Distribution and Network Models: 6.1 Transportation Problem
Distribution and Network Models: 6.1 Transportation Problem
Retail Outlets
Plant Location Des Moines Kansas City St. Louis Capacity
Jefferson City $14 $9 $7 30
Omaha $8 $10 $5 20
Demand 25 15 10
MIN 14JD+9JK+7JS+8OD+10OK+5OS
S.T.
1) 1JD+1JK+1JS<30
2) 1OD+1OK+1OS<20
3) 1JD+1OD=25
4) 1JK+1OK=15
5) 1JS+1OS=10
Scott and Associates Inc., is an accounting firm that has three new clients. Project leaders will be
assigned to the three clients. Based on the different backgrounds and experiences of the three
leaders, the various leader-client assignments differ in terms of projected completion times. The
possible assignments and the estimated completion times in days are presented in the table
below. Formulate the LP problem to determine which project leader will be assigned to which
client in order to minimize total number of day required.
Client
Project Leader I II III
Jackson 10 16 32
Ellis 14 22 40
Smith 22 24 34
MIN 10J1+16J2+32J3+14E1+22E2+40E3+22S1+24S2+34S3
S.T.
1) 1J1+1J2+1J3<1
2) 1E1+1E2+1E3<1
3) 1S1+1S2+1S3<1
4) 1J1+1E1+1S1=1
5) 1J2+1E2+1S2=1
6) 1J3+1E3+1S3=1
Warehouse
Plant 1 2 Capacity
1 $4 7 450
2 8 5 600
3 5 6 380
Customer demand and shipping costs per unit from each warehouse to each customer are as
follows.
Customer
Warehouse 1 2 3 4
1 6 4 8 4
2 3 6 7 7
MIN
4X14+7X15+8X24+5X25+5X34+6X35+6X46+4X47+8X48+4X49+3X56+6X57+7X58+7X59
S.T.
1) 1X14+1X15<450
2) 1X24+1X25<600
3) 1X34+1X35<380
4) 1X14+1X24+1X34-1X46-1X47-1X48-1X49=0
5) 1X15+1X25+1X35-1X56-1X57-1X58-1X59=0
6) 1X46+1X56=300
7) 1X47+1X57=300
8) 1X48+1X58=300
9) 1X49+1X59=400
5
6. Metropolis Public School System of Malawi has 18 school bus routes, of which six will expire
at the end of current school year. They must sign a three year contract for each of the six bus
routes by March of 2006. Bids have been made by five regional bus companies. The values in
the table below represent the price each bus company would charge to service a particular bus
route for three years (in millions of Kwachas). As can be seen in the table below, most of the bus
companies have made bids for only certain routes. In addition, due to limited resources each
company has indicated the maximum number of routes that they can actually accept. Thus,
although Ajax Bus Service has made bids for four routes, they have indicated they have only
enough resources to accept three of the bids. Formulate the LP model to minimize the cost of
securing contracts for each of the six bus routes.
Beagle Hound 25 -- 27 -- 21 -- 2
Magic Bus -- 28 -- 32 -- -- 1
Partridge Bus 18 22 -- -- -- 10 2
5 The LP model below minimizes the shipping cost of products produced in Augusta and
Tupper Lake and shipped to warehouses in Albany and Portsmouth and then shipped to outlets in
Boston, New York, and Philadelphia. 2 points each.
5 a. What would be the total shipping cost if the capacity of the plant in Tupper Lake was equal
to 120?
_________
5b. What is the cut off value for determining when less products would be shipped from
Augusta to Albany?
________
5c. How many products will be shipped to the warehouse in Portsmouth? ________
5d. What is the cut off value for determining when it would be beneficial to ship more products
from Tupper Lake to Portsmouth?
_________
5e. Would the binding constraints change if the capacity at Tupper Lake increased to 130?
Provide numerical support for your answer.
MIN
7Aug_Alb+5Aug_Port+3TL_Alb+4Tl_Port+8Alb_Bos+5Alb_NYC+7Alb_Phil+5Port_
Bos+6Port_NYC+10Port_Phi
S.T.
