OD, Quanti, FM & Entrep
OD, Quanti, FM & Entrep
OD, Quanti, FM & Entrep
A. ESSAY
B. Case Analysis
CREATING A VISION AT PREMIER
Premier is a leading health care alliance collectively owned by more than 200 independent
hospitals and health care systems in the United States. Together, the owners operate or are
affiliated with nearly 1,500 hospitals and other health care sites. Premier resulted from the 1995
merger of Chicago-based Premier Health Alliance, San Diego-based American Healthcare
Systems, and The SunHealth Alliance of Charlotte, North Carolina. Premier offers a
comprehensive array of services and products through its companies and business units, including
group purchasing, consulting services, technology management services, insurance services,
benchmarking and market intelligence services, and legislative advocacy.
Two and a half years after the organization’s formation, a comprehensive organizational
assessment suggested that Premier had not been successful in establishing a common
organizational culture. Many of its services and employees continued to operate in a fractured or
isolated fashion relating largely to their prior organization and its geographic location. As a
result, Premier’s strategy and business model were poorly understood, and more importantly, not
well implemented. The assessment pointed to a growing lack of trust in the organization. Premier
executives conceded that the organization was culturally adrift and without a well understood or
widely accepted sense of direction.
Another key finding of the assessment concerned the organization’s vision. Shortly after the
merger, a new set of values, mission, and vision statements had been developed. The statements
themselves were clear and compelling; however, they had been developed by a relatively small
group of executives. At best, most employees did not feel much ownership of the values; at worst,
they saw the failure of top management to behave consistently with the values as evidence that
they were not trusted, supported, or important.
In the fall of 1997, Premier hired Richard Norling as COO. Norling had been a chief executive at
one of the health care systems that owned Premier, and his arrival signaled the potential for
change and new possibilities. At his former organization, Norling had initiated and sustained a
comprehensive OD effort, based on identifying core organizational values and the behaviors that
supported them. The experience of that health care system had demonstrated that core values
shaped and accepted by an organization’s employees could build a deep sense of community in
the organization, and lead to greater levels of trust and commitment that could be harnessed to
enhance organization performance and effectiveness. Given Premier’s emerging problem, a
similar approach made sense.
In the spring of 1998, Premier executives determined to address these issues by building on the
values and mission statements that had been developed earlier. Their intent was to involve a large
number of employees in validating Premier’s values, specifying the behaviors that supported
them, and identifying ways in which the values could be integrated into the routines and
processes of the organization—all of which would (they hoped) infect the organization with a
renewed sense of identity and enthusiasm.
The first step in Premier’s change process was planning and conducting a three-day 200-
employee values conference. The conference was designed by a team of employees representing a
diagonal slice of the organization and assisted by an OD practitioner. At the conference,
employees examined Premier’s business model and their organizational culture; developed and
recommended a set of core organizational values for the organization; crafted an envisioned
future; and identified and proposed strategies for employee involvement, integration, and
organization transformation companywide.
Following the conference, the team of Premier employees who had planned the meeting was
asked to become a permanent committee, charged with refining and implementing plans and
recommendations that the conference participants had generated. Ultimately, input was obtained
from over 60% of the workforce and 16 actions were recommended and approved by senior
management. Some of those actions included:
> Incorporating the values into Premier’s performance management/performance appraisal
system
>Incorporating the values into the recruitment and selection process by developing sample
interview questions for use by hiring managers aimed at helping them learn whether prospective
employees would be a good match to Premier’s organizational culture.
>Instituting an annual meeting of approximately 200 employees from all parts of Premier
modeled after the 1998 values conference. The agenda should be focused on business issues,
strategy, and organizational culture and values. Rotate those invited so that every Premier
employee has an opportunity to attend every three to five years.
a. Use exponential smoothing with smoothing parameter α = 0.2 to compute the demand
forecast for January (Period 13).
b. Use exponential smoothing with smoothing parameter α = 0. 5 to compute the demand
forecast for January (Period 13).
c. Paulette believes that there is an upward trend in the demand, the initial forecast is 37
and the trend over this period is 0 units. Use trend-adjusted exponential smoothing with
smoothing parameter α = 0. 5 and trend parameter β = 0. 2 to compute the demand
forecast for January (Period 13).
d . Compute the mean squared error for each of the methods used.
4. Eddie’s Restaurant collected the following data on the relationship between advertising
and sales at a sample of five restaurants:
C. Case Analysis
From the given cases, identify and list down the financial challenges presented on
the case and give financial management intervention for each of the
corresponding challenges/problems.
Case 1: The X Company suffered from cash flow issues caused by rapid growth,
undercapitalization, and lack of financial management expertise and control processes.
The X Company accumulated excessive losses and struggled with liquidity issues that
threatened the company’s future viability. They had grown too rapidly and lacked
processes and working capital to fund their success.
Case 2: Sales were beginning to grow rapidly and the company was in need of a clear,
concise mechanism for reconciling sales per the company website to the back gateway
and bank.
Case 3: The Z Company needed to raise considerable equity capital to fund the
continuation of their product development and their sales and marketing efforts.
Previously, the Z Company had raised limited capital from local Angel investors, but
now needed to attract sophisticated institutional investors. This was the first time the
CEO had headed a venture-backed start-up company and he needed prudent business
counsel to avoid the typical pitfalls of a young company.
C. CASE ANALYSIS
Case 1 : The Y Co. needed to raise its first institutional round to complete initial animal studies.
The co-founders completed a draft of a presentable Business Plan, but early investor feedback
indicated that the financial projections were unrealistic and unacceptable. The financial
presentation needed to clearly demonstrate the use of capital and what additional capital
requirements would be required upon successful completion of the animal studies. The Y Co. did
not have the experience to undertake this financial presentation and had limited resources to
engage an experienced full-time Chief Financial Officer (CFO).
1. Identify and list down the challenges/problems of the company.
2. Give financial/entrepreneurial intervention of the identified challenges.
6. Who are the competitors? List at least 5 competitors and compare each (in detail) to
the company being interviewed.
Case 2.6: PictureFrames.com – significant competitor because they have one of the oldest,
largest and best recognized. They have the best SEO. Their prices are higher and they are not
direct competition.
AmericanFrame.com – most significant competitor because they have been in business about
40 years. They are about 5-10 times larger with about 150 employees and about 50,000 sq.ft.
or larger so their economies of scale give them a cost and process advantage. They used to be
mail-order before they became online so they had lots of systems and processes that have
been mature for a long time. The also have a similar product line and pricing model.
Framesbymail.com – lower quality supplier, not quite as good of a website for the user,
higher priced. FramingSupplies.com – tend to more of the full sheet mats versus cut mats so
they are a little more into the DIY market than the finished goods market. They only encroach
on FD’s space in a minor way. FrameFit.com – similar in pricing and product mix but not
highly visible in the online photography forums.
13. What marketing is the entrepreneur using? Is it effective? Do you recommend other
choices?
Case 2.13: Frame Destination relies primarily on a combination of SEO and Forum
participation. A small amount of money is spent on PPC marketing. There are a number of
discussion forums for photographers and Frame Destination is very active in such groups and
has been for many years. The groups are the initial way that Frame destination grew.
14. Explain why you think this business will succeed, struggle, or fail over the next 2
years.
Case 2:14 Mark has proven to be a very resourceful business owner. His business is now well
enough established that he will be able to overcome normal obstacles. The only real threat to
his business is an environmental threat such as a fire or tornado. Otherwise, so long as Mark
continues to be actively involved in the business the business should survive indefinitely into
the future.