Electrical Design Analysis For Commercial Building Sample
Electrical Design Analysis For Commercial Building Sample
This Electrical power distribution system design is governed by various codes and standard (PEC 2017, ANSI, NEMA
and IEC. The design of electrical system aims to satisfy the multiple realistic constraints. The electrical system shall be
economical, safe, environmental, maintainable, sustainable and reliable. In order to satisfy these constraints, there are
provisions from different codes and standards that are adopted in the design. The engineering software’s like AutoCAD,
Revit & Sketchup are used in order to improve the design of lighting layout, power layout and the shop drawing of lighting
fixture, panelboard and enclosed circuit breaker details, cable ladder, meter center, grounding system layout, and electrical
Load Characteristics
The electric power distribution system in a building exists solely to serve the loads- the electrical utilization devices. The
power distribution system should accomplish that assignment safely and economically, provide sufficient reliability to
adequately satisfy the requirements of the building (and its users), and incorporate sufficient flexibility to accommodate
changing loads during the life of the building. In this design, the IEEE 241-1990: IEEE Recommended Practice for Electric
Power Systems in Commercial Building intended to provide typical load data and a suggested method for determining
individual and total connected and total demand load characteristics of a commercial building.
2
Full load current calculation
In Load current calculation, the designers determined the classification of the circuit according to its phase. Upon
determining this classification of the circuit, We are able to design the number of conductors to be used in a circuit and can
choose the best size of the conductor under the provision of PEC 2017 Table PEC 2017 Table 3.10.2.6(B)(16) Ampacities
for Conductor rated 0-2000 Volts: Adjustment Factors: More than three Current Carrying Conductors in a raceway, PEC
2017 Table 2.50.6.13 - Minimum Size Equipment Grounding Conductor, which depends upon the total load calculated for
each circuit.
I = ; Single Phase
I = ; Three Phase
√
I = I ∗ 125%
The sizing of overcurrent protective device is based from PEC 2017 Table 2.40.1.6(A) Standard ampere rating; fuses and
fixed trip circuit breaker and PEC 2017 section 210.20(a) Overcurrent protection- continuous and non-continuous load.
The branch-circuit overcurrent protection device must be sized not less than 125%
The Feeder-circuit overcurrent protection device must be sized not less than 125%
I =I + 1.25I
I = I ∗ 125%
3
Size of Overcurrent protective device and size of conductor for Motor & Equipment Load
The technique in sizing the conductors and overcurrent protection for motor loads is different from the non-motor loads. In
contrast with non-motor loads, motor loads have two levels of protection; thermal overload protection and fault protection. In
case of overloading of motors, the thermal overload relay will be able to sense the limiting temperature of the overload
current that triggers the relay to cut-off the circuit. In case of fault, the overcurrent protective devices will automatically cut-
off the circuit providing its proper sizing of Ampere Interrupting Capacity. (AIC).
According to PEC 2017 Section 4.30.2.2 Single Motor. Conductors that supply a single motor used in a continuous duty
application shall have an ampacity of not less than 125 percent of the motor’s full-load current rating, as determined by
4.30.1.6(a)(1), or not less than spacified in 4.30.2.2(A) through (G). And based from PEC 2017 Table 4.30.4.2 Inverse time
Delay circuit breaker shall have an ampacity of maximum 250% of motor full load current rating.
I = 125% x I
I = 250% x I
The selection of conduit size is determined by the number of conductors that it contains based from PEC 2017 Table C1:
Maximum Number of Conductors and Fixture Conductors in Electrical Metallic Tubing, PEC 2017 Table C10: Maximum
Number of Conductors and Fixture Conductors in Rigid PVC conduit, schedule 40 and HDPE conduit and PEC 2017 Table
C4 (A): Maximum Number of Compact Conductors in Intermediate Metal Conduit (based on table 9.1.1.1)
4
Electrical Load Schedule
The following table shows the electrical load schedule of the building.
