Questions Re - Design of Neve BA283
Questions Re - Design of Neve BA283
Log in Register
Forums
General Discussions
Drawing Board
1 of 2 Next
Ian MacGregor
I Well-known member
Ok,
Now that I have passed my first real transistor design class (with a grade of A, btw; thanks especially to PRR and those who helped on my
labs), I have been looking at the class A Neve BA283 cards and have been trying to figure them out. (Schematics here)
What is the function of the 56k resistor and 4.7k trim pot? I know from experience that the pot can be adjusted to change the amount of
aysmmetrical clipping on the amplifer. I can see how this works, as changing the pot will change the DC level at the input of this stage, but
is there an AC function as well?? It appears to be some sort of feedback??
Report Ad
I'm sure I will come up with more questions later...
Ian
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 1/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Reply
Advertisement
Advertisement
Report Ad
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 2/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
At the risk of heresy (No one expects the Spanish Inquisition!) this is a fairly messy design to analyze. But your first supposition is I believe
correct: these are primarily d.c. feedback adjustment parts---notice that the 56k R is the only d.c. connection to the input Q base. The main
a.c. feedback setting the gain at the collector of the 3055 is via the 3.3k/80uF feedback components to the emitter of the input Q, and the
feedback divider series R/C between "K" and "J" (in parallel with the 1.2k that's there all the time).
You still have a little a.c. feedback due to the 56k at low frequencies since the 3055 emitter moves a little, restrained by the 80uF from "D" to
"M", but I don't believe that's particularly significant.
Brad
Reply
PRR
Well-known member
> What is the function of the 56k resistor and 4.7k trim pot? I know from experience that the pot can be adjusted to change the amount of
aysmmetrical clipping on the amplifer. I can see how this works, as changing the pot will change the DC level at the input of this stage
That's a side-effect.
What defines "symmetrical clipping" in this stage? And under what conditions?
If you run it un-loaded, it is never symmetrical, and the trim pot gives no real optimization.
It has to be adjusted (and probably operated) with rated load, probably 600Ω. Now what is the condition for symmetrical clipping?
Report Ad
Assuming the 47R emitter resistor (strapped to B-) is low compared to transformer primary impedance when loaded (roughly true, about
47R to 300R), the 3055 transistor can pull down any current or voltage (to about 24V*47/(47+300)= 3.2V, or 20.7V swing. To pull up, the
3055 transistor can only turn-off. The transformer, working as a choke, must be flowing enough current to kick the load the other way.
Assuming negative swings are 20.7V and the transformer is 300Ω, we better be flowing 20.7V/300Ω= 0.069A. That bias current causes some
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 3/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
bias drop in the 47R, so the negative swing is a little less, maybe only 6V drop or 18V peak. Now bias current should be 18V/300Ω= 0.060A.
Now the bias drop in the 47R is less... We can iterate to an answer, but we have neglected several small factors. Since the "right" answer is
"enough bias to maximize output, but no more", the best set-up is to build it and trim.
What we are really doing, of course, is setting Q1 base-voltage so Q1 collector sets Q2 and Q3 so the 47R has the right current. We are not
sure what that voltage is, but the 47R will have only a few volts, so Q2 Base is 1.2V higher, still a few volts. The 68K will have most of the 24V
supply. Q1 flows maybe 0.25mA, the 1K2 has maybe 0.3V, Q1 Base must be around 1V. Base current in the 56K makes very small voltage
drop: since it is comparable to the 68K which has ~20V, but flows 100-200 times less current, a few tenths of a volt. So the trim pot wiper is
something like 1.0 to 1.5V, set mostly by Q1 Vbe, some by supply voltage and 68K/1K2, some by Q1 Base current and 56K.
Meanwhile the 47R is dropping something like 0.060*47= 2.5V to 3.0V. The trim-pot ends up somewhere in the center of rotation.
Look also at the extremes. Trim-pot wiper grounded, 47R will rise almost to the supply voltage, eat 10 Watts and die. Pot wiper at top,
current is something like ~1.5V/47Ω or 32mA.
AC feedback is a mess. I'm sure you can figure out why diddling the trimpot has almost no effect on AC gain. But there is an ugly sneak path
through the source, which may be why that 2K2 resistor is there. This is a lot like a once-common phono preamp. With a capacitor on the
output emitter, certain values of source impedance make a dandy phase-shift oscillator.
Reply
bcarso
B Well-known member
But yes, the issue is setting up the optimal quiescent current in Q3. That might not be the optimal sound you are after, but for a given load
you may at least have symmetrical clipping, if that's what you want (although as PRR said in another thread, "Who clips?").
Report Ad
Note also (after pondering and grasping PRR's exegesis), as far as how well the whole thing works, that the temperature coefficient of the
whole thing is a factor too.
