Supervisory Development Program
Supervisory Development Program
Supervisory Development Program
Table of Contents
2.2 Responsibilities 04
3.1.5 Discipline 37
This seminar is desined to help you to better understand the tasks and
responsibilities of a supervisor and give you ideas how to improve your
supervisory skills.
Hopefully the outcome of the seminar will enable you to transfer your new
knowledge into your company and thus enhance the productivity and quality.
Sabine Schacknat
Supervisory Development Program Particulars about Supervision
Just imagine:
Until a few weeks ago you were a normal worker in the production line and you received your
orders from your boss or a supervisor. They gave you instructions of what to do and how do to
it and you were doing it. Two weeks ago the production manager of your company talked to
you and offered you a job to be a supervisor yourself. You happily agreed because it means
some Pesos more every day and you do not have to do all the dirty work yourself anymore.
Last Monday you started your new assignment and you suddenly realize that this new job is
not so easy after all. Before you had to deal only with the work itself but now you have to tell
other people what they have to do!
You wonder what is going wrong because you actually thought that you were a skilled
wood worker!
Actually there is a big difference between the two jobs and you have to recognize what these
differences are.
And you have to learn some new skills before you are really able to do your new job
properly.
As a follower you received your orders from the supervisor or the middle management and
you were following these orders. Sometimes they would ask you for a statement about some
problems and you had to report to them.
Your main task was to function as a worker and to do what you were told. The skills you had
to provide were mainly technical, on how to run a machine and to use tools. Most of the labor
was physical, like planing a piece of wood, the dimensions of the final product were given to
you and you had to do it according to the order.
In the new position as a supervisor you will find a completely different situation to handle:
You have to receive orders from the management and give reports to them.
and
You have to give orders to the workers and receive reports from them.
Now it should be easy to understand that most of your work as a supervisor will be more
mental and not so much physical.
1.2 Responsibilities
If we have a closer look at the organizational structure we can see that a supervisor has a lot
of different responsibilities in his work life:
To maintain work discipline and morale in the section he needs to have a natural authority
which has to be based on knowledge and skills. To make the section an efficient one he has
to make production decisions such as:
Î
Which job has priority?
Î
When do we start with the next order?
Î
Which worker will be assigned at which machine?
Î
Will the machine work more efficient if you assign two workers?
At the same time the management expects from the supervisor that he will maintain a proper
cost control (Material waste, proper production flow, unproductive workers). In order to
improve the productivity of the section the management expects written comments and
suggestions about the situation.
The target is to create a trusting working climate were the workers will be able to talk openly
about problems in meetings. The treatment of all workers has to be equally. The workers
problems have to be handled correctly, a good relationship with the personnel / staff
department has to be established because they can help in all sorts of explanations and
problems like workers payment and benefits. Sometimes the supervisor might have to take
over the role of a counselor but he has to be careful that he does not get involved personally
into the problems, it is very important that he will stay objective in all department matters. The
workers will be efficient if the supervisor provide them with a predictible and stable work load.
The main purpose of supervision is to determine whether the individual who is responsible for
the action understands the information and the directions that were given to him previously,
and whether he is following them satisfactorily. The executive seeks
to learn where further advice and instruction are needed by the
subordinate. Another chief importance of supervision is that it can Subordinates who have
catch deviations of actual from planned results at a time when been properly selected
corrective action may be taken immediately. The executive, however, and indoctrinated need
should remember several things about supervision. Many subordinates less supervision
do not ordinarily like close supervision. As a matter of record,
successful managers do not over-supervise. Subordinates who
have been properly selected and indoctrinated need less supervision than a group seeking a
complex of objectives, the significance of which they do not understand.
Î Directing
Î Guiding
Î Leading
Create an atmosphere Directing, guiding, and leading are three key words that
sum up the whole spectrum of supervision. Directing is a
where workers perform
verbal or written function. It is telling subordinates what
their assignments
they have to do and how they are to do it. As a function
because they want to of order-giving, it may range from a simple request to an
perform. authoritative command. The secret of effective leadership is
not ordering people, but creating an
atmosphere where they perform their assignments because they want to The supervisor must
perform them. Exhibiting their leadership qualities, supervisors are able know what is going on,
to guide and lead their subordinates grow and develop into capable and who is doing what, and
reliable workers and employees of which every organization would have
what the working
reason to be proud of. To be able to direct, guide, and lead, in line with
the function of a supervisor of "watching over", he must know what is conditions are.
going on, who is doing what, and what the working conditions are.
3.1 3.2
Interaction Skills Analysis Skills Technical Skills
3.1.5 Discipline
3.1.6 Rewarding
performance
Good communication is the lifeblood of organizations. It takes many forms, such as speaking,
writing, and listening, though its purpose is always to convey a message to recipients. Use it
to handle information and improve relationships.
Effective communication hinges on people understanding your meaning, and replying in terms
that move the exchange forward – preferably in the direction you would like it to go.
Communicating is always a two-way process. There are always at least two parties involved in
any communication, each of whom may have different wants, needs, and attitudes.
Barriers
Communicator/Speaker Recipient/Listener
These wants and needs can present barriers if they conflict with those of the other party, and
such barriers may stop you conveying or receiving the right message. Breaking down barriers
is one of the first steps towards good communication.
The three rules that govern good communication are all associated with clarity:
Be clear in your own mind about what you want to say
Deliver the message properly
Ensure that the message has been correctly understood
Good communication means saying what you mean – and fully comprehending any feedback.
Your body language – a huge range of unconscious physical movements such as posture,
facial expression, and gestures – can either strengthen communication or damage it. Even if
you are sitting completely still, you may be unknowingly communicating a powerful message
about your real feelings. Because of its subtlety and range, body language is difficult to read
and to control. However, a broad understanding of body language is one route to
understanding the real opinions of others.
Conquering Nerves
The nervousness people feel before making a presentation or attending a meeting is very
natural. Use body language to appear more confident than you feel by making a conscious
effort to smile and to relax your arms. Look people in the eye while you are talking or listening
to them, keep your posture comfortably straight, and do not fiddle with your hands.
