The Flame That Sparked Outrage Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire
The Flame That Sparked Outrage Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire
The Flame That Sparked Outrage Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire
5-2020
https://doi.org/10.33015/dominican.edu/2020.HIST.ST.02
Recommended Citation
Isaacs, Amanda, "The Flame that Sparked Outrage: Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire" (2020).
History | Senior Theses. 2.
https://doi.org/10.33015/dominican.edu/2020.HIST.ST.02
This Senior Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Liberal Arts and Education |
Undergraduate Student Scholarship at Dominican Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in
History | Senior Theses by an authorized administrator of Dominican Scholar. For more information,
please contact [email protected].
THE FLAME THAT SPARKED OUTRAGE
Amanda Isaacs
March 9, 2020
Table of Contents
Table of Contents 1
Abstract 2
Acknowledgments 3
Introduction 4- 8
Conclusion 29-30
Bibliography 31-34
1
Abstract
The 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist Fire, a tragic event in New York City, reflected the ignored
demands by both foreign born and U.S born citizens. The unrelenting rioting and protesting
marked a turning point in progressive American politics. The late 19th and early 20th century
was a glorious time for new beginnings in America. The buzz about the opportunities in the
States roamed the globe and sparked interest in every person encountered. The ships carrying
Eastern European immigrants; Italians, Jews, and those of Polish descent, were migrating across
seas to enter into the modern world of the United States. Contrary to the welcoming propaganda
that is featured in their home countries, the opinions of some American born residents were less
than enthusiastic about the incoming foreigners. The jobs that are available to the immigrants
were meek at best, with intensive and frequent hazardous conditions for the men and women.
This paper will uncover the array of problems factory owners caused their immigrant workers, in
addition to the continuous strikes from the garment workers and a select few of the affluent class.
Finally, the paper will close with the highly suspicious motives that came from both Triangle
Factory owners Max Blanck and Isaac Harris. These theories include whether Blanck and Harris
had a coincidental wrap sheet of unknown insurance collections, or the reasoning behind these
unsafe working conditions, that led to multiple catastrophes, are part of a bigger sceam.
2
Acknowledgements
inspired my efforts towards this topic. I want to thank my family, friends, librarians, and
professors that helped guide my research to the finish line. You all inspired me . . .
3
Introduction
The topic for my paper was created through a "trial and error" platform. At first, my
research led to the 1863-1869 American Transcontinental railroads, with a primary focus on
Chinese laborers. The goal of my initial topic was to highlight the overlooked history of the
Chinese railroad construction. Searching for primary sources, I looked to the Library of
Congress a nd discovered a song by David Meyerowitz, Louis Gildrod, and Jack Kammen. The
Yiddish song is titled "Die Fire Korbunes," and pays tribute to the Jewish factory workers that
died in the Triangle Factory Fire.1 Lacking the historical background of the fire, I began
researching countless databases to be fully equipped with the history of the fire. After my
research journey, I decided to change my topic and focus distinctively on the 1911 New York
In the history of New York, the 1911 fire was the worst tragedy to occur in the city.
There were a record high number of casualties from the fire; 146 deaths. At this point in history,
it was New York's deadliest event. Most of the people that died were young immigrant women.
The 1911 fire remained the worst event to occur for the next 90 years. The fire remained a
record, until the terrorist events that occured on September 11th, 2001 (9/11). The planes that
crashed into the Twin Towers killed 2,977 people.2 The events that had taken place on 9/11
outnumbered the casualties from the fire by 2,831 victims. The victims from both events are
extraordinarily high for moments in history that could have been avoided.
1
Meyerowitz, David, Louis Gilrod, and Jack Kammen. DieFire Korbunes. Theodore Lohr, New York, New
York, 1911.
2
“September 11 Terror Attacks Fast Facts.” CNN. Cable News Network, November 13, 2019.
4
Terms of the tragic events aside, the dates of both events are oddly similar. The Triangle
Shirtwaist Factory fire has a date that aligns with the events of 9/11. The date of the Triangle fire
is on March 25th, 1911, and the date of the terrorist attack is September 11th, 2001 (9/11). The
city of New York has two events that have the number 9 & 11 next to one another. This
coincidence is astonishing, given that the events are over 90 years apart, and encapsulates the
As of May 2020, the COVID-19 virus has taken the lives of over 78,000 people across
the country.3 The current pandemic of the virus has affected communities on a global scale.
Social distancing and the use of masks are important factors that help prevent the spread of the
virus. The year 2020 has broken record high numbers of casualties in the U.S. In a recent news
report, the virus outnumbered the amount of casualties on 9/11.4 My topic has brought my
research to lessons about the past I was not expecting. For example, New York is currently a
hotspot for the Coronavirus. The nurses at the hospitals in New York are understaffed and lack
proper hygiene materials. The lack of masks and gloves prevent the nurses from working in a
safe and clean environment. Amid the 2020 pandemic, the nurses unsafe workplace resembles
the garment workers lack of safety precautions that they faced in 1911.
Today, the Triangle Fire is an event that offers timeless lessons to be remembered. These
lessons include unequal pay for women, and immigation prejudices and laws that still plague the
political spheres of today. With the current political climate the U.S. is involved in, the history of
immigrant women dangles in the horizon. The dynamics of the pay gap between men and women
is an issue that still resides in our country. The gap includes women making .79 cents on the
3
“COVID-19 United States Cases by County.” Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center.
4
Prochilo, Peter and Brittany. “Coronavirus Death Toll in NYC Tops 9/11 Attack.” Fire Engineering, April
7, 2020.
5
dollar, compared to men. It’s important to note that the work between the sexes is the same. The
difference between working men and women resides solely on the inequality of pay.
