A New CMOS Implementation For Miniaturized Active RFID Insect Tag and VHF Insect Tracking
A New CMOS Implementation For Miniaturized Active RFID Insect Tag and VHF Insect Tracking
2, JUNE 2020
Abstract—This paper proposes a new circuit design for Very a complete tag weighing 390mg. However, this could not be
High Frequency (VHF) radio telemetry, in order to miniaturize employed to track animals weighing less than 7g. In 2005,
active RFID tags for tracking small insects and bees. It presents the same author and collaborators [3] further miniaturized the
a CMOS insect-tag implementation for generating 150 MHz
burst-mode signaling scheme by employing digital approach tag size to 200mg and employed two discrete BJT devices in
which was not reported before. This design is vastly differ- this active tag design. This lighter tag also reduced the width
ent from many presently available VHF tags which employs (time-window) of the transmitted signal to save power and
analog signal generation and discrete components. The new enabled a breakthrough in tracking large insects like bumble-
telemeter circuit employs a 150MHz voltage-controlled ring bees. However, the challenge still remains in tracking many
oscillator (VCRO) feeding into a cascade of frequency-dividers
whose outputs are combined to generate an extremely low duty- smaller insects such as honey bees, wasps, etc. which are of
cycle (LDC) burst-mode transmission signal to conserve power. immense ecological and economic importance. The current
In addition, it also incorporates digital-code for insect-tag iden- state-of-the-art active tags still prove unsuitable and too heavy
tification, compared to analog methods which employs small a burden for these smaller insects to bear.
frequency shifts from a reference f (∼150MHz) to f+f MHz There have been concerns raised by many authors about
for individual tag identification. In the proposed design the
strength of the modulated carrier signal is employed to track the adverse effects of radio telemetry on the creatures being
the tagged insect location through the triangulation technique. tracked [4]. Also, some researchers claimed that these tags
A design-rule-check (DRC) and pattern-density clean chip-tag changed the behavior of the creature [5] and therefore, the
was designed for an 8-bit identification code at a throughput of data accuracy could not be ascertained. However, further
576b/s, on a 28-nm CMOS process. It occupies an active layout research has determined that the tag deployment did not affect
area of 1600-µm2 and consumes 8.2-µW. The core transmit-
ter employs supply-voltage of 0.6V to conserve power while the the tracking data if the tag weight is 5% or less of the animals’
output drivers uses 1.2V for high transmitted signal strength. weight and 10% or less of the insects’ weight [6]. Hence, the
In addition, the new LDC burst-mode signal generation method tag’s miniaturization is crucial so that it does not affect the
was verified on silicon through measurements on a fabricated insect’s foraging behavior in any way. Conventionally, VHF
test chip using a 130nm CMOS process. This test circuit con- active-tag transmitter designs employ Pierce oscillators, which
sumed a measured average power of only 7.07-µW. This novel
design enables the smallest tag-size (5mm x 5mm x 2.5 mm) and uses a quartz crystal, bipolar transistor and many passive
tag-weight (< 95mg) compared to many recent VHF tags. components. These discrete components and their integration
into printed-circuit-board (PCB) makes the transmitter bulkier.
Index Terms—CMOS circuit design, low duty-cycle, radio
telemetry, VHF RFID, voltage-controlled-ring-oscillator, triangu- There are passive tags [7] available which are small enough
lation method, insect telemetry, frequency shift keying. for the bees to carry, but the tracking range of these pas-
sive tags is hardly 1m which renders them unsuitable for the
insects home-range (∼1km) analysis. Moreover, the present
I. I NTRODUCTION state-of-the-art individual insect-tag identification is based on
ESEARCHERS have been tracking animals and study- the frequency of the signal that it transmits, and this makes the
R ing their movements and behavior remotely by using
VHF radio telemeter circuitry since the 1960s [1]. Since then,
frequency stability of the transmitted signal a prime concern
for the proper operation of the tracking system. Consequently,
there have been many technological developments in the active for detecting a large number of insects, the separation between
radio-tag design depending on the animal size, their behavior, adjacent identification frequencies decreases for any avail-
tag durability etc., but still, the basic design of the tag cir- able VHF identification bandwidth, thus rendering frequency
cuit has not changed much. In 1993, Naef-Daenzer performed stability a more crucial parameter. In addition, these tags expe-
a major task in reducing the telemeter-size [2] by designing rience frequency drift over time as the output voltage of the
tag battery does not stay precisely the same and this could
Manuscript received August 4, 2019; revised December 8, 2019; accepted also interfere in the correct identification of the tagged insect.
