Doctrine of Indivisibility of Subscription Contract
Doctrine of Indivisibility of Subscription Contract
Doctrine of Indivisibility of Subscription Contract
GR: SH is not liable to pay interest on his unpaid *** where the consideration is other than actual cash,
subscription or consists of intangible property such as patents or
ER: if required by the by-laws copyrights, the valuation thereof shall initially be
determined by the incorporators or the board of
WAYS TO BECOME A STOCKHOLDER OF A directors, subject to approval by the SEC.
CORPORATION AFTER INCORPORATION **** Shares of stock shall not be issued in exchange for
1. By subscribing to the unsubscribed and promissory notes or future service
unissued shares either from the original capital
stock or from the increase in capital stock DOCTRINE OF INDIVISIBILITY OF
2. By purchasing treasure sales from the SUBSCRIPTION CONTRACT
corporation; or no certificate of stock shall be issued to a subscriber
3. By buying shares of stock from another until the full amount of his subscription together with
stockholder of the same corporation interest and expenses, if any is due, has been paid. The
failure to pay any of the installments due would
KINDS OF SUBSCRIPTION necessarily affect all the other installments, because the
1. Pre-incorporation contract – one entered subscription is to be treated as one, whole, entire, and
before incorporation indivisible contract.
2. Post-incorporation contract – entered into the default of any of the installments results to entire
after the issuance of the certificate of subscription becoming due and demandable.
incorporation
PAYMENT OF SUBSCRIPTION
PRE-INCORPORATION SUBSCRIPTION – a subject to the provisions of the contract of
subscription for shares of stock of a corporation still to subscription, the BOD of any stock corporation may at
be formed. any time declare due and payable to the corporation
unpaid subscriptions to the capital stock and collect the
irrevocable for a period of 6 months from the date same or such percentage thereof, in either case, with
of subscription accrued interest, if any, as it may deem necessary.
cannot be revoked after the submission of the AOI to
the SEC. (Sec. 60 RCC) if no payment is made within 30 days form the date
specified, all stocks covered by said subscription shall
Can only be revoked when: thereupon become delinquent and shall be subject to
1. All the other subscribers consent to the sale as hereinafter provided, unless the board of
revocation, or directors orders otherwise. (par. 2, Sec. 66, RCC)
2. When the incorporation of the corporation fails
to materialize within six months or within a DELINQUENCY; Remedies to enforce payment of
longer period as may be stipulated in the subscription
contract of subscription
First Remedy: Permitting the corporation to put up the
CONSIDERATION FOR THE ISSUANCE OF unpaid shares for sale and dispose of it in a
SHARES delinquency sale for the account of the delinquent
Stocks shall not be issued for a consideration less than subscriber.
the par or issued price thereof. Consideration for the Second Remedy: Court action
issuance of stock may be:
*** there should be cash dividends, the amount thereof Requisites for valid transfer:
can be applied to the unpaid balance of the subscription. (a) There must be delivery of the stock certificate
(b) The certificate must be endorsed by the owner
CERTIFICATE OF STOCK – the paper or his attorney-in-fact or other persons legally
representation or tangible evidence of the stock itself authorized to make the transfer; and
and of the various interests therein; merely evidence of (c) To be valid against third parties, the transfer
the holder’s interest and status in the corporation. must be recorded in the books of the
corporation
While a certificate of stock is not a condition
precedent to render one a stockholder, every Effect of failure to record
stockholder has a right to have a proper certificate (a) The transfer cannot be effective as against the
issued to him by the corporation, upon demand, as soon corporation or as to third persons
as he has complied with the conditions which entitle (b) The owner of shares of stock cannot be
him to the certificate. accorded the rights pertaining to a stockholder
the corporation is duty-bound to issue stock i.e. to call for a meeting and the right to vote,
certificates to its stockholders as soon as their or be voted for
subscription prices are fully paid.
the capital stock of stock corporations shall be *** a mere indorsement cannot be the basis of an
divided into shares for which certificates signed by the action for mandamus and that the rights if the parties
president or vice-president, countersigned by the have to be threshed out in an ordinary action
secretary or assistant secretary, and sealed with the seal a corporate secretary may not be compelled to
of the corporation shall be issued in accordance with the register transfers of shares in the basis merely of an
by-laws. indorsement of stock certificates
*** No transfer shall be valid, except as between the When recording is dispensed with
barties, until the transfer is recorded in the books of the when the corporation unduly refused to recognize the
corporation showing the names of the parties to the assignment of shares
transaction, date of the transfer, no. of the certificate or
certificates and the no. of shares transferred. Purposes of Recording:
Two-Fold
STOCK CERTIFICATE NOT A NEGOTIABLE 1. To enable the transferee to exercise all the
INSTRUMENT right of a stockholder, including the right to
because the holder thereof takes it without prejudice vote and to be voted for, and
to such rights or defenses as the registered owner or 2. To inform the corporation of any change in
creditor may have under the law, except insofar as such share ownership that it can ascertain the
rights or defenses are subject to the limitations imposed persons entitled to the rights and subject to the
by the principles governing estoppel. liabilities of stockholder.