In 1909, the factory women earned a salary of $30 per week. The salaries given to the
young women contributed to the paycheck for the entire family. This, not excluding, the money
that was being sent home to their mother lands. The mother lands of the Triangle Factory women
included Southern and Eastern European countries; Italy, Poland, and those of Jewish heritage.
Today, over 109 years after the fire, women are still fighting for equal pay. It is important to
remember the historical salaries of working women, as they mirror the lower salaries that are
On world relations, U.S policies are seen in many global news headlines. The majority of
the headlines involve our country's immigration laws. President Trump has issued claims stating
that immigrants are “aliens” and “smugglers”. The transparency of President Trump’s allegations
towards immigrants align with past prejudices. These prejudices include immigrants of the past
given unwanted jobs and being treated as second-class citizens. Today, immigrants receive the
The Southern and Eastern European immigrants of the 19th century, were treated
similarly to the present-day immigrants in the U.S. The garment workers affected in the fire were
hard-working immigrants who wanted a place to call home. This included a home that was free
of hate and judgment. In the early 19th century, immigrants faced the hardships of assimilation.
The immigrants of today have received a push from different political heads. Certain political
figures have blurred the lines of immigration and have allowed stereotypes and judgment to run
wild. More historical prejudices are seen later in my paper, and are closely related to the same
6
antics and jargon that is spoken by those who support President Trump. The structure of my
paper is going to look at the effects of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire and how the disasters
occured. My paper is organized in chronological order, along with divided sections that lead to
separate subtopics. The subtopics encompass the Triangle Fire, with alarming theories that spark
backgrounds European immigrants faced migrating to America. Then, I proceed to uncover the
lives of the women before the 1909 protesting and discover their world in the factories. Next, the
details of the mass protest organizations and strikes are explained, along with specific individuals
The second half of my research includes primary sources that cover the eerie depictions
of the photographs taken from the building’s exterior on the day of the fire. I then proceed to
discuss the aftermath of the fire. The aftermath of the fire includes answering my audience's
concerns from the day in question. An example of these inquiries include, "How did the fire
happen? '' and "What backlash occured from the workers in New York?" The answers to the
tein’s
multitude of questions are from Leon Stein's critically acclaimed book The Triangle Fire. S
book was published in 2011, and offers a complete outline of the events during and after the
Triangle fire of 1911. Stein's writings are powerful in depicting the tragedy of the fire. The
research and effort that Stein put into his book reflects dedication to the immigrants that lost their
lives due to negligence. Towards the end of Stein's work, he included an in-depth synopsis of
factory owners Max Blanck and Isaac Harris’s suspicious insurance claims. After the final
inquiries are answered, my paper begins to close with the brief trial of Blanck and Harris. Then,
7
the paper discusses the present laws that are in place to avoid disasters similar to the 1911 fire.
The hopes for writing on the topic of the Triangle Shirtwaist factory fire is to promote change
and recognize the women who unjustly died in the fire. This research paper is written to
encourage those who decide to read about the troublesome history of the Triangle fire, and to not
forget what history has taught us. One must never forget that history is the answer, and change is
the goal.
8
Labor and Immigrant Life
The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire of 1911 occurred due to the ignored demands that
united both nonnative and U.S born protestors, along with socioeconomic backgrounds that
caused tension with Americans. Protesting aside, those of authority carried prejudices towards
the working class. With little success coming from the strike organizers, 146 garment workers,
most being young immigrant women, were killed. The casualties of garment workers could have
been avoided, but factory owners Max Harris and Isaac Blanck rallied against the women's
The buzz about the opportunities in America roamed the globe and sparked interest in
everyone. Ideas of a home where anything was possible, made America the best place for
innovation and change in the world. The boats from all over Europe carried the hopes and
dreams of families. The factory workers of the late 19th century to early 20th century, were
primarily of Italian, Jewish and Polish descent. The “American Dream” was eye-catching for
those seeking a prosperous future for their families. The aforementioned European immigrants,
along with other nationalities, were migrating across seas to the modern world of the United
States. Although this era was advertised as a glorious time for new beginnings in the United
testimonials heard in their home countries, the opinions of some American-born residents were
not enthusiastic about the incoming foreigners. The American-born residents' dislike for
An example of the Americans' dislike for the newly migrated Europeans were seen in
multiple newspapers. With the permission of the Hennepin County Library, Figure 1 depicts a
9
satirical image. In 1905, a
Bartholomew represented
Figure 1: (Used with permission from the Hennepin County Library)
on the United States influx of Eastern European immigrants. In the cartoon, Uncle Sam is
shielding his side of the tennis net from foreigners. The Europeans are portrayed as both tennis
balls and players. Bartholomew's sketch depicts the immigrants as nuisances that are hard to
keep track of. Uncle Sam is the hero that plays in the tennis match. In the cartoon, he is drawn as
the hero of American immigration and keeps his side clear from intruders. The piece symbolizes
the Anti-European biases that the American people carried towards immigrants. The intolerances
that Americans had towards immigrants, created Antisemetic and Anti-catholicism messages.
The two main religions that belonged to Southern-Eastern Europeans were Judaism and
Catholicism. Southern-Eastern Europeans were migrating to a country that, in the nineteenth and
The Europeans’ migration to the United States was wearisome. Traveling by sea, they
carried small suitcases. The ships endured strong weather, while passengers experienced freezing
5
Bartholomew, Charles Lewis. Getting To Be a Pretty Strenuous Game For Uncle Sam, (M inneapolis
Journal, November 26, 1905).
6
Waters, Mary C., and Philip Kasinitz. "Immigrants in New York City: Reaping the Benefits of Continuous
42, no. 3 (2013): 92-106, 94.
