Entrepreneurship in Nigeria Report 2021 Fate Foundation

STATE OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN NIGERIA REPORT 2021
R E S E A R CH . P O L I CY . A D V O CA CY
STATE OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP
IN NIGERIA REPORT 2021
1
R E SE ARRECH
S E. APRO
CHL I .CY
PO L IDCY
. A VO. A
CADV
CYO CA CY
R ES EA R C H . P O L I C Y . A D V O C A C Y
STATE OF
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
IN NIGERIA REPORT
2021
2 1
ABOUT THE FATE INSTITUTE

The FATE Institute is the research, policy and advocacy arm of FATE Foundation which leads innovative
thinking and creates platforms to enable idea exchange and problem-solving strategies to foster sustainable
entrepreneurship in Nigeria.
Since inception in 2015, the FATE Institute has published 12 thought leadership reports on Nigeria’s Micro, Small
and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) and entrepreneurs; held a yearly Policy Dialogue on Entrepreneurship; and
in 2021 launched a quarterly Policy Workshop series. The Institute also recently developed the Enterprise Data
Map platform to track data and insights within the ecosystem.
The FATE Institute is a member of the Global Entrepreneurship Research Network (GERN), Aspen Network
of Development Entrepreneurs (ANDE) West Africa and also the Facilitator of the Nigerian Economic Summit
Group (NESG) MSME Community of Practice.
www.fatefoundation.org/research
[email protected]
Download and share a soft copy of this report on www.fatefoundation.org/2021soe
Copyright © 2021 FATE Foundation. The FATE Foundation Limited by Guarantee is a non-profit registered
under the Corporate Affairs Commission RC 393730
3
R E SE A R CH . P O L I CY . A D V O CA CY
4
ACKNOWLEGDEMENTS
We acknowledge the support of Meta, whose grant (ASBON)
support to FATE Foundation made this research • Aspen Network of Development Entrepreneurs
possible. The views presented in this report are those (ANDE), West Africa
of the authors and do not necessarily represent • Endeavor Nigeria
those of the funders. • Enterprise Development Center (EDC), Pan-
African University
We also acknowledge the work, contribution • Global Entrepreneurship Network (GEN) Nigeria
and partnership of the following individuals and • Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN)
organisations. and the Scaling Up Nutrition (SUN) Business
Network, Nigeria
Authors: • Impact Hub, Lagos
• Adenike Adeyemi, Executive Director, FATE • Innovation Support Network
Foundation • Lagos Chamber of Commerce and Industry
• Amaka Nwaokolo, Programs Manager & Head, (LCCI)
Research & Policy, FATE Foundation • Lagos State Employment Trust Fund (LSETF)
• Wilson Erumebor, Economist & Consultant • Loftyinc Limited
• Gospel Obele, CEO, Streetnomics (Market • Meta (Data for Good)
Intelligence and Development) • MSME Africa
• Oyebola Agunloye, Research Associate, FATE • National Association of Small Scale Industrialists
Foundation (NASSI)
• Godwin Henry, Policy Program Officer, FATE • National Agency for Food and Drug
Foundation Administration Control (NAFDAC)
• Nigerian Association of Small and Medium
Design: Cluebox Enterprises (NASME)
• Nigerian Economic Summit Group (NESG)
• Nourishing Africa
Survey & Insight Contributors: • Presidential Enabling Business Environment
Institutions who participated in our insight, focus Council (PEBEC) and the Ease of Doing Business
group sessions or one-on-one interview sessions Secretariat (PEBEC/EBES).
and those who disseminated the surveys to the • Startup South
entrepreneurs in their networks. • Small and Medium Enterprises Development
Agency of Nigeria (SMEDAN)
• Abuja Enterprise Agency (AEA) • South-South/South-East Angel Network
• Access Bank Nigeria • Women In Successful Careers (WISCAR)
• Association of Small Business Owners of Nigeria
5
OUTLINE
Foreword 7
Executive Summary 9
Introduction 11
Data Overview 15
Indicators of Entrepreneurship in Nigeria 19
Business Performance 29
Challenges and Opportunities 55
Recommendations 59
6
1.0
FOREWORD
I am pleased to invite you to explore our 2021 State
of Entrepreneurship in Nigeria Report. This annual
flagship report will be the first of many editions to
come from the FATE Institute, which has evolved
from FATE Foundation’s research and policy unit.
Over the last seven years, we have examined and
analysed data on the Nigerian entrepreneurship
ecosystem and Nigeria’s Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises (MSMEs) to better understand how
existing programmes and policies could be
reviewed, revised and expanded to create a more
sustainable and productive ecosystem that would
benefit all key stakeholders.
Entrepreneurship remains a powerful force and

an important influencer for driving innovation,
productivity, job creation and economic growth.
Nigeria’s entrepreneurship prowess has for a long
time been clearly evident. FATE Foundation’s
inception, twenty-one years ago, was on the basis
that entrepreneurship would be a key driver for
boosting productivity, job creation and economic
growth. Since then, that theory has continuously
been validated with Nigerian entrepreneurs
delivering on innovation, promoting inclusion, In line with our ethos, we strongly believe that
leading to positive socio-economic impact and entrepreneurs are and will remain the backbone
economic growth. of the Nigerian economy. They are critical for the
country to attain its competitiveness potential
This report looks at evolving demographic trends, and readiness to meet the challenges of the 21st
indicators of entrepreneurship and presents new century. Accordingly, I do hope that policy makers,
data that show where entrepreneurship in Nigeria regulators, enterprise training centres, incubators,
stands today and is headed to in the medium to business service development providers, funders
long term. As with other countries around the and other ecosystem players will find this report
world, COVID-19 had a significant impact on beneficial as they cultivate, motivate and enable the
Nigeria’s population, business environment and the different entrepreneurial communities within their
wider economy. This report also presents insights ecosystems.
following the impact of COVID-19 on Nigeria’s
entrepreneurial community, which should be Adenike Adeyemi
helpful to stakeholders within the public, private, Executive Director,
development and academic spaces deliberating on FATE Foundation.
strategies to promote economic recovery.
7
8
2.0
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Entrepreneurs are important to the growth and
development of the Nigerian economy. Following
“...government must
their important role in job creation and in driving intensify efforts to improve
social inclusion, efforts to strengthen their
contribution needs to be prioritised by the relevant the operating environment
stakeholders. In this report, we explored the state of
entrepreneurship in Nigeria, examining how small
for young businesses by
business owners have fared in the last one year, in addressing core traditional
view of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
and non-traditional issues
Key Themes such as limited access
Our findings in this report are centred on three key to finance, inadequate
themes which include:
1. The Entrepreneurial Index in Nigeria.
infrastructure and
2. Women and Youth-led Businesses. insecurity.”
3. Impact of Technology on Businesses.
Youth-Led Businesses
State of Entrepreneurship Secondly, most businesses in Nigeria are youth-
in Nigeria led and an increasing number of businesses are
being led by female. From the survey results, 67%
On the first theme, we computed an entrepreneurial
index for Nigeria which measures the state of of entrepreneurs fall in the age range of 18-35 years
entrepreneurship in the country and across the 24
states covered in our sample. With an overall index
of 0.69 out of 1, we found that entrepreneurship is “...most
fairly strong in Nigeria. This was supported mainly
by the agility and aspirations of Nigerian business
businesses in
Nigeria are
youth-led and
“...entrepreneurship is fairly an increasing
strong in Nigeria.” number of
owners who are resilient, dynamic and are known
businesses are
to forge through amidst severe challenges in the being led by
business environment. Notwithstanding this positive
drive, the government must intensify efforts to female.”
improve the operating environment for young
businesses by addressing core traditional and non- while 43% of business owners are female. These
traditional issues such as limited access to finance, two groups can be considered as Nigeria’s biggest
inadequate infrastructure and insecurity. These three untapped potential especially given their immense
issues were identified as the main obstacles facing contribution to the economy; despite the challenges
entrepreneurs in Nigeria. they face. Specifically for youth-led businesses, they
9
are the cornerstone of technology acceleration and infrastructure space will need facilitate the
are vital in both job creation and value addition. development of structures that improve access and
usage of technology among small business owners
at an affordable rate. With this, small businesses
Female-Led Businesses in Nigeria will be better equipped and prepared to
Female-led businesses remain highly vulnerable compete in a world that is increasingly driven by
especially following the impact of COVID-19 and innovation and technology.
the limited support received from the government.
The survey showed that 34.2% of female-led
businesses did not record growth in the past one
year, with limited access to finance serving as the “...The Government in
main constraint to growth. For these two segments
partnership with key
players in the technology
“...Female- infrastructure space
led businesses will need facilitate the
remain highly development of structures
vulnerable that improve access and
especially usage of technology among
following the small business owners at an
impact of affordable rate.”
COVID-19 and
the limited Enabling Support
support received Overall, the government needs to develop an
entrepreneurial ecosystem that supports growth
from the and innovation. In addition to creating an enabling
government.” business environment, the government, working
with stakeholders, will need to create policies,
financial support, skills development, legislative
-female and youth - of the Nigerian society, one frameworks among other support structures for
thing is clear: there is need for targeted and start-ups and small businesses across the country.
institutionalised support for these businesses by both This will ensure that businesses gain the necessary
the government and the private sector to enable support needed to achieve their potential in the near
their growth and enhance their impact on the future.
economy.
Digital Technology Adaptation

