Teacher'S Perception Towards On-Campus Gender Based Violence
Teacher'S Perception Towards On-Campus Gender Based Violence
Teacher'S Perception Towards On-Campus Gender Based Violence
Submitted By:
BRAIKHNA AMAN
Supervised By
This thesis is submitted to the institute of peace and conflict studies university of
Peshawar as per the requirement for the award of
MASTERS
Submitted By:
BRAIKHNA AMAN
Supervised By:
i
ABSTRACT
The present study “Teacher’s Perception Towards On-Campus Gender Based
Violence” in the different departments of the University of Peshawar. The key
role of this study to explain the idea of faculty staff at various departments about
the gender based violence . Also to study the dimensions of gender based
violence. For this purpose we have collection an information from respondents in
which there were male teachers and female teachers. According to the research
study different dimension of the violence were found in the students of university
of Peshawar e.g physical violence physiological torture, mental torture, jealousy,
sexual violence and many more. In all these males have the key role as perpetrator
of violence in the modes and manifestations, where as the sexual assaults are kept
as confidential in fear of social stigmatization.
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGMENT...........................................................................................i
ABSTRACT.............................................................................................................ii
CHAPTER-1...........................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................1
1.1 BACKGROUND.......................................................................................1
1.2 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY..........................................................3
1.3 AIMS AND OBJECTIVE.........................................................................4
1.4 HYPOTHESIS...........................................................................................4
1.5 RESEARCH QUESTION.........................................................................4
CHAPTER-2...........................................................................................................5
LITERATURE REVIEW......................................................................................5
2.1 WHAT IS GENDER BASED VIOLENCE ?...........................................5
2.2 TYPES OF GENDER BASED VIOLENCE............................................5
2.2.1 Physical Violence:..............................................................................5
2.2.2 Sexual Violence:................................................................................5
2.2.3 Emotional Violence:...........................................................................5
2.2.4 Spiritual Violence:.............................................................................6
2.2.5 Verbal Violence:................................................................................6
2.3 GENDER BASED VIUOLENCE IN VNIVERSITY...............................6
2.4 HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF GENDER BASED VIOLENCE....6
CHAPTER-3.........................................................................................................10
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY.......................................................................10
3.1 Topic:.......................................................................................................10
3.2 Objectives:...............................................................................................10
3.3 Hypothesis:..............................................................................................10
3.4 Research Question:..................................................................................10
3.5 Methodology:..........................................................................................10
3.6 Tools of data collection:..........................................................................11
3.7 Sample size:.............................................................................................11
3.8 Sampling technique:................................................................................11
CHAPTER-4.........................................................................................................12
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION..........................................................................12
CHAPTER-5.........................................................................................................20
CONCLUSION.....................................................................................................20
iii
REFERENCES.................................................................................................21
CHAPTER-1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND
1
institutional and socioemotional dimensions. Involving different stakeholders, in a
democratic manner can develop violence free systems, whereas if social morale of
certain stakeholders is undermined usually in a political climate of egocentric,
competition-oriented attitudes and ideologies, can lead to eruption of violence. In
institutes, denial of recognition and the possibility of violence would be
recognised as an outcome of the increasingly individualistic, examination-oriented
systems, as demonstrated by (Clive Harber&Sakade, 2009) and Davies, (2004).
Universities though represent the outside social norms yet some key differences
are there that may leave different imprints on the psychology of its stakeholders.
This study explores the subject of gender based violence in the University of
Peshawar. The University of Peshawar in located in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and
thus has imprints of Pakhtun culture on its dynamics. Ethnicity wise, most
students are Pakhtun, followed by Chitralis, Sirakis, and Hindko speaking
population. This changes the dynamics from a culturally isolated system outside to
a close system with multiple varied cultures in coexistence. Thus university
students are exposed to an environment of cultural acceptance in the subtlest
manner.
More importantly the Gender based division, is almost 50-50, with few
departments having a bias towards one gender or another, for instance the
department of Geology, UOP, has more male students than female, on the
contrary department of psychology has more female students. Furthermore, the
sophomores have just entered into a new dynamic system of the university, with
co-education, previously coming from schools with genderexclusively form of
education.
Another very important factor is boarding students, including both genders, who
have marked differences to start with – firstly, boarding students are isolated from
their home, hence are not dictated or supervised by elder family members.
Secondly, boarding students tend to feel more responsibility towards their actions,
and have inclinations towards individualism. On the contrary, this group is also
more vulnerable to violence in general and gender based violence. So the stronger
among the students tend to consolidate a more powerful persona, while the weaker
may find the environment more hostile.