Supportive gestures
Supportive gestures such as making eye contact and nodding while somebody is talking,
create empathy – unless the person to whom you are speaking can tell that you are
concealing your true feelings. Everyone can control their body language to an extent, but not
totally. To avoid that the body language is contradicting you, try to be as honest as possible
and show always respect to the one you are talking to.
Recognizing Gestures
All skilled public speakers use
gestures for emphasis.
Devices like smacking your fist
into an open palm, pointing, or
spreading your palms can all
reinforce points you make
verbally. Remember that over-
assertive gestures, such as
banging a table, or other signs
of anger, can alienate people.
Practise a range of
gestures in front of a
mirror to find those
that look natural for
you.
The two-way nature of communication – so that both sides understand each other – is widely
ignored. Listening techniques are vital, since how you listen conveys meaning to the other
person and helps to make the exchange successful.
Showing Attentiveness
When you are in search of information, consensus, or a working relationship, the more
obviously you listen attentively the better. You may need to speak to get a respons, but show
you do not wish to dominate the conversation. Ask open questions, which lead to discussion,
and keep your responses brief. Repeat key words silently as you hear them to help you to
remember what is said.
If you are taking notes while people are speaking, do not try to write their
words in longhand and in sequences or you will fail to keep up. Instead,
listen to what is being said and note down the key points in your own
words. Try writing a succinct explanation of each point, and use headings
and numbers to structure your notes.
Interpreting Dialogue
Take statements at face value without reading hidden meanings
into what is being said. Test your understanding by rephrasing Keep an open mind
statements and repeating them to the speaker. It should then be about what people
clear that you have understood each other – or they may correct say.
you and clarify their statement. However, watch for physical signs,
such as evasive eye contact, and verbal signs, such as hesitation or contradiction, that
provide clues to the thruthfulness of the message. Be careful not to hear only what you
want to hear and nothing else.
Recognizing Prejudice
When what you see or hear only fulfils your own expectations you
probably have an inflexible mind-set. Most people have this Think about the
problem and are unconsciously influenced by stereotypical views. words you hear, not
We are also influenced by others, and often adopt their opinions the person saying
without thinking. Prejudices block good communication. If you them.
can recognize your prejudiced ideas, you will be a better listener. A
frequent mistake is to assume that you know what somenoe is going to say, and not to listen
to the actual message. However, people do not always behave according to stereotype or
expectation. Listen very carefully to what people are saying to you and do not let your
prejudices get in the way.
Choosing questions
When preparing questions in advance, always look at the type of
question that best meets your aims. You may want to initiate a Ask a specific question
discussion, obtain specific information, attain aparticular end, or send if you want to hear a
a command cloaked as a query. However, be aware that prepared specific answer
questions will rarely be enough – answers to them may be incomplete or
may prompt a whole new line of questioning. Keep asking questions until you are satisfied that
you have received the answers you require. When asking prepared questions, watch out for
clues in the answers that you can follow up later with a new set of questions.
Being Understood
Delivering a message that may be misunderstood is all too easy. It may happen because you
are not clear about what you want to say; or because your language is vague even though
your objectives are clear; or your body language contradicts your verbal message. A useful
way to avoid misinterpretation is to get the recipients to repeat your message – you can
then use their feedback to try to correct any misapprehensions. Use positive body language to
emphasize your verbal message.
Giving Feedback
Feedback is essential to communication – to check that you have understood the other
person's message, and to react to what they have said and done. It is vital that you react
honestly to the statements or actions of your employees or staff members. Give reasons for
positive feedback, and use questions when giving negative feedback. It can be difficult to give
negative feedback, but remember that it is bad management to avoid doing this. When giving
negative feedback, follow these simple rules to avoid any antagonism:
"I especially like how you found a solution for using an existing cutter block in producing the
item."
When you were a worker you received your orders from a supervisor and now you receive
them from somebody from the middle management. What is the difference between the two?
x As a worker you normally received an instruction for one job and when that was finished
you got the next one. The communication was pretty easy because you and the
supervisor spoke the same “technical language” and he could even help you with some
complicated setups or jigs.
x Now you have to communicate with somebody from the middle management and you
might have problems understanding him. What is wrong? The fact is that you and him are
not speaking the same “language” anymore because you are a ”technician” and he is a
“manager”. You have to learn to follow his instructions even so his technical knowledge
might be limited. Apart from that you will not only receive one single instruction, but most
probably orders for the whole day.
Receiving Orders
You have to translate the instructions you received from the middle
management into technical language and distribute the different jobs to your
workers. It is very important to write down the instructions you receive
because there might be many of them and you might forget some details.
With the help of these written notes you can break down the work into small
steps, decide what machinery you want to use and which worker would be
the right one to choose. You have to prepare a time schedule for the work and compare it with
the ongoing processes in the workshop so that you will know which machine and which worker
is available when. Than you can make a plan for the day(s) and you will be able to formulate
proper instructions to your workers.
Giving Orders
It is very important that you know the technical details of the process you
want to explain to somebody else. All the processes of the work should be
easy for you to explain. If you are not certain in a specific area you have to
familiarize more with the machine and the process before you start
explaining things to somebody else. In order to give good instructions you
have to plan them. Before you give instructions, take a piece of paper and
write down keywords for the processes you want to explain.
You have to be able to demonstrate the work process, this will support your explanations very
much. Think about safety aspects before you make a demonstration because you have to
consider that the worker will copy your action later on.
You can only be self confident and have some authority if you learn and practice the above
mentioned factors. The workers will only accept you as a supervisor if you have authority
based on knowledge.
Reports are formal documents that will be read by others. They must always be accurate and
well laid out, finishing with a definete conclusion.
Researching a report
If you are reporting on an activity of your own, check every fact to ensure acccuracy. If you
have been asked to report on a subject – say, a new market for a product – write down what
you need to know as a series of points. Then note the sources you can tap and match them to
the points, making sure everything is covered. Before finalizing, get information supplied by
one source confirmed by at least one other reliable authority.
