability of the files, especially on compact disks (CDs) with their large
capacity, allows presentations to be given wherever the technology is available or
distributed where appropriate. Presentations can also be set up to run automatically if
required e.g. as demonstrations/instructions within a laboratory
Staff are often reluctant to invest the time required to convert materials to an
appropriate PowerPoint format. Those that do convert current materials may not do so
in a very acceptable way, simply using PowerPoint as an alternative way to provide text-
based notes. Appropriate use of PowerPoint involves using its features to enhance the
teaching and learning experience and this is daunting to some who do not wish to spend
significant time developing their understanding of the pedagogical opportunities and
limitations offered by PowerPoint. Most of those who do decide to develop their use of
this technology, however, find that for a relatively short-term investment of time at the
start, they receive a long-term benefit in both the quality of their presentations and in the
ease of maintaining and updating their teaching. Seen as an investment for the future,
using PowerPoint is a very positive activity.
The learning curve for the technology is often perceived to be too steep. There is
always a reluctance, particularly among the older and less technology-orientated staff,
to adopt the new technologies: the adage that “you can’t teach an old dog new tricks”
is an appropriate perception for some. However, there is no absolute requirement for all
to use this technology, simply an opportunity for those who are so inclined to become
involved in this new form of delivery of material. Experience from running staff
development sessions aimed at developing appropriate PowerPoint skills, using both
hands-on and seminar formats, suggests that it is actually a remarkably easy process
compared to learning to use some of the other, commonly used software frequently
found on modern computer systems.
There are, of course, several risk factors associated with using the technology that
make some reluctant to commit to its use, the main ones being:
c. Incompatible media: arriving and finding your files are incompatible with the
system available. Best solution is to be aware of the systems you plan to use or
carry your own laptop.
d. Lack of appropriate training in both the programme and the technology. This
is a significant problem in many institutes but is beyond the topic of this paper.
I favour departmentally-orientated staff development activities where both
seminars and hands-on sessions can be very successful.
The use of PowerPoint has caused much debate since its increasing use has
corresponded with a period when attendance at lectures has declined noticeably
throughout Higher Education, largely independent of discipline or institution. This has led
to some implicating the availability of PowerPoint files to the student population in this
decline. However, it is evident from the widespread observations that courses not using
PowerPoint have suffered similar declines in attendance to those that do use it, that the
problem is not specific to the technology. It is much more closely related to the quality
of lectures in general and more general difficulties encountered by the student
population such as having to undertake paid term-time employments. Where PowerPoint
is considered a negative factor, it is usually as a result of the ‘misuse’ of the technology
through inappropriate pedagogical approaches. So how should it be used? The
following is a review of some of the key issues that need to be resolved before PowerPoint
can be used optimally within a course/module.
A key issue is ‘when’ it can be used. ‘When’ may be a curriculum issue that is
discipline dependent or it may be a resource issue in terms of using in computer
projection mode. However, its wider adoption for the production of acetate overheads,
even when computer projection mode is restricted, would unify the presentations
strategy and produce files/materials that are ready for the projection technology once
it becomes available. Even if delivery is by overhead, it would be sensible to produce
PowerPoint files as a student resource that can be distributed or adapted for disability
requirements. They are normally compatible with VLEs such as BlackBoard and webCT so
that an overhead presentation can usefully be provided in PowerPoint format.
In terms of its use within the curriculum, there are many potential options available,
limited only by the nature of the subject and the creativity of the user (e.g. Mills 2003).
Clearly it is most commonly used in lecture/seminar situations, often largely in information
transmission mode. Here the potential improvements in structure and clarity, especially
when appropriate graphics are used, are very significant positives although there are
dangers too: such presentations can e.g. become gimmicky; overloaded with material
and effects; encourage students to be passive during lectures; be delivered too quickly,
etc. The linear structuring typical of many lectures can be made more flexible by using
hyperlinking options, both within and outwith the PowerPoint presentation, and by using
the methods for jumping to particular slides that are not part of the linear sequence. Non-
linear use of PowerPoint, however, is mainly a pedagogical issue that PowerPoint can be
adapted to provide.
