Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

“Right to Equality: It is Basic Feature of our Constitution”

Nikhil Gangappa Mantur
Asst. Professor,
BLDE Law College, Jamkhandi

“When equality is the aim, Mediocrity is the result.

When excellence is the aim, Equality finds it’s true.”
Dr. Idel Dreimer

ABSTRACT:

Right to equality given under Article-14 of Indian Law. It is one of the Fundamental Right. It
ensures the guarantees to every person the right to Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of
Law. It is not only right of Indian citizens but also right of non-citizens. Article-14 says “The
State shall of India”. Article-14 defines no one is above the law and all are equal in the eye of
law. The word Right to Equality need no explanation because it till its meaning itself and it is
one the our Fundamental Right. There are some hidden points which are needed to explain and
this research project highlights those points and exceptions which are admissible by our Law of
the Land.

Keywords: Equality, Equal Protection of Law, Equality Before Law, Fundamental Rights,
Constitution

INTRODUCTION:

The Constitution of India guarantees the Right to Equality through Article 14 to 18.”Equality is
one of the magnificent corner stone of Indian Democracy”. The general principle of “Right to
Equality” needs no explanation as it defines itself.

“Right to Equality” is given under Article 14 of Indian law. It is one of the Fundamental Right. It
ensures the guarantees to every person the Right to Equality before law and Equal protection of
the laws. The Doctrine of Equality before law is a necessary corollary of “RULE OF LAW”
which pervades the Indian constitution. The underlying object of Article 14 is to secure all
persons, citizens or non-citizens, the equality of status and opportunity referrers Preamble to our
constitution.

Article 14 out -laws discrimination in a general way and guarantees equality before law to all
person. In view of a certain amount of indefiniteness attached to the general principle of equality
enunciated in Article-14, separate provisions to cover specific discriminatory situations have
been made by subsequent Article. The Supreme Court has said that the constitution lays down

www.penacclaims.com Page 1
Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

provisions both for protective discrimination and for also affirmative action. The Right to
Equality means every person, who lives within territory of India, has the equal right before the
law. The meaning of this all are equal in same order. No discrimination based on religion, race,
caste, sex and place of birth. It means that all are treated as Equal and no discrimination made
based on lower or higher class.

According to Dicey the concept of legal equality as it operated in England, quoted “With us
every official, from the Prime Minister down to a constable or a collector of taxes, is under the
same responsibility for every act done without any legal justification as any other Citizen”.

Article-14 of the Constitution embodies the principles of “Non-Discrimination”. However, it is

not a free standing provision. It has to be read in conjunction with rights conferred by other
articles like Art-21 of the Constitution. Art-21 refers to “RIGHT TO LIFE” and embodies
several aspects of life. It includes “Opportunity”. Art-21 and Art-14 are the heart of the chapter
on Fundamental Rights. They cover myriad features of life.

Article-7 of Universal Declaration of Human Right,1948 declares that all are equal before the
law and are entitled without any discrimination to the equal protection of laws. By and large the
same concept of equality inheres in Art-14 of the Indian Constitution. Right to Equality has been
declared by supreme Court as a basic features of the constitution. The Constitution is wedded to
the concept of equality. The preamble to the Constitution emphasizes upon the principle of
equality as basic to the Constitution. It means that even a constitutional amendment offending
the right to equality will be declared invalid.

The Supreme Court in BADAPPANAVAR CASE held following words:-

“Equality is a basic feature of the constitution of India and any treatment of equals unequally or
unequalls as equals will be violation of basic feature or structure of the constitution of India”

RIGHT TO EQUALITY:

Article-14 of the Constitution of India reads as under:-

“The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law or the equal protection of
the laws within the territory of India ”.

This provision corresponds to the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment of the US
constitution which declares: “No state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal
protection of the laws”. Art-14 confers rights on all persons whether citizens or foreigners.
moreover, the word “Person” includes legal persons Viz, statutory corporation, companies,
registered Societies or any other type of legal person.

www.penacclaims.com Page 2
Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

The underlying object of this Article is to secure to all persons, citizens or non-citizens, the
equality of status and of opportunity referred to in the Preamble of the Constitution. Article 14
which guarantees right to Equality in general may be related to the Preamble of the Constitution
directly which embodies the ideal of equality. Article-14 stands for the establishment of a
situation under which there is complete absence of any arbitrary discrimination by the laws
themselves or in their administration.