Immigration." Daedalus 1
10
temperatures. When the Europeans arrived in America, the job prospects were undesirable and
dangerous. The popularized stigma of “hard work equaling prosperity”, led the factory workers
to life threatening workplaces. The stigma of the “American Dream” featured hard work that will
earn a family their dreams. The American-dream ideal led workers to believe that the dangerous
jobs that were offered to them, were normal jobs that many Americans gladly received. Contrary
to this belief, the immigrants were given jobs that were unwanted from American-born citizens.
The false pretenses of the immigrants' jobs, plus the ideals of the American Dream, led
immigrants to the disastrous garment jobs that were seen in the Triangle Shirtwaist factory.
The factory workers had grueling hours and working conditions. The women garment
workers took shifts that continued late into the night, rarely having breaks. The various factory
positions included canners (individuals that worked at canning factories) and garment work. The
health and safety of the immigrants were being overlooked. The safety precautions that were
being overlooked included; suppressant lighting, cramped work areas, and tasks highly prone to
injuries. The array of complications factory workers faced led to boisterous protests, the Triangle
Factory fire, and evidence to suspect factory owners, Max Harris and Isaac Blanck, of being
accountable.
conventional sociology. Conventional sociology, “. . .long viewed the family as an end product
of socioeconomic forces and as an institution which functions to maintain the existing social
order."7 The family dynamics surrounded the “end product” or paycheck. The paycheck connects
the working class community with a single goal of survival. In addition, the working class had a
7
ans-McLaughlin, Virginia. "A Flexible Tradition: South Italian Immigrants Confront a New Work
Y
Experience." Journal of Social History 7, no. 4 (1974): 429-45, 429.
11
constant worrying of money, causing an effect on the social normalcy of the classes. This effect
on the social classes led to the middle class, made up of families that worked hard, but were not
considered a low class. The middle class featured families with many jobs, or a single job
depending on the size of their household, and primarily along with the husband's job title.
Jacob A. Riis, a crime reporter, photographed the lives of not only the middle class, but
also the working class. Riis photographed the public in the late nineteenth century and early
twentieth century. A society spokesperson named A.T. Shauffler describes Riis' work as, “. . . a
most remarkable set of stereopticon slides, illustrating the manner of life of many thousands of
our fellow creatures in this city.”8 In Riis’s book, How the Other Half Lives, he captured the
American middle class with black and white photographs depicting their conventions and
day-to-day habits.
Riis proclaims that the middle class, “. . .controls the conflict between rich and poor, to
distinguish itself from the two extremes and oversee the smooth operation of American society."9
The quote outlines Riis’ mantra of the overlooked vitality of the individuals that create the
middle class. In American society, the middle class is used as a scale to balance the upper and
lower classes. Later in history, the middle class becomes, “America's dominant class.”10 The
uptick of families residing in the middle class creates a division between the social hierarchies.
The jolt of tension between the classes creates dichotomies. In the context of opposing classes,
the term dichotomy refers to the stressful occurrences that came from foreigners migrating to the
8
Riis, Jacob. How the Other Half Lives. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1890, 6.
9
Riis, How the Other Half Lives, 31.
10
Ibid., 31
12
The American lifestyle in New York contrasts with the Southern and Eastern Europeans'
previous way of life. The European’s latter customs in their homelands were called "peasant
lifestyles". A peasant lifestyle, is a term that explains a former way of living that revolves around
small communities. These communities are called villages. In accordance with a peasant
lifestyle, the majority of work is agriculture based. A common job in peasant communities
involved working on a farm.11 The different lifestyles were contrasted between the peasant
lifestyle, and the modern American lifestyle. The defining differences between the societies
defined when, where, and how Southern and Eastern Europeans challenged and progressed
through modern America. The assimilating factors led women migrants working in industrial
labor. Coming from a peasant-lifestyle, the modern work the women faced were virtually
unknown to them. The conditions the women garment workers faced were, in fact, strenuous, but
Italian immigrants had the ideals of a peasant upbringing still intact, after coming to
America. Virginia Yans-McLaughlin wrote a journal article called, “A Flexible Tradition: South
Italian Immigrants Confront a New Work Experience.” In the text, Yans-McLaughlin stated,
“American style definitions of success or the reality of what produced economic progress in
modern cities could not easily pierce this cocoon."12 The "cocoon" for the newly migrated Italian
immigrants included an intense yearning for owning land and having large families. This was a
treasured goal Italian families carried into modern America. Similarly, Jewish and Polish
families carried the same traditions as Italian families. The hard work and yearning for land and
large families, left the European immigrants persistent in their factory positions.
11
Ibid., 431.
12
Yans-McLaughlin., 224.
13
In 1912, Lewis Hine photographed a Jewish family working in their home. With the
permission of the National Archives Catalogue, Figure 2 shows Hines' photograph. The photo
included six children, along with an older woman and man sitting at a cramped table. In the
were tending to, are garters13. In 1912, it was not uncommon for children to have jobs. In
fact, the jobs available to children included garment work and long hours. In the same year that
Jewish families were working long hours, Polish families were battling a torn government.
In 1912, Polish migrants were facing a torn representation of both their political and
social views in American newspapers. A political satire piece titled, "The Face of the Polish
Press in America" appeared in a Polish publication in the U.S called, “Ameryka Echo”. 14 The
satire piece featured a cartoon drawing. The cartoon had a mouth that was outlined with the faces
of men. The tone of the cartoon was ominous, with the mouth having a skull-like appearance.
13
eries: National Child Labor Committee Photographs, February 27, 1912. From National
Hine, Lewis. S
Archives Catalog.