As the economy recovers from the impact of
COVID-19, the digital revolution, which was
accelerated by the pandemic is here to stay. While
many small businesses are embracing technology,
some are being left behind due to reasons such
as high data cost, lack of digital skills and lack of
awareness of the potential benefits of technology
on their businesses. These businesses need to
be supported, particularly in gaining access to
technology, digital skills training and awareness
of the benefits of technology. The Government
in partnership with key players in the technology
10
3.0
INTRODUCTION
11
2021 OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN NIGERIA REPORT 2021
STATE OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN NIGERIA REPORTSTATE
INTRODUCTION
Entrepreneurs are the bedrock of the Nigerian of infrastructure deficit, communication gaps and
economy. Data from the National Bureau of logistics bottlenecks.
Statistics (NBS) show that Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises (MSMEs) account for 49.8% of Nigeria’s Despite the important contribution of
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and constitute a entrepreneurs, the business environment has
significant share of the total number of businesses not been fully supportive of their potential.
in Nigeria. In terms of labour force, they account Small business owners continue to grapple with
for about 85% of total industrial employment and numerous challenges which limit their productivity,
are spread across all the sectors of the economy. expansion potential and employment capacity.
These businesses have been instrumental in Traditionally, limited access to capital, high interest
providing creative solutions, innovative ideas and rate, infrastructure deficit, inadequate power supply,
value creation in the sectors where they operate. policy and regulatory inconsistency top the list
In addition to their high economic value, MSMEs of challenges facing small businesses in Nigeria.
have been drivers of social change in Nigeria. In the More recently, insecurity has become a major
last few years, there have been witnessed several barrier to the growth of small businesses in Nigeria.
innovative solutions in key sectors such as education In addition, these businesses operate in a highly
and healthcare. These solutions have leveraged volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous (VUCA)
technology to link consumers/clients to markets/ environment characterised by unpredictable policy
service providers, thereby breaking traditional barriers changes. As an example, further to the impact of
12
Figure 1: VUCA concept explained
VO LATILE
The environment demands you react
quickly to ongoing changes that are
unpredictable & out of your control.
UN CERTAIN
The environment requires
you to take actions
without certainty.
CO MPLEX The environment is dynamic,

with many interdependencies.
AM BIGUOUS The environment is

unfamiliar, outside
of your expertise
Source: Advuca
COVID-19, the government has introduced policy implementation of lockdown and social restrictions
changes or sudden policy adjustment such as the led to the closure of businesses that engaged in the
ban of Twitter and Crypto trading, the closure of production of non-essentials, many of which were
land borders and several foreign exchange policy MSMEs.
adjustments in the last couple of years. These
actions have had detrimental effects on MSMEs in The absence of an adequate and effective nation-
Nigeria. wide business support mechanism also worsened
the impact of the pandemic on small businesses,
With COVID-19 came one of the biggest shocks many of which operate in the informal sector.
the world has ever witnessed since the second
world war. As a result of the pandemic, Nigeria Even with COVID-19, entrepreneurs have remained
experienced one of its worst recessions, with a GDP resilient. Across the world, Nigerians are known
decline of 6.1% in the second quarter of 2020 and to be dynamic, competitive and resilient. So too
a contraction of 1.9% in full year 2020. The impact are MSMEs operating in Nigeria. These businesses
of COVID-19 was huge on individuals, households continue to show dynamism, resilience and
and small and medium enterprises. In April 2020, the adaptability to policy changes, all of which have
become the key traits of the Nigerian entrepreneurs.
During the pandemic, businesses employed several
coping mechanisms including receiving support
Impact of COVID-19 on businesses from families, friends and government, adopting
technology, designing new products and services,
in 2020, compared to 2019. diversifying revenue sources, among others. The
growth of Nigeria’s technology space is a clear
73% of businesses faced liquidity

challenges
demonstration of the resourcefulness and resilience
of entrepreneurs. The industry has grown to become
a veritable source of value creation for young
20%
entrepreneurs in Nigeria, despite the challenges.
of work force were laid off Similarly, informal traders in Aba, Kano, Lagos,
Maiduguri, Warri and Makurdi etc. have continued to
produce goods and services, create new products
Unemployment rate rose from 27% and export to other countries, both within and
in the second quarter of 2020 to 33% outside Africa.
in the fourth quarter.
Amidst the challenges faced by entrepreneurs,
opportunities still exist but the government must
Source: National Bureau of Statistics
13
be committed to unlock these opportunities. In

the last couple of years, the tough business climate,
“....Certainly, the future of
insecurity, infrastructure deficit, poor power supply entrepreneurs in Nigeria
and foreign exchange problems were amplified by
the COVID-19 pandemic. Many small businesses is bright, but it is bright to
were at the receiving end. But huge challenges
come with huge opportunities. We believe that there
the extent in which the
is a glimmer of hope for Nigerian entrepreneurs, environment supports their
made possible by several factors such as:
• Nigeria’s large domestic market.
noble ambition.”
• Nigeria’s huge natural resource endowments.
• A large, young, energetic and entrepreneurial the key challenges facing businesses and implement
population. support interventions for MSMEs across sectors of
• The African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) the economy. Certainly, the future of entrepreneurs
Agreement which creates a single market for in Nigeria is bright, but it is bright to the extent
Africa. in which the environment supports their noble
• The technology/digital revolution accelerated by ambition.
COVID-19.
• Abundant economic opportunities across This report examines the state of entrepreneurship
sectors. in Nigeria. It highlights indicators and emerging
trends of entrepreneurship and how businesses and
To unlock the numerous opportunities, the Nigerian policymakers can reposition to take advantage of the
government will need to intensify efforts to address opportunities in Nigeria.
14
4.0
DATA OVERVIEW
15
4 DATA OVERVIEW
Gender and
Entrepreneurship
Contrary to the traditional perception
of entrepreneurship, the gender gap
among entrepreneurs has narrowed
significantly in today’s entrepreneurial
landscape. While men still dominate
entrepreneurial activities, women
are no longer sidelined. Our survey
reveals that while most businesses
are operated by men (57% of
respondents), women make up as
high as 43% of entrepreneurs in
Nigeria. The relative gender gap in
entrepreneurship, measured as the
ratio of female to male entrepreneurs,
is therefore placed at 0.75. This has
far reaching implications for the
economic benefits of inclusiveness
in entrepreneurship. Among
other benefits, increasing female
participation in entrepreneurship
will result in further improvement
in job creation rates, in the level of
innovation in the country, and in
income levels.
Figure 1: Respondents by Gender
43% 57%
Female Male
Source: The FATE Institute
16
In majority of the states considered in this survey, in Lagos, with 6% of total women-owned businesses
men are more likely to start a business than women; in the country. This suggests that while there is a
this is however not the case in few states such as higher-than-expected participation rate of women
Abia, Bauchi, Edo, Gombe, Kwara, Lagos and Oyo in entrepreneurship, significant disparities still exist
where there are more women entrepreneurs than across states, with only few states having a high
men. The highest rate of female-led businesses was prevalence rates of female entrepreneurs.
Figure 2: Respondents by Gender and State
Abia Kano
Abuja Katsina
Adamawa Kebbi
Akwa Ibom Kogi
Bauchi Kwara
Benue Lagos
Borno Nasarawa
Cross River Niger
Delta Ogun
Edo Ondo
Ekiti Osun
Enugu Oyo
Gombe Plateau
Imo Rivers
Jigawa Sokoto
Kaduna Zamfara
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Female Male
Respondents Respondents
17
Age and Entrepreneurship entrepreneurs are very energetic, with a high

