Digital Transformation For Travel and Expense: Balancing Process Efficiencies, Compliance, and Employee Experience
Digital Transformation For Travel and Expense: Balancing Process Efficiencies, Compliance, and Employee Experience
Digital Transformation For Travel and Expense: Balancing Process Efficiencies, Compliance, and Employee Experience
Get started
cloud-based solutions.
and flexibility.2 Amidst reduced travel and increased cost control,
transforming outdated travel and expense management (T&E)
Lengthy, cumbersome processes and tools
processes and tools must be central to business objectives.
diminish the end-to-end experience for
Opportunity
Amadeus commissioned Forrester Consulting to conduct a survey of employees and impede business operations.
finance, procurement, travel management, IT, and HR leaders at large This adds manual burden to the workload
enterprises to explore the current state and challenges with T&E of employees, managers, and Accounts
processes and tools. Payable teams.
Job Roles
Improving For organizations in the study, respondents said the top business objectives over the next 12 months are
increasing efficiency in operations (75%), accelerating their digital transformation (71%), and improving the
T&E Is Critical experience of employees (69%).
To Digital Modernizing travel and expense management is critical to achieving these business objectives. Seventy-three
Situation
Situation
Transformation percent of respondents agreed that improving T&E processes and tools is a key part of their organization’s
digital transformation journey. A similar proportion said that improving T&E is key to reducing cost and
increasing operational efficiency (74%) and improving EX and employee engagement (74%). Seventy-four
Approach
percent also agreed or strongly agreed that technology vendors have a significant role in advising them on
the digitization of T&E management.
Opportunity
Strongly agree
Agree We expect technology providers to have a significant role 34% 40% 74%
in advising us on the digitization of T&E management.
Conclusion
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 4
“How much of a priority are the following travel and
expenses initiatives for your company?” (Top results)
Overview
experience of the process, even for job roles traditionally perceived Improve ability to gain actionable
68%
insights from analytics on T&E
as cost-driven (e.g., finance, procurement, and IT). Data analytics to
gain actionable insights on T&E is also a top priority for all job roles, Improve integration between T&E
Approach
including HR and travel managers. Beyond these, decision makers in technologies and other enterprise 68%
systems
finance, procurement, travel management, IT, and HR had differing
top objectives. However, in the context of the COVID-19 situation, Increase automation and reduce
68%
manual, repetitive tasks
there is more focus on control and visibility of T&E.
Opportunity
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: Variable manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 5
Overview
Many Many companies still rely on traditional systems and tools for T&E management. This is true for respondents
from organizations that make decisions centrally and for those from firms with a decentralized decision-making
Enterprises
model. Only 15% of respondents said their enterprise has a cloud-based solution for T&E management.
Still Rely On
At centralized companies, 22% still rely on spreadsheets for expenses. One chief human resources officer
Situation
Situation
Traditional of a national retail chain said: “When the time comes for employees to submit an expense reimbursement
T&E Tools report, it’s paper-based right now, which is one of the areas we’d like to change going forward. But right
now, they submit a paper expense report with paper receipts.” At decentralized companies, nearly a third use
Approach
spreadsheets for aspects of their travel management (28%) or expenses management (31%).
Travel Expenses
Spreadsheet-based solution 28% 31%
management
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 6
“To what extent have you automated the following
aspects of your travel and expense management?”
Overview
Between 21% and 30% of respondents said various tasks of T&E Exporting accounting entries
55%
Approach
However, less than half of firms have automated travel approval and
52% Data capture and extraction
document imaging/scanning of expense reports.
52% User alerts of expense report errors
“We’ve got a back-office team that process expenses 50% Violation of expense policy
Job Roles
notifications
and accounts payable. And that administrative time is
low value.” 50% Booking, cancelling, changing travel
– CPO, global company Document imaging/
49%
scanning of expense reports
Conclusion
expense, while 32% said they have partly integrated between two
different tools, and 8% said they have two different tools with no
integration.
Opportunity
60%
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 85 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT involved
in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 8
“With which of these other systems in your company
does your travel and expense solution integrate?”
Overview
platform for travel and expense management, most indicated that Business intelligence/ 57%
these tools currently do not integrate well with other systems like analytics
ERP and daily work tools, like email and calendar. The low level of
Approach
ERP 27%
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 85 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT involved
in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 9
Overview
The Average The number of manual tasks involved in travel and expense management exacerbated by low integration
between travel tools, expense tools, and other enterprise systems, is a top challenge for companies. These
End-To-End
issues contribute to a lengthy and inefficient end-to-end T&E experience. Surveyed finance and travel
T&E Process management leaders indicated that the end-to-end process takes 13.6 hours per trip on average.
