Hydrothermal Corrosion Resistance of Silicon Nitride With O'-Sialon Grain Boundary Phase
Hydrothermal Corrosion Resistance of Silicon Nitride With O'-Sialon Grain Boundary Phase
Hydrothermal Corrosion Resistance of Silicon Nitride With O'-Sialon Grain Boundary Phase
*Institute of Inorganic Chemistry, Slovak Academy of Sciences, 84536 Bratislava, Slovak Republic
**Vitrum Laugaricio – Joint Glass Centre of the IIC SAS, TnU AD, FChFT STU and RONA j.s.c.,
91150 Trenčín, Slovak Republic
#
E-mail: [email protected]
Dense Si3N4-based composites with O’-SiAlON bonding phase were prepared by hot pressing of the mixture of Si3N4 matrix
and polysiloxane (samples SA) and polysilazane (samples SB) based sintering aids. In both samples α-Si3N4 and β-Si3N4 were
identified as major phases and O'-SiAlON with a chemical formula Si1.84Al0.16O1.16N1.84 as a minor phase. The hydrothermal
corrosion tests were performed in subcritical conditions at 250°C for 100 hours. The weight loss was rather low, 0.96 wt. %
and 1.32 wt. % for samples SA and SB, respectively. The corrosion rate of samples SA and SB was 206 mg·m-2·h-1 and
233 mg·m-2·h-1. The higher corrosion rate of sample SB prepared with polysilazane-based sintering aid is most probably due
to the hydrothermal dissolution of Si3N4 grains producing ammonia, as the pH value of eluate of this sample was higher, 8.5
compared to pH = 8.0 determined for sample SA. In sample SA a continuous SiO2-based passivation layer was formed, while
in sample SB the passivation layer was discontinuous and the corrosion medium could easily attack the Si3N4 grains. As the
corrosion solution was more basic in sample SB, the SiO2 passivation layer did not form so effectively, or dissolved faster
than in sample SA. The higher corrosion resistance of sample SA was partly improved also by using Y2O3 sintering additive,
which formed a rather stable Y2SiO5 phase.
prepared by hot pressing of the mixture of Si3N4 matrix homogenized in a Si3N4-based planetary ball mill in
and SiAlOCN-based polymer-derived ceramic sintering hexane and after rotary evaporation of solvent dried
aids. in vacuum drier at 80°C and 200 mbar for 6 h. Soft
agglomerates were crushed in agate mortar. From the
prepared powders pellets (φ = 12 mm) were pressed by
EXPERIMENTAL uniaxial pressing (100 MPa).
Samples were densified in a graphite resistance
Preparation of the sintering hot-pressing furnace. The sintering conditions and den-
additives sification behaviour of the produced samples are summa-
Commercial α-Si3N4 powder (SN-E10, Ube Indust- rized in Table 2. Due to the lower viscosity of polysilo-
ries Ltd., Tokyo, Japan, α-phase > 95 %, d50 = 0.5 µm) xane-based additives samples SA could be densified at
was used as a matrix for the preparation of Si3N4-based lower temperature and shorter time (1600°C/15 min)
composites. Two types of sintering aids have been used, compared to samples SB containing polysilazane-based
both were composed of preceramic polymers combined additives with higher viscosity (1700°C/30 min). The
with very fine inorganic fillers (Table 1). The preparation load of 30 MPa was applied at 1200°C during the heating
of sintering aids is described in details elsewhere [19]. up to the final processing temperature and released at
Briefly, the sintering additive A was prepared from the 1300°C during cooling. Nitrogen gas inlet started at
mixture of polysiloxane (Silres H44, Wacker-Chemie 300°C and was adjusted to constant 0.105 MPa in the
GmbH, Müchen, Germany), γ-Al2O3 (Aeroxide Alu C, furnace during the whole experiment.
