1.1-Definition of Corrosion: 1.3.1 - Conditions Necessary For Corrosion
1.1-Definition of Corrosion: 1.3.1 - Conditions Necessary For Corrosion
1- Definition of Corrosion
Corrosion may be defined as a destructive phenomena, chemical or
electrochemical, which can attack any metal or alloy through reaction by the
surrounding environment and in extreme cases may cause structural failure.
Corrosion can be also defined as the deterioration of material by reaction to its
environment. The corrosion occurs because of the natural tendency for most
metals to return to their natural state; e.g., iron in the presence of moist air will
revert to its natural state, iron oxide. Metals can be corroded by the direct
reaction of the metal to a chemical; e.g., zinc will react with dilute sulfuric acid,
and magnesium will react with alcohols.
1.2- Importance of Corrosion Studies
The importance of corrosion studies is two folds. The first is economic,
including the reduction of material losses resulting from the wasting away or
sudden failure of piping, tanks, metal components of machines, ships, hulls,
marine, structures…etc. The second is conservation, applied primarily to metal
resources, the world’s supply of which is limited, and the wastage of which
includes corresponding losses of energy and water resources accompanying the
production and fabrication of metal structures.
1.3- Basic Causes of Corrosion
1.3.1- Conditions necessary for corrosion
For the purpose of this manual, electrochemical corrosion is the most
important classification of corrosion. Four conditions must exist before
electrochemical corrosion can proceed:
1- There must be something that corrodes (the metal anode).
2- There must be a cathode.
3- There must be continuous conductive liquid path (electrolyte, usually
condensate and salt or other contaminations).
4- There must be a conductor to carry the flow of electrons from the anode
to the cathode. This conductor is usually in the form of metal-to-metal
contact such as in bolted or riveted joints.
The elimination of any one of the four conditions will stop corrosion.
1.3.2- Effect of material selection
One of the fundamental factors in corrosion is the nature of the material.
1
Materials are usually selected primarily for structural efficiency, and corrosion
resistance is often a secondary consideration in design.
1.3.3- Water intrusion
Water intrusion is the principal cause of corrosion problems encountered
in the field use of equipment. Water can enter an enclosure by free entry,
capillary action, or condensation. With these three modes of water entry acting
and with the subsequent confinement of water, it is almost certain that any
enclosure will be susceptible to water intrusion.
1.3.4- Environmental factors
At normal atmospheric temperatures the moisture in the air is enough to
start corrosive action. Oxygen is essential for corrosion to occur in water at
ambient temperatures. Other factors that affect the tendency of a metal to
corrode are:
1- Acidity or alkalinity of the conductive medium (pH factor).
2- Stability of the corrosion products.
3- Biological organisms (particularly anaerobic bacteria).
4- Variation in composition of the corrosive medium.
5- Temperature.
The corrosion problem at KSC is complex. The presence of salts and
acids on metal surfaces greatly increases the electrical conductivity of any
moisture present and accelerates corrosion. Moisture tends to collect on dirt
particles.
2
1- Chemical corrosion: In which the metal is converted into its oxide
when the metal is exposed to a reactive gas or non-conducting liquids.
2- Electrochemical corrosion: The formation of hydrous oxide film occurs
when the metal is immersed in a conducting liquid containing dissolved
reactive substance. The reaction is considered to take place at the metal-
solution interface, due to the heterogeneity on the metal surface, which
creates local anodic and cathodic sites on the metal.
1.5- Factors Influence Corrosion
The nature and extent of corrosion depend on the metal and the
environment. The important factors which may influence the corrosion process
are:
a) Nature of the metal, nature of the environment and the corrosion products.
b) Temperature. c) Concentration of electrolyte.
d) Electrode potential. f) Aeration. g) Agitation.
h) Hydrogen over voltage and pH of the electrolyte.
3
metal. Stronger fields are generated at the physically strained parts of the metal.
The result is that these regions are anodic (oxidation occurs) and simultaneously
different areas are cathodic regions at which a reduction reaction (usually of O 2)
occurs.
The iron atom gives up two electrons to form the Fe2+ ion:
Fe(s) Fe2+(aq) + 2e- (anodic) (1.1)
The electrons that are released flow through the iron metal to the cathodic region
where they react with oxygen:
O2(g) + 2H2O(l) + 4e- 4OH-(aq) (cathodic) (1.2)
4
cathode. One can use standard reduction potentials to determine which metal
will act as the anode/cathode.
When considering a bimetallic system, the metal with the more positive
reduction potential will be reduced (cathode) and the metal with the more
negative reduction potential will be oxidized (anode). For example, if copper
and zinc were connected electrically and immersed in an electrolyte solution, we
might expect that the copper would be the cathode and the zinc the anode, based
on their relative reduction potentials.
1.6.2- Effects of the anode and cathode areas on the corrosion process
Area Effects are important, especially in galvanic and localized corrosion.
Consider the difference between a cell with a very large anode area compared to
the cathode and one in which the cathode is significantly larger than the anode.
Since metal is corroded at the anode only, the rate of corrosion will be
proportional to the rate at which the anodic reaction proceeds. For the anodic
reaction to proceed, however, there must be corresponding cathodic reactions.
The cathodic reaction therefore controls the rate of the overall reaction. With a
large cathode and a small anode, there is more surface area on which cathodic
reactions may proceed so the anodic reaction proceeds at a much faster rate than
if the reverse (i.e. large anode, small cathode) is true. Where use of dissimilar
metals is unavoidable, therefore, it is desirable to use the more noble (cathodic)
metal in the smallest possible exposed area relative to the anode.
1.7- Thermodynamic Principles of Corrosion
Corrosion resistance or chemical resistance depends on the following:
1- Thermodynamic principles.
2- Physical and chemical factors.