risk appetite, and are willing to leverage new
Our results reveal that most entrepreneurs are
youths; that is, between the age of 18-35. This age technologies, older entrepreneurs usually have
group accounts for 67% of entrepreneurs, reflecting greater knowledge of the business landscape
the country’s skewed population structure towards and wider networks. As such, it is expected that
this cohort. It however also reveals differences younger entrepreneurs would be more successful in
across old and young entrepreneurs. While young launching early stage businesses.
Figure 3: Respondents by Age (Years)
Age 30-35 Age 41-50
28.6% 10.3%
Age 25-29 Age 51-60
26.0% 2.8%
Age 36-40 Age 15-24
18.7% 0.6%
Age 18-24 Age 61 & >
12.7% 0.4%
Our results reveal that younger Figure 4: Businesses in Existence for 1-5 years (by age group) (%)
entrepreneurs are more
likely to launch early-stage
businesses (businesses within
1-5 years of existence) than
older entrepreneurs. While
older entrepreneurs have better
experience of the markets and 9.6%
35.5%
enjoy wider networks, they are age 36-40
age 25-29 1.2%
constrained by several factors
age 51-60
(which include the time and
financial demands of catering for a
family) which prevents them from
focusing on growing their business
or taking major risk (such as having
23.0% 25.7%
to quit their regular jobs). Of the age 15-24 age 30-35
respondents that indicated they are
working as fulltime entrepreneurs,
0.2%
48% are youths compared to 28% 4.5% age 61 & >
who are 36 years and above. age 41-50
18
Figure 5: Are you a full-time entrepreneur?
25
20
15
10
5
Yes`
0 No
15-24 18-24 25-29 30-35 36-40 41-50 51-60 61 & >
Entrepreneurs and Years of more likely to be owned by men, startups (that is,
high growth young companies within 1- 5 years
Existence of Businesses with an innovative/disruptive business model and/or
Most businesses run by entrepreneurs in Nigeria are effectively leveraging technology for scale) are more
less than 10 years old. 49% of businesses surveyed likely to be owned by women.
that are “young” are also led by young people.
Figure 7: Size of Business

Figure 6: Business Age
5%
13% 2%
31% 49%
Micro, 71%
Small, 23%
1-5 6-10 11-15 16-20 20+
Medium, 3%
Startup, 2%
Large, 1%
Size of Business Source: The FATE Institute
Most entrepreneurs in Nigeria are micro scale
operators, having between 0-9 employees. The
interplay of several factors has constrained the
operating environment of entrepreneurs, making it
difficult for them to expand their businesses. Also,
while micro, small and medium businesses are
19
Entrepreneurship the country is still very high. Our survey result shows
that the level of informality among entrepreneurs
and Informality (mostly micro and small businesses) is 44%. Also,
Even though most entrepreneurs in Nigeria have while 75% of registered businesses are registered
registered their businesses, the level of informality in with CAC, 12% did so with SMEDAN.
Figure 8: Business Registration
If yes,
Is your what body are you
registered with?
business CAC, 75%
registered? SMEDAN, 12%

Formal trade groups
& associations, 6%
Yes: 56% No: 44%
Others, 6%
Business Incorporation type

Most small businesses are incorporated as a business
name (75% of respondents) with the remaining 25%
of respondents incorporated as either a private
company limited by shares (19% of respondents),
company limited by guarantees (3% of respondents)
or public company limited by shares (3% of
respondents). This result only corroborates previous
findings that most entrepreneurs in Nigeria operate
on a micro scale.
Entrepreneurs by Sector
Most of the entrepreneurs surveyed are engaged
in the retail, fashion & FMCG (23% of respondents).
Other leading activity sectors among entrepreneurs
surveyed include agriculture, fishing & forestry, and
hospitality and hotel.
20
STATE
STATE OF
OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP
ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN
IN NIGERIA REPORT 2021
NIGERIA REPORT 2021
Figure 9: Sectors of operation
22.9% 11.6% 8.1% 6.2% 5.7%

Retail, Fashion Agriculture, Hospitality Advertising Entertainment
& FMCG Fishing & Forestry & Hotels & Marketing & Events
5.4% 5.2% 5.0% 5.0% 3.8%

Digital, Media & Healthcare Art & Design Education Manufacturing
Communications & Training
2.9% 2.8% 2.6% 2.2% 2.1%

Technology Construction Internet & Energy & Logistics &
Telecommunications Utilities Transportation
2.1% 1.6% 1.4% 0.8% 0.8%

Banking, Finance Automotive Real Estate Travel. Tourism Mining, Oil
& Insurance & Aviation & Leisure & Metals
0.7% 0.4% 0.3% 0.2% 0.2%

NGOs Law Law Enforcement Recruitment Government
& Security
21
Education, Training and among entrepreneurs include keeping financial

records (14% of respondents), business expansion
Entrepreneurship (8% of respondents) and managing talent (8% of
Most entrepreneurs (45% of respondents) have a respondents).
Bachelor’s degree while 15% have a Higher National
Diploma (HND). 16% have a secondary education.
Figure 11: Business Training by Entrepreneurs
Majority of entrepreneurs surveyed have taken
some form of training (87% of respondents) with
business management as the most common 3% 3%
form of training embarked upon by entrepreneurs
8%
(51% of respondents). Other forms of training
8%
Figure 10: Highest level of education among respondents
51%
13%
16%
2%
1%
14%
13% 45%
1% Business management Keeping financia records
None Business expansion

7%
Managing talent Instituting corporate
governance
15% Others
BSc HND Msc NCE
OND Primary Secondary Others
Entrepreneurs and Figure 12: Are you a member of any business association
or trade group?
Membership of Business
associations or trade groups
Most entrepreneurs (51% of respondents) do not
belong to any business association or trade group.
This implies that most MSMEs in Nigeria do not
enjoy the benefits associated with membership of
Are you a member
business associations or trade group which include of any business
networking, exchange of ideas, advocacy and legal
representation, amongst others.
association or
trade group?
Yes: 49% No: 51%

22
5.0
INDICATORS OF
ENTREPRENEURSHIP
IN NIGERIA
23
INDICATORS OF
ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN NIGERIA
Entrepreneurship is an integral aspect of an

economy. In Nigeria, entrepreneurs are the drivers
The Entrepreneurial Index
To answer above questions, we developed a
of innovation and continue to play key roles in the composite index which measures the state of
area of job creation in the economy. The global entrepreneurship in Nigeria. The index score falls
recognition of Nigerian start-ups, the significant within a range of 0 and 1, where zero represents
growth of businesses in the technology space as a very weak state of entrepreneurship while 1
well as the opportunities these businesses continue represents a very strong state of entrepreneurship in
to create are clear evidences of the influence and Nigeria.
potentials of entrepreneurs in Nigeria.
The index was constructed from responses of
Following the growing importance of entrepreneurs the survey on entrepreneurship in Nigeria. In
in the economy, it is crucial for stakeholders to constructing the index, we first identified 5 pillars in
understand the dynamics of entrepreneurship, measuring the state of entrepreneurship in Nigeria,
its different components and how each of these drawing insights from our expertise on the business
components can be measured to better understand environment and also from existing literature/studies.
the entrepreneurship space in Nigeria. This section Each pillar represents an aspect of entrepreneurship
examines the questions - What is the state of and captures a set of similar indicators which are
entrepreneurship in Nigeria? How are businesses then measured and aggregated to form an index.
thriving across different sub-areas? Which of these
areas require improvement and what needs to
be done?
24
Figure 13: Indicators of Entrepreneurship in Nigeria
Indicators of Entrepreneurship
Pillars Indicators
• Share of businesses that experienced growth in revenue and

Business employees
Performance • Share of businesses that are recovering from the impacts of COVID-19
25%
• Share of businesses that were shut down in the last one year due to
COVID-19
• Share of businesses that embarked on innovative measures amidst
COVID-19 to stay in business
• Share of entrepreneurs that are optimistic about their business in the