January 2, 2020. Date of publication January 9, 2020; date of current version Furthermore, these signals being analog are more sensitive to
May 25, 2020. This work was supported in part by the New Zealand Institute
of Plant & Food Research Ltd., and in part by the Massey Venture Ltd. phase noise and other interferences. All these impediments and
(Corresponding author: S. M. Rezaul Hasan.) drawbacks leads to a need to explore the design of low-power
The authors are with the Center for Research in Analog and VLSI digital CMOS VHF active tags for insect telemetry.
Microsystem Design, Massey University, Auckland 0632, New Zealand
(e-mail: [email protected]). In this paper, a new digital CMOS transmitter circuit
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/JRFID.2020.2964313 for insect tracking telemeter-tag employing a low duty-cycle
2469-7281
c 2020 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See https://www.ieee.org/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KUMARI AND HASAN: NEW CMOS IMPLEMENTATION FOR MINIATURIZED ACTIVE RFID INSECT TAG AND VHF INSECT TRACKING 125
Fig. 1. An architectural block diagram of the new digital telemeter circuit, consisting of frequency dividers, low duty cycle signal generator, tag code
generator, FSK frequency modulator and output driver. The telemeter is designed for operation at a VHF frequency of 150MHz employing 28nm CMOS
process.
(LDC) burst signal has been proposed. The design has obviated
the need for large passive elements which would otherwise
increase tag area [8]. This tag circuit has been designed to
generate and transmit 8 bit-coded signal bursts after a cer-
tain interval of time. In this methodology, each tag will be
uniquely binary-coded for individual tag identification. These
codes are used by the receiver system to determine the loca-
tion of the particular tagged creature based on the strength
of the modulated carrier wave. The paper also discusses the
VCRO frequency stability and frequency spectrum analysis
of the coded signal. The new digital insect telemeter tag has Fig. 2. The burst signal pulse-interval and the pulse-width for various smallest
commercial active VHF tags and the proposed tag, (a) A2412 (duty-ratio =
been soft-designed on 28nm CMOS to explore the reduction 0.01), (b) the proposed insect-tag (this work), (c) PicoPip, and (d) A2412
in chip-size and power dissipation, and, the digital burst signal (duty-ratio = 0.0037).
generator circuit was verified through experimental fabrication
on 130nm CMOS.
the field and reduces the operational range of the tag [9]. Also,
in [3], it is mentioned that it is difficult to track tags with duty-
II. A RCHITECTURE OF THE N EW D IGITAL I NSECT TAG cycle less than 0.008. However, presently, the lowest duty-ratio
The architectural block diagram of the proposed new digital being used in commercial tag is 0.0037. Hence taking the
insect telemeter design is shown in the Fig. 1. Here, primarily, above into consideration, the duty-ratio of 0.008 was chosen
three functions are being implemented. First, the low duty- which would provide enough operational distance (∼1km) at
cycle (LDC) pulse signal generation, second, the generation low power budget. The duty-ratio, ON-time and the interval
of 8-bit tag identification code and third, the FSK modulation between the burst pulses for the presently available small-
of carrier signal with the 8-bit code for aerial transmission. est active commercial VHF tags and the proposed tag are
The LDC signal controls the synchronized transmission of shown in Fig. 2. There are VHF signals inside each burst
the tag identification code since the codes are generated and square-wave pulse but are not shown in the illustration for
transmitted only when this signal goes high. This is performed simplicity. The Figs. 2(a) and (d) shows the pulse signals
by using it as a shift (strobing) signal in the code generation for the A2412 tag [10] at two different duty-ratios, 0.01 and
circuit. As a result, there is a reduction in the total power 0.0037 respectively; Fig. 2(b) shows the signal of the proposed
dissipation of the telemeter and the battery-life is prolonged. insect-tag, while Fig. 2(c) is the signal of the PicoPip tag [11].