3- Metallurgical factors.
4- Electrochemical principles.
Thermodynamic and electrochemical principles play a major role in
determining the corrosion behavior of materials.
Thermodynamic indicates the spontaneous direction of a chemical
reaction. It is used to determine whether or not corrosion is theoretically
possible.
Almost all metals and alloys used in service are actually in an unstable
thermodynamic state. There is thus a fundamental thermodynamic tendency for
them to return to a stable state through corrosion processes. Thermodynamics is
concerned with energy states. The original metallic ores are said to be in a state
of low energy. External energy is applied in the conversion of the ores to usable
5
metals and alloys, transforming them to a higher energy state. They tend to
revert to a lower (more stable) energy state by reacting with a corrosive
environment. While thermodynamics can predict whether a corrosion reaction
will take place, it does not provide an indication of the rate of corrosion
reactions [6,7].
For a reaction to be occurred spontaneously there must be a free energy
change, ΔG, and since the energy, in the case of spontaneous reaction, is given
out, the sign is negative. The magnitude of the ΔG and its sign are of great
importance, since it indicates whether or not the corrosion reaction will take
place. For example the following reaction of aluminium in hydrochloric acid:
Al + 3HCl AlCl3 + 3/2H2 (1.5)
The reaction is thermodynamically favorable; i.e. free energy change ΔG must
be negative. This reaction can be divided into anodic half and cathodic half
reactions as follows:
Al Al3+ + 3e- (Anodic half reaction) (1.6)
3HCl + 3e- 3/2H2 + 3Cl- (Cathodic half reaction) (1.7)
These two half reactions have associated free energy change, thus, overall, the
sum of the two free energies change must be negative, i.e.
ΔGanodic + ΔGcathodic < 0
where:
ΔGanodic is the free energy change for anodic iron dissolution.
ΔGcathodic is the free energy change for cathodic hydrogen evolution.
The electrical potential, can be related to the free energy change by the
following equation:
ΔG = -n F E (1.8)
where:
ΔG is the free energy change.
n is the number of electrons transferred in the half-cell reaction.
F is the charge transported by 1 mole of electrons and has the value of
96494 coulombs/mole.
E is the measured potential in volts (Vs. SHE).
Similarly,
ΔGo = -n F Eo (1.9)
where:
ΔG˚ is the standard free energy change.
n and F are defined as above.
6
E˚ is the standard electrode potential and can be obtained from
thermodynamic tables.
Al Al3+ + 3e- Eo = 1.7V (1.10)
Under nonstandard conditions i.e., the respective ions not at unit activity, the
electrode potential is related to the standard electrode potential by Nernst
equation [8].
E = Eo + (RT/ nF) ln (aOx/ aRed) (1.11)
As can be seen from this equation the activity of the oxidized species (a Ox)
increases as electrode potential (E) becomes more positive. In aqueous
environments the thermodynamic consideration of electrochemical corrosion
was the bases of the construction of (E)- pH diagram, which are also known as
Pourbaix diagram [9]. Such diagrams are essentially isothermal phase diagrams,
which represent metal-ion/ oxide equilibrium plotted with potential, and pH bas
coordinates [10].
1.8- Types of Corrosion
1.8.1- General or uniform corrosion
Differences in electrical potential occur on the surface of a piece of metal
due to small differences in chemical composition, phase differences, amount of
cold work, etc. These differences set up small corrosion cells each with an anode
and cathode. Corrosion continues until the metal is consumed or the film of rust
formed on the surface sets up a barrier to the electrolyte.
1.8.2- Pitting corrosion
Pitting corrosion is a complex but important problem that is at the root of
many corrosion failures. It has been studied in detail for many years, yet crucial
phenomena remain unclear. In pitting corrosion the surface of the metal is
attacked in small-localized areas. Organisms in water or breaks in a passive film
can initiate corrosion. In pitting corrosion very little metal is removed from the
surface but the effect is marked.
In passivated metals or alloys that are exposed to solutions containing
aggressive anions, primarily chloride, pitting corrosion results in local
dissolution leading to the formation of cavities or (holes). The shape of the pits
or cavities can vary from shallow to cylindrical holes and the cavity is
approximately hemispherical [11]. The pit morphology depends on the
metallurgy of the alloy and chemistry of the environment as well as the leading
conditions. As observed first by McAdam in 1928, these pits may cause local
increase in stress concentration and cracks may nucleate from them.
7
Pitting corrosion occurs mostly in solutions containing halide or
oxyhalides. Chlorides, bromides and hypochlorites are the most aggressive
anions [12]. Fluoride, iodide and iodine containing anions were thought to be
without pitting tendency. However, iodide ions were found to cause pitting
corrosion in many cases [13]. Solutions of certain oxidizing cations produce the
worst pitting attack. Ferric, cupric and mercuric halides are the most aggressive
of all pitting reagents. The non-oxidizing metal halides such as Al, Ca and Na
cause pitting to a lesser degree.
Electrochemical studies of pitting corrosion have found that there exist
characteristic potentials. Stable pits form at potentials noble to the pitting
potential, EP, and will grow at potentials noble to the repassivation potential,
ER, which is lower than EP. During upward scanning in a cyclic polarization
experiment, a stable pit starts growing at EP where the current increases sharply
from the passive current level and, upon reversal of the scan direction,
repassivates at ER where the current drops back. It is generally considered that
materials exhibiting higher values of EP and ER are more resistant to pitting
corrosion, and cyclic polarization experiments are commonly used for this
purpose.
