Auditory-Verbal Techniques and Hierarchies
Auditory-Verbal Techniques and Hierarchies
Judith Simser
Consultant in Childhood Hearing Impairment
[email protected]
In Auditory-Verbal practice there is an expectation that young children with hearing loss can use technologically
assisted hearing to learn to listen, to process verbal language and to speak. The goal is that children with hearing
loss can grow up in regular learning and living environments that enable them to become independent,
participating, and contributing citizens in mainstream society. The A-V philosophy supports the basic human right
that children with all degrees of hearing loss deserve an opportunity to develop the ability to listen and to use verbal
communication in their daily lives. Adapted from Auditory-Verbal International, (1991)
Goldberg & Flexer and (2001) presented an outcome survey of children raised in Auditory-Verbal programmes.
Ninety-three percent of the respondents were severely or profoundly deaf.
The questions in the survey revealed the following:
1) Do you consider yourself part of the hearing world, the deaf world, or both?
--- 76% consider themselves part of the hearing world
--- 21% consider themselves part of both the hearing and the deaf world
--- less than 1% were part of the deaf world
2) Nearly 90% had been fully mainstreamed in regular schools
3) 72% use the telephone
4) 94% went on to post-secondary education
One of the principles of Auditory-Verbal Practice states that diagnostic therapy is individualised with parent
participation1. By individualising therapy, therapists are able to adjust the program to account for differences in a
child's and a parent’s personality, their learning styles, their interests, the degree of handicap and current
functioning level of the child. In therapy sessions, a favourable learning environment is created for the parent and
child with good acoustics, few distractions from others and a child in the presence of positive role models. Toys in
a therapy program should replicate real life activities in a home environment. When the parent and child return to
their home and community, they have ample opportunity in a natural setting to practice the skills and activities that
they learned in therapy sessions. It is beneficial for the therapist to make an occasional home visit so that each
family's home environment and living style is considered in therapy planning. Activities that replicate a specific
family's routine activities in the home and community will foster the use of incidental language throughout their
day. Children learn best by a parent/caregiver integrating targets that are unrecognised by the child, into to the
child's daily life. Examples include:
String up a clothesline between two chairs. Wash and hang out the doll's clothes.
Buy fruit at a market. Return to the therapy session. Cut up the fruit and offer it to other children.
1
Auditory-Verbal International, (1991), Guiding principles. Auricle. Fall Vol.3. Alexandria, VI.
2
In the clinics in Taiwan there are situational therapy rooms: a bedroom, a living room and a kitchen to replicate
those settings in the home. Parents are often nervous about children being in the kitchen. Parents learn that the
kitchen has a wealth of listening, vocabulary and language learning opportunities when engaged in activities such
as: making cookies, pudding, playdoh, toast with facial parts drawn with butter, cutting vegetables and sandwiches,
making simple picture-drawn recipes. Many of these activities can be recreated in any therapy room!
Location of sessions
The auditory-verbal approach can be practised everywhere! Sessions can be held at the park, at the mass rapid
transit station, at the local market or shopping centre or simply during a walk in the neighbourhood.
Therapists may discourage a parent's participation because often it is easier for a therapist, (as an authority figure)
to maintain control of a child without a parent in the room. However, it is not the number of teacher contact hours
that develops a child’s language! Or is it the number of hours sitting at a table doing "therapy". It is not the
quantity or quality of toys! A foundation of language is developed through natural interactions about topics that are
meaningful and interesting to a child. A parent's work is a child's play!
Most early language learners do not have sufficient language to access the set curriculum developed by boards of
education. How can a child follow academic subjects when a child doesn’t have the language to request needs,
explain feelings and observations, to communicate and to learn? An individualised program, suited to the parent
and child’s needs, is created through ongoing assessment and teaching; as well as the teamwork of parents and
therapist.
Parents are instructed in techniques to be the primary language facilitator for their child. Parent's active
participation in therapy sessions can be reinforced by the therapist in the following ways:
stating the goal to the parent before beginning an activity.
modelling strategies clearly.
3
Parent progress
There are a variety of ways to assess and guide parents in their interactions with their child. Most methods involve
interactional approaches such as in "Bromwich's Parent Behaviour Progression Form". 2 Parent behaviours during
different stages of their infant or child’s development are recorded as observed or reported during conversations. In
Cole's book, she provides a checklist, "Caregivers: Communication-Promoting Behaviours." This lists desired
observations during interactions between parent and child.3 These forms can provide a framework for further
discussion between a therapist and parent.
2
Bromwich, R. Working with parents and infants, Baltimore, MA: University Park Press. p.341-359
3
Cole, E. (1992). Listening and talking: A guide to promoting spoken language in young hearing impaired children.