The significance of this LDC signal is further discussed in The figure also shows a comparison of the power being dis-
Section IV. Since for tracking bees, transmitted signal bursts sipated by the tags during the generation of the burst-mode
of around 10ms – 15ms is needed for easy signal detection independent of the duty-ratio. From the comparison table it
by the receivers, and, since the insect/tag location needs to be is evident that the proposed new insect tag design not only
tracked every few seconds, a duty-cycle of around 0.008 is conserves battery-life by employing a very low duty-cycle but
chosen as appropriate for transmission. If the duty-cycle gets in addition consumes 83.7% less power than the next best
too low it creates an issue in the detectability of the signal in A2412 tag during just the burst pulse duration alone.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
126 IEEE JOURNAL OF RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION, VOL. 4, NO. 2, JUNE 2020
TABLE I
T HE F REQUENCY, T IME -P ERIOD AND P ULSE D URATION OF O UTPUT
S IGNALS F ROM E ACH F REQUENCY D IVIDER (FD) TAPPING P OINT FOR
A 150 MH Z I NPUT T HROUGH A C ASCADE OF 28 F REQUENCY D IVIDERS
Fig. 3. The VCRO in 28nm CMOS for generating the 150MHz reference,
consisting of a voltage-divider bias with connection to control/probe pad and
an inverting-buffer at the output. The resistors employs OP (salicide block)
on p+ poly layers (with sheet resistance of 480 ± 15% /sq.) from the 28nm
analog library.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KUMARI AND HASAN: NEW CMOS IMPLEMENTATION FOR MINIATURIZED ACTIVE RFID INSECT TAG AND VHF INSECT TRACKING 127
Fig. 6. (a) FSK modulation using a 2:1 Mux, where the carrier signals f1
(75MHz) and f0 (150MHz) are multiplied (ANDed) with the LDC signal. For
the code bit “1” f0 is selected while for the code bit “0” f1 is selected. (b) The
0.6V-to-1.2V level-shifter in 28nm CMOS (the first inverter) and final burst-
mode tapered buffer output driver (the last three inverters) with the output
Fig. 4. Generation of the low duty-cycle (LDC) signal using the outputs f22
impedance matched to 50 for the antenna attachment.
to f28 of the clock-divider flip-flops FD 22 to FD 28. The output signal is
high only when all the signals f22 to f28 are high at the same time, otherwise
it is low.
power consumption is reduced by preventing unwanted rapid
switching of the transistors in this block.
Sub-block 8: It consists of the final transmission driver
which is a set of four inverters as shown in the Fig. 6(b).
For power reduction, the telemeter supply-voltage is kept at
0.6V. However, the output driver is designed for 1.2V supply
so that the transmitted signal is sufficiently strong for employ-
ing the triangulation method. Hence, the first inverter in the
driver acts as the level-shifter with wider NMOS compared
Fig. 5. Schematic for the generation of code using PISO shift-register and to the PMOS to translate the voltage from 0.6V to 1.2V. The
a set of 8 wires. Each wire of the 8-bit code is connected to the VDD for
“1” or to the GND for “0”. The flip-flops used in the shift register are the other three inverters constitute a 28nm tapered buffer circuit. In
falling-edge triggered master-slave D-flip-flops. When the SHIFT/LD control order to provide broad-band impedance matching for the pulse
is low the code-bits are loaded, and when it is high the code-bits are shifted transmission we have considered the signal transmission in
for transmission.
driving output “high” and output “low”. The impedance look-
ing towards VDD during pull-up and the impedance looking
that of the LDC signal, so that its pulse arrives beforehand towards the ground during pull down are through PMOS and
and sub-block 6 has enough time to load the hardwired code NMOS switches respectively acting in the triode (resistive)
in the flip-flops before the code shifting occurs. region of operation. Hence, the resistance of the switches in
Sub-block 6: This is the circuit for the generation of the 8- the triode (resistive) region are matched as closely as pos-
bit code for the tag so that 256 unique individual tags could be sible to a 50 characteristic load by adjusting the aspect
assigned. The schematic for this circuit is depicted in Fig. 5. It (width/length) ratio of the transistors. Fig. 6(b) shows the
consists of the parallel-input-serial-output (PISO) shift-register impedance matched last-stage of the output driver along-with
and set of 8 wires from B0 to B7 which are connected to the transistor-sizes. Fig. 7(a) demonstrates FSK modulation
ground for “0” s or to the power supply (VDD) for “1” s to for the code 10001110 and Fig. 7(b) illustrates bursts of the
set the unique (distinct) binary code for each tag. These wires carrier with identification code transmitted between the sleep
are fed to the 2:1 MUX of the PISO shift-register. The CLK intervals.
and SHIFT/LD signals are determined based on the word-
length of the code. Here, for the 8-bit code the LDC signal III. F REQUENCY S TABILITY A NALYSIS
is chosen to be the SHIFT/LD signal, while, the output of the The ring oscillator is one of the simplest and easy to imple-
sub-block 4 is chosen as the CLK. The code is loaded into the ment oscillators. However, in general, the use of free-running
flip-flops when SHIFT/LD is low, and, when SHIFT/LD goes ring oscillator as a clock circuit is restrained due to large
high, at every clock-cycle one bit of the code is transferred to power-supply noise and frequency jitter [15]. Also, due to this
the output. reason a PLL or other control circuitry are implemented along-
Sub-block 7: This block takes the output code from the sub- with the ring-oscillator to stabilize the oscillator frequency.