Perception of next one year
Opportunities • Share of entrepreneurs that perceive entrepreneurship in Nigeria as
strong
23%
• Share of entrepreneurs that adopt technology in the course of
executing their business
Digital
• Share of entrepreneurs that adopt social media in the course of
Adoption
executing their business
21%
• Share of entrepreneurs with above secondary education
• Share of entrepreneurs that have attended business training courses
Skills • Share of entrepreneurs that use computer
Acquisition • Share of entrepreneurs that have access to smart devices
21%
• Share of businesses that received support from the government in this
COVID-19 era
Enabling
• Share of businesses that shut down in the last one year due to tough
Environment
business terrain
10% Source: The FATE Institute
In addition, we grouped a set of question(s) under assigned different weights based on its level of
each pillar and estimated a sub-index for that pillar. importance in the measurement of the state of
In all, 18 indicators were used and these indicators entrepreneurship in Nigeria.
were drawn from the survey. Each pillar was then
25
The Entrepreneurial clear indication of the drive, dynamism and resilience

of entrepreneurs in Nigeria despite the harsh
Index: Results operating environment. The score also highlights the
Our results show an entrepreneurial index score of opportunities that exist in the business environment
0.69 out of 1, suggesting that entrepreneurship is as well as the strong level of optimism from
strong in Nigeria. Across the 5 pillars, 4 recorded entrepreneurs regarding the future of businesses in
high scores that are above 0.5 while only 1 pillar Nigeria.
had a score that was below 0.5. The index score is a
Table 1: Summary Statistics
Index N Minimum Maximum Index Distance Distance Standard

score to perfect to perfect Deviation
score score (%)
Business Performance 7106 0.00 1.00 0.55 0.45 45.0 0.22
Perception of Opportunities 7106 0.00 1.00 0.72 0.28 28.0 0.19
Digital Adoption 7106 0.00 1.00 0.80 0.20 20.0 0.36
Skills Adoption 7106 0.00 1.00 0.81 0.19 19.0 0.19
Enabling Business 7106 0.00 1.00 0.45 0.55 55.0 0.24
Environment
Overall Index 7106 0.00 1.00 0.69 0.31 31.0 0.15
Looking at the sub-indices across the 5 pillars, the Among all the pillars, Business Performance and
Skills Adoption and digital pillars showed the highest Enabling Business Environment recorded the
score of 0.81 and 0.8 respectively. This is mainly due lowest scores of 0.55 and 0.45 respectively, driven
to the fact that majority of businesses in the country mainly by the impact of COVID-19, the harsh
are run by young people who are mostly in search business environment and the limited capacity of
of new skills and training to effectively execute their the government to provide adequate support to
businesses. These young business owners are the businesses.
frontiers of technology and innovation in Nigeria and
they adopt technology in executing their businesses.
26
Figure 14: Entrepreneurial Index Score
Perfect
Score
0.80 0.81
0.69 0.72
0.55
0.45
Worst
Score Enabling Business Overall Perception of Digital Skills
Business Performance Index Opportunites Adoption Adoption
Environment
The implication of the above result is that Nigerian which ideally, should provide both direct and
entrepreneurs are ambitious and positive in indirect support particularly in the areas of improving
their outlook on the business environment from access to finance, creating an enabling business
an opportunities standpoint. However, several environment, and addressing insecurity and the
challenges stand in their way. To realise their challenges of high cost of production. Entrepreneurs,
maximum potential, entrepreneurs will require a when supported, will not only create jobs but also
well-functioning entrepreneurial ecosystem that address the core developmental problems of poverty
supports innovation and business growth. At the and inequality facing the country.
center of such ecosystem would be the government,
27
States Entrepreneurial Index performance. Oyo State on the other hand trails
other States, showing the lowest score of 0.51. Oyo
Score Report and Ranking state performed poorly in the pillars of Business
As shown in the table, Abia state ranked the highest Performance and Digital Adoption. The bottom five
with a score of 0.8, closely followed by Imo (0.79) States include – Zamfara, Niger, Oyo, Kebbi and
and Delta (0.77). In these 3 states, Digital Adoption Adamawa States
and Skills Adoption were key drivers of their overall
Table 2: Entrepreneurial Index by States
Rank States Business Perception of Digital Skills Enabling Composite

Performance opportunities Adoption Adoption Business Index
Index Index Index Index Environment (Weighted)
Index
1 Abia 0.73 0.73 0.98 0.89 0.52 0.80
2 Imo 0.76 0.72 0.96 0.89 0.46 0.79
3 Delta 0.59 0.88 0.93 0.87 0.43 0.77
4 Kwara 0.61 0.87 0.79 0.85 0.66 0.76
5 Kogi 0.53 0.73 0.99 0.89 0.66 0.76
6 Osun 0.56 0.75 0.89 0.90 0.39 0.73
7 Bauchi 0.51 0.73 0.92 0.87 0.46 0.72
8 Edo 0.56 0.76 0.86 0.85 0.40 0.72
9 Ekiti 0.51 0.79 0.83 0.90 0.37 0.71
10 Enugu 0.60 0.79 0.74 0.82 0.46 0.71
11 Rivers 0.59 0.78 0.85 0.80 0.28 0.70
12 Kaduna 0.51 0.69 0.80 0.88 0.60 0.70
13 Ogun 0.55 0.73 0.88 0.81 0.36 0.70
14 Lagos 0.49 0.70 0.90 0.84 0.45 0.69
15 Katsina 0.60 0.65 0.89 0.78 0.40 0.69
16 Akwa Ibom 0.56 0.81 0.68 0.81 0.40 0.68
17 Abuja 0.53 0.78 0.79 0.80 0.36 0.68
18 Nassarawa 0.58 0.66 0.78 0.80 0.44 0.68
19 Kano 0.58 0.56 0.72 0.80 0.56 0.65
20 Plateau 0.48 0.63 0.87 0.77 0.36 0.65
21 Gombe 0.49 0.48 0.81 0.89 0.45 0.64
22 Zamfara 0.43 0.54 0.91 0.71 0.36 0.61
23 Kebbi 0.49 0.67 0.55 0.78 0.35 0.59
24 Niger 0.31 0.81 0.60 0.73 0.43 0.59
25 Adamawa 0.44 0.71 0.50 0.58 0.33 0.53
26 Oyo 0.42 0.63 0.42 0.58 0.50 0.51
28
6.0
BUSINESS PERFORMANCE
29
BUSINESS PERFORMANCE
Entrepreneurship, Business set up by entrepreneurs have been successful, with

66% of respondents affirming that the businesses
Survival and Business Demise they have set up have been successful as against
34% that said their businesses failed. However,
Majority of businesses surveyed were created within amongst those that said their businesses failed, a
the last 5 years. These businesses accounted for 49% large percentage experienced some failure in the
of total businesses surveyed, suggesting a high rate past 1 year (44% of respondents) most likely due to
of business creation in the country. Most businesses the negative impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Figure 15. Have you set up a business that failed?
If yes,
Have you set when?
up a business In the last 1 year, 44%
In the last 3 years, 33%
that failed? In the last 5 years, 23%
Yes: 34% No: 66%
Business growth is mild 21.7% experienced a growth of 1-5%. Only 5.5% of

businesses that reported increase in revenue saw
across key indicators a growth of above 25%. This narrative is similar for
the number of employees. 28.8% of businesses that
Although majority of businesses are growing experienced growth in the number of employees
especially since the height of the pandemic, the saw a 6-10% increase while 16.7% witnessed an
rate of growth in key areas such as revenue and increase of 1-5%. For both indicators (revenue and
hiring new staff is still very low. For businesses employee), we however note that some businesses
that recorded increase in revenue, majority (21.7%) that reported growth in revenue and employees did
witnessed a growth in the range of 6-10% while not specify the rate of growth in these areas.
30
Figure 16. Share of businesses that recorded revenue Figure 17. Share of businesses that recorded Growth in
growth in the past one year (% of respondents) employee in the past one year (% of respondents)
1-5% 21.7 1-5% 17
6-10% 21.8 6-10% 26
11-15% 17.9 11-15% 9
16-20% 5.9 16-20% 6
21-25% 4.0 21-25% 3
Above 25% 5.5 Above 25% 3
31
…entrepreneurs cited access Similar to the period before the outbreak of

COVID-19, access to new opportunities was the
to new opportunities as a key major driver of growth in the last one year. It
emerged as the most important factor that enabled
driver of business growth in business growth in the last one year. It accounted
the last one year for 20% of the weighted ranking of growth enablers.
This was followed by increased demand which
had a share of 18.9%. The survey also affirmed the
importance of factors such as access to finance,
capacity building and support, technology adoption
and skilled workforce.
Figure 18. Ranking of enablers by level of Importance for businesses

that recorded growth in the past one year (% of respondents)
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Access to new Access to Increased Capacity Technology Skilled Government Business and
opportunities finance demand building adoption workforce policies & trade groups
&support support
Very Important Important Fairly Important Not Important
Figure 19. Weighted Ranking of enablers by their Overall

Importance for businesses that recorded in the past one
year (% of respondents)
Access to new
20.0
opportunities
Increased demand 18.9
Access to finance 17.4
Technology adoption 12.0
Skilled workforce 10.0
Capacity building
9.0
and support
Government policies
6.1
and support
Business and
5.7
Trade groups
32
7.0
THE PERFORMANCE OF
FEMALE-LED BUSINESSES
33
THE PERFORMANCE OF
FEMALE-LED BUSINESSES
In the past one year, Nigeria witnessed several
events which had major impact on the performance
entrepreneurs reported that
of businesses. From COVID-19 to the EndSARS COVID-19 had a positive
protests, among other events, entrepreneurs in
Nigeria have been through difficult times dealing impact on their businesses…
with both internal and external hurdles. Amidst these
challenges, COVID-19 remains paramount and many 19.5% of female entrepreneurs in Nigeria reported
businesses are yet to fully recover from its impact. In that the COVID-19 pandemic impacted their
this section, we explore how female-led businesses businesses positively (20.3% for male). For these
have fared since the height of the pandemic, the businesses, majority noted that the positive
factors driving recovery, trends in employee and impact was due to the nature of products/services
revenue growth as well as support structures they render and technology (66.7% and 63.5%
available to businesses. of respondents respectively). This is particularly
the case for firms in the agriculture, health,
telecommunications and ICT sectors. These firms
How women-led businesses reported higher sales/revenue due to an increase in
demand for their products/services.
in Nigeria have fared since
COVID-19
Only few female
34
Figure 20. Impact of COVID-19 on female-owned Figure 21. Drivers of the positive impact of COVID-19 on
businesses (% of respondents) female-owned businesses (% of respondents)
Nature of product or
66.7
service rendered
Technology 63.5
10.5%
19.5% Lockdown induced
46.7
demand
Positioning 38.5
Industry advantage 24.8