14
Jaroszyńska-Kirchmann Anna D. “The Polish Hearst”: Ameryka-Echo and the Public Role of the
Immigrant Press. Urbana: Univ. of Illinois Press, 2015.
14
Polish-American's concluded that, "The image was striking, and, frankly, a bit disturbing: a giant
skull with a gaping mouth was composed of figures representing Polish political and clerical
divisions within the Polish American press, which reflected tensions within the community
itself."16 The cartoonist drew their concepts of Polish politics within the American press, in the
form of a satire piece. The piece revealed tensions within the Polish community. The dramatic
satire piece led Polish-Americans to create opinions about the current political environment in
Poland. This includes the differing views that Polish-Americans felt towards the cartoon, which
The garment workers spent their weeks creating shirtwaists to fit the “Gibson Girl”'
persona, a classic 19th century working-girl garment. A shirtwaist was a clothing item designed
for a women's figure. The shirtwaist had long sleeves and resembled a blouse-like clothing item.
The blouse-like item was traditionally white, with a cinched waist. The shirtwaist material was
made with ivory linen. The linen was made with lace insets and had a high buttoned collar.
The women garment workers were paid a set salary of $6 for every 13-hour shift.17 In
mathematical terms, an employee of the factory working from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m., would receive a
payment of .46 cents/hour worked. Concluding these calculations, a week's takeaway for a
garment worker would be about $30. A garment worker in the 19th century would earn less than
$50, for approximately 65 hours of work. In today’s America, it’s hard to fathom supporting a
15
Jaroszyńska-Kirchmann,”The Polish Hearst”: Ameryka-Echo and the Public Role of the Immigrant
Press, 37.
16
Ibid., 37.
17
Ross, Robert J. S. "Memory of Strike and Fire.", (Michigan Press, 2004), 56.
15
The Protests
The Italian, Jewish, and Polish immigrants' working conditions and prejudices were not
improving. The women garment workers had faced enough intolerances, and decided to protest.
The protesters in New York had many supporters that stood against how they were being treated.
The supporters acknowledged that the workers were being harassed for their gender, and
immigrant status. In 1901, Pauline Newman helped women labor unions find their footing.
Pauline Newman, a famous labor-activist, worked in the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory. She
continued her work in the factories until 1901. She discontinued her garment work at the factory
when the strikes started to approach.18 Newman refused to work at the Triangle factory, given the
horrific conditions. After quitting her job, Newman worked to raise money and spoke on behalf
of the Labor Council.19 Newman spent her time, ". . .from November to the end of March upstate
in New York, speaking to the ladies of the Four Hundred [the elite of New York's society] and
sending money back."20 During this time, Newman recognized the importance of funding for a
campaign, and encouraged her audience to be a part of the Women's Labor Union in New York.
The International Ladies Garment Workers Union (ILGWU) stated, "The operators
wanted their desperately low wages raised; they wanted recognition of their union, the
embryonic ILGWU; and they wanted health and sanitary provisions, such as clean restrooms and
fire sprinklers."21 Along with these demands, the women asked to end their 52-hour week
positions, that did not include pay for overtime.22 Today, the ILGWU plea's are promoted by
feminists around the globe. Presently, ILGWU’s plea would not have been seen as unorthodox,
18
Morrison, Joan, Charlotte F. Zabusky, and Oscar Handlin. "Pauline Newman: From Lithuania, 1901”, 12
19
Morrison, "Pauline Newman: From Lithuania, 1901”, 12.
20
Ibid.,12.
21
Ibid., 56.
22
Pool, "The Politics of Mourning”: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging,194.
16
especially for an around-the-clock workplace. Contrary to the 20th century, with women not yet
having the right to vote, their reasonable appeals were viewed as ludicrous amongst lawmakers
In 1909, the garment workers were labeled as "Sewing Girls". At times, their male
employers would refer to them as "girls", and their names would not be remembered. The
garment workers, at times being 14-years-old, began protesting against apparel firms in New
York.23 The 1909 strike was an event that cast a shadow for revolutionary change amongst
The meetings and events leading up to the 1909 strike involved Max Blanck and Isaac
Harris. The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory owners tried to derail the event in strange forms. In
September, upon hearing about the upcoming strike, both Blanck and Harris locked workers out
of the factories. Blanck and Harris decided to hire prostitutes to stand outside the factory. The
prostitutes were hired as “strikebreakers”.24 The term “strikebreaker” included a person or a form
of a distraction to manipulate an organization's efforts. The prostitutes were hired to sully the
efforts of the women who organized the strike. With civilians witnessing prostitutes next to the
protestors, the efforts of the women began to slowly weaken. Blanck and Harris hired the
The strike organizers included all industry-wide workers. The goal of the strike was to
include workers from every corner of the city that felt exploited.25 In most cases, specifically
amongst the protesters, they opposed two main companies in New York. These companies were
23
Ross, "Memory of Strike and Fire.", 52.
24
Pool, Heather. "The Politics of Mourning”: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging, 193.