Pitting is considered to be autocatalytic in nature; once a pit starts to
grow, the conditions developed are such that further pit growth is promoted. The
anodic and cathodic electrochemical reactions that comprise corrosion separate
spatially during pitting. The local pit environment becomes depleted in cathodic
reactant (e.g. oxygen), which shifts most of the cathodic reaction to the boldly
exposed surface where this reactant is more plentiful. The pit environment
becomes enriched in metal cations and an anionic species such as chloride,
which electromigrates into the pit to maintain charge neutrality by balancing the
charge associated with the cation concentration. The pH in the pit is lower
owing to cation hydrolysis and the absence of a local cathodic reaction. The
acidic chloride environment thus generated in pits is aggressive to most metals
and tends to propagate the pit growth.
1.8.3- Stress corrosion cracking
Failure is due to the simultaneous influence of static tensile stresses and a
corrosive environment and this is specific to a particular metal. The stresses may
be internal such as those caused by cold work, welding, heat treatment or
external forces caused by mechanical stresses set up by assembly practices. A
good example of this form of corrosion is 316 stainless steel in marine
environments. 316 stainless steel was developed to withstand attacks in chloride
environments, but if stressed the steel will fail by stress corrosion cracking.
1.8.4- Intergranular corrosion
8
Corrosion occurs at the grain boundaries due to a difference in potential
between the anodic grain boundaries and the cathodic grains. "Sensitized"
stainless steels, where carbides have been precipitated in the grain boundaries
during improper heat treatment or in the heat-affected zone of a weld, are
particularly susceptible to intergranular corrosion.
1.8.5- Corrosion fatigue
Failure under repeated cycling stresses in a corrosive environment.
1.8.6- Filiform corrosion
Filiform corrosion appears as a network of corrosion trials, of a wormlike
structure, particularly beneath thin organic coatings. Salts containing chlorides,
which have been left on the surface prior to coating, are suspected.
1.8.7- Crevice corrosion
Crevice corrosion occurs when there is a difference in ion, or oxygen,
concentration between the metal and its surroundings. Oxygen starvation in an
electrolyte at the bottom of a sharp V-section will set up an anodic site in the
metal that then corrodes rapidly.
1.8.8- Galvanic or bi-metallic corrosion
Galvanic corrosion takes place between two different metals, or coatings,
which are joined together in the presence of an electrolyte. Each metal has a
potential different from any other metal when placed in an electrolyte. A series
can be built up of all the metals relative to each other.
1.8.9- Fretting corrosion
Fretting corrosion occurs when two or more parts rub against each other.
The rubbing action removes the corrosion products and exposes new metal to
the electrolyte.
1.8.10-Erosion corrosion
Erosion is the removal of metal by the movement of fluids against the
surface. The combination of erosion and corrosion can provide a severe rate of
corrosion.
9
Corrosion is not only dangerous, but also costly, with annual damages in
the billions of dollars! If this is difficult to believe, consider some of the direct
and indirect effects of corrosion which contribute to these costs:
1- Replacement of corroded equipment.
2- Unscheduled plant shutdowns for replacement.
3- Process upsets resulting from corrosion.
4- Product contamination.
5- Product loss from a vessel that has corroded.
6- Otherwise unnecessary preventive maintenance.
7- Over design to allow for corrosion.
8- Inability to use otherwise desirable materials.
While the economic costs are frightening, we must consider them to be of
secondary importance to the potential loss of life and damage to the environment
problems, which can have widespread effects upon modern industrial
businesses. It is essential, therefore, for operators of industrial process plants to
have a program for controlling corrosion.
1.10- Methods of Corrosion Protection
1.10.1- Application of protective coatings
Metallic structures can be protected from corrosion in many ways. A
common method involves the application of protective coatings made from
paints, plastics or films of noble metals on the structure itself (e.g., the coating
on tin cans). These coatings form an impervious barrier between the metal and
the oxidant but are only effective when the coating completely covers the
structure. Flaws in the coating have been found to produce accelerated corrosion
of the metal.
1.10.2- Polarize or shift the potential of the metal
Another method of reducing corrosion is to polarize or shift the potential
of the metal enabling it to act as a cathode (rather than an anode) in an
electrochemical cell. One example is the galvanizing of steel with a coating of
zinc. The iron and zinc then function as the electrodes of a cell. Zinc is the more
readily oxidized metal of the pair and functions as the anode and corrodes, while
the iron functions as the cathode. The zinc is used up and protection is effective
as long as some zinc remains. Sacrificial anodes work on the same principal but
use an external electrode made from a readily oxidized metal; this form of
protection is commonly used on buried pipelines.
1.10.3- Cathodic protection
Cathodic protection using an impressed current derived from an external
power supply is a related form of protection in which the metal is forced to be
10
the cathode in an electrochemical cell. For example, most cars now use the
negative terminal on their batteries as the ground. Besides being a convenient
way to carry electricity, this process shifts the electrical potential of the chassis
of the car, thereby reducing (somewhat) its tendency to rust.
1.10.4- Materials selection
Basic recommendations for eliminating corrosion are materials selection
which are summarized as follows:
1- Use corrosion-resistant materials including plastics and non-metallics in
severe environments.
2- Avoid dissimilar metal couples.
3- Avoid the use of back-to-back structural shapes, such as boxbeam
sections and unistrut. When the exterior use of unistrut cannot be avoided,
selection of appropriate material shall be considered, such as stainless
steel. In addition, alternate structural shapes shall be considered such as
C- or d-shaped channel, especially in highly corrosive areas.
4- Avoid the use of alloys susceptible to stress-corrosion.
1.10.5- Corrosion inhibitors
Corrosion inhibitors can be added to solutions in contact with metals (e.g.
inhibitors are required in the antifreeze solution in automobile cooling systems).
These compounds can prevent either the anode or the cathode reaction of
corrosion cells; one way that they can do this is by forming insoluble films over
the anode or cathode sites of the cell. Examples of anodic inhibitors are sodium
phosphate or sodium carbonate while zinc sulfate and calcium or magnesium
salts act as cathodic inhibitors. New forms of paints are being developed which
take advantage of similar properties. These paints promise to nearly eliminate
corrosion in applications like painted car fenders, etc.