2
Furthermore, the university puts a pressure for sociability and courtesy, thus the
means of violence are more psychological than physical. Coercion is generally
avoided while persuasion is the primary method used to inflict violence. To this
effect, it’s important to notice, that certain mixed gendered departments are more
prone to GBV than others, primarily due to the age difference among students of
different departments and subject matter. For instance, science department
students are more vulnerable than arts.
Gender based violence in the university is also structural, since the administration
is male dominated and patriarchy values are followed. Most
Furthermore, University students act more individually and isolated, yet the
institution fails to provide or duplicate support that family, friends and outside
society offers. This disrupts the student’s socialisation in nonacademic life, and
can disrupt the proper socialisation of students, who may develop violent
behaviour in post-university life.
The research tends to determine the reason that lead to violence, and violent
behaviour among the perpetrators, with an aim to curb violence and promote a
more gender positive environment. So as to help policy makers, with its indicators
of violence, to formulate a better and practical policy towards the issue of gender
based violence in the institution.
Gender based violence students from reaching their potentials. They may males or
females, our research is to transform attitude of the perpetrators to prevent gender
based violence. The GBV may have the different dimensions either physical,
physiological, sexual violence. Girls must never be held responsible for the
violence that’s happens to them. Poor, fearful students in university are more
3
exposed to the gender based violence. The Gender based violence is not private
matter it must be uncovered in order for it to be challenged.
CHAPTER-2
LITERATURE REVIEW
The previous chapter provided an introduction to the study. This chapter provides a
critical analysis of the existing literature on the issue under discussion.
4
violence has serious implications for overall society in terms of esteem, happiness
and wellbeing. The problem is more pronounced in our society, as indicated by
many researchers, and women are the primary affected, according to a Thomson
Reuters Foundation Poll, Pakistan is ranked the 3rd the most dangerous country
for women in the world, found in polls in 2011 by experts.
There are different forms of gender based violence which depends on situation
where they happen. Some of the types of the violence are described.
It is the any sexual attempt or act against the person to obtain sexual act, female
students are more exposed to this type of violence.
5
2.2.4 Spiritual Violence:
The case study of selected departments of university of Peshawar was carried out
the main purpose of this study to aware student’s perception about the violence,
the reason for the violence and illustration on the basis of the gender, ethnicity and
class difference. Keeping in view the University are divided into different zones,
the research study were from 8 teachers.They are randomly selected for the
interview based survey, 4 were males and 4 were females. According to books
articles and journals all the points are kept in mind .Their proportionality
allocation were from faculty members (lecturer, assistant professor and professor).
In the 1883; the Bundara suggested that the individuals can learn aggression by
the observing models. He declared that those learning in the four stages the first
one is the response and the outcomes are clearly observed by the observers,
secondly the observations are encoded, thirdly the encoding should lead to the
limitations of observed behaviour, the fourth is if the appropriate conditions for
the incentives to performance exist then the limitations is actually occurred.
6
Dubet, 2003;C. Harber and munccbe 2003). Pakistan labour force survey
(2014_15) states that the overall labour participation different male participation is
67.8% and the female having the 22%. According to this comparison there is huge
gender difference, not only in the educational institute but other sectors as well.
The differences is not only in Pakistan but in the entire world (Aafiazia 2018:64)
Any harmful act which are against the will of person; used in publicly or
privately.(2009:5) the Kestedet and Esiner stated that the distinct of violence have
closely resemblance to each other’s. In the society they have the high rate due
unemployment and financial crises; it may decreases instantly or after end of the
wars. In some terms the violence is the harsh and sudden outburst of the someone
emotions and anxiety and tensions (George 2003)
There are scholars who look at the institution of education quite cynically. Harber
(2002), for instance, believes that the very inception of the idea of mass education
was primarily motivated by the objective of controlling minds and bodies. But
because the idea was garbed under the pretext of producing informed and skilled
citizens, it not only gained social acceptance but also appreciation. Alongside the
institutions of hospital, prison, and
7
as spaces of confinement, wherein the socially integrative duties of family – rear
and care of children and dependents – have been taken away by professionals such
as social workers, psychiatrists, police, teachers and prison guards who dictate
manners to youngsters (Dubet, 2003). Some writers, for example Meighan (1999:
4), argue that the idea of sending children to schools without their consent is a
form of violence itself and an abuse of human rights: “ based on current model of
the compulsory day detention centre, is itself a bully institution. When you take
the free will out of education, this turns it into schooling”.