1) 1Aug_Alb+1Aug_Port<300
2) 1TL_Alb+1Tl_Port<100
3) 1Aug_Alb+1TL_Alb-1Alb_Bos-1Alb_NYC-1Alb_Phil=0
4) 1Aug_Port+1Tl_Port-1Port_Bos-1Port_NYC-1Port_Phi=0
5) 1Alb_Bos+1Port_Bos>150
6) 1Alb_NYC+1Port_NYC>100
7) 1Alb_Phil+1Port_Phi>150
9
5. Red Tomato Soup Cannery (RTSC) ships crates of tomato soup from plants in Aldrich and
Bona to Eudora, Fair Play, and Greenfield. Relevant information on weekly capacities and
demands as well as shipping costs is shown in the table below. As can be seen in the table below
weekly demand exceeds the capacity of the two plants. Therefore, RTSC is planning on re-
opening one of two closed plants. The closed plants are in Cedar Springs and Dunnegan. The
weekly cost of re-opening the plant in Cedar Springs is $400 per week, while the cost of re-
opening the plant in Dunnegan is $600 per week. Formulate the mixed integer LP problem to
minimize shipping and re-opening costs and meet the weekly demand.
Demand 80 70 150
Objective Function
11
10. The Dirty Soxs, a fast-pitch softball team, has three pitchers – J. Nuxhall, V. McDaniel, and
H. Wilhelm. The Dirty Soxs are scheduled to play in a round robin tournament this weekend
with four other teams, the Larks, the Pilots, the Skinflints, and the Zebras. Based on past games
with the four opponents, Smokey Burgess, the manager of the Dirty Soxs, has computed the
average number of runs each pitcher allows the opposition per game for each of the four
opponents (i.e., Earned Run Average or ERA). For instance, Smokey Burgess has determined
that J. Nuxhall’s ERA against the Larks is 3.40 (or J. Nuxhall allows an average of 3.4 runs per
game when pitching against the Larks). Smoky Burgess developed the following LP printout to
determine which pitcher should be used in each game in order to minimize the total number of
runs the opposition scores in the four games.
10b. How many total runs would you expect the opposition to score in the four games (four
games combined)?
_______
10c. Would the pitching schedule change if H. Wilhelm allowed an average of 3.1 runs per
game (ERA = 3.1) while pitching against the Pilots? Provide support for your answer.
10d. Would the solution change if J. Nuxhall was able to pitch more games (pitch against more
teams in the tournament)? Provide support for your answer
10e. If V. McDaniel develops a sore arm and is not able to pitch in any of the games, how many
total runs would you expect the opposition to score in the four games?
__________
MIN 3.4NL+3.8NP+3.2NS+4.1NZ+3.6ML+3.4MP+3.5MS+4MZ+2.8WL+3WP+2.9WS+3.5WZ
S.T.
1) 1NL+1NP+1NS+1NZ<2
2) 1ML+1MP+1MS+1MZ<1
3) 1WL+1WP+1WS+1WZ<2
4) 1NL+1ML+1WL=1
5) 1NP+1MP+1WP=1
6) 1NS+1MS+1WS=1
7) 1NZ+1MZ+1WZ=1
5. The Management Scientist output on the next two pages is for a transshipment problem in
which items are first shipped from plants (D and A) to warehouses (K and L) and then to the
final retail outlets (G, M, H, and N). (Each question is worth two points).
5a. According to the model formulation, what is the cost of shipping per unit from
warehouse K to outlet G?
____________________
5b What would be the new objective function value if the demand at retail outlet M was 360?
_____________
5c. Less items would be shipped from warehouse L to outlet G if the shipping cost was at what
value?
_____________
5d. What would be the total transportation cost if the capacity of Plant A was 730? _______
5e. If the shipping cost from D to K was $7, from D to L was $3.50, and from K to G was $2.40,
would the current solution remain optimal? Demonstrate.
14
MIN 6DK+4DL+5AK+8AL+2KG+6KM+3KH+6KN+4LG+4LM+6LH+5LN
S.T.
1) 1DK+1DL<800
2) 1AK+1AL<750
3) -1DK-1AK+1KG+1KM+1KH+1KN=0
4) -1DL-1AL+1LG+1LM+1LH+1LN=0
5) 1KG+1LG=400
6) 1KM+1LM=350
7) 1KH+1LH=350
8) 1KN+1LN=400
Chapter 6 Part II
6.4 Shortest Route
2 25 6
40 12 11
6 4 23
1
36 8
5
3 15
MIN
40X12+36X13+6X23+6X32+12X24+12X42+25X26+15X35+15X53+8X45+8X54+11X46+23X56
S.T.