COVID-19 opportunity
7.6
for exports
Others 1.7
70.0%
Positively Negatvely Not Sure
… the impact of COVID-19 implementation of lockdown and restrictions were

largely responsible for the negative performance of
was largely negative on these businesses.
businesses In terms of how businesses responded to the

negative impact of the pandemic, 26.9% of
Just like their male counterpart, the impact of entrepreneurs reported that they closed physical
COVID-19 on female-owned businesses was stores and switched to online sales. Other common
largely negative. Specifically, 69.5% of female- responses among Nigerian female entrepreneurs
owned businesses (69% for male) reported that include: reduction of staff’s pay (21.9% of
they were negatively affected by the pandemic. Key respondents) and 20.9% shut down product lines.
aspects of businesses that were affected included
sales, operational efficiency and cashflow. Factors
such as low demand, disruption of value chains, Figure 23. Female owned business response to the
negative impact of COVID-19 in the past one year (% of
Figure 22. Aspects of female-owned businesses negatively respondents)
affected by COVID-19 (% of respondents)
Switch to online sales &
26.9
closed physical store
Sales/Customers 69.5
Reduce staffs’ pay 21.9
Cashflow 36.1
Shut down product lines 20.9
Operational efficiency 32.0
Reduced overhead 18.7
Finance 28.9
Closed some
business outlets 18.3
Raw materials 13.9
Reduced staff 14.7
Talents 8..7 Source manufacturing
materials/input locally 13.0
Others 0.6
Others 1.3
35
… affected female the female-owned businesses that were negatively

affected by the pandemic reported improved
entrepreneurs reported performance since the re-opening of the economy
(65.8% of respondents). This recovery is largely
business recovery in the last driven by an increase in customers as reported by
one year 60.9% of female-owned businesses while 45.3% and
39.7% reported an increase in profit and revenue,
respectively. This is expected, following improving
Following the lifting of the lockdown and the re- consumer demand and improvement in economic
opening of sectors, Nigeria’s economy has been activities relative to the COVID-19 lockdown era.
on the path of recovery. Specifically, majority of
Figure 25. Aspects of business growth in the past one year

Figure 24. Female owned businesses that experienced (% of respondents)
growth or not in the last one year (% of respondents)
Increase in customers 60.9
Increase in profit 45.3
Increase in revenue 39.7
Improved cashflow 33.5
Improved operational
65.8% Growth
24.8
costs
post COVID Increase in employees 15.5
Increased product
34.2% No growth
post COVID
lines/sevices
Additional business
outlets
6.3
14.0
Others 1.4
…poor access to finance Figure 26. Level of importance of enablers for female-
owned businesses that recorded growth in the past one
continued to be the most year (% of respondents)
pressing issue that inhibits Access to new

opportunities
20.0
growth for some MSMEs Increased demand 19.2

According to the survey, 34.2% of female-led
Technology adoption 11.9
businesses did not record growth in the past one
year. Among many constraints, limited access Skilled workforce 9.6
to finance is the most pressing issue accounting
Capacity building
for 14.7% weighted importance of the mitigating 9.3
and support
factors. This has been a long long-standing concern Government policies
6.1
for MSMEs in Nigeria. Other major constraints and support
Business and
to the growth of female-owned businesses in rade groups
5.9
Nigeria include poor financial management, poor
government policies, poor capacity and insecurity. Source: The FATE Institute
36
Figure 27. Level of importance of mitigating factors for female-owned businesses

that did not record growth in the past one year (% of respondents)
Poor access to finance

14.7
Poor financial management 9.1
Poor government policies 8.2

and regulation
Poor capacity building and support 8.1
Insecurity 8.1
Poor technology adoption 7.6

Energy and infrastructure
challenges 7.4
Poor access to input
materials for manufacturing 6.6
Foreign exchange challenges 6.5
Multiple taxation 6.4
Unskilled workforce 6.3
Certification issues 5.8
Non-affiliation with business

5.1
or trade groups
Business support structure Figure 28. Enabling factors of Business Recovery after the
Negative Impact of COVID-19 (% of respondents)
for female-owned businesses
Financial support from
41.9
family and friends
In Nigeria and across the world, small business Technology adoption 30.6
owners rely on friends and family for financial, social Increased demand for
30.1
your product/service
and operational support in running their businesses.
As reported by 41.9% of female entrepreneurs in Access to loan facility 29.7
Nigeria, financial support from family and friends was Government policies
17.5
the most important factor that aided their recovery in and support
Affiliation with business
the last one year. Meanwhile, 30.6% and 30.1% cited and trade groups
15.5
technology adoption and increased demand for their
Other 0.8
products and services respectively as key factors that
enabled their recovery.
37
The private sector was a Scheme to serve as off-taker for small businesses’
produce; N50 billion Payroll Support; N200 billion
major support system for artisans’ loan support; N10 billion private transport
companies support, Creative Industry Financing
entrepreneurs during the Initiative (CIFI) etc. Other major sources of support
COVID-19 pandemic were from non-profit organisations and development
institutions.
The private sector was a major source of support for The major form of support received by female-led
Nigerian MSMEs during the pandemic. A lot of the MSMEs in Nigeria during the COVID-19 pandemic
support however were government interventions was in cash as reported by 33.2% of female
channelled through private sector institutions. entrepreneurs. This slightly differs with men who
The Federal Government of Nigeria particularly received more of credit and loans. In addition, 31% of
supported businesses through its MSME support female entrepreneurs reported they received support
programmes such as the N100 billion Covid-19 in the form of credit and loans. This, perhaps,
Targeted Credit Facility for households and small suggests that females are more affected by issues of
businesses; N100 billion Healthcare Support access to credit than their male counterpart.
Intervention Facility; Guaranteed N15 billion Off-take
Figure 30. Forms of support to female-owned businesses
Figure 29. Where support for female-owned businesses to reduce the impact of COVID-19 (% of respondents)
came from during the COVID-19 (% of respondents)
Cash 33.2
Private sector 28.5 Access to
31.0
credit/loans
Non-profit
18.0 Business support
organizations 26.4
services
Business
15.0 Government
member 2.5
waivers
Government 14.5
Others 0.2
Religious
institutions 8.9
Others 1.0
Outlook of female-led expectation comes from the resilient nature of

Nigerian entrepreneurs, particularly women, despite
businesses in Nigeria the harsh operating environment. Businesses are
most optimistic about sales which had the highest
weighted ranking of 18.3%. Following increasing
Nigerian female entrepreneurs have high optimism sales, Nigerian MSMEs also expressed optimism
about the improvement of their businesses over about market demand as well as the operating
the next year. From the survey, 92% of male environment which will substantially drive the
entrepreneurs are at least optimistic about the future eventual increase in sales. However, they are least
of their business but this share is much higher for optimistic about government policy and regulation
female entrepreneurs (93.5%). This very high positive and foreign exchange management.
38
8.0
7. THE PERFORMANCE OF
YOUTH-LED BUSINESSES
39
THE PERFORMANCE OF
YOUTH-LED BUSINESSES
In this section, we explore how youth-led businesses impacted their businesses positively. This outcome
have fared since the height of the pandemic, the is relatively better than the outcome of overall
factors driving recovery, trends in employee and respondents (19.9%) and female respondents (19.5%).
revenue growth as well as support structures Typically, majority (67.6%) of these youth-led MSMEs
available. reported that technology was the major driver of the
positive impact of COVID-19 on their businesses.
This is unsurprising as young people can easily
adapt and leverage technology in executing their
How youth-led businesses businesses.V
have fared since COVID-19
“...20.3% of youth-owned
Some young entrepreneurs businesses reported that
were able to weather the the COVID-19 pandemic
storm as a few reported that impacted their businesses
COVID-19 had a positive positively. ”
impact on their businesses…
According to the survey, 20.3% of youth-owned
businesses reported that the COVID-19 pandemic
40
Figure 31. Impact of COVID-19 on youth-owned Figure 32. Drivers of the positive impact of COVID-19 on
businesses (% of respondents) youth-owned businesses (% of respondents)
Nature of product or
67.6
service rendered
11.4% Technology 61.0
20.3% Lockdown induced
40.7
demand
Positioning 35.6
Industry advantage 26.3