SYSTEM 400V, 3φ, 3W+N, 60Hz
Panel: MAIN CIRCUIT BREAKER - METER CENTER
ENCLOSURE NEMA-1, WALL MOUNTED
CKT VOLTAGE VOLT AMPERES PROTECTION SIZE OF
LOAD DESCRIPTION WIRE
NO. V AN BN CN AT AF POLE CONDUIT
1 MDP-ADMIN 400 42,480 42,870 42,510 200 250 4 4 - 100 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 14 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 90 mmφ PVC
3 LPPK (KABAYAN) 400 6,980 7,980 9,190 50 50 4 4 - 8.0 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
4 LPP1 400 24,620 125 125 2 2 - 38 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 14.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
5 LPP8 400 24,620 125 125 2 2 - 38 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 14.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
6 LPP16 400 24,620 125 125 2 2 - 38 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 14.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
7 LPP23 400 24,620 125 125 2 2 - 38 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 14.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
8 LPP15 400 24,620 125 125 2 2 - 38 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 14.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
8 LPP2 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
9 LPP3 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
10 LPP4 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
11 LPP5 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
12 LPP6 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 2 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
13 LPP9 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
14 LPP10 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
15 LPP11 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
16 LPP12 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
17 LPP13 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
18 LPP14 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 2 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
19 LPP17 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
20 LPP18 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
21 LPP19 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
22 LPP20 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
23 LPP21 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
24 LPP22 400 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22 mm² THHN/THWN + 2 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
TOTAL 400 186,840 173,540 164,460 800 800 4 4 SETS OF 4 - 100mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 50mm² (G) THHN/THWN 90 mmφ PVC
5
SYSTEM 400V, 3φ, 3W+N, 60Hz
Panel: LPPK (KABAYAN)
ENCLOSURE NEMA-1, WALL MOUNTED
CKT VOLTAGE VOLT AMPERES PROTECTION SIZE OF
LOAD DESCRIPTION WIRE
NO. V AN BN CN AT AF POLE CONDUIT
1 39 - 30 VA LED LIGHTS 230 1170 16 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
2 24 - 30 VA LED LIGHTS 230 720 16 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
3 14 - 180 VA CONVENIENCE OUTLETS 230 2520 20 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
4 14 - 180 VA CONVENIENCE OUTLETS 230 2520 20 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
5 8 - 180 VA CONVENIENCE OUTLETS 230 1440 20 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
6 1 - 2,660 VA 2.5HP WINDOW TYPE ACU 230 2660 32 50 1 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
7 1 2,000 VA SPARE 230 2000 20 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
8 1 - 3,090 VA 4HP SPLIT TYPE ACU 230 3090 32 50 1 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
9 1 - 940 VA 1HP WINDOW TYPE ACU 230 940 32 50 1 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
10 1 - 2,000 VA SPARE 230 2000 20 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
11 1 - 2,000 VA SPARE 230 2000 20 50 1 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
12 1 - 3,090 VA 4HP SPLIT TYPE ACU 230 3090 32 50 1 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
TOTAL 400 6,980 7,980 9,190 50 50 3 4 - 8.0 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
6
TYPICAL TO: LPP2, LPP3, LPP4, LPP5, LPP6, LPP9, LPP10, LPP11, LPP12, LPP13, LPP14, SYSTEM 230V, 1φ, 3W, 60Hz
Panel:
LPP17, LPP18, LPP19, LPP20, LPP21, LPP22 ENCLOSURE NEMA-1, WALL MOUNTED
CKT VOLTAGE VOLT AMPERES PROTECTION SIZE OF
LOAD DESCRIPTION WIRE
NO. V VA AT AF POLE CONDUIT
1 17 - 30 VA LED LIGHTS 230 510 16 50 2 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
2 6 - 180 VA CONVENIENCE OUTLETS 230 1,080 20 50 2 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
3 1 - 1,000 VA REFRIGERATOR 230 1,000 20 50 2 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
4 1 - 3,000 VA ELECTRIC RANGE 230 3,000 32 50 2 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
5 1 - 2,050 VA 3HP SPLIT TYPE ACU 230 2,050 32 50 2 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
6 1 - 2,050 VA 3HP SPLIT TYPE ACU 230 2,050 32 50 2 2 - 5.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 5.5 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 32 mmφ PVC
7 1 - 2,500 VA SPARE 230 2,500 20 50 2 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
8 1 - 2,500 VA SPARE 230 2,500 20 50 2 2 - 3.5 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 2.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 20 mmφ PVC
TOTAL 230 14,690 80 100 2 2 - 22.0 mm² THHN/THWN + 1 - 8.0 mm² (G) THHN/THWN 40 mmφ PVC
7
Voltage Drop and Voltage Regulation
The calculation of voltage drop and voltage regulation of the electrical design is based on the measurement of the length of
the conductors at the architectural layouts and the impedances of the conductor is determined by its corresponding
resistance and reactances that refered to PEC 2017 Table 10.1.1.9 Alternating-Current Resistance and Reactance for 600-
The formula for the voltage drop is length times the impedance with a multiplier factor of 1.732 which is obtained because
the system is wye connected. The impedance depends upon the type of circuit per 1000ft constant value, different nominal
voltage are used as a divisor in these computation with respect to the number of its phase. The calculations made for the
voltage drop and voltage regulation is referred in PEC 2017, Voltage Drop Calculation.