THERE ARE DIVERSE WAYS THAT IT CAN BE USED, EVEN DURING LECTURES AND SEMINARS,
INCLUDING:
There are diverse teaching and learning contexts in which PowerPoint can be
used for presentations but the key general requirements are summarised below.
a. Plan your presentation structure carefully and according to the general rules
of presentations. The key to a successful presentation/lecture is to have a clear
structure and generally not more than five key topic areas.
b. Know the level at which the presentation is aimed and develop the content for
this level
c. Do not present too much textual material on each slide and avoid simply
reading out what is on the slide: provide mainly structural headings and sub-
headings around which the bulk of the verbal presentation takes place so that
students still require to be active and take notes of detail, etc
d. Make sure that you speak at a normal pace and do not allow the use of
PowerPoint to deliver material too quickly: this is one of the most commonly
encountered problems when converting to using PowerPoint.
e. Utilise the visual and other media opportunities offered to enhance your
presentation whenever possible but be careful to avoid excessive use of colour
effects, animation effects, transition effects, sound effects, etc.
a. Try to avoid having more than 6 lines of text per slide and make them primarily
headings or subheadings.
b. Remember that a picture can be worth a thousand words (Beakes, 2003) — use
graphics to enhance your presentation. Consider how you will make such
diagrams available to the students (time to copy during presentation,
handouts, files, etc) but be aware of copyright limitations on non-original
material.
c. Try to avoid using red and green combinations for emphasis — the most
common form of colour blindness prevents separation of reds and greens.
d. Consider introducing lines of text one at a time, dimming the previous lines as
the new line is introduced: this facilitates concentration on the current item.
Putting the full slide up can result in the audience reading ahead and not
listening to what is being currently discussed. This facility is accessed within the
custom animation option.
f. Use a Sans Serif font such as Arial rather than a Serif font such as Times New
Roman: typographical texts recommend this as being easier to read on a
poster or presentation slide. If you want a more casual font, Comic Sans is a
popular alternative. For reading from paper handouts, etc, a Serif font is
recommended.
g. Do not use more than two text colours in a presentation unless there are
particular reasons for doing so.
h. Consider whether to use a dark or a light background for the presentation. Dark
backgrounds may not work well if the room is not fairly dark. Remember too
that the darker the room has to be, the more likely the audience are to find it
hard to stay awake!
i. Bear in mind that students with dyslexia often find high contrast between text
and background (such as black text on white background) very difficult to
read (http://www.essex.ac.uk/psychology/overlays/). Consider standardising
on reduced contrast combinations (e.g. yellow text on dark blue background)
for that reason.
The mechanics of using the programme are well dealt with both through the help
options that are included with the programme and through texts such as that of Wempen
(1999)
b. Utilise the options for headers and footers to include at least the name of the
presenter/course designation and the slide number on each slide to provide
easy navigation by students within their own notes
e. Restrict the number of key topics to no more than 5 per 50 minute presentation.
h. Provide good contextual material during the introduction and make sure that
you have time to conclude the session appropriately. For largely information
transmission sessions, use the adage “Tell them what you are going to tell them,
tell them, then tell them what you have told them”: it is a well established
strategy in a learning context.
i. Generally use no more than 6 lines on a slide, excluding a heading, and avoid
long sentences
j. Use a font and a font size that is appropriate and clear. Arial is recommended
for clarity whilst I use Comic Sans in less formal presentations. Do not use
gimmicky fonts and do not mix fonts unless it is for a good reason e.g.
presenting quotes.
k. Do not use capitals except for occasional emphasis — they are harder to read
than lower-case letters
l. Use graphics where appropriate but do not overuse them. No more than 2
graphics per slide is a good general rule. It is perfectly valid to continue to mix
media when using PowerPoint. The projector does not have to be switched off
when another device needs to use the same screen: while presenting a slide
show, the B key becomes a toggle switch that blanks the screen to allow other
media to use it! Appropriate graphics include photographs, screen-shots
a. Use sound and video from within PowerPoint very sparingly: sound rarely adds
anything and sound effects can become very irritating whilst video clips are
very demanding on the storage media. Video is usually better when run from
a dedicated video player unless you have a very high-specification system.
The most common abuses in PowerPoint use for teaching and learning include:
a. Including excessive detail so that students need not be active (or even present
if files are made available) during delivery.
b. Slides are visually poor and/or boring or even over the top — this is particularly
the case when reds and greens dominate
i. Not making plans for coping in event of technological failure e.g. backup
overheads (expensive) or alternative activities, etc
These negative aspects are easily avoided by training and reflecting upon your
approach to teaching and learning.
14 POWERPOINT PRESENTATION TIPS TO MAKE MORE CREATIVE SLIDESHOWS
Written by Jamie Cartwright @cart_writing
https://blog.hubspot.com/marketing/easy-powerpoint-design-tricks-ht
A presentation is made up of multiple slides, and now that you know how
to make one, you can delve deeper into PowerPoint's capabilities.
On the left pane, right click the thumbnail of the slide you want to
duplicate. Choose "Duplicate Slide" from the pop-up menu.
To access them, select the "Transitions" tab from the top ribbon.
From there, you can select a transition for it to preview on your
screen. To customize it further, click "Effect Options" and play with
the features to find something that suits your liking. To remove a
transition, select "Transitions" and click "None."
f. Add animations to your slides (optional).