COVID-19 opportunity
8.3
for exports
Others 1.0
68.3%
Positively Negatvely Not Sure

41
… however, the impact of …access to new

COVID-19 is still largely opportunities is the major
negative on youth businesses driver of growth of youth-
led businesses and poor
Similar to female-led businesses, 68.3% of youth-
led businesses reported that they were negatively
access to finance is a major
affected by the pandemic. Sales, cashflow and headwind to growth
operational efficiency were the key aspects of youth-
led businesses that were negatively affected by
COVID-19. Access to new opportunities emerged as the most
important factor that enabled the growth of youth-
In terms of recovery from the impact of the led businesses in the last one year as it accounted
pandemic, 67.9% of youth entrepreneurs reported for 20.6% of the “weighted importance” of growth
that their businesses experienced growth in the enablers. This was followed by increased demand,
past one year as economic activities resumed. The access to finance and technology adoption. On the
growth in youth businesses over the past one year other hand, limited access to finance was the most
was driven largely by an increase in customers as important factor mitigating growth in the past one
reported by 58% of youth respondents. year. Other major mitigating factors include poor
financial management, poor government policies,
poor capacity and insecurity.
Figure 33. Weighted ranking of enablers by the level of

importance for youth businesses that recorded growth in Figure 34. Weighted ranking of mitigating factors by
the past one year (% of respondents) Importance for businesses that did not record growth in
the past one year (% of respondents)
Access to new
20.6
opportunities Poor access to finance 16.1
Increased demand 19.0 Poor financial

9.3
management
Access to finance 17.3 Poor government policies 8.3
and regulation
Technology adoption 12.4 Poor capacity building
8.2
and support
Skilled workforce 9.9
Insecurity 7.9
Capacity building
9.7
and support Poor technology adoption 7.6
Government policies Energy and infrastructure
5.7
and support challenges 7.4
Business and Poor access to input
5.3
rade groups materials for manufacturing 6.4
Foreign exchange
6.3
challenges
Multiple taxation 6.1
Unskilled workforce 5.9
Certification issues 5.8
Non-affiliation with 4.7

business and trade groups
42
Business support structure Figure 35. Enabling factors of Business Recovery after the
Negative Impact of COVID-19 (% of respondents)
for youth entrepreneurs
Financial support from
43.4
family and friends
As reported by 43.4% of youth entrepreneurs in Technology adoption 39.0
Nigeria, the most important driver of recovery Increased demand for
32.9
over the past one year was financial support from your product/service
family and friends. Meanwhile, 39% and 32.9% cited Access to loan facility 27.1
increased demand for their products and services, Government policies
and technology adoption respectively as key factors and support
19.2
that enabled their recovery. Affiliation with business

18.4
and trade groups
Other 0.9
The private sector also by 25.6% of youth entrepreneurs and was followed
by support from non-profit organisations as well as
played the most important from the government.
role in the support system for Unlike the case of female businesses, the major
youth entrepreneurs during form of support received by youth-led businesses in
Nigeria during the COVID-19 pandemic was credit
the pandemic and loans as reported by 31.2% of the respondents.
In addition, 30.9% of respondents reported that they
Likewise, at the peak of the pandemic, the private received cash support while 27.5% reported that they
sector emerged as the most important source of received business support services.
support for youth-led businesses. This is as reported
Figure 37. Forms of support to youth-owned businesses to
Figure 36. Where support for youth-owned businesses reduce the impact of COVID-19 (% of respondents)
came from during the COVID-19 (% of respondents)
Cash 31.2
Private sector 25.6 Access to
30.9
credit/loans
Non-profit Business support
20.2
organizations 27.5
services
Business
14.9 Government
member 2.8
waivers
Government 13.3
Others 0.2
Religious
institutions 9.5
Others 0.9
43
Outlook of youth businesses entrepreneurs are optimistic about the future of their
businesses. This optimism could be attributed to the
in Nigeria depth of technology adoption and resilience among
the youthful population. Young Nigerians are most
optimistic about sales, market demand, operating
Nigerian youth entrepreneurs have high optimism environment, access to finance and expansion.
about the improvement of the businesses over the
next year. According to the survey, 92.5% of youth
Figure 39. Weighted ranking of optimism around aspects of

Figure 38. Optimism about improvement in youth-owned the youth-owned business in the next one year
business in the next one year (% of respondents) (% of respondents)
3.3%
13% Sales 18.8
13% 5.1%
Market demand 15.2
Operating environment 12.9
45.7% Expansion 11.2
46.0% Internal management 9.0
Hiring new employees 8.1
Foreign exchange 6.7
Government policies
6.5
and regulation
Very optimistic Optimistic Source: The FATE Institute

Pessimistic Very Pessimistic
44
9.0
TECHNOLOGY ADOPTION
45
TECHNOLOGY ADOPTION
Technology is vital in the everyday affairs of
small businesses, particularly those run by young
entrepreneurs. COVID-19 has accelerated the
digital revolution across the world and many
businesses had to explore new ways to cope
and adapt to the new normal. The adoption of
technology, therefore, became necessary for
many entrepreneurs in Nigeria, particularly for
those who could afford the technological costs
and also acquire the relevant technical skills
needed to expand output, maintain existing
customers, gain access to wider markets and
improve sales. Although technology is crucial
for many businesses, there are entrepreneurs in
Nigeria that do not adopt technology for several
reasons such as cost, religious beliefs and lack
of skills.
In this section, we explore the role of

technology in the day-to-day operations of small
businesses across the country.
46
Technology Adoption Figure 40: Do you adopt technology in the course of

carrying out your business?
amongst MSMEs
Of the 7,106 respondents, 6,116 representing
86% said they adopt technology in the course
of executing their businesses. The highest share
of respondents that adopt technology fall within
the age range 30-35 years (29%) while those that
fall within the range 25-29 years were second,
Do you adopt
accounting for 27% of total respondents that use technology in
technology. This is not surprising especially because the course of
majority of respondents fall within 30-35 years age carrying out your
bracket followed by 25-29 years. business?
Yes: 86% No: 14%
Figure 41: Breakdown of business owners that adopt technology by age range (years)
29%
27%
19%
14%
9%
2%
0%
15-24 25-29 30-35 36-40 41-50 51-60 61 & >
However, when we explore Figure 42. Share of respondents within each age group that adopt technology
the share of technology
adoption within each age
Age 15-24 Age 41-50
group, 15-24 years age
bracket had the highest
share. In other words,
93% 75%
93% of respondents that Age 25-29 Age 51-60
fall within 15-24 years
adopt technology. From a 88% 69%
gender perspective, 58% of
entrepreneurs that adopt Age 30-35 Age 61 & >
technology were male,
while 42% were female. 87% 77%
Age 36-40
86% Source: The FATE Institute
47
Technology Adoption
by sector
21.2% of respondents that adopted technology
in running their businesses operate in the Retail,
Fashion & FMCG sector. Players in this sector
interface with consumers directly and therefore
make use of technology platforms particularly
social media in engaging with existing and
potential clients. Business owners operating in
Agriculture and Hospitality & Hotel accounted for
11.1% and 8.7%, respectively.
48
Figure 43: Technology adoption by sector
21.2% 11.1% 8.7% 6.3% 6.0%

Retail, Fashion Agriculture, Hospitality Advertising Digital, Media &
& FMCG Fishing & Forestry & Hotels & Marketing Communications
6.0% 5.2% 5.1% 5.1% 4.0%

Entertainment Healthcare Art & Design Education Manufacturing
& Events & Training
3.2% 2.8% 2.5% 2.3% 2.1%

Technology Internet & Construction Banking, Finance Energy &
Telecommunications & Insurance Utilities
1.9% 1.5% 1.4% 0.9% 0.8%

Logistics & Real Estate Automotive Travel. Tourism NGOs
Transportation & Aviation & Leisure
0.6% 0.4% 0.2% 0.2% 0.1%