According to Vander Ven et al. (2001), working mothers have negative effect on
children’s socialization and possible incorporation into delinquency. However,
this is usually the case in urban contexts but not in rural contexts. With respect to
urban areas, Vander Ven et al. (2002 cited in Fry, 2010: 09) argues that children
whose mothers are working spend more time with peer groups; the pattern of
orientation and learning shifts towards peers which in most of the cases lead to
delinquent behaviour and violence.
8
schools thus making them vulnerable to negative effects outside schools (Hayden,
2009: 19).
Although scrutiny of the research findings presented above in the review has
concluded that gender based violence has taken a shape of phenomenon across the
globe, both in developed and developing countries. Students irrespective of gender
considerations had been the victim of violence in any institute the mode of
violence varies from situation to situation and area to area, ranging from verbal
abuse to physical abuse and even sexual harassment. This situation has drastically
reduced the creativity amongst the students and has bad effects on their future
aspects.
9
CHAPTER-3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The previous chapter provided an analysis of the existing literature on the issue
under discussion. This chapter provides the research design of the study.
3.1 TOPIC:
My topic for the research studies is the “Teacher’s Perception towards On-
Campus Gender Based Violence”
3.3 HYPOTHESIS:
Is the perceptions of males and females are same towards gender based
violence?
Females are more exposed to physical and sexual harassment (GBV)?
Is the Gender based violence happening in the campus?
2. To determine the ratio of the Gender based violence in male and female?
3.5 METHODOLOGY:
The data was collected from male teachers and females teachers of interview
based the university of Peshawar. An exploratory analysis was performed to study
10
perception of males and females towards Gender based violence and also to study
the dimension of Gender based violence.
A well defined open ended questionnaire was designed to collect the information
from males and females faculty staff at various departments of the University of
Peshawar. The questionnaire is one of the important tools to collect data on object
related to a problem under study. This method is time consuming but accurate to a
problem under consideration.
The University of Peshawar are divided in the 4 zones, and the teachers are
selected randomly from them. Eight teachers were interviewed, including 4 males
and 4 females.
In order to conduct this study the information was collected from total is
respondent things convenience sampling. The convenience sampling is a non
probability sampling technique. Were we must fill the questionnaire from the
respondents. Who show willingness and also they are easily approachable.
11
12
CHAPTER-4
The two teachers interviewed from the specific zone and gave information of
Gender based violence happening in the campus. The zone 1 teachers have the
idea about Gender based violence is that; “Gender based violence is the use of
force and violence by one gender against the other. It may be violence by a male
or female or by a female on male. But commonly gender based violence is
considered as violence by a male over female”.
The another teacher idea about Gender based violence is that; “It is inter gender
transgressions of physical form aimed at hurting a person or persons of the
opposite gender.”
The two teachers interviewed from the zone 2, and their idea about the Gender
based violence is such as, “Gender based violence is a phenomenon that is
accelerating a high pace, because of multiple reason.”
The another teacher from the same zone having idea that; “Gender based violence
includes domestic violence, sexual harassment, assaults, social exclusion. Men
and women equally exercise gender based violence but in different forms.
Whenever mostly suffer physically which is quite evident. Men faces emotional,
economic violence, but its unseen, most of the time.”
The two teachers were interviewed from the zone 3 and their idea about Gender
based violence are; ”Violence on the basis of gender whether male or female.”
And “Gender based violence greatly form past four years and effecting the overall
mental health and capabilities of new generation.”
13
The remaining two teachers from the zone 4 were interviewed and have the idea
about Gender based violence is that ; “Gender based violence is violence against
women category. I am not saying that men can’t be victims of violence ever but
my emphasis is a women or girls who suffer more in society due to unequal socio-
economic status.” And “Gender based violence in my opinion a violence done
with females due to discrimination. It is a violence which female faces due to
patriarchal society.”
“Gender based violence is deeply concerned with the gender inequality and
continues to be relation with the violations of human rights in a society. Both male
and female are experienced with this issue but majority of the victims are related
to females.’
From the study it was concluded from the most of the respondent; that gender
based violence is the physical harm mostly of the male over the female, they may
also leads to the domestic violence, sexual violence and many other forces of the
violence. These violence were mostly of the inequality, lack of the human rights
either for the male and female .