Structuring a report
Write the purpose of a report and summarize its main conclusions in your opening
paragraphs. In the body of the report, support your findings with evidence, set down in logical
sequences, in numbered paragraphs. Use headings, subheadings, and bullet points, all of
which are effective structural aids, drawing attention to key facts. Use underlining and bold
type for emphasis. End the report with recommendations for action in summary form.
Ensuring clarity
Reports are not works of literature, but good ones follow the rules of
good writing. Avoid ambiguities. If you are unsure about your Be ruthless:
conclusions, state the alternatives and invite the readers to make Cut out all
up their own minds. Express yourself in short sentences. Above all, unnecessary words
put yourself in the readers' shoes. Will they understand what you in your report.
mean? If you can, get a friend or colleague to read the report before
you distribute it.
DO'S DONT'S
Do make each report interesting. Don't write long, unbroken paragraphs.
Do emphasize your most important Don't overuse the first person singular (I)
findings and facts. or allow your personal prejudices to show.
Do use numbered paragraphs to make Don't draw conclusions from insufficient
cross-referencing easier and to keep evidence.
points separate. Don't print your report without thoroughly
Do use headings for changes of subject checking your sources.
and sub-headings for related themes.
Explaining Delegation
Delegation involves intrusting another person with a task for which the Delegate to boost staff
delegator remains ultimately responsible. Delegation can range from
morale, build
a major appointment, such as the leadership of a team developing a
new product, to one of any number of smaller tasks in the everyday confidence, and reduce
life of any organization – from arranging an annual outing to stress.
interviewing a job candidate.
Am I devoting enough time and resources to strategic planning and overall monitoring?
Is my desk overflowing with uncompleted tasks?
Am I delegating routine but necessary tasks to staff?
Is staff training given priority to ensure effective skills for future delegation plans?
Doing it yourself
As a supervisor, you will probably be more efficient at many tasks Avoid keeping work
than your staff. But if you attempt to do everything because you are
quicker, surer, and more proficient you will inevitably find yourself
because you do it
overburdened. As a result you will not have sufficient time to spend better
on the higher-level tasks that only you can do.
Overburdening staff
The fear of overburdening staff is a strong barrier to delegation – it is natural for good
supervisors to want to ensure that staff workloads are not excessive. If staff members appear
to be working to full capacity, how can you delegate tasks without overburdening them? One
solution is to keep back tasks and find time to do them yourself. A more sensible approach is
to make employees analyze their own use of time and free capacity for more work. If staff
shortage is truly the problem, the answer is to take on more staff.
If the answers are positive, then there is nothing to fear, and the delegation should succeed.
Once you have overcome your initial fears, your efficiency as a delegator and supervisor will
be greatly increased.
Uses schedules
when planning.
Being to busy
Some supervisors do not delegate enough because they lack the time to
explain or monitor the tasks which should be delegated. Therefore, they are If you often say
always busy doing the tasks that should have been delegated and they don't "I don't have time",
have time to delegate tasks – a vicious circle. Organize your schedule to you are badly
ensure that you have enough time available to plan and manage a organized.
delegation properly, including writing an effective brief and the actual
monitoring of your delegates.
Lacking trust
If both sides in the delegation process do not trust each other, the process will be hindered. A
manager must have complete confidence in a delegate's ability to perform the task, and
delegates should feel that their supervisors are consistent and fair in their approach.
Subordinates must feel assured about their supervisors integrity, competence and loyalty. On
both sides, trust is conditional. Maintain trust by showing respect to your delegate and by
giving honest and constructive feedback during the delegation.
Use this breakdown as a basis for reducing any unnecessary activities, delegating more tasks,
and concentrating on tasks that only you can complete.
Where delegation seems to be necessary it has to be cleared with your own supervisor.
Prioritizing tasks
Having decided which tasks to delegate, your first concern is to allocate these tasks. Then
prioritize the tasks you have decided to handle yourself according to their importance and
urgency. Start each day by listing these tasks and tackle them one by one in order to priority. If
circumstances allow, always complete a task before starting a new one. The closer you keep to
this system, to more effective you will be.
Setting up a structure
When setting up a structure, your priority will be to ensure that the organizational framework is
balanced and responsive to any of the inevitable changes that can
occur. Do this by ensuring that each delegate has sufficient support Ensure to provide
and back-up when unforseen problems arise and that, as far as enough support and
possible, adequate cover will always be made available in any back-up to each
absence. Inform each delegate of the support structure you have delegate.
devised so that each knows where they can go to seek assistance
immediately in a crisis.
Avoiding duplication
When planning a structure, delegating, and distributing tasks, avoid giving the same task to
more than one person. To prevent confusion, create a chart with all key activities listed on the
left-hand side, and the names of those with delegated resposibility along the bottom line. Tick
off each box in the chart with both a task and a delegate to reveal any gaps or overlaps in the
distribution and structure of the tasks.
Setting guidelines
Delegation operates within guidelines, and the most important of
these is an understanding that each delegate will be accountable Make clear to
for a specific task. It follows that you must define the tasks very delegates the areas
clearly, and the delegate must confirm that they fully understand for which they are
what the task involves. However clear the delegation, and however accountable.
much you wish to avoid interference, there are likely be occasions
when the delegate does not know what to do. The guideline here is: when really in doubt, ask.
Appointing Sub-Leaders
Create a production team and involve them actively in the planning and decision making. Give
them some responsibilities in the production and you can concentrate more on the
management of the production. It is a little bit like having your “own company”, now you are in
the higher management and you have your own “sub-leaders” as supervisors supporting you
in the day to day activities. By creating such an internal department structure you can solve
some of the problems related to motivation: By delegating work and responsibilities to your
group leaders they feel treated as individuals and they can implement some of their ideas, in
the end they feel that their work is meaningful.
x Try to work down with this system to the workers who do not have a lot of self motivation
x Try to get them involved in the system in small steps
x Make notes of their performance, set regular individual meetings to discuss their
improvement or the lack of it
x If you see potential in a worker but he lacks certain skills, give him some individual
attendance or send him to some training courses outside.
x Sharing authority does not mean giving it away. You as a supervisor always remain
ultimately responsible.