Situation
Takes 13.6 The most time is spent on travel booking by employees, travel approval by managers, and expense
Hours In Total processing by AP teams. The longest part of the process is expense processing and reimbursement. One
chief procurement officer of a global company said, “Once I send expenses off, and they get approved, I
Approach
might be waiting two or three weeks for the money to hit my account.”
organization?”
Employees to create
an expense report
3.0
2.7 Managers to approve
expense report
Conclusion
Satisfaction With Current T&E Tools And and processes?” (Showing “very satisfied” + “satisfied”)
Processes Varies By Department Finance/accounting Human resources/training IT
Procurement Travel management
Situation
The current state of travel and expense management needs 82% 88%
73% 79% 74%
improvement. More than a fifth of respondents in the study said
Overall technology/solutions
they are not satisfied with the overall technology and processes, but and processes
satisfaction varies by department.
Approach
• Over a fifth of procurement leaders are not satisfied with Level of automation
the level of automation and integration with other enterprise
systems. 77% 80% 79% 79%
Job Roles
67%
Level of integration with
• Nearly a quarter of IT leaders are not satisfied with overall other enterprise systems
technology and processes. (e.g., CRM, ERP, etc.)
78% 75% 80% 79%
69%
Conclusion
Reporting/analytical
capabilities
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 11
“What are your company’s main challenges with
travel and expense management?” (Top results)
Overview
Privacy and/or
this [includes] flights and hotel, I would say it’s probably 5 minutes. 21%
security concerns
Expenses is the longest bit of the process. You need to download or
print a form or fill it in electronically row by row with the dates. Then Compliance-related expense
tracking, reconciliation, and 21%
Opportunity
attach receipts and scan them in. Doing that will probably take 20
auditing
minutes or half an hour, depending on how many you’ve got.”
Too much time to submit
The lack of a global solution is another top challenge. The group expenses, approvals, and 20%
HR director for a national automotive company said: “We have 250 documentation
Job Roles
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 12
Overview
Employees Respondents from firms without an integrated platform for T&E said employees complain about cumbersome,
restrictive processes for booking travel that are exacerbated by issues with platforms that do not provide
Complain
value-add information. For expenses, lengthy and manual processes for submitting receipts and expense
About A reports are top employee complaints. Firms with an integrated T&E tool are much less likely to receive
Situation
Lengthy And employee complaints, but one in five respondents noted issues with inflexible approval flows, restrictive travel
Cumbersome booking, and lack of value-added information. This indicates that while an integrated tool solves a lot of the
T&E Experience typical challenges, there is still room for improvement on overall processes.
Approach
Firms with an integrated tool have fewer employee complaints: 27% had no complaints
compared to 10% of other firms.
Opportunity
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 13
Overview
T&E Issues Organizations recognize that problems with their travel and expense management have a direct impact on
EX and business operations. Surveyed HR leaders indicated that T&E issues cause decreased employee
Impede EX
productivity, poor engagement, decreased retention, and lower employee satisfaction with work technology.
And Business T&E challenges also result in inefficient business operations, including delays in reimbursing employees and
Situation
firms. Similarly, only 18% of respondents noted employee dissatisfaction or disengagement due to manual tasks
compared to 26% from other firms.
Opportunity
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 14
“How satisfied are you with the following aspects of
your company’s current travel and expenses tools
Overview
tool are satisfied with their overall T&E and the ease of use and 94%
accessibility, compared to around three-quarters from other firms. Ease of use/accessibility
76%
Similarly, between 86% and 88% of respondents from companies
Opportunity
Opportunity
with an integrated tool are satisfied with the level of automation and
86%
integration and reporting/analytical capabilities, compared to about Level of automation
three-quarters of other firms. 73%
This may explain why 73% of respondents from companies that have
Job Roles
an integrated T&E tool said they plan to expand or upgrade their Level of integration with 88%
other enterprise systems
platforms/solutions.
(e.g.,CRM, ERP, etc.) 75%
86%
Conclusion
Reporting/analytical
capabilities 76%
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 15
“What benefits does your company achieve from an
integrated travel and expense management tool?”
Overview
T&E tool include better compliance with T&E policies, increased Increased user satisfaction
(e.g., traveler, travel approver, 37%
user satisfaction, and improved financial planning and analytics. AP staff satisfaction)
An integrated T&E tool also supports other business objectives, Improved cash flow analysis,
Approach
35%
including greater digitalization and efficiency of company operations forecasting, budgeting, and
planning
and improved ability to handle duty-of-care obligations through
greater visibility into employee travels. Improved analytics on budget 35%
and spending
Opportunity
Opportunity
much more timely, and much more user-friendly for Improved visibility into
employees to get reimbursed versus the procedures employee travels and ability 33%
we had years ago.” to anticipate burnout
Job Roles
Improved efficiency in
33%
accounting and auditing
Conclusion
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 51 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT involved
in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises that have an integrated T&E platform
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 16
Overview
Critical Priority The majority (73%) of respondents from companies with an integrated T&E tool (73%) said their
organization plans to expand or upgrade its platforms/solutions. Departments have different critical
Capabilities In
priority capabilities in an integrated T&E tool. Amongst the most demanded functionalities are:
An Integrated • Automated policy violation notifications (top for finance, HR, and travel management)
Situation
• Receipt image via photo capture (top for finance, procurement, and travel management)
• Relevant, comprehensible, comparable content (top for travel management)
Opportunity
Opportunity
“What functionalities are most important in an integrated travel and management platform/solution for your company?”