Teachers of the different zone were interviewed and gave the idea about the
dimensions of the Gender based violence. The zone 1 teachers have the perception
about dimensions of Gender based violence is that; “According to my opinion,
patriarchal structure of society leads to gender based violence.” And “It includes,
in my opinion; Physical hitting, Hitting with objects, Threatening to hit,
Psychological torture.”
The teachers from the zone 2 were interviewed and having opinion about
dimensions of Gender based violence : “The possible dimensions, I can think of
be, Jealousy, Superiority complex, Incompetence, Social factors.” And “Domestic
violence (I believe more women hit their children than husband hit their wives) ,
Rape, Assaults, False allegations on men, women”
14
As from same structure of data collection two teachers interviewed from the zone
3, their opinion about dimensions of Gender based violence ; “Beating of the
weaker gender, Torture – physical, psychological and social torture to keep one in
alone, Acid “ And “Considering it as very much common now a days it has
hazardous affects on new generations, specially kids. They will not be great
leaders, sportsman, scientist etc”.
The data were collected from the zone 4, two teachers interviewed and gave their
opinion about dimensions of the Gender based violence; “According to me the
dimension or effect that it causes depends on form of gender based violence,
whether it is physical or mental torture. Physical violence can cause injuries and
mental violence can result in lack of confidence and fear of society which could
be stigmatizing.” And “Physical violence: Any act which causes physical harm as
a result of unlawful physical force.
Sexual violence: Any sexual acts perform on a person without their consent. This
includes rape or sexual assault.”
According to this research many aspects in our society take place in the face of
physical harm, superiority complex, incompetence, social factors, false allegation
(on both men and women) all these have the hazardous affects on the new
generation.
The Gender based violence are the broad sense crime and increase in our society
slowly and steadily .It also happening in the campus. The teachers interviewed
about the prevalence from the different zones in the University of Peshawar
The teachers from the zone 1 were interviewed and their idea about prevalence is
that; “May be, but personally, I haven’t observed gender based violence in
campus.” And “As any congregation of Humans I think it will be happening but I
think it prevalence will be very low.”
15
As for the same structure of data collection two teachers interviewed from the
zone 2, and their idea about prevalence is that; “Off course, it happens on
campus.” And “No self experience.”
The two teachers from the zone 3 were interviewed and have the idea about
prevalence; “Yes, it is becoming prevalent much more in past few years and
several serious cases are coming in view.” And “Might be”
The remaining two teachers from the zone 4 were interviewed and have the idea
about prevalence of Gender based violence on campus; “Well I would say ‘yes’
more or less. This would be psychological violence which causes emotional
violence. It happens due to unbearable response by person to authority and in
response, person be ready to receive threats of any sort of harm, on campus many
students get attacked and any disturbance could lead to mental violence. It all
depends on nature of people in campus” and “I heard but never seen or observed
by it. Many of the female students are suffered from such issues.”
The study found that most of the teachers mentioned the existence of Gender
based violence in the campus. However, most of the teachers declared that the
frequency for the prevalence is very low.
My research study have also related to determine the complaint, is there any
Gender based violence happening in the campus? For this I collected the data
from the campus. According to the divided wise zone I interviewed eight teachers.
Their perspective as under, from the zone 1; I interviewed two teachers their ideas
about complaint of Gender based violence “Yes, I have heard rare complaint of a
female who was teased by a male student by demanding his contact number .This
was the only case I have observed.” The second teacher idea about the complaint
is “In my 12 years of career there is one incident where a male student threatened
to hurt a female student.”
16
As same as the above structure data were collected from the two teachers of the
zone 2. They told “No, I am not part of the concerned committees.” The other
teacher gave idea such as “Female students are more exposed to such incidents;
however, in a year or two we have encountered cases/complaints from male
students as well.”
From the zone 3 two teachers interviewed their idea about complaints of Gender
based violence is such as “Never, I am always comfortable in my work place
environment. My male students, male colleagues have show greater respect than
their counterparts. In case of others, yes male students had complaint their last
year.” The other teacher of the zone 3 have the idea “Yes, but only once in my 8
years career over here.”
As above methodology two teacher of zone 4 gave their idea that “ No, I never
received any complaint regarding gender based violence. Students in my
department are very well mannered.” Same as the data were collected from the
second teacher;He told that “I have received complaint about gender based
violence from both male as well as female students. Most of the complaints were
about their teachers related with their marks.”
This study shows that Gender based violence happening in the campus, some
cases are reported in the face of the harassing the students in both Gender i-e male
and female. Some males harassing the females, demanding their contacts,
addresses etc.