Supervisor
Things to do:
Structuring a brief
Briefing sessions
The supervisor's task primary at the briefing is to communicate effectively and ensure the
delegate's full understanding of the assignment: Explain the task objective clearly and state
your expectations in terms of deadlines and levels of measured achievement. Be clear about
which areas of the brief are flexible and which must be followed to the letter
Ending a briefing
Draw the briefing session to a conclusion by summarizing the key points of the delegation.
End the meeting by thanking your delegate for taking on the task and communicate your
confidence that the assignment will be carried out successfully – it is important to emphasize
that you have appointed this delegate because you trust his or her abilities. Finally, establish a
date for a follow-up meeting to review progress
Reviewing progress
Once a task is underway, you will need to review its progress and the performance of the
delegate. There are a number of ways in which you can keep tabs on proceedings, including
face-to face discussions with the delegate, written reports, and personal observations.
Choose a system that suits you, is appropriate to the task, and gives you all the informantion
you need to review what has been achieved so far. It must also enable you to check that you
are on course to achieve the objective and pinpoint any corrective action that may be required.
Avoiding interference
Supervisors who can maintain a distance between themselves and
their delegates are more likely to see positive results. Nobody will Operate on the
work in exactly the same way as you, so resist the temptation to assumption that
intervene the moment you suspect the task is not being performed every process can
your way. Instead, set up a system of regular checks, meetings, and be improved.
reports, wether formal or informal, to ensure that the task objectives
are being met. Heavy intervention, in which the delegator makes all the decisions, will frustrate
the delegate and deny him or her the chance to gain experience.
DO'S DONT'S
Do encourage all delegates to make their Don't say or hint that you doubt the
own decisions. delegate's ability.
Do move from hands-on to hands-off as Don't miss any stage in the briefing
soon as possible. process.
Do intervene when absolutely necessary, Don't place seniority above ability.
but only at that time. Don't deny a delegate the chance to learn
Do ask delegates if they feel thoroughly by interfering to much.
prepared for their task. Don't take back a task without a good
reason.
Questioning yourself
If a delegated task has not been performed to your satisfaction, look first
at your own actions. Perhaps you should have kept this particular task to Deal with any
yourself, or been more selective when choosing a delegate. Go over the known difficulties
brief to find out if you could have made it clearer, and examine your at once.
monitoring procedures to be sure that they were adequate for the task.
Maybe you made yourself too remote, or did not provide sufficient guidance when problems
arose. Be as objective as possible in this self-examination so that you can identify and deal
with your own weakness.
Looking at Performance
Results alone will not necessarily tell you all you need to know about the performance of a
task. More accurate indicators can be gathered from your feedback sessions with your
delegate, and other personal observations. However, remember that you cannot maintain a
delegate's trust if you make inquiries behind his or her back. Be open about seeking relevant
information from trusted colleagues and inviting comments from those who are affected by the
delegation. If any defects come to light, it is your responsibility to take steps to improve the
delegate's performance.
Opening a Meeting
After making any necessary introductions, remind all those present of the meeting's purpose,
what outcome it is expected to deliver, and when it will end. If there are ground rules, state
them straight away. Check that everybody has any relevant papers and that the agenda is
approved. If there has been a previous meeting, minutes may need approval and discussion,
but do not discuss anything that already features on the agenda. Instead, go straight into the
first item, preferably calling upon another participant to initiate the discussion.
Conducting a Meeting
Strike a balance between keeping the discussion process moving briskly
forward and ensuring that everyone who wants to speak has a chance to Make sure you stick
state their opinion. The custom of debating an issue until a decision is to the time limit for
made can be time-consuming and lead to tension. To prevent this, act as each item on an
a timekeeper (make sure you have a watch to hand). Set time limits to agenda.
discussions so you can end the meeting at the appointed time.
Closing a meeting
Allow yourself enough time for winding up a meeting. Summarize the discussion and check
that others agree with your account. Make decisions about unfinished business, which may
include nominating someone to deal with it, and, finally, run through the implementation of any
decisions taken. These decisions determine the actions, which will be the result of the
meeting. Assign each action to a person, and attach a time target for completion.
Meeting formally
For formal one-to-one meetings the rules are the same as for any other meeting. Get to the
point quickly, stick to the agenda, sum up at the end, and make sure that the other side
agrees with the summary. In any one-to-one meeting the relationship between the supervisor
and subordinate has a tendency to move into one of dominance and submission. To make
meetings productive, listen to the other person, aim for rational discussion, and be courteous.
Remember that a certain degree of confrontation may be perfectly healthy – and also
unavoidable.
Being prepared
For regular meetings, preparation can make all the difference between a satisfactory or
unsatisfactory outcome. Some companies stage one-to-ones between supervisors and
subordinates every month to discuss any problems, define objectives, and deliver written
performance reviews. For these one-to-ones, the supervisors distribute the reviews a few days
beforehand. This preparation time gives the staff a chance to consider their response.
Coaching Staff
Good managers must be good coaches who know how to encourage
staff to raise their performance at work, improve their knowledge, and Listen to your staff.
realize their full potential. Coaching is inherent in the whole Coaching and
management process and should not be confined simply to counselling may
performance reviews and annual appraisals. As a supervisor, take the provide solutions to
initiative by setting staff goals, by regularly encouraging staff to discontent.
achieve higher standards, and by discussing any strength or
weaknesses. As the people being coached gain in confidence and performance, they will take
on more responsibility for setting personal targets for improving at work.
Counselling Staff
Problems that arise either from work or from personal life can be helped by counselling. But
unless you are a trained counsellor or have considerable experience, leave this to a
professional, who will help people to confront and resolve their problems. If an employee has
become unhappy over a situation, offer to arrange a counselling interview, and be
sympathetic. The counsellor will try to help the individual get to the root of any problem. Give
practical support when you can.
Ensuring Motivation
The second factor is a set of "motivators" that actually drive people to achieve. These are
what a manager should aim to provide in order to maintain a satisfied workforce. How much a
person enjoys achievements depends purely on its recognition. The ability to achieve, in turn,
rests on having an enjoyable job and responsibility. The greater that responsibility, the more
the individual can feel the satisfaction of advancement. Motivators are built around obtaining
growth and "self-actualization" from tasks. You can raise motivation in your staff by increasing
their resposibility, thereby "enriching" their jobs.