block 6 and employs it as the base-band signal for carrier This enhancement additionally requires an external reference
modulation, followed by the transmission of the carrier signal. clock which along with the PLL increases the size and the
For this purpose, Frequency-Shift Keying (FSK) modulation power requirement of the composite ring oscillator. In the
technique has been chosen so that the transmitted signal has insect telemeter tag implementation, where power dissipation
maximum power and it could be employed in the triangulation and chip-area are highly constrained, inclusion of PLL (with
technique [14] to find the location of the tag for insect tracking. a few mW of power budget by itself) [16] and other control
This circuit is shown in the Fig. 6(a) where a 2:1 multiplexer circuitry with the ring oscillator is not feasible considering
outputs the carriers f0 and f1 for the transmission of 1s and miniaturization and battery life of the tag. On the other hand,
0s respectively. Before being fed into the MUX, the carriers this insect tag is extremely minute compared to the present-
are first multiplied with the LDC signal so that the modulated day VLSI chips where millions of transistors may be switching
signal is transmitted only when the LDC signal is high, and the simultaneously generating a large Ldi/dt voltage across the
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
128 IEEE JOURNAL OF RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION, VOL. 4, NO. 2, JUNE 2020
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KUMARI AND HASAN: NEW CMOS IMPLEMENTATION FOR MINIATURIZED ACTIVE RFID INSECT TAG AND VHF INSECT TRACKING 129
TABLE II
P ERFORMANCE OF THE I NSECT T ELEMETER TAG
AT VARIOUS F REQUENCIES
Fig. 10. Frequency jitter of the Ring Oscillator including random noise and
Fig. 11. Normal distribution plot of the oscillator’s frequency with a mean
power supply noise indicating a maximum jitter of around 450kHz.
of 150.8 MHz and a standard deviation of 0.157 MHz.
fa (150.87 MHz in this case). The graph shows that the max-
imum jitter in the VCRO’s frequency, represented as f, is
around 450 kHz. From this frequency jitter, the maximum
period jitter, Tp at 150.87 MHz is determined using (2) below:
1 1
− = Tp (2)
fa fa + f
From the above, the Tp value is found to be around 20 psec for
the time-period of 6.63nsec. Also, the throughput of the code
inside the burst signal is 576b/s which varies around 0.67 %
per MHz change in the oscillator frequency as per the Table II. Fig. 12. Monte Carlo analysis plot showing the effect of mismatch variation
in the resistive voltage divider considering 200 Samples.
At this bit-rate, the 20psec oscillator jitter is extremely low to
influence the performance of the insect-tag.
The effect of this jitter has also been analyzed in terms of the
this graph are 151.12MHz and 0.67MHz respectively. From
normal probability distribution of the oscillator’s frequency.
this plot, it is quite clear that the reference frequency for
From the simulated frequency data, the mean frequency, µ is
99.7% of the tags will be in the range of 149.07MHz to
determined to be 150.8MHz with 0.157MHz standard devi-
153.09MHz. Hence, the voltage-divider resistor-mismatch will
ation (σ ). Fig. 11 shows the normal distribution plot of the
not be a bottle-neck issue in the operation and performance of
oscillator frequency. It can be seen from this plot that due
the insect telemeter. The VCRO control-voltage may also be
to the small 3σ value which is 0.47MHz, 99.7% of the time
adjusted externally (external trimming) using the probe-pad, if
the oscillator’s frequency varies within a very small frequency
at all required.
range of 150.5MHz to 151.2MHz. This confirms that the
power supply noise will not be an issue in this miniaturized
insect-tag design. B. Temperature Variation
Mismatch of the voltage-divider resistors in generating Foraging activity of bees and other insect pollinators nor-
the control-voltage of the VCRO has also been considered. mally occur within an environmental temperature range of
Fig. 12 depicts the Monte Carlo simulation result for 200 sam- 14◦ C to 38◦ C [20, 21]. Hence, to understand the operation of
ples indicating the effect of the resistance mismatch variation the tag in this temperature range, simulations were performed
on the VCRO frequency at the typical-typical (TT) process for temperature variation from 10◦ C to 40◦ C. Fig. 13 shows
corner. The mean frequency and the standard deviation for that in the operational temperature range, the tag’s frequency
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
130 IEEE JOURNAL OF RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION, VOL. 4, NO. 2, JUNE 2020
Fig. 15. Frequency variation for the VCRO (with OP-resistors) at various
process corners, ss (slow-slow), sf (slow-fast), tt (typical-typical), fs (fast-
slow) and ff (fast-fast).
Fig. 13. Simulated frequency drift due to environment temperature varia-
tion. In the operational temperature range, the tag’s frequency varies between
118.43MHz and 185.11MHz.
Fig. 16. Monte Carlo simulation result of sample distribution vs. frequency
for various process corners showing a 55% pass with a mean of 155.09 MHz
for 1000 samples.
