Topic 2 - Problem Set
Topic 2 - Problem Set
The Rustic Welt Company is proposing to replace its old welt-making machinery with
more modern equipment. The new equipment costs $9 million (the existing equipment has
zero salvage value). The attraction of the new machinery is that it is expected to cut
manufacturing costs from their current level of $8 a welt to $4. However, as the following
table shows, there is some uncertainty both about future sales and about the performance
of the new machinery.
Conduct a sensitivity analysis of the replacement decision, assuming a discount rate of 12%
and enter the Equivalent Annual Cost Savings in the table below. Rustic Welt does not pay
taxes.
2. Dog Days is considering a proposal to produce and market a caviar-flavored dog food. It
will involve an initial investment of $90,000 that can be depreciated for tax straight-line
over 10 years. In each of years 1 to 10, the project is forecast to produce sales of $100,000
and to incur variable costs of 50% of sales and fixed costs of $30,000. The corporate tax rate
is 30%, and the cost of capital is 10%
a. Calculate the NPV and accounting break-even levels of fixed costs
b. Suppose that you are worried that the corporate tax rate will be increased immediately after
you commit to the project. Calculate the break-even rate of taxes.
c. How would a rise in the tax rate affect the accounting break-even point?
3. Modern Artifacts can produce keepsakes that will be sold for $110 each. Nondepreciation
fixed costs are $1,600 per year, and variable costs are $90 per unit. The initial investment of
$4,500 will be depreciated straight-line over its useful life of five years to a final value of
zero, and the discount rate is 10%.
a. What is the accounting break-even level of sales if the firm pays no taxes?
b. What is the NPV break-even level of sales if the firm pays no taxes?
c. What is the accounting break-even level of sales if the firm’s tax rate is 20%?
d. What is the NPV break-even level of sales if the firm’s tax rate is 20%?
4. Modern Artifacts can produce keepsakes that will be sold for $91 each. Nondepreciation
fixed costs are $1,000 per year, and variable costs are $68 per unit. The initial investment of
$4,100 will be depreciated straight-line over its useful life of five years to a final value of
zero, and the discount rate is 12%.
a. What is the degree of operating leverage of Modern Artifacts when sales are $7,735?
b. What is the degree of operating leverage when sales are $13,195?
5. In a slow year, Deutsche Burgers will produce 2 million hamburgers at a total cost of $3.5
million. In a good year, it can produce 4 million hamburgers at a total cost of $4.5 million.
a. What are the fixed costs of hamburger production?
b. What are the variable costs when the firm produces 2 million hamburgers?
c. What is the average cost per burger when the firm produces 1 million hamburgers?
d. What is the average cost when the firm produces 2 million hamburgers?
6. An auto plant that costs $100 million to build can produce hybrid cars. If successful, the
investment will produce cash flows with present value of $140 million. If unsuccessful, the
cash flows are only $50 million, in present value terms. The probability of success is 50%.
You only find out whether the plant is a success or failure after it is built.
a. Would you build the plant?
b. Suppose you could immediately sell the plant to another automaker for $95
million, if your line is unsuccessful. Does your decision change?
c. Illustrate the option to abandon in part (b) using a decision tree