Level I - Quantitative Methods: Probability Concepts
Level I - Quantitative Methods: Probability Concepts
Level I - Quantitative Methods: Probability Concepts
Probability Concepts
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
www.ift.world
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
Graphs, charts, tables, examples, and figures are copyright 2020, CFA Institute.
nstitute.
99 ah
Reproduced and republished with permission from CFA Institute. All rights
ghts reserved.
reser ed.
M
1
Contents
1. Introduction
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
4. Topics in Probability
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 2
1. Introduction
• Investment decision require an evaluation of risk
om 1
.c 60
relevant for investment managers
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 3
2. Probability, Expected Value, and Variance
• Random variable is an uncertain quantity / number
om 1
.c 60
• Exhaustive events
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
• Probability of an event, P(Ei), is between 0 and 1
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
• Sum of the probabilities of mutually exclusive and exhaustive events
ents = 1
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 4
Ways of Estimating Probability
• Empirical Probability: calculated by analyzing past data
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
• Subjective Probability: less formal and involves personal judgment
ment
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 5
Practice Question
Which of the following type of probability is most likely to be based on logical analysis?
A. Empirical probability
B. A Priori probability
C. Subjective probability
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
Answer: B
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 6
Probability Stated as Odds
• Given P(E), odds for E = P(E) / [1 – P(E)]
om 1
• Odds against E = [1 – P(E)]/P(E), reciprocal of the odds for E
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
• Give odds against E of “a to b”, the implied probability of E is b/(a + b))
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 7
Practice Question
Given that the odds for the company’s share price to fall below $45 are 1 to 5, which of
the following is most likely to be the probability of this event?
A. 0.17
B. 0.20
C. 0.83
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
Answer: A
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 8
Conditional vs. Unconditional
Unconditional probability: P(A), the probability of an event regardless of the
outcomes of other events
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 9
Joint Probability and Multiplication Rule
The probability that both A and B will occur is their joint probability: P(AB)
Compute joint probability using the multiplication rule
P(AB) = P(A|B) x P(B)
P(A|B) = P(AB)/ P(B), P(B) ≠ 0
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
P (stock price increases) = P(S)
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
P (stock price will increase given interest rates decrease) = P(S|D) = 70%
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
Probability of a stock price increase and a interest rate decrease:
w 4 li
w 20 aka
P(SD) = P(S|D) x P(D) = 0.7 x 0.4 = 0.28 = 28%
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 10
Addition Rule for Probabilities
The probability that A or B occurs, or both occur, is equal to:
P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B) – P(AB)
Example:
P(Price of A increases) = P(A) = 0.5
P(Price of B increases) = P(B) = 0.7
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
P(Price of A and B increases) = P(AB) = 0.3
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
P(A or B) = 0.5 + 0.7 – 0.3 = 0.9
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 11
Practice Question
Irfanullah & Co. has issued two callable bonds with a maturity of 2 and 5 years
respectively. The probability that Bond A will be called is 60% and the probability that
Bond B will be called is 50%. The probability that at least one of the bonds will be
called is closest to?
A. 0.8
B. 0.3
C. 0.83
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
Answer: A
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
usingg
The probability that at least one of the bonds will be called can be calculated using
ak / C
ah 58 ok
Addition rule of probability which is:
.m 1 o
w 11 B
P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B) – P(A and B) where P(A and B) is P(A) x (PB)
w 4 li
w 20 aka
P(A or B) = 0.6 + 0.5 – 0.6 x 0.5 = 0.8
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 12
Independent and Dependent Events
Independent Events
Occurrence of one event does not influence the occurrence of the other
P(A|B) = P(A) or equivalently P(B|A) = P(B)
Multiplication rule: P(AB) = P(A)P(B)
Concept Checker: What is the addition rule for independent events?
Dependent Events
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
Two events are not independent
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
Knowing the outcome of one tells you something about the probability of thee other
oth
o her
ak / C
ah 58 ok
Concept Checker: What is the relationship between dependent events and d
.m 1 o
w 11 B
conditional probability?
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 13
Practice Question
If events A and B are mutually exclusive, then which of the following is true?