1.11- Corrosion Inhibitors
1.11.1-Corrosion inhibition in acid solutions
Acid solutions are widely used in industry, where the most important
fields of application are acid pickling, industrial acid cleaning and oil well
acidizing. Because of general aggressively of acid solutions, the practice of
inhibition is commonly used to reduce the corrosive attack on metallic materials.
The selection of appropriate inhibitors mainly depends on the type of
acid, its concentration, temperature and velocity of flow, the presence of
dissolved organic and/or inorganic substances, and on the type of metallic
material exposed to the action of acidic solution.
Most of well-known acid inhibitors are organic compounds containing
nitrogen, sulphate and oxygen [14-21].
11
1.11.2-Factors affecting inhibitors action in aggressive acid media
a- Interaction of the inhibitor with a metal surface
Physical (or electrostatic) adsorption and chemisorption are the principle
types of interaction between an organic inhibitor and a metal surface.
i- Physical adsorption
Physical adsorption is the result of electrostatic attractive forces between
inhibiting ions or dipoles and the electrically charged surface of the metal. The
surface charge of the metal is due to the electric field at the outer Helmhaltz
plane of the electrical double layer existing at the metal/solution interface. The
surface charge can be defined by the potential of the metal E corr vs. its zero
charge potential (ZPC) (Eq=o) [22] when the difference Ecorr - Eq = ф is negative
charge, cation adsorption is favored. Adsorption of anions is favored when ф
become positive. This behaviour is related not only to positively or negatively
charged compounds, but also to dipoles whose orientation is determined by the
value of the ф potential.
According to Antropov [22], at equal value of ф for different metals,
similar behaviour of gives inhibiting species should be expected in the same
environment.
In study the adsorption of ions at the metal/solution interface, it was first
assumed that ions maintained their total charge during the adsorption. Giving
rise in this way to a pure electrostatic bond. Lorenz [23-25] suggested that
partial charge is present in the adsorption of ions; in this case a certain amount
of covalent bond in the adsorption process must be considered. The partial
charge concept studied by Shultz and Kappitz [26] and others [27-29], they
defined electrosorption valency as the coefficient for the potential dependence
and charge flow of electrosorption process. The term electrosorption valency
was chosen because of its analogy with the electrode reaction valency, which
enters into Faraday’s law as well as the Nernest equation.
ii- Chemisorption
Another type of metal/inhibitor interaction is chemisorption. This process
involves charge sharing or charge transfer from the inhibitor molecule to the
metal surface in order to form a coordinate type of bond.
The chemisorption process takes place more slowly than electrostatic
adsorption and with higher activation energy. It depends on the higher
temperature; higher degree of inhibition should be expected at higher
temperature.
Chemisorption is specific for certain metals and is not completely
reversible [28]. The bonding occurring with electron transfer clearly depends on
12
the nature of the metal and the nature of organic inhibitor. In fact, electron
transfer is typical for transition metals having vacant, low-energy electron
orbitals.
The structure characteristics of the rest of the molecule influence the
electron density on the heteroatom and as a consequence, the strength of the
chemisorption bond. Regular and systematic changes in the molecular structure,
such as the introduction of substituents in various positions on the aromatic and
heterocyclic compounds, may influence the electron density and the ability of
compounds to inhibit corrosion.
Relationship between electronic structure and efficiency of various
classes of inhibitors has been deduced from quantum mechanical calculations
[30-33]. In this way, the electron density, the order of the bond along the bond
line, the index of free valence and the charge of atoms in the free and adsorbed
states have been calculated. Other structure parameters influencing the inhibiting
efficiency may be mentioned. Thus, the projected molecular area [34],
molecular weight [35] of various series of organic compounds has been
correlated with variation in inhibiting efficiencies.
b- Interaction between adsorbed inhibitors
When the coverage of the metal surface by adsorbed inhibitor species,
lateral interaction between inhibitor molecules may arise, influencing the
inhibition efficiency. Attractive lateral interactions usually give rise to stronger
adsorption and higher inhibition efficiency. This effect has been show in the
case of compounds containing long hydrocarbon chains due to attractive Vander
Waals forces [36,37]. In the presence of ions or molecules containing dipoles,
repulsive interaction may occur, weakling the adsorption and diminishing the
inhibition efficiency.
c- Interaction of the inhibitor with water molecules
Due to adsorption process of an inhibitor, water molecules are being
removed from the metal surface. During the adsorption process of a molecule
the interaction energy between molecule and water changes as it passes from the
dissolved to adsorbed state. This change forms an important part of the free
energy of adsorption, i.e., the higher the solvation energy of the adsorpting
species, the higher the free energy of adsorption. Increasing the size of the
hydrocarbon portion of an organic molecule will increase the solvation energy
of an inhibitor leading to decrease the solubility and increasing absorbability
[38].
d- Relationship between inhibitor reactivity and efficiency
13
The nature of the inhibitor initially present in acid solutions may change
with the time and/or the electrode potential as a consequence of reduction
reactions, polymerization reactions, or formation of surface products. The
inhibition due to the reaction products is usually called secondary inhibition,
whereas primary inhibition may be higher or lower than secondary inhibition,
depending on the effectiveness of the reaction product [39].
1.11.3-Adsorption isotherms
The adsorption isotherms describe the relation ship between the coverage
(θ) of an interface with adsorbed species and concentration of the species in
solution. Various adsorption isotherms have been listed as follow [40,41]:
a- The Henry isotherm: It has the following form:
θ=KC (1.12)
where:
K is the adsorption equilibrium constant.