Like transitions, animations can add movement, reveal
information, and help you underscore the points you want to hit
during your speech. To animate an element, follow these steps:
You'll also have the option to move animations around as you edit
your slides with the "Reorder Animation" function in the top ribbon.
Make sure that preset PPT themes complement your needs before
you adopt them.
Try to get away from using Microsoft Office’s default fonts, Calibri
and Cambria. Using these two typefaces can make the
presentation seem underwhelming.
Type the height and width of the background you'd like, and click
"OK." A dialogue box will appear. Click "OK" again. Your
background is resized!
Tip: Resize your slides before you add any objects to them or the
dimensions of your objects will become skewed.
Often, it's much easier to edit your PowerPoint template before you
start -- this way, you don't have design each slide by hand. Here's
how you do that.
Make any changes you like, then click "Close Master." All current and
future slides in that presentation will use that template.
d. Write text with your audience in mind.
A significant part of a
PowerPoint's content is text.
Great copy can make or break
your presentation, so
evaluating your written work
from a few different angles
could make you seem more
persuasive. Thinking about how
your text is received
differentiates good presenters
from the best.
Some fonts are seen as clean and professional, but this doesn't mean
they're boring. A common mistake is thinking your font isn't "exciting"
enough, which could lead you to choose a font that distracts from
your overall message.
That said, you can still use fun and eccentric fonts -- in moderation.
Offsetting a fun font or large letters with something more professional
can create an engaging presentation. Above all, be sure you're
consistent so your presentation looks the same throughout each slide,
so your audience doesn't become distracted by too many disparate
fonts.
Select all objects by holding down "Shift" and clicking on all of them.
Select "Arrange" in the top options bar, then choose "Align or Distribute."
Select "Arrange" in the top options bar again, then choose "Align or Distribute."
Creating a natural
perspective shadow
behind an object.
Recoloring photos
manually and with
automatic options.
g. Take advantage of PowerPoint's shapes.
Many users don’t realize how flexible PowerPoint’s shape tools have
become. In combination with the expanded format options released
by Microsoft in 2010, the potential for good design with shapes is
readily available. PowerPoint provides the user with a bunch of great
shape options beyond the traditional rectangle, oval, and rounded
rectangle patterns, unlike even professional design programs like
Adobe Creative Suite or Quark.
When you create a shape, right click and press "Edit Points." By editing
points, you can create custom shapes that fit your specific need. For
instance, you can reshape arrows to fit the dimensions you like.
Subtract cuts out the overlapping portion of one shape from the
other. By using these tools rather than trying to edit points precisely,
you can create accurately measured custom shapes.
Choose "Crop,"
then "Mask to
Shape," and then
choose your
desired shape. Ta-
da! Custom-
shaped photos.
l. Keep it simple.
PowerPoint is an excellent tool to support your presentation with
visual information, graphics, and supplemental points. This
means that your powerpoint should not be your entire presentation.
Your slides -- no matter how creative and beautiful -- shouldn't be the
star of the show. Keep your text and images clear and concise, using
them only to supplement your message and authority.
If your slides have dense and cluttered information, it will both distract
your audience and make it much more likely that you will lose their
attention. Nothing in your slides should be superfluous! Keep your
presentation persuasive by keeping it clean. There are a few ways to
do this:
Limit bullet points and text.
Avoid paragraphs and long quotes.
Maintain "white space" or "negative space".
Keep percentages, graphs, and data super basic.
m. Embed your font files.
Here’s the trick: When you save your PowerPoint file (only on a PC),
you should click Save Options in the "Save As …" dialog window.
Then, select the "Embed TrueType fonts" check box and press "OK."
Now, your presentation will keep the font file and your fonts will not
change when you move computers (unless you give your
presentation on a Mac).
o. Embed multimedia.
Embedding also means that the file stays within the PowerPoint
presentation, so it should play normally without extra work to
only insert video or audio files once the presentation and the
containing folder
For many presenters, this tool can help unify their spoken presentation
and their visual aid. You never want to make the PowerPoint seem
like a stack of notes that you use a crutch. Use the Presenter View
option to help create a more natural presentation.
With style, design, and presentation processes under your belt, you
can do a lot more with PowerPoint than just presentations for your
clients. PowerPoint and similar slide applications are flexible tools that
should not be forgotten. With a great template, you can be on your
way to creating presentations that wow your audience.
CREATE A PRESENTATION IN POWERPOINT
WITH POWERPOINT ON YOUR PC, MAC, OR MOBILE DEVICE:
https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/create-a-presentation-in-powerpoint-
422250f8-5721-4cea-92cc-202fa7b89617
1. Select Insert.
2. To add a picture:
3. Select Picture.
4. Browse for the picture you want and select Insert.
5. To add a shape, art, or chart:
6. Select Shapes, Icons, SmartArt, or Chart.
7. Select the one you want.