Mining, Oil Law Law Enforcement Government Recruitment
& Metals & Security

49
Impact of Technology Figure 44: Impact of technology on your business
Adoption Widened my reach to

35%
In examining the impact of technology on new customers
small businesses, the survey results showed that Improved sales
30%
and profit
technology has affected businesses positively. The
Become more efficient in
most prominent usage of technology is to expand operations through cost reduction
18%
customer base (35%), followed by improving sales Bad management or
17%
and profit (30%), becoming more efficient (18%) and internal causes
staying competitive (17%). Other usage of technology
cited by respondents include to conduct research,
drive innovation, improve knowledge and obtain Source: The FATE Institute
customer feedback.
50
Is there any direct linkage striking difference between businesses that adopt
technology and those that do not. 40% of businesses
between technology and that adopt technology reported an increase in the
number of employees since the lockdown, while
business performance? only 19% of those that do not adopt technology
When we delved deeper into the impact of
increased the number of employees.
technology on businesses, we find some interesting
pattern. 70% of businesses that adopt technology
Although we have not established a direct causal
say that their businesses have been on the path of
impact between technology and business growth/
recovery since the COVID-19 lockdown. For those
recovery, the above analysis shows some interesting
that do not adopt technology, a lower share of 50%
linkages that could further be explored in future
reported their businesses have been on the path of
studies.
recovery. In terms of employment, there is also a
Figure 45: Technology and Business Recovery

Businesses that use technology
70%
Businesses that do not use technology
50%
40%
Interpretation Legend: 70% of businesses
19% that use technology say they are on the
recovery path since the lockdown; 19% of
businesses that do not use technology say
Share of businesses that Share of businesses that they increased the number of employees.
say that they are on the increased the number
recovery path of employees since the
lockdown Source: The FATE Institute
Lack of Technology Adoption prevents you from adopting technology in your

business”, the most common reason cited for lack
According to the survey results, 14% of businesses
do not adopt technology in the course of their of technology adoption was “my business does not
operations. While some entrepreneurs see the need need technology”. 31% of businesses that do not
of technology but cannot afford it, others do not adopt technology cited this reason (see Figure 41).
see the value of technology. When asked “what
Figure 46: Reason for not adopting technology (% of respondents that do not adopt technology)
31%
18% 18% 17% 15%
1% 1%
My business Cost of Lack of interest Lack of Lack of digital Religious Lack of access
does not need usage in adopting digital tools training beliefs to internet
technology technology (smart phone,
laptop, etc)
51
Among those that say their Figure 47. Share of respondents within each age group that not need technology
businesses do not need
technology, the age group 25-29
Age 15-24 Age 41-50
years dominate, followed by 30-35
years. However, the age group
of 61 years and above had the
3% 9%
highest share of respondents that Age 25-29 Age 51-60
say they do not need technology
when compared with the total 5% 9%
survey respondents within each
age group. Only 3% of the total Age 30-35 Age 61 & >
survey respondents in the age
group 15-24 years say they do 3% 10%
not need technology. Majority of Age 36-40
entrepreneurs in this age group
that do not adopt technology cited
factors such as cost of usage, lack
5%
of digital tools and lack of digital
training. Source: The FATE Institute
Usage of Social Media channels for their business. This was followed by
Twitter, YouTube, Clubhouse and TikTok. In fact,
Social media has become a veritable tool for
businesses, particularly those that are run by 80% of businesses that use technology consider
youths. The data from the survey show that 78% of Facebook as important to their business. Still on the
entrepreneurs say they adopt social media channels level of importance, 19%, 13% and 7% of businesses
in the course of their business. Among businesses that use social media ranked Clubhouse, TikTok and
that use social media, they rated Facebook, Twitter as Not Important, respectively, while only 2%
WhatsApp and Instagram as the most important ranked Facebook as Not Important (WhatsApp: 1%).
52
Table 3. Ranking of Social Media Platforms by level of importance (% of businesses that adopt social media)
Very important 66%* 58% 42% 23% 10% 5% 3%

Important 11% 7% 14% 12% 6% 3% 2%
Fairly important 3% 1% 6% 13% 13% 10% 6%
Not important 2% 1% 3% 7% 9% 13% 19%
*Interpretation Legend: 66% of businesses that use social media consider Facebook as very important Source: The FATE Institute
Social Media channels and Facebook. Both platforms are the most used social
media platforms in Nigeria. Instagram was third
Revenue/Audience Reach on the list with 14.4% followed by Twitter (7.3%). In
WhatsApp and Facebook ranked highest as the terms of access to wider audience, Facebook had a
channels with the most impact on the revenue of share of 42%. Overall, the three platforms, Facebook,
businesses in the country. While 38% of businesses WhatsApp and Instagram, were most influential in
that adopt social media reported that WhatsApp the areas of revenue generation and access to wider
had the most impact on their revenue, 36% cited audience relative to other channels.
Figure 48: Which channel impacts your revenue the most? Figure 49: Which channel gives you access to a wider
(% of businesses that adopt social media) audience? (% of businesses that adopt social media)
Whatsapp 38.0 Facebook 41.8
Facebook 36.4 Whatsapp 30.1
Instagram 14.4 Instagram 17.8
Twitter 7.3 Twitter 8.1
Youtube 3.0 Youtube 1.9
Clubhouse 0.4 Clubhouse 0.4
Tiktok 0.3 LinkedIn 0.2
LinkedIn 0.2

53
Twitter Ban and its Impact these businesses that said they were not affected
are registered (55%) and use social media (65%). For
In June 2021, the Federal Government of Nigeria
placed a suspension on Twitter, which over the those affected by the Twitter ban (49% of overall
years had grown to become a platform for social, respondents), only 12% were severely affected, 17%
business and civic engagement. From the survey were moderately affected and 19% were mildly
results, 51% of business owners say their businesses affected.
were not affected by the Twitter ban. Majority of
Figure 50: How has the Twitter ban affected your business?
(% of overall respondents)
12% 17% 19% 51%
Severely affected Moderately affected Mildly affected Not affected
For businesses that were affected, the impact has their customers and 42% of the affected businesses
been negative. 53% of the affected businesses cited experienced lower sales/loss of revenue. When
limited access to relevant business information as businesses were asked whether the Twitter ban
the most prominent impact of the ban on their should be lifted, 83% stated that it should be lifted
businesses. 43% of the affected businesses lost while 17% disagreed.
Figure 51: In what way has the Twitter ban affected your Figure 52: Should the Twitter ban be lifted? (% of overall
business? (% of overall respondents) respondents)
53%
43% 42%
83% 17%
13%
Limited access to Loss of Lower sales/ Piling

relevant business customers loss of revenue inventory Yes No
information
54
10.0
CHALLENGES AND
OPPORTUNITIES
55
“ The business
environment in Nigeria
has been tough
for entrepreneurs.
“
The emergence of
COVID-19 and its
attendant effects only
worsened the situation
56
CHALLENGES AND
OPPORTUNITIES
The business environment in Nigeria has been tough competitiveness. Examining the results of the survey,
for entrepreneurs. The emergence of COVID-19 and the top five most challenging factors that affect
its attendant effects only worsened the situation small businesses in Nigeria include inadequate
across sectors of the Nigerian economy. Many infrastructure, insecurity, multiple taxation, poor
businesses have had to struggle with numerous business support from the government and limited
challenges, which have increased cost of doing access to affordable finance.
business, reduced profit margins and limit overall
Figure 53: Ranking of key challenges facing small

businesses in Nigeria
Inadequate infrastructure 15.9%
Insecurity 14.0%
Multiple taxation 12.0%

Poor business support
from the government 11.8%
Limited access to
10.0%
affordable finance
Government policies
9.7%
and regulation
Bribery and corruption 9.6%
Complex certification
8.9%
processes
Foreign exchange
problems 8.0%

57
Comparing the results with previous surveys on the of production for businesses, particularly those in
business environment, the challenge of insecurity high-risk areas. Other factors such as infrastructure,
has become a burning issue, with incessant cases multiple taxation, limited access to affordable finance
of kidnapping, theft, robbery and other social are traditional problems that are yet to be addressed
vices. This problem has resulted in the closure of by the government and other stakeholders.
businesses, low levels of productivity and high cost
Figure 54: Ranking of key areas that need to be addressed

to improve the state of entrepreneurship in Nigeria
Access to finance 15.9%
Energy and infrastructure 14.0%
Taxation 12.0%
Certification processes
11.8%
Access to internet/
10.0%
technology
Targeted business
9.7%
support
Access to markets 9.6%
Government policies
8.9%
and regulation
From a solutions point of view, majority of requirements by financial institutions. These