A. P(A|B) = P(A)
B. P(AB) = P(A) x P(B)
C. P(A or B) = P(A) + P(B)
om 1
Answer: C
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
Mutually exclusive events are those events which cannot happen together, i.e.
al 98 en
ak / C
there is no intersection between two events. Therefore, both P (A|B) and P (AB)
AB
B)
ah 58 ok
must be equal to zero.
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 14
The Total Probability Rule
In investment analysis we often formulate a set of mutually exclusive and exhaustive
scenarios and then estimate the probability of a particular event
om 1
.c 60
If we have more than two scenarios:
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
P(A) = P(AS1) + P(AS2) +… + P(ASn) = P(A|S1) P(S1) + P(A|S2) P(S2) + … + P(A|Sn) P(Sn)
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
The total probability rule enables us to state unconditional probabilities
es in terms
ms of
term
w 20 aka
conditional probabilities
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 15
Expected Value of a Random Variable
Probability-weighted average of the possible outcomes of the random variable
Example: A project’s cash flow for the upcoming year depends on the state of the economy, as
shown in the table below. What is the expected value of the cash flow?
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
Good 0.3 50
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
Average 0.5 40
ah 58 ok
Weak 0.2 20
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
Expected value = 39
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 16
Practice Question
The probability distribution for the dividend yield of Donna Diamonds Ltd is tabulated
as follows:
Probability Dividend Yield
0.40 6.4%
0.20 7.2%
0.15 8.1%
0.25 6.8%
om 1
Which of the following is most likely to be the expected dividend yield?
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
A. 6.40%
ak / C
ah 58 ok
B. 6.92%
.m 1 o
w 11 B
C. 7.13%
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 17
Solution
Answer: B
n
E ( X ) P ( Xi ) Xi
i 1
E(X) = (0.4 × 6.4) + (0.2 × 7.2) + (0.15× 8.1) + (0.25× 6.8) = 6.92%
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 18
Variance of a Random Variable
Expected value of squared deviations from the random variable’s expected value
Recall: Expected value is the probability weighted average
Example: A project’s cash flow for the upcoming year depends on the state of the economy, as
shown in the table below. What is the variance of the cash flow? What is the standard deviation?
om 1
Average 0.5 40
.c 60
(40 – 39)2 = 1 0.50
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
Weak 0.2 20 (20 – 39)2 = 361 72.20
ak / C
Variance 109.00
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
Std Dev 10.44
44
4
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
σ2(X) = E{[xi – E(X)]2} = ΣP(xi)[xi – E(X)]2
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 19
Practice Question
The probability distribution for the rate of return for Imogen Investments Ltd is
tabulated as follows:
Probability Rate of Return
0.30 12.4%
0.25 7.2%
0.20 10.8%
0.25 8.6%
om 1
Which of the following is most likely to be the variance for the above distribution??
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
A. 2.07
ak / C
ah 58 ok
B. 4.28
.m 1 o
w 11 B
C. 9.83
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 20
Solution
Answer: B
n
(X) = P (X) [X - E(X)]2
i 1
E (X) = (12.4 x 0.3) + (7.2 x 0.25) + (10.8 x 0.2) + (8.6 x 0.25) = 9.83
2 (X) = (0.30) (12.4 - 9.83)2 + (0.25) (7.2 - 9.83)2 + (0.20) (10.8 - 9.83)2 + (0.25) (8.60 - 9.83)2 = 4.28
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 21
Compute σ of a Random Variable using the Calculator
State Prob. CF Keystrokes Explanation Display
Good 0.3 50 [2nd] [DATA] Enter data entry mode
Average 0.5 40 [2nd] [CLR WRK] Clear data registers X01
Weak 0.2 20 50 [ENTER] 1st possible value of random variable X01 = 50
[↓] 30 [ENTER] Probability of 30% for X01 Y01 = 30
[↓] 40 [ENTER] 2nd possible value of random variable X02 = 40
[↓] 50 [ENTER] Probability of 50% for X02 Y02 = 50
[↓] 20 [ENTER] 3rd possible value of random variable X03 = 20
[↓] 20 [ENTER] Probability of 20% for X03 Y03 = 20
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
[2nd] [STAT] Puts calculator into stats mode.