Washington, DC: Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf. p.48-50
4
Individualised diagnostic sessions are routinely held once weekly for one to one and a half hours. The following
outline describes some essential components of a therapy session and factors to be considered in planning:
All components are to be integrated into daily natural, useful and meaningful play activities.
AUDITORY-VERBAL TECHNIQUES
The following are some of the techniques used in Auditory-Verbal education
to enhance a child’s listening, speech and language skills.
A hand cue is especially useful when talking to a visually oriented child with hearing loss who is searching for
visual cues.
If a child has a profound hearing impairment and has insufficient aided hearing to access the speech range to
develop spoken language through hearing, his/her parents may chose cochlear implantation for their child. Once
the cochlear implant is programmed, this child will be a beginning auditory learner and with effective auditory-
verbal techniques will gradually transition from using only vision to developing his/her newfound hearing potential
by learning to listen.
“CAN TECHNIQUES OTHER THAN THE HAND CUE BE USED TO EMPHASIZE HEARING?”
Yes! Preferably the primary caregiver should sit beside the child, close to the better ear or the microphone of the
cochlear implant. The closer they are to the child’s ear the softer the voice to ensure the opportunity to hear the
less salient speech sounds. Vowels are louder than consonants and often mask a child’s hearing of the softer
consonants. This is often evident in a child’s speech when consonants are deleted or substituted. No hand cue is
necessary with preferential seating unless the child is actively searching for visual cues.
The therapist or teacher can suggest that the older child turn away to emphasise listening. This helps the child
attend to the listening task and to concentrate on what is heard.
2. ACOUSTIC HIGHLIGHTING
The earliest form of acoustic highlighting used is called “Motherese” or “Parentese.” It is speech used by
parents/caregivers in talking with young children to make speech more audible to help them in learning language.
Research by Dr. Patricia Kuhl indicates that parentese is universal and plays a vital role in helping infants analyse
speech. The use of early highlighting is an auditory technique that is extended in communicating with the
beginning hearing aid or cochlear implant user to increase the audibility of language. As a child learns to listen,
the aim is to progress towards a more normal, less highlighted mode of communication.
© Judith I. Simser
However, having reached the goal of less highlighting, it must be remembered that there are many noisy acoustic
environments where acoustic highlighting may continue to be necessary just as it is with those who have normal
hearing.
3. AUDITORY FEEDBACK
When children imitate or use spontaneous speech, they match their voice production with the speech patterns of
others thus monitoring their own speech production. Besides this direct auditory feedback, children receive
indirect feedback from the listener’s reactions to their vocalisations and speech, which further reinforces the quality
of their production. In auditory directions, asking children to imitate what they heard, discourages guessing as it
serves to verify what the children heard before attempting the task.
In developing a listening function, there is a constant interplay of targets in listening, speech, language,
communication and cognition in all interactions throughout a child’s day, with any variety of targets incorporated
into any one event. Weekly targets are given to parents/caregivers and classroom teachers to co-ordinate efforts
and to build upon listening basics. When parents integrate Auditory-Verbal techniques and targets into everyday,
meaningful activities and experiences then their children have the best opportunity to develop good listening and
language outcomes. Only once children have developed language can they then access school curricula.
LEARNING TO LISTEN
Guidance in creating a listening, learning environment is pertinent to the beginning stages, regardless of age.
Suggestions include some of the following:
Enhance the acoustic environment by being close to the microphone of a child’s cochlear implant or the
hearing aid of the better ear. Encourage listening by sitting beside a child, (not across), and focusing on objects
in front of parent and child.
Be aware of and minimise background noises especially the noise of an air conditioner, television, fridge or
radio.
This student is a BEGINNER. Assist a child by making speech more audible using parentese; that is, spoken
language that is rich in suprasegmental qualities, repetitive in nature, initially focusing on low and mid-
frequency vowel content, and in the context of short, meaningful two-to-three-word phrases.
Throughout the day cue a child to “listen” while pointing to your ear to alert a child to attend to auditory input
and meaningful environmental sounds. Observe a child’s listening and responding behaviours such as
cessation of movement, eye contact to an object or person, imitation of a sound or a response indicating
listening through body posture.
Follow a child’s interest level in age and stage appropriate activities and experiences with specific targets
integrated.