businesses view access to finance as the most challenges need to be resolved for small businesses
important factor that needs to be addressed in order to scale and become productive. Other important
to improve the state of entrepreneurship in Nigeria. areas that should be prioritised include energy and
Access to affordable finance remains one of the infrastructure, tax laws and policies, simplification of
most difficult tasks for entrepreneurs considering certification processes and access to technology.
the high interest rate and strenuous collateral
58
11.0
RECOMMENDATIONS
59
STATE OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN NIGERIA REPORT
RECOMMENDATIONS
Entrepreneurs in Nigeria are resilient. Even with the tough
business terrain, these business owners continue to forge ahead
and create impact in their immediate environment and across
the globe. To ensure the realisation of their potential, some
key actions are required from both policymakers and other
stakeholders. Some of these actions include:
• The Nigerian government, working with the desired impact, the Nigerian Government needs
private sector, needs to establish a well- to engage with entrepreneurship ecosystem
functioning entrepreneurial ecosystem that stakeholders, ensuring their opinions on
supports innovation and business growth. Such intended programmes and policies are duly
ecosystem will need to ensure the provision considered and represented during design and
of direct and structured support to nurture implementation. Also, proper consultation with
talents and provide young business owners with entrepreneurship stakeholders before regulatory
relevant training, skills, and funding to enable decisions are implemented will prevent a
them grow and enhance productivity overtime. negative impact on businesses. For example, the
The Entrepreneurial Index confirms that business Twitter ban was implemented without consulting
owners are resilient but support is required from entrepreneurship stakeholders which negatively
the government and other stakeholders going affected businesses providing jobs.
forward.
• Among the challenges facing entrepreneurs are
• There is an urgent need for concerted efforts three key factors – inadequate infrastructure,
by Government and other stakeholders to insecurity and poor access to finance. Insecurity
improve access to technology for small which was not among the top 5 issues pre-
business owners in Nigeria. Although evidence COVID-19 has emerged as a major problem
from the survey showed that technology for entrepreneurs. The government needs
adoption has a positive impact on businesses intensify efforts to address incessant kidnapping,
performance, some small business owners do banditry, and other forms of insecurity which
not still adopt technology in their operations, continue to affect business performance. In
mainly due to the associated costs and lack addition, addressing infrastructure bottlenecks
of technology skills. It becomes important, by improving spending efficiency and attracting
therefore, for the Nigerian government, at private capital into infrastructure development
both federal and state levels, to incentivise the are crucial. Lastly, instituting dedicated financial
private sector to make investments in broadband support for small businesses will go a long way
infrastructure across the country. This should to address problems associated with funding.
be accompanied by technology training
programmes for small businesses and ease • For Women and Youth-led businesses, specific
of doing business reforms aimed at reducing institutional support is important to unlock
overall costs and ensuring competitiveness of their potential. Support such as funding
businesses providing ICT related services in the and advisory services will go a long way to
country. improve the state of these businesses. Proper
enforcement of the national collateral registry
• There is the need for Entrepreneurship law which allows for the use of moveable assets
Ecosystem Representation in the design and as collateral will relax the strenuous demand for
implementation of Regulatory programs and fixed asset, which has limited access to finance
policies: For policies and programmes to yield for women and youths.
60
12.0
REFERENCES
61
REFERENCES
National Bureau of Statistics (2021). Labor Force Statistics:
Unemployment and Underemployment Report (Q4 2020).
Retrieved from https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/elibrary/read/1238
National Bureau of Statistics (2021). Nigeria GDP Report for Q1,

2021. Retrieved from https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng
National Bureau of Statistics (2021). The Impact of Covid-19 on

Business Enterprises in Nigeria 2021. Retrieved from
https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/elibrary/read/1241076
National Bureau of Statistics (2019). Micro, Small, and Medium

Enterprises (MSME) National Survey 2017 Report. A report
prepared by the National Bureau of Statistics and Small and
Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria. Retrieved
from https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng/pdfuploads/SMEDAN%20
REPORT%20Launch%20Presentation%202017.pdf
Sylvain Cottong (2020). What are the characteristics of the VUCA

world, including the current sanitary crisis? Retrieved from
https://www.advuca.com/post/what-are-the-characteristics-of-
the-vuca-world-including-the-current-sanitary-crisis
62
13.0
APPENDIX
Methodology Notes entrepreneurship used in this report – skills
acquisition, technology adoption, business
The FATE institute conducted a survey of business
establishments across several states in Nigeria performance, perception of opportunities and
for this study. A nationally representative sample enabling business environment. At every aggregation
of 5,000 business establishments was selected. level – pillar, the aggregated measure is computed
Establishments cut across formal and informal using the average of scores of its components. The
sectors and were located in both rural and urban EI score is the average score of the five pillars of
areas. The businesses in this study are captured measurement. Using the EI score, which ranged
under 25 sectors of the economy. between 0 and 100, a distance to perfect score is
computed by deducting the EI score from the ideal
The survey was executed in two major forms: state of 100.
questionnaire (online and physical) and interviews
of government regulators and business member Individual indicators are first transformed -
organisations. The principal objective of the survey normalized into a progress score between 0 and 1 to
was to provide data support towards the mapping measure transition to a perfect score (ideal state) of
of the State of Entrepreneurship in Nigeria. Other 1. Weights, rounded to 1 decimal place, are applied
objectives included to capture data on the impact to the five pillars.
of COVID-19 on small businesses, to provide data
on key business trends, survival and death rates of The steps below capture the computation process.
businesses, the level of technology adoption as
well as highlight key challenges and perception of Step 1: Compute the sub-index:
entrepreneurs on the business environment.
The surveys were conducted in the month of Where K represents each pillar (sub-index);
September and October 2021. In terms of data J represents each component in a sub-index;
collection, 176 enumerators were deployed across X represents observations
the states covered. Final number of surveyed i represents each respondent.
businesses was 7,106 which exceeded the initial
sample of 5,000. Field responses accounted for Step 2: Compute the composite index (weighted
95% of respondents while online responses had and unweighted) for States and national:
the remaining share of 5%. For the interviews, 10
organisations were interviewed. After completion,
the data were lodged, validated, cleaned up and
analysed in line with the objectives of the report. Two Where CI represents Composite Index
main statistical software - Ms Excel and SPSS - were
used in the analysis.
Step 3: Compute the composite index:

Entrepreneurial Index:
Methodology
The computation of the Nigerian Entrepreneurship
Step 4: Compute the distance to a perfect
Index 1.0 is based on successive aggregation
score (PS):
of mean scores covering the five pillars of
Distance to PS=(1- CI)*100
63
64
65
66
67
68

Entrepreneurship in Nigeria Report 2021 Fate Foundation

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Entrepreneurship in Nigeria Report 2021 Fate Foundation

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Entrepreneurship in Nigeria Report 2021 Fate Foundation

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

STATE OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN NIGERIA REPORT 2021

ABOUT THE FATE INSTITUTE

Download and share a soft copy of this report on www.fatefoundation.org/2021soe

Entrepreneurship remains a powerful force and

Digital Technology Adaptation

Figure 1: VUCA concept explained

CO MPLEX The environment is dynamic,

AM BIGUOUS The environment is

73% of businesses faced liquidity

be committed to unlock these opportunities. In

Source: The FATE Institute

Figure 2: Respondents by Gender and State

Akwa Ibom Kogi

Cross River Niger

Source: The FATE Institute

Age and Entrepreneurship entrepreneurs are very energetic, with a high

Figure 3: Respondents by Age (Years)

Age 30-35 Age 41-50

Source: The FATE Institute

Figure 5: Are you a full-time entrepreneur?

Source: The FATE Institute

Figure 7: Size of Business

Figure 8: Business Registration

registered? SMEDAN, 12%

Source: The FATE Institute

Business Incorporation type

Figure 9: Sectors of operation

22.9% 11.6% 8.1% 6.2% 5.7%

5.4% 5.2% 5.0% 5.0% 3.8%

2.9% 2.8% 2.6% 2.2% 2.1%

2.1% 1.6% 1.4% 0.8% 0.8%

0.7% 0.4% 0.3% 0.2% 0.2%

Source: The FATE Institute

Education, Training and among entrepreneurs include keeping financial

1% Business management Keeping financia records

None Business expansion

BSc HND Msc NCE

OND Primary Secondary Others

Source: The FATE Institute

Source: The FATE Institute

Entrepreneurship is an integral aspect of an

Figure 13: Indicators of Entrepreneurship in Nigeria

• Share of businesses that experienced growth in revenue and

• Share of entrepreneurs that are optimistic about their business in the

10% Source: The FATE Institute

The Entrepreneurial clear indication of the drive, dynamism and resilience

Table 1: Summary Statistics

Index N Minimum Maximum Index Distance Distance Standard

Source: The FATE Institute

Figure 14: Entrepreneurial Index Score

Source: The FATE Institute

Table 2: Entrepreneurial Index by States

Rank States Business Perception of Digital Skills Enabling Composite

Source: The FATE Institute

Entrepreneurship, Business set up by entrepreneurs have been successful, with

Figure 15. Have you set up a business that failed?

Source: The FATE Institute

Business growth is mild 21.7% experienced a growth of 1-5%. Only 5.5% of

1-5% 21.7 1-5% 17

6-10% 21.8 6-10% 26