Fig. 14. The influence of supply-voltage variation on the oscillator’s
frequency (@ typical-typical process corner and 27◦ C temperature).
during fabrication. This variation has always been a serious
varies between 118.43MHz and 185.11MHz. This is around concern to the designer in the yield of working chips, partic-
2.78MHz change per ◦ C fluctuation in the temperature, and, ularly when the size of the circuit is quite large [22]. To con-
the Table II shows the parameters of the tag in this frequency sider the effect of process variation on the running frequency,
range. From this table, it can be seen that with the change the VCRO in Fig. 3 (with OP-resistors) was simulated at
in environmental temperature, the sleep-time, burst-signal various process corners, Slow-Slow (SS), Slow-Fast (SF),
width and data-rate will vary considerably, but, as long as Typical-Typical (TT), Fast-Slow (FS), and Fast-Fast (FF). The
the frequencies are detectable by the receiver, this will not results are plotted in the Fig. 15. Here, for this oscillator
have any impact on the insect tracking, as the tag identifi- the frequency varies significantly with process variation, but,
cation codes are frequency invariant. This is an additional this variation always has an associated statistical distribu-
benefit of this digitalized telemeter insect-tag over the conven- tion with mean and standard deviation [23]. The TT corner
tional analog-based telemeter where the frequency stability is is essentially the mean of this distribution. Since the size of
stringent and paramount for the correct identification of the the circuit is very small in this insect-tag design, a reason-
individual insects. able yield for this telemeter chip can be delivered [16]. The
yield for this telemeter design is predicted by running the
full Monte-Carlo simulation for 1000 sample points. The tags
C. Voltage Variation
with frequencies in the range 120MHz to 180MHz will be
Fig. 14 depicts the effect of supply-voltage fluctuation on binned for the telemeter application and the rest will be dis-
the oscillator’s frequency at typical-typical process corner and carded. Fig. 16 shows the Monte-Carlo simulation result with
27◦ C ambient temperature. It changes at the rate of 1.3MHz 55% (557/1000) successful yield. The pass range is shown by
per mV change in the supply-voltage. However, as discussed the green shaded region in the figure. The associated mean
in the above Section III-A, due to the skeletal telemeter circuit- frequency and standard deviation are 155MHz and 42MHz
size and isolated power supply-line provided for the oscillator, respectively.
a significant fluctuation in the supply-voltage due to power-
supply noise is not expected. IV. D ESIGN AND S IMULATION R ESULTS
The new insect telemeter circuit was designed and simulated
D. Process Variation in 28-nm Global-Foundries (GF) CMOS process. The chip was
Process variation is the change in the transistor attributes in verified to be DRC and pattern-density clean and cleared man-
terms of width, length, oxide-thickness and threshold-voltage ufacturability checks. The transmitter circuitry occupies only
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KUMARI AND HASAN: NEW CMOS IMPLEMENTATION FOR MINIATURIZED ACTIVE RFID INSECT TAG AND VHF INSECT TRACKING 131
Fig. 18. Frequency control-voltage of the VCRO for various process corners.
The tuning range of the oscillator is wide enough to allow appropriate control-
voltage to set the frequency to 150 MHz for each process corner.
Fig. 19. Timing diagram for the PISO shift-register in strobing the insect-tag
identification code 10001110.
Fig. 17. Layout of (a) the transmitter circuit, and, (b) the die with bond pads
including ESD protection cells (available in the 28nm cell library) with each
I/O pad. The zoomed-in view of the fill pattern-density for Rx, poly, n-well The complete transmitter circuit was extensively simulated
and all metal layers is also shown.
using Cadence spectre. Parasitic extracted post-layout simula-
tion was also carried out and performance difference compared
to the pre-layout simulation was found to be insignificant. This
around 1600 µm2 [Fig. 17(a)] while the total chip-size along is because the RC time-constant due to the parasitic capac-
with the bond-pads is 1mm2 [Fig. 17(b)]. A zoomed-in view of itance and the finite (non-negligible) via-resistance is small
the fill pattern-density for Rx, poly, n-well and all metal layers (with the resulting pole at extremely high frequency) com-
is also shown. The I/O pads have electrostatic discharge (ESD) pared to the 150MHz operating frequency of the VCRO in
protection. With such miniaturization, the weight of the silicon this chip. The effect of the parasitics will be more prominent
die will be negligible, and the tag load will be constituted by at much higher radio frequencies. Since the entire circuitry,
the battery, antenna and any packaging. The circuit employs except the output driver, employs 0.6V supply-voltage, the
14 bond-pads as labeled on the die photo. There are 3 power- VCRO is in particular sensitive to process variation [24] which
supply pads, VDDD for the driver circuit, VDDO for the was discussed earlier in Section III-D. To indicate that stable
oscillator and VDDC for the rest of the transmitter circuit. 150MHz oscillation is achievable in all cases, PSS simula-
A DC-DC converter was not implemented at this stage as it tion was further carried out for the VCRO for various process
may require large on-chip inductor as well as extra control corners. Fig. 18 shows the frequency vs. control-voltage plot
circuitry which would increase the chip-size and power dissi- where it can be seen that with process variation the running
pation thus diminishing the tag life-span. An off-chip matched frequency of the oscillator changes considerably. However, the
external wire antenna will be deployed with the fabricated die. tuning range of the oscillator is wide enough to allow the con-
For the chip I/O wire-bond type pads designed on the LB (Last trol voltage to set the frequency to 150MHz in each case. The
metal option) layer in accordance with the 28-nm design-rule control-voltage is set to generate 150MHz for the TT process
are employed. For passivation opening, rectangular shaped box corner (R1 and R2 design point in Fig. 18) but can be varied
were made on the DV level as an overlay over the LB layer. if required through external probe-pad bias.
