Challenges and Solutions For Moisture Sensitive API Formulation
Challenges and Solutions For Moisture Sensitive API Formulation
Challenges and Solutions For Moisture Sensitive API Formulation
Introduction
Today, formulators are looking for alternative processes to reformulate existing products or to formulate
New Chemical Entities (NCEs) since most of them are poorly water-soluble. More and more,
formulators want to develop new galenics and textures, to have specific release kinetics, to formulate
several actives in the same finished dosage form... Moreover, pharmaceutical industries want to
develop forms targeting specific population such as children and elderly people. Improvement of drug
performance is also strategic for formulators. The improvement of bioavailability, safety, the reduction
of toxicity & side effects, the controlled release are some key parameters for formulators.
In formulation, one of basic requirements is that the pharmaceutical active ingredient (API) remains
stable in the finished dosage form until the end of its shelf life to ensure efficacy and patient safety.
The degradation of the API can occur through thermal degradation, oxidation, UV, microorganisms or
hydrolysis [1].
The physical and chemical properties of pharmaceutical solids are critically dependent on the presence
of water: e.g. flow, compaction, dissolution, stability, storage, processing into formulations and
final product packaging [2] .
Moisture has a real impact on the formulation stability due to its influence in the glass transition
temperature of the compounds.
Atmospheric humidity is one of the main sources of moisture that influences chemically or physically
the active ingredient. Many APIs but also excipients are hygroscopic in nature and need to be protected
from moisture.
Specific attention needs to be given when formulating such ingredients in order to prevent degradation
due to hydrolysis [3].
In the following paper we will describe different ways of protecting the API through formulation using
either a moisture absorbent, a film coating designed to prevent moisture uptake or lipid solvent-free
solutions.
Caking of powder mixes has been an issue in the industry for many years [4].Basically the mechanism
for caking is the absorption of moisture by one ingredient resulting in the agglomeration of particles.
Formation of caked powder has a negative impact on product manufacturability and quality and can
lead to the hydrolysis of the API.
1
One way to protect the formula from moisture is to use a tabletting excipient
designed to absorb water in the place of the active in order to prevent its
degradation.
Amongst such excipients we can find magnesium aluminium silicate, carboxymethylcellulose or calcium
carbonate [5]. All those excipients have porous structure and the ability to bound water.
SEPPIC’s Partially pre-gelatinized starch Sepistab™ ST 200 possess those characteristics as well and
hence can play the role of anti-caking agent in a tablet formula. On top of that Sepistab ST 200
compressibility is very good compared to the other anti-caking agents.
Sepistab™ ST 200 is a co-processed excipient that contains native and pre-gelatinized starch. As a
consequence it combines the benefits of both ingredients. In addition to its excellent flowability and
compactability behavior, its specific surface area at 0.5 m²/g -compared to around 0.25m²/g for the
others partially pre-gelatinized starches- as well as its low water activity makes Sepistab™ ST 200 a
good candidate for moisture absorption.
The spherical shape of Sepistab™ ST 200 gives the excipient very good flowability as we can see in
Graph 1. Moreover Sepistab™ ST 200 water activity (aw) is the lowest of the excipients tested. A low aw
indicates that the excipient contains less free water. The water it contains is trapped inside the structure
– it is referred to as bound water. Only free water is available to potentially hydrolyze the API.
This parameter together with a porous structure makes Sepistab™ ST 200 a perfectly versatile
excipient also adapted to moisture adsorption.
2
14 0.6
12 0.5
10
Time for flowability
0.4
8
Activity
0.3
Water
6
0.2
4
2 0.1
0 0
Native starch Pregelatinized Sepistab™ ST 200 MCC Lactose
starch Time (sec)
Water activity (Aw)
Sepistab™ ST 200 level of use is generally 10 to 30 % in a formula as it can replace several excipients
at once. It is adapted to capsule filling and tablets manufacturing.
Sepistab™ ST 200 is currently used in many marketed drugs worldwide.
2. Film Coating
Another solution for protection of a finished drug product is through packaging. Although efficient it
does not exclude moisture uptake during multiple openings. Protecting the cores with a moisture barrier
film is appropriate, since it also eliminates this problem. An ideal moisture barrier coating should exhibit
low permeability to water vapor without compromising its dissolution functionality [6]. For a film-coating
to be able to protect the core, it must contain a hydrophobic ingredient. This ingredient can be the
polymer itself or a hydrophobic plasticizer.
3
2.1 Sepifilm™ LP - Product characteristics
SEPPIC’s Sepifilm™ LP range has been used for over 30 years for moisture protection purpose.
Sepifilm™ LP is a ready-to-use film coating range of excipients containing stearic acid that prevents the
moisture from reaching the core of the dosage form.