THEORY X THEORY Y
If I did not drive my people constantly,
If somebody falls down on the job, I
they would not get on with their work. first ask myself what I did wrong.
I sometimes have to fire somebody or
I should sometimes take a back seat
tongue-lash them to encourage others. at meetings and let others take the
Leaders have to lead by taking all key lead.
decisions themselves.
If I ask someone for their opinion on
I find that most people are an issue, I try to do as they suggest.
unambitious and must be forced to
People should appraise their bosses
raise their sights. as well as be appraised by them.
I keep my distance from the team
Anyone can have creative, innovative
since it is necessary for effective ideas if they are encouraged.
command.
Managing to Motivate
An essential foundation for motivation is a positive workplace environment created by you ,
the supervisor. Employees have the right to expect fair treatment and understanding. They
also expect professional competence, part of which includes delegating tasks in order to
increase staff members' self-management and participation.
Establish a system that is constructive – not obstructive – in which people can hope to
perform at their best.
Prepared by Eng'r S. Schacknat Page 31
Supervisory Development Program Creating a no-blame culture
Anyone with responsibility – including yourself – must accept their failures. However, to
motivate effectivly you need a culture in which no blame is laid for failure. Errors should be
recognized, then used to improve changes of future success.
POSITIVE NEGATIVE
+ -
Discuss problems Quality and customer Reprimand all
with staff satisfaction fall sharply those involved
Helping Staff
Two key motivational questions to ask your staff are:
If you co-operate by acting on the answers, for example by investing in new tools or training if
requested, you can bring about major improvements in motivation. Not acting on such
feedback will demotivate. The prime objective is to help staff to help themselves.
Taking an overview
When analyzing staff motivation, stand back and look at the overall situation. Do not
concentrate solely on one set of needs – wether they be team, individual, or task needs. Think
about atmosphere, team complaints, and results achieved. Above all, ask a lot of questions –
you will then form a picture of how the system operates and how well it works.
Working conditions
When we are talking about winning the co-operation of
the workforce we should not forget about what the
company should provide to create a proper working
environment. A proper workplace shows the staff that
you value them and will increase their co-operation. Ask
yourself the following question about the workshop
situation and try to improve until you reach the proposed
conditions. Formulate similar questions for other
workspaces such as packaging area, administration
office, etc.
A safe working space is compelling. Do they use in the machining section fences and
guides, proper jigs and other safety equipment?
Does the finishing section provides masks to keep the workers from inhaling fumes and
dust?
Is proper lighting be provided?
Is the workshop floor out of concrete and are you able to use trolleys for the workshop
internal transport?
Is the workshop cleaned daily and as dust free as possible?
Are the machines maintained regularly by a mechanic?
Has the workshop a dust exhaust for the machines?
Are the tools organized in a tool room and are they kept sharp all the time?
Does the company provide good quality raw materials or is it the cheapest available?
Is there an existing production administration system implemented? Do you use Routing
Sheets, Cutting Lists, Drawings, and Samples to speed up the production?
Identifying causes
Demotivation must first be analyzed before you can do anything about it. It may be caused by
stress, emotional problems, or physical illness. Alternatively, there may be something wrong
with the job itself, or with the person's approach to it. Talk to the demotivated person in order
to identify where the problem lies, and tailor the remedy to the cause, for example by
arranging secretarial help for someone who is overworked.
Tackling Problems
Personal difficulties and workplace problems are both potential causes of demotivation at
work. Never ignore your staff's emotional strains, even if performance is going well, because
there is a high probability that the personal troubles will eventually affect work. Your first
responsibility must be to the job. At the same time, you must also look after the individual.
Approach emotional upsets in the same way as workplace difficulties. First, get the problem
clearly defined, then seek the root cause. See if there is a solution that the individual will
accept. If so, act upon it. It is important not to let the situation worsen. If you are unable to
provide enough help, make sure that you find someone who can.
Encouraging Teamwork
When team members of your staff seem to be constantly at loggerheads, masterly tact is
usually required to replace the element of confrontation with collaboration. One course of
action is to move the couple into a larger team, insisting that they co-operate with and not
ignore each other. Another approach is to have the two people swap roles for a while, so that
they can gain an understanding of each other's workload. If all else fails, separate the two
warring parties permanently to avoid disrupting the work of the entire team.
3.1.5 Discipline
3.1.5.1 Rules and regulations
3.1.5.2 Disciplinary action
0.3 Peso / minute x 30 minutes late x 20 days / month x 50 workers = 9000 Pesos / month
Productivity is lower because the attendance per day is only 94 % instead of 100 %.
x Describe the performance problems and review past discussions and reminders
x Ask for reasons for the situation and listen openly to the employee's response (do not get
involved too deeply into personal problems because you will loose your objective position).
x Indicate what kind of disciplinary action you must take, and explain why
x Discuss and agree on ways to improve the workers performance and set a follow - up date
x Ask the employee to summarize the discussion in order to find out whether he takes the
situation seriously and whether he understood the problems
x Indicate your confidence in the employee's ability to improve and give hints on how to do so.
Your role as a supervisor is to be a mediator between the workforce and the management.
You have to stay objective. Leave personal emotions out of a meeting like that.
Defining performance
Every job has its own skills, necessary knowledge, and attributes, so be sure to know and to
specify them. Whatever level of job you are looking at, it should be of interest and give
satisfaction to the worker. Including the factors below will help to make any post more
appealing in the long term and motivate the job holder to perform more effectively. Check
each job if the different areas are covered or if you have to make adjustments.
Targets Interest
Accountability Multiskilling
Prospects Variation
Another part of the process of evaluating an exsisting job involves looking at past performance
levels and deciding what new qualities or tasks are needed to improve them. Arriving at a
single measure of performance is difficult. Financial results are the best all-inclusive measure,
but do not rely solely on them, since they will convey the wrong message – that only profit
counts. To measure quality, rather than just quantity, include staff morale, customer
satisfaction, inter-team collaboration, and other specific areas.