The bond pads are placed over a metal (M1) ground plane The performance of the circuit is demonstrated for the tag
which is connected to the substrate and the ground pad to code 10001110 in the Fig. 19 showing the timing diagram
prevent any noise from the substrate. for the PISO in strobing the code. Fig. 20 provides all the
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
132 IEEE JOURNAL OF RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION, VOL. 4, NO. 2, JUNE 2020
TABLE III
P OWER B UDGET OF THE T RANSMITTER FOR THE VARIOUS
S UB -B LOCKS IN F IG . 1
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KUMARI AND HASAN: NEW CMOS IMPLEMENTATION FOR MINIATURIZED ACTIVE RFID INSECT TAG AND VHF INSECT TRACKING 133
TABLE IV
T HE S IMULATED F REQUENCY, T IME -P ERIOD AND P ULSE D URATION OF
O UTPUT S IGNALS F ROM E ACH F REQUENCY D IVIDER (FD) TAPPING
P OINT FOR A 132MH Z I NPUT (F ROM THE VCRO O UTPUT ) T HROUGH
A C ASCADE OF 13 F REQUENCY D IVIDERS
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
134 IEEE JOURNAL OF RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION, VOL. 4, NO. 2, JUNE 2020
TABLE V
P ERFORMANCE C OMPARISON OF THE P ROPOSED CMOS VHF I NSECT T ELEMETER TAG W ITH VHF P RIOR -A RTS BASED ON S EVERAL C RITERIA
Fig. 24(b) whose root-mean-square (RMS) value is calculated a much smaller ASIC chip-size compared to the ASIC digital
to be 24 mV. This shows that 99% of the signal power is con- code incorporated in Nano-tag [29] as well as a much smaller
centrated in the 132 MHz fundamental and only 1% power tag weight compared to [3]. For attaching the 10 cm whip-
is distributed among the spurious frequencies. This proves the wire-antenna a bond-wire will be used to first connect from
theoretical prediction in Section III-A, that due to the low the tag-die output-port pad (100µm x 100µm) on the chip
oscillator dynamic current, as well as the low package para- to a metal-pad (with larger spatial dimensions) on the battery
sitics, the supply and the ground noise in the fabricated circuit providing the mechanical support for the chip. The whip wire
is quite negligible and would have no significant effect on antenna will then be attached to this metal-pad resting on the
the oscillator’s stability for this telemeter application. As, dis- battery surface thus completing the connection with the tag-die
cussed earlier this eludes the need of crystal oscillators in transmitter-output.
RFID tag [26]. The verified operation of the LDC burst signal
generation on 130 nm CMOS supports this LDC generation
VII. A NALYSIS OF THE M ODULATED
method on the 28 nm CMOS insect-tag employing 28 FDs.
B URST-M ODE S IGNAL
The frequency spectrum of the transmitted burst is now
VI. P ERFORMANCE C OMPARISON OF THE P ROPOSED VHF analyzed considering here for simplicity a sine-wave approx-
I NSECT T ELEMETER TAG W ITH VHF P RIOR -A RT imation (at the matched external wire antenna output) of the
The complete insect-tag would consist of, a 4 mAH silver- burst-mode modulated carrier signal, f (t) so that,
oxide Sony battery which weighs around 80 mg, a 10 cm long
V(sin(ω0 t) + 1) for logic 1
thin-wire whip-antenna weighing 3 mg, and the transmitter f (t) = (4)
V(sin(ω1 t) + 1) for logic 0
circuit on 1mm2 silicon-chip weighing under 2mg. Hence, the
total weight of the composite tag consisting of all the com- Here, ω0 and ω1 = ω0 /2 are the two carrier frequencies with V
ponents mounted over the battery along-with glob-top epoxy (half of the peak-to-peak carrier signal) being the amplitude
encapsulation (packaging), is expected to be around 95mg and the DC off-set. The Fourier series analysis of the signal is
or less. This would reduce the VHF tag weight by at least possible because the two carrier signals have common multiple
52% and the volume by 58% of the presently existing small- ω1 and are phase synchronized which allows the signal to
est active 200mg VHF telemeter-tag on PCB [3], and hence, be periodic [27]. The Fourier even-coefficients (an ) and the
achieve the original objective of this work. The comparison odd-coefficients (bn ) of the 8-bit coded signal are derived as
of the new CMOS VHF telemeter in terms of tag weight, follows.