C is the concentration of the adsorbate in the bulk phase in moles / liter.
θ is the degree of surface coverage.
b- The Freundlich isotherm: It has the following form:
θ = K Cn (1.13)
where:
K and C are defined as in Henry isotherm.
n is a constant where, 0 < n < 1.
c- The Langmiur isotherm: It has the following form:
θ/ 1- θ = K C (1.14)
d- The Volmer isotherm: It has the following form:
K C = θ/ 1 - θ exp (θ/ 1 - θ) (1.15)
e- The Amagat isotherm: It has the following form:
K Cn = θ/ 1 - θ exp (θ/ 1 - θ) (1.16)
which has the same form as the Volmer isotherm but the concentration is raised
to the power n where, 0 < n < 1.
f- The Frumkin isotherm: It has the following form:
K C = θ/ 1 - θ exp (-2 a θ) (1.17)
where:
a is a parameter characterizing the interaction between the adsorbed
particles..
a > 0, Attraction while a < 0, Repulsion.
14
g- The Parsons isotherm: It has the following form:
K C = θ/ 1 - θ exp ((2 - θ / (1 - θ )2 - 2 a θ) (1.18)
h- The Temkin isotherm: It has the following form:
ln K C = a θ (1.19)
where all terms are defined as described above and θ varies between
0.1 < θ < 0.9.
Interpretation of adsorption and performance of organic inhibitors can be
evidenced by fitting the data to one of the adsorption isotherms.
1.12- Corrosion Monitoring
1.12.1-Definition of corrosion monitoring
Corrosion monitoring (measurement) is the quantitative method by which
the effectiveness of corrosion control and prevention techniques can be
evaluated and provides the feedback to enable corrosion control and prevention
methods to be optimized. Corrosion measurement employs a variety of
techniques to determine how corrosive the environment is and at what rate metal
loss is being experienced.
1.12.2-Corrosion monitoring techniques
A large number of corrosion monitoring techniques exist. The following
list details the most common techniques, which are used in industrial
applications:
a. Corrosion coupons (weight loss)
The weight loss technique is the best known and simplest of all corrosion
monitoring techniques. The method involves exposing a specimen of material
(the coupon) to a process environment for a given duration, then removing the
specimen for analysis. The basic measurement which is determined from
corrosion coupons is weight loss; the weight loss taking place over the period of
exposure being expressed as corrosion rate.
The simplicity of the measurement offered by the corrosion coupon is
such that the coupon technique forms the baseline method of measurement in
many corrosion monitoring programs.
Advantages of weight loss coupons are that:
The technique is applicable to all environments- gases, liquids, and solids/
particulate flow.
Visual inspection can be undertaken.
Corrosion deposits can be observed and analyzed.
15
Weight loss can be readily determined and corrosion rate easily
calculated.
Localized corrosion can be identified and measured.
Inhibitor performance can be easily assessed.
The disadvantage of the coupon technique is that:
If a corrosion upset occurs during the period of exposure, the coupon
alone will not be able to identify the time of occurrence of the upset, and
depending upon the peak value of the upset and its duration, may not even
register a statistically significant increased weight loss
Therefore, coupon monitoring is most useful in environments where
corrosion rates do not significantly change over long time periods. However,
they can provide a useful correlation with other techniques such as E/R and LPR
measurements.
b- Electrical resistance (E/R™) monitoring
E/R probes can be thought of as "electronic" corrosion coupons. Like
coupons, E/R probes provide a basic measurement of metal loss, but unlike
coupons, the value of metal loss can be measured at any time, as frequently as
required, while the probe is in-situ and permanently exposed to the process
stream.
The E/R technique measures the change in Ohmic resistance of a
corroding metal element exposed to the process stream. The action of corrosion
on the surface of the element produces a decrease in its cross-sectional area with
a corresponding increase in its electrical resistance. The increase in resistance
can be related directly to metal loss and the metal loss, as a function of time is
by definition the corrosion rate.
E/R probes have all the advantages of coupons, plus:
Probe remains installed in-line until operational life has been exhausted.
They respond quickly to corrosion upsets and can be used to trigger an
alarm.
The response time for E/R monitoring is far shorter than that for weight
loss coupons.
E/R probes are available in a variety of element geometries, metallurgies
and sensitivities and can be configured for flush mounting such that
pigging operations can take place without the necessity to remove probes.
The range of sensitivities allows the operator to select the most dynamic
response consistent with process requirements.
c- Linear polarization resistance (LPR) monitoring
16
The LPR technique is based on complex electro-chemical theory. For
purposes of industrial measurement applications it is simplified to a very basic
concept. In fundamental terms, a small voltage (or polarization potential) is
applied to an electrode in solution. The current needed to maintain a specific
voltage shift (typically 10mV.) is directly related to the corrosion on the surface
of the electrode in the solution. By measuring the current, a corrosion rate can be
derived.
Advantages of the LPR technique are that:
The measurement of corrosion rate is made instantaneously.
This is a more powerful tool than either coupons or E/R where the
fundamental measurement is metal loss and where some period of
exposure is required to determine corrosion rate.
Disadvantages of the LPR technique are that:
It can only be successfully performed in relatively clean aqueous
electrolytic environments.
It will not work in gases or water/ oil emulsions where fouling of the
electrodes will prevent measurements being made.
d- Galvanic/potential monitoring
The galvanic monitoring technique, also known as Zero Resistance
Ammetry (ZRA) is another electrochemical measuring technique. With ZRA
probes, two electrodes of dissimilar metals are exposed to the process fluid.
When immersed in solution, a natural voltage (potential) difference exits
between the electrodes. The current generated due to this potential difference
relates to the rate of corrosion, which is occurring on the more active of the
electrode couple.
Galvanic/Potential monitoring is applicable to the following electrode couples:
Bimetallic corrosion.