Evonik Industries AG, Essen, Germany, d50 = 13 nm),
amorphous Si3N4 (Goodfellow, Huntingdon, England, Table 2. Hot pressing conditions (temperature T, dwell time td,
d50 = 20 nm), carbon black (Vulcan XC-72, Cabot, load P) and weight loss (Δm) of samples SA and SB.
Leuven, Belgium, mean particle size of 20 - 50 nm) and
Samples Tmax (°C) td (min) P (MPa) Δm (%)
Y2O3 (Inframat Advanced Materials, Manchester, CT,
USA, mean particle size of 30 - 50 nm) in isopropyl SA 1600 15 30 -5.87
alcohol. The homogenized slurry was dried for 8 h at SB 1700 30 30 -4.33
60°C. The fillers were active, because they formed a
SiAlON-based solid solution during sintering. Carbon
Materials characterization
acted as a reducing agent to produce in situ AlN from
γ-Al2O3, which was incorporated into the structure of Density measurements were carried out by the
SiAlON. Y2O3 served as a common sintering aid and Archimedes method in mercury. Each sintered sample
should decrease the viscosity of SiAlON-based liquid was measured three times and the standard deviation
phase during sintering. of density values was less than 0.02 g·cm-3. The micro-
The sintering aid B was prepared from the mixtu- structures were observed by scanning electron microsco-
re of polysilazane precursor (Ceraset PSZ20, KiON py (EVO 40HV; Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany). Phase
Defense Technologies Inc., Huntigdon Valley, PA, USA) composition was investigated by X-ray diffraction ana-
and γ-Al2O3 nanopowder (Aeroxide Alu C) in hexane. lysis (D8-Discover; Bruker, Madison, WI, CuKα radia-
After drying the mixture was crosslinked at 300°C for 1 tion), and applying the X’Pert HighScore Plus 3.0 soft-
h and pre-pyrolysed at 600°C for 30 min in flowing N2. ware (PANalytical, Inc., Westborough, MA).
Finally, the heat treated powder mixtures A and B were Vickers hardness and indentation fracture resistance
separately ball milled in Si3N4 milling container with were measured using Leco hardness tester (LV-100, Leco
Si3N4 balls. Co., St. Joseph, MI) by indentation method applying a
load of 9.8 N and 98 N, respectively. The indentation
fracture resistance was calculated according to Shetty’s
Preparation of composites equation [20]:
The starting powders for the preparation of Si3N4- KIC = 0.0889(H · P/4l)0.5 (2)
based composites were composed of 82 wt. % of α-Si3N4
(SN-E10, Ube Ind. Ltd., Japan) and 18 wt. % of sintering where H is the hardness, P is the applied load, and l is
additives (A or B, Table 1). The powder mixtures were the crack length.
a) SA b) BA
Figure 1. SEM micrographs of the plasma-etched cross-sections of sintered samples SA (a) and SB (b).
(HV ≈ 20 - 21 GPa) and O’-SiAlON (HV ≈ 16 - 17 GPa) that the amorphous SiO2 on the grain boundaries was
is higher compared to β-Si3N4 (HV ≈ 15 - 16 GPa). more readily dissolved into solution than the Si3N4 grains
For that reason the hardness of sample SA is higher, as it and the aqueous corrosion of Si3N4 was categorized as
contains in total larger amount of these harder phases (cf. intergranular corrosion. In our earlier work we have
Table 3). Surprisingly, the indentation fracture resistance observed a lower corrosion rate for dense Si3N4 with
of sample SB is slightly lower compared to sample SA, 5 wt. % Y2O3 sintering additive and the weight loss
although it contains larger amount of β-Si3N4 with an was 1.0 ± 0.2 mg·cm-2 after 100 hours of hydrothermal
elongated shape of grains (Figure 1b). Slight decrease of corrosion at 290°C [15]. It seems that amorphous silica
fracture resistance might be due to the larger content of was the weakest compound in the above mentioned
brittle O’-SiAlON phase (24.3 %). hydrothermal corrosion tests of Si3N4. The solubility of
SiO2 in water is temperature and pressure dependent and
Table 4. Density (ρ), Vickers hardness (HV) and indentation it is higher for amorphous silica (a-SiO2) compared to
fracture resistance (KIC) of samples SA and SB. crystalline phase. The solubility of a-SiO2 at 97°C and
340 °C is 415 mg·l-1 and 1660 mg∙l-1, respectively [25].