1) 1X12+1X13=1
2) -1X12+1X23-1X32+1X24-1X42+1X26=0
3) -1X13-1X23+1X32+1X35-1X53=0
4) -1X24+1X42+1X45-1X54+1X46=0
5) -1X35+1X53-1X45+1X54+1X56=0
6) 1X26+1X46+1X56=1
17
OPTIMAL SOLUTION
Variable Value
-------------- ---------------
X12 1.000
X13 0.000
X23 0.000
X32 0.000
X24 1.000
X42 0.000
X26 0.000
X35 0.000
X53 0.000
X45 0.000
X54 0.000
X46 1.000
X56 0.000
Constraint Slack/Surplus
-------------- ---------------
1 0.000
2 0.000
3 0.000
4 0.000
5 0.000
6 0.000
18
The network below represents traffic traveling through Cincinnati from north to south. The arcs represent
highways and the values represent the maximum number of cars (in thousands) per hour that can travel on
each particular route. Formulate the LP model to maximize the number of cars that can flow through the
network per hour.
3
2 5
5 2 2 3 8
6 1 1
1 3 7
3 7 7
5
4 6
5
MAX 1F
S.T.
1) 1X12<5
2) 1X13<6
3) 1X14<5
4) 1X23<2
5) 1X25<3
6) 1X32<2
7) 1X35<3
8) 1X34<3
9) 1X36<7
10) 1X46<5
11) 1X56<1
12) 1X57<8
13) 1X65<1
14) 1X67<7
15) 1X12+1X13+1X14-1F=0
16) 1X12-1X23-1X25+1X32=0
17) 1X13+1X23-1X32-1X35-1X34-1X36=0
18) 1X14+1X34-1X46=0
19) 1X25+1X35-1X56-1X57+1X65=0
20) 1X36+1X46+1X56-1X65-1X67=0
21) 1X57+1X67-1F=0
19
MIN 2X15+5X26+3X37+3X48+0.25X56+0.25X67+0.25X78
S.T.
1) 1X15<600
2) 1X26<300
3) 1X37<500
4) 1X48<400
5) 1X15-1X56=400
6) 1X26+1X56-1X67=500
7) 1X37+1X67-1X78=400
8) 1X48+1X78=400
5. Crow Tank Company must relocate heavy equipment located at Node 1 in the
network below to a new plant location (Node 7). Formulate the LP model to find the
shortest route from Node 1 to Node 7.
ST:
1.
23
5. The LP model below represents the production of carburetors for automobile engines over the
next four quarters. Items not sold in the quarter in which they are produced can be put into
storage and sold during the next quarter.
5a. According to the model formulation, what is the cost of storing each unit after the second
quarter so that it can be sold during the third quarter?
__________
5b. If 700 Carburetors could be produced during the first quarter, what would be the new
objective function value?
_________
5c. More Carburetors would be produced during the fourth quarter if the cost of production was
equal to what value?
________
5d If the demand during the third quarter was equal to 600, what would be the new objective
function value?
_________
5e. During which quarter will production not be at full capacity? ______
MIN 10X15+12X26+14X37+16X48+1X56+2X67+2X78
S.T.
1) 1X15<600
2) 1X26<500
3) 1X37<400
4) 1X48<700
5) 1X15-1X56=300
6) 1X26+1X56-1X67=350
7) 1X37+1X67-1X78=550
8) 1X48+1X78=900
24
4. The LP model below maximizes flow of oil through a network (in thousands of gallons per
hour).
4a. According to the model, what is the maximum flow of oil per hour from Node 2 to
Node 3?
______________
4b. What is the maximum flow per hour through the network ? ______________
4c. What is the optimal amount of oil that should be sent from node 2 to Node 3?
____________
4e . Assume additional funds become available to improve one pipeline. If it was possible to
increase the capacity of some routes by 1(000) gallons, which routes would you consider
increasing the route’s capacity? (list all that apply)
MAX 1F
S.T.
1) 1X13<20
2) 1X15<10
3) 1X23<9
4) 1X32<4
5) 1X35<8
6) 1X53<8
7) 1X24<15
8) 1X34<10
9) 1X36<25
10) 1X46<14
11) 1X56<10
12) 1X12+1X13+1X15-1F=0
13) 1X12-1X23+1X32-1X24=0
14) 1X13+1X23-1X32-1X35+1X53-1X34-1X36=0
15) 1X24+1X34-1X46=0
16) 1X15+1X35-1X53-1X56=0
17) 1X36+1X46+1X56-1F=0
18) 1X12<18
1. Ozark Mountain Bike is planning the production schedule for the next four months. Relevant
information is presented in the table below. Formulate the LP model to minimize production and
inventory cost and meet the forecasted demand.
ST.
28
Assume Farmer Dale needs to rent a BEFCO for the four month planting season from Buck &
Knobby Equipment Rental A BEFCO can be rented based on a one-month, two-month, three-
month or four months plans. The costs vary depending on the length of the rental and the
particular month due to demand fluctuations. The table below summarizes the possibilities based
on last year’s rental costs.