Crevice and pitting attack.
Corrosion assisted cracking.
Corrosion by highly oxidizing species.
Weld decay.
Galvanic current measurement has found its widest applications in water
injection systems where dissolved oxygen concentrations are a primary
concern. Oxygen leaking into such systems greatly increases galvanic
currents and thus the corrosion rate of steel process components. Galvanic
monitoring systems are used to provide an indication that oxygen may be
invading injection waters through leaking gaskets or deaeration systems.
e- Specialized monitoring
17
i- Biological monitoring
Biological monitoring and analysis generally seeks to identify the
presence of Sulphate Reducing Bacteria- SRB's. This is a class of anaerobic
bacteria which consume sulphate from the process stream and generate sulphuric
acid, a corrosive which attacks production plant materials.
ii- Sand/ erosion monitoring
These are devices, which are designed to measure erosion in a flowing
system. They find wide application in oil/gas production systems where
particulate matter is present.
iii- Hydrogen penetration monitoring
In acidic process environments, hydrogen is a by-product of the corrosion
reaction. Hydrogen generated in such a reaction can be absorbed by steel
particularly when traces of sulphide or cyanide are present. This may lead to
hydrogen-induced failure by one or more of several mechanisms. The concept of
hydrogen probes is to detect the amount of hydrogen permeating through the
steel by mechanical or electrochemical measurement and to use this as a
qualitative indication of corrosion rate.
1.13- Corrosion inhibition of C- steel in acidic solutions
1.13.1-Uses of C- steel
Steel is a metal alloy whose major component is iron, with carbon content
between 0.02% and 1.7% by weight. Carbon is the most cost effective alloying
material for iron, but many other alloying elements are also used. Carbon and
other elements act as a hardening agent, preventing dislocations in the iron atom
crystal lattice from sliding past one another. Varying the amount of alloying
elements and their distribution in the steel controls qualities such as the
hardness, elasticity, ductility, and tensile strength of the resulting steel. Steel
with increased carbon content can be made harder and stronger than iron, but is
also more brittle. The maximum solubility of carbon in iron is 1.7% by weight,
occurring at 1130° Celsius; higher concentrations of carbon or lower
temperatures will produce cementite which will reduce the material's strength.
Alloys with higher carbon content than this are known as cast iron because of
their lower melting point. Steel is also to be distinguished from wrought iron
with little or no carbon, usually less than 0.035%. It is common today to talk
about 'the iron and steel industry' as if it were a single thing; it is today, but
historically they were separate products. Steel is often classified by its carbon
content: a high-carbon steel is serviceable for dies and cutting tools because of
its great hardness and brittleness. low- or medium-carbon steel is used for
sheeting and structural forms because of its amenability to welding and tooling.
18
C- steel, also called plain carbon steel, is steel where the main alloying
constituent is carbon. The American Iron and Steel Institute (AISI) defines
carbon steel as: "Steel is considered to be carbon steel when no minimum
content is specified or required for chromium, cobalt, columbium, molybdenum,
nickel, titanium, tungsten, vanadium or zirconium, or any other element to be
added to obtain a desired alloying effect; when the specified minimum for
copper does not exceed 0.40 percent; or when the maximum content specified
for any of the following elements does not exceed the percentages noted:
manganese 1.65, silicon 0.60, copper 0.60. The term "carbon steel" may also be
used in reference to steel which is not stainless steel; in this use carbon steel
may include alloy steels. Steel with a low carbon content has properties similar
to iron. As the carbon content rises, the metal becomes harder and stronger but
less ductile and more difficult to weld. In general, higher carbon content lowers
the melting point and its temperature resistance. Carbon content influences the
yield strength of steel because carbon atoms fit into the interstitial crystalline
lattice sites of the body-centered cubic (BCC) arrangement of the iron atoms.
The interstitial carbon reduces the mobility of dislocations, which in turn has a
hardening effect on the iron. To get dislocations to move, a high enough stress
level must be applied in order for the dislocations to "break away". This is
because the interstitial carbon atoms cause some of the iron BCC lattice cells to
distort. 85% of all steel used in the U.S. is carbon steel. Mild steel is the most
common form of steel because its price is relatively low while it provides
material properties that are acceptable for many applications. Low carbon steel
contains approximately 0.05–0.15% carbon and mild steel contains 0.16–0.29%
carbon, therefore it is neither brittle nor ductile. Mild steel has a relatively low
tensile strength, but it is cheap and malleable; surface hardness can be increased
through carburizing. It is often used when large quantities of steel are needed,
for example as structural steel. The density of mild steel is approximately
7.85 g/cm3 (0.284 lb/in3) and the Young's modulus is 210,000 MPa
(30,000,000 psi). Low carbon steels suffer from yield-point runout where the
material has two yield points. The first yield point (or upper yield point) is
higher than the second and the yield drops dramatically after the upper yield
point. If a low carbon steel is only stressed to some point between the upper and
lower yield point then the surface may develop Lüder bands.
19
derivatives by weight loss, galvanostatic polarization, and potentiodynamic
anodic polarization techniques [42] . The explored methods gave almost similar
results. Results obtained reveal that inhibitor (I) is the best inhibitor and the
inhibition efficiency (IE%) follows the sequence I > II > III > IV. The
percentage inhibition efficiency was found to increase with increasing
concentration of inhibitors and decreases with increasing temperature of the
medium. The addition of KI, KSCN, and KBr to cyanoacetohydrazide
derivatives enhanced the inhibition efficiency due to synergistic effect. The
effect of temperature on C-steel corrosion in 2 M HCl and with the addition of
11 10-6 M of investigated compounds in the temperature range 30°-50°C was
studied. Some thermodynamic functions were computed and discussed. The
inhibitors are adsorbed on the carbon steel surface according to Temkin's
adsorption isotherm. Polarization data suggested that the additives used act as
mixed-type inhibitors. It was found that the cyanoacetohydrazide derivatives
provide good protection to carbon steel against pitting corrosion in chloride-
containing solutions.
