Draft Reclamation Manual Release Comments On This Draft Release Must Be Submitted To by 1/17/2022
Draft Reclamation Manual Release Comments On This Draft Release Must Be Submitted To by 1/17/2022
Draft Reclamation Manual Release Comments On This Draft Release Must Be Submitted To by 1/17/2022
The Bureau of Reclamation is revising the HRM 04-08, Hiring Process-Merit Promotion, to
ensure compliance with the recently issued Department of the Interior’s Merit Promotion &
Staffing Policy Personnel Handbook, dated November 2020, and streamline consistency in merit
promotion hiring practices using newly acquired human resources systems. This revision will
provide consistency in merit promotion program operations Reclamation-wide, promote
collaboration between all stakeholders involved in the hiring process, and provide emphasis on
Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Accessibility (DEIA) efforts during hiring practices.
Reclamation subject matter experts throughout the Human Resources Policy Office (HRPO) and
Servicing Human Resources Offices (SHROs) have collaborated to revise this D&S and
incorporate the goals outlined above. The following is a summary of the changes from the
current publication within this revision:
•formatting changes have been made throughout the document to comply with the new
required template for D&S documents per RCD 03-01;
•the addition of applicable authorities (e.g., PB 20-20) and removal of rescinded or
superseded authorities (e.g., 370 DM 335);
•the addition of new definitions and updating definitions for clarity and consistency
throughout this HRM and across all HRMs;
•the updating of terminology consistent with new DOI Initiatives, USA Staffing, and the
DOI MPP (PB 20-20);
•the removal of any binary language IAW EO 13988;
•the addition of DEIA efforts and strategic hiring requirements assessing a vacancy and
available recruitment mechanisms;
•the addition of shared recruitments/certificates (PB 20-14);
•the removal of all mentions of the Reclamation Merit Promotion Desk Guide and directs
readers to the DOI MPP;
•the updating approval process for hiring official requests to restrict an area of consideration
to the Reclamation HCO (previously the Manager, HRPPD);
•the addition of language to applicability to clearly include all GS, FWS and pay band
positions (such as BB) in the competitive and excepted service (agreements still prevail);
•the addition of timeliness requirements for corrective actions to program violations;
•the removal of Accretion of Duties language, providing direction to higher level or alternate
HRM policy;
•the addition of recordkeeping and electronic case filing requirements;
•the addition of Interest Announcements;
•the requirement for hiring officials to provide a selection justification and/or non-selection
explanation with certificate reviews; and
•the extension of the life of certificates to promote and facilitate using shared
recruitments/certificates.
The goal of preparing this external review is to and provide stakeholders with the opportunity to
comment on it in draft form.
The Reclamation Manual is used to clarify program responsibility and authority and to document
internal Reclamation-wide methods of doing business. All requirements in the Reclamation
Manual are mandatory.
Purpose: This Directive and Standard (D&S) establishes promotion and internal
placement requirements for filling competitive and excepted service
positions. The benefits of this D&S are to standardize the Bureau of
Reclamation’s systematic means of selection for promotion and internal
placement to assure recruitment methods and selection procedures are
equitably and consistently administered on the basis of merit and fair and
open competition.
1. Introduction. This D&S, together with procedures outlined in the DOI Merit Promotion
Plan (MPP) (PB 20-20), cover promotion and internal placement actions for competitive and
excepted service positions. Identification, qualification, evaluation, and selection will be
made on the basis of merit principles, without regard to political, religious, or labor
organization affiliation or non-affiliation, marital status, race, color, sex, national origin,
non-disqualifying physical or mental handicap, sexual orientation, or age and shall be based
solely on job-related criteria in accordance with legitimate position requirements. A sound
Merit Promotion (MP) program properly administered and fully supported by management
and employees at all levels is essential to the staffing of an effective and highly motivated
workforce. Servicing Human Resources Offices (SHROs) will advise and provide training
to hiring officials and employees on MP practices and selection procedures as needed. The
Human Resources Policy Office (HRPO) will provide clarifying guidance, implementation
procedures, and determine appropriate action for MP procedural best practices and
corrective actions. Procedural guidance outlined below must be followed during MP
recruitment efforts to conform with the requirements of 5 CFR part 335.103.
2. Applicability. This D&S applies to all Reclamation General Schedule (GS) positions up to
the grade GS-15 level or equivalent and to Senior Level (SL) positions, Federal Wage
System (FWS) positions, and positions in any other pay systems (e.g., Bargaining Board
[BB]) unless specifically exempted by special instructions and authority governing the
specific pay system involved. Where this guidance is silent, flexibilities within the DOI
MPP or higher authority are preserved. Where this guidance conflicts with a negotiated
agreement covering bargaining units, the agreement will prevail.
3. Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Accessibility (DEIA). Where at all possible, the MP
program will utilize outreach recruitment and hiring through DEIA efforts to represent a
diverse and equitable workforce. Hiring officials must consider (at a minimum) the
utilization of non-competitive hiring authorities when assessing a vacancy to ensure a
welcoming environment to all prospective applicants, placing a high value on diversity of
experience and cultural perspectives to build a 21st Century workforce that reflects the
diversity of the Nation. Sources for improving diversity will include outreach to Historically
Black Colleges/Universities, Hispanic Serving Institutions, Tribal Colleges, schools with
significant Asian Pacific Islander populations, and other academic institutions focused on
underserved communities. SHROs and Diversity and Inclusion Specialists will jointly
identify and utilize targeted recruitment outreach sources and advise hiring officials, as
appropriate. See Reclamation Manual D&S HRM 04-04, Pre-recruitment Consultation for
more information.
4. Strategic Hiring. Reclamation stakeholders of the MP hiring process include (but are not
limited to) the Reclamation Leadership Team (RLT), hiring officials, SHROs, EEO,
personnel security, and subject matter experts (SMEs). Appropriate stakeholders will utilize
strategic hiring methods during MP hiring while maintaining fair and equitable hiring
practices. In order to effectively recruit and acquire top talent for Reclamation, SHROs and
EEO will partner to educate and consult hiring officials on various targeted outreach and
strategic hiring methods available for effectively and efficiently filling vacancies during the
Pre-Recruitment Consultation and on an as-needed basis. SHROs will advise and counsel
hiring officials on available tools and options to retain Reclamation’s top talent. All
stakeholders participating in the MP program have an obligation to execute effective hiring
solutions most likely to best meet the Reclamation’s mission objectives, contribute fresh
ideas and new viewpoints, and meet Reclamation’s affirmative action goals (5 CFR part
335.103).
A. Hiring Flexibilities. Hiring officials will consider leveraging flexible hiring authorities
and programs during MP hiring alongside the competitive process, prior to the use of
contracting with private sector temporary firms (HRM 04-02, Obtaining Private Sector
Temporary Help Services). Hiring flexibilities include (but are not limited to):
(3) Direct hire authorities (e.g., Scientific, Technical, Engineering and Mathematics
(STEM), Cybersecurity);
(4) Federal, DOI, or Reclamation student hiring programs (e.g., Pathways, Resource
Assistant Internship); and
B. Data Analysis. Stakeholders will use reporting mechanisms such as the MD-715,
FEORP, and Time-to-Hire (T2H) datasets to assess and evaluate areas to improve the
overall MP hiring process. Hiring officials will practice data-driven decision-making to
evaluate the effectiveness of previous recruitment efforts to develop hiring solutions
that produce sufficient candidate pools.
Government’s official website for posting jobs. Exceptions only apply to recruitment
associated with reorganizations and budget constraints (see exceptions in paragraph
5.B.(2) below). Hiring officials must notify direct reports of MP opportunities during
an approved extended period of absence of five business days or longer.
B. Area of Consideration (AOC). Hiring officials, in consultation with the SHRO, will
determine the AOC and the length of time a JOA will remain open. The AOC may be
as large as Government-wide or as narrow as Reclamation-wide local commuting area
(LCA), unless covered by an exception listed in paragraph 5.B.(2) below. AOCs must
be sufficiently broad to ensure the availability of high-quality candidates and to
consider the nature and level of the positions covered. All AOCs must be set to
promote fair and open competition and to attract and maintain a diverse workforce.
(b) Budget Constraints. If budget constraints prevent a manager from hiring for
a new position or increased responsibility, the existing employees within that
organization may be exclusively considered for promotion to accommodate
the new tasks and responsibilities.
D. Open Period. A typical JOA open period (i.e., the duration of the USAJOBS JOA
application acceptance timeframe) is ten business days, however, the minimum open
period for a MP JOA is five business days. In partnership, SHROs and hiring officials
will establish an adequate open period based on the recruitment strategy developed
during the Pre-Recruitment Consultation and Strategic Recruitment Discussion (refer
to HRM 04-04). Considerations when determining the JOA open period include (but
are not limited to) the job analysis, assessment strategy, nature of the position,
promotion potential, duty location, previous recruitment efforts, and/or available labor
market. Where Standing Registers (or “Open Continuous”) JOAs are used when many
vacancies exist, or future personnel forecasting approves proactive recruitment, the
JOA must clearly specify the nature of the open period.
B. Multiple Hurdle Assessments. For those JOAs that include multiple hurdle
assessments, applicants must comply with assessment procedures as outlined on the
JOA and any follow-on instructions and deadlines provided to further evaluate
candidate qualifications. This may require candidates to submit further supporting
documentation to SHROs after the JOA open period.