Discussing weaknesses
In appraisals, emphasize what the people being appraised have done well – their strength.
You must, of course, also remark on and discuss their weaknesses, but only for
improvement´s sake. Eliminating weaknesses strengthens performance. It is not just staff
performance that should be discussed. How does the person being appraised perceive the
contribution of the appraiser? Has the supervisor been helpful and motivating throughout the
year? If not, the appraiser has just as great a responsibility to improve performance as the
others.
Listening to opinions
Appraisal interviews provide a chance to talk Opinions
widely over external and internal matters, so do not
confine them to issues of personal performance.
Remember that all employees are sources of ideas Ideas
and opinions. Discuss these throughout the year,
not just at appraisals. Note the ideas and opinions collect
that you think the company could benefit from, and
consider implementation. The appraisal is ideal for
constructive question-and-answer sessions, and
you, as the suppervisor and appraiser, should do
more listening than talking.
Developing ability
Write a list of the key qualities that are needed for a particular task, and assess how they
match the qualities of the jobholder. If you feel there is a mismatch – especially one that is
likely to cause demotivation – do not reallocate the task, but take immediate action to develop
the missing attributes. Abilities are learned, and rarely inborn. In almost every case it is
possible to be taught a necessary skill, and where abilities are weak they can nearly always
be developed. If you feel certain qualities need to be acquired, be sure to provide the training.
Celebrating success
Personal thanks for exceptional performance are powerfully reinforced by being repeated or
given at a public celebration. Celebrate success, and you can motivate everybody in the unit,
not just the achiever. External awards and dinners have proliferated, and few industries are
now without them. Pay for entries and tables at these events, and make a fuss of any winners.
The same format applied internally is also effective. If a whole team, rather than an individual,
is involved, celebration is highly appropriate. Parties give you the chance to motivate by words
and by singling out special contributions. Ensure that any event of this type is carefully
planned and well staged. Skimping on any element, especiallly on catering, is a false
economy in terms of motivation.
Assessing costs
Despite the expense involved in training, it is cheaper than the cost of persisting without it,
which will damaging the performance. Calculate the costs of training, including training staff,
materials, room hire, course fees, subsistence, travel, and loss of work hours. Weigh up these
costs against the expected financial gains and improvements evident in team performance
following training.
Training leaders
As a supervisor, you should be exemplifying the qualities necessary to
manage a unit/team successfully. Ensure that you receive the requisite Set an example to
training to develop prioritizing, process-chasing, delgation, and your staff by being
motivating skills. Make these an integral part of your personal trained yourself.
development plan, and ensure that unit members – especially your sub-
leaders – also develop their own leadership skills. Listening carefully, criticizing
constructtively, being tolerant of error while correcting mistakes, and retaining objectivity are
leadership qualities that members should use within a team and in future projects.
Informal training
You can develop your staff in informal training, meaning to say you train them within the
production while you assign a job to them. This training has the advantage that you can take
care of each worker by himself. On the other hand communication is not so easy because of
the noise in the workshop. Mostly you will only have time to show him HOW something works
but not WHY. When it comes to the next assignment you might have to start from zero again.
To avoid this, you have to use a specific training method that assures a good and long-term
training effect. We call the method the Four-Step Method, which will be explained in the
following chapter.
Formal training
On the long run your staff development will be more efficient if you try to introduce some
formal training to your department / company. A formal training will be done either through you
or part of your more experienced staff in a planned and organized schedule or mostly through
other training institutions.
Before you can actually start with a formal training, you should evaluate the staffs
strengths and weaknesses in order to know WHAT you should teach them.
Try to classify the staff in each training relevant area into three different skills levels
(Beginner, Advanced, Experienced) and make training plans according to these results.
Talk to the HRD department and the management about time and a room to conduct
some of this formal training for the three different levels on a Saturday or as evening
classes.
Do not put all staff members into one class because the experienced ones will be bored
and the beginners will be overcharged and can not follow your explanations.
Accompany the theoretical lectures with some hands-on practices in a quiet workshop.
Try to convince the HRD department to introduce a company internal grading and
certification system. At the end of a “Circular Saw Training Module” the worker should
undergo a hands on exam and if he passes should receive a certificate as a “Circular Saw
Operator”. This system should be accompanied as well by some incentives, workers who
undergo these training and take them seriously should be acknowledged. Try to convince
somebody from the management to hand out the certificates to stress the importance of
the program.
Make a Manpower Development Plan with HRD to send some staff members to Training
Centers, especially if you do not have time and facilities to conduct training in your own
company.
Be serious about the training and explain it to your staff according to that. While courses
are conducted, discipline, attendance and active participation should be valued very high
1. 2. 3. 4.
The informal training in a company to teach technical or handicraft skills of any kind should be
done in an appropriate way to ensure a successful impact. There is a special method for this
kind of teaching that was developed by taking into consideration the principle of learning of the
human being. This method is taught in Germany and many other countries to mastercraftsmen
to equip them with a proper knowledge to teach effectively and successfully. You have to
break down each working process in very small steps and make a kind of work analysis that
will help you to apply the four-step method. You find a form for the work analysis on page 47.
Î
Place the trainee so that he is standing in the same
direction to the workpiece than you.
Î
Demonstrate the whole procedure in the original time.
Î
In case of complicated procedures devide them into
modules and teach them step by step.
Î
Repeat the demonstration and make the single steps
visible
Î
Say what you are doing, how and why you are doing
it in that way.
Î
Give the opportunity to ask questions.
Î
Enhance the trainee to try it on his/her own.
Î
Don't interrupt the trainee in his/her first attempts.
Î
Make comments on serious mistakes.
Î
Precision is more important than speed.
Î
Let the trainee say what he/she is doing, how and
why.
Î
Give enough time to exercise.
Î
Acknowledge progress.
Î
Control that no mistakes are done during the process.
Î
Change the conditions of exercising.
Î
Slowly adapt to real working conditions.
01.
How to break down a working process
02.