ρ HV KIC
amples
S Considering the linear relationship in the dependence of
(g·cm-3) (GPa) (MPa·m1/2)
log of dissolution rate vs. 1/T, the estimated solubility of
SA 3.11 19.0 ± 0.1 5.07 ± 0.12 a-SiO2 at 250°C is about 1150 mg·l-1. Perera et al. [26]
SB 3.09 18.4 ± 0.6 4.74 ± 0.15 showed that during the hydrothermal corrosion tests of
silicate glasses water penetrates into the surface layers of
the Si−O lattice and reacts with Si−O bonds:
Properties after hydrothermal Si−O−Si + H2O = SiOH + HOSi (3)
corrosion
These bond-breaking reactions destroy the structure
Both samples SA and SB exhibited a good hydro- and the silicate islands dissolve in water and form ortho-
thermal corrosion resistance. The measured weight silicic acid according to reaction:
loss in sample SA after the hydrothermal corrosion test
SiO2 + 2H2O ↔ H4SiO4 ↔ H3SiO4– +
at 250°C for 100 hours was 0.96 wt. %. In sample SB (4)
+ H+ ↔ H2SiO42- + 2H+
the weight loss was higher, 1.32 wt. % (Table 5). The
pH value of corrosion media changed from neutral to Such a corrosion could take part in a certain extent
also in our samples, especially in sample SA with higher
Table 5. The results of hydrothermal corrosion tests of samples oxygen content. However, reaction (4) decreases the pH
SA and SB at 200°C for 100 hours. of corrosion solution and we have observed an increase
of pH to 8 and 8.5 for sample SA and SB, respectively.
Δm pH Δm/A rate
amples
S
(wt. %) (GPa) (mg·cm-2) (mg·m-2·h-1) The pH value can increase by the dissolution of Si3N4
in water yielding ammonia according to reaction (1), or
SA -0.96 8.0 2.05 205.5 summarized reactions (1) and (4) [27]:
SB -1.32 8.5 2.33 233.4
Si3N4 + 12H2O = 3Si(OH)4 + 4NH3 (5)
alkaline after the corrosion test, concretely to 8.0 in Ammonia is a weak base highly soluble in water and
sample SA and 8.5 in sample SB. increases the pH of eluate. This might be a reason, why
There are several factors which could cause the the pH value of the corrosion medium of sample SB was
differences in corrosion rate of samples SA and SB. higher. While sample SA contained polysiloxane-based
The first is the phase composition, especially the much (Si–C–O) precursor as sintering additive, in sample SB
higher α-Si3N4 and lower O’-SiAlON content in sample nitrogen/rich polysilazane-based (Si–C–N) precursor
SA compared to sample SB (Table 3). It is known that was used. This resulted in a higher content of β-Si3N4 in
the lattice oxygen content is much lower in β-Si3N4 the sintered product and according to reactions (1) and/
than in α-Si3N4 [22]. Although it is not necessary that or (5) more ammonia formed and dissolved in subcritical
α-Si3N4 contain oxygen to stabilize its structure, it can water and increased the pH value of corrosion medium.
accommodate a considerable amount of oxygen [22]. It Although the hydrothermal corrosion of both samples
was found that at 1400°C ca. 0.8 ± 0.2 wt. % oxygen can SA and SB was low, the weight loss of sample SB was
dissolve in α-Si3N4 [23]. The highest oxygen solubility approximately by 38 % higher than in sample SA. The
measured in β-Si3N4 single crystal is 0.26 wt. % [24]. higher weight loss and higher pH value of corrosion
Oda at al. have investigated the hydrothermal corrosion medium in the case of sample SB gives a hints that
of pure, hot isostatically pressed Si3N4 (containing reactions (1) and (5) prevail during the hydrothermal
1.4 wt. % O as an impurity) and observed a weight loss corrosion of Si3N4-based samples in subcritical water.