For determines the ideas of the teachers about the politics of the Gender based
violence in campus. In this special type of question we can compare the western
society and eastern society. For this we interviewed eight different teachers.
According to the data requirement. The zone 1 teachers ideas is “I agree to some
extent that gender based violence is a western idea but ideas transfers socially and
geographically. Hence it does not further remain a western idea.” The second
17
teacher from the same zone perspective is “Probably relationship between men
and women in East is face different from the West .We can’t evaluate a position of
a person on the basis of western value. Some forms of gender based violence do
not exist. But gender is not a main issue in our world. We need much more than
this. There is Pashto proverb (Da mare hetekhabare) and gender is one of it.”
Same as the case the zone 2 teachers ideology the politics of Gender based
violence is such as “It is one of the many types of violence that happens. This just
gets more press time.” As data were collected from the second teacher of the zone
2 . He told that “The gender based violence is not a western idea. It happens
around the globe.”
We interviewed zone 3 teachers their ideology is “I do not think that gender based
violence can be totally western based idea , since cultural norms and religion are
two strong expects in here that can overcome any western pressure unfortunately,
getting away from religion restriction and cultural norms are more compared to
other sources.” The second teachers from the same zone gave the idea about
politics of the Gender based violence. He told that “It is the issue one may not
complain due to treat for students yours teachers or from boss your employee
In comparison to west, in Pakistan there may be less gender based violence but
without proper system of redressal while in west gender based violence it seem
less because of having proper system.”
The last not the least, two teachers interviewed for the data collection and their
idea is: “I am not so sure about it but this could be done for the sake of
economical differences and for forcefully prioritizing themselves.” Same as the
data collection, second teacher from the same zone told that “I think gender based
violence is not a big issue the western and hence we can’t judge the relationship of
men and women with the concept of western committees.”
18
The study proved that Gender based violence existed all over the world in
different forms. It may differ in east and may differ in west, so it’s not a western
idea.
CHAPTER-5
CONCLUSION
The previous chapter provided analysis of the collected data for the study. This
chapter provides the conclusion for the study.
The current study is concluded that the Gender based violence is one of the big
issue in our today society. Both the male and female are suffered from this issue,
however females are more exposed as compared to males. The exposition of
gender based violence exists due to patriarchal society, discrimination of gender,
and some other. Furthermore, the Gender based violence is not related only to
physical violence, or sexual violence, but this is also related to domestic violence,
superiority complex, social factors, jealously or mental torture. From the study it
was also concluded that Gender based violence exist in our University campus as
19
well. The female students were teased by male students, threats received from
male students for different purpose. Similarly different cases and complaint were
received from a male students about their teachers in which mostly related to their
marks. More over concluded that Gender based violence is not a problem only
related to the western societies but this is also happen is eastern communities
specially in Pakistan the Gender based violence greatly affect our new generation.
Hence we need to attract the attentions of our policy makers and other non
possible organization to overcome this problem.
20
REFERENCES
Cavanagh, C., Morell, M., Mackay, I., & Powell, W. (2008). From mutations to
MAGIC: resources for gene discovery, validation and delivery in crop
plants. Current opinion in plant biology, 11(2), 215-221.
Dubet, F. (2003). Que faire des classes sociales?. Lien social et Politiques, (49),
71-80.
Dubet, F. (2003). Que faire des classes sociales?. Lien social et Politiques, (49),
71-80.
Elson, E. L., Fried, E., Dolbow, J. E., & Genin, G. M. (2010). Phase separation in
biological membranes: integration of theory and experiment. Annual review of
biophysics, 39, 207-226.
Foucault, M. (1977). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison, trans. Alan
Sheridan.
Meighan, M., Davis, M. W., Thomas, S. P., & Droppleman, P. G. (1999). Living
with postpartum depression: The father's experience. MCN: The American
Journal of Maternal/Child Nursing, 24(4), 202-208.
Van Renesse, R., Minsky, Y., & Hayden, M. (2009, November). A gossip-style
failure detection service. In Proceedings of the IFIP International Conference on
Distributed Systems Platforms and Open Distributed Processing (pp. 55-70).
Springer-Verlag.
VanderVen, T. M., Cullen, F. T., Carrozza, M. A., & Wright, J. P. (2001). Home
alone: The impact of maternal employment on delinquency. Social
Problems, 48(2), 236-257.
21
Wikström, P. O. H. (2014). Situational action theory. Encyclopedia of
Criminology and Criminal Justice, 4845-4852.
22