03.
04.
05.
06.
07.
0.8
Page 47
Scheme of a working analysis
Supervisory Development Program Planning a process
You have to consider some aspects for the determination of your goals:
Quality and workmanship = determine the quality of the product in relation to the
time available and the requirements of the customer
Cost and Budget control = consider the costing when you produce an item,
production time and quality are relevant
Clarify these aspects before you start your production planning in order to achieve the right
output before the deadline, in the right quality and within the cost frame.
With this information and the drawing etc. you are able to start the planning of the production
for the next period. Discuss it again with the manager if the production goal is too high, be
specific, have facts and numbers when you talk to him.
Measuring Performance
After setting the standards we can now record the results of the worker or production line.
(After 50 hours production time, only 500 legs are finished, quality is lower than the sample).
Evaluating Performance
Now that we have our actual production results, we can compare them with the standards
from before and we will find out whether we reached our production goals or not. (Evaluation
compares standards with results: 500 legs finished after 50 hours = lower than the standard,
quality is not as good as sample = lower than standard).
Î
Training of workers
Î
Better machines and equipment
Î
Use of jigs
Î
Identify bottleneck in the production
Î
Allocate materials for each order right in time
If you are involved in costing, establish a proper post calculation process in order to check
on the accuracy of your costing. Check on the physical accomplishments (number of work
pieces, in specific time, in a certain quality) of the workers, it is an important thing to know
about the efficiency of each single person in the production line. The easiest way is to
evaluate a worker’s data from his punsh card and the routing sheets.
Prepared by Eng'r S. Schacknat Page 50
Supervisory Development Program The principle of continuous improvement
Reasons to implement
You might ask, if a problem has been fixed, why can't it be checked off the list of things to
correct, and fogotten about? Because nothing is static: suppliers may change some aspect of
their materials; equipment may develop problems that, however slight, affect output;
technology may be upgraded, requiring new and different training, and so on. A modern
company which considers Total Quality Management (TQM) should allow for this ongoing
cycle of continuous quality improvement, a concept that Japan has been using for a long
time but which is still quite a revolutionary idea to most western organisations.
Kai = change
Zen = good
It is through Kaizen that the processes which bring forth or sustain the product are made more
competitive. If customer satisfaction (the larger the better) and cost (the smaller the better) are
choosen as the primary quality characteristics, then the focus of workplace Kaizen is to
improve value, and hence competitive advantage. Total Quality Control is the system to
implement Kaizen.
6. Evaluate
Decide what will be done with any future problems, evaluate the team's effectiveness
and lessons learned, and develop an action plan for remaining problems. This step
identifies the Deming Wheel as a tool, which should continue to be used to evaluate the
problem and any changes in circumstances. By continually turning the wheel,
adjustments can be made as circumstances change.
This is the story of a Quality Control program that was implemented in the
main office of a large bank. An average of 500 customers call this office
every day. Surveys indicated that the callers tended to become irritated if
the phone rang more than five times before it was answered, and often
would not call the company again. In contrast, a prompt answer after just
two rings reassured the customers and made them feel more comfortable
doing business by phone.
1. Selection of a Theme.
Telephone reception was chosen as a QC theme for the following reasons: (1)
Telephone reception is the first impression a customer receives from the company, (2)
this theme coincided with the company’s telephone reception slogan, "Don’t make
customers wait, and avoid needless switching from extension to extension", and (3) it
also coincided with a company-wide campaign being promoted at that time which
advocated being friendly to everyone one met.
First, the staff discussed why the present method of answering calls made callers wait.
Figure 3.1 illustrates a frequent situation, where a call from customer B comes in while
the operator is talking with customer A. Let’s see why the customer has to wait.
At (1), the operator receives a call from the customer but, due to lack of experience,
does not know where to connect the call. At (2), the receiving party cannot answer the
phone quickly, perhaps because he is unavailable, and nobody can take the call for
him. The result is that the operator must transfer the call to another extension while
apologizing for the delay.
from 'The Quest for Higher Quality - the Deming Prize and Quality control," Ricoh Company Ltd.
 Customer satisfaction.
 Involvement
 Continuous improvement.
Customer satisfaction.
Whether the customer is external or internal to the company, this is what keeps a company in
business. Marketing departments often take on the task of determining what the customer
wants, via methods such as customer surveys. But surveys may have design pitfalls: if you
don't ask the right questions, you won't get the right answers. TQM must consider both current
and future customer needs, while keeping in mind such possibilities as the development of
new products that customers might not think of on their own but which they would respond
positively to.
Involvement.
To achieve TQ, everyone in an organisation must be committed. Achieving this commitment is
not easy and takes a long time. This is why most authors suggest that organisations need
strong leadership and commitment from the top. Companies use mechanisms such as Quality
Circles (which nowadays are cross-functional teams that meet regularly) and suggestion
schemes to include people in the TQ objective. However, if these are not complete with
training and information sharing, they won’t work. The best results come when people work on
issues which are relevant to them, using techniques they are familiar with, and they have the
responsibility and often the resources to effect changes. Prior to practical and effective
implementation of the TQ the following breakthrough concepts are necessary:
Continuous improvement
In the ideal TQM environment, all processes are constantly under examination, and everyone
in the company is committed to the concept of continuous improvement. If an organisation
recognises that analysis and improvement of processes must be never-ending in order to
achieve and retain customer satisfaction, provides avenues for both customer and employee
feedback, and uses all the quality tools available, Total Quality Management can be realised.
Prevention
Correction
Quality
Direct costs: Can be related directly to a job order. Direct work, materials, etc.
Overhead costs: Can not be related directly to a job order. Insurances, repairs, rents, etc.
To look more specific at different kinds of costs which play an important role in the workshop
we have to divide them further. Mainly you have to deal with three types of cost:
ÂMaterial costs
ÂProduction costs
ÂOverhead costs
Material costs
The material costs contain actually of two different kind of costs. One is easy to understand:
the material costs are the costs for producing a specific item (direct costs). So the costs are
directly related to a job order. But materials also causes overhead costs like storage,
administration, work that you have during ordering materials, etc.. If we talk about real material
costs we have to consider that they should consist of the two different types mentioned above,
the direct and the overhead costs of material. Therefore your selling price for a specific
material cannot be the same than the one you payed your supplier. Usually the management
provides you with the material costs you have to use if you are the one the make a calculation.