20
follows Langmuir adsorption isotherm. The effect of temperature on the rate of
corrosion in the absence and presence of these compounds was also studied.
Some activated thermodynamic parameters were calculated.
In the first part of this study, the inhibitor effect of single, binary and
ternary mixture of chromate, molybdate, nitrite, tetraborate, ortophosphate,
benzoate, acetate, ascorbic acid on the corrosion of carbon steel was investigated
[46]. Experiments were carried out in neutral aqueous solution containing 100
ppm Cl- at room temperature. The current-potential curves were obtained by
potentiostatic (1mV/s) method and the corrosion rates were determined by the
extrapolation of the Tafel slope of the cathodic polarization curves method and
linear polarization method. In the second part, the inhibitor effect of some one
component, binary and ternary inhibitor blends was investigated depending on
the temperature (30, 40, 50 oC) and pH (5, 7, 9). The inhibitor effects were
found to be %95 for solutions containing 50 ppm nitrite. Of all inhibitor systems
tried, chromatemolibdate and chromate- nitrite- molibdate was found to be the
most effective binary and ternary inhibitor blends, the effectiveness of which is
equal to that of sodium chromate, sodium nitrite, sodium molibdate that alone
and used at a high level.
21
investigated [47]. The results show that the inhibition efficiency increases in
early stage and decreases for a long immersion time.
22
the LCS surface charged with a negative layer of chemisorbed I − ions. An
adherent layer of inhibitor is postulated to account for the protective effect. EDX
examinations of the electrode surface confirmed the existence of such adherent
layer on the electrode surface. The inhibition efficiency increases with increase
in the concentration of AD and immersion time. The potential of zero charge
(PZC) of the LCS electrode was determined in 4.0 M H2SO4 solutions in the
absence and presence of 0.001 M KI, and the mechanism of adsorption was
discussed. The results obtained from chemical and electrochemical
measurements were in good agreement.
23
Potentiodynamic polarisation, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy
and weight loss studies were carried out [53] on the inhibition of carbon steel in
1 M hydrochloric acid solution by three bipyrazolic compounds. The examined
inhibitors are 5,5′-dipropyl-1H,1′H-[3,3′]bipyrazolyl (Bp1), 5,5′-diphenyl-
1H,1′H-[3,3′]bipyrazolyl (Bp2) and 5,5′-bis-(4-chloro-phenyl)-1H,1′H-
[3,3′]bipyrazolyl (Bp3). All measurements show that inhibition efficiency
increases with increase in inhibitor concentration and the variation in inhibitive
efficiency mainly depends on the type and nature of the substituents present in
the inhibitor molecule to attain 98% for chloro derivative (Bp3) at 10 −3 M. This
reveals that inhibitive actions of bipyrazolic compounds were mainly due to
adsorption on steel surface. Adsorption of these inhibitors follows Langmuir
adsorption isotherm. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS)
measurements showed that the dissolution process of steel occurred under
activation control. The curves of polarisation indicated that the examined
inhibitors act primarily as cathodic inhibitors. From the adsorption isotherm,
thermodynamic data for the adsorption process (K, ) are calculated and
discussed. Some quantum parameters (highest occupied molecular orbital
(HOMO) energy, lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) energy and total
partial charge of inhibitors atoms) are computed.
24
medium. Thus, our findings showed that the antibacterial activity of ATMP is a
result of a combined effect of the pH solution and the chemical nature of the
used phosphonate molecule.
25
surface, and four different adsorption mechanisms may take place in different
regions of surfactant concentration.
26
The conductivity, weight loss and A.C. impedance studies were carried
out [61] to establish the influence the presence of neutral copolymer (Vinyl
pyrrodlidone/Vinyl acetate copolymer) with anionic surfactant (Disodium
laurethsulfosuccinate) in cyclohexane propionic acid (CHPA) on the corrosion
behaviour of carbon steel. The protection efficiency (P%) of AS in the absence
and presence of polymer increases with increase in AS concentration until it
reaches a maximum constant value near the CMC of AS and decreases with
increase in solution temperature. The protective efficiency of AS can be
enhanced and its critical micelle concentration shifts to low value by adding of
0.05 g/l of polymer. The critical micelle concentration of AS in the absence and
presence of polymer increases with increase in temperature. The calculated
thermodynamic parameters of micellization (ΔGmic), (ΔHmic) and (ΔSmic) in the
presence of neutral copolymer molecules with AS show that these processes are
spontaneous and exothermic in nature and indicate the association between AS
and neutral copolymer molecules.
27
type inhibitor with anodic predominance in case of pure iron and a mixed type
inhibitor in case of C-steels. The inhibition efficiency of PgTPhPBr increased
with increasing temperature up to 60 °C. Adsorption of the inhibitor was found
to follow the Langmuir’s isotherm. This inhibitor was more efficient for CS2
than for other samples at different temperatures. It was proposed that PgTPhPBr
decreases the corrosion rate through the reduction mechanism of metal
reactivity.
28
method and polarization and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS)
techniques. In order to study the effect of polyethylene glycols’ structure on the
inhibition efficiency, different molecular weights (400, 1000, 4000, and
10,000 g mol−1) were selected. This work has demonstrated that polyethylene
glycols have inhibition effect on corrosion process and their inhibition
efficiencies are between 50 and 90%. The inhibition efficiencies are increased
by increase of the inhibitors’ concentration and molecular weight.
29
and the interpretation of the results is given. These results are complemented
with quantum chemical study in order to provide an explanation of the
differences between the probed inhibitors. Correlation between the inhibition
efficiency and the structure of these compounds are presented.