25
Stein, Leon. 2011. The Triangle Fire. Vol. Centennial ed. Ithaca, N.Y.: ILR Press. Stein, xiv
17
The Triangle Shirtwaist Company and Leisorson's Dressmaking Factory.26 The strike included an
array of speakers. In Leon Stein's The Triangle Fire he states, "Speeches were translated among
English, Italian and Yiddish."27 The translations of the speeches emulated the majority of the
worker's nationalities. Later in history, the strike of 1909 was called "The Uprising of the
Twenty-Thousand." The strike procured the name from the amount of workers that rallied
together in protest. The 1909 strike had over twenty-thousand protesters. The Uprising of the
Twenty-Thousand was the most significant recorded strike organized by women. Later, the strike
revealed to be the biggest world-wide strike, organized by women in the 20th century.28
By November, the strike was fully initiated across the state of New York. The audience
and passerbys of the protesters started to grow tired of their message. The protestors’ message
plainly asked for improved wages and safer working environments. Ignoring the women’s
speeches, onlookers decided to show their aggression. Men and boys abused the women by
throwing objects and physically assaulting the strikers. During the months of organized strikes,
over 100 protesters were severely injured and arrested.29 A journalist of the New York Chronicle
was at the scene when a group of women were being arrested. The journalist wrote, "﹣arrested
women appeared in court with broken noses and bandaged arms and heads."30 In court, the
women pleaded to be treated with the rights of an American citizen. To the protesters pleas, law
enforcers mocked their cries of justice. The police officers that arrested the women viewed their
26
Ibid., 52.
27
Ibid., 53.
28
Stein, The Triangle Fire. xiv
29
Pool, Heather. "The Politics of Mourning: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging." Polity 44, no. 2
(2012): 182-211, 193.
30
Ibid.,193.
18
efforts as unforgiving. Instead of arresting the men that openly abused the women in public, the
The opinion of most men working in the garment factories did not support the efforts for
women's suffrage. In 1909, women did not have the right to vote. They were unable to voice
their opinions in the form of a ballat. The patriarchal laws that ruled women’s every moment,
were voted in favor of men. During this time period, the laws mandated by Congress did not
favor women. The laws in 1909 inclined male factory workers to ignore women’s suffrage. Men
were unbothered by the industrial conditions the women were forced to work in. This could have
been due to the low titled positions the women were automatically assigned too. The men,
fearing to have a lower salary than a woman, did not complain about the salary differences.
In the Triangle Shirtwaist factories, ". . .men held supervisory and more lucrative
positions in the ladies' garment industry, women did the bulk of the work."31 The "bulk" work
involved women working in tight sewing quarters amongst one another. Along with the cramped
working conditions, the women had trouble completing their Shirtwaists due to a lack of lighting.
Support for women's workplace conflicts turned bleak amongst the male employees of the
workplace. During this time, Samuel Gompers had much to say about the treatment of women in
Samuel Gompers was the president of the American Federation of Labor (AFL).
Gompers was cherished for his progressive ideals from both male and female garment factory
workers. Although he indicated his ambivalence towards the generality of strikes, he proclaimed
that if one were to go on strike, then one must finish with determination.32 Gompers had a sharp
31
Ibid,,191.
32
Ross, "Memory of Strike and Fire, 53.
19
tongue towards the inequality that occured at the Triangle Factories. One of his quotes began
with, "Yes, Mr. Shirtwaist Manufacturing," continuing... "it may be inconvenient for you if your
boys and girls go out on strike, but there are things of more importance than your convenience
and your profit. There are the lives of the boys and girls working in your business."33 The ending
of Gompers quote addresses Blanck and Harris' disdain for their workers on strike. In addition,
Gompers connects the lives of “boys and girls” with the unsafe working conditions in the
Triangle Factory.
During one of his proclaimed speeches, a socialist daily newspaper called The New York
Call, q uoted Gompers in an article.34 The article stated, "I have never declared a strike in all my
life. . . but there comes a time when not to strike is but to rivet the chains of slavery upon our
wrists."35 Within this quote, he compared slavery to garment workers that chose to not protest.
Gompers revealed that if one chooses to not strike, then one is allowing oneself to be enslaved to
the conditions of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory. Other exemplary activists during this time
include a societal woman named Miss Anne Morgan who could not ignore her sisters’ cries for
help.
Miss Morgan came from a lavish upbringing. In 1909, Morgan ". . .worked with the
National Civic Federation to provide food to underprivileged women workers in New York."36
Morgan's progressive political stances were not commonly shared among her class. Her strong
political beliefs led her to support the women's labor movement. In 1910, a flyer was created in
Morgan's honor. The flyer stated, "Rich Women's Aid Gives Strikers Hope, Shirtwaist Girls Sure
33
Ibid, 53.
34
“The New York Call-1909-.” The New York Call: 1909.
35
Kheel Center, Cornell University. The 1911 Triangle Factory Fire.
36
“Anne Morgan: Advocate for Women and Workers.” PBS. Public Broadcasting Service.
20
of Victory Since Miss Morgan and Others Joined Their Causes. . ." 37 Morgan’s donations helped
the strikers who lacked funds to excel in their efforts. Morgan, and many women alike, helped to
ensure the strikers efforts were not fruitless. Protest organizers recognized her efforts and held
A glimpse of the women's working conditions was told by Clara Lemlich Shavelson, a
23-year-old garment worker.38 Shavelson revealed the working conditions of the Triangle
factory. She chose to enclose her experience working at the factory to a former newspaper
company, New York World. Shavelson stated, "The girls at all the other rows of machines back in
the shops have to work by gaslight, by day as well as by night. Oh, yes, the shops keep the work
going at night, too. The shops are unsanitary—that's the word that is generally used, but there
ought to be a worse one used."39 Shavelson explains that the factory never stops running. It is
descriptions of the
Figure 3: Group of striking women - shirtwaist workers. NYC. 1909, Library
of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540
USA.
37
Ibid., Anne Morgan PBS. Public Broadcasting Service.
38
Ross, "Memory of Strike and Fire”, 54.
39
Ross, "Memory of Strike and Fire”, 56.
21
an accident-prone factory painted a picture for her audience. The picture invoked a
chaotic environment. Consequently, with Morgan's support and contributions towards the
garment strikers, the 1911 fire was very much on its way.
The 1909 strike occurred two years before the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire in 1911.