of 9 - 12 mg·cm-2 after the corrosion test at 300°C and The SEM study of the corroded samples shows that
pressure 8.6 MPa for 96 hours [7]. They have observed in sample SA very fine, almost continuous SiO2 corro-
Ceramics – Silikáty 62 (4) 382-388 (2018) 385
Vetrecin M., Lenčéš Z., Galusková D., Šajgalík P.
sion layer was formed (Figure 2), which slows down the by Nickel et al. [30] was in the range of 190 ± 70 mg·m-2·h-1
dissolution of the sample. In sample SB the corrosion and that of dense Si3N4 with 5 wt. % Y2O3 sintering
layer consisted of whisker-like grains, copying the additive measured at 290°C in our earlier work from
structure of original elongated β-Si3N4 grains (Figure 3). the leached amount of nitrogen was 210 ± 2 mg·m-2·h-1
In this case the corrosion layer was not compact and [15]. The corrosion rate of samples SA and SB in this
did not separate the sample surface from the corrosion work at 250°C was 206 mg·m-2·h-1 and 233 mg·m-2·h-1
media. The solubility of SiO2 is much lower in neutral (Table 5), respectively. Although the listed corrosion
and in acidic solutions than in basic solutions [28]. rates are similar, the values cannot be compared due
In the case of sample SB the pH value of eluate was to the different testing temperatures and also due to the
higher (8.5) and the SiO2 passivating layer did not form different ratio of the sample surface (S) to the volume of
so effectively than in sample SA with lower pH value corrosion media (V). If we compare only dense Si3N4-
(8.0). The lower weight loss during the corrosion tests of based samples, then in the work of Galuskova et al.
sample SA might be influenced also by the use of Y2O3 [15] the ratio S/V was 0.7, while in this work due to the
sintering aid, which increases the corrosion resistance of smaller size of tested samples the ratio was lower, 0.17.
Si3N4 under hydrothermal conditions [29]. Yuan et al. [31] have studied the influence of S/V ratio
The corrosion rate of Si3N4 powder (grade LC 12N, on the hydrothermal corrosion of SiCN-based ceramic
s.s.a. = 17 m2·g-1, H.C. Stack) in water at 300°C determined composites and reported that with decreasing S/V ratio
the weight loss increased. Therefore, higher weight loss
is expected for samples SA and SB at 290°C with S/V
ratio 0.17 compared to the corrosion rate of samples with
S/V ratio 0.7, as their corrosion rate was similar to these
samples already at 250°C.
Finally it can be concluded that both samples SA
and SB composed of α-Si3N4, β-Si3N4 and O’-SiAlON
phases have a good corrosion resistance in subcritical
water at 250°C.
CONCLUSIONS
the corrosion solution was more basic in sample SB, the 1 N H2SO4. Journal of the European Ceramic Society,
SiO2 passivating layer did not form so effectively, or 26(16), 3909–3917. doi: 10.1016/J.JEURCERAMSOC.
dissolved faster than in sample SA. The higher corrosion 2005.12.001.
13. Blugan G., Wittig D., Kuebler J. (2009): Oxidation and
resistance of sample SA was partly influenced/improved
corrosion of silicon nitride ceramics with different sintering
also by using Y2O3 sintering additive, which formed a additives at 1200 and 1500 °C in air, water vapour, SO2
rather stable Y2SiO5 phase. and HCl environments – A comparative study. Corrosion
Science, 51(3), 547–555. doi: 10.1016/J.CORSCI.2008.
12.014.