8. Issuing a Certificate of Eligibles. SHROs will issue certificates for 30 calendar days to
hiring officials, allowing no more than two 30-calendar-day extensions to make candidate
selections.
assigned the appropriate Audit Code on the certificate before returning to the SHRO. If a
certificate is to be returned unused and the vacancy is filled through an alternate source, the
non-selection explanation and Audit Code will be included and assigned appropriately for
recordkeeping, quality review, and auditing purposes.
10. T2H Reporting Requirements. Stakeholders will adhere to DOI T2H reporting
requirements and collaborate to continually improve MP processes to strengthen the hiring
process. SHROs will ensure all data fields are key entered appropriately into USA Staffing
for accurate data collection, to include the requirements for reporting on DOI Key
Performance Indicators and any other data fields as directed by the HRPO to streamline
efficiencies. Refer to PB 20-09, Time-to-Hire Reporting Requirements and PB 20-12,
Strengthening Departmental Hiring and Vetting Practices for DOI requirements.
11. Recordkeeping. SHROs must maintain an electronic case file record for all MP hiring
actions and personnel associated through maximum utilization of USA Staffing.
Competitive hiring recruitment records will be maintained in the VIN case file documents
and non-competitive hiring action records will be maintained in the New Hire case file
documents, appropriately. New Hire records must reflect a status of “Complete” within
60 days of a New Hire’s entrance on duty date, to include any required documentation
transmitted to the employee’s electronic Official Personnel File (eOPF). Records not
authorized to be maintained in an appropriate personnel system or database will be filed and
managed in accordance with the Information Management Handbook (RCD 05-01,
Information Management).
12. Corrective Actions. SHROs must take immediate action to correct a violation or program
deficiency. In order to ensure that actions are processed in accordance with regulatory
and/or procedural requirements, corrections of errors will be made as soon as discovery is
made.
A. Records. Case file documentation will include all relevant and sufficient historical data
to enable a third-party reviewer to reconstruct a case file.
14. Interest Announcements (IA) for Temporary Assignments of 120 days or less. Where
timing and budget allows, hiring officials must consider the use of IAs to fill vacancies
temporarily (120 days or less) with internal employees while such MP vacancy public notice
requirements are being conducted. IAs will be distributed to all Reclamation employees to
afford interested, eligible, and qualified candidates such growth opportunities. SHROs will
survey internal employees, capture the applicant pool, refer candidates, and coordinate
temporary assignments (the use of USA Staffing functions is permitted). Candidates must
provide a supervisory endorsement with their application to be considered for the temporary
assignment. Hiring officials must coordinate temporary assignments with the supervisor of
record for those candidates selected for IA opportunities. Time spent on detail or temporary
promotion based on a selection from an IA does not afford non-competitive eligibility for
promotion to the permanent vacant position of record.
15. Definitions.
C. Career Transition Assistance Plan. A legally required Federal program that provides
eligible displaced Federal employees with intra-agency selection priority and
placement assistance for agency eligible employees who have been identified as
surplus and/or displaced due to downsizing or restructuring.
E. Competitive Service. All civilian positions that are (a) in the executive branch of the
Federal Government not specifically excepted from civil service laws (Excepted
Service) by or pursuant to statute, the President, or the Office of Personnel
Management (OPM), and not in the Senior Executive Service; and (b) in the legislative
and judicial branches of the Federal Government and in the government of the District
of Columbia specifically made subject to the civil service laws by statute.
H. In Writing. A form of communication that can be recorded and verified (i.e., email or
electronic notification).
J. Local Commuting Area. The geographic area that usually constitutes one area for
employment purposes. It includes any population center (or two or more neighboring
ones) and the surrounding localities in which people live and can reasonably be
expected to travel back and forth daily to their usual employment, (5 part CFR
351.203).
Q. Receiving SHRO. The SHRO that requests a Certificate of Eligibles (i.e., a shared
certificate) from an Originating SHRO.
U. Subject Matter Expert. A person with bona fide expert knowledge about what it takes
to do a particular job. Former and current first-level supervisors are normally good
SMEs. Superior incumbents in the same or very similar positions and other individuals
may also be used as SMEs if they have current and thorough knowledge of the job's
requirements. An SME may provide input on qualifications determinations if they are
not the Selecting Official and if all applicant identifying information has been removed.
An SME who provides input on qualification determinations should not be a panel
member.
X. Time-to-Hire. A term for the data metrics used to track the time it takes to recruit and
hire vacancies, measure the quality and speed of hiring, and report results to OPM
annually.
Y. USA Staffing. Reclamation’s talent acquisition system used to recruit, evaluate, assess,
certify, select, and onboard talent.
Z. Workforce Planning. A systematic process used to align the mission and goals of an
organization with the personnel needed to meet those goals.
16. Review Period. The originating office will review this release every four years.