The following provisions of the Philippine Electrical Code (PEC) are stated below PEC 2009 Article 2.10.2.2 FPN No. 4
Conductors for branch circuits as defined in Article 1.0, sized to prevent a voltage drop exceeding 3 percent at the farthest
outlet of power, heating, and lighting loads, or combinations of such loads, and where the maximum total voltage drop on
both feeders and branch circuits to the farthest outlet does not exceed 5 percent, provide reasonable efficiency of operation.
PEC 2017 Article 2.15.1.2 FPN No. 2 Conductors for feeders as defined in Article 1.1, sized to prevent a voltage drop
exceeding 3 percent at the farthest outlet of power, heating, and lighting loads, or combinations of such loads, and where
the maximum total voltage drop on both feeders and branch circuits to the farthest outlet does not exceed 5 percent, provide
𝑉 = 𝑉 − 𝑉o𝑙𝑡𝑎𝑔𝑒 𝐷𝑟𝑜𝑝
8
Voltage Drop Schedule
The following table shows the voltage drop schedule of the building.
Meter Center LPPK 400 19.32 27.89 THHN 8 1 77 0.78 0.065 0.8 8.084469836 2.02% 391.916
Meter Center LPP2 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 37 0.31 0.06 0.8 3.520741725 1.53% 226.479
Meter Center LPP3 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 42 0.31 0.06 0.8 3.996517634 1.74% 226.003
Meter Center LPP4 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 47 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.472293542 1.94% 225.528
Meter Center LPP5 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 52 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.948069451 2.15% 225.052
Meter Center LPP6 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 56 0.31 0.06 0.8 5.328690178 2.32% 224.671
Meter Center LPP8 230 24.62 85.63 THHN 38 1 37 0.16 0.057 0.8 3.370023504 1.47% 226.630
Meter Center LPP9 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 42 0.31 0.06 0.8 3.996517634 1.74% 226.003
Meter Center LPP10 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 47 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.472293542 1.94% 225.528
Meter Center LPP11 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 52 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.948069451 2.15% 225.052
Meter Center LPP12 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 57 0.31 0.06 0.8 5.42384536 2.36% 224.576
Meter Center LPP13 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 61 0.31 0.06 0.8 5.804466087 2.52% 224.196
Meter Center LPP14 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 42 0.31 0.06 0.8 3.996517634 1.74% 226.003
Meter Center LPP15 230 24.62 85.63 THHN 38 1 52 0.16 0.057 0.8 4.736249249 2.06% 225.264
Meter Center LPP16 230 24.62 85.63 THHN 38 1 42 0.16 0.057 0.8 3.825432086 1.66% 226.175
Meter Center LPP17 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 47 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.472293542 1.94% 225.528
Meter Center LPP18 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 52 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.948069451 2.15% 225.052
Meter Center LPP19 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 57 0.31 0.06 0.8 5.42384536 2.36% 224.576
Meter Center LPP20 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 62 0.31 0.06 0.8 5.899621269 2.57% 224.100
Meter Center LPP21 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 66 0.31 0.06 0.8 6.280241996 2.73% 223.720