Reinforce the expectation that with Auditory-Verbal techniques a child will learn to listen
© Judith I. Simser
Name: DOB: Date started A.V.:
Hearing loss: Hearing aid model or implant:
Key: Beginning ┴ Inconsistent + Consistent Expressive Use (Cross out check)
Ling 6 Sound Test: detection & identification m__ u__ a__ i__ sh__ s__ silence__
distance (12 cm. 50 cm. 1 m. 2 m.): m___ u___ a___ i___ sh___ s___
words in phrases: 1. vowels + syllables differ ___ 3. rhyming words ___
2. same consonant, vowels differ ___ 4. final consonants only differ ___
AUDITION
dates:
st
Vocabulary (1 year only): comprehension ___ wds ___ wds ___ wds ___ wds
spontaneous use ___ wds ___ wds ___ wds ___ wds
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
nouns: sound-word ___ subject nouns ___ object nouns ___ parts of objects ___
by description___ plural nouns, irregular ___ regular___
verbs: directives ___ present progressive ___ future ___ past tense ___ conditional ___
pronouns: mine ___ I ___ you ___ he ___/or she ___ they ___ him ___
her ___ them ___ his ___ hers ___ theirs ____ we ___ us___
LANGUAGE
examples of spoken language (bracket missing parts of speech) i.e., Daddy(‘s) car no (won’t) go.
date _________________________________________________________________________
date _________________________________________________________________________
10
voice quality (low 1- 5): ___ speech intelligibility (1-5): in context ___ out of context ___
suprasegmentals: duration: long ___ short ___ varied ___
intensity: loud ___ soft ___ varied ___
frequency: high___ low ___ varied ___
vowels: u___ a___ o___ æ ___ - i ___ ʌ ___ ɑ __ ɛ ___ - ʋ ___ e ___ ɝ ___ ɔ ___ ɪ ___
vowels alternated: u-a ___ a-u ___ - i-a ___ e-i ___
SPEECH
sorting: identical objects ___ categories ___ by function, shape, colour, number, texture, content
go togethers: real objects ___ cards or puzzles___ colours: red ___ blue ___ green ___ yellow ___
rote counting: 1-10 ___ number concepts: 1-3 ___ 4-6 ___ 7-10 ___ 11-20 ___ no. after___ no. before___
COGNITION
no. in-between ___ count by twos, threes ___ addition by one ___ by twos ___ subtraction by one___
create equal sets___ number stories ___
shapes: circle ___ square ___ star ___ triangle ___ rectangle ___
textures: soft ___ rough ___ continue concept list ___
comparisons: same___ different ___ doesn't belong ___ how alike ___ categorise and give reasons why ___
sequencing: shapes ___ colours ___ patterns ___ 2-4 pt. story ___ events ___ tell story __ multiple endings__
identity of an object ___ opposites ___ analogies ___ inferences ___ synonyms ___
double meanings ___ simple jokes ___ riddles ___ idioms ___
practises turn taking ___ uses courtesy language: e.g., bye, I'm sorry, excuse me ___
initiates interactions ___ uses questioning ___
initiates conversational topics ___
repair strategies: asks for repetition ___ uses appropriate topic transitions ___
verifies partial information ___ shares conversational control ___
asks for clarification ___ provides clarification ___
maintains topic: 1 turn ___ 2 turns ___ 3 turns ___ extends conversation ___
NOTES:
© Judith I. Simser
mser
10
AUDITORY MEMORY DEVELOPMENT
The items underlined indicate examples of the items a child needs to identify to understand the directions or
information.
*Develop ability to follow a one-item memory task:
1. containing repetition of sound-word association in phrases, e.g.” The ball goes bounce, bounce,
bounce.”
2. in single repetition of a sound-word association, e.g.” Where’s the cat that goes meow?”
3. in single objects representing nouns, verbs, adjectives and common phrases with varied
suprasegmentals and vowel content, e.g. “Pick the flower” vs. “Wash, wash, wash your hands”
vs. “Mmm, that’s good.”
4. in single objects varying in vowel content and syllables, e.g. “Where’s the spoon?” vs. apple
vs. ice cream cone.
5. with word presented at end of sentence, e.g. “Please get the bananas.”
6. with word presented in middle or at beginning of sentence to prepare for two item memory,
e.g. “Please put the bananas on the table,” while the speaker is pointing to the table.
SELECTION BY DESCRIPTION
A child begins to listen to longer information by identifying known vocabulary by its description
in a closed set (where a choice of objects is visible to the child). Begin after the child has about a
two-item memory.
1. where a known word or object representing a sound-word is used repeatedly, e.g. “It flies, up,
up, up in the sky, it goes ah….ah, you ride in it.” “What is it?” Use a choice of four objects of
different categories and all known vocabulary. For example, a shoe, a ball, a car and a dog.
2. identify an object by attending to a single repetition of familiar key words in the description,
e.g., “It has four legs, it swims in the water, it hops and it is green. What is it? All characteristics
in the choice of objects should vary.