(Top results for “critical requirement”)
Ability to handle multiple Automated T&E policy Intuitive user Analytics/data Receipt image from
1 workflows for approval (34%) violation notifications (37%) interface (40%) reporting (35%) email inbox (40%)
Automated T&E policy Intuitive user Analytics/data Ease of making changes/ Relevant, comprehensive, and
2 violation notifications (33%) interface (33%) reporting (38%) cancellations on existing easily comparable content
bookings (35%) (e.g., air travel/hotel/car) (39%)
Conclusion
Receipt image via photo VAT calculations VAT calculations Receipt image from Automated T&E policy
3 capture (32%) (33%) (38%) email inbox (35%) violation notification (37%)
FORRESTER OPPORTUNITY SNAPSHOT: A CUSTOM STUDY COMMISSIONED BY AMADEUS | SEPTEMBER 2020 Base: 556 manager and above decision-makers in finance, travel management, procurement, HR, and IT
involved in travel and expense management solutions at large enterprises
Source: A commissioned study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of Amadeus, April 2020
DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION FOR T&E: BALANCING PROCESS EFFICIENCIES, COMPLIANCE, AND EX 17
Overview
• Finance/accounting leaders said improving T&E • Procurement leaders said improving T&E tools and
tools and processes is a key part of their firm’s processes is a key part of their firm’s digital transformation
digital transformation (73%) and critical to improving (82%) and critical to improving employee engagement (78%).
Approach
employee engagement (70%). • Top T&E priorities: improving end-to-end experience of the
• Top T&E priorities: meeting industry standards (68%), T&E processes (84%), improving ability to gain actionable
increasing automation/reducing manual tasks (66%), insights from analytics on T&E (72%), and improving visibility
Opportunity
improving integration between T&E tools and other of existing and expected travel spending (53%).
enterprise systems (64%), and improving ability to gain • Top challenges with current T&E management: a lack of a
actionable insights from analytics on T&E (64%). global solution for all entities (21%), the amount of time taken
• Top challenges with current T&E management: time to submit/approve/document expenses (21%), an inability
Job Roles
taken to submit expense/approvals/documentation to manage travel compliance (20%), and the number of
(27%) and low speed of existing tools/processes (26%). inaccuracies due to human error (20%).
Conclusion
Travel Management (N=111) • Surveyed IT leaders said improving T&E tools and processes
Situation
Conclusion
Contributing Research:
• Outdated tools and lengthy processes for travel and expense
management is causing frustration in EX and friction in business Forrester’s Application
operations. Development & Delivery
Opportunity
research group
• Poorly integrated tools contribute to lengthy and disjointed end-
to-end processes. This increases the manual burden of T&E tasks
for employees, managers, and AP professionals.
Job Roles
Methodology
This Opportunity Snapshot was commissioned by Amadeus. Forrester Consulting
conducted a custom survey with 556 manager level and above decision makers
Situation
ENDNOTES
1
Source: “Align Your Tech Spending With Your Pandemic Priorities,” Forrester Research, Inc., April 22, 2020.
Opportunity
2
Source: “The Pandemic Recession Demands A Digital Response,” Forrester Research, Inc., June 25, 2020.
Forrester Consulting provides independent and objective research-based consulting to help leaders
succeed in their organizations. Ranging in scope from a short strategy session to custom projects,
Forrester’s Consulting services connect you directly with research analysts who apply expert insight to your
specific business challenges. For more information, visit forrester.com/consulting.
© 2020, Forrester Research, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction is strictly prohibited.
Information is based on best available resources. Opinions reflect judgment at the time and are subject to
Conclusion
change. Forrester®, Technographics®, Forrester Wave, RoleView, TechRadar, and Total Economic Impact are
trademarks of Forrester Research, Inc. All other trademarks are the property of their respective companies.
For additional information, go to forrester.com. [E-46651]
Demographics
COMPANY SIZE
GEOGRAPHY (NO. OF EMPLOYEES) JOB ROLE
Situation
India: N=35
T&E BUDGET JOB FUNCTION
Nordics: N=44