The strike's success came from the collaboration of both men and women workers who, during
the time, had vulnerable labor unions. The constant protests and strikes that occured in 1909
made small waves of change. After the strikes ended factory owners had, "Many employers,
Figure 4: Group of mainly female shirtwaist workers on strike, in a room, New
York, Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C.
20540 USA
did not increase. The strike organizers, along with the twenty-thousand that participated,
In a one year period, photographs were taken of different women protesters in 1909 versus 1910.
With the permission of the Library of Congress, Figure 3 and Figure 4 feature groups of women
40
Stein.,59.
22
that had entirely different facial expressions. The photograph in Figure 3 was taken in 1909. The
strikers in New York City assembled in a line, holding onto one another in laughter with
expressions of hope. The strikers were dressed in hats, ankle-length skirts, and mink scarfs. The
women in the photo were standing in front of a building with an ascending staircase, to a
possible courthouse in the background. The results of the 1909 strike, with the Triangle
Shirtwaist Company, along with other establishments not changing their policies, added to the
sad faces in the 1910 photograph. Figure 4 d isplays a photograph taken in 1910. In the
photograph, a meeting of mostly female strikers gathered in a small room in New York City.41
The photograph, compared to the picture taken a year prior, showed expressions of
exhaustion.The strikers were abused and harassed, and their demands were still not met. During
this time, women of all classes were choosing to either ignore the strikes, or help by joining the
cause. The societal women that ignored the protestors pleas, did so because they were not
directly affected by the factory. While the working women who chose to not participate, feared
The employers of the garment workers lacked empathy for the women and their harsh
working conditions. There were high amounts of suspicion towards the immigrants in the
factory. The suspicions of theft led employers to mandate strict policies against workers. For
example, before each of the women's shifts the employers on duty would lock the doors behind
them to avoid theft of material. The women would remain locked in tight working quarters with
insufficient lighting and were expected to continue working quietly. Prejudice towards women
41
Group of mainly female shirtwaist workers on strike, in a room, New York.,1910.
23
garment workers, combined with improper maintenance, led to poor working conditions that
The fire started at approximately 4:30 p.m. The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, ". . .was
located on the corner of Greene Street and Washington Place, just to the east of Washington
Square, in the heart of Greenwich Village."42 The fire spread through the fourth and ninth floors
of the garment factory. When the fire started, women were locked in their quarters, creating
shirtwaists. The women and men that escaped the building, were met with their employers at the
exit. The employers on the bottom floor checked every worker's items and pockets to ensure they
were not stealing. The checkers became oblivious to the catastrophic scenes occurring on the
floors above them. The employers were checking the frightened girls' personal items, as
hundreds of employees screamed amongst the roaring flames. The scenes of the fire shocked the
pedestrians walking near the building, as they gazed up towards the smoke filled building.
The pictures of that fateful day show broken fire escapes and a plethora of other issues.
Captain Dominick Henry was one of the first responders at the scene. He later spoke in a court
case against the garment company. Captain Henry stated, "I saw a scene I hope I never see again.
Dozens of girls were hanging from the ledges. Others, their dresses on fire, were leaping from
the windows."43 Dozens of pictures taken on March 25, show police officers trying to identify
burn victims. The burns of the deceased women were, at times, too extreme to identify.
Firefighters searched maintenance holes near the factory for any possible survivors. On March
42
Karmel, Jonathan D. "The Torch That Lighted Up the Industrial Scene." In Dying to Work: Death and
Injury in the American Workplace, Ithaca; London,19-26, 19.
43
Stein.,16.
24
26, one day after the fire, the ILGWU organized a memorial for the fallen men and women in
Grand Central Palace. The group of people that came to the organized memorial were nearly all
women.44
viewed the bodies in a makeshift morgue over the next few days; and hundreds of thousands
participated in an immense display of public mourning on April 5, 1911."45 The 1911 fire that
took 146 lives, shook the entire world. Weeks after the fire, on April 5, protesters mourned the
deaths of the fallen garment workers. With the permission of the National Archives, Figure 5
revealed protesters that held banners on the streets of New York. The banners portrayed the labor
unions that protested against unsafe working conditions in the garment factories.
Blanck and Harris lacked safety precautions in the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory. The lack
of precautions that the protesters demanded is what caused the fire. The banners stated, "Ladies
44
Stein.,137.
45
Pool, "The Politics of Mourning: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging.",183.
25
waist & Dressmakers Union Local 25/ we mourn our loss” and "We mourn our loss-- United
Hebrew Traders of New York.”46 The protesters' banners depict the women that were killed, and
specifically the Jewish women that were killed among the flames. One of the banners
acknowledged the United Hebrew Trades of New York (UHTNY). The UHTNY created a
banner in honor of the Jewish workers. During the time of the fire, 60 percent of all garment
workers in New York were Jewish.47 After the fire, the citizens of New York were in dire need of
an explanation.
After the tragic events of the fire, people began questioning the owners of the Triangle
Shirtwaist Factory. During this time, speculations towards Max Blanck and Isaac Harris started
to appear. Notions loomed whether the “Triangle King's” had planned the disaster. Many sources
revealed paper trails towards the Triangle factories insurance claims. Leon Stein's text offers a
complete outline of the factory's insurance claims with a multitude of primary sources.
Stein’s research uncovers insurance checks that the Triangle Factory received. The
factory received insurance checks before and after the 1911 fire. Blanck and Harris claimed at
least seven different incidents within their factories, all covered by insurance. The first insurance
collection was issued to their Asch Building. The reason for the claim was due to complications.