3. include some objects that have a few similar characteristics, e.g., a bird and an airplane both
fly; a fish and a frog both swim in the water.
4. *begin open set descriptions beginning with steps 1 and 2 above.
SPEECH DEVELOPMENT
In developing speech through hearing, a developmental rather than remedial program is used.
Speech babble is used to develop speech perception. As speech perception improves there is a
reciprocal benefit in speech production, Ling, D. (1997). Just as we repeat syllables in learning
new words or a new language, so do we encourage the use of syllabic babble to heighten the
auditory perception and production of speech sounds. Segments of therapy will involve practise
in identifying early emerging phonemes such as vowels [a], [u], [o] and [i] and consonants [b],
[m], (sh) and whispered [p] and [h]. Initially do not combine [u] with [m] as these will sound too
similar to the beginning listener. The young child can practise phoneme perception by playing
with objects with the above phonemes as associated sounds, (see Appendix A) and the older child
can listen to identify them by their phonetic equivalents. When phonemes are identified,
encourage production in syllabic babble and once achieved, phonemes should be transferred into
phonology. Suggestions to develop intelligible speech include the following:
listen carefully to a child’s speech to analyse speech errors rather than lip-reading him/her.
in all speech techniques attempt to elicit a phoneme through hearing first. If a visual or
tactile cue is used, once the child produces the sound, have him/her say it repeatedly using
hearing only for auditory feedback to occur.
when phonemes are missing, distorted or substituted, soften voice, get close to the implant or
hearing aids and acoustically highlight the defective phoneme in syllabic babble. Once well
produced in syllabic babble, transfer to phonology.
continue to improve the suprasegmental qualities of speech. To aid in intelligibility
emphasise rhythm in word groupings to create short phrases. For example, “My sister…went
to school…on the school bus.”
12
13
as a child progresses, use less acoustic highlighting with goal of more normal speech
reception and production.
APPENDIX A
SUGGESTIONS FOR HIGHLIGHTING BEGINNING VOCABULARY
Vehicles
boat - p-p-p (unvoiced) car - b-r-r-r (truck)
airplane - a-a-a train - oo-oo-oo bus - bu-bu-bu
Animal sounds
cow - moo dog - bow-wow horse - neigh
cat - meow lamb - ba-a-a fish - swish
pig - oink frog - hop-hop-hop chicken - cluck
bird - chirp duck - quack-quack monkey - ee-ee-ee
owl - hhoo lion - rroar-rroar bear - grr-grr
Common Phrases
13
14
REFERENCES
Auditory-Verbal International. (1991). Guiding principles. Auricle. Fall Vol.3. Alexandria, VI.
Bromwich, R. (1981). Working with parents and infants. Baltimore, MA: University Park Press.
Cole, E. (1992). Listening and talking: A guide to promoting spoken language in young hearing
impaired children. Washington, DC: Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf.
Estabrooks, W., Editor, (2001). 50 FAQ About AVT, Toronto, Ont.: Learning to Listen
Foundation
Estabrooks, W., Editor, (1994). Auditory-verbal therapy for parents and professionals,
Washington, DC: Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf.
Flexer, C. (1999), Facilitating hearing and listening in children. (2nd Ed.). San Diego, CA: Singular
Publishing Group
Goldberg, D.M &. Flexer, C. (1993) Outcome survey of auditory-verbal graduates: Study of
clinical efficacy. Journal of the American Academy of Audiology, 4, 189-200.
Ling, D. (2002). Speech and the hearing impaired child: Theory and Practice. 2nd Edition.
Washington, DC: Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf.
Ling, D., & Ling, A.H. (1978). Aural habilitation: The foundations of verbal learning.
Washington, DC: Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf.
Luterman, D. (1999). The young deaf child. Baltimore, Maryland. York Press, Inc.
Pollack, D., Goldberg, D., & Caleffe-Schenck, N. (1997). Educational audiology for the limited-
hearing infant. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas (3rd Edition).
Simser, Judith, (1999). Parents, the essential partners in the habilitation of children with hearing
impairment, in the Australian Journal of Education of the Deaf, Vol. 5, Adelaide, South Australia.
Simser, J.I. (1993). Auditory-verbal intervention: Infants and toddlers. The Volta Review, 95,
(217-229).
Simser, J., & Steacie, P. (1993). A hospital clinic early intervention program. In A. Phillips & E.
Cole (Eds.), Beginning with babies: A sharing of professional experience. Washington, DC:
Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf.
Stokes, J. (Ed.) (1999) Hearing impaired infants: Support in the first eighteen months.
Washington, D.C. Alexander Graham Bell Association for the Deaf.
14