dimensions, average current, frequency, power during signal For each logic “1” at kth
1 bit-position from left to right where
generation and transmission, pulse width, pulse interval, and 0 ≤ k1 < 8:
life span with the previous VHF telemeters is provided in the
(K1 +1)T
Table V. The table includes a commercial Nano-tag [28] which 2V 8 2nπ t
an = (sin(ω0 t) + 1) × cos dt (5)
uses a 2.8 mm2 ASIC chip implementing a digital-code for T K1 T T
8
the tag identification and weighs 250mg. This design is 50mg
heavier than the tag in [3] even after some ASIC implementa- When n = 220 , 221 the integral in (5) collapses to,
tion, most likely due the use of discrete oscillator components nπ nπ
8Vω0 T
in addition to the ASIC chip, and hence is not suitable for an = sin × sin (2K 1 + 1) (6)
tracking small insects. The core novelty of this telemeter cir- (Tω0 )2 − (2nπ )2 8 8
cuit lies in the digital low duty-cycle clock generator replacing (K1 +1)T
2V 8 2nπ t
the analog signal generator of [3] which enables the ultimate bn = (sin(ω0 t) + 1) × sin dt (7)
T K18 T T
goal of reduced tag weight and size to facilitate tracking of
tiny creatures. In addition, it will transmit digitally coded sig- When n = 220 , 221 the integral in (7) collapses to,
nal allowing a large number of tags to be identified at the
same frequency and will also eliminate the need for a very 4Vω0 T nπ nπ
bn = sin × cos (2K1 + 1) (8)
stable clock for the tag identification. This is achieved with (Tω0 )2 − (2nπ )2 8 8
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
KUMARI AND HASAN: NEW CMOS IMPLEMENTATION FOR MINIATURIZED ACTIVE RFID INSECT TAG AND VHF INSECT TRACKING 135
VIII. C ONCLUSION
A digital burst-mode insect radio-telemeter tag employing
a new energy-saving low duty-cycle circuit is presented in this
paper. A DRC and pattern-density clean tag-chip designed in
28nm CMOS also results in reduced size and weight along-
Fig. 25. Plot showing the normalized an (with respect to V) vs. frequency. with better tag identification bandwidth. Detailed PVT analysis
for frequency stability and yield including Monte Carlo anal-
ysis has been carried out. A mathematical analysis of the
For each logic “0” at kth
0 bit-position from left to right where burst-mode signal is also provided. In addition, the proposed
0 ≤ k0 < 8: methodology of LDC burst signal generation has been verified
(K0 +1)T by measurements on a fabricated chip in 130 nm CMOS pro-
2V 8 2nπ t
an = (sin(ω1 t) + 1) × cos dt (9) cess. Owing to the small oscillator current, the effect of ground
T K08 T T and supply noise is negligible and does not significantly effect
When n = 220 , 221 the integral in (9) collapses to, the LDC signal stability which makes it quite feasible for the
nπ nπ telemeter application.
4Vω0 T
an = 2 sin × sin (2Ko + 1) (10)
Tω0 8 8 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
2 − (2nπ )2
(K0 +1)T The authors wish to acknowledge MOSIS, USC, for the
2V 8 2nπ t chip fabrication support, and the anonymous reviewers for their
bn = (sin(ω1 t) + 1) × sin dt (11)
T K0 T T comments, which helped improve the quality of the manuscript.
8
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
136 IEEE JOURNAL OF RADIO FREQUENCY IDENTIFICATION, VOL. 4, NO. 2, JUNE 2020
[14] G. C. White and R.A. Garrott, “Estimating animal locations,” in Analysis Meera Kumari (Student Member, IEEE) received
of Wildlife Radio-Tracking Data, London, U.K.: Academic, 2012. the B.Tech. degree in electrical engineering from the
[15] L. Goldberg, H. F. Taylor, J. F. Weller, and D. M. Bloom, “Microwave National Institute of Technology, Agartala, India, in
signal generation with injection-locked laser diodes,” IET Electron. Lett., 2016. She is currently pursuing the Ph.D. degree
vol. 19, no. 13, pp. 491–493, Jun. 1983. in electronics engineering with Massey University,
[16] M. Amourah and M. Whately, “A novel switched-capacitor-filter based Auckland, New Zealand. She has coauthored several
low-area and fast-locking PLL,” in Proc. IEEE Conf. Custom Integr. journal articles. Her research interests include RFID
Circuit (CICC), Sep. 2015, pp. 1–6. tag design, mixed signal integrated circuit design,
[17] S. Bhowmik, S. N. Pradhan, and B. K. Bhattacharyya, “Clock jitter and VLSI design.