Sepifilm™ LP products can be applied on powder, pellets or tablets at various weight gain depending
on the hygroscopicity of the formula and the protection to be achieved.
500 mg Ranitidine tablets (Table 1) were coated with various ready-to-use solutions in order to test the
products performances regarding moisture protection.
PVA-based coating designed for moisture protection was compared to Sepifilm™ LP 030.
5% weight gains were applied for all film-coating using the vendors recommendation for application and
the swelling of the tablets was measured during 8 days at 25°C and 75 %RH.
The results in Graph 2 show that ranitidine tablets coated with Sepifilm™ LP 030 swelled less than the
other tablets, indicating that the coating prevents moisture from entering the core. Uncoated tablets
became too soft to be handled after 3 days.
16
14
12
10
Swelling (%)
uncoated tablets
8 PVA-based coating
6 Sepifilm LP 030
0
0 2 4 6 8 10
Days
Graph 2: Ranitidine tablets swelling with different coatings, 25°C, 75 %RH
4
2.3 Sepifilm™ LP Dynamic Vapor Sorption
Dynamic Vapor Sorption (DVS) is a gravimetric technique that measures how quickly and how much of
a solvent is absorbed by a sample such as dry powder absorbing water. It does this by varying the
vapor concentration surrounding the sample and measuring the change in mass which this produces.
500 mg SEPIFIT™ Protect tablets, a hygroscopic nutraceutical active (Table 2) containing polyphenols
were coated with various ready-to-use solutions in order to test the products performances regarding
moisture protection.
Tablets were placed in the DVS measuring device. The percentage of relative humidity was gradually
increased from 0%RH up to 90%RH (sorption cycle) and then decreased (desorption cycle). The
weight variation of the tablet was recorded continuously thanks to a microbalance.
The maximum weight variation is an important parameter because it reflects the water uptake of the
tablet. The final weight variation is the second parameter we take into account since it represents the
amount of water trapped inside the core and that can possibly hydrolyze the API.
3.5
2.5
Cycle 1 - uncoated tablets
Change in mass in %
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
-0.5
% RH
Graph 3: DVS recording of tablets coated with different coatings
5
Uncoated tablets adsorb much more moisture than coated ones but they
dry more as well. The maximum water uptake is 3.26% but the final moisture
content is 0.15%. On the contrary coated tablets absorb less moisture but the moisture
remains a more inside the core. It is due to the fact that the coating forms a barrier to prevent the water
from entering the core. However, coating being a process where water is used, there is always some
amount of water brought to the core. The aim of moisture protection film-coating is to include as less
water as possible.
We can notice that tablets coated with Sepifilm LP 030 absorb less water than PVA-based coated
tablets but moreover the remaining water content is lower, making Sepifilm LP 030 the best choice for
moisture protection in that case.
It is possible to combine both anticaking agent and moisture protection coating to improve the
formulation.
If the tablets are too sensitive to be coated with a water based process there are solutions using
solvents (ethanol most of the time). In that case SEPPIC’s proposal would be to use Sepifilm™ LP 914
based on HPC or Sepifilm™ SN based on shellac gum. Both coatings can be used in 100% solvent
and give excellent core sealing for extremely hygroscopic APIs.
Pharmaceutical products can be administrated by different routes of administration. There are three
main routes of administration: oral, topical and injectable. The oral route of administration represents
the principle market share for the pharmaceutical drug products. Each route of administration has its
benefits and drawbacks and has specific requirements. For the oral route, the main benefits are ease of
use and cost efficiency.
However, oral administrations are limited by problems related to physic-chemical properties of the drug,
including poor solubility, low permeability, instability and rapid metabolism. All of these parameters
decrease oral bioavailability.
6
Substances containing a fatty acid in their chemical structure are referred to as
lipid-based excipients. Waxes, vegetable oil and its derivatives, polyoxylglycerides, fatty
acids, monoacylglycerides, diacylglycerides, triacylglycerides, animal fats, polyglycerides, PEG fatty
acid esters, sucrose fatty acid esters. [9]
Lipid-based excipients are integrated in various types of formulations: solutions, SEDDS (Self
Emulsifying Drug Delivery System) for example and can be used in various technologies such as melt
granulation, extrusion and coating, spray congealing and drying, adsorption on solid carriers;
processing solid liquid nanoparticles.[7]
No/limited dispersion
I Oil : 100% Dustasteride (Avodart®)
Requires digestion
SEDDS
Oil : 40-80%
II Emulsion Alfacalcidol (One-Alpha®)
Surfactant (low HLB) : 20-60%
Will be digested
SMEDDS/SNEDDS
Oil : <20-80% Fine emulsion
III A : Ritonavir (Norvir®)
III Surfactant (High HLB): 20-50% Transparent dispersion
III B : Cyclosporin A (Neoral) ®
Cosolvents : 0-50% Digestion may not be
necessary
Surfactant (Low HLB): 0-20% Lipid-free
IV Surfactant (High HLB): 30-80% Micellar solution Amprenavir (Agenerase®)
Cosolvents : 0-50% Limited digestion
Table 3: The Lipid Formulation Classification System [8]
The main factors that determine the choice of excipients for lipid-based formulations are miscibility,
solvent capacity, self dispersibility, behavior in the digestive system, regulatory issues, toxicity,
chemical stability, melting point…[7]
Lipid formulations can be also used for coating either to modify drug release characteristics or to
protect against humidity for example.