Meter Center LPP22 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 47 0.31 0.06 0.8 4.472293542 1.94% 225.528
Meter Center LPP23 230 24.62 85.63 THHN 38 1 57 0.16 0.057 0.8 5.19165783 2.26% 224.808
Meter Center LPP24 230 14.69 51.10 THHN 22 1 57 0.31 0.06 0.8 5.42384536 2.36% 224.576
9
Fault Analysis
A significant part of the preparation for a short-circuit current calculation is establishing the impedance of each circuit
element and converting impedances to be consistent with each other for combination in series and parallel. Sources of
impedance values for circuit elements are nameplates, handbooks, manufacturers’ catalogs, Two established consistent
forms for expressing impedances are ohms and per unit (per unit differs from percent by a factor of 100). Individual equipment
impedances are often given in percent, which makes comparisons easy, but percent impedances are rarely used without
conversion in system calculations. In this chapter, the per unit form of impedance is used because it is more convenient than
the ohmic form when the system contains several voltage levels. Impedances expressed as per unit on a defined base can
be combined directly, regardless of how many voltage levels exist from source to fault. To obtain this convenience, the base
voltage at each voltage level must be related according to the turns ratios of the interconnecting transformers. In the per-unit
system, there are four base quantities: base apparent power in volt-amperes, base voltage, base current ,and base
impedance. The relationship of base, per unit, and actual quantities is as follows:
actual quantity
per unit quantity (voltage, current, etc) =
base quantity
Usually a convenient value is selected for base apparent power in volt-amperes, and a base
voltage at one level is selected to match the transformer rated voltage at that level. Base volt-
ages at other levels are then established by transformer turns ratios. Base current and base
impedance at each level are then obtained by standard relationships. The following formulas
apply to three-phase systems, where the base voltage is the line-to-line voltage in volts or
kilovolts and the base apparent power is the three-phase apparent power in kilo-voltamperes or
mega-voltamperes:
10
(base V) (1000)
base impedance (ohms) =
(base MVA)
Impedances of individual power system elements are usually obtained in forms that require conversion to the related bases
for a per-unit calculation. Cable impedances are generally expressed in ohms. Converting to per unit using the indicated
relationships leads to the following simplified formulas, where the per-unit impedance is Zpu:
Transformer impedances are in percent of self-cooled transformer ratings in kilo-voltamperes and are converted using the
following:
Motor reactance may be obtained from tables providing per unit reactances on element ratings in kilovolt amperes and are
11
Single Line Diagram
100
𝑍𝑢 = = 0.20 𝑝𝑢
500
12
𝑋𝑢 = sin(87.13°) × 0.20 = 𝑗0.199 𝑝𝑢
𝑍𝑢 = 0.01 + 𝑗0.199 𝑝𝑢
4.12 100
𝑍𝑡 = = 8.24 𝑝𝑢
100 0.5
𝑍𝑡 = 2.07 + 𝑗7.97 𝑝𝑢
𝑅𝑐 = 2.07 × 10 Ω
𝑚 × 10𝑚 × 4 = 0.00828Ω
𝑋𝑐 = 1.67 × 10 Ω
𝑚 × 10𝑚 × 4 = 0.00668Ω
Convert to p.u.
0.00828
𝑅𝑐 = × 100 = 5.175 𝑝𝑢
0. 400
0.00668
𝑅𝑐 = × 100 = 4.175 𝑝𝑢
0. 400
𝑍𝑐 = 5.175 + 𝑗4.175 𝑝𝑢
13
Impedance Diagram
𝑍 =𝑍 + 𝑍 +𝑍
𝑍 = 7.255 + 𝑗12.344 𝑝𝑢
𝑍 = 14.303∠59.66 𝑝𝑢
100 × 10 1∠0
𝐼 ( ∅) = ×
400 × 1.732 14.303
14