reduction and flat frequency generation in PLL using autogenerated con-
trol feedback,” IEEE Trans. Compon. Packag. Manuf. Technol., vol. 7,
no. 11, pp. 1832–1841, Nov. 2017.
[18] K. B. Unchwaniwala and M. F. Caggiano, “Electrical analysis of IC
packaging with emphasis on different ball grid array packages,” in
Proc. 51st Electron. Compon. Technol. Conf., Orlando, FL, USA, 2001,
pp. 1496–1501.
[19] J. Li and S. M. R. Hasan, “Design and performance analysis of a 866-
MHz low-power optimized CMOS LNA for UHF RFID,” IEEE Trans.
Ind. Electron., vol. 60, no. 5, pp. 1840–1849, May 2013.
[20] Bee Keeping Organization. [Online]. Available:
https://www.uky.edu/Ag/Entomology/ythfacts/4h/beekeep/basbeop.htm
[21] Waikato Domestic Beekeepers Association. [Online]. Available: S. M. Rezaul Hasan (Senior Member, IEEE)
http://www.waikatobeekeepers.org.nz/bee-information/bee-facts/ received the Ph.D. degree in electronics engineer-
[22] A. J. Barker and E. L. Russell, “Multidimensional process corner deriva- ing from UCLA in 1985. From 1983 to 1986,
tion using surrogate based simultaneous yield analysis,” U.S. Patent he was a VLSI Design Engineer with Xerox
7 716 023 B2, May 11, 2010. Microelectronics, El Segundo, CA, USA, where he
[23] T. McConaghy, K. Breen, J. Dyck, and A. Gupta, 3-Sigma Verification was involved in the design of CMOS VLSI micro-
and Design. New York, NY, USA: Springer, 2013. [Online]. Available: processors. In 1986, he moved to the Asia–Pacific
https://m.eet.com/media/1177441/variation-aware%20ch4a.pdf region and served several institutions, including
[24] S. Paul et al., “A sub-cm3 energy-harvesting stacked wireless sensor Nanyang Technological University, Singapore, from
node featuring a near-threshold voltage IA-32 microcontroller in 14-nm 1986 to 1988, the Curtin University of Technology,
tri-gate CMOS for always-ON always-sensing applications,” IEEE J. Australia, from 1990 to 1991, and Universiti Sains
Solid-State Circuits, vol. 52, no. 4, pp. 961–971, Apr. 2017. Malaysia, Malaysia, from 1992 to 2000. He held an Associate Professor
[25] Sony SR Micro Battery Available. [Online]. Available: position with University Sains Malaysia, where he was the Coordinator of
https://www.sony.net/Products/MicroBattery/sr/spec.html the Analog and VLSI Research Laboratory. From 2000 to 2004, he was
[26] Y.-H. Kim, Y.-C. Choi, M.-W. Seo, S.-S. Yoo, and H.-J. Yoo, “A CMOS an Associate Professor of microelectronics, integrated circuit design, and
transceiver for a multistandard 13.56-MHz RFID reader SoC,” IEEE VLSI design with the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering,
Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 57, no. 5, pp. 1563–1572, May 2010. University of Sharjah, UAE. He currently leads the Analog and VLSI Design
[27] Digital Image Processing—University of Cape Town. [Online]. Research Group, Massey University, New Zealand, where he is serving as
Available: http://www.dip.ee.uct.ac.za/∼nicolls/lectures/eee482f/13_ a Senior Faculty Member in computer engineering. He has authored 78 journal
fsk_2up.pdf and 100 conference papers in the areas of analog, digital, RF, and mixed-signal
[28] Holohil Transmitters. [Online]. Available: https://www.holohil.com/ IC design, MEMS sensors, bioelectronics, and VLSI design. His present areas
transmitters/lb-2x/ of interests include analog integrated circuit and VLSI microsystem design,
[29] Nano Tags. [Online]. Available: http://www.lotek.com/nanotagFW- CMOS MEMS sensors, and biological circuit design. He received the Sharjah
0718.pdf Award for Outstanding Publication in IC Design.
Authorized licensed use limited to: Faculty of Science & Technology IFHE. Downloaded on March 09,2022 at 10:55:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.