30
indicated that the phosphonic acids tested inhibit the corrosion of carbon steel in
seawater. Potentiodynamic polarization curve shows clearly the fact that the
addition of these molecules is associated with corrosion current density decrease
and a corresponding reduction of the corrosion rate. The phosphonic acids tested
as corrosion inhibitors of carbon steel in natural seawater are effective even with
small concentration. Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy was used to obtain
information on bonding mechanism between the metallic surface and the
inhibitors. The morphology of the metal surface in the uninhibited and inhibited
solution was examined using the scanning electron microscope coupled with an
energy dispersive X-ray analysis system.
31
anodic reactions in both acidic media, by virtue of adsorption on the carbon steel
surface. This adsorption obeyed Langmuir's adsorption isotherm. In the both
media, 2-SH-BI showed the highest efficiency while the lowest efficiency was
observed for BI. The comparative analysis of the inhibitor adsorption in both the
media, as well as, the synergistic effect of bromide ions (Br −) in H2SO4 solution
suggests that the physical adsorption of the cationic form of BI and 2-CH3-BI
occurs, while 2-SH-BI is adsorbed chemically.
The effect of chloride and nitrite ions on the passivity of steel in alkaline
solutions was investigated [77]. Four nitrite dosages were tested, resulting in
various nitrite/chloride ratios. The behavior of steel was evaluated on electrodes
aged during 1 and 90 days, measuring electrochemical parameters such as the
corrosion, pitting and repassivation potentials, the corrosion current density, the
weight loss and performing electrochemical impedance spectra. The presence of
0.8 mol l−1 of chloride induced pitting only under polarization and when the
chloride/hydroxyl ratio was not less than one. Nitrite ions behave as effective
inhibitors of pit propagation for all the concentrations tested (0.2–0.8 mol l−1). A
nitrite/chloride ratio of 0.25 induces complete surface repassivation.
Nevertheless, at open circuit potential, the high alkalinity guarantees passivation
even in the presence of chlorides. In the event that the passive layer is damaged
and pitting can be initiated, nitrite ions are effective in inhibiting pit
propagation.
32
The effect of pH value on the adsorption behavior and inhibition
mechanism of dodecylamine for carbon dioxide corrosion of carbon steel was
investigated [79] by electrochemical methods and scanning electron microscopy
(SEM). The results indicated that the pH value of the solution played the crucial
role to the adsorption behavior and inhibition mechanism of dodecylamine. The
inhibition performance of dodecylamine on carbon steel was dependent on the
pH value and the inhibition efficiency increased with the increase of pH value.
At pH 4.9, dodecylamine mainly inhibited the cathode process of the corrosion.
The adsorption energy of dodecylamine on the metal surface was lower. The
adsorption of dodecylamine on the metal surface was not stable and an anode
desorption phenomenon could be observed. Hence, dodecylamine did not
provide effective inhibition to the corrosion. While at pH 6.9, it had much higher
adsorption energy. Dodecylamine adsorbed on the metal surface tightly and
formed the effective diffusion barrier which inhibited both the cathode and
anode processes effectively.
The role of water, acetic acid, chloride, and oxygen level in corrosion
and pitting behaviour of carbon steel in simulated fuel-grade ethanol (SFGE)
was investigated [81]. In the absence of the supporting electrolyte, modified cell
geometry enabled us to conduct the electrochemical measurement in low-
conductivity ethanolic solutions. Results have shown that the water in the SFGE
strongly influences the surface film stability and interface electrochemistry in
ethanolic environments. The increase in the water concentration induces pitting
and metal loss. Dissolved chlorides and higher acidity promote the pit initiation
and growth. Alkaline condition inhibits both localized and uniform corrosion.
33
HCl solution. The inhibition efficiencies of the tested inhibitors were depended
on the hydrophobic chain length and the used doses of the inhibitors. The
polarization measurements showed that these inhibitors are acting as mixed
inhibitors for both anodic and cathodic reactions. The results showed that the
inhibition efficiencies were increased by increasing the inhibitor doses and the
hydrophobic chain length and reached the maximum at 500 ppm by weight for
stearyl derivative. The efficiencies obtained from the impedance measurements
were in good agreement with those obtained from the gravimetrical and
polarization techniques which prove the validity of these tolls in the
measurements of the tested inhibitors.
34
interface was used and the values of the corresponding parameters were
calculated and discussed. The results obtained from weight loss and
electrochemical studies were in reasonable agreement. X-ray photoelectron
spectroscopy (XPS) was carried out to establish the mechanism of corrosion
inhibition of nitrided C38 steel in 1 M HCl medium. The enhancement of the
corrosion resistance is believed to be related to the iron nitride compound layer
formed on the C38 steel surface during plasma nitriding, which protected the
underlying metal from corrosive attack in the aggressive solutions.
35
presence of the salicylaldehyde and ethylenediamine mixture, showing that in
acid medium the Salen molecule undergoes hydrolysis, regenerating its
precursor molecules.
36
in marine site reaches a maximum during the period of transition and then
fluctuates in a certain range; however, the instantaneous corrosion velocity
follows different exponential functions before and after the period of transition.
37
The present work was designed to:
1. Investigate the inhibiting effect of some inhibitors towards the corrosion of
C- steel in 1 M HCl.
2. Determine the rate of corrosion of the C- steel, in the presence and absence
of these derivatives by weight- loss method (chemical method), and DC, AC
(electrochemical methods).
3. Study the effect of the temperature on the corrosion rate by one of the two
methods this enable us to:
(a) Calculate the thermodynamic parameters related to the corrosion process.
(b) Determine the kind of adsorption isotherm and the type of noidprosda
(physical or chemical).
38