Acknowledgments 14. Galusková D., Kašiarová M., Hnatko M., Galusek D., Dusza
J., Šajgalík P. (2014): Hydrothermal corrosion and flexural
This work was supported by Slovak Grant Agencies strength of Si3N4-based ceramics. Corrosion Science, 85,
94–100. doi: 10.1016/j.corsci.2014.04.005.
APVV-14-0385 and VEGA 2/0164/18.
15. Galusková D., Hnatko M., Galusek D., Šajgalík P. (2011):
Corrosion of structural ceramics under subcritical conditions
in aqueous sodium chloride solution and in deionized
REFERENCES water. Part I: Dissolution of Si3N4-based ceramics. Journal
of the American Ceramic Society, 94(9), 3035–3043. doi:
1. Riley F.L. (2004): Silicon nitride and related materials. 10.1111/j.1551-2916.2011.04553.x.
Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 83(2), 245–265. 16. Tatarko P., Kašiarová M., Dusza J., Šajgalík P. (2013):
doi: 10.1111/j.1151-2916.2000.tb01182.x. Influence of rare-earth oxide additives on the oxidation
2. Nagae M., Yoshio T., Oda K. (2006): Corrosion Behaviour resistance of Si3N4–SiC nanocomposites. Journal of the
of Structural Ceramics in Supercritical Water. Advances in European Ceramic Society, 33(12), 2259–2268. doi:
Science and Technology, 45, 173–177. doi: 10.4028/www. 10.1016/j.jeurceramsoc.2013.01.008.
scientific.net/AST.45.173. 17. Opila E.J., Robinson R.C., Fox D.S., Wenglarz R.A.,
3. Weingärtner H., Franck E.U. (2005): Supercritical water Ferber M.K. (2003): Additive effects on Si3N4 oxidation/
as a solvent. Angewandte Chemie International Edition, volatilization in water vapor. Journal of the American
44(18), 2672–2692. doi: 10.1002/anie.200462468. Ceramic Society, 86(8), 1262–1271. doi: 10.1111/j.1151-
4. Haldeman C.W., Ahern B.S., Johnson K.H. (1997). Super- 2916.2003.tb03462.x.
critical water fuel composition and combustion system. 18. Linck C., Ionescu E., Papendorf B., Galuskova D., Galusek
US6010544A. D., Šajgalík P., Riedel R. (2012): Corrosion behavior of
5. Sato T., Haryu K., Endo T., Shimada M. (1987): High-tem- silicon oxycarbide-based ceramic nanocomposites under
perature oxidation of silicon nitride-based ceramics by water hydrothermal conditions. International Journal of Materials
vapour. Journal of Materials Science, 22(7), 2635–2640. Research, 103(1), 31–39. doi: 10.3139/146.110625.
doi: 10.1007/BF01082156. 19. Parcianello G., Bernardo E., Colombo P., Lenčéš Z.,
Vetrecín M., Šajgalík P., Kašiarová M. (2014): Preceramic
6. Kim H.-E., Moorhead A.J. (1990): High-temperature
polymer-derived SiAlON as sintering aid for silicon nitride.
gaseous corrosion of Si3N4 in H2-H2O and Ar-O2 environ-
Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 97(11), 3407–
ments. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 73(10),
3412. doi: 10.1111/jace.13134.
3007–3014. doi: 10.1111/j.1151-2916.1990.tb06708.x.
20. Shetty D.K., Wright I.G., Mincer P.N., Clauer A.H.
7. Oda K., Yoshio T., Miyamoto Y., Koizumi M. (1993): Hydro-
(1985): Indentation fracture of WC-Co cermets. Journal
thermal corrosion of pure, hot isostatically pressed silicon
of Materials Science, 20(5), 1873–1882. doi: 10.1007/
nitride. Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 76(5),
BF00555296.
1365–1368. doi: 10.1111/j.1151-2916.1993.tb03768.x.