Production costs
The production costs are all the costs created through work in the production for one job
order. They can be related directly to the job order and include the work on machines, work
done manual with hand tools, the set-up for the machines etc.. To determine the production
costs you have to know the different machine rates you have to relate to each machine, the
rates for the workers and the exact time for each operation. Production costs are also direct
costs. A lot of companies include in the production costs the overhead costs for the machines
and hand tools. Then the production cost is also a combination of direct and overhead costs
for production. If your company don't do it this way, you have to include these overhead costs
in the general overhead rate.
Overhead costs
As mentioned before overhead costs are no direct costs, which means you cannot relate them
to a job order. To run a company you have to pay a lot of additional costs such as SSS, taxes,
insurances, rents, electricity, administration costs, repairs, maintenance, payment of interest,
depriciation costs, vacation allowance, etc.. But nevertheless somehow the money for the
overhead costs has to be earned. So you have to include these expenses partly in the costs
for producing a job order/product. This is usually done by an overhead rate (in per cent) which
you add to the production and material costs of a product.
Reducing costs
Since you are now familiar with the different types of costs you can determine in which area
you can mostly influence the saving of costs:
With these information you can come up with the cost of sales for an item. If they expect you
to give the net amount, you need the margin and the overhead rates they ususally add to the
cost of sales.
Machine rates
The correct computation of the machine rates does not belong to your responsibilies, since it
is a very complicated business management skill and usually done by specialized personnel
like plan managers. They have to consider for example the depreciation, the interest and the
expenses for the machine in relation to the space it requires and also the extimated operating
life for a year.
Î
Interpret technical drawings properly.
Î
Recall the different materials and the hardware.
Î
Memorize the operations of all woodworking machines.
Î
Recognize the fastest production processes.
Î
Describe the working process step by step.
Î
Predict possible bottle-necks.
Î
Estimate the time for each working operation.
Î
Consider and estimate set-up times for each machine.
Measuring of materials
The first step for making a calculation is to determine the need
of the different materials. We usually prepare a cutting list
and an additional list for accessories such as hardware. For
the accessories list you have to check not only for the supplier
but also if the items are available in time. A cutting list is not
only used for calculation but also afterwards in the production
process. Below you can see an example for a very detailed
cutting list, which provides all the necessary information for
calculation and production process. The use of the metric
system in your workshop should be trained and carried out
since it is already an international standard.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
No. Part Material No. of Length Width Thickn. Area Volume Waste Vol. + Price Price
pieces mm mm mm m2 m2 Waste m2
1 Leg Gimelina 4 477 50 50 0,10 60 40 0,14 162,- 22,68
2 Rail Gimelina 2 1130 10 50 0,02
2 Rail Gimelina 2 630 10 50 0,01 60 0,03 150 0,08 162,- 12,96
With a complete cutting list you can compute the material costs for your job order.
Determination of time
The second step for making a calculation is to determine
the time that is needed for each working operation. You
need this for the computation of the costs of production.
The more experience you have in the production process
the easier it will be for you to estimate the time for a
working procedure. The scheme for the determination of
working time is the following:
When you have gathered these information you can prepare with the help of machine rates
and operator rates the costs of production. But you can also use the information for the
preparation of routing sheets and your further production planning process since they are
vital for the production process.
Machine set-ups
A special cost factor is the time for the set-up of machines. The lower the number of items you
have to produce the more important are the costs for the set-ups. It is advisable in general to
lower the time for machine set-ups as much as possible to minimize the costs in production.
Below you find some measures for lowering the time for machine set-ups:
Look for set-up "friendly" machines when you buy a new one
Train your staff in setting up all the machines
Store tools and devices for set-ups clearly arranged and close to the machine
Use fences, jigs and measuring devices
Use only carbide tipped tool since they last much longer
Specialize some workers for complicated and costly set-ups
Very frequent set-ups can be avoided by buying a second machine of the same
type
Pay attention to the need of only a few set-ups during the design process of a
product (choose suitable measurments)
The time you need for the most frequent set-ups can be determined by time and motion
studies so that you have a proper estimation for the duration of them.
To have an overview of the basis for proper calculations look at the picture below. You as a
supervisor can be responsible for determining the material and the production costs as long as
you get the required information form your superior. For coming up with the cost of sales or
even the net amount of an item you need to know what the overhead rates and the margin
are.
Let us have a look at a example. Here you can see the composition of the cost of sales for a
product and how to come up with a gross amount the customer has to pay.
Material Chipboard
costs Solid timber
Veneer
39,300 Pesos Plywood
Glue, screws
Hinges
32% Laquer, etc.
31,920 Pesos
26%
Overhead Taxes
costs Insurances
Administration cost
Rents
51,580 Pesos Electricity
Maintenance
Repairs
42% Depreciation
Interest, etc.
Total Cost:
Company Name ORDER ID
Process Equip- Process Description Time Setup Jigma- Worker ID Date Addit. Actual Time Qty. Bal. Worker
No. ment used (min) Time king (min) Worker Needed Sign.
(min)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
TOTAL:
Supervisory Development Program Basis for proper calculations
Customer: Material:
Adress: Drawing No:
Quantity:
Material Costs
Material Overhead %
(Plus)
Production Costs Prod. Mach. Worker Mach . Rate
(Machine/Section) (hrs.) Rate Rate incl. Wages
(Equals)
Administration Overh. %
Sales Overheads %
Product Developm. Overh. %
(Equals)
Total Costs
(Plus)
(Equals)
Retail Price
Profit Peso
5. 4. 0. Once a Day
x Observe one employee or work station continuously for 15 minutes
x Look for time wasted, dull or improper tools, need for work positioning jigs and fixtures, interference,
delays and bottlenecks, and expenditure of excessive time to get parts and materials. Do find ways
to cut costs or make improvements in any of these