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 4/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
"The sound is in the iron." Well, yes; but this may well be a design where the interaction with the solid-state portion, temperature, and even
signal history is where the sound is as well.
Reply
Advertisement
Report Ad
PRR
Well-known member
The maximum negative swing is "most of the supply voltage". We paid good money for that supply, and that transformer to give the
required output voltage from the specified (probably battery-backed) supply voltage.
Report Ad
The maximum positive swing, OTOH, is the stored current in the transformer times the load, which is actually about 300Ω at the primary.
The stored current is basically the idle current.
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 5/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Test tones are symmetrical. Speech/music never is, but we never know which side the peaks will land on. So the maximum output is the
symmetrical output.
So we need to set current so positive swing is at least as much as negative swing. We could go wild and set it higher "just in case", but that
increases heat and electric-bills!
Setting high current does improve clipping in those moments when speech/music peaks land on the positive side, but do not help (slightly
hurt) negative peaks, and does not help pass the Acceptance Test which will look at maximum output before clipping (either side).
The optimum bias is (most of B+)/(primary impedance) or around 60mA. +/-10% variation will give either 10% extra heat or 1dB less
output: +/-20% variations are probably quite acceptable.
The design and the bias-set process assume a specific load. With maybe some leeway: if you dedicate a module to drive a 1K load, you
could fudge the trim to a lower current and save a little heat/power (but lose interchangeability). If you had 600Ω||Ω load, 150Ω at the
transformer primary, you could increase current to either double (for symmetrical clipping) or until the 2N3055 or 47R sizzled.
And of course the load is often +/-20%, so +/-20% tolerance on bias-set better be acceptable.
And "symmetrical clipping" isn't going to happen. On one side the transistor is fat and happy, on the other side it starves. You can trim so
the flat-tops are about equal, but it is going to hit bottom more sharply than it goes over the top.
Today however these beasts may be seeing 10KΩ loads. The Zobel on the secondary damps the main top-ring in the transformer but the
load impedance is rising as frequency falls. Without a slip-stick, about 1KΩ at 8KHz but 10KΩ at 800Hz and heading for ~1K at 80Hz due to
inductance. That changes distortion production, gain/feedback, and HF loss in various ways: it may have a quite different "sound" when not
loaded in 600Ω as intended. I wonder which way the kids today like it.
I'm overlooking the fact that high idle current will soak the core in DC, first phattening the bass, then reducing bass output, and finally
going all to heck. There may be enough air-gap so it fails 20Hz flatness without actually getting real-sick.
Report Ad
Break one loop and rough-estimate the gain implied by the other loop.
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 6/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
The 2K2 and 56K imply a gain of about 25. We estimate the trimmer is set halfway, so gain to the emitter is 50, assuming the emitter cap
isn't there (it isn't doing enough in the bass). Gain from emitter to collector is about 300/47 or 6. So this loop holds gain down to about 300.
The default 3K3 1K2 feedback values set gain to the collector at ~4. So the lower network's gain of 300 makes only 1% difference to the
gain=~4 loop.
The table says that pin K can see 110 ohms, giving gain of about 33. (The table quotes gain including ~3dB gain in the iron.) Still the
gain=300 loop has only about 10% effect on the gain=~33 loop. Even less when the emitter cap is working.
I neglected that emitter cap. If you see Q1 as a high-gain voltage amp, and Q2 Q3 as a big emitter follower, then the emitter cap gives one
pole and the 56K resistor with the input cap gives another pole. Q1 can have a LOT of gain, so if the two poles are anywhere near the same
frequency you have a 2-pole response that is liable to ring. Many phono preamps exhibit this, and sometimes at the 0.5Hz record-warp
frequency. The cheap fixes include undersizing the input cap and adding some damping resistance in series (the 2K2). Both are bad ideas in
phono amps: they raise input noise. When I worked this out, I resorted to hypersizing the emitter cap: 10,000uFd on a 2mA transistor's
emitter. (Hey, surplus caps are cheap.) I see some of that in the BA first stage: 125uFd with 470R||1K5 is pretty beefy.
I don't understand putting 15K from S to U. That appears to give a very low input impedance with a high noise resistance, but it varies with
gain-setting? I suspect a typo.
Reply
bcarso
B Well-known member
Is the output tranny 1:1.5 as connected? That's the only way I get a gain of 15dB or thereabouts with nothing across K and J except the 1.2k.
Reply
Report Ad
PRR
Well-known member
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 7/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Something like that. It does have voltage-gain, I know. And 3.5dB or 1.5 falls out of the gain-chart, as you say. And a 2N3055 in a TO-3 on a
small finned sink would be a little overkill for 600Ω with 20V-24V swings.