21. Lindqvist O., Sjöberg J., Hull S., Pompe R. (1991):
8. Proverbio E., Carassiti F. (1996): Low-temperature oxida- Structural changes in O’-sialons, Si2−xAlxN2−xO1+x, 0.04 ≤ x ≤
tion of silicon nitride by water in supercritical condition. 0.40. Acta Crystallographica Section B Structural Science,
Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 16(10), 1121–1126. 47(5), 672–678. doi: 10.1107/S0108768191004883.
doi: 10.1016/0955-2219(96)82256-4. 22. Kato K., Inoue Z., Kijima K., Kawada I., Tanaka H.,
9. Seipel B., Nickel K.. (2003): Corrosion of silicon nitride in Yamane T. (1975): Structural approach to the problem
aqueous acidic solutions: Penetration monitoring. Journal of oxygen content in alpha silicon nitride. Journal of the
of the European Ceramic Society, 23(4), 595–602. doi: American Ceramic Society, 58(3–4), 90–91. doi: 10.1111/
10.1016/S0955-2219(02)00280-7. j.1151-2916.1975.tb19564.x.
10. Fox D.S., Opila E.J., Nguyen Q.N., Humphrey D.L., 23. Peuckert M., Greil P. (1987): Oxygen distribution in silicon
Lewton S.M. (2003): Paralinear Oxidation of Silicon nitride powders. Journal of Materials Science, 22(10),
Nitride in a Water-Vapor/Oxygen Environment. Journal 3717–3720. doi: 10.1007/BF01161483.
of the American Ceramic Society, 86(8), 1256–1261. doi: 24. Hirao K., Tsuge A., Brito M.E., Kanzaki S. (1993): Prepa-
10.1111/j.1151-2916.2003.tb03461.x. ration of rod-like β-Si3N4 single crystal particles. Journal of
11. Nickel K.G., Seipel B. (2004): Corrosion penetration the Ceramic Society of Japan, 101x(1177), 1078–1080. doi:
monitoring of advanced ceramics in hot aqueous fluids. 10.2109/jcersj.101.1078.
Materials Research, 7(1), 125–133. doi: 10.1590/S1516- 25. Morachevsky Y. V., Piryutko M.M. (1956): Solubility
14392004000100017. of silicic acid. Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the
12. Schilm J., Gruner W., Herrmann M., Michael G. (2006): USSR Division of Chemical Science, 5(8), 917–923. doi:
Corrosion of Si3N4-ceramics in aqueous solutions Part 10.1007/BF01166404.
I: Characterisation of starting materials and corrosion in 26. Perera G., Doremus R.H., Lanford W. (1991): Dissolution
rates of silicate glasses in water at pH 7. Journal of and basic solutions and under hydrothermal conditions.
the American Ceramic Society, 74(6), 1269–1274. doi: Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 23(4), 585–594.
10.1111/j.1151-2916.1991.tb04096.x. doi: 10.1016/S0955-2219(02)00303-5.
27. Greil P., Nitzsche R., Friedrich H., Hermel W. (1991): 30. Nickel K.G., Däumling U., Weisskopf K. (1993):
Evaluation of oxygen content on silicon nitride powder Hydrothermal reactions of Si3N4. Key Engineering
surface from the measurement of the isoelectric point.
Materials, 89–91, 295–300. doi: 10.4028/www.scientific.
Journal of the European Ceramic Society, 7(6), 353–359.
net/KEM.89-91.295.
doi: 10.1016/0955-2219(91)90058-8.
28. Herrmann M. (2013): Corrosion of silicon nitride materials 31. Yuan J., Luan X., Riedel R., Ionescu E. (2015): Preparation
in aqueous solutions. Journal of the American Ceramic and hydrothermal corrosion behavior of Cf/SiCN and Cf/
Society, 96(10), 3009–3022. doi: 10.1111/jace.12509. SiHfBCN ceramic matrix composites. Journal of the
29. Herrmann M., Schilm J., Michael G., Meinhardt J., Flegler European Ceramic Society, 35(12), 3329–3337. doi:
R. (2003): Corrosion of silicon nitride materials in acidic 10.1016/j.jeurceramsoc.2014.12.009.