PROCEDURE FOR DELINQUENCY SALE “Over-Issue” of shares occurs when certificates are
1. The BOD must make a call by resolution issued for more than the number of shares authorized by
demanding the payment of the balance of the the articles; VOID.
subscription (notice of the call)
2. The notice shall be served on each stockholder GR: entire subscription must be paid first before the
either personally or by registered mail. At this certificates of stock can be issued.
point, there is no need for publication
3. If the stockholder does not pay the amount on Exception: in the Baltazar v Linagayen Gulf Electric
the date designated, the Board shall issue, by Power Co case, it was the practice of the corp to issue
resolution, a “notice of delinquency” certificates of stock to its individual SHs for unpaid
4. Notice of delinquency shall be served on the shares of stock and to give full voting power to shares
non-paying subscriber either personally or by fully paid.
registered mail, PLUS publication in a
newspaper in the province or city where the RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS OF HOLDERS OF
principal office of the corporation is located, UNPAID BUT NON-DELINQUENT STOCKS
once a week for two consecutive weeks
5. The amount due in the notice must include all 1. Shall have ALL the rights of a stockholder
expenses (notices are jurisdictional) 2. Subscribers for stock shall pay to the
6. In the Public Auction, the corporation will corporation interest on all unpaid
give the highest bidder the certificate of stock subscriptions from the date of subscription,
in the number of his bid; the remaining number if so required by, and at the rate fixed in the
will be issued a certificate of stock in favor of by-laws (if no interest is fixed, such rate shall
the subscriber as fully paid. be deemed to be the legal rate).
7. If there are no bidders, the corporation must 3. No certificate of stock shall be issued until
bid for the whole number of shares regardless the full amount of his subscription, together
of how much the SH has paid. Such stocks will with the interest and the expenses (in case of
pertain to the corporation as fully paid treasury delinquent shares) if any is due, has been
stocks. paid.
Requisites for exercise of right to inspect: merger or consolidation does not become effective
1. Must be exercised at reasonable hours on by mere agreement of the constituent corporations.
business days Approval of the SEC is required.
2. The stockholder has not improperly used any
information he secured through any previous Mere Acquisition/Transfer (3 levels)
examination MERGER/ TRANSFER OF
3. The demand is made in good faith and for CONSOLIDATION PROPERTY
legitimate purpose Loss of separate existence by no loss of separate
the absorbed corporation or existence
Effect of refusal to inspect the constituent corporations
Any officer or agent who shall refuse to allow
inspection and/or reproduction of records shall be liable 1. ASSETS-ONLY LEVEL
for: GR: a corporation that purchases the assets of another
1. Damages will not be liable for the debts and liabilities of the
selling corporation provided the former acted in good The plan or merger of consolidation hall set forth the
faith following:
Except, when the following circumstances are present: 1. The names of the constituent corporations
1. Where the purchasers expressly or impliedly 2. Terms of the merger or consolidation and the
agrees to assume the debts mode of carrying the same into effect
2. Where the selling corporation fraudulently 3. A statement of the changes, if any, in the AOI
enters into the transactions to escape liability of the surviving corporation in case of merger;
for those debts and in case of consolidation, all the statements
3. Where the purchasing corporation is merely a required to be set forth in the AOI for
continuation of the selling corporation corporations organized under the RCC; and
4. Where the transaction amounts to a 4. Such other provisions with respect to the
consolidation or merger of the corporations proposed merger or consolidation as are
deemed necessary or desirable.