The sum of the claim amounted to $19,142. Interestingly, the cause of the “complications” are
unknown. The claims that are labeled “unknown” were never filed with an appropriate
explanation. Additionally, the highest amount of insurance the factory procured ($19,142)
46
Demonstration of Protest and Mourning for Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire of March 25, 1911.
47
Argersinger, Jo Ann E. The Triangle Fire: a Brief History with Documents. Boston: Bedford/st Martins,
2009.
26
intertwined with the time period as the 1911 fire.48 Why would the largest claim (equaling the
most disastrous) suspiciously not have the appropriate reasoning filed? The suspicion towards
Blanck and Harris’ insurance claims became thicker.49 The suspicion thickens with large sums of
money that are not filed with a suitable reason, or an exact amount. For example, Blanck and
Harris’ claims were riddled with the word “unascertainable”. The “unascertainable claims” were
towards the sums of money that the factory was granted, yet it is not acknowledged in the
insurance claims. The vague wording that is filed with Blanck and Harris insurance claims are
skeptical. Stein’s use of primary and secondary sources makes the reader question if Blanck and
Harris had a coincidental wrap sheet of unknown insurance collections. Unless, the reasoning
behind the unsafe working conditions in their buildings are a part of a bigger scheme.
The factory workers in New York, along with protesters in mourning, received news on
the trial against Max Blanck and Isaac Harris. The trial occurred, "On April 10, 1911, barely two
weeks after the fire, Blanck and Harris were indicted for manslaughter and criminal negligence.
But they were absolved of guilt at their trial and were acquitted on all accounts.”50 The verdict of
the trial was a shock for the supporters of the 146 deceased garment workers. After the trial, the
Within three consecutive years of ILG protesting, the organization's membership rose
from, "58,000 in 1909 to 84,600 in 1912."51 The side of over 26,000 members from 1909 to 1912
is directly tied to massive strikes (rain, wind, or shine), and the relentlessness of women. The
women and men supporters proved they were worth more than their meager salaries and
48
Stein.,172.
49
Ibid.,172.
50
Pool., 202.
51
Stein.,59.
27
workplace conditions. Between 1913-1916, an artist named Henry Glintenkamp sketched scenes
from the fire. With the permission of the Library of Congress, Figure 6 displays a sketch named
Triangle Fire.
The 50th anniversary was held in 1961 in honor of the deaths of the immigrant
workers.53 Along with the ceremony, elderly survivors attended in tribute to their fallen sisters.
The survivors remember their friends that were killed a mere fifty years ago. Between
1968-1970, laws were mandated to improve the health and safety of labor workers. Peg
Seminario, Safety and Health Director for the national AFL-CIO, wrote an article titled, “Even
52
Girls Wanted, 1916. Henry Glintenkamp, 1887-1946. Crayon. Published in The Masses, no. 8.
53
Survivors at Ceremony Commemorating Tragedy. New York, 1961. Photograph.
28
after tragedy, it takes organized action to bring change.”54 The article was written in 2011, which
marked the 100 year anniversary of the 1911 Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire. In her article,
Seminario discussed the 1968 coal mine explosion killing 78 miners.55 The coal mining tragedy
encouraged the formation of the Federal Coal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1969. Following
the 1969 act came the Occupational Safety and Health Act.56 In 1970, the Occupational Safety
and Health Act was born. In addition to the Occupational Safety and Health Act, Seminario
stated, “Workers, unions and their allies again must rise up, defend the right to organize and to
have a union, and demand the right to dignity, respect and safe jobs.”57 Seminario implores her
readers to remember the successes of protesting and the acts that brought change for labor
workers.
Conclusion
In the 21st Century, the fallen immigrant workers are memorialized. In 2018, New York
protesters organized a ceremony called, “CHALK”.58 The organized event included protesters,
“. . .remembering the dead and writing their names in chalk on the sidewalks in front of their
addresses in the Lower East Side, Little Italy and elsewhere.”59 The importance of CHALK
promoted open dialogue with individuals that were unaware of the tragedy. Additionally, the
Workers Union annually commemorates the 1911 fire with the assistance of New York City
54
Seminario, Peg. “Don’t Mourn – Organize Lessons from the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire.” The New
York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health, March 25, 2011, 1–39.
55
Seminario, Peg. “Don’t Mourn – Organize Lessons from the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire.”, 4.
56
Seminario, 4.
57
Ibid, 4.
58
Ticzon, David. “New York City Events Honor Triangle Fire Victims, Focus on New Activists.” Cornell
Chronicle, March 1, 2018.
59
Ibid., David
29
firefighters.60 A, “. . . fire department truck raises a ladder to the sixth floor, the highest its
equipment could reach in 1911, painfully short of the eighth, ninth and tenth floors, where the
fire occurred.”61 The annual ceremony represents the accomplishments technology has made
towards safety precautions. Including, the hardships that the 1911 firefighters faced trying to
save the garment workers lives. The deaths of 146 women and men immigrant workers is a stain
that cannot be undone by the employers of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory.62 The victims' history
remains present within primary sources, secondary sources, historians and social activists. March
25, 1911 is a day when money and greed surpassed the lives of innocent immigrant workers.
60
Freeman, Joshua. “Remembering the Triangle Fire.” The Nation, June 29, 2015.
61
Ibid., Freeman
62
Pool, The Politics of Mourning: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging, 183.
30
Bibliography
Anne Morgan: Advocate for Women and Workers.” PBS. Public Broadcasting Service.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/triangle-fire-anne-morgan/.
Argersinger, Jo Ann E. The Triangle Fire: a Brief History with Documents. Boston: Bedford/st
Martins, 2009.
Bartholomew, Charles Lewis. Getting To Be a Pretty Strenuous Game For Uncle Sam. Political
Cartoons. Minneapolis Journal, November 26, 1905. From Hennepin County Library
Digital Collections https://digitalcollections.hclib.org/digital/collection/Bart/id/6872.