Interpreting the scope of the Article, the Supreme Court of India held in

Chiranjit Lal Choudhury vs Union of India that:

a. Equal Protection means equal protection under equal circumstances.

b. The State can make reasonable classification for purposes of legislation.
c. Presumption of reasonableness is in favor of legislation.
d. The burden of proof is on those who challenge the legislation.

EQUALITY BEFORE LAW AND EQUALITY PROTECTION OF LAW:

The concept of “Equality Before Law” is the British origin. While the concept of “Equal
Protection of Laws” has been taken from the American Constitution.

EQUALITY BEFORE LAW CONNOTES:

 The absence of any special privileges in favor of any person.

 The equal subjection of all persons to the ordinary law of the land administered by
ordinary law courts.
 No person (whether rich or poor, high or low, official or non-official) is above the law.

EQUAL PROTECTION OF LAW CONNOTES:

 The Equality of treatment under equal circumstances, both in the privileges conferred and
liabilities imposed by the laws.
 The similar application of the same laws to all persons who are similarly situated.
 The like should be treated alike without any discrimination.

Because of this reason Equality Before Law is negative concept. And Equal Protection of Law is
positive concept. However, both of them aim at establishing equality of legal status, opportunity
and justice.

Supreme court held that where equals and unequals are treated differently, Article-14 does not
apply. Which Art-14 forbids class legislation; it permits reasonable classification of persons,
objects and transaction by the law. But the classification should not be arbitrary artificial or
evasive. Rather, it should be based on an intelligible differential and substantial distinction.

www.penacclaims.com Page 3
Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

Article-14 forbids class legislation, it does not forbid reasonable classification of persons, objects
and transactions by the legislature for the purpose of achieving specific ends. Classification to be
reasonable should fulfill the following two tests:-

 It should not be arbitrary, artificial or evasive. It should be based on an intelligible

differentia, some real and substantial distinction, which distinguishes persons or things
grouped together in the class from others left out of it.
 The differentia adopted as the basis of classification must have a rational or reasonable
nexus with the object sought to be achieved by the status in question.

Article-14 in its ambit and sweep involves two facets, viz it permits reasonable classification
which is founded on intelligible differentia and accommodates the practical needs of the society
and the differential must have a rational relation to the objects sought to be achieved. Further, it
does not allow any kind of arbitrariness and ensures fairness and equality of treatment. It is the
“fon juris” of our Constitution, the fountain head of justice. Differential treatment does not per
se amount to violation of article-14 of the Constitution and it violation of article-14 only when
there is no reasonable basis and there are several tests to decide whether a classification is
reasonable or not and one of the tests will be as to whether it is conducive to the functioning of
modern society.

RULE OF LAW

The concept of “Equality Before Law” is an element of the concept of “RULE OF LAW”
propounded by “A.V.DICEY”, the British jurist. His concept has the following three elements or
aspects:

1) Absence of arbitrary power, i.e., no man can be punished except for a breach of law.
2) Equality before the law, that is, equal subjection of all citizens (rich or poor, high or low,
official or non-official) to the ordinary law of the land administered by the ordinary law
courts.
3) The priority rights of the individual, that is, the Constitution is the result of the rights of
the individual as defined and enforced by the courts of law rather than the Constitution
being the source of the individual rights.

The first and second elements are applicable to the Indian system and not the third one. In the
Indian system, the Constitution is the source of the individual rights.

The Supreme Court held that the “Rule of Law” as embodied in Article-14 is a “Basic Feature”
of the constitution. Hence, it cannot be destroyed even by an amendment.

www.penacclaims.com Page 4
Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

EXCEPTION TO RIGHT TO EQUALITY:

The rule of equality before law is not absolute and there are Constitutional and other exceptions
to it. These are as follows:

 The President or the Governor enjoy the following immunities (Article-361)

a) The President or Governor is not answerable to any court for the exercise
and performance of the powers and duties of his office.
b) No criminal proceeding shall be instituted or continued against the
President or the Governor in any court during his term of office.
c) No process for the arrest or imprisonment of the President or the
Governor shall be issued from any court during his term of office.
d) No civil proceedings against the President or the Governor shall be
instituted during his term of office in any court in respect of any act done
by him in his personal capacity whether before or after he entered upon
his office, until the expiration of two months next after notice has been
delivered to him.
 No person shall be liable to any civil or criminal proceedings in any court in respect of
the publication in a newspaper( or by radio or television) of a substantially true report of
any proceedings of either house of Parliament or either house of the Legislature of a
state.(Article 361A)
 No member of Parliament shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in respect of
anything said or any vote given by him in Parliament or any committee thereof.(Article
105)
 No member of the Legislature of a state shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in
respect of anything said or any vote given by him in the Legislature or any committee
thereof (Article 194)
 Article 31-C is an exception to Article-14. It provides that the laws made by the state for
implementing the Directive Principles contained in clause (b) or clause (c) of article 39
cannot be challenged on the ground that they are violative of Article 14. The Supreme
Court held that “Where Article 31-C comes in, Article 14 goes out”.
 The foreign sovereigns (rulers), ambassadors and diplomats enjoy immunities from
criminal and civil proceedings.
 The UNO and its agencies enjoy the diplomatic immunity.

CONCLUSION:

In its struggle for social and political freedom mankind has always tried to move towards the
ideal of equality for all. The urge for equality and liberty has been the motive force of many
revolutions. The Charter of the United Nations records the determination of the member nations

www.penacclaims.com Page 5
Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

to reaffirms their faith in the equal rights of men and women. Indeed, real and effective
democracy cannot be achieved unless equality in all spheres is realized in full measures.
However, complete equality among men and women in all spheres of life is a distant ideal to be
realized only by the march of humanity along the long and difficult path of economic, social and
political progress. The Constitution and laws of a country can at best assure to its citizens only
limited measures of Equality. The framers of the Indian Constitution were fully conscious of this.
This is why while they give political and legal equality the status of a fundamental right,
economic and social equality was largely left within the scope of Directive Principle of State
Policy.

The Right to Equality affords protection not only against discriminatory laws passed by the
legislatures but also prevents arbitrary discretion being vested in the executive. In the modern
state, the executive is armed with vast powers in the matters of enforcing by-laws, rules and
regulations as well as in the performance of a number of other functions. The equality clause
prevents such power being exercised in a discriminatory manner.

Article-14 prevents discriminatory practices only by the state and not by individuals. For
instance, if a private employer like the owner of a private business concern discriminates in
choosing his employees or treats his employees unequally, the person discriminated against will
have no judicial remedy. One might ask here, why the Constitution should not extend the scope
of these right to private individuals also. There is good reason for not doing so. For such
extension to individuals action may result in serious interference with the liberty of the
individuals and in the process, fundamental right themselves may become meaningless. After all,
real Democracy can be achieved only by a proper balance between the freedom of the
individuals and the restrictions imposed on him in the interests of the community. Yet, even
individual action in certain spheres has been restricted by the Constitution, as for example, the
abolition of un-touchability and its practice in any form by any one being made an offence.
Altogether, Article-14 lays down an important fundamental right which has to be closely and
vigilantly guarded. The right to equality and equal protection of laws loses its reality if all
citizens do not have equal facilities of access to the courts for the protection of their fundamental
rights. The fact that these rights are guaranteed in the Constitution does not make them real
unless legal assistance is available for all on reasonable terms. There cannot be any real equality
in the right “To sue and be sued” unless the poorer sections of the community have equal access
to courts as the richer section. There is a evidence that this point is widely appreciated in the
country as a whole and the government of India in particular and that is why steps are now being
taken to establish a system of legal aid to those who cannot afford the prohibitive legal cost that
prevails in all parts of the country.

www.penacclaims.com Page 6
Volume 10, May 2020 ISSN 2581-5504

References:

1. http://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/1688/Right-To-Equality--A-Fundamental-
Right.html
2. http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-1253-right-to-equality-and-equal-
protection-of-laws-article-14-to-18.html
3. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334284805_Right_to_Equality-
Reasonable_Classification_Rule_Versus_Rule_Against_Arbitrariness_Under_the_Indian
_Constitution_A_Note_1
4. https://iitr.ac.in/internalcomplaintscommittee/annexure.pdf
5. M.P Jain : Indian Constitutional Law
6. DD.Basu: Introduction to the Constitution of India
7. Mahajan. V.D: Constitution of India
8. Pylee.M.V: Constitution of India

www.penacclaims.com Page 7