Lipidic coating is an alternative to aqueous and solvent-based coating. Lipidic coating provides eco-
friendly, cost-effective and time-saving processes.
Lipid coat increases the hydrophobicity of the final product, inhibiting the uptake of moisture from
environment and improving stability of the product.
When lipid-based formulations are used, it is necessary to take into account some characteristics such
as lipid crystallinity changes which can affect the product performance overtime. [9]
7
3.2 Hot Melt Coating
3.2.1 Description
Hot Melt Coating technique is the application of a fine layer of coating material over a substrate. The
coating materials are in molten state when it is applied on the substrate, then solidified by cooling.
No solvent is used in hot melt coating process, therefore, solvent elimination, treatment is not required.
HMC is cost effective, efficient, precise, simple and allow easy compliance with regulatory
requirements.
Various substrates can be coated with Hot Melt Coating: powders, tablets, pellets, capsules, granules,
etc. with different characteristics. The substrate can be lipophilic or hydrophilic in solid or liquid form.
The mean particle size of capsule is included between 20 and 1500µm and a high loaded of API is
possible (i.e up to 90%).
Regular forms (i.e tablets, capsules) as well as innovative forms like orodispersible granules (ODGs) in
stick packs can be obtained with Hot Melt Coating.
Different lipid-based excipients can be used in Hot Melt Coating like vegetable oils and its derivatives,
waxes or surfactants. Excipients are carefully chosen depending on their melting point, their behavior in
the digestive system or the functionality that they can offer (i.e controlled release, taste masking). Lipid-
based excipients, thermostable with a relatively low melting point (< 80°C) are used in Hot Melt coating.
These excipients are functional, safe and have a well-established history of use in oral dosage form.
3.2.3 Process
The Hot Melt Coating process is easy. It is composed of the following steps:
8
Diagram 1: Diagram for Hot Melt Coating Process in bottom spray fluidized bed coater
3.2.4 Equipment
There are various Hot Melt Coating techniques but commonly used equipments are bottom spray
fluidized bed coaters.
Alternative for bottom spray are top spray or tangential spray fluid bed coaters.
Pan coater can be also used for Hot Melt Coating as alternative equipment to fluidized bed coaters.
Hot Melt Coating is a multi-purpose technology and can be used for various applications:
SEPPIC developed solutions for Hot Melt Coating technology for taste masking and/or controlled
release. These solutions are mixtures composed of waxes and surfactants. By modifying the coating
thickness, the desired controlled release profile can be obtained.
9
100.0%
90.0%
80.0% 6% weight gain
% release of urea
70.0%
8% weight gain
60.0%
10% weight gain
50.0%
40.0% 11% weight gain
Conclusion
While developing a formulation for a moisture sensitive drug, the following strategies need to be
considered during the entire development process:
Designing the dosage form with non-hygroscopic/low water-activity excipients
Use anti-caking excipients
Providing the dosage form with a moisture protective coating (either water-base solutions or lipid-based
coatings)
Packaging the dosage form with an appropriate moisture-resistant material.
SEPPIC is your partner of choice for the formulation of moisture sensitive APIs in Oral Solid Dosage
Forms. Thanks to our many years of expertise we can provide data, trainings, technical visits as well as
all documents required for the registration of you finished dosage form.
For contact or more information visit us on our website, www.seppic.com
10
References
3. Joshi et Petereit
Film coatings for taste masking and moisture protection
Int. J. Pharm., 457 (2013), pp. 395-406
4. Carpin et al,
Caking of lactose: a critical review
Trends in Food Science & Technology, Vol. 53, 2016, p. 1-122016
6. Mwesigwa et al,
An investigation into moisture barrier film coating efficacy and its relevance to drug stability in solid dosage forms
Int J Pharm ;497(2016), pp70-77
8. Colin W. Pouton
Formulation of poorly water-soluble drugs for oral administration: Physiochemical and physiological issues and
lipid formulation classification system.
European Journal Pharmaceutical Sciences 29 (2006). 278-287
11