(accessed February 23, 2020).
“COVID-19 United States Cases by County.” Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center.
Accessed May 9, 2020. https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/us-map.
Drehle, David Von. Triangle: the Fire That Changed America. Bridgewater, NJ: Distributed by
Paw Prints/Baker & Taylor, 2008.
Freeman, Joshua. “Remembering the Triangle Fire.” The Nation, June 29, 2015.
https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/remembering-triangle-fire/.
Greenwald, Richard A. ""The Burning Building at 23 Washington Place": The Triangle Fire,
Workers and Reformers in Progressive Era New York." New York History 83, no. 1
(2002): 55-91. http://www.jstor.org/stable/23183517.
Hine, Lewis. Series: National Child Labor Committee Photographs, February 27, 1912. From
National Archives Catalog https://catalog.archives.gov/id/523525 (accessed February 23,
2020).
Jaroszyńska-Kirchmann Anna D. The Polish Hearst: Ameryka-Echo and the Public Role of the
Immigrant Press. Urbana: Univ. of Illinois Press, 2015.
Karmel, Jonathan D. "The Torch That Lighted Up the Industrial Scene." In Dying to Work:
Death and Injury in the American Workplace, 19-26. Ithaca; London: Cornell University
Press, 2017. Accessed February 21, 2020. www.jstor.org/stable/10.7591/j.ctt1w0dcfj.6.
31
Kahan, Arcadius. "Economic Opportunities and Some Pilgrims' Progress: Jewish Immigrants
from Eastern Europe in the U.S., 1890-1914." The Journal of Economic History 38, no. 1
(1978): 235-51. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2119326.
Lyons, Paul R. Fire in America! Boston: National Fire Protection Association, 1976.
McClymer, John F. The Triangle Strike and Fire. Fort Worth: Harcourt Brace College Publ.,
1998.
"Meaning of Acquittal in the Triangle Fire Case." Journal of the American Institute of Criminal
Law and Criminology 2, no. 6 (1912): 942-43. Accessed February 21, 2020.
www.jstor.org/stable/41955227.
Melech Epstein, and Irwin Yellowitz. "Communications on Epstein's "Jewish Labor in U.S.A.""
Jewish Social Studies 33, no. 2/3 (1971): 249-51. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4466663.
Morrison, Joan, Charlotte Fox Zabusky, and Oscar Handlin. "Pauline Newman: FROM
LITHUANIA, 1901." In American Mosaic: The Immigrant Experience in the Words of
Those Who Lived It, 8-14. Pittsburgh, Pa.: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1980. Accessed
March 17, 2020. doi:10.2307/j.ctt6wrcs0.7.
“NFPA's Response to the Triangle Waist Company Fire.” Youtube. The National Fire Protection
Association, March 10, 2011.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=WCsQ4YuIDA4.
Prochilo, Peter and Brittany. “Coronavirus Death Toll in NYC Tops 9/11 Attack.” Fire
Engineering, April 7,
2020.https://www.fireengineering.com/2020/04/07/486377/coronavirus-death-toll-in-nyc
-tops-9-11-attack/#gref.
Pool, Heather. "The Politics of Mourning: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging." Polity 44,
no. 2 (2012): 182-211. Accessed February 18, 2020. www.jstor.org/stable/41426930.
“Remembering The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire.” Youtube. CBS News, March 20, 2011.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=17&v=4ulaG9x4GpE.
32
Riis, Jacob. How the Other Half Lives. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1890.
Ross, Robert J. S. "Memory of Strike and Fire." In Slaves to Fashion: Poverty and Abuse in the
New Sweatshops, 52-71. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2004.
http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.3998/mpub.15439.6.
Sangiovanni, Andrea, and Heloise Finch-Boyer. "Italian Working Men’s Masculinities in the
Latter Half of the Twentieth century." Clio. Women, Gender, History, no. 38 (2013):
95-119. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26273597.
“September 11 Terror Attacks Fast Facts.” CNN. Cable News Network, November 13, 2019.
https://www.cnn.com/2013/07/27/us/september-11-anniversary-fast-facts/index.html.
Stein, Leon. 2011. The Triangle Fire. Vol. Centennial ed. Ithaca, N.Y.: ILR Press.
https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=nlebk&AN=671612&site=eds-l
ive.
“The New York Call-1909-.” The New York Call: 1909. Accessed February 21, 2020.
https://www.marxists.org/history/usa/pubs/the-new-york-call/1909/index.htm.
Kheel Center, Cornell University. The 1911 Triangle Factory Fire, accessed February 13, 2014,
http://www.ilr.cornell.edu/index.html
Ticzon, David. “New York City Events Honor Triangle Fire Victims, Focus on New Activists.”
Cornell Chronicle, March 1, 2018.
https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2018/03/new-york-city-events-honor-triangle-fire-victims
-focus-new-activists.
“Triangle Fire.” PBS. Public Broadcasting Service. Accessed October 21, 2019.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/films/triangle/.
Waters, Mary C., and Philip Kasinitz. "Immigrants in New York City: Reaping the Benefits of
Continuous Immigration." Daedalus142, no. 3 (2013): 92-106. Accessed February 17,
2020. www.jstor.org/stable/43297253.
Yans-McLaughlin, Virginia. "A Flexible Tradition: South Italian Immigrants Confront a New
Work Experience." Journal of Social History 7, no. 4 (1974): 429-45.
http://www.jstor.org/stable/3786465.
33
Yans-McLaughlin, Virginia. 1977. Family and Community: Italian Immigrants In Buffalo,
34