2. BUSINESS ENTERPRISE LEVEL
Purchase of substantially all the assets of the STEP 2: Board Approval
corporation extending it its “going concern” (ability to by majority vote of each of the boards of the
do business and make money, goodwill, clientele, corporations involved at separate meetings
stock-in-trade, etc.). There is case law, based on equity, plan of merger has to be approved by majority of
that holds the transferee liable for the debts and the board of each constituent corporation; it has to be
liabilities of the transferor. approved by affirmative vote of stockholders
representing 2/3 of the outstanding capital stock or 2/3
However, not every transfer of the entire corporate of the members in case of a non-stock corporation
assets would qualify under Sec. 39. It does not apply:
1. If the sale of the entire property and assets is STEP 3: Stockholders’ or Members’ Approval
necessary in the usual and regular course of 1. Notice of such meeting should be given to all
business of corporation, or stockholders or members at least 1 week
2. If the proceeds of the sale or other disposition before the meeting
of such property and assets will be 2. The plan has to be approved by a vote of
appropriated for the conduct of its remaining stockholders representing 2/3 of the
business outstanding capital stock, if a stock
corporation, or 2/3 of the members of the non-
3. EQUITY LEVEL stock corporation
purchaser takes control of the business by purchasing 3. Dissenting stockholders may exercise their
the shareholdings. Purchasing corporation is still right of appraisal. However, if the board
protected by the limited liability feature but the same abandons the plan, such right is extinguishable
can be pierced. 4. Any amendment to the plan must be approved
by the members or trustees and stockholders or
*** in order to transfer ownership of shares of stock members required for the original plan
not traded in the Stock Exchange, it is necessary to
secure a Certificate of Authorizing Registration (CAR) STEP 4: Articles of Merger or Consolidation
pursuant to the process laid down in RMO no. 15-03. must be signed by the president or vice-president and
The receipts of the payment of the tax shall also be filed certified by the secretary or assistant secretary setting
with and recorded by the secretary of the corporation forth:
pursuant to Sec. 11 of RR no. 06-08. 1. Plan of the merger or the plan of consolidation
2. As to stock corporations, the number of shares
Constituent corporation Consolidated outstanding, or in the case of non-stock
corporation corporations, the number of members
The corporations that The corporation formed 3. As to each corporation, the number of shares
shall cease to exist after after the consolidation or members voting for or against such plan,
joining together through of two constituent respectively
consolidation corporations 4. The carrying amounts and fair values of the
assets and liabilities of the respective
companies as of the agreed cut-off date
PROCEDURE OF CONSOLDIATION OR 5. The method of accounts of the companies
MERGER 6. The provisional or pro-forma values, as
merged or consolidated, using the accounting
STEP 1: Drawing up of the Plan of Merger or method; and
Consolidation 7. Such other information as may be prescribed
by the SEC
STEP 5: Approval by the SEC e. Real or personal property
the Articles of Merger or Articles of Consolidation f. Receivables due on whatever account
shall be submitted to the SEC for approval. (hence surviving/ consolidated
HOWEVER, in the case of special corporations, corporation has the power to file an
like banks, insurance companies, building and loan action for recovery) including:
associations, etc., the favorable recommendation of the i. Subscriptions to shares and
appropriate government agency shall first be obtained other choses in action
ii. And every other interest of,
If the SEC is it shall issue a certificate of merger belonging to, or due to each
satisfied that or consolidation, at which time the constituent corporation
the merger or merger or consolidation shall be 5. Regarding liabilities and pending claims:
consolidation effective a. Liabilities and obligations of
is legal constituent corporation:
it shall set a hearing to give the i. Surviving or consolidated
corporations concerned the corporation shall be
opportunity to be heard. Written responsible
If the SEC is b. Pending claim, action or proceeding
notice of the date, time and place
not satisfied brought by or against any constituent
of hearing shall be given to each
constituent at least 2 weeks before corporation
said hearing i. May be prosecuted by or
against the surviving or
EFFECTIVITY OF MERGER OR consolidated corporation
CONSOLDIATION c. The rights of creditors or liens upon
A merger does not become effective upon the mere the property or such constituent
agreement of the constituent corporations, but through corporations are not impaired
open approval of the articles of merger by the SEC
issuing the certificate of merger as required (Bank of R.A. 10667 (PHILIPPINE COMPETITION ACT)
Commerce v Heirs of Rodolfo dela Cruz).
“Acquisition” refers to the purchase of securities or
LIMITATIONS OF MERGER AND assets, through contract or other means, for the purpose
CONSOLIDATION of obtaining control by:
1. Should not create monopolies 1. One entity of the whole or part of another
2. Should not eliminate free and healthy 2. Two or more entities over another; or
competition 3. One or more entities over one or more entities
3. Act 3518 Sec 20 inhibits illegal combinations
“Merger” refers to the joining of two or more entities
EFFECTS OF MERGER OR CONSOLIDATION into an existing entity or to form a new entity
1. Constituent corporations become a single the Philippine Competition Commisison can review
corporation the mergers and acquisitions of a corporation/s based on
a. Merger: surviving corporation the factors it deems relevant (Sec. 16 RA 10667).