ks 65
al 98 en
[2nd] [SET] Press repeatedly till you see Æ 1-V
ak / C
ah 58 ok
[↓] Total number of entries N=1
100
00
0
.m 1 o
w 11 B
[↓] Expected value of random variable X = 39
w 4 li
w 20 aka
[↓] Sample standard deviation Sx = 10
10.49
99 ah
[↓] Population standard deviation σx = 10.44
M
www.ift.world 22
Total Probability Rule for Expected Value
Recall that the total probability rule enables Similarly, we can state expected values in
us to state unconditional probabilities in terms of conditional expected values
terms of conditional probabilities
P(A) = P(A|S) P(S) + P(A|SC) P(SC) E(X) = E(X|S) P(S) + E(X|SC) P(SC)
P(A) = P(A|S1) P(S1) + P(A|S2) P(S2) + … + E(X) = E(X|S1) P(S1) + E(X|S2) P(S2) + … +
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
P(A|Sn) P(Sn) E(X|Sn) P(Sn)
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 23
Example
What is the expected price of a stock at the end of the current period given the following
information: probability that interest rates will decline = 0.4. If interest rates decline there is a 75%
chance that stock price will be $100 versus a 25% chance that the stock price will be $90. If interest
rates do not decline there is a 50% chance that the stock price will be 80 versus a 50% chance that
stock price will be 70.
Price = 100
E(X) = E(X|S) P(S) + E(X|SC) P(SC) Prob = 0.3
0.75
Price = 90
0.4 0.25
om 1
Prob = 0.1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
Exp Stock
ak / C
Price=? Price = 80
ah 58 ok
0.50 Prob = 0.3
.m 1 o
w 11 B
0.6
w 4 li
w 20 aka
0.50 Price = 70
99 ah
Prob = 0.3
M
www.ift.world 24
3. Portfolio Expected Return and Variance
Portfolio expected return is the weighted average expected return of
a portfolio with n securities
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
Computing portfolio variance is a more complicated
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
Understand covariance and correlation first
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 25
Covariance
Covariance is a measure of how two variables move together
RA = 20% 0.15
E(RA) = 13%
RA = 15% 0.6
RA = 4% 0.25
E(RB) = 18%
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
Covariance between RA and RB is:
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
0.15 (0.20 – 0.13) (0.40 – 0.18) + 0.6 (0.15 – 0.13) (0.20 – 0.18) + 0.25 (0.04 – 0.13) (0 – 0.18))
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
= 0.0066
w 4 li
The sample covariance is the average value of n
Ri,t Ri R j,t R j
w 20 aka
the product of the deviations of observations on Cov Ri , R j n 1
99 ah
two random variables from their sample means. i 1
M
www.ift.world 26
Covariance and Correlation
Covariance is a measure of how two variables move together
Values range from minus infinity to positive infinity
Difficult to interpret
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ρ (Ri, Rj) = Cov(Ri, Rj) / σ (Ri) σ (Rj) Æ this represents forward-looking population correlation.
ak / C
relaat on.
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 27
Correlation
What is the correlation between the returns on A and B?
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ρ (Ri, Rj) = Cov(Ri, Rj) / σ (Ri) σ (Rj)
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
= 0.0066 / (0.0548 x 0.1229)
w 4 li
w 20 aka
= 0.98
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 28
Practice Question
Two companies, Lemon Co. and Demon Co. have the following probability
distributions in different economic situations:
Scenario P(Scenario) Expected Expected
Calculate the covariance of the
Returns of Returns of
Lemon Co. Demon Co. expected returns for Lemon and
Recession 0.25 2% 4% Demon.
Normal 0.5 8% 10%
Boom 0.25 12% 16%
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4
w 20
99
www.ift.world 29
Solution
E[L] = (2% x 0.25) + (8% x 0.5) + (12% x 0.25) = 7.5%
om 1
.c 60
= 0.000825 + 0 + 0.000675
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
= 0.0015
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 30
Practice Question
Two companies, Lemon Co. and Demon Co. have the following probability
distributions in different economic situations:
Scenario P(Scenario) Expected Expected
Calculate the correlation of the
Returns of Returns of
Lemon Co. Demon Co. expected returns for Lemon and
Recession 0.25 2% 4% Demon.