This gives clipping level just at +28dBm minus losses. I would not rate it +28, but it is up in that ballpark. It isn't just a mike-amp: when the
bombs fall (WWII was not that long in the past) and you have to patch a radio broadcast around a tattered network, this will give +8VU
cleanly even over long lines.
Reply
Ian MacGregor
I Well-known member
Wow... Some really cool stuff here. I'm slowly following along, but these discussions exceed my skill level quite quickly. When I was analyzing
the amplifier, I overlooked the 47 ohm resistor on the emitter of the 2N3055 :shock:
Is there a good reference that covers feedback theory in general (not just in particular to op amps??)
Ian
Reply
Advertisement
Report Ad
Report Ad
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 8/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
bcarso
B Well-known member
A good reference---hmmm. There are so many, each with a particular flavor. I just reviewed the material in Chapter 4 of Horowitz and Hill's
Art of Electronics 2nd Ed., and it isn't too bad: it starts with smple op amp circuits, gives some motivating examples, then gets to the effects
of finite open-loop gain, more examples, and finally tackles gain/phase issues. It's not how I learned about it but it's not too shabby---a
decent place to start.
Avoid books with a specific control theory emphasis for now, as there are some significant differences in certain definitions of terms
compared to amplifier-oriented accounts.
Reply
PRR
Well-known member
So where is the output stage current flowing down through? The 4K7 trim-pot? Aside from bad form, at max it would flow 24V/5K= 5mA, or
for "best power" 12V/5K= 2.5mA, allowing only 12V*2.5mA for the output stage. Even if a miracle allowed 100% efficiency, 30mW is not
much when mike-amps can generally make +18dBm or 50+mW.
At some point in your career, (after you learn to find emitter resistors) you should figure out why Rupert didn't wire the 47R emitter resistor
or its bypass cap to the ground bus. Hint: it might not matter for a single amp, but becomes a problem in a large system. And it might
matter less in music-mixdown than in some radio situations.
Report Ad
Start with much less messy designs than this one, and work up.
This is a good example of complexity through forced simplicity. Transistors cost money then. This has very few transistors compared to
modern designs, so it had to be very clever to make the most from the least. Use a 99-transistor chip, and the feedback action can be very
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 9/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
simple.
But the idea here is: Q3 emitter to Q1 base is an inverting amplifier, Q3 collector to Q1 emitter is a non-inverting amplifier. Each has
different AC and DC gain. The main DC reference is Q1 Vbe, though other parts have lesser roles to play.
Reply
peter purpose
P Well-known member
"The B283 (or 183) is designed to drive an inductive load in the collector of the 2N3055. If you don't use a LO1166 transformer for the load
(the easiest solution) you have to use a T1310 inductor as the load and wire a LO2567 transformer across the capacitor de-coupled
unbalanced output."
I've just measured some LO1166s and they range from 450 to 500mH and a T1310 measures 900mH.
peter
Reply
PRR
Well-known member
Report Ad
Yes, but it will run fine (at much lower maximum output) with 150Ω R in the collector.
> measured some LO1166s and they range from 450 to 500mH
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 10/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
?? Seems low? I'd expect 1H to 10H for a winding supporting a 300Ω load.
Also you have to measure the way it is used: with ~60mA DC flowing in it.
And you should measure at 20Hz-50Hz; a 1KHz test on an iron-core will give a different number.
Iron-core is also sensitive to signal level, though with heavy DC flowing the effect is small enough to neglect for first-order approximation
and cloning.
Reply
Advertisement
PRR
Well-known member
Yes, but also you are too young to have even a nodding acquaintance with some of the old-time classic circuits.
As a glance I class the 283 as a super phono amp. If you consider the power darlington as a single transistor, and resistor-couple the output,
this was a VERY popular plan for phono (huge black CDs) preamps.
Report Ad
I've re-drawn the 283 in simpler form. We don't need the monster output to understand the basic action. I've omitted AC paths and
feedback: the DC operation is fascinating.
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 11/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
I know this circuit is "somewhat stable" against supply and temperature variation, but never really looked at it. Note the blue curve, output
stage current for supply from 0V to 40V and temperatures of 0, 30, and 60 deg C. Over a 4:1 range of supply and a large range of
temperature, the output current varies only 2:1 from 0.85mA to 1.6mA and in the "good" direction (when voltage is ample, current is ample).
Considering the prime reference is the drifty Vbe, temperature has hardly-no effect. Less than the effect of using 10% resistors.
Replacing R3 with a short or a choke does not affect the DC bias enough to notice.
If you are used to high-gain balanced circuits where everything is stable to point-oh accuracy, this plan is sloppy. Everything has a little
effect and they all interact in little ways. The value of R5 has more effect than I thought, even with SPICE's optimistic Beta values.