b. Consolidation: consolidated
corporation under the plan of parties to a merger or acquisition agreement without
consolidation complying with the thresholds are prohibited from
2. Separate existence of constituent corporations consummating their agreement until 30 days after
cease, except that of the surviving or providing notification to the Commission in the form
consolidated corporation and containing the information specified in the
3. Surviving or consolidated corporation regulations issued by the Commission.
possesses the rights and privileges immunities; a transaction that meets the thresholds and does not
and powers and is subject to all duties and comply with the notification requirements and waiting
liabilities of a corporation organized under the period set out in Sec. 5 shall be considered void and
RCC will subject the parties to an administrative fine of 1%
4. ALL of the following are deemed transferred to five percent of the value of the transaction. (Sec. 17
to and vested in such surviving or consolidated RA no. 100667).
corporation (by operation of law)
a. Rights Thresholds for compulsory notification
b. Privileges M&A transactions whose definitive agreements are
c. Immunities executed on or after 1 March 2020 will be subject to
d. Franchises of each constituent mandatory notification to the PCC if they meet the
corporation following thresholds:
SIZE OF i.
The aggregate annual gross
PARTY revenues in, into or from the
Philippines, or
ii. The value of the assets in the
Philippines of the ultimate
parent entity (UPE) of either
the acquiring or acquired
entities exceeds Php6B
SIZE OF The size of the transaction will be
TRANSACTIO met if the transaction value, as
N determined below, exceeds
Php2.4B
Exemptions:
i. The concentration has brought about or is
likely to bring about gains in efficiencies
that are greater than the effects of any
limitation on competition that result or likely
to result from the merger or acquisition
agreement; or
ii. A party to the merger or acquisition agreement
is faced with actual or imminent financial
failure and the agreement represents the least
anti-competitive arrangement among the
known alternative uses for the failing entity’s
assets.
PROHIBITED ACTS
Requisites:
1. Does not have a capital stock divided into Membership:
share personal and non-transferable, unless the AOI or the
2. No part of its income is distributable as bylaws otherwise provide
dividends as to its member only those who are actual, living members with
3. They must be formed or organized for voting rights shall be counted in determining the
purposes specified under Sec. 87 existence of a quorum
However, for the purpose only of winding up its affairs GR: a corporation shall have perpetual existence. The
and liquidating its assets, its corporate existence AOIs of existing corporations shall be deemed amended
continues for a period of 3 years from such dissolution. to reflect their perpetual term.
upon dissolution, the corporation ceases to be a ER: when the AOIs of corporations created under the
juridical person and consequently can no longer effectivity of the RCC provide for a specific period.
continue transacting its business
*** petition for revival of corporate existence may be
*** if no dissolution papers are filed with the SEC by filed
the corporation claiming dissolution, such corporation is
still deemed legally existing, notwithstanding the fact VOLUNTARY DISSOLUTION
that it has ceased to operate.
i. Where no creditors are affected
MODES OF DISSOLUTION
a corporation cannot be dissolved except in the Procedure:
manner prescribed by law 1. Meeting must be held on the call of directors
or trustees
VOLUNTARY INVOLUNTARY 2. Notice of the meeting given to the stockholders
Voluntary surrender of its Expiration of the by personal delivery or registered mail at least
charter by the vote of the shortened corporate 20 days prior to the meeting
BOD/T and the term 3. Notice of the meeting should also be published
1 stockholders/members once in a newspaper published in the principal
where no creditors are place of business, otherwise, in a newspaper of
affected general circulation
By the judgment of the By legislative 4. The resolution to dissolve must be approved by
SEC after hearing of a enactment the majority of the directors/trustees and
2 petition for voluntary approved by the stockholders representing at
dissolution, where least majority of the outstanding capital stock
creditors are affected or majority of members
Amending the AOI to Failure to organize 5. A verified reques for dissolution is then filed
shorten its term and commence with the SEC stating:
3 business within 2 a. The reason for the dissolution
years from b. The form, manner and time when the
incorporation notices were given
In case of a corporation Cessation of c. Names of the stockholders and
sole, by submitting to the business for 5 years directors or members and trustees
4 SEC a verified who approved the dissolution
declaration of the d. The date, place, and time of the
dissolution for approval meeting in which the vote was made;
By merger or By order of the and
consolidation SEC on the grounds e. Details of the publication
5 under existing laws 6. In addition, the following shall be submitted to
(Sec. 138) the SEC:
By order of the a. Copy of the resolution authorizing the
Courts following a dissolution, certified by a majority of
quo warranto the board and countersigned by the
proceeding, a secretary
proceeding b. Proof of publication
6 involving a c. Favorable recommendation from the
financially appropriate regulatory agency, when
distressed necessary
corporation, or for 7.
grounds under