Normal 0.5 8% 10%
Boom 0.25 12% 16%
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ρ (Ri, Rj) = Cov(Ri, Rj) / σ (Ri) σ (Rj)
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
= 0.0015 / (0.0357 x 0.0424)
w 4 li
w 20 aka
= 0.99
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 31
Portfolio Expected Return and Variance
My portfolio consists of two stocks, Oracle and Mindtree. Oracle represents 60% percent of the
portfolio and Mindtree the remaining 40%. Oracle has an expected return of 12% and a
standard deviation of 16%. Mindtree has an expected return of 16% and a standard deviation
of 24%. The covariance is 0.0269. What is the expected return and variance of my portfolio?
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
σ2(RP) = w12σ12(R1) + w22σ22(R2) + 2w1w2Cov(R1R2)
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4
w 20
99
www.ift.world 32
Scatter Plot
• A scatter plot is a graphical representation of correlation.
• In a scatter plot, each observation is represented as a point, and the points are not
connected.
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 33
Limitations of Correlation Analysis
1) Correlation only assesses the strength
of a linear relationship.
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
4) Correlations can be spurious.
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 34
• Bayes’ Formula
• Principles of Counting
www.ift.world
4. Topics In Probability
M
99 ah
w 20 aka
w 4 li
w 11 B
.m 1 o
ah 58 ok
ak / C
al 98 en
ib 20 te
oo 6 r
35
ks 65
.c 60
om 1
4.1 Bayes’ Formula
Bayes' formula allows us to adjust our viewpoint when we receive new information
P(E | I) = P(E) x P(I|E) / P(I)
Example:
Event: P(EPS exceed expectation) = 0.50
P(EPS meet expectation) = 0.30
P(EPS below expectation) = 0.20
P (Company expands | EPS exceed) = 0.75
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
P (Company expands | EPS meet) = 0.20
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
P (Company expands | EPS below) = 0.05
ak / C
ah 58 ok
New Information: Company expands
.m 1 o
w 11 B
Calculate P(I) using the total probability rule
w 4 li
w 20 aka
Calculate P(E | I)
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 36
4.2 Principles of Counting
• Labeling
• Combinations
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
• Permutations
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 37
Multiplication Rule
om 1
ways
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
• Number of ways in which k tasks can be done
.m 1 o
w 11 B
is: n1 x n2 x n3 … x nk
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 38
n factorial = n! = n(n-1)(n-2)…1
www.ift.world
Factorial
M
99 ah
w 20 aka
w 4 li
w 11 B
.m 1 o
ah 5 8 ok
ak / C
al 98 en
ib 20 te
oo 6 r
39
ks 65
.c 60
om 1
Labeling
You have n items of which each can receive one of k labels. The number of items that
receive label "1" is n1 and the number that receive label "2" is n2, and so on.
For example: A portfolio consists of eight stocks. The goal is to designate four of the
stocks as "long-term holds," designate three of the stocks as "short-term holds," and
designate one stock a "sell." How many ways can these labels be assigned to the eight gh
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
stocks?
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
Answer: (8!) / (4!x3!x1!) = 280
w 4
w 20
99
www.ift.world 40
Permutations
Number of ways to choose r objects from a total of
n objects when the order in which the r objects are
chosen does matter
n Pr = n! / (n - r)!
om 1
to sell three stocks. How many ways can we choose
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
three of the eight to sell if order of sale does
al 98 en
ak / C
matter?
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 41
Combinations
Number of ways to choose r objects from total of n
objects when the order in which the r objects are
chosen does NOT matter.
nCr = n! / (n - r)!r!
om 1
stocks from a portfolio that consists of six
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
stocks. How many ways can the four stocks be
al 98 en
ak / C
sold when the order of the sale is NOT
ah 5 8 ok
important?
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 42
Summary
• Probability
Mutually exclusive and exhaustive
Conditional probability
Multiplication rule
Addition rule
Total probability rule
• Expected Value
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
• Variance
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
• Covariance, Correlation, Scatter plot
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
• Expected value and variance of a portfolio
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
• Counting
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 43
Conclusion
om 1
.c 60
oo 6 r
ib 20 te
ks 65
al 98 en
ak / C
ah 58 ok
.m 1 o
w 11 B
w 4 li
w 20 aka
99 ah
M
www.ift.world 44