Another little trick: if you want more constant output current, you reduce the value of R1. This is opposite to simple 1-transistor stages
where you need a large emitter resistor for bias stability. And small R1 means small voltage-noise.
We could spend a week on the AC action. Like: as-shown it has a very low AC input impedance. And when we fix that, the value of R2 has
almost no effect on AC gain (so we can use odd-lot resistors). It can be an amplifier, or a phase-shift oscillator, or both. All good jolly fun,
but you may see why when chips got inexpensive enough to use more complex and less interacting topologies, cheap-HiFi designers quit
playing with this plan.
Reply
peter purpose
P Well-known member
[quote author="PRR"]you have to measure the way it is used: with ~60mA DC flowing in it. [/quote]
Reply
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 12/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
PRR
Well-known member
Turns ratio is 624:1044 or 1:1.673. Z ratio is 2.8. 600Ω on the secondary gives about 214Ω on the primary. Or more exactly: sec DCR is ~40Ω,
so we have 640Ω over there, 229Ω inside the primary, plus ~15Ω pri DCR is 244 ohms looking into the primary, shunted by reactances and
eddy losses.
DCR referred to the secondary is ~82Ω implying something over 1dB loss. In fact the loss nearly equals the difference between nice-round
1.5 and the actual 1.673. They fudged the ratio to hide the loss.
Since all feedback is from the primary and gain is high, true output impedance is ~80-100Ω.
Total primary inductance (according to CJ, who may be testing without DC, and maybe at 1KHz) is 1.22H. This crosses the 244Ω primary
resistance around 32Hz. There is enough feedback to extend the -3dB point to a few Hz, but (assuming just 1.22H) the power response will
suffer (or "color" will improve) below 32Hz.
Reply
echorec
Well-known member
Just found this great and informative thread. Lots of it exceeds my level though...
I have a cople of 1272 amps and one of my 283 cards has a problem. The sound is a bit more "midrangey" and honky and noise bursts out
Report Ad
on some positions on the gain control potentiometer on the front.
All the electrolytics have been replaced and the gain potentiometer is new and when I swap the card for another 283, everything works
great so it must be the 283, not anything else in the 1272 housing.
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 13/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Could it be that the trim pot is set wrong? The 3055 gets a bit hot. Could I damage anything by experimenting with different settings on the
trim pot?
Thanks!
Reply
Advertisement
Report Ad
Tekay
Well-known member
measure the current with a working 283 then check the current draw for the "bad" card. If the current ain't the same try adjust the trimmer
so it reads like a working 283.
Reply
echorec
Well-known member
Report Ad
Thanks!
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 14/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Reply
Greg
Well-known member
The +24 rail, but remember to measure current you just don't probe. You have make the ammeter part of circuit.
Reply
PRR
Well-known member
Measure the voltage drop across the 47 ohm resistor in the 2N3055's emitter.
Reply
Advertisement
Report Ad
1 of 2 Next
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 15/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Post reply
Similar threads
HELP ME ON NEVE BA283
D dhonny
· May 15, 2022
· Drawing Board
Replies
12 · May 20, 2022
Share: ReportAd
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 16/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Spode Blue Italian (Camilla, Newer) SB-1000 Pro Gretsch 5pc Catalina Maple Drum Healthy, Chef-Prepared Meals
9" Rectangular Tray 9" SVS Set Cm1-e605-sdcb Delivered For Weight Loss
Replacements US Sound Pure BistroMD
Remember Her? Take A Deep Plastic Surgeon Tells: If You Have Amazon Has Millions Of Prime SUNDAYS CHILD TEE - 3Y / FLINT
Breath Before You See What She Wrinkles, Do This Immediately (It's Subscribers - But Few Know STONE
Looks Like Now Genius!) About This Savings Trick The Sunday Collective
SurelyAwesome Beverly Hills MD OnlineShoppingTools.com
Report Ad
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 17/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
$6.24 $4.64
$0.50 $0.31
$2.40 $19.40
$4.98 $13.92
Mouser
Mouser Electronics
Report Ad
Latest posts
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 18/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Latest: gyraf
· 22 minutes ago
Mini Oscilloscope
T
Latest: Tubetec
· 48 minutes ago
M Help needed from someone who understands tube amplifiers / tube heaters
Latest: moamps
· Today at 1:24 AM
Report Ad
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 19/20
6/9/22, 4:36 AM Questions re: Design of Neve BA283 | GroupDIY Audio Forum
Mouser
Mouser Electronics
Forums
General Discussions
Drawing Board
ReportAd
https://groupdiy.com/threads/questions-re-design-of-neve-ba283.6425/ 20/20